Are White People Smarter than Black People? (2019-02-18)
Description
This is a discussion with “Ralph” a far right man who believes that blacks are intellectually inferior to whites on a genetic level.
He is probed on how he comes to this conclusion given the ungeneralisable nature of the IQ tests.
Summary of Are White People Smarter than Black People?
*This summary is AI generated - there may be inaccuracies.
00:00:00 - 00:10:00
the presenter discusses the idea that white people are not inherently smarter than black people, and that the IQ test is not an accurate measure of intelligence. They suggest that an IQ test should not be used to categorize races, because it is based on a flawed social science.
00:00:00 argues that the IQ test is not an accurate measure of intelligence, and that it is biased because of the biases of the people who created it. He also points out that social sciences are weaker than science, and that IQ tests are used to justify further racism.
- *00:05:00 Discusses the idea that white people are smarter than black people, and asks the person asking the question how they can justify this claim. The person asking the question also asks the presenter why racism is a neutral term. The presenter responds by saying that racism is an expression of a collective group of people who refer to themselves as "white people," "black people," or "people of color." They go on to say that this claim is not objective, and that white people expect others to agree with them because they have been taught this by the left.
- 00:10:00 argues that people who can speak multiple languages are more intelligent than those who can only speak one. They also mention that due to colonialism, many people have forgotten about the negative effects of colonialism. suggests that an IQ test should not be used to categorize races, because it is based on a flawed social science.
Full transcript with timestamps: CLICK TO EXPAND
0:00:00 all righty Kip uses example I say you
0:00:02 can white finish black you said black
0:00:05 people are less intelligent than white
0:00:07 people as a result of their results on
0:00:09 the IQ tests as a collective group and
0:00:12 that's that's that's indicative of a
0:00:15 genetic go to guru today please please
0:00:18 calm down please
0:00:20 just let you keep laughing but I just
0:00:22 wanna you saying that it's problematic
0:00:24 on account of the following IQ tests
0:00:28 themselves are not compliant with the
0:00:33 scientific method let me explain to you
0:00:38 the IQ test itself is a configuration
0:00:43 which is susceptible to human critique
0:00:47 and/or amendment well wrong correct
0:00:51 therefore using it as an exact measure
0:00:54 for PMON intelligence currently as a
0:00:57 current measure is unjustifiable
0:01:00 especially considering let me let me
0:01:02 explain let me explain especially
0:01:03 considering excuse me especially
0:01:05 considering that those who constructed
0:01:08 the IQ test themselves were people who
0:01:12 might have had biases well we have let
0:01:17 me give an example I mean I may have an
0:01:18 example right and this is not something
0:01:20 this let me give an example is
0:01:23 bilingualism
0:01:25 or multilingualism included in the IQ
0:01:27 test my question is it included yes or
0:01:30 no no no it's no it's not now
0:01:33 yes here's the point do black people do
0:01:35 let me ask a question do black people
0:01:37 have a higher or lesser chance of being
0:01:40 bilingual or multilingual than a white
0:01:42 man please please please I'll ask it a
0:01:51 question does a black man in Africa have
0:01:54 a higher or lesser chance of being
0:01:55 bilingual or multilingual than a white
0:01:57 man in Europe
0:01:58 no it's not equal no it's not you know
0:02:01 why no it's not okay Ralph you Ralph is
0:02:05 more equal and not one sorry Ralph sorry
0:02:07 I'm sorry I apologize I apologize I'm
0:02:14 sorry let's let's be specific let's be
0:02:18 specific
0:02:19 again the Western European example
0:02:20 Western Europe I'm going to be very
0:02:22 specific I'm talking about this colonial
0:02:25 narrative of especially Western Europe
0:02:27 okay and I think you have to understand
0:02:30 something brother
0:02:31 yeah you have to really understand side
0:02:33 these you know these eugenics programs
0:02:35 that they did and in what you call it in
0:02:37 Germany yeah where they brand it they
0:02:40 had you know that the supreme race the
0:02:42 white man with the blue eyes and so on
0:02:44 and this is the you know the ideal the
0:02:46 women so she would know she would know
0:02:51 she would know so she would know what
0:02:53 her parents are poor forefathers in fact
0:02:55 there would have been there would have
0:02:56 been part of this right so that the idea
0:02:59 of the the idea of the white man with
0:03:02 the blue ice the white man with the blue
0:03:04 eyes being the the apex balls and the
0:03:07 boogey man that scares you their points
0:03:09 not completed my sentence oh yeah right
0:03:14 I'm not saying that just because it's
0:03:16 provided a justification I'm saying that
0:03:19 this I'm not making that point I could
0:03:21 say that
0:03:23 Ralph sorry I could have made the point
0:03:26 I said I'm not gonna be more emotive
0:03:28 sanctimonious and say well that's how
0:03:29 they justified the burning of the
0:03:30 Ashkenazi Jews you you said all the
0:03:31 highest IQ and it was ironic you tell me
0:03:34 but but just let me say my first the
0:03:37 point is the the inherent biases in
0:03:42 those scientific practices from German
0:03:46 scientists
0:03:48 reflected upon subsequent subsequent
0:03:51 results of so-called scientific
0:03:53 discoveries so therefore you have to
0:03:56 understand number one how science can be
0:03:57 very biased because you have a lungful
0:03:59 you really need to like take a minute
0:04:01 let me help someone so summarize what
0:04:03 your so let me summarize it give me one
0:04:06 minute just one minute
0:04:07 and then you can talk for two minutes I
0:04:09 put up one minute okay
0:04:11 to summarize you're right science itself
0:04:13 can be used by racist people and then
0:04:16 those racist people can then use the
0:04:19 word data to make it seem as if science
0:04:21 has this is a legitimate racism now
0:04:23 moving on to social sciences which is
0:04:26 even weaker it's more feeble than
0:04:28 science yes because it attempts to mimic
0:04:30 it it's a cheap copy
0:04:31 it's a pseudoscience according to Karl
0:04:33 Popper sure and then the resulting
0:04:36 placement tests which are called IQ
0:04:38 tests which are put in place to try and
0:04:40 measure people's intelligence
0:04:41 collectivise them and then justify
0:04:43 further racism which is what your
0:04:46 phase-two might be if not for you but
0:04:48 someone else would say it's phase 2 of
0:04:49 the program the point not it's not
0:04:52 finished
0:04:54 so you have to justify why the
0:04:57 parameters included in the IQ test are
0:05:01 the the best possible parameters when
0:05:04 they don't include those things which
0:05:05 black people or people of color would
0:05:08 have this advantage would have as
0:05:10 advantages over and above white people
0:05:11 and do link and other and do link to
0:05:15 intelligence according to a majority of
0:05:17 studies that have been done on it so
0:05:19 that can you answer that question so let
0:05:20 me know you get about 20 minutes one
0:05:23 minute yeah
0:05:24 before the
0:05:27 I let me start by produced popper and
0:05:30 your question the scientific method
0:05:32 requesting basically Western
0:05:34 civilization which is with some brand
0:05:36 you're standing on let me tell you about
0:05:38 Western civilization so in the end is
0:05:40 what you're referring to loosely as
0:05:41 logical positivism and Wittgenstein and
0:05:43 pauper down the room and everyone else
0:05:45 this was still 40 years before the
0:05:47 invention in computer science we see
0:05:49 people at myself as two types of chimps
0:05:51 in this world those who get theoretical
0:05:52 computer science and those that don't
0:05:54 the scientific method is just an
0:05:55 algorithm it's a class backwards not
0:05:58 alternative hypotheses are algorithms
0:06:00 wrong the type on that your errors are
0:06:02 algorithms methodological it depends on
0:06:04 algorithm as large composite is an
0:06:06 algorithm the Trinity we style and the
0:06:08 pauper give me the Trinity we spiral
0:06:11 that populated with three world world
0:06:13 there are three worlds one is a physical
0:06:15 world which I will measure using science
0:06:17 and computer science as the time the
0:06:19 universe fifteen billion years plus our
0:06:20 space-time continuum for human eyes
0:06:22 chimps in a data point time T then I
0:06:25 would look at evolution she stopped uh
0:06:26 performing computational science for
0:06:28 this abstraction World War two is
0:06:30 measured by conscious creatures in it
0:06:32 you and I as to terms and those at
0:06:35 processing that was that Trinity that
0:06:37 creates us tells us that from a gene to
0:06:40 itself bring me to sell to sell to chimp
0:06:44 she about to get twenty thousand I
0:06:46 forced you into your saliva using forty
0:06:49 register your saliva in twenty-three
0:06:51 your chin down twenty thousand
0:06:52 I'll see you Mohammad Javad is twenty
0:06:55 thousand on the bow see which tribe you
0:06:57 came from down from Baghdad for Maui I
0:06:59 will find every temple and I will see
0:07:01 your propensity with diabetes for motor
0:07:03 neuron disease for heart I would look
0:07:05 for using medicine algebra tremor when
0:07:08 you're in a space about this way that
0:07:19 this is the data immunological regions
0:07:22 you say racism because obviously you
0:07:24 will have to form allies with the left
0:07:26 while yes term
0:07:28 yeah okay so in that Christian Western
0:07:56 science in that Christian we have data
0:07:59 I'm going to look at the data and racism
0:08:01 and some left-wing quite a white light
0:08:03 from our racist and Mahalo doesn't
0:08:06 interest me
0:08:06 I apologize queue of racism I told you
0:08:14 today I'm not going to be morally
0:08:16 sanctimonious I'll let that for other
0:08:17 people to talk about right and I haven't
0:08:19 accused you of racism by the way racism
0:08:20 is a neutral term hold on hold on why I
0:08:23 mean by racism being a neutral term it
0:08:25 doesn't have to be necessarily
0:08:26 derogatory depending on how you define
0:08:28 it and how its expressed racism sorry
0:08:31 racism is just an expression of a
0:08:33 collective of group a collective
0:08:35 referring themselves referring to
0:08:37 themselves so self identifying or being
0:08:39 referred to as watching I referring to
0:08:44 themselves being self-identified or
0:08:46 being referred to as others as say for
0:08:47 instance black or Y or ever being
0:08:50 oppressed through power relations or
0:08:51 otherwise by other people and all being
0:08:53 discriminated against
0:08:54 now that could have undertones which are
0:08:57 political but it could also be something
0:08:59 which is neutrally used my question to
0:09:01 you which you couldn't answer you tried
0:09:02 talking about algorithms with what the
0:09:04 fact no no no is the fact that how can
0:09:06 you justify making them my questions how
0:09:09 can you justify I haven't finished my
0:09:11 question how can you justify making
0:09:14 overarching generalizations about
0:09:16 intelligence when the systems and
0:09:18 methods hollow the systems and methods
0:09:20 by which involve an acuity the end Ralph
0:09:22 by the way I did let you speak okay
0:09:27 our changes are not working or performed
0:09:29 equally another you're not on the oh
0:09:31 you're you're thinking in a linear way
0:09:34 okay checked it you're thinking a value
0:09:36 it's not objective no I've not told you
0:09:40 about my emotion so you're talking about
0:09:41 something else now have I said I feel
0:09:43 this way already you seem to love them
0:09:45 well I don't know I didn't say this
0:09:47 though I say that everyone seemed like
0:09:49 no no no I'm not saying I like you I'm
0:09:51 not talking about you now what I'm
0:09:53 saying is this my claim is very so him
0:09:56 rough you expect me to say certain
0:09:58 things because you hear that from the
0:09:59 left I'm not left wing guy hold on I'm
0:10:04 not no identifiers with the left all the
0:10:06 way I don't know I don't believe so yeah
0:10:11 although I really genuinely don't
0:10:12 believe so I disagree with that
0:10:13 completely yeah but what I was gonna say
0:10:15 was this yeah no and we're not left all
0:10:18 right we don't go in your your spectrum
0:10:20 your political spectrum we don't have to
0:10:21 fit nicely with it yeah yeah yeah so
0:10:23 what I was gonna say was this yeah was
0:10:26 the point I was making you keep using
0:10:28 words like data and objective truths and
0:10:30 emotions no it's no no it's an easy it's
0:10:33 an easy argument to win against someone
0:10:34 who doesn't know what they're talking
0:10:35 about but if you're talking to someone
0:10:37 who's done Social Sciences and I spent
0:10:39 many years doing so like myself and I
0:10:41 tell you now it's magic no no no I'm not
0:10:44 to be funny but no not to be funny but
0:10:46 I've got the credentials from those guys
0:10:47 that you take us I do have those
0:10:53 credentials if you want to show them to
0:10:54 you as well but even even if we don't
0:10:56 talk about that and I said you look the
0:10:58 issue is this the issue is that you're
0:11:01 using a measure which is a byproduct
0:11:03 listen to me carefully
0:11:05 it's a but it's a by-product of a of a
0:11:09 social science that was done from
0:11:12 usually you're not listening to my you
0:11:14 know listening to my objection they say
0:11:16 but the IQ test is not cannot be seen as
0:11:21 an incorrigible test that is that is
0:11:24 incapable of being amended in the future
0:11:26 you can assume excuse me tonight before
0:11:29 I have a finish
0:11:31 and moreover and moreover therefore to
0:11:34 categorize races as as a result of their
0:11:38 performances on IQ tests when for
0:11:41 knowing full well that within the
0:11:42 parameters of IQ test certain things
0:11:44 like bilingualism and multilingualism is
0:11:46 not included which I really you're not
0:11:48 you're not you're not listening you're
0:11:51 simply not listening I will say to you
0:11:53 I'm gonna make a statement right now
0:11:54 yeah I'm gonna say to you that people
0:11:56 that can speak two languages are
0:11:58 cleverer in my eyes than people that
0:12:00 could speak one okay
0:12:01 yes colonial people that have been
0:12:04 colonized by the West and others because
0:12:06 in 1914 according to one of your great
0:12:09 scholars his name was homi Bhabha I'm
0:12:10 not sure you've heard of it yeah yeah is
0:12:13 there post-colonial think of it tonight
0:12:15 85% of people 85% of the world was
0:12:20 colonized by a few European countries
0:12:21 eighty-five percent a lot of people have
0:12:23 colonial amnesia
0:12:24 you have colonial amnesia you know
0:12:25 unremember one thing is not you have
0:12:35 because you don't know the extent to
0:12:37 which colonial powers that are have
0:12:41 affected educational systems of
0:12:43 measuring intelligence and giving
0:12:45 intelligence so that so that so that
0:12:48 compartmentalization collectivization
0:12:50 and then exploitation can be continued
0:12:53 in the post-colonial narrative now
0:12:54 here's the point that's why they do it
0:12:56 now I'm saying to you something very
0:12:58 simply that in Western Europe the people
0:13:01 that were meant to see as the Superman
0:13:02 the you know the Superman with a blue
0:13:05 eyes and the white skin
0:13:07 sorry that the Indonesian word the
0:13:10 ubermensch at the ubermensch those
0:13:12 individuals were meant to be the apex
0:13:13 yet those individuals who are meant to
0:13:15 be the apex of human civilization
0:13:16 because of their schools and IQ tests
0:13:19 which have been rigged so that they can
0:13:20 be the IQ test can be rewritten a high
0:13:28 you feel this summer no no I can
0:13:29 summarize your words into anything no I
0:13:31 mean summarize your board you would help
0:13:32 IQ chess I'm not I'm not falling for
0:13:35 that I'm not
0:13:36 for that trap I'm not [ __ ] over so
0:13:39 that Ralph will you take an IQ test
0:13:40 livestreaming what will you take I don't
0:13:43 believe an IQ test you don't listen to
0:13:45 argument ok now go away don't talk about
0:13:59 IQ test I've done enough just in this
0:14:01 country for ten years so yeah Wow Wow
0:14:05 the point is this if I if you can take
0:14:08 if you if you agree with me that people
0:14:10 that know more than one language on if
0:14:12 everything staying the same would be
0:14:15 more intelligent than person over one
0:14:16 language the question I asked what a
0:14:18 question I asked is why have why has the
0:14:20 elitist Westerners not put language
0:14:24 ability in the IQ test because you know
0:14:27 why do you know why the answer is never
0:14:28 say the reasons the reason why price
0:14:30 today the reason why is because black
0:14:31 people are going to go higher off in
0:14:33 that test and Ashkenazim Jews are going
0:14:35 to go down yeah
0:14:37 goodbye thank you very much thank you
0:14:38 thank you very much Bob thank you thank
0:14:43 you
0:14:48 well dunno