Skip to content
On this page

116 Tafseer ul Quran Surat Al-An'am Professor Dr Muhammad AL MASSARI (2022-11-13) ​

Description ​

حلقات ودروس الشيخ الدكتور محمد بن عبدالله المسعري Study Circles of Professor Dr. Muhammad AL-MASSARI

116 Tafseer ul Quran Surat Al-An'am Professor Dr Muhammad AL MASSARI

#quran #alanam #الأنعام

Summary of 116 Tafseer ul Quran Surat Al-An'am Professor Dr Muhammad AL MASSARI ​

This summary is AI generated - there may be inaccuracies. *

00:00:00 - 01:00:00 ​

is a lecture by Professor Dr. Muhammad AL MASSARI on the meaning of the word "Allah." He argues that Allah cannot be linguistic, since it can only refer to nothing and has no existence. He also notes that Allah is the Supreme controller and master of all creation, by necessity of Reason.

**00:00:00

  • Discusses the importance of fear and hope in motivating humans, and how the Quran uses both to encourage people to obey Allah. It explains that if people lose fear, they will not be able to obey Allah, and will end up in trouble.
  • **00:05:00
  • Discusses the Qur'an's teachings on blessings and hardship, and how both can befall believers. It reminds viewers that obedience to Allah is the key to achieving happiness and success, and that if they fall into hardship, there is no one who can help them but God.
  • **00:10:00
  • Discusses how events in the universe can only happen with Allah's permission, and how the current condition of the universe is supportive of this. It explains that diseases are a result of Allah's testing of humans, and that there is a cure for them. It also discusses the importance of technology in finding the cure for diseases.
  • **00:15:00 ** The professor discusses the impossibility of creating an infinite mass, and how this is relevant to the impossibility of Allah creating a stone which is infinite in weight. He goes on to say that even the formulation of the idea is misleading, as the stone is heavy relative to another body which does a gravitational attraction, making it possible for it to be created.
  • **00:20:00 ** is a lecture by Professor Dr. Muhammad AL MASSARI on the meaning of the word "Allah." He argues that Allah cannot be linguistic, since it can only refer to nothing and has no existence. He also notes that Allah is the Supreme controller and master of all creation, by necessity of Reason.
  • **00:25:00 ** , Professor Dr. Muhammad AL MASSARI discusses Surat Al-An'am, which discusses the importance of reason (khabir) over blind faith (taqwa). He argues that this concept is essentially synonymous, as both involve relying on Reason rather than outward appearances. He then goes on to discuss how one can bear witness to the truth by relying on God's witness. Finally, he concludes the video by discussing how one can be an atheist and still agree with the main point of the Quran - that there is only one God.
  • **00:30:00
  • Discusses the origins of the Quran and how it cannot be from Muhammad because he was not lettered and did not have any background in history or intelligence. He goes on to argue that it must be from outside of the Arab world, from Allah or the Devil.
  • **00:35:00
  • Discusses how an atheist must prove that there is no god, and how the Quran establishes that god exists. He also discusses how some atheists argue that the universe is self-existent and therefore does not need a creator, but this is not possible because the universe is contingent and has a beginning.
  • **00:40:00
  • Discusses the idea that there is proof of God, and that this proof comes in the form of evidence from the Quran. He discusses the idea that this evidence must be verified by accessible records, and that this is a difficult task. He goes on to say that the first part of this verification is to assume that the idea of proof of God is true, and to examine the available evidence. He then concludes that, without evidence from outside of the Quran, the idea of a divine being cannot be proven.
  • **00:45:00 ** reviews various evidences that suggest that Muhammad is only one of many deities, and concludes that he is not a witness to the existence of spirits. He rejects any connection between himself and these entities, and declares himself innocent of any involvement in their affairs.
  • **00:50:00
  • Discusses how the majority of why people reject belief in a messenger is because of the contradictions in their inherited reasoning. also mentions that even if a person accepts that a messenger is telling the truth, they must still follow him because of the importance of Ä«man.
  • **00:55:00
  • Discusses various stories of two Jewish scholars who came to the Prophet Muhammad and asked him to join them in going to Israel. Muhammad Abdullah, who claimed to be a prophet, refused, noting that he does not use the word "prophet" if he hears it. The two Jewish scholars then asked various strange questions, which seem strange for them, but Muhammad Abdullah explains that this is because he is applying principles from the Quran. Once he has shown he is knowledgeable in the Quran, the scholars allow him to join them.

01:00:00 - 02:00:00 ​

Professor Dr. Muhammad AL MASSARI discusses the issue of abrogation in the Quran. He argues that abrogation is only allowed for rules that are not based on creed, and that it is clearly understood by everyone. He also discusses the issue of Allah's freedom and explains that it is impossible for Allah to be bound by previous law.

**01:00:00

  • Discusses the concept of "al-taafseer ul Quran," or "the interpretation of Quran." The speaker, Dr. Muhammad Al Massari, discusses how Quran interpretation can be difficult for Muslims because they are conditioned to believe that they are the "elected people" and that they have a special relationship with Allah. He also explains how the concept of "al-taafseer ul Quran" can be difficult for non-Muslims to understand because it is two-sided, involving both Muslims and educators working together.
  • **01:05:00
  • Discusses the importance of honesty and modesty, and how one of the most honest and modest scholars of Islam, Dr. Muhammad al Massari, recognized and praised Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) when he met him in secret. Dr. al Massari also recounted a dream in which he was climbing to heaven and someone said, "Go up until you reach the top." He held on to the rope, and when he woke up, his hand hurt from being tightly twisted. This dream symbolized the Quran's importance to him and his belief that he would hold on to it until he died.
  • **01:10:00
  • Discusses the issue of people fabricating lies about Muhammad in their attempt to discredit Islam. He points out that this is a very serious offense, and those who commit it will never be able to reach a happy state in this life or the next.
  • **01:15:00 ** is a translation of a lecture by a professor about Surat al-An'am (The thunder). The professor discusses how grave fabricating these verses are, and how even the slightest act of wrongdoing will have severe consequences. The professor then goes on to talk about how the Quran warns of a day when all the wrongdoers will be gathered together and punished.
  • **01:20:00 ** The professor discusses how some Muslims believe that a new Prophet cannot abrogate the laws of Judaism. He goes on to say that this argument is invalid, as there are Divine names and descriptions associated with the Divine action universe.
  • **01:25:00 ** Professor Dr. Muhammad AL MASSARI refutes claims made by some Muslims that the Quran contains rules that were later abrogated by Prophet Musa (Moses). He also discusses the issue of Allah's freedom and explains that it is impossible for Allah to be bound by previous law. He concludes the video by discussing the issue of male and female relations and how they have evolved over time.
  • **01:30:00
  • Discusses how two Muslims who took shahada at different times reacted to being attacked by Jews, and how their actions show that Islam is a necessary existing religion.
  • **01:35:00
  • Discusses the various verses in the Quran that refer to the Prophet Muhammad as a "Servant of God," and how these verses contradict Paul's claim that he is the "Christ." argues that this conflict is clearly documented in the Quran and the Epistles attributed to Muhammad, and that it was not previously understood because scholars only studied these texts after the Islamic empire had already been established.
  • **01:40:00
  • Discusses how the complete ICI is available in the distance Scrolls and how it proves with certitude that Muhammad is a messenger from God. It also discusses how the woman's claim to be originally from Israel is not true, and that her son was healed by Muhammad despite being an unbeliever.
  • **01:45:00
  • Discusses the Prophet Muhammad's miracles, which include healing a child and sending a disciple to fetch water from a fruit tree without finding any fruit. also discusses the Prophet Muhammad's prophecies, specifically his prediction that he would be rejected and cut off from the people. ends by discussing the Prophet Muhammad's connection to the Messiah.

provides evidence that Muhammad is the true Prophet of God and that his prophecies will be fulfilled.

  • **01:50:00
  • Discusses the dating of the Quran, which has been independently dated by archaeological evidence and by polygraphy. It argues that the Quran was copied and written before Muhammad, and that it is impossible for Muhammad to fulfill the prophecy of Teresa coming.
  • **01:55:00 ** Professor Dr. Muhammad al Massari discusses abrogation, which is when a previous statement or law is superseded by a more recent one. He notes that abrogation is only allowed for rules that are not based on creed, and that it is clearly understood by everyone.

02:00:00 - 02:05:00 ​

The professor discusses the concept of ta'feer, or the Islamic practice of repentance, and how it can be applied to specific situations in life. He also discusses the importance of having a clear understanding of Islamic law and how it can change with the Prophet Muhammad's (PBUH) sayings. The professor makes the point that debates over meaning are often fought using fallacious arguments, leading to a lack of understanding and compromise on either side.

**02:00:00 ** The professor discusses the concept of ta'feer, or the Islamic practice of repentance, and how it can be applied to specific situations in life. He also discusses the importance of having a clear understanding of Islamic law and how it can change with the Prophet Muhammad's (PBUH) sayings. The professor makes the point that debates over meaning are often fought using fallacious arguments, leading to a lack of understanding and compromise on either side.

  • **02:05:00 ** Professor Dr. Muhammad al Massari discusses how a person's moral ground should be based on what is a minimum requirement, not what is a "highway." He goes on to say that using faulty premises to attack an opponent is a mistake, and that a person's behavior should change in order to earn the respect of others.

Full transcript with timestamps: CLICK TO EXPAND

0:00:10 foreign0:00:10 0:00:53 foreign0:01:06 these episodes are broadcast live on the0:01:09 study Circles of Professor Dr Muhammad0:01:11 al-masri YouTube channel every Sunday at0:01:14 1pm UK time we invite you to subscribe0:01:17 to the channel and activate the0:01:18 notification Bell for all new content0:01:20 please note also the link to the0:01:22 broadcast of the live broadcast for0:01:23 wider dissemination do not forget to0:01:25 interact with us during the broadcast by0:01:26 participating in the comments and asking0:01:28 questions through the chat box you find0:01:30 by the broadcast link next to the video0:01:31 also do not forget to support our0:01:33 activities by donating when asking0:01:35 questions in the conversation or through0:01:37 the thank you button under the video0:01:39 today is Sunday the 13th of November0:01:44 2022 the doctor continues to pasir with0:01:47 Surat Al and am we are now on Ayah 15.0:02:01 or it is continue0:02:08 I'll just translate0:02:22 Rush do you hear me sorry sorry0:02:25 yeah so this is um this ends on a dream0:02:28 so the translation is say behold I would0:02:31 dread where I thus to rebel against my0:02:34 sustainer the suffering which will0:02:36 before which would before me on that0:02:37 awesome day of judgment0:02:39 next translation0:02:41 say if I disobey my Lord I fear the0:02:45 punishment of the great day0:02:47 yeah so that's so we don't need to0:02:49 comment very much for that but it is the0:02:51 the habit of the Quran when Mission said0:02:52 in fact and then also to force the0:02:56 people to to review their position0:02:57 because most disbelief is coming from a0:02:59 psychological position it's not a0:03:01 metallobe as we will discuss down over0:03:04 the coming with the Ayah it's not that0:03:06 really that the evidences are not0:03:08 compelling still the evidence could be0:03:10 compelling as usual and still you can0:03:12 just make a decision against that0:03:14 because of certain psychological0:03:15 problems such as motivations certain0:03:18 complex motivation certain just0:03:20 arbitrary decision uh it could be0:03:22 motivated by social pressure it could be0:03:25 motivated by by personal issues could be0:03:27 motivated many other things so the Quran0:03:29 always intermixed using fear to Foster0:03:32 People it may be ending in a catastrophe0:03:35 let me let me review my situation if0:03:38 it's ending for example the Hellfire0:03:39 that's a miserable end let me review0:03:41 something again let me go back and think0:03:44 again maybe I should review my position0:03:46 things like that and reminding he0:03:48 doesn't say0:03:50 I am I am concerned I fear that if I0:03:54 disobey my Lord I say the word is this0:03:56 over your side will not rebel against0:03:58 one if they disobey my Lord0:04:01 that that there will be a punishment in0:04:04 a great oral tremendous day so that's0:04:06 just just losing the fear fear is0:04:08 important you have to motivate humans by0:04:10 hope and fear0:04:12 as the Sophie said you have you must be0:04:15 like a bird traveling toward Allah and0:04:18 the head of the bed is the lamp and the0:04:19 desire to be close to him to enjoy his0:04:23 uh Eternal business with him to be in a0:04:26 pleasure in a pleasurable relation0:04:27 elaboration so the head the head of the0:04:30 bed the brain of the bed is the love0:04:31 that's the front one but you have to0:04:34 have two Wings one right wing is hope0:04:37 the left wing is fear and they should be0:04:39 well balanced0:04:41 if it feels if her home is too much then0:04:44 you will Veer out of the way0:04:46 it's clearly imagine a a plane and the0:04:49 left wing has has a crack or pathway is0:04:52 flown away the plane will not be able to0:04:53 fly you have to find the nearest0:04:55 emergency landing place but you're gone0:04:57 or you are gone and the same with the0:05:00 other one so neither should hope become0:05:02 excessive so that that you are lopsided0:05:05 nor fear become excessive like and you0:05:08 become lopsided it will be well balanced0:05:10 but the head the main motivation is love0:05:13 and and love to Allah and the0:05:16 willingness and the desire to have his0:05:18 eternal pressure never ending0:05:20 companionship0:05:22 so that's that's the habit of the Quran0:05:25 manipulation on various places always0:05:27 reminding of that to overcome this0:05:28 because most of rejection of Revelations0:05:31 is coming from psychological reasons and0:05:34 the and the other reasons not because0:05:36 the evidences are not compelling or0:05:39 something like that most of the time0:05:40 sometimes the evidences are for someone0:05:42 not compelling because they have the0:05:43 deficiency in background and so on that0:05:45 has to be worked on but in most cases0:05:48 especially in cases confronting a0:05:50 messenger like a case of Musa which we0:05:52 discussed part during time past0:05:54 is that the evidences are overwhelming0:05:58 and compelling in such a way especially0:06:00 after the challenge with the magician0:06:02 and the magician foreign0:06:05 was not willing to admit to that what he0:06:09 perceived internally that this is the0:06:11 earlier truth but if I accept it0:06:13 then the throne and the kingdom is gone0:06:16 I will be following two two slaves I am0:06:18 the king of the world and the biggest0:06:20 foreign word at that time0:06:23 I'm not going to follow slaves even if0:06:26 that's truth0:06:27 no0:06:28 so that's the problem so maybe you are0:06:31 putting the master of fear in front of0:06:34 someone like that is maybe breaking his0:06:36 stubbornness and then reminding him but0:06:38 yeah listen you may end into a0:06:40 catastrophic situation revive review0:06:42 your situation so the Quran reminding of0:06:45 that is not is using the natural0:06:48 tendency of a human being is having fear0:06:50 which is natural because human beings0:06:52 are all created all creatures are0:06:55 contingent and finite0:07:00 pain and suffering so warning of that is0:07:04 a very effective tool to get the people0:07:06 to think again that's it not to get the0:07:09 people because of fears just to to0:07:10 believe what what has been uh like the0:07:13 like drawing the devil on the wall no0:07:15 think again go back so that's it so tell0:07:18 them0:07:19 you are asking me to disobey the road0:07:21 and stop maybe when you mentioning sets0:07:23 and things you don't like but I can't I0:07:24 can't disobey my or stop even the0:07:26 message just keep it for yourself do it0:07:27 but in private don't but but that's0:07:30 probably but I can't I have an order to0:07:32 do that and if I disobey there is a0:07:34 severe punishment for me here too nobody0:07:36 will be a get away if it is so this is0:07:40 the the purpose of such an Ayah0:07:43 and that continuation was this great0:07:44 deal this tremendous day0:07:51 foreign0:07:59 information about it Translate0:08:02 upon him we shall be spared on that day0:08:05 he will indeed have bestowed his grace0:08:07 and this will be a manifest trial next0:08:10 translation God will be truly merciful0:08:12 to whoever is fair on that day this is0:08:15 the greatest victory yeah so there's no0:08:17 need to admit it's just just0:08:20 reminding of the other wink to keep that0:08:23 to get the other Wing becoming balance0:08:25 if you escape that punishment I'm right0:08:28 meeting here you see this obeying Allah0:08:32 then you have gained the mercy of Allah0:08:34 and this is a great success a great0:08:36 Victory a great gain so strive for that0:08:38 gain hope for that King0:08:40 but he has started because we are0:08:42 dealing with stubborn people who are0:08:43 rejecting faster fear and then but0:08:46 there's another side of the coin there's0:08:48 a great Mercy there and great success0:08:50 and great gain to be gained if you avoid0:08:54 that by reviewing your situation and0:08:57 complying with the command0:09:01 then a new set of it should start0:09:04 relating what has happened the universe0:09:06 the harm and good and so on but it's0:09:08 later obviously to their claim that that0:09:11 harm and uh and and can can be from0:09:14 their Idols or Gods Etc what it says0:09:16 here is0:09:24 okay0:09:28 and if God shall touch thee with0:09:30 Misfortune there is none who could0:09:32 remove it but he and if he should touch0:09:34 thee with Good Fortune it is he who has0:09:36 the power to will anything the0:09:38 translation if God touches you with0:09:40 hardship only he can remove it and he If0:09:42 He blesses you it is his choice he can0:09:45 do anything he Wills yeah0:09:47 so this is this is uh uh again uh it's0:09:52 establishing a fact of the reality of0:09:54 existence that if a ham purports you0:09:58 it doesn't mention how the harmony Falls0:10:00 should harm because you could not have0:10:01 before you without Allah permission in0:10:03 the universe there's no way it can0:10:04 happen so it is hidden there some aspect0:10:07 of Qatar that whatever things happen in0:10:09 the universe which after they have0:10:10 happened it could not have happened0:10:12 without Allah solution it didn't happen0:10:13 Allah was not surprised that happened he0:10:15 knew in advance that it could happen and0:10:18 he allowed it to happen and he's0:10:19 allowing that to happen is that so it is0:10:22 not not to be attributed to any Idol or0:10:24 anything so if uh if for example like0:10:27 that woman which which suffered0:10:30 blindness and the courage a lot has0:10:33 caused her to go blind0:10:36 has no power to do with that anymore but0:10:39 it is just happening like like it0:10:42 happened to anyone blind just like any0:10:43 disease or like an episode of blindness0:10:45 and0:10:46 as as a reward for her belief and firm0:10:50 conviction she didn't have sight again0:10:52 which proves to the people the second0:10:54 one with the Small Miracles with the0:10:56 people we have the narration some people0:10:58 say generation is probably the case that0:10:59 yes maybe we can see it now but at that0:11:01 time if it is true the people president0:11:03 could not deny that understand0:11:06 so they said all that has caused that no0:11:09 nobody calls that this is it cannot0:11:10 happen except the Allah permission0:11:12 yesterday maybe an immediate cause like0:11:13 like an accident like something yet but0:11:15 this is all happening in that verse or0:11:17 in that just within the design of the0:11:20 nature of the universe with his0:11:22 permission for this either event though0:11:23 happened0:11:27 based on that by necessity if nobody can0:11:30 remove it except him0:11:32 Only He Will Carry move it because it0:11:34 could not happen without his without his0:11:36 permission and he allowed it to happen0:11:37 and with the design that the possibility0:11:40 of happening is already enshrined in the0:11:42 Qatar and the structure of the universe0:11:43 and then actualization is with Divine0:11:46 permission0:11:48 and0:11:49 can it be removed yes it can be removed0:11:51 by Dua by the medical treatment but0:11:53 whatever it is kind of harmful example0:11:55 but that's only again only the one who0:11:57 can remove it Allah medical treatment0:12:00 will work only if it is fits us in the0:12:03 mirror Mass which has been decided by0:12:05 the beginning of the creation and in the0:12:07 individual situation now in this case by0:12:10 Allah permission that it will become0:12:11 effective0:12:13 both have to work together the general0:12:15 system with the Invaders and so on if0:12:17 you don't use the the proper medicine so0:12:19 on you don't expect it to happen because0:12:20 you're not using the weather0:12:23 not uh doing the things which will0:12:27 produce that result0:12:29 yeah you're waiting for Allah to break a0:12:30 system with their Visa Do America for0:12:32 you who does not acceptable that's not0:12:33 the way the universe works so you have0:12:35 to be with medication for example but if0:12:37 you get a harm of a disease and so on0:12:39 yeah0:12:41 from the beginning of creation we know0:12:44 that that the system are invest because0:12:46 the universe is contingent that created0:12:48 will have deficiencies under in this0:12:50 testing University because it's an0:12:52 informal disease genetic mutilation all0:12:54 of these things but there may be a cure0:12:56 for them0:13:02 diseases ensure us that there is no0:13:05 disease Allah did not allow any disease0:13:07 to exist to come there except there is a0:13:09 cure for it inside the universe but I'm0:13:12 trying to kill after work you have to do0:13:14 science to do pharmacology you have to0:13:16 do medicine to get it0:13:18 to see other people experience it all0:13:20 the way how to get a cure but there's a0:13:22 cure0:13:24 so0:13:26 uh0:13:27 technology0:13:31 because sometimes the Cure is not known0:13:34 but there's a cure so work for it get it0:13:37 and use it0:13:39 that's it and the one who's doing that0:13:41 that and the other one who is removed0:13:43 the harm the disease and cure is Allah0:13:45 because it couldn't have been occurring0:13:48 if it was not enshrined from the0:13:50 beginning moment of the universe in the0:13:51 structure that there would be a cure nor0:13:54 in the individual situation that you0:13:56 find or found or someone found the Cure0:13:58 and you came to know what some maybe0:13:59 someone found a cure thousand years ago0:14:01 in in India but you know and aware of0:14:03 that0:14:04 so it would not work either way but if0:14:06 you came to know it listen you're coming0:14:08 to know it could not happen is that0:14:10 Allah permission in the universe because0:14:12 you you travel to India or you read0:14:13 books from there with the Publications0:14:15 you do the things which will get you the0:14:17 knowledge but this could not happen0:14:18 without all our permission in the0:14:19 universe so all nothing happened without0:14:21 Allah permission database both in0:14:23 general the general structure with the0:14:25 color for the initial and in every0:14:27 moment of time what happened next next0:14:30 moment cannot happen without Allah0:14:32 permitting it to happen0:14:36 even if you say the the medicine cured0:14:39 but the one who really moved this Allah0:14:41 because the medicine could not have0:14:43 worked except the tree to work with a0:14:45 fitness system anyways which established0:14:47 by Allah in the beginning0:14:50 will have this effect in due course and0:14:53 in in the individual case but the0:14:55 current condition and the real situation0:14:58 at this very moment is is supportive for0:15:00 it to work otherwise it wouldn't and0:15:02 this is all going back ultimately to0:15:04 Allah's action and permissions0:15:09 not meaning that he steps in and do0:15:12 miraculous no that's that's the mini0:15:15 simple-minded idiots may think this way0:15:17 but it's not like that and sometimes0:15:19 obviously to show America's foreign0:15:33 statement for every harm whatsoever0:15:36 it will not come without whether we are0:15:39 being Happening by Allah0:15:41 Allah will touch you with her0:15:44 meaning it happens with Allah permission0:15:46 and it was in the design from the0:15:48 beginning0:15:51 that moment we should not have been0:15:53 there no no it is already in in in in0:15:55 built in in the structure of the0:15:57 universe0:16:00 situation by Allah celebration to happen0:16:04 otherwise could not have happened0:16:06 and the same with the cash removing the0:16:08 Hub0:16:11 with him0:16:13 not a lot0:16:16 not that people think maybe because then0:16:17 this poison is the one that should we0:16:19 have yes the poison had an attribute and0:16:21 the national to be harmful because it's0:16:22 so designed Allah is the one who0:16:24 touching with the harm through this0:16:26 initial qadar and suno permission of0:16:28 this happening at that very moment0:16:32 so that's only Allah can do that0:16:34 and0:16:36 nobody else with the explanation I0:16:38 mentioned that with the catalans on the0:16:39 proper instruction0:16:41 and if it touches you with good0:16:44 it's even even better0:16:46 he's capable doing all things that's all0:16:49 within his power good and her but good0:16:51 is not mentioned by that it can be0:16:54 removed in the sun because when when a0:16:55 god comes from Allah there's no plan0:16:58 initially to remove it unless it's a0:17:00 punishment for some of you misdeeds0:17:01 again would be a harm because of your0:17:03 misleads so even the hair is coming the0:17:07 most important is the fundamental here0:17:08 the initial here is that your own0:17:09 existence your own mental capability0:17:11 your own free will is from him that's0:17:14 the fundamental here everything else is0:17:16 just just some tarnishing because it's a0:17:18 testing universe but it's a fundamental0:17:20 hit0:17:22 and this is from purely from his gift0:17:24 and mercy you were not there to ask for0:17:26 it because you did not exist yet so it's0:17:28 impossible to ask for anything unless0:17:29 you exist but the weird that you existed0:17:32 with these features and characteristics0:17:33 and ability to think and ask is already0:17:36 a hair we shall received for free0:17:38 so he's capable of doing everything and0:17:41 as we discussed everything meaning0:17:42 everything well doable everything which0:17:44 is not uh rationally under logically0:17:47 impossible0:17:48 but physically it was someone he can do0:17:51 like saying linguistic momentarily in a0:17:54 network0:17:58 mean in the universe maybe a plant can0:18:02 develop into a snake over the hundreds0:18:04 of millions of years but not monetarily0:18:06 maybe but not but not not like what has0:18:08 happened to Musa that's something else0:18:09 so he is0:18:12 capable his omnipotent his power his0:18:14 power extent to every contingent and0:18:16 everything the wobble in principle0:18:19 The Impossible directionally and0:18:22 logically impossible not the physical0:18:24 orthodologically impossible0:18:26 if it's established to set it to the0:18:28 Starship physically impossible0:18:30 is not it is not the kind of a subject0:18:31 for power because it does not fit in the0:18:33 definition of power0:18:36 it's not doable so it cannot be done but0:18:38 has nothing to do with power so the0:18:40 usual atheists claim that can Allah0:18:43 create a stone which is infinite so0:18:45 hearing that he got uplifted is a0:18:47 statement though it is contradictions0:18:51 does not make any sense0:18:53 even even the formulation is misleading0:18:55 because the stone infinitely heavy with0:18:57 many effective heavy meaning heavy is0:18:59 relative to another body which does a0:19:01 gravitational attraction so maybe they0:19:03 mean with such a big Mass0:19:05 so there's not this is just stand alert0:19:07 so it's fine so if the mass is infinite0:19:10 that's not creatable no there's no way0:19:12 to create infinite Mass you cannot be0:19:14 actualized it's impossible0:19:16 so that's the whole the whole the whole0:19:18 standard algorithm is containing0:19:20 internal values and the training for0:19:22 things which cannot exist as you're just0:19:24 playing playing uh playing a game with0:19:27 words0:19:29 which which is nothing than a web play0:19:32 but it sounds a Thrust like like a like0:19:34 in Reading it's supposed to be a part of0:19:37 a cable doing everything like creating a0:19:39 stone which you cannot lift0:19:47 that's very trivial such such things and0:19:50 and things but still you find some0:19:53 simple-minded atheists and many0:19:54 simple-minded people around who still0:19:56 something like that will will shake them0:19:59 how to answer that0:20:02 that whole statement is self-controlled0:20:04 actually that's just that's it can't be0:20:06 linguistic exist at every part of the0:20:08 statement can be understood and give and0:20:10 have some kind of mental representation0:20:12 of a meaning does not mean that it has0:20:14 any existence it may refer to something0:20:15 and the usual my standard example for0:20:17 that is that the following statement the0:20:20 uh the square cell this this square0:20:23 circle is beautiful nothing over with0:20:26 this would sound very pleasing0:20:28 if you substitute for the square circle0:20:30 like a flower this flower is beautiful0:20:32 it's a perfectly fine one but the0:20:34 problem is that flower really don't0:20:35 exist and some of them may be regarded0:20:37 as beautiful at least in the eye of the0:20:39 beholder or they want to express that0:20:41 according to his feeling but Square0:20:43 second doesn't exist so this nothing it0:20:45 is is nothing in this is is a statement0:20:47 which is referring to nothing to0:20:49 actually to impossibility which can0:20:50 never be actualized off into anything0:20:52 it's another pointer in programming0:20:54 language even worse another point that0:20:56 we should kind of point to anything0:20:58 the simple0:21:00 which can be programmed you know how in0:21:01 program you can program something on a0:21:03 pointer which will never be used in the0:21:05 program to point to anything let's stand0:21:07 there we just occupy some peer press in0:21:09 the memory but would never be actualized0:21:23 all right one second0:21:29 yes up there one second sorry for he0:21:32 alone holds right over his creatures0:21:35 he and he is he alone is truly wise or0:21:38 where next translation he alone is the0:21:40 Supreme master of his creatures and he0:21:43 alone is all wisely all aware the word0:21:46 is come from Qatar0:21:48 is when we talk about human beings is0:21:51 usually negative0:21:53 the this this man or this this Emperor0:21:57 for example0:22:00 he's abreast them he says subdued them0:22:05 because in human being this you0:22:08 usually connected to using Force but in0:22:11 most cases unjustified in most cases0:22:17 this is a matter of0:22:19 the initial of necessity existing being0:22:21 to be subduing and Superior in every0:22:25 aspect to any other other creation which0:22:28 contingent so his career foreign0:22:32 the master the controller the compeller0:22:37 above all uh creation about all creation0:22:41 by necessity of the nature that is is0:22:44 existing it is not that electricity it0:22:47 just says the English before that they0:22:49 were not study when the subject no it's0:22:52 eternally by by definition by being an0:22:55 assistant existing and those all0:22:57 creation are created by Him purely with0:23:00 with his free and Sovereign will they0:23:03 are automatic by being creature they are0:23:05 ultimately under his control and his0:23:07 dominance so that's by necessity of0:23:09 Reason a necessity of of the definitions0:23:13 so his Supreme of creation the reason of0:23:16 mentioning that is that some of the0:23:18 deities for example of the king are not0:23:21 only as part of the creation so I tell0:23:24 him if that's so then this is this0:23:25 really not a necessary existing that0:23:27 cannot be really creative it is it is0:23:30 only your Eclipse it is an item we will0:23:32 fix the imagination it's just an0:23:33 imaginary item it can't be that can be0:23:36 uh that that these are the these deities0:23:39 are not because by Necessities there0:23:42 must be acquired but according to your0:23:43 description of them they are not so they0:23:45 cannot be deities0:23:47 but this is a side point so but Allah is0:23:49 definitely okay for everybody by0:23:50 necessity of being necessarily existing0:23:52 a detainer0:23:54 and also he is Hakim is the Hakim is0:23:57 wise or as we said perfectionist0:23:59 whatever has come from0:24:02 wisdom or perfectionism putting things0:24:05 together in a proper way as they0:24:07 supposedly to be fit0:24:09 under khabir is more than knowledgeable0:24:12 Alim is the one who is ex expat0:24:22 this man is an expert in in genetic0:24:25 Sciences it's not only knowledgeable he0:24:28 has experiences he he interacted with it0:24:31 and got perform experience now for for0:24:34 finite being that gives you a knowledge0:24:37 from experience from from the from the0:24:40 reality which is more than just my0:24:42 knowledge hearing from other people and0:24:44 adopting without self-verification but0:24:46 in the case of Allah his element is by0:24:48 necessary also0:24:49 because all what he knows is that all0:24:54 the things he created he knows about for0:24:56 them their design and then by creating0:24:59 them he knows the in in and out0:25:01 completely so his habit when he said but0:25:04 he is the aspect of being khabir is0:25:06 being stressed forward0:25:09 putting forward0:25:12 using a terrible0:25:14 is essentially synonymous because of the0:25:17 necessity of Reason Not because the0:25:18 concepts are reflecting the same meaning0:25:20 now they're different for contingent0:25:22 being they're called visible it could be0:25:24 Adam in an area but not expected0:25:26 to have knowledge you memorize many0:25:29 facts and so on but you are not expect0:25:30 you are not capable of verifying this0:25:32 knowledge you're not capable of of you0:25:35 don't have the tool or the training but0:25:37 only the the information as a memorizer0:25:39 you know that and you're convinced it's0:25:40 correct and the people who added that to0:25:42 you you have verified from various0:25:44 sources when you are convinced hundred0:25:46 percent that this physical fact but can0:25:48 you verify it can you go to the lab and0:25:50 do it by yourself or even extend that0:25:51 and video and do further research that0:25:54 you have to be expect not only just0:25:56 knowledgeable0:25:57 foreign0:26:04 comes0:26:08 actually0:26:18 is0:26:28 two major sentences there so okay first0:26:32 translation say what could most0:26:34 weightily bear witness to the truth say0:26:37 God is witness between me and you and0:26:40 this Quran has been revealed unto me so0:26:42 that on the strength thereof I might0:26:44 warn you and all whom I Whom It May0:26:48 reach0:26:49 could you in truth bear witness that0:26:50 there are other deities side by side0:26:53 with God say I bear witness I bear no0:26:56 such witness say he is the one and0:26:59 behold far be it from me to ascribe0:27:01 Divinity as you do to alt beside him0:27:04 next translation0:27:06 say what counts most as a witness to the0:27:09 truth0:27:09 say God is witness between me and0:27:12 between you and me this Quran has been0:27:15 revealed to me and to warn you and0:27:17 everyone riches could you in truth bear0:27:20 witness that there are other gods0:27:21 besides God0:27:23 say I bear no such witness say he is0:27:26 only one God and I have nothing to do0:27:29 with whatever you are so associate with0:27:31 him yeah we have two two major section0:27:36 um0:27:37 the one going all the way to that I I0:27:39 have revealed I had received the0:27:41 simulation of the Quran to warn you and0:27:43 do whoever receive the message foreign0:27:46 then let's continue with other things so0:27:49 that's0:27:49 that at first it seems to be like a0:27:52 symbol uh argument0:27:54 address to simple-minded people in first0:27:57 instance but it can be extended to0:27:59 higher if necessary but let's say with0:28:01 the simple people who0:28:03 agree with with the most messenger or0:28:07 live with or with the like the majority0:28:08 of the Quran College there may have been0:28:10 few people who are almost bothering on0:28:12 atheists but let's leave that at the0:28:14 moment0:28:15 I doubt that there may be one or two you0:28:18 cannot exclude0:28:19 in such a business community and0:28:21 sophisticated we should interacting with0:28:23 with the with the with charm with0:28:25 Peugeot that there would be one or two0:28:27 atheists maybe they don't they're saying0:28:28 that but they may be0:28:31 so and this is clear from them when0:28:34 teachers says it's only our life we we0:28:37 are born we die that's the effect of0:28:39 time essentially save time on the0:28:41 university is essentially some kind of a0:28:43 relatively primitive emphasism but0:28:45 expressed in the matter of that this is0:28:48 the life that's all what is it and we0:28:50 just want to die it's just as they say0:28:53 it is there's nothing there except wombs0:28:56 which are producing babies and0:28:58 a land or a soil which swallows bodies0:29:01 and other bodies are nothing and only0:29:03 the type passage of time is doing that0:29:05 and it goes also in from eternity to0:29:08 Eternity but this is essentially another0:29:10 form of stressing atheism0:29:12 so feel well like that definitely0:29:14 but the majority were believing there's0:29:16 a there's God or this is the main deity0:29:18 which is called in Arabic language Allah0:29:20 also in Arabic Allah and the Jews could0:29:23 be or something like that0:29:25 and possibly maybe other minor deities0:29:27 or offspring their daughters and sons0:29:29 and things like that0:29:32 so ask them0:29:34 Muhammad is instructed to ask them0:29:40 which thing is highest or most trustwise0:29:43 the other Witness0:29:47 they must then admit by necessity that0:29:50 Allah is the biggest one0:29:53 that is Allah and they will agree with0:29:56 that in that phase there may be some0:29:58 Israel say no we don't agree that's we0:30:00 discussed that maybe now or maybe0:30:01 another occasion maybe now0:30:03 so Allah okay we agree there's no0:30:05 dispute that Allah0:30:07 then he said this Allah is witnessing0:30:12 with me and you that he revealed to be0:30:14 this Quran0:30:16 to warn you and whoever received the0:30:19 message let's stop here0:30:24 and they say0:30:26 obviously0:30:27 they will say0:30:29 but we don't believe that you have0:30:30 received the revelation0:30:33 on this Quran so the the prophet will0:30:35 ask him okay so where does Quran come0:30:37 from0:30:38 tell me0:30:40 where does it come from could help I0:30:42 mean this is specially revealed but I0:30:44 said maybe mid to Mid time0:30:46 came in the sixth or seven year in one0:30:49 in one block so there before that there0:30:51 have been many things to call it the0:30:53 miracle of spirit in the world all of0:30:55 these things have happened before that0:30:58 so what it does it come from0:31:05 what they are supposed to answer0:31:07 they say it's come from you you have0:31:09 written it down0:31:11 but you know that I am not lettered and0:31:13 they don't have any background about0:31:14 history and they have no interaction0:31:16 with other Nation except maybe one or0:31:18 two business trips and if you go on a0:31:20 business trip to charm you're sending0:31:21 links and buying you won't be able to do0:31:23 any significant scholarship to know0:31:25 about previous Nations and previous0:31:27 intelligence philosophies it's a sort of0:31:29 question I didn't know that0:31:32 myself someone is teaching you that's it0:31:34 and there's someone some from people0:31:36 that book a teaching and for multiple0:31:39 Quran but this has two policies first of0:31:41 all if he's teaching the Quran the0:31:43 humanity that he's formulating the Quran0:31:45 for him but the one you are referring to0:31:46 is not an Arab so he cannot do it in0:31:49 Arabic0:31:52 no no you formulated it but it gave you0:31:54 the information okay but you have0:31:56 checked with the people the work that's0:31:58 come in the next hour you have checked0:32:00 the people of the book about the0:32:01 information0:32:02 and they have you have very few people0:32:05 of the book there a couple of them none0:32:08 of them scholarly slaves and they don't0:32:10 know what whatsoever you will see it now0:32:12 even in modern times for the widespread0:32:14 education the people of the book are0:32:15 blatantly ignorant about what they're in0:32:17 books and their stories you may say0:32:19 because we're on the current time0:32:20 because we have wide secularism but in0:32:23 reality despite widespread secularism0:32:26 even even if you go to the Middle Ages0:32:28 they were as ignorant as these are even0:32:30 more ignorant because at the time before0:32:32 King James version at this translation0:32:34 the majority of people or all people0:32:37 except fuels is elected or then priest0:32:39 they could not read the language in0:32:41 which these scripture are available so0:32:42 they don't know what's going on they0:32:43 have to refer those trees they don't0:32:45 know anything about Solomon they would0:32:47 accept one or two statements no details0:32:49 like that Israel Quran has brought and0:32:52 the only one who maybe scholari is0:32:53 living almost like among secluded Andrea0:32:57 has no relation with with Muhammad0:32:59 whatsoever they know that they know they0:33:01 know with whom he goes without the act0:33:03 with whom he lives you know someone0:33:04 living with you in the same city for the0:33:06 same Village or same city for years but0:33:09 so so the content has uh must have come0:33:12 from elsewhere0:33:15 so then then we got stuck with that in0:33:18 addition obviously before that there0:33:19 were certain Miracles and then signs and0:33:21 then evidences which are quite0:33:23 compelling0:33:24 so it cannot be from Muhammad is it from0:33:27 you did you make it clearly not because0:33:29 you are denying it so it's not from you0:33:31 not from you from some Arab and so on0:33:33 from somebody else like some some0:33:35 so-called revision is claiming is some0:33:37 of it is taken from a Syriac and so on0:33:39 but this is just as absurd as it gets0:33:41 but some people claim that there will be0:33:43 there will be some age of screaming that0:33:48 in Mecca none of this is is of any0:33:52 significance and that the people who0:33:54 claim that some bits of some phrases or0:33:57 something called from Quran to be found0:33:58 in in some Syriac scripture very0:34:01 effective scriptures who is prominent in0:34:02 Syria were found in Iraq and so on far0:34:04 away from Arabia and nothing0:34:07 nothing indicate but not even an address0:34:10 not even in a artifact not even an0:34:12 inscription or rocks around Mecca we0:34:15 found for example a new type some some0:34:18 images of the lat riding in a cabin the0:34:21 goddess lat but we don't find anything0:34:22 indicating that anyone there inscribed0:34:24 anything related to Syria called0:34:26 anything like that not in Mecca not in0:34:28 Aroma not in life not in this area so0:34:31 this is just nonsensical0:34:34 so it must be from outside the Arab from0:34:37 Outsiders it must be that's the argument0:34:38 that has very essentially is that okay0:34:40 so it must be outside of these from0:34:42 where it could be the remains only0:34:44 either from Allah or from the Devil0:34:47 that that argument could be brought some0:34:49 like the bush grandfather claims that0:34:51 Muhammad is leader Prophet the prophet0:34:52 of the devil and in time passed a0:34:55 heretic0:34:57 first century Christian Century early0:35:00 second century his name is marcion or0:35:02 marcion or marcion0:35:04 claim that that the Old Testament0:35:06 scripture and Professor all the prophets0:35:09 and messengers of the devil0:35:11 and this is the revelation of the devil0:35:12 the only the Divine elevation of the0:35:15 good God the only one is Elisa he's the0:35:17 only one hoping to tell to that all of0:35:19 that obviously this was so intolerable0:35:21 and so asynchronous with all but the0:35:24 illic Christians have had in the heart0:35:25 that's regarding if they believe in0:35:27 Divinity or not believe in duty of0:35:29 Christ that's so outrageous that0:35:30 degraded we're heretic and the Catherine0:35:32 and so on and the right reason that's0:35:33 kind of be accepted that that would0:35:36 contradict all what is known and0:35:38 narrated from Lisa disregarding the0:35:40 generations through or partially0:35:42 fabricated or fully fabricated it does0:35:44 it doesn't settle anything it's just0:35:46 absolutely nonsensical0:35:48 so0:35:50 so that can be answered in a similar0:35:52 ground also they have checked the people0:35:53 of the book0:35:55 so remains only that Allah so this is0:35:58 the one with the snow if Allah is0:36:00 according to the definition of both0:36:02 sides agree that he is the Supreme God0:36:04 the father of the Gods even which they0:36:06 can agree that he is the Supreme one the0:36:08 top one even the dualists who believe0:36:10 that there's a good God and a bad God0:36:12 Allah and the devil0:36:15 and agree that Allah is the good one and0:36:18 the devil is the bad one and the good0:36:20 one is the dominant one and the devil0:36:22 need to appease him by by offering one0:36:24 of his relatives as a wife which is a0:36:26 lot that's one of their Arabic mystery0:36:28 you can you will read0:36:31 even in that they agree that the good0:36:33 God is the truthful one and they're0:36:35 telling the truth so but this one0:36:38 if we come to the conclusion after so0:36:40 long discussion we should summarization0:36:42 and and just invoking Allah as a witness0:36:44 if you come to that that one the0:36:47 truthful one0:36:48 who has no reason to the absolutely no0:36:50 reason it's definitely not lying because0:36:53 he's the truth and he's the good one the0:36:55 good goodness entails truthfulness by0:36:57 necessity he said there's no other deity0:37:00 there's no offspring0:37:01 and the devil is not another deity it's0:37:03 a clear created being0:37:05 yes he rebelled and so on but for other0:37:07 reasons and because of the desirable as0:37:10 being a testing Universe had nothing to0:37:12 do with us to have no divine power he0:37:14 could not reveal anything0:37:16 and even even if we try to reveal0:37:18 something and and may become like an0:37:21 imposter for Allah we will undermine0:37:23 that he will not be able to do that all0:37:25 that he can do is whisper0:37:28 confusing I think but they will never0:37:30 come forward and claim that he is Allah0:37:31 and revealed that's impossible Allah0:37:33 will prevent that that's necessary by0:37:35 necessary reason so0:37:37 so if we agree that this is the Supreme0:37:40 witness Allah and this Revelation is0:37:43 ultimately this Quran is revealed to me0:37:46 if you deny the revelations0:37:48 how come it's fractured this way0:37:51 which has been challenged before because0:37:52 I am said maybe like mid or late late0:37:55 plenty of Revelation has been covered in0:37:57 plenty of discussion and some of it is0:37:58 coming after that even0:38:00 so0:38:02 then this witness must be the one we0:38:04 accepted0:38:07 now someone could say okay0:38:10 foreign0:38:13 accepted but this is under assumption0:38:15 that something called Allah exists maybe0:38:18 there's something like that it's just0:38:19 that how it is the passage of time it is0:38:21 just nature uh the whole universe yeah I0:38:24 agree nobody will deny that myself these0:38:27 mountains and so on obviously well we0:38:29 see that the mountain can be broken and0:38:31 received over our lifetime see some of0:38:33 the mountains lose some rocks and fall0:38:35 down so they cannot be there from0:38:37 eternity and things like fine but let's0:38:40 build the whole universe now we know by0:38:42 science about the time they didn't know0:38:44 they thought maybe the stars are0:38:45 detained and things like that but they0:38:48 they the whole universe in its totality0:38:49 as having either a source image from a0:38:51 source which is eternal and the0:38:54 necessarily existing but it's not a0:38:56 deity it is like something like a nature0:38:58 it's dead blind diff0:39:02 so it's kind of what they say it doesn't0:39:03 know anything this is just like a dead0:39:05 method it's called matter or nature0:39:10 you may come on more will come in this0:39:13 direction then the question will be0:39:14 after them I will not adjust the0:39:16 structure okay0:39:19 can you prove that this is that the0:39:21 State of Affair is is the absolutely0:39:23 true they cannot not not that we are0:39:26 challenging to prove that the god or0:39:27 Allah does not exist what is I need to0:39:29 prove this is negative we don't ask0:39:31 anyone to prove a negative that's that's0:39:32 unfair and irrational but we assume to0:39:35 prove a positive because the other the0:39:37 adult this negative meaning that this0:39:40 which we agree or the world address see0:39:42 that this universe around us and this0:39:45 world is exist and including myself the0:39:48 starting of this no doubt about that so0:39:51 there's something exists in existence0:39:52 and must go ultimately to uh to uh0:39:56 necessary existing source so your claim0:39:58 as an atheist is that the source of that0:40:01 already is a matter or a nature which is0:40:04 dead blind deaf has no knowledge answers0:40:08 that cannot be invoked as a witness by0:40:10 necessity0:40:11 so prove that0:40:14 nobody can promote that this Improvement0:40:16 that's not not possible to prove0:40:18 whatsoever0:40:19 there's no way to prove that it's0:40:21 impossible0:40:22 so0:40:24 but they say proof of the good accessory0:40:26 we don't need just watch immediators0:40:28 assume he exists make this assumption go0:40:30 along the line of discussion until we0:40:31 reach the Quran0:40:32 and then from there reversing back by0:40:35 necessity it must be the Assumption0:40:38 otherwise we get a contradiction the0:40:40 other assumption0:40:42 will will lead will lead to the that0:40:44 that that we cannot explain how the0:40:46 whole outcome and the various radicals0:40:48 which have been shown to you before so0:40:50 both assumptions have been worked out0:40:52 but we can still go to the beginning and0:40:54 prove that by by positive arguments0:40:56 which which we discuss for example in0:40:58 various videos and other places and many0:41:01 other people develop various types of0:41:02 evidences and also the usual atheist0:41:06 attacks against the proof of God and so0:41:08 on has been essentially almost0:41:10 completely undermined now by by all kind0:41:13 of a scientific I wouldn't say exactly0:41:16 because science cannot prove that0:41:18 science can describe the universe but0:41:20 but it will produce material and0:41:24 information to put on the table from0:41:25 which we then metaphysically done with0:41:28 rational arguments conclude that this0:41:30 universe could not have been uh come0:41:32 except by by from a free agent that0:41:35 cannot be from a dead blind matter0:41:39 so even that's covered but this is not0:41:42 the first addressee but we can see every0:41:44 distance then we expand and start by we0:41:46 prepare the starting another one and0:41:48 then follow the same job if if you0:41:51 cannot prove that and you will never be0:41:53 able to that that the whole universe is0:41:55 coming from from uh dead blind matter0:41:58 and so on and there's no Pro for that0:42:00 definitely the unable there's no way0:42:01 negative then this is assumed there's a0:42:04 Divine being it existence that's you0:42:06 just assume it and then build on that0:42:07 and then see if we get in a0:42:09 contradiction or if we get conscious in0:42:11 reality if we start with this then we0:42:14 will end necessarily that this0:42:16 assumption must be verified0:42:18 by by the accessible records and0:42:20 profitable so the the establishing of a0:42:22 prophethood all what we need we don't0:42:24 need to establish let's say it exist all0:42:26 that said it's a possibility let's start0:42:28 with that and then look at that claim0:42:30 which is available in front of us in0:42:32 space and time let's assume we are in0:42:34 Mecca now we are not real if we are a0:42:36 later time then we have to verify0:42:38 narrations make sure that the the pro0:42:40 there are professors which have been0:42:42 fulfilled after being recorded and the0:42:44 liquidation is is established with0:42:46 absolute certainty etc etc so-called0:42:48 Einstein condition that's for data0:42:50 viewer but let's assume we are in Makara0:42:51 and we are facing This Man Called0:42:53 Muhammad and claiming that and he0:42:54 bringing these arguments and he brought0:42:56 some kind of of Miracles and so on in0:42:59 Florida why now we have to we have to0:43:01 deal with this and there's no way to0:43:02 deal with it except that0:43:04 except by by admitting that the0:43:07 Assumption initial assumption must be0:43:08 true otherwise it's impossible to0:43:10 explain what comes after that0:43:13 so that's that's uh that's although it0:43:15 looks at that faces uh a bit simple mind0:43:19 and straightforward it's much deeper0:43:20 than people think if you analyze it0:43:22 properly so that's the first first part0:43:24 of the eye0:43:25 dispatcher of that0:43:27 if it's funded properly we can't even0:43:29 expand that produce it takes a volume to0:43:31 expand probably of beginning the first0:43:33 assumptions leave that aside assume we0:43:36 have done that0:43:38 then what's the conclusion of that so0:43:40 this is I have received the conclusions0:43:42 that I received this Quran it's not from0:43:44 me it's not from you it's not from the0:43:46 Arabs0:43:47 clearly is not even out from a Serial0:43:49 review around it it says and it is not0:43:52 and for us now we can settle that even0:43:55 further by further arguments from things0:43:57 in the Quran we shall be come to to be0:43:59 proven correct later on which were not0:44:01 available at the time for the People by0:44:03 adding more evidence to the existing0:44:05 evidence already so multi layers of0:44:07 evidences0:44:09 then what what is the current0:44:12 what what what what we conclude in that0:44:14 the messenger telling them you are0:44:16 witnessing0:44:18 that there's other data beside Allah0:44:23 I don't share with you the witness0:44:25 because your witness is a is a perjury0:44:27 you are witnessing for something untrue0:44:31 because0:44:33 did you see these deities interact with0:44:35 them no you don't claim that nobody0:44:37 claims that okay secondly0:44:40 where did you know that there was or we0:44:42 got it from our parents of a tradition0:44:43 that they have information and so on a0:44:46 generation of origination did your0:44:47 parent interactively witness outside0:44:49 their miracles no it's just from0:44:51 donation to generation0:44:54 so I witness it was something you did0:44:55 not see and you have no evidence for it0:45:00 is there any Scripture or something0:45:02 revealed from these any miracle stand by0:45:04 these these entities which you can0:45:06 present to us and we can't verify no0:45:08 there's not so we are witness you you0:45:10 are perjury doesn't perjury I'm not0:45:12 going to participate in this perjury in0:45:13 this false witness0:45:19 with you0:45:21 say0:45:22 the reality is this is only one deity0:45:26 but its own testimony and by necessary0:45:28 reason if we go to the more higher level0:45:30 of complex argument but just by by the0:45:33 Quran itself and by the necessity by the0:45:35 definition of a Divine being it must be0:45:37 cannot cannot lie it must be truthful it0:45:40 must be it must be it's essentially the0:45:42 absolute truth in himself so this cannot0:45:44 be so that's his witness and we have0:45:46 established a discolores from him so0:45:48 he's witnessing that he is only one one0:45:51 deity so all these stories about that0:45:53 you have offsprings and they will0:45:55 approach him with them with the one with0:45:56 one of his daughters one of noble ladies0:45:59 of of the satanic uh branch of divinity0:46:02 and uh settled the war with God by by0:46:05 marrying a lot to God and becoming his0:46:07 gods for God's wife and all of these0:46:09 things so obviously a myth not even0:46:13 genuinely Arabic it's coming from even0:46:15 the the old say uh the old Aramaic and0:46:18 the old babylonic methods and so on all0:46:21 of this is just imagination there's an0:46:22 attempt to explain even in the universe0:46:25 I explain what's going on in the0:46:26 universe but this is all based on0:46:27 imagination and putting Souls together0:46:31 which have no evidence it's just0:46:32 imagination Pure Imagination fiction0:46:34 fictional solution of the reality0:46:36 nothing else0:46:39 so that's it it's only 180 by all these0:46:42 evidences especially the witness0:46:45 assuming that he exists and by necessity0:46:48 being a supreme mind Supreme knowledge0:46:51 Supreme helm0:46:55 then the sweetness is absolute and0:46:57 cannot be denied0:46:59 under Israel in his Revelation which has0:47:01 been proven to be a revelation because0:47:02 we discussed that before0:47:04 based on that0:47:06 I have nothing to do with your the 80s0:47:09 and what do what you are associated with0:47:10 Allah I'm completely innocent I have a0:47:12 relation but not witness for the0:47:14 Existence I don't know spirit for their0:47:16 rank they don't exist for me I have0:47:18 nothing to do with them I reject them I0:47:19 reject their existence I deny their0:47:21 exercise0:47:23 I am completely0:47:25 innocent and divorced from anything0:47:27 which you are alive without whatever0:47:29 your life0:47:31 even if the the circuit is only the0:47:34 Shirk of hatimia that you attribute to0:47:36 your kings on your tribal Chieftains or0:47:38 to yourself as a community the right of0:47:40 legislation and the right of0:47:41 establishing laws and what's Good and0:47:43 Evil making yourself so your ultimate0:47:46 Sovereign I deny that you cannot be0:47:48 without viswani only the one can be the0:47:51 ultimate so I reject that you may exist0:47:54 as entities but you are not ultimately0:47:57 foreign0:48:29 guy who was never outside the country0:48:31 except maybe a couple of trips maybe one0:48:33 or two trips or three trips for business0:48:42 no no great relevance0:48:45 uh it has it has everything it's because0:48:50 and they they are Arabic is a their ex0:48:54 Arabic it's very difficult for them to0:48:56 communicate with Muhammad except for0:48:57 just buying and selling pure Goods like0:48:59 Market on an intellectual level of books0:49:01 and things like that the the dialect is0:49:04 far away from from the Arabic and very0:49:07 difficult foreign0:49:21 from them but he was never there anyway0:49:24 so it doesn't make any sense0:49:26 but they didn't they didn't rely on all0:49:29 the the information about this man and0:49:31 their life so they must have gone to the0:49:32 people to look at ask him about this man0:49:34 what how much uh truth is he saying is0:49:37 it possible is not possible and clearly0:49:40 some of these consulted did not answer0:49:43 the answer which is synchronizing with0:49:45 the truth0:49:47 and the Quran condemned them that the0:49:49 next eye is is condemning the admission0:49:52 clearly connected with the previous one0:49:54 that there have been previous checks and0:49:57 interactional so let me come say oh we0:49:58 checked in the Bible book they said this0:50:00 is not a messenger he's a liar0:50:02 foreign0:50:19 yeah0:50:20 Translate0:50:22 they unto whom we have perhaps a fourth0:50:25 time no this is this as they know their0:50:27 own children yet those of them who have0:50:29 squandered their own selves it is they0:50:31 who refuse to believe0:50:33 next translation those to whom we have0:50:36 previously given the book before know0:50:38 this as well as they know their own0:50:40 children0:50:41 yet those who deceive themselves refuse0:50:44 to believe0:50:45 sure0:50:47 um those who lost themselves0:50:50 they lost themselves because they they0:50:52 lost their happiness they lost their0:50:54 next life and so on so because they0:50:56 refused to believe and listen so that0:50:58 the coming of this after the previous0:51:00 Ayah hence that they have been checking0:51:03 with the people of the book and the0:51:06 people in the book and we know everyone0:51:08 with a story about the three questions0:51:13 a discussion another Arab question but0:51:15 not sophisticated enough to ask this0:51:16 question0:51:17 they went to the real website to check0:51:19 all these three questions and uh and uh0:51:23 if he answers correctly then uh and they0:51:26 give him that gave them the answer or0:51:28 something like that they said we tell0:51:29 you whatever day what has happened one0:51:31 is about the role one is about a man who0:51:34 went in time passed and uh but barely0:51:38 any information is still known about him0:51:40 about the canine and the third one or0:51:44 scanned most of the world and the normal0:51:47 weather and the third one is um0:51:51 what else was the third one0:51:55 I just remember at the moment maybe0:51:56 someone divided me anyway0:51:59 was clear it is it is a secret from0:52:01 Allah you don't have enough knowledge0:52:03 now to answer it so the question was0:52:05 what makes living being a animal walk0:52:08 and go and so on and bark and attack and0:52:10 so on what's the secret of life what0:52:12 what what what's what's the essential0:52:15 biology even if we say life is just0:52:17 purely material and the expression of a0:52:19 complex chemical and physical processes0:52:21 even if that at that time they don't0:52:24 have enough knowledge to answer this0:52:25 question that's so that's not what they0:52:27 oneself answer ask about that0:52:37 and there must be other examples and0:52:40 they are sentences it seems to be there0:52:43 was a feedback to these these people who0:52:45 were the people in the book and they0:52:47 were the collection reported them what0:52:49 has happened and they said oh he's a0:52:51 liar he's not his or some of them at0:52:53 least not all of them they did not0:52:56 recognize that this is a messenger and0:52:59 accepted him0:53:05 on children0:53:09 but they have lost themselves because0:53:10 they refused over to believe what was0:53:13 the main reason for the rejected0:53:14 rejection of belief0:53:17 the majority of the of uh of reasoning0:53:21 is because it contradicts what they0:53:24 inherited from their father and0:53:25 grandfathers0:53:26 see or they0:53:30 decided that for example the Jews0:53:32 specifically mostly is because the final0:53:34 messenger or the Messiah or whatever0:53:36 they're waiting for0:53:45 knows where he put his message he's not0:53:48 going to ask you for permission or take0:53:50 care of your racism and their0:53:52 nationalism it's not able just opposite0:53:54 he breaks it0:53:56 others0:53:57 said oh he's a messenger but to the0:53:59 Arabs0:54:01 but they're done in our conclusion he0:54:03 himself if he's a messenger is truthful0:54:05 then he must be truthful in his claim0:54:07 that he sent to all mankind0:54:11 so he must be lying either so he cannot0:54:13 be a messenger so how can you0:54:15 synchronize that then another party he0:54:17 was confused he is a mistaken so they0:54:19 attribute to profits the possibility0:54:20 being confused reporting of Allah in a0:54:23 confusion so what's the purpose of0:54:25 messenger doesn't make any sense that0:54:26 messenger can can make such a mistake0:54:28 and get confused0:54:30 although they know he is a messenger and0:54:33 here's he will get revelation0:54:35 with all kinds of arguments doesn't care0:54:38 about their arguments but they know that0:54:40 it's a revelation as they know their own0:54:43 children0:54:44 but they have lost themselves because0:54:45 they fuse Faith they make a decision0:54:47 will not believe will not will not0:54:48 follow will not accept him0:54:52 Iman is not only but believing that that0:54:54 he is telling the truth that's just0:54:56 something if that's not a man a man is0:54:58 accepting it and0:54:59 surrender to it and following him0:55:03 there's a there's various stories of0:55:04 this this clarify this nature the two0:55:07 two Jewish Scholars came to the0:55:09 messenger of Allah they said let us go0:55:11 to Israel this one who claims to be a0:55:13 prophet0:55:15 don't use the word Prophet if he hears0:55:17 that word he will grow up and his head0:55:20 will go up all through the ceiling even0:55:22 he will break the ceiling don't say it0:55:24 just said we hate you Muhammad Abdullah0:55:26 that you say this and this don't merge0:55:29 it even a prophet or make him there give0:55:31 him the benefit of the doubt to start0:55:33 with Let's test him at this regular man0:55:35 and they are asking various questions0:55:38 see if you give the the correct answer0:55:42 then0:55:43 you have proven you posted0:55:46 answer them one two three0:55:49 and they fell on his hand and feet0:55:50 kissing see0:55:52 you are through the messenger all over0:55:53 prophet and they're also asking the0:55:55 following strange questions seems0:55:56 strange for them0:55:57 but why don't you follow me why don't0:55:59 you exercise0:56:01 join me because that's that's that Iman0:56:04 man it's not enough that there's a0:56:05 statement of fact I'm not always talking0:56:07 about the Pythagorean theory that is0:56:08 true no0:56:10 apply it0:56:11 follow it but in theorem obviously0:56:14 there's no issue of applying it because0:56:16 if you don't apply it your machine will0:56:18 not work and your equipment will fail0:56:20 but this is because of the related to0:56:22 material universe but here we are0:56:24 related to the purpose of life to the0:56:26 intention how you produce your life it's0:56:27 different it is depends upon the act of0:56:29 will acceptance they said we are afraid0:56:32 if you follow you publicly the Jews will0:56:35 kill us so we have to wait we don't know0:56:37 what happened to these guys the the0:56:38 diabetes system after that or not0:56:41 we help us the story of uh here that is0:56:44 by himself I think he's truthful but if0:56:48 you study all his his what he said some0:56:50 people claim that he blessed Islam to to0:56:52 mutilate Islam and the injector foreign0:57:32 I think the general scholarship point of0:57:35 view that is that he is that he is a0:57:38 genuine believer is is true and his0:57:41 reporting but here reports from the0:57:42 scripture as he know it and for you to0:57:45 to regard that as an additional0:57:46 knowledge or non-knowledge or wrong0:57:48 that's for you to analyze in a scholarly0:57:50 way0:57:52 so that that's the way to go with our0:57:53 Capital report that he was studying the0:57:56 Quran in Yemen position0:57:59 of converted Arabs and we're like most0:58:02 Jews Arab tribes0:58:06 from from Arab and not not from uh from0:58:10 uh Israel they are the people who0:58:13 accepted Judaism joint but they say but0:58:15 they're not society and in descent0:58:18 as he said he he has to to fight with0:58:23 himself for a long time that uh0:58:27 to do the step Embrace Islam because0:58:29 this means he will break with his0:58:30 Society he's a human is a major scholar0:58:32 in his people he will be denounced he0:58:34 will be rejected he knows that there's0:58:36 no doubt about that people will not0:58:38 follow him0:58:39 maybe they will kill him and so on and0:58:42 he said when theories die and sort of0:58:44 which we passed that0:58:46 you know0:58:53 so every time I did the Ayah0:58:58 so they will turn backwards or something0:59:01 like that instead of looking forward You0:59:03 Look Backwards which is an extreme form0:59:05 of immutilation0:59:07 maybe it says a metaphorical because I0:59:08 don't think anyone can barely made alive0:59:10 after that but you never know I couldn't0:59:12 say that people can be deformed into0:59:14 monkeys and pigs they can't be developed0:59:15 like that say every morning after0:59:18 reading that when I wake up look I look0:59:20 in the mirror to check that my face is0:59:22 still in the straight Direction0:59:24 out of fear but he was struggling for0:59:26 some time then ultimately he overcame0:59:28 that and became Muslim and came to a0:59:31 breast Islamic type of Omar what is wise0:59:33 he could have became a companion of0:59:35 embrace Islam in the time of the prophet0:59:37 and went to him he missed that and he0:59:39 missed the time he came to Mid Romer0:59:41 time and became close to Omar and was0:59:43 attending his classes and so on and0:59:45 discussing and making input and giving0:59:47 ideas and things like that0:59:51 so we have we have the we have all of0:59:54 these cases0:59:55 which shows how difficult it is for some0:59:57 people to especially for the Jews who0:59:58 thinks the elected people of God and1:00:00 they grow on from childhood to believe1:00:02 that they are the elected people and1:00:04 living in the fiction that they're1:00:05 people of Covenant1:00:07 they're never told that the Covenant you1:00:08 have broken the Covenant of the Covenant1:00:10 is gone it's not Covenant left1:00:12 you broke the Covenant the Covenant the1:00:15 Covenant is Allah promise of the land1:00:17 it's a bit of Covenant you do this I do1:00:19 that it's a covenant it's a it's a1:00:21 two-party agreement two-party agreement1:00:23 if one party breaks it the other part is1:00:25 at Liberty to forsaken it's gone it's1:00:27 finished it is not an it is not an1:00:30 action from from a one-sided now it is1:00:33 two-sided action1:00:40 but still1:00:42 it's extremely difficult to overcome1:00:44 that1:00:45 it's awfully difficult you have to make1:00:47 a decision1:00:48 which means essentially you will be1:00:50 alienated from your family1:00:52 you'll be alienated from your Society1:00:54 most of the time and you may be killed1:00:57 like the famous story of the the bishop1:01:01 in the threshold1:01:04 educator1:01:08 foreign1:01:13 or something like that1:01:16 which allegedly most likely it's true1:01:19 the narration is quite good the hell1:01:22 Kelby when you handed the the the1:01:24 message to pretended to be respecting it1:01:27 putting it in a perfuming and putting it1:01:30 in a box and so on say a student with1:01:33 respect not like kestra the Persian1:01:36 Emperor who was towards the letter apart1:01:38 and invited the kids and the fabrication1:01:40 of prophet against him here he behaved1:01:43 respectfully1:01:45 and he told to here you see I I can't I1:01:48 can't embrace the otherwise I'll lose my1:01:49 kingdom even though the Roman will kill1:01:51 me1:01:52 but go to this man or the educator1:01:55 almost like a high Bishop the best1:01:57 assumption is that he's in homes record1:01:59 that time uh uh1:02:01 Hercules was in Iraqis was in in1:02:04 Hampshire1:02:06 because hamster is the the main city of1:02:08 sham and he comes from time to Sham and1:02:10 back and forth his capital city is1:02:12 constant you know you know that but in1:02:14 sham and most likely this educator which1:02:17 we don't find any threats indications1:02:19 out of History we'll see why1:02:22 go to him and see what he respond so he1:02:25 told him I've got the message1:02:32 teacher most likely they say about an1:02:35 artificial banana almost or something1:02:36 because I'm so the main city I must have1:02:38 an artificial there1:02:41 and then1:02:42 the Archbishop said yeah this is the1:02:44 messenger which we have been promised1:02:45 and that we were expecting a start to1:02:47 come I witnessed1:02:52 was not most likely he was even a modern1:02:54 face before that unlikely that he would1:02:57 leave because there was still wonderism1:02:59 was widespread and some people can1:03:01 hiding it because this street tarantee1:03:03 did not really benefit people heads for1:03:07 centuries and even until modern times1:03:09 anyway1:03:11 and then1:03:13 but he did not dare I'm afraid of the1:03:16 people he's not there going for his1:03:18 Sunday sermon so he pretended to be sick1:03:22 and then another Sunday he pretended to1:03:24 be sick and though he is with him and1:03:26 the third Sunday they came look at his1:03:27 daughter said listen1:03:29 your sickness is becoming too long for1:03:31 our taste your behavior is strange since1:03:34 this Arab has arrived what is the1:03:37 problem with you1:03:39 either you'll come or will take you by1:03:41 force and check what's going on so he1:03:43 went the last Sunday third Sunday or1:03:44 fourth Sunday1:03:45 you have a second one say this man1:03:47 brought me a message from the final1:03:49 messenger Citizen and I witness said to1:03:51 messenger and that that there's only1:03:54 many detail Allah they said the seventh1:03:57 Allah is not an 80 Etc and the immediate1:03:59 jumped up and killed him immediately1:04:03 and he told you here stand aside for1:04:05 watching from Far Away in a safe place1:04:07 okay so the the Calamity and then went1:04:10 back to say to uh1:04:12 and told himself told you1:04:34 kept the secret because he was forced to1:04:36 give a second but this one is not1:04:38 telling the truth and his reviews the1:04:39 money anyway that's not our story so it1:04:41 is it's not easy1:04:44 but as disregarding what the motivation1:04:46 excuses no excuses those who knew that1:04:49 it's like their sons they knew their1:04:51 sons they have lost themselves1:04:54 because they rejected Faith but they1:04:56 don't make the decision it is an act of1:04:58 making a decision it's not a belief they1:05:00 know it1:05:01 there's also an interesting story that1:05:04 uh that when uh1:05:06 um1:05:07 one of the major Jewish Scholars for1:05:10 Medina1:05:11 um1:05:13 uh1:05:14 Medina1:05:18 he recognized him and he analyzed him1:05:20 and then he came to him in secret and1:05:22 told him I praise love1:05:24 um I will get a name1:05:26 one of the major sahaba and I told them1:05:31 the Jews are the people of fabrication1:05:34 and lies I am one of the major Scholars1:05:36 but1:05:38 invite them and ask him to address faith1:05:40 and so on while I'm hidden in the side1:05:42 room1:05:43 in the second row foreign1:05:57 of your major Scholars what do you think1:06:00 about Allah1:06:03 what do you think about him say he's one1:06:05 of him he's on our best he's the best1:06:07 scholar he's our best scholar he's our1:06:09 best man our best woman most honest more1:06:11 reliable1:06:12 etc1:06:13 etc1:06:15 I say what if what what what will you do1:06:18 if you come to know that he embraced1:06:19 Islam1:06:20 Allah will protect him from that he1:06:22 can't do that such a blender1:06:26 and then in that based on that1:06:30 came out and say I witnessed Saturday1:06:33 there's no date except Allah they said1:06:35 oh this one no no this one is one of the1:06:37 West he's not a scholar he's an imposter1:06:40 he's this this is immediately just in1:06:42 the same session just few minutes ago he1:06:43 was the great scholar he was this or1:06:45 this the referred him as an authority1:06:46 and now when we Embrace Islam he was1:06:48 denounced as as uh as the west of us is1:06:51 not a scholar or what we said before1:06:53 that was just just uh just a matter of1:06:56 of giving him a good name but he's a1:06:59 really not up to scratch he's not the1:07:01 one the authority we can't rely upon he1:07:03 is not the same or that1:07:04 in one day this happened this Abdullah1:07:10 will come to me1:07:12 this one Omar asked him some years I1:07:16 said Allah said in the Quran1:07:17 those who got the scripture they know1:07:21 Muhammad as they know their own sad that1:07:23 he's a messenger as they know their own1:07:24 Sons1:07:28 is it is it true for you is that is that1:07:30 what you felt when you saw Muhammad and1:07:32 you received them for you because he1:07:33 received therefore he knew or that1:07:34 person about Muhammad before he was1:07:36 scrutinizing because there are narration1:07:38 that he sent his son to check in Makkah1:07:40 what's going on so the man is following1:07:42 the matter and it's working him for his1:07:43 time it is not simultaneously when the1:07:45 prophet arrived in Medina1:07:47 so he got that information follow he was1:07:49 digesting it analyzing time to find what1:07:51 it said that they're doing some hard1:07:53 work1:07:55 is it true that you recognized him the1:07:57 same way you're carrying your son say1:07:58 Wallah by Allah I recognize him more1:08:00 than I recognize my own son because my1:08:03 own son yes I rely on my wife but1:08:05 there's no absolute certainty that he1:08:07 may be committing something1:08:09 you see the point1:08:11 but Muhammad I'm absolutely sad1:08:14 so I even my own son yeah is born in my1:08:18 bed and they have no reason to doubt1:08:20 that my wife is honest and that she did1:08:22 not but she cannot be excluded1:08:24 absolutely certainly that she may1:08:26 committed azina and this was son is not1:08:28 my son1:08:30 although I recognize it as my son for1:08:31 according to all reasonable self-con1:08:34 levels there's no observices1:08:36 is more than accepting to my own son and1:08:39 I will kiss to his forehead1:08:41 Abdullah that said the name of the of1:08:44 the uh of the Jewish scholar convented1:08:48 and this one is1:08:51 one is one people of the paradise and he1:08:54 was a very very modest mother said1:08:56 someone1:08:57 said met him in the streets I say uh you1:09:01 are saying they say people say that to1:09:05 you you have a you have a witness of1:09:06 horizon people say things which they1:09:09 should not be saying all the things what1:09:11 is there is that one day I saw so you1:09:15 see the the honesty and the modesty of1:09:16 this man I saw a vision or a dream that1:09:20 I was climbing up like like a like a1:09:23 pool like a road going to heaven and up1:09:27 up and someone said go up go up go up1:09:29 until I I reached almost the top and1:09:31 they held on on on the Rope there or not1:09:37 and this somehow it was shaking or1:09:39 something and then I hold to it firm and1:09:42 I woke up while holding extent I walk1:09:44 and my hand was hurting of being tight1:09:47 twisted1:09:48 Allah said you will hold to this robe is1:09:51 a is a symbol symbolizing the Quran1:09:56 until you die1:09:59 until you die you'll end in Paradise1:10:03 did not like that's a conclusion the guy1:10:06 they're going overboard1:10:08 that's all what is there they should not1:10:11 even make that almost natural and1:10:13 practical way1:10:15 they will be such odd guys on Modern1:10:17 Times very assured scholarships Islam1:10:19 and they announced they have their1:10:21 videos in in1:10:23 in in in in1:10:24 YouTube and so on but it's awfully1:10:27 difficult but you know the independence1:10:29 is difficult not difficult easy not easy1:10:31 if skill is not excused if some some may1:10:33 be excused the the1:10:35 childhood condition their level of1:10:38 knowledge is so deficient that they will1:10:40 be true we don't bother about that is1:10:43 that Allah said those who have already1:10:45 recognized1:10:47 this Messenger as they recognizer or sun1:10:50 they have lost themselves because they1:10:52 did not only do so in their best friend1:10:54 they have go against themselves again1:10:55 there after life they gain the power1:10:56 that started when they have lost1:10:57 themselves1:11:00 so1:11:03 so this that I come after that meaning1:11:06 part of the discussion there is1:11:08 summarizing some some of the bits there1:11:10 that they have double checked about the1:11:12 Quran with the people of the book and1:11:14 they they got some feedback which must1:11:17 have shown them that it couldn't be1:11:19 possible for Muhammad1:11:21 because it contains things which only1:11:23 prophets could know or clarification1:11:25 which only a prophet can know or answers1:11:27 only about honest prophets would say1:11:29 that foreign1:11:33 at least1:11:36 not known now but you have a very little1:11:38 knowledge this opened the door that in1:11:41 down the future when you get more1:11:42 knowledge you may be able to understand1:11:44 the secret of life what is that one but1:11:46 not now now we have very little1:11:48 technology your knowledge now is not up1:11:50 to that level that's all the double1:11:51 answer1:11:52 did not endure to mention any imaginary1:11:55 nonsense or something like that like a1:11:57 fabricator or liar or someone could1:11:59 could do that1:12:09 next album1:12:18 one second1:12:22 and who could be more wicked than he who1:12:25 attributes his own lying inventions to1:12:26 God or gives the light to his messages1:12:29 verily such evildoers will never attain1:12:32 to a happy state next translation who1:12:34 does greater wrong than someone who1:12:36 fabricates lies against God or denies1:12:38 his Revelations those who do such wrong1:12:41 will not prosper1:12:42 yeah that's very clear1:12:45 so the biggest wrongdoing the biggest1:12:49 Justice if we translate1:12:51 Injustice which is transcription1:12:55 is fabricating Allah against Allah1:12:58 say Allah said that for attributing a1:13:01 book to him which is not1:13:02 like for example one of the arguments of1:13:04 the Jews against Muhammad is that1:13:06 that is1:13:08 received Aviation that they will be1:13:10 always messengers of coming from from1:13:14 bani style until the end of time1:13:18 and there would be only foreign1:13:33 to send a messenger like him to the1:13:36 people from themselves on the last time1:13:38 we will send a messenger from their1:13:40 Brethren their brothers1:13:46 that's they have a they have a tradition1:13:49 for Musa and so well the book is clearly1:13:51 saying not that so they're fabricating1:13:54 against someone that's that that that1:13:56 grave translation Injustice applies to1:13:59 anyone who is fabricating also a Hadith1:14:01 because the Hadith is supposed to be1:14:04 when it's established it's supposed to1:14:06 be based on Revelation so you're1:14:08 fabricating Aristotle if you say Allah1:14:10 said that I mean you know it's a1:14:11 publication you're fabricating it as1:14:13 soon as you say the message you're1:14:14 always saying that but because it's1:14:15 Alpha level messenger it's actually a1:14:17 revelation you're attributing that1:14:18 follows for data so but1:14:22 someone think that's obligating Hadith1:14:25 is is less serious he's mistaken Hadith1:14:28 is as serious at fabricating our1:14:30 academic something is in the Quran which1:14:32 is not in the Quran and this is the1:14:34 greatest of West or in the previous1:14:36 books the greatest and West Constitution1:14:40 or the one who are the who attributes1:14:43 lies to to Allah's civilization see and1:14:46 declare them to be an eye1:14:48 although you know they are they are The1:14:49 Liberation like for example1:14:51 the some of the results claiming he's a1:14:54 messenger but the the claim that is not1:14:57 true1:14:58 he was confused that one was not1:15:00 reported probably1:15:03 or something like that that's also as1:15:05 Grave as fabricating these are the most1:15:08 clear one1:15:09 those who that generally the wrongdo1:15:12 weather and just once especially the one1:15:14 with the extremist level of1:15:16 the deepest bottom better because it's1:15:18 the Injustice is really low not high so1:15:21 to the bottom of the deepest abyss of of1:15:24 Injustice and transportation1:15:27 the the rep even worse but all1:15:29 transgressor and and just once they will1:15:31 not succeed1:15:34 but they will not prosper1:15:37 and then again the usual habits of the1:15:38 Quran give a warning what could be the1:15:40 repercussion of this Behavior wake up1:15:43 it's not that it's not an intellectual1:15:45 exercise it's not it's not a Pythagorean1:15:47 theorem it's going to prove them what's1:15:49 going to bother about it let other1:15:51 people grow with them applied in1:15:52 engineering I'm going to go to uh to do1:15:55 some Agriculture and animal breeding we1:15:57 don't need a mythical theorem most1:15:59 likely1:16:00 forget about it no it is not it has to1:16:03 do with your1:16:04 eternal life and your destiny1:16:06 it's much more grave than that1:16:09 ultimate collaborative meaning your1:16:11 place in the universe it's not just just1:16:13 a matter of applying in some technology1:16:16 which I don't like it I will go live1:16:18 like an Amish life in America and just1:16:21 live in agriculture and an animal1:16:23 breeding I don't need Pythagorean1:16:25 theorem engineering products no that's1:16:27 it doesn't work this way that's much1:16:29 more grip this is the meaning of your1:16:31 existence there1:16:33 and how we know that the Isis1:16:49 for one day We Shall Gather them all1:16:52 together and then we shall say unto1:16:53 those who described new Divinity to all1:16:56 beside God where now are those beings1:16:59 whom you imagine to have a share in1:17:01 God's divinity1:17:02 next translation one day we shall we1:17:05 will gather them all together and say to1:17:07 the idolaters where are those things you1:17:09 imagined to be partners with God1:17:15 so that would be the question1:17:19 where are they show me who are they1:17:22 most of these do not exist in the1:17:24 festival just fix them imagine where1:17:26 they look at it but some may exist as as1:17:28 entities but not with the attribution1:17:30 they had like for example Kings and1:17:32 rulers1:17:36 he's the king he's the one who has the1:17:39 violate the one who can enact close and1:17:41 defying Good and Evil1:17:44 but he is now1:17:46 completely downtrodden1:17:48 naked1:17:49 may be pulled from his leg on his face1:17:53 that doesn't have any1:17:55 alternative relevance who is the1:17:57 authority you claimed1:17:59 it's not none there it's not that as as1:18:01 if he's not in existence he may exist as1:18:04 a person but not with his attribution so1:18:06 either either type of divinity either1:18:09 rulership an ultimate reference being1:18:11 ultimate reference frame or device sets1:18:15 or Divine of streak whatever it is no1:18:17 there's not show me us1:18:19 obviously there will be none please1:18:21 there will be none or short known to be1:18:23 that what the people claimed about them1:18:32 so what some of them not all of them but1:18:34 we'll discuss that so it's a little1:18:36 translation best1:18:38 whereupon in their utter confusion they1:18:40 will only be able to say by God our1:18:42 sustainer we did not mean to ascribe1:18:45 Divinity to ought beside him next1:18:47 translation in the utter confusion they1:18:49 will only say by God our Lord we do not1:18:52 mean to associate partners with him yeah1:18:55 so that's that's1:18:59 saying that that's not true the Quran1:19:01 says sometimes if it's fractions says1:19:04 that a fraction of people say something1:19:06 and the others either agree or do not1:19:08 object clearly and separate themselves1:19:10 based on that it's attributed to all of1:19:12 them that's a standard speech way of1:19:15 speaking of the Quran and this we see1:19:17 that for example in baccarat said1:19:20 Allah's hand is tied to his neck being1:19:23 alive1:19:26 and clearly the one the one who said1:19:29 that's only one or two of them but the1:19:31 others approved it or trying to defend1:19:33 himself he was he was like for example1:19:35 he is a scholar yeah he made the score1:19:38 blender but he was really in a state of1:19:40 the debate and debate you are allowed to1:19:43 go to extreme points of view just to1:19:45 accept the other point or something like1:19:46 that some people make that excuses that1:19:48 if someone is in debate then he may may1:19:51 go overboard because of the necessity of1:19:54 debate someday this is that's happening1:19:55 with the Islamic company give you an1:19:57 example for example in the book response1:19:59 to khadariya and Shia by even Tamia he1:20:03 brings such nasty things about alibner1:20:05 and so on and the Defenders1:20:08 because it's a debate he said you can1:20:10 debate with the Shia and give them1:20:12 another voice but you always usually1:20:14 advocated by nasabi enemy of other bite1:20:17 as a possible to challenge them to1:20:19 answer to that or something like that's1:20:21 not an excuse that's not an excuse1:20:23 that's not the way the best should be1:20:25 that's meaning you are debating to1:20:27 defeat someone and not to bring the1:20:28 truth forward and this is a very bad1:20:30 debate a very bad behavior and it will1:20:33 stale you it will if you use arguments1:20:37 of nasibi1:20:38 then you are one of the nasabies I can't1:20:41 we can't say we can barely save and time1:20:43 here is an awesome because of using1:20:44 these arguments even if it's not debate1:20:46 this is not an acceleration the same1:20:48 here1:20:49 all of them approved that essentially1:20:52 silently or over by saying ah1:20:56 we don't object to that let him let him1:20:58 debate with the Muslim to see because uh1:21:01 because uh he was arguing Abu Bakr about1:21:04 about usury as I said okay your God1:21:07 prohibit usually and uh and give and1:21:09 give us a himself he trading it usually1:21:12 he asked us for charity and he can visit1:21:14 us multiple fold That's essential1:21:16 usually1:21:17 foreign1:21:54 all the few but the few who said no1:21:57 that's not under reject that they they1:22:00 are not Jews anymore they had a few days1:22:02 they became Muslims to become something1:22:03 else1:22:04 so in that in that sense it says the1:22:07 same year1:22:09 that is some of them saying that in1:22:11 confusion some of the approving that1:22:13 some of these men or maybe this is a1:22:14 good argument maybe you can get away1:22:15 with that in their other confusion and1:22:17 things like that but genuinely some will1:22:20 be saying that uh thinking they can't1:22:22 get away1:22:23 for example uh a hint upon this if they1:22:27 ask you on camera say oh we know it's1:22:28 only one God did they say it and you1:22:30 can't see in their movies and their when1:22:32 they discuss various idols and go say oh1:22:34 we know this is our manifestation of one1:22:36 God but the common people are too too1:22:39 simple-minded to comprehend such as1:22:41 abstract things so it's better to leave1:22:43 them with their idols and so on at least1:22:46 let's give some some kind of of1:22:47 commitment and moral a moral commitment1:22:50 and some some reasonable Behavior1:22:51 otherwise they will become completely1:22:53 Godless and then they will be behaving1:22:56 immoral and Society will disintegrate1:22:57 them we need it for social zero cohesion1:22:59 assumes that that's a very common1:23:01 argument if you discuss with them1:23:03 philosophically that is it's only one1:23:05 one more reality these are all1:23:07 manifestations faces of that the same1:23:09 with territory and say oh it's actually1:23:11 the only one God this faces1:23:13 sharing somehow a substance or something1:23:15 like that1:23:17 it's only one God1:23:19 three three in one but this one let's1:23:21 limit this one that's one algorithm and1:23:23 and similar arguments I'll advocate so1:23:25 it's genuinely something that that1:23:28 algorithm these arguments are valid1:23:29 which is that definitely in a manifest1:23:31 three notified1:23:33 manifested not because if you're talking1:23:35 about various attributes and aspects of1:23:37 the Divine you have the Divine names1:23:40 and description of the Divine action1:23:41 universe and approaching him for example1:23:44 if you are asking for for healing then1:23:46 you approach him as a massive or not and1:23:48 we're asking for him to help you against1:23:49 the enemy and smash your enemy that you1:23:51 ask him as a as a competitor and1:23:53 forceful the same one but you would1:23:56 invoke the attributes which is suitable1:23:58 for your supplication for example you1:24:00 don't need to go invoke for that one1:24:01 call him a Vishnu and then Shiva no1:24:07 just trying to justify their paganism or1:24:10 their shirk by giving it a a nice polish1:24:13 as a various faces over there or the1:24:16 various Persona of the same Identity or1:24:18 something like that all this is not1:24:19 going to work so all of these may be1:24:21 happening1:24:24 but this will not help1:24:26 Allah1:24:36 um before I go on there there's a couple1:24:38 of questions if you don't mind yeah okay1:24:40 so one is um1:24:42 what about the Jewish claim that a new1:24:44 Prophet cannot abrogate their laws1:24:46 that's the first question what what1:24:48 should what's a good question the Jewish1:24:50 people they claim that the you know at1:24:52 the time when a new Prophet cannot1:24:55 abrogate their laws1:24:57 yeah that's that's one that's that's1:24:59 that's one of their clips1:25:01 that's when the claims are the Quran1:25:03 refuted1:25:05 we told them listen Musa obligated some1:25:09 of the law of of yakub1:25:14 himself1:25:22 and this is a new Torah bring it and1:25:24 read it1:25:25 so the the they are recruiting1:25:27 themselves right away1:25:31 also um the other question about um1:25:36 apology but I would bring that as an1:25:37 argument this cannot be a prophet1:25:39 because it's obligating but obligation1:25:40 is not possible and they either make it1:25:42 as a notification for a lot to obligate1:25:44 his injunctions1:25:46 that's that's one one uh one claim which1:25:49 means Allah is bound by his own1:25:51 injunction and so on which is then he's1:25:52 not a free agent he's then deaf dead1:25:55 deaf the blind nature cannot be so he's1:25:57 essentially declaring Allah to be a to1:25:59 be a deity or or or a Creator but not a1:26:04 commander1:26:09 this goes to a deep philosophical issues1:26:11 of Allah's Freedom absolutely Act1:26:18 so the fact that um a lot of their rules1:26:20 were as a result they're misbehaving1:26:22 purely if he imposed rules of the1:26:25 punishment he would be the one to decide1:26:26 when to elapse yeah but but this is this1:26:29 is the country but it goes to the1:26:30 fundamentals is possible for the Divine1:26:32 being which is absolutely sovereign1:26:59 is not bound by any previous law nobody1:27:02 he bind himself with Satan limited that1:27:05 he does not make an injection which is1:27:06 unexecutable but that would be Injustice1:27:08 and things like that but otherwise he1:27:11 has his he he can make various various1:27:14 uh laws which one I will get the other1:27:16 one and all of them and this also1:27:19 refused to kill a claim for example of1:27:21 hesitari for example that is the divine1:27:23 revelation is the best solution so it's1:27:25 not it's a possible solution could be1:27:27 the best in certain time could be the1:27:29 best like for example uh how how for1:27:32 example uh in a outside the in the1:27:35 creative realm how for example the1:27:37 relation between male and female1:27:39 for for cliche who have the two Sexes1:27:42 well separated as usually for Animals1:27:44 higher animals at least1:27:47 uh that's the the relation is very1:27:49 complex we have we have for example uh1:27:52 we have a relatively monogamous relation1:27:55 like for example the leopards but they1:27:57 are still from the big cuts and we have1:27:59 a multi uh not monogamous what they call1:28:02 it polygamous relation both sides in the1:28:05 alliance four or five lens shared like1:28:08 10 15 layers1:28:09 on this work perfectly for lens and they1:28:12 are not far away evolutionary and1:28:13 biologically from it works for them very1:28:15 well and for the leopards the other one1:28:17 works very well monogamous relation1:28:20 for example if you go for example a1:28:22 little bit lower you'll find for example1:28:24 the example which make one one zoologist1:28:27 become an atheist1:28:30 let me report that is that some type of1:28:33 of1:28:34 spider so the one with eight legs either1:28:38 from scorpions they are not insects they1:28:40 are from1:28:41 Arachnophobia or something like yeah1:28:47 creatures1:28:48 insects are sex-legged so that there's1:28:51 another another big class1:28:54 in one of them the arrangement of male1:28:56 and female is the following the the1:28:58 function of the male is to in to1:29:01 fertilize the female the Montage is1:29:03 fertilized she stinks him1:29:05 with a poison with a slow poison or1:29:07 there's not a poison it's some kind of a1:29:09 synonym or something like that so he's1:29:12 completely paralyzed1:29:14 yeah1:29:15 and his life function sinks almost to1:29:18 zero what remains alive1:29:20 and then when the eggs are ready to be1:29:22 she put the eggs in the body of the1:29:24 father1:29:24 the male1:29:26 and the hatch and the first meal first1:29:28 generally first meal for some time is1:29:30 the body of the father so they consume1:29:32 the father1:29:33 and this slowly just saw that and say oh1:29:35 we will he imagine himself most likely1:29:38 as a male a scorpion a million1:29:42 male spider1:29:46 and imagine how painful and suffering it1:29:49 will be but this is only imagination1:29:51 this work for the spider excellently for1:29:54 clearly this has been established at1:29:56 least 400 500 million years ago because1:29:58 spider have reached their Peak and the1:30:01 time in the carbon time and this I think1:30:03 400 300 million years back something1:30:05 like that and it's persisting and stable1:30:07 since then so it functions excellently1:30:10 and to resist all the changes of1:30:12 evolution1:30:13 so1:30:15 no this so this works there's another1:30:18 way to function for functionality1:30:20 obviously it's not for animals who give1:30:22 birth it doesn't work for Animals you1:30:23 get bad because it will that you know1:30:25 the theology will not work this way now1:30:28 we understand that but at least for1:30:30 those who lay eggs the eggs in the body1:30:31 of the father now our friend who became1:30:34 atheists throughout the Cannons we got1:30:36 this must be some blind dead nature1:30:37 doing that obviously I say how how do1:30:41 you know how do you know that it is1:30:43 painful for the father maybe he enjoyed1:30:45 this thing1:30:46 he becomes high like as having a crack1:30:49 cocaine and they enjoy the whole process1:30:51 he's not no it's just imagining he's1:30:54 imagining that that male spider is1:30:57 feeling the same way like I'm just1:30:58 answering to his argument that this is1:31:00 it cannot be a God who allow that to1:31:02 happen in the universe no it can be very1:31:04 well it can be red it can it can be1:31:07 tuned to work but I mean my point here1:31:09 is not that a God or not God is that1:31:11 there are various models of mating in in1:31:13 the animal kingdom and all work1:31:17 Liberty to establish this or this or1:31:19 this or establish with them in parallel1:31:21 so you can see the various various1:31:22 variations and all of them fit in the1:31:24 context and in their species probably1:31:26 and bring whatever needed for that1:31:28 species to that level1:31:30 it's actually a childish argument it's1:31:32 like saying I don't like gravity because1:31:33 I dropped my favorite yeah so so there's1:31:36 there's a limit I mean that's out of1:31:38 something this atheist guy because he's1:31:39 simple-minded obviously he's just1:31:40 Immortal isn't that Christianity that's1:31:42 this whole concept yeah yeah yeah yeah1:31:43 but but even even in Christian frame1:31:46 he's not he's not allowed to say that1:31:48 because how do you know that this male1:31:50 as a spider is is suffering maybe that's1:31:53 the ultimate pleasure for him it's like1:31:55 a paradise1:32:03 which produce a very stable1:32:06 species going for hundreds of millions1:32:08 of years without any problem1:32:10 that's possible that's possible that's1:32:12 possible the same with human society the1:32:14 the arrangement of marriage and uh how1:32:17 to how to organize intercourse1:32:21 can be discount this is the local change1:32:25 it can be very well done certain law1:32:27 there's no limit on number of wives like1:32:29 in previous laws1:32:31 then Islam is restricted to four for1:32:33 example1:32:35 there are many many things like that you1:32:38 know and both work in a certain historic1:32:40 context some of them may be the suitable1:32:42 one until the end of time that's we1:32:43 can't argue about that and analyze it1:32:45 and study philosophical aspect of1:32:47 society and things like that but this is1:32:48 ultimately until end and that's that's a1:32:51 possibility that's a possibility and1:32:52 Allah is a liberty to to enact this or1:32:54 enact this and don't forget this with1:32:56 this1:32:59 another another one um so this is this1:33:02 algorithm to the Jews is is is1:33:03 rationally not defensible1:33:12 previous injunction comparing him to to1:33:15 uh not to make another injunctional1:33:16 abuse that's impossible that's that's1:33:18 contradict by the attribute of being a1:33:21 necessary existing no1:33:25 um another one question was uh no I'll1:33:28 pick it up on these questions a bit1:33:29 later so when you were mentioning about1:33:32 um the person who was wavering in uh1:33:34 taking shahada that was not Abdullah1:33:39 no which one which one what do you think1:33:42 well because I've caught this late1:33:43 unfortunately um is the one who was1:33:46 studying when the prophet was in Makkah1:33:48 sending his son when the prophet came he1:33:50 came and took I took him say I saw his1:33:52 face as clearly not the face of Malaya1:33:54 his behavior then he embraced Islam and1:33:56 then he was hiding and the Jews came and1:33:58 they started attacking him that's the1:34:00 story I'm wrenchling so the other one1:34:02 the other person is uh Kabul Ashraf who1:34:04 was who took shahada at the time of um1:34:19 the famous Jewish1:34:22 foreign1:34:52 to establish proof of profit from the1:34:55 previous scriptures1:34:56 um so basically Isaiah it mentions here1:34:58 is my servant whom I uphold My Chosen1:35:00 One in whom I Delight I will put my1:35:03 spirit on him and he will bring Nation1:35:05 Justice to the Nations he will not cry1:35:07 or shout or raise his voice in the1:35:09 streets a bruised read but basically you1:35:11 know a raise of1:35:12 I think it might be similar to raise1:35:14 them up a profit for a month your1:35:16 brethren there's various proofs that1:35:17 they use1:35:18 um what's your thought on on as I and1:35:20 all these various1:35:22 um verses in the Bible that allude to1:35:25 the prophet or a messiah that's that's1:35:27 that's it if you read the context and so1:35:29 on it's clearly talking about the future1:35:31 Prophet which have these characteristics1:35:35 the Christian claim that is that's1:35:37 that's announcing uh announcing Issa but1:35:40 if you look at exactly what what Teresa1:35:42 did and what what he did1:35:45 much more better1:35:48 let's read it1:35:50 so this is uh so here is my servant whom1:35:53 I uphold My Chosen One even whom I1:35:55 Delight I will put my spirit on him and1:35:57 he will bring Justice to the Nations who1:35:59 will not cry shout or cry out or raise1:36:01 his voice in the streets a bruised1:36:03 wreath he will not break and a1:36:04 smoldering Wick he will not snap out in1:36:06 faithness he will bring in faithfulness1:36:08 he will bring forth Justice he will not1:36:10 falter or be discouraged till he1:36:12 establishes Justice on Earth in his1:36:14 teachings that Islands will put hope1:36:17 this is what God the Lord says the1:36:19 creator of the heavens who stretches1:36:20 they're out who spreads out the Earth1:36:22 with all that Springs from it and gives1:36:24 breath to its people and Life to those1:36:27 who walk on it by the Lord hath for1:36:29 called you in righteousness I will take1:36:31 hold of your hand I will keep you and1:36:33 make you to be a covenant for the people1:36:35 and the light of the Gentiles to open1:36:37 eyes that are blind to free captives1:36:39 from prison and to release from the1:36:41 Dutch from the Judgment those from the1:36:43 dungeon those who sit in darkness I am1:36:45 the Lord that is my name I will not1:36:47 yield my glory to another1:36:56 then you have to admit that he is a1:36:59 servant of Allah is not a son that's1:37:00 very clear it's number one secondly that1:37:03 he is sent to the Gentile this is1:37:05 clearly like of the Gentiles talking1:37:06 about the Gentiles that the Gentiles is1:37:09 well established in the Old Testament1:37:11 meaning anybody except the Jews the1:37:13 gentites the non-jews the non-descendant1:37:15 of Yahoo the argentites1:37:20 is that in various places that he is1:37:24 sent to the Lost Children of an Israel1:37:26 the only one who claims that he is the1:37:28 Gentile is actually Paul claiming he is1:37:30 the messenger of Arisa to the Gentile so1:37:32 during his life on Earth and all the1:37:34 disciples except for all they they they1:37:37 claim is a sense of an Israel1:37:39 and then the poor came with this odd1:37:42 Theory and then have a conflict with1:37:44 them and so on this is described him in1:37:45 his Epistles some people study important1:37:48 more explicitly after obviously the1:37:50 shares were hold on power vein and1:37:52 nobody is afraid of being banned on the1:37:54 stake which shows clearly that the issue1:37:56 that the Christianity should be spread1:37:58 to the Gentile is a Pauline invention1:38:00 relying on the claim that suggests that1:38:03 there is a empowered them to that in the1:38:05 spirit1:38:06 but also he mixed up with that ASA and1:38:08 the Son of God not a servant1:38:10 that's very clear so that if that's true1:38:14 if that's true in itself then it1:38:16 contradicts IC or or or1:38:19 pole is contradicting idea if let's say1:38:22 that that message then the message does1:38:25 not fit on ASA because you say only a1:38:27 servant who is the life of the Gentiles1:38:28 Isa was not like that also the center of1:38:31 Israel that is very clear1:38:33 and for all the disabled disciples1:38:35 stating that clearly except the the the1:38:38 the the1:38:39 Renegade or the or the heretic uh1:38:43 appalled1:38:44 independent obviously is doing that1:38:46 deliberately to undermine Christianity1:38:48 or he's really convinced and he has some1:38:50 visions and so on or is mentally1:38:51 deranged or sick or it doesn't matter1:38:53 what's his motivation clearly that's his1:38:56 statement and this is the Epistles1:38:58 attribute to him seven of them are so1:39:00 well established almost with attitude1:39:01 being from him1:39:03 they clearly saw that and clearly they1:39:05 saw the conflicts in some places with1:39:07 the or with with the rest of the1:39:10 Disciples of what they call the the the1:39:12 the the the holy men of Jerusalem1:39:16 and in one place they complained clearly1:39:19 about I'll say that what's about it are1:39:22 they super opposite or I met the Lord1:39:24 the Christ in spirit and the and he's1:39:27 got mourning that when he leaves the1:39:28 place then the people of Jerusalem sent1:39:30 someone behind him to educate the people1:39:33 that what Paul told you is not correct1:39:35 here messages gospel is not a correct1:39:37 one say but my ghost was the correct one1:39:39 their gospel is not correct and they1:39:41 sometimes mocked them call them the1:39:42 circumcision party because they could1:39:45 they stick to the the Jewish law of1:39:47 circumcision1:39:48 Etc so it's clear the conflict is there1:39:50 what has been glossed over through1:39:52 history and the scholar did not discuss1:39:54 it until modern times1:39:56 so that message that that prophecy does1:39:59 not fit anybody since Isaiah until now1:40:01 that it's I say I do let you know that1:40:03 ICS is as as written like that is1:40:06 written before before a reason for1:40:08 Muhammad absolutely certainty is1:40:10 definitely because we have almost a1:40:12 complete IC and I did see Scrolls1:40:15 yeah we have a complete one1:40:17 carbon dated and polygraphically dated1:40:20 being to be there like 150 years before1:40:23 ASA so it's a prophecy ahead of the1:40:26 coming of Israel coming of Muhammad1:40:28 number one number two the the one in our1:40:32 hand is truly and Mr Kelly she copied1:40:35 from that because we have IC itself I1:40:37 said almost a complete Ico and the DC1:40:39 Scrolls and fragments of the of uh of uh1:40:43 uh Daniel and others but almost a1:40:46 complete I think it's a complete not1:40:47 almost a complete idea and the choice it1:40:51 proves with certitude that the Kobe from1:40:53 Kobe from Kobe from Kobe we have at the1:40:55 10th Century 10th Christian Century uh1:40:58 which which was codified and regarded as1:41:01 the masoretic test text which is rather1:41:03 the canonical Old Testament in Hebrew1:41:05 and Aramaic that one1:41:09 fits almost exactly with that with that1:41:11 version except few maybe variations and1:41:13 and spelling uh and transcription errors1:41:16 which means the copying process is1:41:18 absolutely reliable over 11 centuries so1:41:22 we have all of these problems especially1:41:23 icr is really uh we could say is a1:41:26 Divine protection of Isaiah that the1:41:28 complete ICI is available in the1:41:30 distance Scrolls that it can be1:41:32 approving with certitude being being1:41:34 there uh 150 before Christ so in the1:41:37 second century before Christ it is there1:41:40 without any doubt and it has been copied1:41:43 ridiculously and kily and Killingly1:41:45 without any mistake of any relevance1:41:47 there would be Mistakes One mistakes1:41:49 will be there but they can be gleaned1:41:50 out and clearly identified like any book1:41:54 any book is cleared over a covered over1:41:56 Generations what happens even even1:41:57 printed books the first the second print1:42:00 will correct some mistakes of husband1:42:01 that's that's natural that's by1:42:03 necessary nobody argued about that1:42:05 until the 10th century when we have the1:42:07 codified version of school gamma solitic1:42:09 text which is in the hand of the people1:42:10 now since 10th Century there's a1:42:13 thousand year roughly so that's that's1:42:15 you could say that's part of the1:42:17 protection of the Divine uh Revelation1:42:19 that we have therefore ICA and this if1:42:23 you read it it doesn't fit twice set a1:42:26 lot1:42:27 not the issue of the post Nicene belief1:42:36 to be the life of the Gentile even in1:42:39 some places he expresses even in a1:42:43 radical form so don't go through the the1:42:45 ways of the nation.gov1:42:47 and in another episode an interesting1:42:50 one1:42:51 which this is the fact that he's only1:42:53 too many side is that one woman from the1:42:56 Samaritan Samaritan are1:42:58 claiming to be uh originally for Israel1:43:02 but they they they they they I think the1:43:04 remaining of the state of Israel not of1:43:06 the Judea1:43:07 somehow we don't their history is very1:43:09 dark but they are not classified as1:43:11 somebody is1:43:12 and one woman1:43:14 came with a child girl or boy or1:43:18 something sick and wanted Lisa to heal1:43:20 him1:43:22 foreign you know that's obviously the1:43:25 report seems to at first sight a bit1:43:27 offensive but it's not it's a test1:43:30 it is a model so you have to look at the1:43:33 F3 between the lines to see what's going1:43:34 on and1:43:36 said I give us from the the grace that1:43:40 God have given to you show to my son1:43:43 and he said1:43:45 but it states in the scripture also I1:43:48 said the State written that you should1:43:49 not throw good food or something to the1:43:52 dogs so essentially saying hey you are a1:43:54 dog I'm not sent you I'm not sure you're1:43:57 giving you anything that's the word of1:43:58 occasion this is this is not the Teresa1:44:01 I said believing that there are dogs no1:44:04 but you have to understand what's the1:44:06 context and she said1:44:07 follow Iman and trust in him say even1:44:11 Lord or Master even dogs or Rabbi1:44:15 even dogs they deserve some of the1:44:18 crumbs of the table1:44:20 forgive me from the camps and he tends1:44:22 today now that the whole education1:44:24 process has finished and the attention1:44:26 to the decibel tell them see the face of1:44:28 this woman do you have such a faith and1:44:31 he healed her her child immediately1:44:33 became healing so but that's that1:44:36 indicate very sick place to test her1:44:37 head Give an example for the disciples1:44:39 how fast should be and how she'll accept1:44:41 because1:44:43 an unbeliever would say how come that1:44:46 this man is insulting me at the Academy1:44:47 as a dog no1:44:49 he's a messenger1:44:51 what he says must have some sense good1:44:52 sense as I accepted1:44:55 I accept even if he classify as a dog1:44:57 that's a promo classification he has1:44:59 good reason because he has that from God1:45:01 the Almighty1:45:03 I'm not secondly kissing God I'm sick1:45:04 and kissing myself that's Faith that's1:45:07 through Iman1:45:08 genuine Iman and he healed the child1:45:14 you have to read these things with with1:45:16 the eye of of really that's that's a1:45:18 messenger of Allah and what he does is1:45:20 invaluable to expose Satan deeper deep1:45:23 realities which you may not see it at1:45:25 first like for example the volume story1:45:27 which made people say this is his his1:45:31 anti-environment or his his hostile to1:45:34 the to the environment or to the world1:45:36 because he sent his disciple to get him1:45:38 some some uh some Thin what's his name1:45:41 some um1:45:43 from from uh from a tree what's the name1:45:46 of the fruit1:45:48 no not the olives the other one the1:45:49 famous one of Palestine yeah1:45:51 fig tree and1:45:54 they went and didn't find any fruit they1:45:56 came back say master1:45:58 teacher we didn't find any fruit1:46:02 and he cares the tree and the three1:46:03 without the way three sir why because1:46:06 the trees looks like stupid Behavior no1:46:08 it's not1:46:10 that tree which has no fruit is a symbol1:46:12 symbolizes1:46:17 they will not bring any fruit anymore1:46:19 they are finished at the people of1:46:21 Covenant whatever1:46:23 and he cares them and the three whether1:46:25 the way meaning but Israel conformation1:46:28 after him because it was clear for him1:46:30 very religious at the moment they will1:46:32 reject you but it's clear if in the1:46:34 Daniel prophecy that he will be rejected1:46:36 and be cut away from other people so he1:46:38 knew that now this became apparent and1:46:40 he cares that tree1:46:42 and that he immediately became yellow1:46:44 and without the way disintegrated so1:46:47 showing the seats here the this levels1:46:49 of one Miracle because just by by1:46:52 carries it will not throw that away1:46:54 immediately that's not that's against1:46:55 the physical law of the universe1:46:58 it aged let us see it aged in a second1:47:01 few seconds it taste water based over1:47:04 100 years1:47:05 time accelerated it's along another1:47:08 timeline if you believe in the language1:47:09 of Star Wars and static1:47:12 this one secondly he gave them a symbol1:47:14 with it and you just need to think a1:47:16 little bit what what is the tree which1:47:18 doesn't give it through it's not worth1:47:19 staying it should be kids on God what1:47:22 was that this symbolizing what is this1:47:24 right I'm taking more small carburetor1:47:26 of the of the New Testament agree on1:47:28 that that is he that's a symbol for1:47:30 Israel it's not her style or environment1:47:32 or casting re-arbital you know but that1:47:35 is too unfollable and too Noble to be1:47:37 like that so that's an example an1:47:39 example of the things which are the1:47:41 first for the simple-minded one atheists1:47:43 and so on will be offensive but it's not1:47:45 it shows deep realities anyway all of1:47:48 that1:47:49 all of that including a three-story the1:47:52 dog story The Samaritan lady1:47:55 etc etc all of that produce certain1:47:58 knowledge that he is not sent to the1:48:00 Gentile1:48:03 while I see a silicon in the light of1:48:05 the Gentile the lighter we have1:48:07 established Justice1:48:09 in the world1:48:11 and this this fits only to Muhammad not1:48:14 Teresa which is the Daniel prophecy1:48:18 will be cut off from the people and he1:48:20 has been cut off in the people whatever1:48:22 the cutoff mean crossfaction whatever1:48:24 that's another issue which I am working1:48:26 on in some English writing issue1:48:28 inshallah hopefully will get sometimes1:48:30 in there in the future I put that aside1:48:32 for some time because of various reasons1:48:34 related to1:48:36 synchronizing all this and things like1:48:38 that but what this does work out now1:48:40 alhamdulillah who may be able to give us1:48:42 a bit a few more months and years life1:48:44 we will finish that and bring it out but1:48:46 so that doesn't fit1:48:49 and then and and obviously of Daniel1:48:52 it's in the time frame exactly it was1:48:55 the day the dot they dotted exactly and1:48:58 secondly it mentioned him with the name1:48:59 the Messiah and mentioned with the1:49:01 Messiah the ruler and mentioned that1:49:03 will be cut off from the people1:49:06 There's No Escape if it's an Issa then1:49:08 he's not the one in Isaiah1:49:10 is1:49:13 the only one that fits it is but I would1:49:16 say this is one of the1:49:18 irrefutable1:49:20 absolute evidences for various things1:49:22 one of it that Ico must be of divine1:49:25 because there's a very structural polio1:49:26 prophecy1:49:28 it is not like going toward Empire1:49:30 Merida and tell you the old Maria and I1:49:31 scare and get three boys that happens to1:49:33 the 40 50 percent or thirty percent ten1:49:37 percent of human beings so that's not1:49:39 that a description which fits1:49:42 only one man or if it's no man1:49:45 and we see it fits from these two1:49:46 competing benefits only one that's one1:49:49 second this is really recorded and will1:49:51 establish what absolutely statutory1:49:53 before the coming of Muhammad evidence1:49:55 the full idea in the in the or in in the1:50:00 in the in the Dead Sea Scrolls1:50:04 dated by by archeology dating by1:50:07 polygraphy and I think I think it has1:50:09 been dated by radio glad you're dating1:50:12 if not then they can't do it still it's1:50:13 available and you can't cut some of the1:50:15 parchment and they're still available1:50:16 and don't know where it is that can be1:50:18 related if someone is doubt it but1:50:19 nobody even doubted that or because of1:50:21 the calligraphy is free and that's right1:50:23 out of writing and the place of that1:50:25 gets clear and uh1:50:28 uh under the dates of the Quran1:50:31 Community is clear all of that is1:50:32 cleared with certitude1:50:35 so it is definitely before Muhammad and1:50:37 even before Isa with with the Parisa1:50:39 with the about uh let us say one century1:50:42 at least one and a half century and1:50:43 before Muhammad at least with five1:50:45 centuries extensions1:50:48 and this in our hand independently1:50:51 and the Fulfillment of the Prophet the1:50:53 prophecy is not depending upon1:50:55 Muhammad's action nor that he says1:50:56 action or anybody's accent especially1:50:58 the prophecy about Teresa coming a set1:51:00 indeed it's impossible to be fulfilled1:51:03 except by a supranational divine power1:51:06 the one who controls the universe the1:51:09 same with Muhammad's one neither he nor1:51:11 his companions or anyone reading that1:51:13 can can fulfill it so that that's some1:51:16 kind of oh we got that message let's fix1:51:18 our situation so it fits the message no1:51:20 that's not fixable that's exactly like a1:51:22 volcano erupting a set in a certain1:51:25 place cannot be fixed because nobody can1:51:27 initiate a volcano1:51:29 sure1:51:30 this I would say this one this one is I1:51:34 would say if analyzed properly with all1:51:36 circumstantial it thinks about but it1:51:39 has to be done first a strategy I say1:51:41 establishing its dating establishing the1:51:43 copying establishing all of these things1:51:44 it has no other interpretation1:51:48 sure if I'm conscious of time because of1:51:50 other so I think we we we stopped here1:51:53 at the work for devs yet and then one1:51:55 question that's outstanding it's not1:51:57 related to this so if we just stop the1:51:58 stuff here there and we will I'll time1:52:00 soon this question is not related to1:52:02 that we can leave it for the for the1:52:04 private session after that otherwise we1:52:05 do it now that question if you want to1:52:08 ask very quickly it's a very simple1:52:09 question so basically1:52:10 um1:52:11 to uh he's got a question he wants to1:52:13 start make a website where people can1:52:16 share good memories of people who have1:52:18 passed away so their families can read1:52:19 them1:52:20 should I make it for everyone or only1:52:23 for Muslims if I make it for everyone it1:52:25 is very likely that Christians will1:52:27 write comments of shirk should I make it1:52:30 only for Muslims1:52:31 if the purpose of that they share they1:52:35 share their memories and things like1:52:36 that fine1:52:38 and everyone responsible with his right1:52:40 you are putting a platform1:52:42 that's that's no problem with that1:52:45 who guarantee you that some Muslims will1:52:48 not try to also filter1:52:52 this is this is this is he's thinking1:52:54 about things which either why should the1:52:57 memory of someone containing shirk1:53:03 and just ask ask himself objectively how1:53:06 can expect memories sharing memories of1:53:08 their past ones1:53:10 they may mention something miraculous1:53:12 for example but all the what the1:53:14 corporation for example making Dua and1:53:16 being healed and so on does not contain1:53:18 any1:53:20 instead makes application to Allah1:53:31 in having a platform are you I think1:53:34 that's that's coming from mentality of1:53:35 being obsessed with things which are do1:53:37 not exist in reality if you make a1:53:39 website with this and with this other1:53:40 and that's the specification other1:53:42 people expressed freely their memories1:53:44 that's perfectly fine if you think it's1:53:47 weird it's wealthy of of of making for1:53:50 for whatever reason for dawa for just1:53:54 sharing pain and feeling or just1:53:56 psychological healing whatever it is1:53:58 that's why1:54:00 the question really is around are you1:54:02 liable so for example it could be1:54:04 anything like I give someone 50. no no1:54:05 no1:54:07 yeah because um where do you stop you1:54:10 could put condition that if someone had1:54:11 for example something which which is1:54:13 sexually offensive or something1:54:15 insulting profits or insulting deities1:54:17 or something something like that or plus1:54:19 famous it will be removed that's fine1:54:23 but post not before1:54:25 because assuming that before is is is1:54:27 making you what's about if I want to go1:54:30 to the to the high road near high road1:54:32 to have a couple of of of Costa maybe I1:54:36 will I will I will stumble on on the1:54:40 boardwalk and my stumbling will push1:54:42 someone under the bus and kill him it1:54:44 can't happen1:54:46 does it mean that I will not go out all1:54:48 this is just imagining things which may1:54:50 happen but it's either remote or some of1:54:52 them are highly highly possible1:55:01 I think if you think something maybe but1:55:04 it just give instruction that this the1:55:07 such statement of this or this type but1:55:10 you have to specify or things1:55:12 pornographic or things like that or1:55:14 immoral will be removed1:55:16 so that people will when they post their1:55:18 posters but most likely memories of the1:55:21 loved one who passed away will not1:55:22 contain anything like that I don't think1:55:24 I'm excited that's my my mother was a1:55:26 pornography1:55:28 a pornographic actor I don't think1:55:31 anyone will share that so what would be1:55:33 there I'll put you in picture of her I1:55:34 don't think so1:55:36 so just to follow on for that1:55:39 um so his worry is someone will say1:55:40 accept Jesus you know like prosthetize1:55:42 proselytize no problem accept yourself1:55:45 we're accepting we have already accepted1:55:47 him as the messenger of God1:55:48 and we already tell you that that your1:55:50 claimed that he is the Son of God and1:55:52 son is is nonsensical it's not what the1:55:54 scriptures say the only one who said1:55:55 that in extensive numbers of time is is1:55:58 port and Paul is a heretic1:56:00 by the witness of the early church that1:56:02 the conflict pushes described but1:56:04 you're indicated not tell you that I1:56:07 know many Christians who read by1:56:08 themselves and so on they have recognize1:56:10 that they are working to us1:56:12 sure let him and then you just make a1:56:14 note prepare and prepare a response for1:56:16 that prepare a structure response like1:56:18 the one from uh from various various uh1:56:22 people who have blogs and things like1:56:24 that say see for this this1:56:26 response in this block just prepare1:56:29 prepare a rebutter for that1:56:31 I don't think there's any any injuries1:56:33 over that but just the opposite it's1:56:35 good to have that and you have done a1:56:37 rebutton there maybe in the context of1:56:40 of uh1:56:42 of uh besides the one who said for1:56:44 example and here they in her death she1:56:46 accepted Jesus and died smilingly but1:56:49 most likely she did not accept him she1:56:51 was an atheist before that definitely1:56:52 accepting Jesus whatever you accept him1:56:54 as a messenger we don't know how she1:56:56 accepted him what was in her mind but1:56:58 it's much better than than dying as an1:57:01 atheist still it's good1:57:05 guys I think this is all based on an1:57:08 obsessed mind of someone who who uh is1:57:11 used to the mentality1:57:13 behind every tree there is a heretic1:57:15 behind every wall there is someone with1:57:17 a machine gun that's not true1:57:19 it's behaving anyone with machine gun1:57:22 behind in any wall ultimately it's it's1:57:25 ultimately it's the motherhood mentality1:57:27 that seek the monster yeah it's it's a1:57:29 segmentality it's the segmentality yeah1:57:31 but the thing is the thing is this1:57:32 because the charlatans the charlatans of1:57:36 The Madras they want to Corner the1:57:39 market on this issue and make an issue1:57:41 out of nothing while they ignore1:57:55 delegation came and discussed with him1:57:58 various issues when it came to even to1:57:59 the mutual causation but they bailed out1:58:01 and they decided no we'll Beijing and so1:58:03 on and1:58:05 Etc during the the time they were in1:58:08 Medina the prayer time came and they1:58:10 asked and and they went even with not1:58:12 asking permission to do their prayer1:58:14 they made the temporary Altar and they1:58:16 wanted to do whatever inside the masjido1:58:18 Medina unless I leave them1:58:21 what's your problem people want to play1:58:23 according to their religion1:58:25 they're not urinating or defecating1:58:27 they're praying1:58:29 leave them1:58:31 so this this this mentality is this1:58:33 limited mentality was even the term1:58:35 sahaba but the prophets counteracted the1:58:37 don't stop them1:58:39 settled no no I think this is all of1:58:42 systemite we should get out of this man1:58:44 just the opposite regarded the opposite1:58:46 as as as a as a1:58:59 sacraments on the deathbed because he1:59:01 was before that an atheist and this is a1:59:04 great step forward1:59:06 you may have some some aspects of wrong1:59:08 belief because they did not know better1:59:10 or something like that that's fine1:59:12 but uh1:59:14 has raised his hands I'll allow him to1:59:16 mute1:59:17 um and just conscious of the time he1:59:19 should stop in about five minutes okay1:59:21 okay I I just need even1:59:24 um you know no more than five minutes uh1:59:27 so assalamualaikum Prof uh you were1:59:29 talking about the um uh you were1:59:31 answering the question about uh1:59:33 abrogation abrogation of bani Israel's1:59:37 rule I guess so uh so um like uh so we1:59:42 can say that abrogation is only1:59:45 permitted for uh rules for uh for1:59:49 not for creed1:59:53 does it make any sense it's clearly yes1:59:56 yes but yeah there's not say it's1:59:58 obligation about Akbar no what they are2:00:00 saying is that when Allah made an2:00:02 injunction for example that let us say2:00:04 that a circumcision is obligatory2:00:09 yeah it's even a sign of belief it's2:00:11 like shahada2:00:12 cannot be abrogated no it can't be it2:00:15 can be2:00:16 yes yes2:00:18 that that issue of obligation and so on2:00:20 I think this philosophy have I think2:00:22 developed late in scholarship just2:00:24 before Christ when the so-called uh uh2:00:28 the independent Scholars uh confronted2:00:31 the the prista class the kohenim they2:00:34 were undermined by by uh by the other2:00:37 one what's the name I don't remember the2:00:39 name at the moment who were doing2:00:40 scholarship independently and there was2:00:42 then the scholarship started developing2:00:44 which it was enshrined later in the both2:00:46 terms2:00:48 a couple of centuries2:00:51 possibly the issue of obligation was2:00:53 also used by by the people to attack the2:00:56 messengerhood of Lisa2:01:02 for example did things on Saturday which2:01:05 he should not have done2:01:06 yeah2:01:08 um that's that's true this is a tool so2:01:10 he cannot be a messenger so they2:01:12 developed that to reject enemies so it2:01:15 is it is developed but it is original2:01:17 ground it's it's fallacy inspirational2:01:20 abroad it's a fallacy2:01:22 yeah even though I I don't see any2:01:26 problem with the ISA alaihissalam not um2:01:29 not you know following kosher or not2:01:32 no no no because2:01:37 they wanted to use a tool to say this2:01:39 cannot be a messenger and they develop2:01:41 the theory Authority Theory so this is2:01:44 developing a theory to undermine2:01:45 something specifically but the theory2:01:48 itself as developed is irrationally in2:01:52 uh uh uh not not uh not uh not2:01:57 defensible definitely Russian into2:01:59 visible and also scripturally is based2:02:02 on Ally claiming that we have a2:02:03 narration that that and we have a2:02:05 statement that uh that that uh that uh2:02:09 that Musa said even the attributors say2:02:11 there I will tell you that the heavens2:02:13 and earth will go before the law will go2:02:20 but does not mean that particular ruling2:02:23 may change or not and the same if2:02:25 there's something attributed to Musa2:02:27 which is unlikely it will be having the2:02:29 same meaning as a matter of fact the2:02:31 fact that some law of the Apple has been2:02:33 abrogated by Musa in individual and2:02:36 specific laws is very clearly and black2:02:38 and pretty clear2:02:39 so they have no ground in scripture and2:02:42 no ground irrationality it's just just2:02:44 making a statement which is similar to2:02:48 The Atheist argument can Allah create a2:02:50 stone which is heavy as heavy that he2:02:52 cannot carry as just as a statement2:02:54 which is empty doesn't Professor fallacy2:02:56 it's a fallacy it's absolute fallacy2:02:58 it's absolute fallacy but that's the way2:03:00 the way sometimes you start to escape2:03:01 from the compelling reality and2:03:04 evidences brought by Risa always2:03:06 Muhammad internally2:03:12 yes yes Prof I'm not gonna take any any2:03:15 longer I just want to end up uh finish2:03:17 up with that with the laugh you know you2:03:18 were mentioning2:03:20 you know he he likes to debate with the2:03:24 nasibi arguments you know we see that a2:03:26 lot you know that that reminds me with2:03:28 the uh pro pro abortion activist you2:03:32 know they say no no we're not2:03:34 pro-abortion we are pro-choice you know2:03:37 even though we they come up with the2:03:40 with the pro-abortion points so it's so2:03:43 so if they were truly um pro-choice then2:03:46 they should they shouldn't have like a2:03:48 problem if the majority choose to you2:03:51 know to uh to uh to to make abortion yes2:03:54 the whole thing is going around the2:03:56 fallacies2:03:57 same thing with even to me unfortunately2:03:59 we see this no but even Tammy is is the2:04:02 meaning debate has become uh the papers2:04:06 are debate to defeat The Other Side by2:04:07 any argument that meaning that this is a2:04:10 massive debate this is2:04:14 with the truth yes and and you should2:04:18 always in in any debate with anybody2:04:20 like Imam shafri said it's not yet from2:04:23 here I hope it is true that he said in2:04:25 any debate I always wish that the truth2:04:28 will come apparent in the from from the2:04:30 argument of the other side2:04:32 from the other side because I know for2:04:34 myself that I would submit the truth he2:04:36 knows himself that he is willing to2:04:37 submit total government to see the2:04:39 evidence but he is not certain that2:04:41 other people have this high level of2:04:43 commitment to the truth so he wishes2:04:45 that the other side prevails and shows2:04:47 the evidence and says okay so I agree I2:04:50 withdraw my point debate is over I agree2:04:52 that you are correct but he is not2:04:54 certain that the other side will2:04:55 behaving the same way if he is the one2:04:57 to expose you at all yeah so this is2:05:00 high moral ground but it's not highway2:05:02 it's a minimum that you should be well2:05:07 using arguments not to embarrass the2:05:09 other one and put them in the SWOT but2:05:11 to tell him give him the evidences which2:05:14 are really premises which are well2:05:16 established and so on not to exactly uh2:05:18 faulty premises just to get them stuck2:05:21 into into a circle no that's a mistake2:05:25 yes2:05:26 yes2:05:28 this shows that he is2:05:31 looking for the truth2:05:34 to ridiculous for him as a nasty because2:05:37 you're using an assembly arguments even2:05:40 if he is2:05:44 way and you are not no no you don't want2:05:46 to get that to the truth that you have2:05:48 very hard condemned Yourself by your own2:05:49 behavior change your behavior then we2:05:52 accept that2:06:14 2:06:25 foreign2:06:30 2:06:39 2:06:45 2:06:56 foreign2:07:02