Muhammad Ibn Abdul Wahab Hero or Heretic? (2022-11-29) ​

0:00:00 Music
0:00:03 foreign
0:00:09 Music
0:00:25 video this week on the subject of
0:00:29 Muhammad
0:00:31 paretic or hero
0:00:33 there have been numerous discussions in
0:00:35 recent times and very recently on the uh
0:00:38 on the internet with various from
0:00:40 Islamic YouTubers those affiliate
0:00:42 affiliated with the seller fee or more
0:00:44 accurately the doctrine of Mohammed IBN
0:00:46 Abdullah in accordance with the Saudi
0:00:49 Alliance scholarship and others
0:00:50 personalities and other prominent
0:00:53 personalities rebuttling them
0:00:55 without delving into individuals
0:00:57 personally there are certain common
0:00:59 themes that we've identified at we think
0:01:01 require further clarification and
0:01:04 rebuttal from a more fundamental point
0:01:06 of view
0:01:07 to summarize the arguments of the Saudi
0:01:09 camp or as is often known
0:01:12 being The prominent Saudi assigned
0:01:15 government scholar with whom our
0:01:17 resident scholar Professor Muhammad
0:01:19 al-masri is quite familiar the recurring
0:01:21 themes are as follows
0:01:23 the insistence on what is referred to as
0:01:26 the pure kid of the Silas of the salaf
0:01:29 and an alleged consensus on the
0:01:31 following what constitutes Salif what is
0:01:35 the Akita and an assumption that ruling
0:01:40 and accountability any forms
0:01:42 that rebuttal the current incumbent
0:01:44 rulers by necessity falls into a
0:01:47 category of and they bring certain
0:01:49 evidences or at least
0:01:51 part of a picture of certain evidence is
0:01:53 to build a narrative that automatically
0:01:56 anyone who has a counter point of view
0:01:58 or vocalizes a counter point of view
0:01:59 without even any kind of physical action
0:02:02 is by necessity and by building an
0:02:06 identity of uh consensus around this
0:02:09 they often continuously
0:02:11 dismiss people and by extension
0:02:16 their words are no longer valid and
0:02:19 other other kind of other kinds of
0:02:21 wraparounds they put on that is also the
0:02:23 concept of
0:02:24 the Modi ironically the modern Saudi
0:02:27 State owes its original its actual
0:02:29 Origins to a former and the original
0:02:32 religious justification provided to the
0:02:36 fatty Street was a state was the wahhabi
0:02:38 doctrine
0:02:39 and
0:02:41 hence the time the reason for the title
0:02:44 of Muhammad IBN Abdullah or heretic is
0:02:47 really around the fact that if you look
0:02:49 hopefully by the end of this video
0:02:51 you'll find that that description of
0:02:56 is actually more appropriate from
0:02:58 Muhammad
0:03:01 we've prepared this piece to further
0:03:03 elicit discussions and to clarify the
0:03:05 misconceptions there are many numerous
0:03:07 there are many days that we we
0:03:09 appreciate and we certainly follow
0:03:11 um
0:03:16 among others have provided some very
0:03:18 good rebuttals and their counterparts
0:03:21 Sergeant lipman's chumsy or stada Abdul
0:03:23 Rahman and salafi Publications we feel
0:03:26 are not quite addressing the issue
0:03:28 adequately and have provided a narrative
0:03:30 which we don't agree with which we
0:03:32 certainly think this is the junction for
0:03:34 us to rebuttal
0:03:36 we hope this is just a the beginning
0:03:38 Salvo and we are more than open to open
0:03:41 discussion and facilitating any kind of
0:03:43 discussions directly or on other
0:03:46 people's media channels
0:03:47 um and before I hand over to Sheikh I'll
0:03:49 give a brief introduction as to the uh
0:03:51 as to who Sheikh Professor Muhammad
0:03:53 al-masri is and his background Professor
0:03:55 Muhammad al-masri is uh has been a was
0:03:59 previously a professor of physics and he
0:04:01 comes from a lineage of Scholars his
0:04:03 father uh with a contemporary of being
0:04:05 bad and his cried and his grandfather
0:04:06 was the Imam
0:04:08 in the 80s and 90s he formed a group to
0:04:12 account the rulership of el Saud
0:04:15 called the committee of Defense
0:04:16 committee the committee of Defense to
0:04:19 the legitimate rights
0:04:21 cdlr
0:04:22 um he was unfortunately Exile from
0:04:25 chased out of Saudi rather and seeked uh
0:04:28 sought asylum in the UK and has been a
0:04:30 very prominent activist in the UK
0:04:32 he has produced quite a number of books
0:04:34 uh books that are being published in
0:04:36 English as well as uh currently in
0:04:37 Arabic on some very fundamental issues
0:04:40 and has really clarified a lot of
0:04:42 fundamental issues which were taken as
0:04:45 um as dismissed by the Saudi government
0:04:48 scholarship because it's not in the
0:04:51 interest to entertain these kinds of
0:04:52 issues and the the material that's been
0:04:54 produced we can say with confidence is
0:04:56 very strong and reaches the level of
0:04:57 moto in terms of evidences are
0:05:00 referenced
0:05:01 um however we will publish those links
0:05:03 but without further Ado I'd like to hand
0:05:05 over to Professor Muhammad
0:05:08 and
0:05:10 Professor you're familiar with with the
0:05:13 current uh dialogue that's been
0:05:15 happening between uh these various camps
0:05:18 um
0:05:18 what is it just to start things off what
0:05:22 is your understanding of what
0:05:23 constitutes a seller and this is
0:05:25 distance from Akida isn't that a good
0:05:28 thing is there a consensus on what
0:05:30 constitutes Akita and is this something
0:05:32 that is something which we should aspire
0:05:34 to and this is uh what they what they
0:05:37 call salafand or the definition of self
0:05:39 is uh is relatively late uh it it was
0:05:43 used casually like for example we have
0:05:46 one one Hadith narrating scholar of high
0:05:50 level of authenticity and exactness and
0:05:53 matter of narratives and the other
0:05:55 personal piety he was doing doing rebat
0:05:58 doing guarding at the border of the
0:06:00 Romans and and so on but he was quite
0:06:05 negative to some Scholars because his
0:06:06 goofy is from otakafi origin he was
0:06:09 negative to other Scholars and did not
0:06:11 want to sit with them and so on because
0:06:13 he said they attacked the salaf actually
0:06:14 they were attacking that's what he means
0:06:17 her so the word like that is
0:06:19 the previous generation the past
0:06:22 the the similar in the in the in
0:06:25 Christianity we talk about the
0:06:27 disciplines of the Apostles that's
0:06:28 something something like that but it was
0:06:30 not made precise and nobody dedicated
0:06:32 himself
0:06:34 until we we uh we came almost to the
0:06:38 fourth century when the first one called
0:06:39 himself salafi is
0:06:43 so it became like a title
0:06:46 so it is
0:06:47 meaning what have been passed but it is
0:06:51 what's the definition
0:06:53 there's no nuclear definition if you ask
0:06:56 them to say the three good degenerations
0:06:58 according to a Hadith that the best of
0:07:00 the of the human species or another is
0:07:03 are the three my uh these my my
0:07:07 generation and then the one for the
0:07:08 followers and the fair to follow and
0:07:11 some Nations say he mentioned four
0:07:12 something just say three so we can agree
0:07:14 on three definitely
0:07:16 that's that's that's the that's the
0:07:18 first one then
0:07:20 when things are scrutinized a little bit
0:07:22 it turns out that the third generation
0:07:24 is having so much divergences and points
0:07:27 of view
0:07:28 even less than what we have now so they
0:07:31 escape to tavieri Second Generation
0:07:33 meaning generation meaning companions
0:07:35 that one moment also the profit Etc
0:07:37 would have an obscore of definition will
0:07:39 come to that and then the one who follow
0:07:41 them called tabulary which are
0:07:43 themselves
0:07:48 but the Mr Prophet did not meet him
0:07:51 because they blessed Islam later or they
0:07:53 were far away and this is the elder or a
0:07:57 senior tabian that's the one who are
0:07:59 born just maybe time Abu Bakr or the end
0:08:02 time of the Prophet so they cannot come
0:08:04 that's companion
0:08:05 and then we have the middle tab here in
0:08:07 the one boy it's actually born around
0:08:10 the time of the end time of Omar and
0:08:12 then the under middle
0:08:14 which are born about the time of the end
0:08:16 of Osman and then there's
0:08:18 in the 50s history and so on like like
0:08:22 uh the famous One is
0:08:25 because he met at least and he got from
0:08:28 anasematic so he's a table
0:08:30 with the lowest generation is wise
0:08:34 but also these have various
0:08:36 disagreements and various conflicts and
0:08:38 various talents and various things so
0:08:40 they escape to the sahaba
0:08:42 and then you have the problem with the
0:08:44 definition who is also happy
0:08:47 there was no clear definition even even
0:08:49 the the Tiberian and the sahaba did not
0:08:51 have a clear definition for example they
0:08:54 got the best and the great of tabby and
0:08:56 the most Pious and maybe in Hadith
0:08:58 sounds more exact thing I would say
0:09:00 shabby is more exact thing of narrative
0:09:03 and more sharp in The Knowing men but of
0:09:06 course I don't say was more more Pious
0:09:07 and more pure-hearted but more
0:09:09 straightforward and to know the men and
0:09:11 concise them and analyze them you need
0:09:13 to be a little bit more a man of
0:09:15 political insight and Analysis of
0:09:17 personality so shall be superior shall
0:09:20 we say I took from a trustworthy source
0:09:22 and mentioned the name of the source
0:09:24 then you can realize really translated
0:09:25 them thoroughly always a human being he
0:09:28 may made a failure here and there
0:09:30 sometimes
0:09:32 uh side woman said is regarded the same
0:09:35 category but because he's someone who is
0:09:37 straightforward and trusting he may be
0:09:39 misled or fooled by someone thinking
0:09:41 he's trustworthy is not
0:09:43 that's depending on how to analyze men
0:09:45 and the character but I'm just
0:09:46 mentioning that as a casual information
0:09:48 aside from the same say asahabi is the
0:09:50 one who stayed with a prophet one one
0:09:53 year or two years or participated in one
0:09:56 or two battle campaigns with him so he
0:09:58 regard anyone anything less than one
0:10:00 year anything like less than one battle
0:10:03 campaign as not enough to be a Sahari
0:10:08 that that will create a problem for many
0:10:10 with the regardless so happy many of the
0:10:13 plenty of knowledge of people who are
0:10:15 not according to definition some people
0:10:17 say no he must have attended at least
0:10:19 three battle uh
0:10:21 combat Etc somebody say it has to be a
0:10:24 resident of Madina like answer Marcos
0:10:26 asked is there any sahabilities because
0:10:28 you stayed until High age I think he
0:10:31 maybe he outlives that high judge maybe
0:10:32 he died 95 degrees
0:10:34 and high age say they ask him in high
0:10:37 age is that it is a happy lift
0:10:39 besides you so no no there's none except
0:10:42 maybe some Bedouins so he didn't regard
0:10:44 them asahabi they saw him between
0:10:47 so for him you have to be combining him
0:10:50 in Medina for a certain time
0:10:53 so that's again the division of sahabi
0:10:55 because we We Know by from the statement
0:10:57 if we if she shows any definition
0:11:00 whatsoever they will be under them on a
0:11:03 15 by the clear and fundamental text of
0:11:05 the Quran
0:11:35 we know them
0:11:38 we will punish them twice and Dunya and
0:11:40 they won't be returned to enormous
0:11:42 punishment meaning they will die cover
0:11:44 otherwise did not know them
0:11:46 those in Medina are most likely
0:11:48 interacting we know some of them by name
0:11:50 one of them at least alone who is known
0:11:52 as the one after nobody but he
0:11:54 participated the battle campaigns he
0:11:56 initiated the story of the Afghan attack
0:11:58 against Asha all of this and he is the
0:12:00 one who said in his private circles now
0:12:02 that's the end we are we adopted
0:12:04 Muhammad and gave him protection and
0:12:06 make him fat and now according to the
0:12:08 old saying make your dog fat he will eat
0:12:10 you meaning Muhammad is a dog
0:12:12 and he denied that saying that but the
0:12:14 Quran explores him
0:12:16 so we have that so there's no Escape
0:12:19 there's various
0:12:21 at this point just just to put the setup
0:12:23 in the corner first that even your
0:12:25 depletion of sahaba is not clear not
0:12:27 well established is an old record
0:12:29 nothing one Hadith not two five six a
0:12:32 Hadith
0:12:33 that's why my companion even the Hadith
0:12:37 about the Jews who promoted to kill him
0:12:38 in akaba on the way back from tabuk in
0:12:40 the ninth year
0:12:42 few people saw the prophet Sam took the
0:12:44 high mountain way and asked the Army to
0:12:46 go the valley and said nobody should
0:12:48 take the high mountain way except the
0:12:49 prophet
0:12:51 and he took it why we don't know maybe
0:12:53 he wanted to be supervising what's going
0:12:55 on seeing what's going on and that way
0:12:57 is very narrow Canada so there was uh
0:13:00 someone sent in the Army calling nobody
0:13:03 should take that that way is only for
0:13:05 the messenger Allah
0:13:06 said good opportunity that you will
0:13:09 attend we did not hear or we hit and
0:13:10 then we go that way about 15 of them and
0:13:13 we push him over the Ridge and get rid
0:13:15 of him
0:13:21 famous event well established narrated
0:13:23 by tawater
0:13:25 and then the process that I'm exposed
0:13:29 them and I think for therefore I'm
0:13:31 struck their the comments in the face
0:13:33 too they went downhill and so on and
0:13:35 nothing has happened and then he told
0:13:38 the uh
0:13:41 Music
0:13:42 in one of the leader of a house this
0:13:46 this happened Andrew says it's very
0:13:48 simple send someone to their tribes so
0:13:51 they you know them say I know them and
0:13:53 even the holiday for our knew their
0:13:55 comments so they can be identified and
0:13:58 sent an order to get it or get the next
0:14:01 track this is their Association against
0:14:02 the head of state it's high treason
0:14:05 you're stuck as the museum said no I'm
0:14:07 not going to do that obviously because
0:14:09 it's prohibited to do that it has it
0:14:12 will have the result that the people say
0:14:13 Muhammad is killing his companions
0:14:16 but they are not companionship was
0:14:18 insisted again repeated I am not going
0:14:20 to kill my companion meaning you're you
0:14:22 will claim that they are not combining
0:14:24 is wrong the word companion fits on them
0:14:26 so the companion is kept in the Arabic
0:14:28 language meaning Arabic language is
0:14:29 someone going with you on about on a
0:14:33 trip is a companion some your wife is
0:14:36 your companion
0:14:37 says
0:14:41 is a companion so he kept it in the
0:14:44 linguistic meaning so all these
0:14:45 definitions are wavering and they're not
0:14:47 wearing anything for Fruitful
0:14:49 is very well known we know that from
0:14:52 various historic reasons
0:14:55 they want to get Maui to have the honor
0:14:58 on the protection of companion but they
0:15:01 will not succeed that's just a Prelude
0:15:03 so salaf is not well defined and even
0:15:06 the companion is not clearly well
0:15:07 defined
0:15:09 secondly okay say they say the sahaba
0:15:12 were around the prophet
0:15:13 and they saw the revelation of the Quran
0:15:16 Etc
0:15:17 and they are most of them except a few
0:15:20 which do not count five six seven are
0:15:23 not Arabic speaker Arabic speaker so
0:15:27 they answered the Arabic language better
0:15:28 than us by Nature they are born in
0:15:30 Arabic language we we have to learn it
0:15:31 by effort as a foreign language for us
0:15:34 now I mean the high Arabic Arabic even
0:15:36 myself
0:15:38 is a direct not a high Arabic so I have
0:15:42 to learn Safari language it's easy
0:15:44 obviously because the direct is close
0:15:45 but still I have to learn it but the one
0:15:48 born in it it is done in his blood he
0:15:50 has the taste of it so based on that
0:15:52 their understanding mystery must be the
0:15:54 best of understanding
0:15:56 but again a fallacy first one because
0:15:59 understanding is related to Satan not
0:16:01 only understanding Arabic and being with
0:16:03 the prophet is related to the certain
0:16:05 mental and intellectual capabilities not
0:16:08 everyone is having
0:16:10 and depth of understanding and we have
0:16:12 many evidences that many of the
0:16:13 companions were quite simple-minded and
0:16:15 very Shadow it doesn't mean it doesn't
0:16:18 stain them because their virtue is being
0:16:20 that they are
0:16:26 secondly they are sincere and they are
0:16:28 willing to sacrifice their life on their
0:16:30 wealth for Islam that's what gave them
0:16:32 the virtue
0:16:33 High virtue not that they are better
0:16:35 understanding and evidence show that
0:16:37 give you just one example just casual
0:16:39 example for the reason that they don't
0:16:40 know these things for example in one
0:16:42 Hadith where is
0:16:44 casually
0:16:45 related to khilafa and election and so
0:16:48 on Asians we were in in in in in in
0:16:51 Mina with Omar in his last bill garment
0:16:54 before he died
0:16:56 and someone and I was imagine even Abbas
0:17:00 who was just coming out of age when the
0:17:02 prophet died because he was just coming
0:17:04 up to age we know the other narrations
0:17:06 foreign
0:17:34 so it's not it's not this is a fallacy
0:17:37 but also in his final sermon said
0:17:41 those who have this heard me
0:17:45 they should report what they hid as they
0:17:47 heard it
0:17:49 may Allah make the face beautiful with
0:17:51 the one who hear what I say
0:17:53 as it is and reported that this is to
0:17:55 other people who are not present here
0:17:57 including people in the future because
0:18:01 maybe someone receiving the message
0:18:03 comprehend it better and make sense
0:18:05 better of it than the one who hears it
0:18:07 now
0:18:08 so even that refused that
0:18:11 so this is a fallacy
0:18:13 secondly what's meaning the self the
0:18:15 idea the point of view yourself
0:18:17 because they have we have absolute
0:18:20 evidence that they agree disagreed and
0:18:22 many issue some of them very substantial
0:18:23 like personal disagree disagree Edition
0:18:25 disagreement between uh abubakar and
0:18:27 Omar about fighting
0:18:31 and it came to a dispute until even
0:18:34 until even said shocked himself
0:18:38 and the coward in Islam I am not going
0:18:41 to let those who do not pay there's a
0:18:43 guy get away I'm going to fight them
0:18:44 until they pay it's not allowable
0:18:47 Under Armor then caved in because
0:18:49 without Authority and the character of
0:18:51 Abu Bakr that's all but they had to read
0:18:52 in such a potential point and there's
0:18:54 many other disagreement so what does
0:18:57 this mean the point of view
0:18:59 and the teaching of the Salah there are
0:19:01 various disagreement even in such an
0:19:02 important Point fighting someone and
0:19:04 killing someone is a fundamental issue
0:19:06 Bloodshed is a series
0:19:11 so
0:19:15 has adopted
0:19:18 not only is something which makes sense
0:19:20 is that what they agreed all of them
0:19:22 let's assume
0:19:24 if you check you will not find ishma
0:19:27 almost in nothing except with copyright
0:19:30 from Islam which nobody disagree for
0:19:31 your stamina of this
0:19:34 genuine one which is well established
0:19:36 and also narrated by tawato because you
0:19:38 have to be to be sure that it's well
0:19:40 established and there is really ijima
0:19:42 that many people must have reported that
0:19:44 other it is few people making a factor
0:19:47 maybe in kufa and the people in Yemen
0:19:49 are not aware about that so it's
0:19:50 currently College
0:19:52 the result is that only the couple of
0:19:55 Islam which there is no disagreement
0:19:56 actually only those who prefer to get
0:19:59 out of cover and depart Islam will not
0:20:01 would disagree so it doesn't give us any
0:20:04 any uh advice or the or Direction where
0:20:07 to go in in issues of differences in
0:20:10 fact and secondary issues what they call
0:20:13 Akida which is again
0:20:15 name so
0:20:17 in reality if we scrutinize because the
0:20:20 one using the way itself most commonly
0:20:22 the wahhabi or the they call themselves
0:20:25 salafi they don't like the word Hobby
0:20:28 but really the other side of you are not
0:20:30 a hobby so they should be called wahhabi
0:20:32 and even tell me here was definitely are
0:20:35 more open-minded and wiser than the Hub
0:20:38 is is not a good student of him it's
0:20:40 related by generation but he grew in the
0:20:42 school with Emi and became even more
0:20:44 extreme
0:20:45 he uses self
0:20:47 as an other going to reduce called the
0:20:49 Theologian and they were discussing
0:20:51 philosophical issues as as an uh as a as
0:20:55 a tool of intellectual Terror and
0:20:57 essentially what he means what he
0:20:59 invokes is points revealed and hamper so
0:21:02 Allah
0:21:04 that's the reality so this is all
0:21:07 deceptive these names are deceptive
0:21:09 because they sound very nice the
0:21:11 predecessors
0:21:12 uh old people think that previously you
0:21:14 know people have a tendency to nostalgia
0:21:17 the past was good if you ask most people
0:21:19 in England how it was the time of your
0:21:21 fathers was much better we are now
0:21:23 suffering prices are high at the time
0:21:25 you you know the benefit you the weekly
0:21:28 benefits have been like in that I was
0:21:30 here the same thing because some
0:21:31 relatives and they have neighbors
0:21:33 English neighbors living on benefits the
0:21:35 benefits with five pounds per week they
0:21:38 were living lavishly more than today
0:21:40 with a benefit of 100 or 120 per week
0:21:43 associate was willing for five pounds
0:21:45 this one people are nostalgic so they
0:21:48 always imagine that the past because the
0:21:50 the president is having its problems and
0:21:51 they're suffering the past held also but
0:21:54 it's forgotten now and only the nice
0:21:56 thing remaining the nice memories
0:21:57 Nostalgia so it appears to that
0:22:01 it's a piece to that but there's nowhere
0:22:02 in Quran also any praise for the
0:22:04 previous one
0:22:05 most likely there is usually a displace
0:22:08 or disapproval a previous one like
0:22:10 saying We are following the ways of our
0:22:12 father and grandfathers and the Quran
0:22:15 says even if if the relation comes to
0:22:17 Muhammad is more guided and more
0:22:20 rational than your grandfathers and
0:22:21 fathers even your brings better things
0:22:23 than what you have for me and they still
0:22:25 insist stuck through that so even you
0:22:28 could say going back to the Center for
0:22:30 sticking to them
0:22:31 is actually not the spirit of the Quran
0:22:33 Sunnah yeah but what about the uh Hadith
0:22:36 which talks about the best of me are the
0:22:38 ones after me uh that's what I said
0:22:40 that's what I said best generation the
0:22:42 whole generation but in the generation
0:22:43 of assalam was also a group of the West
0:22:46 tyrants in Islam in in human history
0:22:48 abujah and so on the Veron of this
0:22:53 in his generation meaning the whole
0:22:56 generation as a total and what makes
0:22:58 them best
0:23:00 as I stated earlier what makes the
0:23:02 sahaba especially that's not the one
0:23:03 meant obviously he doesn't mean the
0:23:05 kofara Polish definitely does that means
0:23:08 and the Roman Empire definitely not
0:23:10 they're not the best of human being but
0:23:12 the best of of generations who follow
0:23:14 the prophets that's that has to be
0:23:16 restricted but let's assume the best of
0:23:18 all Humanity fine what makes them the
0:23:20 best
0:23:21 because they have the thousands of
0:23:23 companions who accelerated to Islam and
0:23:26 they will were willing to sacrifice
0:23:28 wealth and life for Islam and they were
0:23:31 sincere
0:23:35 he does not mention that they are more
0:23:37 intelligent and more sophisticated a
0:23:39 better industry that's not what makes it
0:23:41 better
0:23:42 what makes it better is these features
0:23:44 and these features are not related to
0:23:45 matter of understanding the Quran Sunnah
0:23:47 or or uh claiming that what they have
0:23:51 stated in certain situation is the
0:23:53 correct is the correct statement no not
0:23:56 necessary they could make a mistakes
0:24:01 even various places in the Quran there's
0:24:03 a relocation even the battery you got
0:24:05 the cream of the cream
0:24:07 the first to accelerate to Islam up to
0:24:10 the day of Badr are called The sabrielle
0:24:11 Promise Paradise yeah
0:24:14 the cream of those are the rule of
0:24:16 butter even the real bad have been
0:24:18 rebuked because they gave them a wrong
0:24:20 advice about the issue of of taking uh
0:24:24 taking ransom for for the detainees in
0:24:27 violation of the injunction that transom
0:24:30 should not only taken after the enemy
0:24:31 has been crushed down
0:24:34 and they get the advice because they
0:24:35 wanted the booty they wanted the the the
0:24:37 money coming from from the Alonso and
0:24:40 the Quran fast
0:24:42 foreign
0:24:48 and he said you you want to Dunya you
0:24:50 did not give the cesare advice
0:24:52 because you want to Dunya this is the
0:24:54 battery so they could have even in this
0:24:56 not have some feeling
0:24:58 so it's very important to recognize and
0:25:00 and particular sahaba in this slide to
0:25:03 everyone makes it feasible around to
0:25:05 strive I can't compete or come close to
0:25:07 them at this but if you have them like
0:25:09 engines who have come down and you may
0:25:11 ask yourself do they really where they
0:25:13 go into the toilet where they defecating
0:25:15 and urinating yes they were maybe maybe
0:25:18 the edification was smelling like like
0:25:20 musk no it was smell bad
0:25:23 like I was so this way they come closer
0:25:26 to us and we can't really strive to come
0:25:28 similar to them in piety meaning in
0:25:30 sincerity and willingness to sacrifice
0:25:32 wealth and life for Islam that's what's
0:25:35 right
0:25:36 intellectual issues and discussing the
0:25:39 explanation of Eye of Quran no so so
0:25:42 basically you just to recap so you're
0:25:44 officially saying that there isn't the
0:25:46 things that they agreed on were already
0:25:48 they disagreed on loads of issues of fit
0:25:50 in terms of comprehension they aren't
0:25:52 necessarily the oldest would have the
0:25:54 strongest comprehension I'll give you
0:25:56 two examples for the comprehension two
0:25:58 examples for for the the the faulty
0:26:02 completion sets and situation we should
0:26:03 not be there was something in the in in
0:26:06 the tribe of ashari the ashari tribe is
0:26:08 the one joined the person who was in
0:26:10 hybrid the best Islam they joined Jaffa
0:26:12 coming from Abyssinian that's in the
0:26:14 beginning of the uh sixth year I think
0:26:17 the beginning of the sixth year end of
0:26:19 the sixth year we deliver seventh year
0:26:20 when the prophet finished
0:26:23 then he got away with March towards so
0:26:26 he went to immediately fine
0:26:30 uh he was communicating with the najashi
0:26:32 to said Jafar and His companion who was
0:26:35 staying there about 15 years
0:26:37 as a Islamic Reserve but also carrying
0:26:39 it down there and carrying it down to
0:26:40 India and China many people do not know
0:26:42 that and on the way they were joined
0:26:45 with some of the tribe of ashari
0:26:47 the ideology that's someone who from the
0:26:52 tribe established that ashadi ideology
0:26:54 or theology
0:26:55 that's right they joined together and
0:26:58 they came to to tribe and the process
0:27:00 was so elated to see Alpha that he asked
0:27:02 the Muslim to give them some of the moti
0:27:04 ETC of these stories are known
0:27:06 one of their personalities something in
0:27:08 the tribe happened which you should have
0:27:10 prevented to having or commanding good
0:27:11 and evil or something I don't remember
0:27:13 what has happened maybe another
0:27:14 narration narration did not mention and
0:27:16 the Lord said ask him why didn't you do
0:27:19 Taria why didn't you change the mankar
0:27:21 and the man answered
0:27:23 because Allah said
0:27:30 concentrate on yourself you will not be
0:27:32 we mentioned that interfere by the way
0:27:34 it will not harm you those who go astray
0:27:37 if you are guided and our son was angry
0:27:40 said where did you go lost
0:27:43 how can you be lost and understanding
0:27:45 the eye and he said holy Quant Arabic
0:27:47 Arab man and a Believer and the one who
0:27:51 is just arrived After High but so he
0:27:53 participated in many battles after that
0:27:55 possibly in conquist of Makkah Etc
0:27:58 this is for the kofar because the word
0:28:00 Dal usually means go take out getting of
0:28:02 the way into Comfort nobody unless you
0:28:04 have other evidence that means making a
0:28:06 mistake
0:28:07 so this is foreign
0:28:13 just focus on your Iman and establish
0:28:15 your Iman that's the meaning of the eye
0:28:17 so he did not understand it this way
0:28:20 another
0:28:21 there was someone African who left
0:28:23 Madina broke their immigration and
0:28:25 joined the the Hostile comfort
0:28:27 and they were they're passing in under a
0:28:29 covenant to security with someone who
0:28:31 has a covenant with the Medina and this
0:28:33 is have over disputing about what to do
0:28:35 with them kill them not kill them
0:28:36 because they joined the Arabic Cafe
0:28:39 was silent
0:28:41 and the Quran foreign
0:28:53 now they are passing there with a
0:28:55 Covenant security and they have the
0:28:57 Covenant security just apply to them
0:28:58 disabled of the citizenship they belong
0:29:00 to
0:29:01 how it's a problem
0:29:05 it should be obvious
0:29:09 so there's two events and many other
0:29:11 events like that happening at the time
0:29:13 of the Prophet so it's not not matter of
0:29:15 going so this is the fallacy but it is
0:29:17 present at such a way to companion
0:29:19 there seems to be angels
0:29:23 coming from Heaven this is from another
0:29:25 world they don't they were not living
0:29:26 there maybe they're not even walking
0:29:28 maybe they were flying in the air and
0:29:30 things like that but that's where you
0:29:31 have an imaginary picture of something
0:29:33 which is not real with the with the
0:29:35 purpose intent to pass my own statement
0:29:38 and my honest they had all my own
0:29:41 misconceptions as the one coming from
0:29:43 their self
0:29:44 in reality it is not coming from itself
0:29:46 and even discovering themselves it must
0:29:48 have been disagreement about that
0:29:51 check but here's another thing I mean
0:29:52 there's one thing about
0:29:54 silk
0:29:55 what they tend to record on the market
0:29:57 on is around the issue of Akita so what
0:29:59 they're obviously the
0:30:01 Theta Vida and obviously obvious of that
0:30:05 great version but the thing is this so
0:30:08 by building so obviously for us belief
0:30:11 is a fundamental component you know to
0:30:13 be a Muslim one of the fundamental uh
0:30:15 aren't having the right belief so they
0:30:18 just obviously
0:30:20 again there's a fallacy developed a
0:30:23 history and the people swallowed it down
0:30:29 talk about Iman
0:30:32 Iman is not just Akita a set of reports
0:30:36 which you you believe they are true no
0:30:39 that's not him this is yakim and this
0:30:43 has nothing to do with the Iman ifs is
0:30:45 the base of the Iman you have you have
0:30:46 to do translinkual things which have
0:30:48 come from Allah or dictated by the
0:30:49 system of reason
0:30:51 but that's not
0:30:52 you have to accept it and make your life
0:30:54 according to it Daniel you are done you
0:30:57 are movement before that you are just
0:30:59 Musa for example read the Quran who
0:31:02 talks about the people of course
0:31:11 they have absolute conviction this is
0:31:14 the truth but they reject the same
0:31:16 what's going to follow us a couple of
0:31:18 slaves
0:31:19 and that Nation slaves under us which we
0:31:22 can Slaughter our kill as well and take
0:31:24 the woman with ever for servants or
0:31:25 whatever and and then two of those come
0:31:28 and claim to be messenger of God and we
0:31:30 are supposed to follow them no that's
0:31:32 what they said although this is wrong
0:31:39 let's say it's a convention
0:31:41 scholarly conversation okay actually
0:31:42 that is what the heart has been about
0:31:44 from not the heart is not enough is
0:31:48 convicted about that that's not enough
0:31:49 it has to be more to become Iman but
0:31:52 let's go to that what's that shall be
0:31:54 noted about
0:31:55 is that what allow order to know with
0:31:58 statitute in the Quran says
0:32:04 no it's attitude that Allah knows
0:32:06 everything and is comprehensive in
0:32:08 knowledge
0:32:09 it's capable of doing everything
0:32:11 knowledge no will certainly do this and
0:32:14 this and this the Quran did not leave it
0:32:16 open and another place is specified what
0:32:18 should be believed on
0:32:20 for example foreign
0:32:32 he has gone astray far away so these are
0:32:35 the the main portion of Iman
0:32:38 but nobody disagree with Muslim there so
0:32:40 they they they got stuck or got involved
0:32:43 somehow and secondary issues of
0:32:46 uh related like for example what's
0:32:50 really
0:32:52 Allah created the heavens in six days
0:32:54 and after that he mounted the throne
0:32:55 what does it mean mounted
0:32:58 uh
0:33:00 some people said it can't be the
0:33:02 physical reality because Allah is our is
0:33:05 outside as a space he cannot be located
0:33:07 in a place and that's impossible
0:33:10 because if he can be in a place he must
0:33:12 be in every place otherwise you'll
0:33:14 notice is existing
0:33:17 and then they indulge in these things
0:33:19 this is maybe a philosophical discussion
0:33:20 should not be a matter of Akita yeah
0:33:22 maybe Scholars can discuss that in
0:33:24 Academia but you should not even ask
0:33:26 Muslims common Muslim to to have an
0:33:28 opinion they say
0:33:30 just just take it as it appears and if
0:33:32 you have a mental image whatever mental
0:33:34 image come in your mind like someone
0:33:36 sitting on a chair this is just your
0:33:38 your limited imagination as a human
0:33:40 being and you are forgiven Allah phrase
0:33:42 this way so that you can have this
0:33:43 imagination in your mind but know Allah
0:33:45 is different but that's enough for
0:33:47 common people how do you drive at that
0:33:48 conclusion for example how do you derive
0:33:51 that because they build a narrative in
0:33:54 terms of this is what you must know
0:33:55 Muslims must know this place
0:33:58 that's inventing that's not what the
0:34:00 Quran made an injunction
0:34:08 and you come casually to it for example
0:34:11 that the wife of an azizian of Egypt uh
0:34:14 tried to seduce Yusuf this is a fact
0:34:16 this is the fact she tried to reduce
0:34:18 user and he almost fell but he recovered
0:34:21 and ran away fine if you say no that's
0:34:23 not true you are a cafe because you have
0:34:25 declared the Quran to be false but is
0:34:26 that part of the Akida should they stand
0:34:28 in the door of the mosque and ask you do
0:34:30 you know what the wife of uh did to
0:34:33 yourself
0:34:36 obliged to know that but if you come
0:34:38 casually fine you don't put that in
0:34:40 arcade books even if there are Akita
0:34:42 books it doesn't mention this or they
0:34:44 should be in that according to the
0:34:45 division
0:34:46 they got stuck in problems which their
0:34:50 ancient School especially
0:34:52 were not qualified to study
0:34:55 because the people of Hadith and
0:34:56 narration
0:34:58 but they gave certain answers which are
0:35:01 most likely false and they want to
0:35:03 connect that ID and declare your deviant
0:35:06 of this service that's it that's what
0:35:08 they wanted that's what has happened to
0:35:10 it
0:35:11 that's what happened with historical
0:35:13 so that's what they care now if it comes
0:35:15 to check now the hobby is having the the
0:35:18 tool of shark
0:35:21 and the main thing which is they have
0:35:22 the the the financial himself for
0:35:24 Muslims on the starting actually the
0:35:26 problems started with intermedia but not
0:35:28 that extreme and sharp not like it was
0:35:31 like a knife but it was not sharp yet
0:35:33 not sharpened enough to be to be deadly
0:35:36 half shaft that went to the extreme
0:35:39 follow the consequence to its end so his
0:35:42 his consistent with himself more in that
0:35:44 epitaphia epidemia is
0:35:48 the conclusion is that is that ibada
0:35:52 um
0:35:54 is a certain list of Acts like for
0:35:57 example that will help you to the
0:35:58 following me that greeting the banner
0:36:01 when the banner is lifted or the
0:36:03 national anthem is is a is sound for him
0:36:07 in England people stand for example
0:36:09 there's a certain procedure and they
0:36:11 sing with it
0:36:12 or if you see the banner especially if
0:36:14 you are a member of the military then
0:36:15 you're supposed to give strike put like
0:36:17 this and give a certain greeting they
0:36:20 say that for a week standing in front of
0:36:22 the banner in a specific way
0:36:24 showing respect and so on is that
0:36:27 natural rebada and you are worshiping
0:36:29 the banner and you are a mushrika and
0:36:30 the cafe
0:36:33 so the act of what they call Active
0:36:35 worship or this ritual
0:36:38 they declare to be everybody and if it
0:36:40 is directed to someone else beside Allah
0:36:42 it is
0:36:49 because when they get to sujured they
0:36:51 got stuck in the problem
0:36:53 that the people the the family of Jacob
0:36:56 is a prophet under them
0:36:59 to yourself when they entered Egypt of
0:37:03 greeting
0:37:04 how come the sujood is one time greeting
0:37:06 and so on well what makes us greeting on
0:37:08 that greeting and they got stuck
0:37:10 every day definition is fundamentally
0:37:12 for policy and based on that they
0:37:15 invented what they call
0:37:16 these people are worshiping Graves
0:37:19 foreign
0:37:27 Islam
0:37:31 based on the 40 definition
0:37:35 so even that they missed and their
0:37:37 definition it is not really in cover but
0:37:40 we don't take care of the capital
0:37:41 because the the fundamental principle is
0:37:43 that if you have a certain point of view
0:37:45 which necessary doesn't mean that you
0:37:48 are a Catholic because
0:37:49 that maybe you know you're not aware
0:37:51 that it is couple you did not do the
0:37:53 necessary logical steps but it's but I
0:37:56 am at able to tell you your point of
0:37:58 view result necessary and comfort
0:38:01 because if you defend worship like this
0:38:03 acts meaning if you direct that up to
0:38:04 the banner for example you made the
0:38:06 banner identity beside Allah that's it
0:38:10 you adopt the god beside Allah so
0:38:18 identity is something which is worshiped
0:38:21 that's his definition
0:38:22 that meaning Allah was not worshiping
0:38:25 Eternity for any creation so he was not
0:38:26 a deity in that
0:38:28 which is
0:38:30 but they never think this way but if you
0:38:32 show someone of them this way they will
0:38:34 stop and start wavering and knowing what
0:38:36 they say I hate to tell the people that
0:38:38 your point of view is ending and cover
0:38:40 but sometimes you are forced to say that
0:38:43 they are
0:38:52 not qualified to do these conclusions
0:38:56 so can you explain a bit more so
0:38:59 for them Anila is something that is
0:39:01 worship and in the absence of it being
0:39:03 worshiped it ceases because the
0:39:06 definition earlier they haven't they
0:39:07 haven't expressed it as such as
0:39:12 almost here I would say he's lying
0:39:15 deliberately because even Tamia doesn't
0:39:17 say that and all Scholars are even
0:39:19 linguistic people agree on that that's
0:39:20 what he says
0:39:21 by the way it's not interested but it
0:39:24 comes later
0:39:26 with a quote on the reference and the
0:39:28 books are everywhere they cannot even
0:39:30 hold it back and erase it from the books
0:39:34 that's its definition
0:39:37 Which flies it's essentially giving a
0:39:39 slap to the Quran because the Quran
0:39:40 defines exactly what he lies
0:39:47 there are two types of villa
0:39:49 says
0:39:57 it says Allah has no son that's a report
0:40:00 there are other reasons to prove that
0:40:03 Allah is impossible to have a son but
0:40:05 enough to say that Allah is reporting
0:40:06 you claim I have daughters and children
0:40:08 Offspring I have an offspring
0:40:11 actually is an offspring it can be
0:40:15 female or male Allah has not offspring
0:40:18 and he has no reason to lie about his
0:40:20 own F3 which we had
0:40:21 and there's another attitude with him
0:40:23 otherwise the other deity will take its
0:40:26 own creation and depart away that's the
0:40:28 definition of Allah the one who can
0:40:29 create and take his own creation and get
0:40:31 away or try to dominate the other one
0:40:34 the one created by your own internal
0:40:36 probability
0:40:37 and can dominate the others or Shield
0:40:40 them
0:40:42 or an offspring of
0:40:45 string of the spring of saturated in
0:40:48 programming you are a programmered
0:40:50 acrosive definition it goes ultimately
0:40:52 is the entity which can create
0:40:55 by its own power
0:40:57 has its own creation as in the Dominion
0:41:00 of creation and can Shield it take away
0:41:02 from anybody else or dominate someone
0:41:03 else
0:41:05 foreign
0:41:15 you have taken that and put it in the
0:41:18 bin
0:41:19 I'm using very very harsh language so to
0:41:22 shock The Listener to think about that
0:41:24 seriously what would that mean I mean
0:41:27 to for for that to be an exclusive
0:41:29 definition wouldn't he had to say illah
0:41:31 as in some way some way to say that this
0:41:34 is this exclusive definition
0:41:37 there's no deity except one which is
0:41:39 have in Arabic the name Allah
0:41:43 Allah sorry what I mean is that by
0:41:46 saying that an illah is a is something
0:41:48 that is worshiped is that the exclusive
0:41:50 definition the only thing that he
0:41:52 considered to be a constructive
0:41:53 difference yeah that's right and that's
0:41:54 and the studies even here the only thing
0:41:56 he said he said he says for example
0:41:59 about about the the the the uh the uh
0:42:04 the Dome or the on top of the grave of
0:42:07 al-bada in Egypt he's taking the weather
0:42:09 as an example it was very famous and the
0:42:11 people go there and have celebration
0:42:14 Etc he says this is an idol fight say if
0:42:18 you ask Al badawi for help on the or or
0:42:20 cure Etc and so on then you made him
0:42:23 Allah not illah Allah
0:42:26 you identified him with Allah
0:42:29 that's his exact words
0:42:33 this man is is gone in such a way that
0:42:36 is a bug's imagination
0:42:38 and is as unbelievable that people but
0:42:41 we will not worry of that time all
0:42:43 almost 100 illiterate very few Scholars
0:42:46 and he was able to to to to cooperate
0:42:49 with one one guy in Power who's sneaking
0:42:51 enough and and mischievous enough to
0:42:54 recognize this opportunity to have
0:42:55 someone who's so obsessed and willing to
0:42:58 kill people and fight for that and can
0:43:00 extend my power that's Muhammad episode
0:43:02 let me I usually say in Arabic could be
0:43:05 a very nasty language
0:43:07 so obsessed that he sang to the level of
0:43:10 Donkey and he was
0:43:12 I decided to ride that donkey there's no
0:43:15 doubt that a man is obsessed with the
0:43:16 idea it tooks all his life and all his
0:43:18 imagination occupied him completely
0:43:22 and he got the opportunity of support of
0:43:24 someone who regarded as an excellent
0:43:26 opportunity
0:43:28 let me give you a following story when
0:43:29 he had arrived in the area after his was
0:43:31 expelled from Mariana
0:43:34 also worked with him initially but
0:43:37 Ronald received a threat from the from
0:43:39 the Osmani uh Wadi in eastern region to
0:43:43 whom this was belonging
0:43:47 it's a midwin area the central power in
0:43:50 Istanbul and even the Eastern region in
0:43:52 the mom of the haran now called the
0:43:54 mamadhara actually
0:43:57 they will not battle very much but he
0:43:59 still belongs to them
0:44:03 outside
0:44:05 but we come to that later
0:44:08 so he the ruler of the Eastern region
0:44:11 form of sort of threatening a letter to
0:44:14 uh to uh
0:44:16 uh for one reason because
0:44:21 a stoned she admitted and stoned assume
0:44:25 that's correct no problem with that but
0:44:27 stoning and the executing is a matter of
0:44:30 the of the government
0:44:32 so it seems it looks for for the
0:44:35 governor of
0:44:36 that
0:44:39 they have user power and they'll make a
0:44:42 decision who should be made by the
0:44:44 government at least by the way or by
0:44:46 Istanbul
0:44:47 not here
0:44:50 there is running out of order of
0:44:53 authority
0:44:54 because you cannot like for example if
0:44:56 you go if you go in Lister in detail
0:44:57 Someone putting in prison then you
0:44:59 declare respective Authority you have no
0:45:00 right to do that only the police who
0:45:02 shall authorized probably and establish
0:45:04 properly by The Authority by the home
0:45:05 office in the home office minister or or
0:45:08 secretary is elected by the parliament
0:45:10 Etc in a well-known procedure part of
0:45:12 the state you are not attributed to do
0:45:13 that
0:45:17 Islamic entity
0:45:26 about this act
0:45:28 so
0:45:30 that area
0:45:32 in the meeting with the with uh Muhammad
0:45:34 who talked for us few years before by
0:45:37 killing his own cousins and so on take
0:45:39 apart like the Habit in the tribal areas
0:45:41 there killing each other taking power
0:45:43 underwriting to the local Valley uh
0:45:46 declaring that I have took powers on
0:45:48 sanctioned me and appoint me or
0:45:50 something a technicality
0:45:52 went with him and the following
0:45:54 conversation as narrated by a book which
0:45:57 is now represented and we have have in
0:45:59 our site so you can people can download
0:46:01 it
0:46:03 look at the sneaker question he noticed
0:46:05 that this man is obsessed completely
0:46:08 and he hates stories in the Nia and it's
0:46:10 not far away from there just maybe I
0:46:13 don't remember maybe 50 kilometers
0:46:14 something I was living in the area
0:46:16 myself when I was there
0:46:19 I told him
0:46:22 I hear that you came here and you won't
0:46:24 have protection like Robert Muhammad I
0:46:26 saw someone who can protect you out
0:46:27 there and help in the tower
0:46:29 and you want to stay here say yes
0:46:32 I want to establish the hidden fight
0:46:34 share it can be the answer say okay
0:46:36 that's fine but there's a problem
0:46:37 Michelle
0:46:38 you are you are a uh you are a Pious man
0:46:42 a devotee and we are sinners because we
0:46:46 are eating Haram
0:46:50 what does he mean and he explains I have
0:46:53 some taxes and he knows there are
0:46:55 legitimate taxes
0:46:57 from the people of plantations and
0:46:59 because the areas is the associated palm
0:47:01 trees that the main the main income of
0:47:03 the people they they have they have
0:47:05 dates and palm tree and some animals and
0:47:07 so on and they have a text here
0:47:10 not as I cut some extra just for my for
0:47:13 my for my for my treasure Treasury
0:47:17 do eating Haram how can we stay in a
0:47:19 country which is which is uh which is uh
0:47:22 the ruler is eating Hara
0:47:24 that's exactly what he said and even
0:47:26 there and what makes their story with
0:47:28 this formulation more more more
0:47:30 trustworthy is he still is written down
0:47:33 in the dialect of we expect from any
0:47:35 ignorant man like Muhammad to be talking
0:47:38 Dale if you'll not be talking in Arabic
0:47:40 like some reports try to translate this
0:47:42 statement High Arabic and they will say
0:47:44 no problem continue eating Haram as long
0:47:46 as you'll support me through defeating
0:47:48 shirk
0:47:50 continue
0:47:56 let Mr Jose what a great gift from
0:47:59 heaven
0:48:00 this man is busy demolishing Graves and
0:48:04 I'm busy extending my power
0:48:05 and that's what had happened from that
0:48:07 day
0:48:08 recently by the way although this is not
0:48:10 an Evidence
0:48:11 there Ambassador in London you may have
0:48:13 it the segment he said he said who said
0:48:15 we have anything to do with religion we
0:48:17 are we are a tribe which won the wars
0:48:19 defeated the others uncut all things my
0:48:21 religion is just what was at all he
0:48:23 admitted that's him
0:48:32 English media
0:48:34 so don't regard us that the guardian of
0:48:36 Islam I think that this is all
0:48:39 meaning that's always fake it was just
0:48:41 too good we actually won the war and to
0:48:44 establish power and convince the
0:48:45 population to obey and not Rebel
0:48:47 religion was a very good tool that's it
0:48:50 that's it
0:49:01 reporting that
0:49:03 yeah but what in terms of him what was
0:49:06 his Machiavelli reason to even express
0:49:09 that talk so he said from the man
0:49:11 something okay just occasion it says
0:49:23 how can you stay here
0:49:25 meaning tell me something give me some
0:49:28 solution
0:49:29 oh the solution came
0:49:32 does this tie into the mentality whereby
0:49:35 take currently for example also
0:49:38 they can round up people put people in
0:49:40 prison every river everybody
0:49:44 that's the founding of the state when
0:49:46 some people say what happened some
0:49:47 people there's a fabricated what could
0:49:49 it and I think by some Shia Scholars
0:49:50 claiming that they've been having
0:49:53 himself is a British agent and there was
0:49:55 a British spy called Jefferson or
0:49:57 something like that and he has
0:49:58 confessions if the moment you open the
0:50:00 book and read a few pages it's means
0:50:02 yeah publication there's no doubt about
0:50:04 that I can't even write a details about
0:50:06 that if necessary but they know that and
0:50:09 nobody is expecting that book everyone
0:50:10 is your application that's nonsense the
0:50:12 reality is this man is have been taken
0:50:14 over this idea to the level of absolute
0:50:17 Obsession he himself Brothers
0:50:20 before before several years I did not
0:50:23 know any about to read I was mushrik all
0:50:25 my teachers are muslik and kaffir until
0:50:27 I walk up to the reality and to become
0:50:29 recognize the realtor of it here
0:50:32 businesses here about himself the man is
0:50:34 soft overtaken with the idea he is not a
0:50:36 British agent or anything the British
0:50:38 Asian baby Mohammed with rude but not
0:50:39 this man
0:50:41 he's completely obsessed that answering
0:50:43 your question is he a hero or whatever
0:50:45 it is
0:50:47 he's mentally so obsessed that you could
0:50:50 prefer as mentally dereged completely
0:50:53 gone and this man recognized Muhammad
0:50:56 this is a man who is out for power and
0:50:58 government because this is a very
0:51:00 excellent tool for control but I have
0:51:03 fishes to check that he will not
0:51:05 interfere with my income and money and
0:51:07 the illegitimate taxation which you know
0:51:09 just a legitimate it's known to everyone
0:51:11 this terrible taxation is a legitimate
0:51:14 and then he goes to him with this fatwa
0:51:16 and then the alliance was was made
0:51:19 based on approving that that will
0:51:22 continue yes you support the hate
0:51:24 meaning demolition Graves and secondly
0:51:26 another condition you don't live here
0:51:29 without them by permission
0:51:31 by the way
0:51:33 a condition does not entail that
0:51:36 Muhammad cannot kick him out the
0:51:37 formation doesn't tell that you don't
0:51:39 live with that type permission but
0:51:41 there's no essay and I gave you as a
0:51:43 covenant that I don't kick you out no
0:51:44 it's not even stated like that
0:51:48 but the man is so obsessed
0:51:50 that's just a promise I support you that
0:51:52 was enough for him he doesn't see
0:51:54 anything else
0:51:55 just to understand the character of them
0:51:57 person
0:52:02 going to extreme until exactly like now
0:52:04 dash because they have set their
0:52:06 intelligence in their mind
0:52:08 they are the the confused by anyone
0:52:12 they're blind
0:52:13 dream isn't blind to you blinds you
0:52:16 does not let you see the way
0:52:19 so basically this whole insistence on
0:52:21 shirk you rebuttal because of the
0:52:23 fundamental definition of shook yeah
0:52:26 in full in Arabic the path is translated
0:52:29 actually only the introduction part
0:52:31 which because the the reason for This
0:52:34 calamity to happen is that his osule and
0:52:37 the way he load but you cannot blame him
0:52:38 very much because at the time and this
0:52:40 time Islamic scholarship was at the
0:52:42 bottom
0:52:43 Islamic scholarship was increasing and
0:52:45 advancing until let's say the fifth
0:52:47 Islamic Century roughly with more
0:52:49 elaboration and development then slowly
0:52:51 it started stagnating I said maybe three
0:52:54 four centuries and same level up to even
0:52:56 tell me and afternoon
0:52:59 just just
0:53:01 collecting things but nothing really
0:53:03 creative even few creations with Emir
0:53:06 are not that genuinely creative and then
0:53:08 after that started declining
0:53:10 genuinely declining
0:53:13 until the bottom of the time of
0:53:15 hamburger so you cannot blame him that
0:53:16 that he is no no he is at the end of a
0:53:20 declining period after a stagnation and
0:53:22 after the development of scholarship
0:53:23 which was starting to become deviant
0:53:25 after the time of sahaba anyway
0:53:28 so you cannot believe me but that's a
0:53:29 reality
0:53:30 his osun the way he looks at Quran Sun
0:53:33 the way he reads it is with half-blind
0:53:36 eyes
0:53:38 so that's the reason the book of the
0:53:39 head we have these three first chapters
0:53:41 try to clarify that for example
0:53:43 principle going to the bottom of the
0:53:45 absolute necessities of of of of uh of
0:53:50 reason and perception and also the
0:53:52 necessity of the Quran only that most
0:53:54 fundamental and pressing Necessities are
0:53:57 directed there then we discuss later
0:53:59 than the evidences of prophet told us on
0:54:01 and then about the issues of and
0:54:04 worshiping grievance on so the other
0:54:07 thing that they kind of
0:54:08 um hang their Appeal on is the issue of
0:54:12 better and
0:54:16 this entire insistence of having purity
0:54:19 of Dean so this Creed okay and then
0:54:22 there's the acts themselves
0:54:24 almost because because
0:54:32 this is the reason it's believing that
0:54:34 Allah has messenger
0:54:37 Etc even that it is
0:54:44 essential that's it but all the details
0:54:46 there are many Hadith about details of
0:54:48 of how accounting would be in your
0:54:51 Mercury you're not required to believe
0:54:53 in them if you pass on them Ayah okay
0:54:55 then you will believe them automatically
0:54:56 because they they have goodness now they
0:54:58 seem to be authentic that's it
0:55:04 these secondary questions about is the
0:55:07 Quran created not created uh what is the
0:55:09 mounting the throne that's what they
0:55:11 declare Akita and put it as a part of to
0:55:14 read and play a game with that to the
0:55:15 people that have a cool their mind you
0:55:17 have become an issue when did this
0:55:18 become an issue and how do they are how
0:55:20 how would you rebuttal that the the
0:55:22 articulation that is is an issue and
0:55:24 it's because it's related to create
0:55:25 because because clearly it was not the
0:55:27 issue of the time that they claimed the
0:55:28 sale of sahaba they never discussed that
0:55:31 because they understood that everyone
0:55:33 understood his own way as a Canal's
0:55:36 imagination and they understood that
0:55:38 they understood the general principle
0:55:39 that Allah is different than what if I
0:55:40 imagine but whatever imagine is okay
0:55:42 according to our limited human
0:55:44 perception full stop stay there that's
0:55:46 it they didn't need they didn't have any
0:55:48 need to discuss and go in this issue
0:55:51 barely there may be 102 issues related
0:55:54 to what is the course one or two
0:55:57 narrations that's all that is there
0:56:00 that's it and nothing else about that
0:56:03 they were disputes about who is Muslim
0:56:05 on the cover and what gets you are the
0:56:06 problem of Islam when the time of sahaba
0:56:08 by the qawal that would dispute that's
0:56:10 the beginning but not least what they
0:56:12 call it
0:56:13 but they usually call it rapidly
0:56:15 especially their own Akita which is the
0:56:17 defining the Divinity in a in a
0:56:20 definition which control
0:56:28 so that's that that's it
0:56:29 that's part of the problem so for
0:56:31 example take the issue this is more
0:56:35 important than Sharia you have to have
0:56:37 the correct Creed
0:56:38 and the view will confuse Creed with
0:56:40 Iman all this mixed up becomes then a
0:56:43 major issue pushes not matter it's not
0:56:46 even secondary
0:56:47 okay so so the issue that they make they
0:56:50 fixate on life example the hand the
0:56:52 Cursi there's no requirement at all to
0:56:54 to extrapolate that or to have an
0:56:56 adoption on that absolutely no
0:56:57 requirements that's cleared another
0:56:58 equipment
0:57:01 when they use the word
0:57:03 is it usually they they use it on the
0:57:06 issue of creed and they also use it in
0:57:07 related to actions so for example
0:57:09 Millard birthday of the Prophet various
0:57:13 things again on a fundamentally that
0:57:16 what whatever this Harbor did not do we
0:57:19 should not do which is completely even
0:57:22 whatever the prophet did not do we
0:57:23 should not do because we're not doing is
0:57:26 nothing nothing comes with evidence for
0:57:27 anything nothing is is a fundamental
0:57:30 logical flow
0:57:33 so I can understand for example actions
0:57:36 results
0:57:38 action and leave it the only you think
0:57:41 you can conclude that by the necessary
0:57:43 visa and by the old overwhelming
0:57:45 narration is that that what he has left
0:57:47 cannot be cannot have been obligatory
0:57:49 that's all of it it may be still
0:57:51 desirable lifted deliberately
0:57:54 did the deliberately leave it to uh to
0:57:59 show that it's not obligatory it could
0:58:00 be desirable it could be play mobile it
0:58:04 could be undesirable it could be Haram
0:58:05 all these four you have to have extra
0:58:07 evidence for that
0:58:09 that's if he has done an act and left it
0:58:12 if he has done no act at all like for
0:58:14 example
0:58:15 he enabled he never uh
0:58:20 planned or or tried to to to to build
0:58:23 the rocket to go to the Moon
0:58:26 because it it was not given at his time
0:58:30 can you conclude that building located
0:58:38 would you apply it to such odd cases in
0:58:41 normal cases they can play they say he
0:58:43 did not celebrate his his birthday
0:58:46 the only thing you can say for that yeah
0:58:48 it's not obligatory
0:58:50 that's all
0:58:52 but if they frame certain things as
0:58:54 being but in fact he prayed the one day
0:58:56 as you say this is about Monday fasting
0:58:58 Monday because this is my birthday
0:59:00 that's the day I'm born so in things
0:59:02 that the day is born is a nice day worth
0:59:04 of celebrating by fasting or whatever
0:59:05 celebration ending but he did not do
0:59:08 and also the Arab tradition in the other
0:59:10 position there was no celebrating your
0:59:12 birthdays while other nations celebrate
0:59:14 birthdays
0:59:16 so showing that SSA is a assembly
0:59:20 assembly uh you cannot conclude from
0:59:23 that you have to have other desert
0:59:24 someone could say based on that he
0:59:26 present Monday passing on Monday because
0:59:28 he said Monday is the day I am born on
0:59:30 the meaning Monday is a good day we're
0:59:34 celebrating with Siam but his birthday
0:59:36 is also worth celebrating because he
0:59:38 made that a good feature of Monday
0:59:42 so you may conclude from that that is
0:59:43 maybe desirable disability of his
0:59:45 birthday even if he doesn't maybe he did
0:59:47 not get celebrated so that it doesn't
0:59:49 break it came an injunction and burden
0:59:51 to his ummah then they go through the
0:59:53 excessive exactly like the case with the
0:59:55 discussion going around between some
0:59:57 Sunni and Shia
0:59:59 Etc or some Shia and Sunni
1:00:02 as a matter of fact he started Torah we
1:00:04 had started even the Masjid
1:00:06 and then more people came more people
1:00:08 came then he decided it's becoming
1:00:10 dangerous now so he stayed home
1:00:12 and they came with it I started Wiki
1:00:16 sound that we are here ignored them at
1:00:19 the end and the last day they thought
1:00:22 even Stone against his daughter was very
1:00:24 angry
1:00:25 and he said you all must have caused
1:00:27 Allah to make obligatory on you I
1:00:30 abstained from doing it so it doesn't
1:00:33 may become obligatory
1:00:35 when the best player besides after
1:00:37 fariba is the one the one who you pray
1:00:40 at home
1:00:42 you see the point and then people said
1:00:44 after that because of that some people
1:00:45 she has it it's a bit of almost no it's
1:00:48 not Buddha because after the part passed
1:00:51 away there is no danger of to become
1:00:52 obligated
1:00:54 now we can do the nice thing and bring
1:00:57 the people and have an Imam who is good
1:00:59 in with a good voice and eating and even
1:01:01 having an Imam for men and a man for
1:01:03 woman because the Masjid was very big
1:01:05 and they couldn't hear them but they
1:01:06 didn't have microphones at that time or
1:01:08 megaphones so I said so his problem was
1:01:10 not better it's a very good act
1:01:13 as a very good act
1:01:15 just to give you an example but the
1:01:18 problem is the Also let's go to the
1:01:19 fundamental soul
1:01:22 that he did not do something or even
1:01:24 left something after doing
1:01:26 in the case of tarawi has very clearly
1:01:28 breaking through in Jamaica in the
1:01:30 Masjid
1:01:31 is because he was concerned that it may
1:01:34 become obligated on them
1:01:36 and the junction May Come From Heaven
1:01:38 making to obligatory
1:01:40 and he did not want to have too many
1:01:41 applications I wanted to make it easier
1:01:43 as much as possible
1:01:45 like for example the habitualism was to
1:01:47 do with every salad to do and the day of
1:01:49 concrete
1:01:51 in the morning and one morning because
1:01:54 he stayed several days before going to
1:01:56 Africa
1:01:58 and then
1:01:59 and Lord he did not make and pray to God
1:02:02 and also
1:02:04 messenger of Allah he did something I
1:02:06 have never seen it you do it before
1:02:10 you did not make odor foreign
1:02:27 there would be some dumb people like
1:02:28 that
1:02:30 to break that he would did it one day
1:02:32 show it it's not obligatory but he
1:02:34 prefers to do what do for more Purity
1:02:36 for more beautification for calling
1:02:39 whatever is it
1:02:41 obligatory
1:02:45 do you see the fundamental issue that
1:02:47 was only they have faulty also there is
1:02:50 not Hadith conclude something based on
1:02:52 on face value another Hadith they
1:02:54 conclude something in the Third how did
1:02:55 they conclude something
1:02:57 and they didn't put them together and
1:02:59 they don't go to a fundamental principle
1:03:00 alcohol which is enshrined by necessity
1:03:02 of reason and Quran and Sunda like the
1:03:05 same for example not only say I will
1:03:06 have you but many of us and they show or
1:03:09 basically uh ruling of permissibility
1:03:16 the basic learning of action thoughts
1:03:19 and everything is permissibility
1:03:24 for example some Scholars I don't know
1:03:26 the names would argue that if you
1:03:28 repeated a certain act and you
1:03:31 incorporate into your your your worship
1:03:33 and you consider it to be recommended or
1:03:35 something of that nature that makes it
1:03:37 into a bidder
1:03:38 if you if you make it recommended
1:03:40 without any evidence
1:03:47 like for example you you you can very
1:03:50 well celebrate at the moment of the
1:03:51 neighborhood yes it's certain Arabic
1:03:53 tradition he did not say about it
1:03:55 celebrated for whatever reason so it's
1:03:57 definitely not obligatory but he Praises
1:03:59 Monday being said that's the day I am
1:04:01 born in meaning is a blessed day if the
1:04:05 Monday is blessed in the week then the
1:04:07 day he is born
1:04:08 or supposed to be born because the day
1:04:10 the people that live now is almost
1:04:12 certainly the wrong there I have some
1:04:14 work for that but that's not our issue
1:04:15 today
1:04:16 is almost certainly the wrong day
1:04:19 but still
1:04:21 they assume it is being the day and they
1:04:24 celebrated as an occasion
1:04:27 I say the first place that had regarded
1:04:29 as a blessed day you can celebrate
1:04:33 so as long as it's framed in the road
1:04:35 because you have an argument the other
1:04:37 one is purely
1:04:40 making a uh with absolutely no evidence
1:04:43 like for example taking that profit
1:04:46 usually may God offer every Salah will
1:04:48 she showed that is not obligated you see
1:04:50 but it is even better and more desirable
1:04:52 and closer to Allah foreign
1:04:58 not even one hint
1:05:03 you see my point that's it that's Rida
1:05:06 but the other one is not better because
1:05:08 the possible point of view and the
1:05:09 argument is actually structural and well
1:05:11 well established it's a good argument
1:05:14 did not do it it's not that partition
1:05:18 they were busy with Jihad did not come
1:05:20 in their mind keep in mind with the
1:05:22 people later
1:05:23 so this recession about Buddha is being
1:05:25 well firstly framing something is bitter
1:05:28 and then making it such an overwhelming
1:05:30 issue
1:05:32 which almost you know overrides shedding
1:05:35 blood this is this indicate a mentality
1:05:39 which is going extremely religions which
1:05:41 is very destructive
1:05:42 prohibited that and then occasion which
1:05:45 is shocking you know the story now let
1:05:47 me repeat the story in his in his final
1:05:49 uh uh pilgrimage just few months before
1:05:52 he died
1:05:58 and also another I think uh
1:06:03 they were mounting behind the prophet in
1:06:05 exchange sometimes they alphabet
1:06:07 sometimes they'll have battle so taking
1:06:09 that it was my turn when it arrived in
1:06:12 in Muslim
1:06:15 and then we set down you know it was
1:06:17 there before you set down because they
1:06:18 depart on camel back and then coming
1:06:20 back you don't have a traffic jam
1:06:22 because Cummins was killed to go up with
1:06:23 the warranty and so on and the number
1:06:25 was also limited that time nowadays if
1:06:27 you depart with cars we get stuck you
1:06:30 are happy tradition was dead from Before
1:06:31 Dawn I will not get any opportunities to
1:06:34 happen but at the time they went so we
1:06:36 settled there
1:06:38 and before going to sleep I think I've
1:06:41 been working that project I think we'll
1:06:42 go to sleep as a precaution if not even
1:06:44 us select for me uh Stones so on so much
1:06:48 most likely for every day it's like
1:06:50 almost daily from the stones that is
1:06:52 more than nice
1:06:56 but in that place
1:06:58 I selected small stones which are like
1:07:01 the size of chickpeas
1:07:04 very small
1:07:06 and they put in his hand he was amazed
1:07:08 about
1:07:09 while
1:07:11 this is maybe the right to the right
1:07:14 size for nice management and putting a
1:07:16 big number in a bag I think it's a baby
1:07:18 that's right okay
1:07:19 and the people around him also visit we
1:07:22 were around him continuously to learn
1:07:24 from him to get advice to get
1:07:25 instructions to get guidance
1:07:28 on the filters maybe the last pilgrimage
1:07:30 so they have to get opportunity to soak
1:07:33 as much as possible from the knowledge
1:07:34 coming from Heaven through him
1:07:38 and then to the people say
1:07:40 like with this size
1:07:43 dostoning and then he make a statement
1:07:46 which seems to be shocking seems we are
1:07:47 related to this small Silverstone
1:07:51 don't go extreme in devotion indeed din
1:07:55 here means the dayun being devoted being
1:07:57 religious don't call Extreme because the
1:08:00 previous nations were destroyed by going
1:08:02 this extreme empty
1:08:05 because you may think I am going to
1:08:07 Stone the devil
1:08:09 I think I saw Stone so so is hostility
1:08:13 and hated more
1:08:14 um take a big Stone and the next time
1:08:17 you take a bigger Stone
1:08:19 and the next time to recover the machine
1:08:21 gun and then you kill the people think
1:08:22 about that's not what develops that's
1:08:24 all of the game would lead to your
1:08:26 destruction
1:08:29 couldn't you have a counter argument in
1:08:31 the sense that is the fact that people
1:08:33 incorporate other rituals
1:08:36 is what's leading to Hulu so for example
1:08:38 no no no the argument is faulted
1:08:44 now now you show if they come with that
1:08:47 argument say we have this Hadith showing
1:08:50 he's saying clearly had a farm with this
1:08:53 size
1:08:57 and avoid and a Saturday avoid going
1:08:59 extremism indeed
1:09:01 because the previous things were
1:09:03 destroyed
1:09:04 and the only occasion he said previously
1:09:06 will destroy it is this one and another
1:09:08 one that they they punished the the poor
1:09:10 and the lowly and leave the rich and the
1:09:13 noble from punishment
1:09:15 and the equation of cutting the hand of
1:09:17 the Jose Jose
1:09:19 and he said even if Fatima committed
1:09:23 and another two other occasions of what
1:09:26 we destroy another one is that they were
1:09:28 asking to their messenger and going back
1:09:30 and forth with questions and
1:09:31 interrogations so they missing you that
1:09:33 destroys Nations
1:09:34 Etc then four or five you can you can't
1:09:36 even you can't even search in in any
1:09:39 collection of Hadith and so on with the
1:09:41 word
1:09:43 then you will find four or five types
1:09:46 that's one of them and the example given
1:09:48 is clear it's not increment in English
1:09:50 but it's exaggerating the size of the
1:09:52 Stone
1:09:54 foreign
1:09:59 people from around the world
1:10:01 even from Arabia itself but the river
1:10:03 they tend to be a little bit better
1:10:05 educated about that especially Egyptian
1:10:07 they're very hot devoted and so on
1:10:10 at the astonic site some of them take
1:10:13 their shoes and throat at the Devil
1:10:14 you'll cause me to divorce my wife
1:10:17 and just you need to mess with the shoe
1:10:19 and hit someone in his head
1:10:20 you are lucky if you don't plug his eye
1:10:22 out
1:10:25 and if it comes a general habit or
1:10:26 integrating everything
1:10:28 between to destruction
1:10:32 ultimately it's that simple but it will
1:10:35 grow because the mentality the obsessed
1:10:37 mentality that's a small pious
1:10:40 so in some in some ways this whole and
1:10:43 so a good parallel for this one another
1:10:45 example there is an example of that one
1:10:48 time in a battle campaign the part of
1:10:49 those fasting usually he doesn't faster
1:10:51 without a trip
1:10:53 in a comment and then the sun just sank
1:10:55 just barely suck and the Horizon is
1:10:58 burning
1:10:59 with light
1:11:00 and you say to the one driving the camel
1:11:03 stop and let us go down and do us for a
1:11:05 drink
1:11:10 say stop I tell you stop and they said
1:11:12 why like whoa on you stop and start
1:11:15 doing the drink
1:11:17 because the man think I should wait a
1:11:19 little bit maybe five two more minutes
1:11:20 two more minutes that's more bias
1:11:23 and then it goes more and more and more
1:11:25 and more and more until you continue
1:11:27 until next sahore like some people try
1:11:30 it
1:11:32 so this is fasting fantastic
1:11:35 and who told them this is not the idea
1:11:37 so if you as I said I have a I have a
1:11:39 special I have a specialty but it would
1:11:41 Allah my Lord feed me something
1:11:43 spiritual for him but for you it's not
1:11:45 it's off limit
1:11:46 I understand Sam insisted and he faster
1:11:48 than them do you know how much how much
1:11:50 uh he did
1:11:52 he did it not only one night did the
1:11:54 seven days in a row
1:11:56 after they collapsed
1:11:58 don't do it that's really especially for
1:12:00 me
1:12:01 but some people have this tendency think
1:12:03 it's more pious
1:12:08 that's all over the incomes
1:12:11 so the example of uh you know the
1:12:13 example actually that definition of
1:12:15 bitter and bigger it's cyber did not
1:12:16 that's all over D that's going to
1:12:18 extreme
1:12:20 what whatever did not do it who said
1:12:22 they will do everything reasonable and
1:12:24 nice until we almost get up
1:12:27 who said that
1:12:29 what they do that excelled with the
1:12:31 Quran said clearly they're truthful they
1:12:34 are spending they are sacrificing
1:12:35 themselves the cause of Allah ahead of
1:12:37 everyone
1:12:38 that's what made them like that not
1:12:40 anything else that's it read the Quran
1:12:43 from A to Z
1:12:44 you have to go back to the Quran and
1:12:46 read it you have to do the number of the
1:12:48 Quran you cannot just rely on one Hadith
1:12:51 here maybe one uh the highest maybe even
1:12:54 40 maybe we not related completely go to
1:12:57 the one which is completely protected
1:12:59 the Quran from cover to cover to have
1:13:01 these more fundamental issues clarified
1:13:03 in your mind
1:13:10 you often give an example of uh the man
1:13:13 who came to the Masjid and the Hadith
1:13:16 which talks about the mass of shaitaan
1:13:18 yeah can you explain how this kind of
1:13:21 relates to this because that because on
1:13:22 this subject what they call it a Divine
1:13:25 drama or Divine Comedy like uh the one
1:13:28 of Dante but it's not a common sadama
1:13:30 oh you can't call it comedy if you want
1:13:32 uh um anything that is various channels
1:13:34 so most of them are weak but if you put
1:13:37 them together and analyze them you will
1:13:38 come to the conclusion that once the
1:13:40 story must have been outtended for the
1:13:42 goal so we went Allah for some time
1:13:46 and we were talking about and then we
1:13:48 mentioned a man who is known for extreme
1:13:50 piety
1:13:52 and was frustrating in Jihad is not only
1:13:56 and we mentioned heat is distant Empire
1:13:57 I don't know him I'll go to your
1:14:00 prescription I don't remember that now I
1:14:02 don't know
1:14:03 just let me comment here quickly that of
1:14:06 us have I don't know him meaning he does
1:14:07 not attend the Halal he's not gaining
1:14:09 knowledge
1:14:11 make a note on that and Allah put it as
1:14:13 Dex textbook now anyway we are
1:14:15 discussing this man and describing he
1:14:17 looks like that his bed is like that the
1:14:18 man came
1:14:26 they have a place of sitting near the
1:14:29 Bible or sofa in the back at that time
1:14:31 let's assume that all at that entrance
1:14:33 there far away from the end
1:14:38 this is the man we are talking about he
1:14:40 is he is coming and he first looked at
1:14:43 him say this one
1:14:46 I don't know yet but I see in his face
1:14:48 the strike of the devil
1:14:51 shocking
1:14:53 that's because the prophetess have
1:14:55 spirituality and receive why the others
1:14:57 do not see see only the external work
1:15:01 and then the birds want to teach them
1:15:02 why he has a strike of the devil
1:15:04 so when he came close he said Salaam I'm
1:15:07 saying
1:15:11 when you came close to this to us to
1:15:13 this group of sitting people
1:15:15 did you think in your mind that you are
1:15:17 better than everyone here
1:15:19 maybe through the airport maybe the
1:15:21 others at least let's assume that let's
1:15:23 let's give the man a better benefit of
1:15:25 the doubt unlikely that he thinks it's
1:15:27 better than the prophet but
1:15:29 the man who is thoughtful say Allah by
1:15:33 Allah yes
1:15:37 now we know what this is
1:15:39 looking down on his Muslim Brothers
1:15:42 I do more I am doing more in the
1:15:44 battlefield I pray more
1:15:49 than he proceeded does he sit and ask
1:15:52 why you are asking me what's going on
1:15:53 why the strange question no no he
1:15:56 doesn't need he knows everything
1:15:59 he has everything already
1:16:02 showed that otherwise he would have to
1:16:04 be said imagine you get the opportunity
1:16:06 to pass at the messenger allow people
1:16:08 sitting and he asks you such a straight
1:16:09 question wouldn't you sit as I said why
1:16:12 are you asking me this question
1:16:14 strange question what's happening
1:16:16 it's something wrong with me no he
1:16:18 didn't
1:16:18 he continued doing the Masjid to the
1:16:20 front of the Masjid maybe behind the
1:16:22 wall or a character or something most
1:16:24 like the prophet was that was in the
1:16:26 back at a period of sofa people were
1:16:28 living in the machine doing Quran and so
1:16:30 on
1:16:32 Amazon I come to the people there almost
1:16:34 were there and Ali had saw and a few
1:16:35 others so it was really an important
1:16:37 Catholic
1:16:39 imagine he thinks it's better this
1:16:41 including Alia possibly even including
1:16:43 the prophet but let's say we will not go
1:16:45 to that extreme
1:16:49 a strange command or request
1:16:52 see who from you will go and kill this
1:16:55 man
1:17:00 is not Warrior you didn't say anything
1:17:04 until they know that all his life that
1:17:06 must be laid in in time because Abu Bakr
1:17:09 also reported that but in a mutilated
1:17:10 way so maybe in the ninth or tenth year
1:17:12 really and also awareness must have been
1:17:14 mature and old sitting with these people
1:17:16 because he started serving the prophet
1:17:18 with 10 years 10 years old will not
1:17:20 bother with six most likely must be 15
1:17:21 16 17 quite late so what happened but
1:17:25 maybe why when something exceptional
1:17:28 so like I said I will do it there was a
1:17:31 go if you can so he went he saw the man
1:17:34 praying
1:17:35 and that he hesitated
1:17:39 this is all a Divine Comedy Allah
1:17:41 producing it visibly
1:17:43 because we at the end we know it as a
1:17:45 divide comedy he would not have been
1:17:46 killed because he's not worthy of
1:17:47 killing
1:17:48 be well but we'll do he says
1:17:54 I'm not I'm prohibited from killing
1:17:57 Muslim the one who pray especially if
1:17:59 that is now praying now
1:18:03 but this is the one who is playing right
1:18:06 now
1:18:08 so he went back to the messenger while I
1:18:09 saw him praying and you have prohibited
1:18:11 us from killing
1:18:13 numbers you are not the one for that you
1:18:16 are not the one very distant for this
1:18:18 one almost said almost said I will do it
1:18:23 he goes and then pull the sword the
1:18:24 heads of w will dispatch with this man
1:18:27 he came and found almost upon him in
1:18:30 sujood
1:18:31 hey this is even worse the money is in a
1:18:33 student
1:18:35 the lowest the lowest body position
1:18:38 foreign
1:18:42 not only he's playing under Abu Bakr
1:18:44 hesitated is a good example I should
1:18:46 follow Abu Bakr he hesitated
1:18:51 we are not the man for him
1:18:53 and I said I let me go
1:18:56 but I said see what has he said to Ali
1:18:59 go you will kill him if you find him
1:19:03 if you find him
1:19:05 and then he goes in the man has finished
1:19:07 unquote
1:19:08 I came back said he's gone messenger
1:19:11 said
1:19:13 their people this way of guidance
1:19:16 all of themselves Paragon looking down
1:19:18 other Muslims believing that they have
1:19:20 all the knowledge and reality they read
1:19:21 the Quran without digesting it that's
1:19:24 the first occasion or one of the king
1:19:26 said
1:19:27 and they will deviate from Islam or from
1:19:31 obedience and from the community
1:19:33 them
1:19:36 if you have killed him which is a puzzle
1:19:39 by design of Allah he would have the
1:19:42 first and the last of the khawaj but
1:19:45 it's not aware of the universe that's
1:19:46 not the way Universe have been started
1:19:48 the beginning as a testing Universe
1:19:50 could it be possibly have been killed
1:19:53 if you have killed him but it's if it's
1:19:55 impossible it's impossible you could not
1:19:57 have killed
1:19:58 because their history has to take away
1:20:00 and you have to be tested by hawaris
1:20:02 tested by monafithine tested by your own
1:20:04 desires you have to be tested now
1:20:06 tomorrow this these days in our
1:20:09 interaction now tomorrow there's no
1:20:11 escape this is Qatar fixed at the
1:20:13 beginning of the creation unescapable
1:20:18 anyway this show this now we know it's a
1:20:21 Divine Comedy
1:20:22 I like exposing to them like an act in
1:20:25 front of them
1:20:27 that man could not have been killed
1:20:28 because he's not pulling the sword
1:20:29 that's number one
1:20:31 the appropriate ordering him killing by
1:20:33 wahi
1:20:34 either knowing or jibree
1:20:36 Allah knowing that he would not be
1:20:38 killed and these people will fail and
1:20:40 also hinting that the one who will fight
1:20:42 khawaj and if he finds them
1:20:45 and is supported Hadith
1:20:48 we mentioned it's just to to give some
1:20:52 some some nice taste to our discussion
1:20:55 today and to give valuable value-based
1:20:57 virtual in this special regard
1:20:59 one time I'm still gonna say
1:21:01 one of you will be fighting about the
1:21:03 top wheel about their proper
1:21:05 interpretation of the Quran as I thought
1:21:07 about its revelation
1:21:09 notice the web it's the same way I
1:21:11 thought about the simulation
1:21:13 one of you will fight about its status
1:21:16 interpretation not about the video
1:21:18 people do not denying it with this but
1:21:20 they were entirely interpreted wrongly
1:21:22 and the same the way he's saying like I
1:21:25 thought tanzino we know the fighting was
1:21:27 also uh potential is unfallible and is
1:21:30 the correct way to doing it giving a
1:21:32 warning sending Messengers doing this
1:21:34 thing we don't we have that structure we
1:21:36 have even writing and this area which
1:21:38 will be very strong
1:21:39 so Ali will be doing it the correct way
1:21:41 in this regard not necessarily an
1:21:44 inheritance law not necessarily a matter
1:21:46 of selling a bike slips or she has some
1:21:48 factors which are almost manifestly
1:21:50 wrong no in this one it will be correct
1:21:54 so backup this is a great virtue that
1:21:56 you would be the one fighting for the
1:21:57 meaning of the Quran in the time which
1:21:59 is misinterpreted so it is Allah
1:22:02 no not you mama said me I want to be
1:22:05 happy this great honor say no so who is
1:22:08 it then say the one who is fixing my my
1:22:10 son that and Ali was fixing the sandals
1:22:12 Allah stitching it
1:22:15 that's the one who do it it's the same
1:22:18 as the one who here he felt by the man
1:22:21 because he could not find it now that's
1:22:22 not the time to be found
1:22:24 so there's also a projection of the
1:22:26 possible future there which the history
1:22:28 have brought forward as a reality
1:22:32 but at that appointment is not that is
1:22:34 very true and so on this is important by
1:22:36 itself that is understanding the point
1:22:38 here is that
1:22:40 the mentality of demand
1:22:43 he doesn't answer the help of the
1:22:45 prophet
1:22:45 yes the Quran or do you think he has
1:22:48 digested it probably
1:22:50 because
1:22:54 you have to refer the Sunnah
1:22:57 in its totality obviously
1:23:00 and even even if you don't have a Sunnah
1:23:03 it had like a uh when Allah
1:23:13 with the provision you read it and
1:23:15 digest it
1:23:17 and you read it all of it
1:23:18 is
1:23:22 then if you go through it all of it
1:23:24 interconnected it properly analyze it
1:23:27 consistently then if they logic in your
1:23:30 mind it must be of divine origin there's
1:23:32 only one Divinity there's a day of
1:23:34 judgment that's the address
1:23:40 but he is now looking down his Muslim
1:23:43 brothers are not willing even to sit in
1:23:45 with the prophet to learn more things
1:23:47 who she need as a companion who's
1:23:49 supposed to be carried that after the
1:23:51 prophet
1:23:52 he's not doing
1:23:54 observations so one observation here is
1:23:57 the fact that
1:23:59 um this person so for example you you
1:24:00 previously mentioned about the huarach
1:24:02 how they when it when it says that it
1:24:04 doesn't go deep in the throats you you
1:24:06 also you you made the argument that
1:24:09 southern is deep conviction deep solid
1:24:12 in metaphorical because the southern is
1:24:16 there is the place of knowledge like the
1:24:18 database
1:24:19 the storage
1:24:21 heart is a metaphor for the center of
1:24:24 the CPU the processing unit the
1:24:27 Consciousness the mind the also the
1:24:28 associated feeling and the way you
1:24:31 conclude things and causes things and
1:24:33 the knowledge goes in the sudden
1:24:35 people think it's the physical one no
1:24:37 it's a metaphorical one
1:24:39 and even if the Quran says it is it is
1:24:41 not it is not the the eyes which become
1:24:45 blind it is the heart which is in the
1:24:47 chest meaning that metaphorical heart or
1:24:49 the spiritual heart in the spiritual
1:24:51 chest
1:24:53 so that's what the Arabic convention and
1:24:55 the third it fits with the like for
1:24:57 example if you if you detect for example
1:25:00 or you do you are programming you are a
1:25:02 programmer or they're doing doing
1:25:04 computer issues if you detect something
1:25:07 on the way to to do a service today to
1:25:09 connect programs and you feel
1:25:13 you feel as if your chest is elated you
1:25:16 feel like it is on the chest
1:25:19 it's in here but you feel the ease here
1:25:22 if you get a bad news you feel the pain
1:25:25 and you feel the pain in your heart here
1:25:27 you feel it because of vagus but reality
1:25:29 is here I'm going still this time
1:25:31 metaphorical wonders so that that
1:25:32 reflection with the people even some
1:25:34 people go into extreme things that
1:25:36 really the physical heart is there and
1:25:38 then obviously refuted by Ultra heart
1:25:40 transplantation we know that when you
1:25:42 transfer to the heart of someone who
1:25:43 died
1:25:44 the one who received the heart remain
1:25:46 the same person the same character and
1:25:48 so on barely anything from the other one
1:25:50 will come we know that but that's
1:25:52 actually interesting so for example
1:25:54 so that's the chest the information so
1:25:57 whenever
1:25:58 it doesn't go down through the circle
1:26:00 through the chest it doesn't become
1:26:02 knowledge
1:26:03 useful knowledge
1:26:05 sitting in the chest it doesn't
1:26:08 chewing on it that's it
1:26:11 is not digested because if it's digested
1:26:13 if you something goes through the throat
1:26:15 will go down then it's digest it and if
1:26:17 it's just the compound from the body in
1:26:18 the case of wood in the case of
1:26:20 knowledge or on
1:26:22 it goes in your chest as knowledge and
1:26:24 understanding not just made bits of data
1:26:27 understanding correct understanding
1:26:29 correct
1:26:32 getting the correct and the connected
1:26:34 Munich
1:26:35 and then say there is the Quran not the
1:26:38 ayat or Quran the Quran the total Quran
1:26:40 and they still are unable to digest
1:26:42 because they don't do the correct
1:26:43 digesting tools even in fundamental
1:26:46 things for the Hawaii
1:26:49 yeah
1:26:53 we will come to that point because some
1:26:55 of the people currently are discussing
1:26:57 that issue Malik is there because they
1:26:59 relate to rulers and many of these
1:27:00 salafi and so on are agents either paid
1:27:03 agents and traitors
1:27:07 or many follower who think is is really
1:27:10 a Pious man and guiding them to the
1:27:12 right way and the reality is he's a paid
1:27:15 man he's an agent anyone person I met
1:27:17 him personally I discuss with him
1:27:18 personally
1:27:19 so
1:27:22 what do I say yeah about it
1:27:25 suffered because the issue of of rolling
1:27:28 it seemed it's clear that they're
1:27:30 reading the Quran with the digesting
1:27:31 it's called the issue of ruling is clear
1:27:32 in the Quran
1:27:34 when they say
1:27:35 yes
1:27:37 but what's what's in which ruling is
1:27:39 only for Allah because the Quran says
1:27:41 there are places we reveal the Torah
1:27:43 with guidance and light and so on with
1:27:45 which the prophets and the scribes and
1:27:48 the Rabbani rabbis
1:27:52 etcolors judge rule also so the prophets
1:27:57 and the scribes and they're all
1:27:59 so there's a ruling of profits and so on
1:28:03 the message
1:28:04 if they come to you to rule between them
1:28:07 meaning the Jews and their dispute then
1:28:09 you have the Liberty either you roll
1:28:10 with them and say no no you are an
1:28:11 independent entity manage your officer
1:28:13 or or your issues if you choose to rule
1:28:16 the rule with Allah has revealed
1:28:18 Injustice it's not Liberty you don't
1:28:20 follow their desires you rule with that
1:28:21 are everyday to you not what they want
1:28:23 you to worry about yours what I will
1:28:26 revealed to you
1:28:27 so there is a ruling of the messenger
1:28:33 which one is that
1:28:36 that's a question
1:28:38 for that if you have read all the Quran
1:28:40 you will digest have digested it you
1:28:43 would understood that that this ruling
1:28:45 is something else than what they
1:28:47 objected to alibner agreeing to have uh
1:28:50 arbitration it's not arbitration all the
1:28:52 Declaration was a political mistake and
1:28:54 Ali said if this is the trick but they
1:28:55 don't obey him okay fine but in the
1:28:57 village of that has nothing to do with
1:28:59 with the with violating it's ruling only
1:29:02 for Allah
1:29:07 a game
1:29:10 that we have to get to to write as men
1:29:13 who who make a ruling about what is the
1:29:16 equivalent animal animal of cattle or
1:29:18 the equivalent care expiration which we
1:29:20 discussed result in my area for example
1:29:25 for example
1:29:28 so it's a couple of observations
1:29:29 actually various two rulings to Allah
1:29:32 what is
1:29:35 they thought every ruling including the
1:29:37 arbitration
1:29:39 is is only for Allah no it's not true
1:29:41 Allah order to others
1:29:44 so what is the ruling which is exclusive
1:29:46 for Allah that has to be said understand
1:29:48 our book of the year which is almost the
1:29:51 translation is almost finished I
1:29:53 understand
1:29:54 yeah yeah I think you are editing the
1:29:56 final version yeah
1:29:58 it's sorted out after a long deep
1:30:01 discussion invoking essentially a Quran
1:30:03 necessary reason we don't even use a
1:30:04 Hadith for that so if they have read the
1:30:07 Quran and digested it
1:30:10 they would have reached that conclusion
1:30:12 or a similar code maybe not as
1:30:14 sophisticated this one in our book is
1:30:16 sophisticated because I'm building on
1:30:18 knowledge and discussion over 1400 years
1:30:21 for God's sake that will make you more
1:30:23 sophisticated more advanced we develop
1:30:25 things and let us say the 14th 15th
1:30:28 generation like a car of the first
1:30:30 International be most sophisticated and
1:30:32 Polished than the illegals or go around
1:30:42 they don't get they got a pile of junk
1:30:45 and in Detroit
1:30:48 themselves for the ummah and was able to
1:30:51 get away and I suspect that even more
1:30:53 how you penetrated them and instigated
1:30:55 them and played with their work most
1:30:57 likely and they're very very many hints
1:30:59 indicating that he was playing the
1:31:00 string so bad the scene but that's not
1:31:02 our issue
1:31:03 so part of that also because they think
1:31:06 they have with this blubbering and
1:31:08 reading just shallow reading they got
1:31:10 all their knowledge so they don't bother
1:31:13 about asking companies that asking other
1:31:15 scholar people so there's there seems to
1:31:18 be very close parallels in two respects
1:31:20 with this individual and the wahhabi
1:31:22 movement so just to jump ahead slightly
1:31:24 exactly so for example the one thing is
1:31:26 you know you mentioned about the number
1:31:28 of Quran you see very clearly right now
1:31:31 in this current issue
1:31:33 what they do is they don't even
1:31:37 uh show all the Hadith related to a
1:31:39 given subject matter so for example they
1:31:42 build we're obviously going to cover
1:31:43 this in a few minutes but they build a
1:31:45 they build a narrative about de facto
1:31:48 default position everyone agrees that
1:31:50 you can't rebel against a ruler you
1:31:52 can't say anything against the ruler and
1:31:54 then they build this narrative
1:31:56 while ignoring all the Hadith which talk
1:32:00 about when you turn the Quran before
1:32:01 that
1:32:03 the Quran before that because the Quran
1:32:05 where weather will admission the Quran
1:32:08 in only two places one place is the eye
1:32:11 of famous eye of buildings
1:32:12 so obey Allah
1:32:15 and obey his messenger with the
1:32:17 repeating the word obey because the
1:32:18 obedient messenger is separate and
1:32:20 additional why because of Allah because
1:32:25 the machine is unvaluable we know the
1:32:27 message is not Allah he's a human being
1:32:30 he's not eternal
1:32:32 he's a female
1:32:34 it will be recircuited for eternity the
1:32:36 hopefully all of us in Paradise but he
1:32:38 is not by his own essential being a
1:32:41 necessary being so his obedience is
1:32:44 essentially because he's reporting Alpha
1:32:46 life from Allah so this is like obeying
1:32:48 Allah obey obedience is saved clearly so
1:32:51 nobody is at Liberty when you see when
1:32:53 he receives the Hadith proved to be
1:32:55 authentic but possible to say no I'm not
1:32:58 going to obey because it's not a Quran
1:33:00 no we are not that Liberty you become
1:33:01 Catholic this way
1:33:04 by this position the studies in the
1:33:06 Quran the extreme Quran you say the
1:33:08 Sunnah by itself is not is not binding
1:33:13 yeah this is meaning if I hear it even
1:33:16 from the messenger
1:33:18 I'm not going to obey I obey on the
1:33:19 otherwise
1:33:29 without the word obey again meaning it
1:33:32 is a minor level it is just an appendix
1:33:35 and then after that the addition where
1:33:37 they stop most of the time they don't
1:33:56 most likely from the from the context he
1:33:59 means mainly the dispute between you and
1:34:01 the rulers but also between you and
1:34:03 others is it loaded but the dispute here
1:34:06 is focused morally not excluded but not
1:34:09 worth it so if you have this filter the
1:34:10 rulers
1:34:17 his messenger
1:34:19 if you believe in Allah of judgment
1:34:21 that's the only way to go and this will
1:34:24 have the final conclusion the better
1:34:25 result another place where the other
1:34:27 upcoming is that
1:34:29 rebuilding and those those are those
1:34:32 rumor mangas and so on by the way
1:34:36 if they receive any news about which
1:34:39 related to security and fear and War War
1:34:42 and Peace like for example someone
1:34:44 coming from in the time past no nowadays
1:34:47 impossible to happen almost likely but
1:34:50 in time past you may have you may
1:34:52 expecting a caravan to come from champ
1:34:54 for example for the goods you have and
1:34:56 you go outside maybe longing to meet a
1:34:59 caravan outside Medina
1:35:03 we saw in the whole Horizon a gathering
1:35:06 of One Tribe or something with arms and
1:35:08 so on with gear which shows it's maybe
1:35:10 you were and they look they're advancing
1:35:11 it looks like they're advancing to
1:35:13 Medina so there may be a danger
1:35:15 and you know about it these rumor
1:35:18 mongers and these they take that news
1:35:21 they sit in the master say there may be
1:35:23 an army coming to Medina I like this and
1:35:25 so on Allah rebuking them for that if
1:35:27 they receive such a news
1:35:30 they broadcasted everywhere to show that
1:35:33 I'm knowledgeable I know or with the
1:35:35 intent to make a Believers afraid and
1:35:37 shaking and Confused what's going on is
1:35:40 there's an army coming
1:35:41 what they should have done
1:35:44 they should have referred to Allah
1:35:46 messenger and the one in charge
1:35:48 then the one in charge will know how to
1:35:52 analyze that and take our approach
1:35:54 action maybe the Army is going as well
1:35:56 maybe it will need to do a preparation
1:35:59 maybe you need to dig up ditch they will
1:36:01 make the decision because they were in
1:36:03 charge they are responsible for one at
1:36:04 peace
1:36:07 that's the second place mentioned so
1:36:09 this is the obligation and this is a
1:36:11 poor and peace security you have to
1:36:13 repair
1:36:16 nowadays there's no compatible case
1:36:19 possible except maybe you see a bag in
1:36:20 another train station it looks
1:36:22 suspicious
1:36:23 then you go to the coffee shop so there
1:36:25 is a bug here people run away
1:36:27 that's not the correct Behavior
1:36:28 correlation call the police there is a
1:36:31 bug it's suspicious come check it
1:36:32 because they have the tools and the
1:36:34 vocabulary to do it don't go to the
1:36:36 coffee shop or say people there's about
1:36:38 maybe the one blown away
1:36:40 causing confusion
1:36:49 your Danger
1:36:51 so it's not a correct way the people may
1:36:54 panic and some fold their break his neck
1:36:56 and so on causing a catastrophe
1:36:59 the correct way is calling the authority
1:37:01 the one who responsible for for security
1:37:03 and so for example and more than that
1:37:05 could happen like that but in this not a
1:37:07 complete Army coming there's too many
1:37:09 satellites and observation posts there
1:37:12 to detect that but something like that
1:37:14 it should be with this category
1:37:19 in addition
1:37:21 so the the is really care said if you're
1:37:24 a dispute about single reflector it says
1:37:27 they might be dispute it could be
1:37:28 dispute and it may be a legitimately
1:37:30 dispute and had to be settled by
1:37:31 reference to other messenger
1:37:33 which is very structured the need for
1:37:35 the discussion is in our book about
1:37:37 obedience what the meaning refer to our
1:37:38 lives meaning referring to an authority
1:37:41 which can make a decision being referred
1:37:42 to something like a constitutional Court
1:37:45 that's hinted there and if you analyze
1:37:47 it correctly you will do that but leave
1:37:48 this very Advanced spot but it hence it
1:37:51 possible so you could very well dispute
1:37:53 with the ruler you may have a good
1:37:55 reason you may not have a good reason
1:37:56 some other authority like a court will
1:37:58 arbitrate about that so let's not hold
1:38:00 on
1:38:05 only pulling the sword and starting
1:38:07 killing the people that's all which
1:38:09 disputing the ruler even going into
1:38:11 civilian Disobedience reviews that go to
1:38:13 work is not reached it's just this
1:38:16 obedience could be just the right
1:38:18 continuous it has to be arbitrated
1:38:19 according to Allah said
1:38:22 but if the one in children ruler reached
1:38:26 a level of of making cover
1:38:28 and attacking the Deen
1:38:31 foreign
1:38:39 because you have no Covenant this in the
1:38:42 eye is
1:38:47 of the college and so on indeed but it
1:38:50 applies also to the domestic rulers
1:38:53 if they do the same
1:38:55 if they break the Covenant yes because
1:38:57 the ruler could not become a ruler
1:38:59 unless has given a covenant or an oath
1:39:01 that he will attend to the public Affair
1:39:03 and protect uh people's wealth money
1:39:07 life and so on and do not do not attack
1:39:10 the religion or undermine the religion
1:39:12 or violate the well-established agreed
1:39:15 upon rules
1:39:16 but like for some allow usually we'll
1:39:18 come to user in a minute
1:39:20 if he doesn't do that
1:39:22 and attack the religion by allowing
1:39:23 usually or by permitting a giving by
1:39:26 giving licenses in the Islamic domain
1:39:28 not outside Islam to Two Brothers
1:39:31 that he's he's fulfilled the Ayah
1:39:34 they have to fight them
1:39:36 because they have no Covenant anymore
1:39:39 maybe if you fight them they will stop
1:39:41 that when they start the fight so you
1:39:43 are pulling the sword against them so
1:39:44 now it's becoming serious but step back
1:39:46 I'm sorry I'm correcting then we can
1:39:48 negotiate and go from there and start
1:39:50 correcting that
1:39:52 but without showing such type of people
1:39:54 disorder they will not stop
1:39:58 that they may stop them
1:40:01 the Quran it's enough you don't need to
1:40:03 go to Hadith about obedience and the
1:40:05 recoverable showing cover and those are
1:40:08 practicing Injustice
1:40:11 and those who would violate the Sunnah
1:40:13 fundamentally and the behavior of a
1:40:15 proper Imam Etc there are many I had it
1:40:17 about it
1:40:19 this I mentioned
1:40:22 this application to quraish can they
1:40:24 argue in the context of the Qureshi and
1:40:27 so on that's fine but but the reasoning
1:40:30 is mentioned there
1:40:35 that's the reason for fighting them and
1:40:37 declaring them to the leader of
1:40:39 that could be applied also to a Muslim
1:40:42 locally who broke his Covenant
1:40:48 and established Justice
1:40:51 if he breaks that
1:40:54 and attack the religion by permitting
1:40:55 usually for example and so on
1:41:05 because usually is act of War
1:41:13 your religion is BS it's not worth
1:41:18 we have passed that stage we are now in
1:41:20 possible then time
1:41:22 plus exactly
1:41:26 who says it's only the Qureshi can
1:41:28 behave this way
1:41:32 anyone fit because the diet gives a
1:41:34 description the reason for that
1:41:36 if they complete their covenants of the
1:41:39 Oaths
1:41:40 religion
1:41:45 or declare to be false and it's not
1:41:48 applicable
1:41:51 there these these guys were listed they
1:41:54 are the leaders of corporal
1:41:56 I'm not even invoking the Hadith
1:41:58 said this Ayah all those came in the
1:42:01 context of quraish the people which
1:42:03 should be fought in this Ayah they have
1:42:05 not come yet they will come down the
1:42:06 road
1:42:13 at face value
1:42:18 because of these two things
1:42:22 that was of comfort and make them liable
1:42:26 of being fought
1:42:29 because they have no no Covenant no I
1:42:31 might they broke it already maybe they
1:42:33 stopped
1:42:34 give you also the wisdom of fighting if
1:42:36 you pull the sword in front of his
1:42:37 people say this is serious now
1:42:40 the whole people are rebelling with the
1:42:41 sword I have to step back
1:42:44 and take a breath at least or I have to
1:42:46 fight ultimate about one if if I survive
1:42:48 them until you finish him
1:42:51 if he stops and says the mistake I'm
1:42:53 going to correct
1:42:54 show us
1:42:56 close these these brothers close this
1:42:58 you're in the Islamic domain outside the
1:42:59 Islamic domain which is very easy and so
1:43:01 on that's very visible under the
1:43:02 description
1:43:18 may Allah
1:43:34 to be correct say yeah they are right
1:43:37 they're saying that correct things or
1:43:39 help them in the in their in their
1:43:41 transgressions
1:43:42 has nothing to do with me and they have
1:43:44 nothing to them his relation is broken
1:43:47 of Allah
1:43:50 had this clearly the Hadith
1:43:53 about Quran so on this is a lot of
1:43:56 college the amounts would be information
1:43:57 satellite Etc
1:43:58 and then he said
1:44:03 as long as they will be the reason as
1:44:06 long as they if they if they
1:44:09 if they when they when they ruled they
1:44:12 roll with Justice
1:44:13 when they promised the effect of the
1:44:15 promise and where they asked for Mercy
1:44:17 they show Mercy when they asked they are
1:44:19 not obliged to do much to start with
1:44:21 they may be rough and harsh okay fine
1:44:24 but if they ask for Mercy In a
1:44:26 reasonable Justified way they should
1:44:28 show Mercy and who even know doesn't do
1:44:31 anything of that
1:44:32 of these events for sure any other Imam
1:44:35 after college has expired from Irma then
1:44:38 Allah scares the case of his angels and
1:44:41 the case of all people will be upon them
1:44:42 thus Hadith is
1:44:46 after that
1:44:51 which comes from three channels
1:44:54 one form for one one from uh
1:44:57 one from um
1:44:59 and one from
1:45:04 foreign
1:45:09 were almost excluded because they were
1:45:12 narrated it says
1:45:15 on them that's fine no we know that
1:45:17 about that value if they don't comply
1:45:19 with these for three conditions
1:45:21 then put your sword on your shoulders
1:45:23 and exterminate them perish them don't
1:45:26 let them
1:45:27 otherwise the whole life will will
1:45:29 degenerate into into operation and you
1:45:31 will become you will become lowly
1:45:33 farmers who are living from from plowing
1:45:36 the ground slowly from I just flowing
1:45:38 the ground having no dignity no no
1:45:40 character no standing
1:45:42 at that time Farmers regarded as Lord is
1:45:45 like self like in the time that I was a
1:45:47 funeral time it's not that farming is
1:45:49 except but profession but farm at a time
1:45:52 were regarded as the law when the one
1:45:54 oppressed no one submissive to the few
1:45:55 the Lords
1:45:59 otherwise you'll be hapless farmer
1:46:04 the one who plowed the grounds who was
1:46:06 just surviving and eating from that what
1:46:07 they pull out that's it
1:46:10 the Lords and the Kings and so on are
1:46:12 oppressing them on
1:46:14 providing them like donkeys then you
1:46:16 will be like that
1:46:17 this narrative that the Madras have
1:46:20 trying to make it almost like an ichima
1:46:22 and they try to you know say it's some
1:46:25 kind of a consensus some kind of
1:46:27 overwhelming
1:46:28 is it does it have any basis how did it
1:46:32 there's this one or two
1:46:33 not probably analysis and neglecting it
1:46:36 is a Hadith because even the Hadith
1:46:38 about obedience
1:46:42 does not support them and that's the
1:46:45 reason they say oh there's no government
1:46:46 we don't see any coverage usually it's
1:46:48 just a sin it's not government no my
1:46:50 dear friend
1:46:55 and one
1:46:57 with the following characteristic
1:46:59 clarification what cover worth of the
1:47:02 Lower Side will be saying
1:47:05 unless he command you with an obedience
1:47:08 this obedience to Allah or Haram
1:47:10 publicly
1:47:14 that you stand there I don't believe in
1:47:16 a God or
1:47:18 I have become a Buddhist now that's not
1:47:21 the color boy this is by with his play
1:47:23 with that field or he loses that
1:47:25 Authority no we know that a capital
1:47:27 control of the Muslim that's fine but
1:47:29 that's not what Hadith means
1:47:30 because the other form of related from
1:47:32 outside
1:47:34 but same thing it's saying
1:47:39 unless he commands
1:47:42 with disobedience to Allah with a sin
1:47:44 publicly
1:47:48 now allowing your uh usually banking in
1:47:52 the Islamic is not allowed even in even
1:47:55 the Confederation demand even in the
1:47:57 medium is not allowed because of the
1:47:59 Nigerian treaty even that would allowed
1:48:01 there he allows that
1:48:04 foreign
1:48:13 publicly
1:48:15 ordering we will not attach these
1:48:17 resource
1:48:18 or not to sue them in court
1:48:24 but these people are Jokers these people
1:48:26 are that's just the last of it and
1:48:28 that's the reason they they they they
1:48:30 they they play games with the Quran and
1:48:32 Sunnah and they hide most of it exactly
1:48:34 like that when it's condemns
1:48:38 when asked the Jews who revealed when
1:48:41 they denied say but when their argument
1:48:43 with one of the sahab I think and then
1:48:45 one of them said
1:48:46 say you see that what has come to
1:48:48 Muhammad is similar to come to Musa he
1:48:51 said who told you that Moses received
1:48:52 the Revelation all these are all the
1:48:54 myths
1:48:56 so that how blessed you scholar escaped
1:48:59 through denying the Revelation and Allah
1:49:01 asked him then who revealed in the Torah
1:49:03 to Musa said no no Revelation has come
1:49:06 to anybody
1:49:08 brought down the Revelation to Musa well
1:49:11 she brought down the generation you show
1:49:14 some part of it and the rest you are
1:49:15 hiding from the public
1:49:17 who did that who revealed it it's Allah
1:49:21 revealed it all your history is based on
1:49:23 that that elevation came to Musa and he
1:49:25 got you after Egypt with all these
1:49:27 Miracles all your history is defined
1:49:29 this way
1:49:30 and now we denying everything because
1:49:31 you don't want to accept Muhammad you're
1:49:33 not going to get away
1:49:36 exactly happened to us with some scholar
1:49:39 starting on the ancient before even
1:49:40 Madras
1:49:41 unfortunately some Hadith Scholars
1:49:45 unfortunately very unfortunate but this
1:49:48 has happened with this we will expose
1:49:50 that in various ways already I hate that
1:49:52 but it has to be sometimes you need to
1:49:54 go to history and clean the messages
1:49:56 accumulated
1:49:58 I mean this whole mentality of building
1:50:00 almost like this absolute consensus it's
1:50:03 not based on anything I mean how do they
1:50:05 get nothing give you an example
1:50:09 in his deathbed or that his son Abdullah
1:50:12 to strike Hadith not saying this Hadith
1:50:14 is bad they're more attention so it's so
1:50:17 his reasoning the morteza use it as a
1:50:19 reasoning
1:50:20 for not attending Juma what's the
1:50:23 headache with structure which is struck
1:50:25 at this in the in the initially the one
1:50:27 the narrator of the Muslim from the son
1:50:29 Abdullah said there was a line on the
1:50:31 top at that time they they cross out not
1:50:33 by Crossing through because above that
1:50:36 was their Convention of Crossing out it
1:50:37 was crossed out he said but it's not it
1:50:39 crossed out but not least still the
1:50:42 wedding is there that is the famous
1:50:45 will be destroyed by this some some
1:50:48 subtypes of quraish
1:50:50 or or uh stupid uh young people of
1:50:54 course
1:50:58 and the people were shocked so what we
1:51:00 should do with them
1:51:02 what can we do with them
1:51:04 said if the people would have Heritage
1:51:07 would avoid interacting with them avoid
1:51:10 obeying them do a civil disobedience
1:51:12 essentially those generalists like
1:51:14 essentially but use that at the salon if
1:51:16 they will spare it from them even depart
1:51:19 from the country the country for them
1:51:21 then they will collapsulated they will
1:51:22 not be able to do anything if the people
1:51:24 depart
1:51:25 this is the right medicine for for
1:51:27 aggressive and satanic governments just
1:51:29 general strike stay home the regime will
1:51:31 collapse no regime can survive
1:51:33 but if all people comply unfortunately
1:51:36 people do not comply so the medicine is
1:51:37 not effective
1:51:39 he gives you a medicine if it should be
1:51:41 taken right those you don't take it
1:51:44 I understand
1:51:45 is is this I am very doubtful that is
1:51:49 really that's his real motivation
1:51:50 because there's water that I use that as
1:51:52 a reason not to attend Yuma because with
1:51:54 these bad imams I don't think so I think
1:51:57 the reason is that Hadith talks about
1:51:58 some types of courageous meaning and his
1:52:01 beloved possibly but this is judging
1:52:04 intentions there are people who should
1:52:05 abstain from that with that could but we
1:52:08 in the case of because so many Hadith he
1:52:10 cut and mutilated just too expensive so
1:52:13 we have we have the right to doubt
1:52:15 really his intention but even the
1:52:17 argument he used is a faulty and so is
1:52:19 stupidity in the understanding even if
1:52:21 they're used to avoid Juma
1:52:28 the Hadith
1:52:29 what's that mean you had if they use it
1:52:31 what's the problem and they called
1:52:32 Hadith a bad Hadith and evil Hadith
1:52:36 and that's not one of the best you can
1:52:38 find in the whole world
1:52:40 Hadith until now
1:52:43 it's famous
1:52:48 himself
1:52:51 plenty
1:52:56 if he gets to hear them nobody he
1:52:58 doesn't hear them and when any of his
1:53:00 narrate these things he put cotton his
1:53:03 ears or he goes far away so he cannot
1:53:04 take it and is narrated by several of
1:53:06 his students
1:53:08 they think it's a virtue by the way you
1:53:10 get so blinded and admiring you Sheikh
1:53:14 that his blatant Falls become a virtue
1:53:18 in your life that's how how how
1:53:21 the devil can blind you
1:53:24 and how you could blind yourself by not
1:53:26 by choosing the right Imam you're right
1:53:29 Imam I write Imam should be the Quran
1:53:31 that should be your Imam
1:53:35 not anybody in the world
1:53:39 that should be your email and that's
1:53:40 what the father told her today for let
1:53:42 me asking about the previous so
1:53:43 therefore the specialist whatever
1:53:44 million is the specialist
1:53:47 yeah we know that he's The Specialist of
1:53:49 faithan so we asked about you said he
1:53:51 said to himself we will ask about us
1:53:53 about goodness how to build good and
1:53:55 they're asking about evil because they
1:53:57 want to avoid it I know evil will come
1:53:58 fit and will come there's no way that we
1:54:00 will stay in the high level of the
1:54:03 Prophet that's that's not the nature of
1:54:05 the universe this is a testing Universe
1:54:07 remember again this is not a paradise
1:54:09 that's where you are tested
1:54:11 they said with the time of the Prophet
1:54:13 but let's take a double private maybe
1:54:15 relatively easy and simple because you
1:54:18 have the unfaluable one protecting you
1:54:19 there and doing the job for you but if
1:54:22 he is gone there's nobody is there
1:54:24 so we're asking for this kind of
1:54:26 interview and yeah he asked after after
1:54:29 this child will be here and after every
1:54:31 question he asked
1:54:33 Davidson Allah saidifa is
1:54:39 will not benefit you what benefit you
1:54:42 learn the book of Allah and apply it is
1:54:45 better for you
1:54:46 three times then he said there will be a
1:54:49 filter like that we should face it
1:54:51 towards the time of backup that is then
1:54:53 he asked and after that there's a
1:54:54 fitness say yeah the heart will not be
1:54:56 as few as they were before
1:54:57 but before that he warned him three
1:54:59 times to learn the book of Allah and
1:55:01 that he asked his case then he said
1:55:02 something after that say yes
1:55:04 don't waste your time they'll be fitting
1:55:07 after Fitness
1:55:09 and apply it is better for you and then
1:55:12 he tells the next one
1:55:14 is insistent to get more knowledge about
1:55:17 the economic Fitness
1:55:19 is the fitness specialist but every time
1:55:21 he reminds him three times
1:55:23 don't waste your time with this this
1:55:25 will not benefit you benefit usual land
1:55:27 the book of Allah and apply it Allah
1:55:32 is better for you than this question
1:55:35 about Fitness so which will come because
1:55:37 the system of the world is going to work
1:55:38 like that going to grind everyone nobody
1:55:41 will escape
1:55:43 nobody will escape that's it until the
1:55:45 Dunya ends with that reward and the
1:55:48 sorting out not engineer
1:55:50 foreign
1:55:55 the whole Quran
1:55:58 learn it
1:55:59 and apply it will be better for you then
1:56:02 you will see the way
1:56:04 you don't need to have it behind but
1:56:09 you don't need anything
1:56:12 The Book of Life Is Enough
1:56:14 even in the miserable English
1:56:16 translations
1:56:18 even in that there's enough guidance
1:56:21 there to protect you all from utmost
1:56:23 extreme failure at least yeah maybe fine
1:56:26 issues of inheritance and things like
1:56:28 that need the most sophisticated
1:56:29 scholarship and the Hadith but will not
1:56:31 talk about that those are the major
1:56:33 things that we have today results in
1:56:36 cutting your neck and destroying your
1:56:38 life that's what it's about the problem
1:56:40 I have today is is because of Petro
1:56:42 dollars and building this kind of
1:56:44 narrative exactly yeah
1:56:46 let me just mention that I mentioned
1:56:50 to to give what has happened
1:56:54 we had a participated in the pilgrimage
1:56:57 I think in the year 91 or something in
1:56:59 1991 or 90 or something like that
1:57:03 and that here's something characteristic
1:57:05 happened is that
1:57:07 it was full
1:57:09 as usual in the recent 20 30 years the
1:57:11 places full
1:57:13 and then they have arranged things like
1:57:14 that and the police was blocking the way
1:57:16 inside Arafat
1:57:18 okay
1:57:19 some Turks you know the Turks are hot
1:57:21 blooded and stuff tough heads they came
1:57:23 and it was blocked
1:57:25 and I told the police we were to go in
1:57:27 Arafat and they stubborn they don't know
1:57:29 that is full then you can extend outside
1:57:32 because you have to have a festival for
1:57:34 that okay fine
1:57:36 and they say it's Alpha is full they
1:57:38 don't know you are lying the Turks look
1:57:41 here there's guard there we can go there
1:57:43 ultimately
1:57:45 long talk short sense they came down
1:57:47 beat up the police remove the blocks and
1:57:50 entered
1:57:53 they get my military to do something so
1:57:56 the police got beaten up nicely that
1:57:58 time police
1:58:00 after Hajj we hear that story is under
1:58:02 what without percussions at the
1:58:04 discussion about that we were in a
1:58:06 gathering after Hajj we were in normal
1:58:07 clothing and everything
1:58:09 and the people say that I mean is in
1:58:11 this house of seriously let's go and see
1:58:13 what he said and he was talking about
1:58:16 various things trivia things the same
1:58:18 I'll call them stoning and so on before
1:58:21 you know the never-ending Australia I
1:58:23 stoned before this I did and they
1:58:25 settled by the prophet long ago he said
1:58:27 someone said a stone before slow take
1:58:29 say do no problem do no problem any
1:58:30 orders okay
1:58:34 so I want to say this is this is this
1:58:36 talk is is trivial
1:58:39 addressing
1:58:44 what has happened now
1:58:48 first of all blocking like that is not
1:58:50 appropriate there's no need to block if
1:58:53 Alpha become full the buses and the cars
1:58:56 will be will be backing up backing up
1:58:58 until the border of Alpha and then you
1:58:59 come and see everything back up nothing
1:59:01 can be done you have to stand there but
1:59:04 most people are ignorant that in that
1:59:05 case Arafat actually is extended
1:59:07 overflow
1:59:09 up to accommodating any number but the
1:59:12 people need a structure people like you
1:59:15 a massage like you should issues that
1:59:17 fight or with authority to solve this
1:59:19 problem so we don't get police breathing
1:59:20 or particular meeting and both of both
1:59:22 have lost their height the weight of
1:59:24 their Hajj by this violence is a
1:59:26 place who has a time of Peace not
1:59:28 violence
1:59:31 and also maybe you should advise The
1:59:34 Authority that they should disable the
1:59:35 police otherwise that's not problem to
1:59:37 treat like that when you say that
1:59:39 Authority a man I don't know him at that
1:59:42 time looks like
1:59:44 a lot without any abuse like a lot
1:59:49 smaller
1:59:50 the first impression in my mind that is
1:59:52 the rat not a human being
1:59:55 someone was asking about that he's told
1:59:58 before and God went back to stoning
2:00:00 before after learning some trivial
2:00:01 questions
2:00:03 that attention was diverted I heard you
2:00:06 this is celebrity by their dismissal
2:00:08 with this rat so after we left
2:00:13 who came and spoiled a meaty discussion
2:00:16 this is a little bit more meaty than
2:00:18 discussing High politics this is how to
2:00:20 extend Alpha how to manage the huge
2:00:22 numbers which is more worthy than uh
2:00:25 stoning before or after and so Before
2:00:26 Sunset after Sunset and so on it's valid
2:00:29 invalid should we repeat
2:00:30 she didn't know this this what you call
2:00:33 that say no this is
2:00:36 I knew him from writing before when I
2:00:39 wrote
2:00:40 a pistol about the coming of the forces
2:00:44 and argue that it's eligible to call
2:00:47 them for this collaboration of quit and
2:00:49 so on I had a result went around
2:00:51 at the time the regime was I think
2:00:53 that's the reason I think it was 91 or
2:00:55 92 that that happened the regime was so
2:00:58 weak and then the disgraced that they
2:01:01 didn't dare defend anybody so I got away
2:01:02 with this
2:01:03 but he responded in his in he made the
2:01:06 writing say definitely
2:01:10 defending against the attack of muradin
2:01:13 of the atheist meaning it is and his
2:01:16 theory by invoking the help of mushriki
2:01:20 that's his book and he says unless Ali
2:01:23 says as well we don't agree with him
2:01:24 which is that this is like this that so
2:01:26 he's mentioned by Crystal there so as
2:01:28 there was an interaction intellectually
2:01:29 before that and this was a that action
2:01:31 face to face
2:01:33 and after that nothing good we hear from
2:01:36 him
2:01:37 as a matter of fact there are very good
2:01:39 evidence I don't say it's an absolute
2:01:40 evidence only where I can't make an oath
2:01:42 on it but it's very strong from various
2:01:43 sources that they saw his name in the
2:01:46 so-called Messiah the list of salaries
2:01:49 issued monthly and he was listed I think
2:01:52 with the rhyme of uh major so on with
2:01:55 this with that Crown this one star two
2:01:57 star three star on the club I think it's
2:01:59 major I think major Captain something
2:02:01 like that in in the second police
2:02:04 so a man allows him to work as a spy
2:02:08 in a religion respiring is absolutely
2:02:10 prohibited I Leave You judgment about
2:02:12 him and this is called Scola
2:02:18 but this the other one is based on a
2:02:19 witness for someone who saw the Messiah
2:02:21 and I think the witnesses feels worthy
2:02:23 as well but I couldn't make an author of
2:02:25 that but the other things I have seen by
2:02:26 Android
2:02:29 the money says is
2:02:34 so it's paid by money
2:02:38 I can't I I cannot say anything at this
2:02:42 time
2:02:45 with the discussion with it and
2:02:48 diverting the issue is clearly that the
2:02:51 whole Markov of 15 they attend to
2:02:54 Scholars simple-minded or scale or or
2:02:56 coward scholar even if it means they're
2:02:58 covered he admitted himself publicly to
2:03:01 many people that is a God and he doesn't
2:03:03 that day something or even buzzer so
2:03:05 it's not a coward but it's weak it's
2:03:07 just a message
2:03:15 they attend to these Scholars and either
2:03:18 put stupid questions so they get all the
2:03:20 the session wasted for nonsensical
2:03:22 questions or uh or uh or they if there's
2:03:28 any immediate discussion happens then
2:03:30 they cross me with with the with the
2:03:32 nasty question to divert that attention
2:03:34 I just then deliver it it's intelligent
2:03:36 service work does not scholarly work
2:03:38 that's not people who think that they
2:03:40 will meet it when they Allah might be
2:03:42 questioned it doesn't look like that so
2:03:44 what they what they do is they they it's
2:03:47 red herricks basically red herring is
2:03:48 something of that distraction so another
2:03:50 one for example this fixation on bidder
2:03:53 this fixation on so for example Builders
2:03:56 are an interesting one so by them making
2:03:58 better or more today or for example is
2:04:01 another big one in terms of
2:04:03 um
2:04:04 it's based on their own beta of
2:04:06 definition of of uh of uh definition of
2:04:10 illa this is beta it's not a definition
2:04:11 of the Quran so they invented the
2:04:13 definition
2:04:22 then it becomes itself
2:04:25 honestly I'm creating definition as
2:04:27 there you can as a mathematician
2:04:28 mathematical definition as even a
2:04:31 scholarship you can't define something
2:04:33 division you give the correct definition
2:04:35 and so on but if we make that definition
2:04:38 declare is the deal that's the only way
2:04:40 to go
2:04:41 that's number one or
2:04:44 you you you're based on it something
2:04:46 within then this definition then become
2:04:48 a better
2:04:50 if if it's not a correct definition
2:04:52 according to the Quran it is then
2:04:54 created and then declared to be a dean
2:04:56 and worse if it is contradicts the Quran
2:04:58 like the illah is the God is that the
2:05:01 worship the deity is the things which is
2:05:04 worshiped
2:05:13 in chapter 7 8 9 and so on and uh that's
2:05:18 a clear heresy obviously a person can be
2:05:20 excused by ignorance or what it may be
2:05:21 so all of that is
2:05:23 declaring that touching the graves and
2:05:25 visiting the people in the grave and
2:05:27 asking them for this asking for them and
2:05:28 so on they claim that is
2:05:32 that that naming itself is because if if
2:05:36 that has any standing we would have a
2:05:38 Hadith or a Quran mentioning worshiping
2:05:40 a game anywhere there's none whatsoever
2:05:42 the only thing they are related on is
2:05:44 that a faulty narration in bukhari
2:05:46 allegedly
2:05:48 we have proven that is also but even if
2:05:51 it is not bus allegedly that a lot which
2:05:54 is mentioned
2:05:55 is a man who used to be doing elect
2:05:59 kneeing the door and making like like a
2:06:02 sweet or some dish and giving it to the
2:06:04 whole Jazz for free and then The Story
2:06:06 Goes that that after he died they
2:06:09 honored his grave
2:06:11 but according to the Quran
2:06:15 to say that even if it rabba said that
2:06:17 relying on some mythical stories of the
2:06:19 Arabic the Quran says clearly
2:06:25 from beginning with the end discuss
2:06:27 various issues and then comes to Allah
2:06:29 Allah are female deities and the Quran
2:06:33 is clearly from the beginning to end
2:06:35 nothing is female in that Surah
2:06:38 except Allah all these females and the
2:06:41 female deities clearly
2:06:44 and they are supposed to be the the
2:06:46 consort on the the the offsprings the
2:06:49 the daughters of Allah
2:06:51 ascribe daughters to Allah female why do
2:06:54 you don't like female girls
2:06:55 come why is Allah supposed to have
2:06:58 daughters and you are do not like
2:06:59 daughters
2:07:00 and the Quran rebook that in other
2:07:02 places but in this Surah Allah is
2:07:04 something female a female deity
2:07:07 so they took that 40 narration which is
2:07:09 not a Hadith from it who could being
2:07:12 wrong could believe this mythical
2:07:14 stories of the Allah
2:07:16 it's definitely fabricated against him
2:07:19 but assume is from him he took that and
2:07:22 structurally give the Quran Islam on the
2:07:24 face
2:07:29 taking even though that's the old thing
2:07:32 ever in that all Narrative of Quran and
2:07:34 Sunnah and narrative about the Arabs
2:07:36 behavior and so on which it talks about
2:07:38 Graves and honorary grave all the
2:07:40 natives about honoring graves in the
2:07:43 Arabia area is only that the grave of
2:07:47 tribal shifted is regarded as a refuge
2:07:49 if you go there then the sons of the
2:07:51 tribal shift 10 will protect you from
2:07:53 any prosecutor so it's like like a like
2:07:55 have a sanctuary has nothing to do with
2:07:57 anything worse with it
2:07:59 and even some people thought if we get
2:08:01 buried the prophet is not discuss how
2:08:03 we've created him outside in in bhakia
2:08:06 outside our control someone who have
2:08:08 committed a crime may come and said hold
2:08:10 in the grave say you cannot touch me I
2:08:12 mean Sanctuary so we bury him rather in
2:08:15 the machine which is continuously under
2:08:16 our supervision that's one of the
2:08:18 discussion made in the death of his
2:08:21 death and was the reason they made it in
2:08:23 the Masjid or in the house of Aisha
2:08:25 which is next to the Massachusetts under
2:08:26 control nobody will will abuse it
2:08:28 because the house of action who can
2:08:29 enter is Haram to enter she's under
2:08:31 hijab so that that excluded so that's
2:08:34 the Habit that I don't know about grapes
2:08:36 and the famous gravey would you like
2:08:37 that the grave of tamim and maybe two or
2:08:40 three Graves were known to be Sanctuary
2:08:42 for someone running away taking
2:08:44 protection has nothing to worship
2:08:45 anything
2:08:46 someone taking just a sanctuary's
2:08:48 protection like nowadays some people run
2:08:50 in certain countries which have respect
2:08:52 for the churches
2:08:54 there are in the church and at the
2:08:56 moment in the church nobody will pursue
2:08:57 him inside they're waiting for them
2:08:58 outside to come some countries still
2:09:00 have this tradition and some Muslim has
2:09:02 that for the Masjid
2:09:04 unfortunately it's not very common for
2:09:07 the Muslims for the holy Sanctuary
2:09:09 should be like that
2:09:10 by very prophetic injection
2:09:13 I think so this is true that's all
2:09:15 what's there about grapes so from this
2:09:17 from nothing exhale you they created
2:09:19 deity and worshiping Graves and
2:09:22 declaring 85 percent of Pakistani are
2:09:24 Railway and barely worship Graves and
2:09:26 their Muslim craft
2:09:29 for example to attack the Ottomans and
2:09:31 all this kind of stuff but partly
2:09:33 because of that yeah
2:09:35 also and the other thing is about um
2:09:37 using this issue of bid up maybe someone
2:09:40 looked at it it's also being used right
2:09:43 this moment in time to not discuss with
2:09:45 them so for example
2:09:47 um
2:09:48 this is an open forum and it's actually
2:09:50 open to anyone we've this anything that
2:09:54 comes out of this we are willing to have
2:09:56 open discussions on Zoom with anyone
2:09:59 everyone bring it on
2:10:00 they won't allow you in their forums
2:10:03 yeah but what I'm saying is establishes
2:10:06 following bid out again is that
2:10:07 listening to them study and the Deviant
2:10:09 may may spoil your heart and get you to
2:10:12 become whatever like him so the best
2:10:14 thing is to do like the people of new
2:10:16 when they treated no way put put plugs
2:10:19 in their ear and cover their clothes
2:10:21 like this
2:10:31 plug your ears under
2:10:34 which is the opposite of the Quran it
2:10:36 made an injunction to everyone
2:10:40 of understanding and insight they listen
2:10:43 to everything anyhold any statement
2:10:46 and they follow the best out of it they
2:10:48 recognize what is true what is good and
2:10:50 check the other one the only thing
2:10:52 prohibited is only one place and
2:10:55 reminded in Madina shows in accident
2:10:56 Mecca if you see they are sitting and
2:11:02 rejecting and mocking rejecting
2:11:05 the right way foreign
2:11:18 but not if the eyes of Allah and this
2:11:20 Revelation are being mocked
2:11:29 okay then we discussed with algorithm
2:11:32 but not very smokery then it has become
2:11:35 the the comedy session well
2:11:37 entertainment that's cannot be Quran and
2:11:39 Sunnah and Allah and his messenger are
2:11:41 often with entertainment
2:11:42 absolutely what is that where did they
2:11:44 come up with this don't sit with them
2:11:46 all this I mean it's it's sustainable
2:11:48 scholarships that's what they're in the
2:11:50 Quran Quran says listen to every talk
2:11:53 if you are man of reason
2:11:54 or you say I am not having enough loop I
2:11:57 will not listen
2:11:58 I'm not able to select but saying is
2:12:00 prohibited you don't do don't sit with
2:12:02 that and they even this scholar said we
2:12:04 are not going for example
2:12:10 they said I'm not going to give him a
2:12:11 platform to spread his bit out to the
2:12:13 whole of the world
2:12:15 relying on what some scholar and time
2:12:17 passed Ahmad will happen so you don't
2:12:19 say to each other don't discuss with
2:12:20 them a reality he knows deep inside that
2:12:23 he will not be able to win any debate
2:12:24 with khaliliary from the debate
2:12:28 they invented that this is an invasion
2:12:30 invented I think one started inventing
2:12:33 this way way of thinking and this advice
2:12:35 is the second generation like people
2:12:38 like ayubus diani and so on
2:12:41 Hadith
2:12:48 to the tune that one of the students he
2:12:52 had heard that our one famous
2:12:55 full of Nations
2:13:01 from Amish which
2:13:04 is
2:13:06 so he went to Obama and I told him
2:13:08 listen I hear that you collected the
2:13:10 Hadith from
2:13:12 from Amish can I take a look to them so
2:13:14 you say yes and he took the Hadith and
2:13:16 follow them in the in the oven burning
2:13:18 them what would you like to take
2:13:20 someone's work and burn it in the oven
2:13:22 and to add inside to injury
2:13:24 someone else
2:13:26 I'm not sure which one or both of them
2:13:30 what they did who did that but I did is
2:13:33 the right or wrong says he did right you
2:13:36 should do the same
2:13:48 you are doing well so they encourage
2:13:51 people to take other people who are
2:13:52 writing and box and burn them
2:13:57 foreign
2:14:16 Ty that's that's his behavior a
2:14:20 narration is no doubt about that he is
2:14:22 but anything else
2:14:25 any reasonable point of view in a
2:14:27 rational discourse is nil
2:14:30 so you could be very well first class in
2:14:32 a narration and the exactness
2:14:35 until in any understanding
2:14:38 I'll give you a simple example
2:14:40 take a recording device MP3 recorder and
2:14:43 record our discussion it will recorded
2:14:44 more metically than bukhari or anybody
2:14:46 in the world but ask a device to give
2:14:48 you an advice about the medical issue it
2:14:50 can't has no mind
2:14:52 you're being an excellent recorder does
2:14:54 not mean that you have any might
2:14:56 but have confused I think those Hadith
2:14:58 recorder on imams of Hadith
2:15:01 no they are not
2:15:03 some of their blatantly deficient to the
2:15:06 level of experimental retirement
2:15:11 also in terms of the setup I mean if
2:15:14 it's more of a solid than ever been
2:15:16 handled yeah technically unless there
2:15:18 isn't all of them or these of this
2:15:19 category the attacker hanifa declared to
2:15:21 be in narration week and in matter of
2:15:24 piety and then to be either deviant or a
2:15:26 kaffir
2:15:28 many of them have declarative
2:15:31 is much more serious I think
2:15:44 or a guardian or a supporter Ali is also
2:15:49 a supporter he said don't ask about that
2:15:51 and don't mention it again
2:15:54 instead of explaining him what is the
2:15:56 meaning that's not what the meaning the
2:15:58 Shia thinks well she's well structure
2:16:00 all but you need to go to the Quran and
2:16:01 scan what the meaning of that mawla
2:16:04 there may be seven eight ten minutes and
2:16:06 you can't exclude one and one by one
2:16:08 with meticulous exacting World which I'm
2:16:10 doing now at the moment
2:16:11 the only one remaining is that anyone
2:16:13 worthy of support and can is is the
2:16:15 messenger of Allah is if anyone is
2:16:19 supportive and and willing to sacrifice
2:16:21 and support them Allah which every
2:16:23 believer should be then he should do the
2:16:25 same for Ali
2:16:26 we should do it for every believer
2:16:28 that's Allah Allah everyday but the
2:16:30 alliance of Ali is a higher rank the
2:16:32 same like Alliance of the product the
2:16:35 same with the other Hadith said that
2:16:36 whoever insults are insulting the
2:16:38 prophet if I insult you this is the sin
2:16:40 no doubt about that maybe a lie maybe a
2:16:43 public history about you I saw this guy
2:16:45 with a woman which is not his wife
2:16:48 that's that's book done
2:16:50 doesn't it take you a photo of them but
2:16:52 if you do something through the prophet
2:16:54 or Ari then you get also then you become
2:16:56 a catheter because I have the same
2:16:58 protection from from insult like the
2:17:00 prophet because of the Hadith and this
2:17:02 Hadith also for example he could have
2:17:05 answered that if he had any break
2:17:07 she's unable
2:17:09 and she said I don't understand the
2:17:10 meaning let's go and ask somebody
2:17:13 at that time no no no don't don't talk
2:17:17 about that don't ask about that
2:17:19 covering up
2:17:22 I I know it is very hard for many people
2:17:24 to be shocked to hear that today about
2:17:26 the scholars and Imam I just don't know
2:17:28 what Jamal Ahmed hamburger and things
2:17:31 like that be shocked
2:17:33 because you have to get out of this
2:17:35 mindset the alma is now buffed at the
2:17:37 decline and the complete defeat and
2:17:39 finishing of the khilafa on the ground
2:17:40 now now we have to build clean
2:17:43 look at the foundation the foundation
2:17:45 which we have received over the
2:17:47 generation is definitely rotten
2:17:49 otherwise the building would not have
2:17:50 collapsed
2:17:52 so we have to clean that Rod but
2:17:55 solid iron hard
2:17:58 Granite hot Foundation I built on it and
2:18:01 this cannot go on without digging a
2:18:03 little bit and getting the belt out even
2:18:05 if it's painful
2:18:08 even if it's painful there's no
2:18:10 freelance you have to do it
2:18:12 as I would be being circular anyway let
2:18:15 me tell me just summary about the
2:18:17 current monthly and salafi live in
2:18:19 alhamdulillah may be obsessed and maybe
2:18:21 you have some some positive aspects for
2:18:23 this video was extremely anti-change of
2:18:26 sharia and things like that no doubt
2:18:28 about that let's assume that but these
2:18:30 guys they are only
2:18:34 in the protection of the job they have
2:18:36 no other job
2:18:38 they will be extremely hard to do with
2:18:40 any small violation or that if I think a
2:18:42 violation and they will be extremely
2:18:44 lenient liberal with the with the rulers
2:18:48 and because they cannot run away from
2:18:49 issue of cover boy because the agreement
2:18:51 of all Muslims although they will become
2:18:52 clever blatantly they try to get their
2:18:55 Rolexes but if it does everything and
2:18:58 even the publicly publicly they say for
2:19:01 example this is recently said even if
2:19:03 you see him in television publicly
2:19:06 doing sodomy and fornication
2:19:09 you still have to obey him
2:19:14 holikoff
2:19:16 even when I came in or record not saying
2:19:18 that if you see conference only you
2:19:19 cannot Rebellion but he said in a
2:19:22 question
2:19:23 ing the algeena regime by the way
2:19:26 he said
2:19:28 let's assume
2:19:30 an assumption Which is far away but this
2:19:32 assume the following assumption let's
2:19:34 assume he's cut about the ruler usually
2:19:37 the discussion was about the question
2:19:39 was about a general rule as after the
2:19:41 coup d'etat in the 90s but it applies so
2:19:44 everyone else
2:19:46 then
2:19:50 charge the hearts against him
2:19:53 meaning you should not tell the people
2:19:55 he's the recovery you should hate him
2:19:57 you should reject him Etc not even that
2:20:00 he asked why
2:20:02 why
2:20:04 essentially saying just to let it cover
2:20:07 and close your eyes leave it don't get
2:20:09 involved with that
2:20:12 even the conspiracy undis available now
2:20:14 the record is available and the videos
2:20:15 just before we did this I probably made
2:20:18 a very good point he sent me a message
2:20:20 said we should start calling them
2:20:21 secular celebrities
2:20:24 secular selfies yeah essentially because
2:20:27 essential because basically there is
2:20:30 nothing you can do or they can legislate
2:20:33 or a power they are as deviant from from
2:20:37 Islam with basic Foundation as Paul is
2:20:40 deviant from true Christianity Paul was
2:20:43 also a selfie in that sense and the
2:20:45 magically in that sense because he told
2:20:46 the people uh arguing with Qatar now
2:20:49 they take the Escape Route of Qatar
2:20:51 arguing he said that you you should obey
2:20:55 the Emperor who was Pagan at the time he
2:20:57 doesn't want to have a conversation with
2:20:58 the government
2:20:59 because he could not become an emperor
2:21:02 without Allah permission this obviously
2:21:04 appearing for qataria
2:21:06 and he is needed to establish the safety
2:21:09 of the Roses exactly what I want to say
2:21:11 um I'm an amount of security and that's
2:21:13 all what counts and the kingdom of
2:21:17 Christ is Otherworld in the next life
2:21:19 not here there's no Kingdom of Christ
2:21:20 here
2:21:21 because Christ has has announced the
2:21:24 kingdom the whole book is about the
2:21:26 gospel is saying about announcing the
2:21:29 kingdom the kingdom is near and so on
2:21:31 and the interpreted kingdom is
2:21:32 Otherworld reality the kingdom let me
2:21:34 give you an interpretation and people
2:21:35 may think about it the other side issue
2:21:38 as an important issue the kingdom he's
2:21:40 announced is essentially announcing
2:21:41 Muhammad or the Sharia will be
2:21:43 established and we will have will have
2:21:45 systems
2:21:46 essentially so the kingdom of God will
2:21:49 be on earth
2:21:50 the kingdom of the other word is
2:21:52 something yes it's not this word
2:21:54 but anyways of that that's the sport so
2:21:57 there are probably in Muslims like like
2:22:00 a deviant and
2:22:02 Christianity which the only one survived
2:22:05 since the third century reportage is or
2:22:08 even second century is is utter
2:22:10 deviation
2:22:12 and that is connected with attributing
2:22:14 divinity to Christ and things like that
2:22:16 which attacks our people more attention
2:22:18 but the reality the catastrophe happens
2:22:19 with this statement
2:22:21 that the kingdom colleges otherworldly
2:22:23 that the emperor Rules by by Allah's
2:22:25 permission even is only the creative
2:22:27 permission nobody should Rebel you
2:22:29 should submit should obey and listen
2:22:31 that's exactly probably in Christianity
2:22:34 is just like an icing on the cake
2:22:37 actually
2:22:38 in that example you gave him Abdullah
2:22:40 when he uh had that interaction with
2:22:42 with Saud and he's and just the fact
2:22:46 that he was prepared to relegate issues
2:22:49 of a person legislate more oppressing or
2:22:52 taking tax and just considering it not a
2:22:54 big deal is another early indicator of
2:22:56 this kind of hierarchy that they said
2:22:58 the motivation is he said as long as you
2:23:02 support me for the for for tahit he was
2:23:05 so obsessed that he's blinded of that
2:23:07 that's not the same like
2:23:08 systematically and theoretically and
2:23:11 found it as a structured argument in
2:23:13 books and publications
2:23:15 they they are acting like the yahoots
2:23:17 they are clearly when you say the
2:23:19 evidence is completely blind say oh this
2:23:22 is the sin and so on okay and another
2:23:24 another
2:23:27 in the future you will be the taxes I
2:23:29 think it's fabricated this Edition but
2:23:31 maybe that's what he came in his mind
2:23:32 and the other writer
2:23:34 gets what is his mind whatever
2:23:36 justification is just because of the
2:23:38 blinding of opposition that's different
2:23:40 than astruction Theory represented for
2:23:45 example one recent guy of them
2:23:47 foreign
2:24:00 that's what the ruling is excluded to
2:24:02 Allah the fundamental initial definition
2:24:05 the formulation maybe is given to the
2:24:08 prophets the application in court
2:24:10 judicial is left to the judges
2:24:12 application in executive branch is left
2:24:15 to the executive branch that's a type of
2:24:16 ruling a judgment and so on that's just
2:24:18 to clarify what we said about the
2:24:20 stupidity about there's the only ruler
2:24:24 is Allah Only Rule in that sense okay
2:24:26 this this meaning Allah is Ultimate
2:24:29 which is a fundamental Muslims one is
2:24:31 essentially the meaning
2:24:35 foreign
2:24:45 to give you a message from him
2:24:47 do don't do
2:24:49 know me don't know me
2:24:51 avoid this to do this
2:24:54 or just even present him you must know
2:24:57 that I have these attributes even if he
2:24:58 doesn't have any injunction just telling
2:25:00 you about the Divine media Divine wants
2:25:03 you to believe in that and appreciate it
2:25:05 at least
2:25:06 foreign
2:25:42 do you know what the title of the book
2:25:43 says
2:25:49 something extra
2:25:53 like like if you say the peak of the
2:25:56 mountain no the the base of my team
2:25:58 first but ignore the peak the peak does
2:26:00 not need to considered as if the peak is
2:26:02 not resting on the base
2:26:05 is
2:26:12 coming from Hakimi not from from and we
2:26:16 have a unique case which is purely
2:26:18 Hakimi has nothing to do with other
2:26:19 deity in the classical sense the circle
2:26:22 of people
2:26:23 because they dead legislate for
2:26:25 themselves that that that
2:26:27 cohabiting with male is permissible
2:26:29 that's it if you check the Old Testament
2:26:32 did they have any Idols no Quran does
2:26:35 not mention any
2:26:37 story after a lot from the beginning of
2:26:39 the end of the Quran I was surprised
2:26:42 when I noticed this thing a few years
2:26:44 ago so I said maybe I'm mistaken so let
2:26:47 me say I had it nothing about the Hadith
2:26:49 story let me check the Old Testament it
2:26:53 may be part of it to be fabricated but
2:26:55 at least the core of the story may be
2:26:56 correct and the whole story of a lot and
2:27:00 the people of lot
2:27:01 no Idols nothing absolutely nothing only
2:27:04 legislating that's what they desire
2:27:06 undermining hakimia
2:27:09 and there we speak English and they have
2:27:11 punished one of the most civil
2:27:13 punishment in history by volcanic
2:27:15 eruption Stone from heaven
2:27:18 so we have this head all other
2:27:20 prophecies like that mostly it's
2:27:21 hakeemia
2:27:23 which people don't recognize
2:27:26 even if around
2:27:27 when he ultimately after a long
2:27:29 discussion tells Musa
2:27:32 if you adopt another day at himself me I
2:27:35 will put you in prison I am the deity
2:27:37 I am the ruler
2:27:39 I'm the king of Egypt and the son that
2:27:41 he's the son of the god of the sun god
2:27:44 that's fine that's something
2:27:45 metaphysical but the reality of the
2:27:47 discussion is I am the king here and I
2:27:50 am the deity Here I Am the ruler here
2:27:54 that's being founded on being the son of
2:27:56 the sun god I suggest metaphysical but a
2:27:59 reality
2:28:00 my ruling is final not your God
2:28:05 like most other musician if you analyze
2:28:07 it carefully is that
2:28:10 it's going to hackamia
2:28:12 not to have another day it is also they
2:28:15 have they have I'm not saying they don't
2:28:16 have but the real a lot they'll not have
2:28:18 a lot
2:28:19 and he's mentioned the same stream like
2:28:21 other progress the same general
2:28:23 statement
2:28:27 and so just at the recommend this guy I
2:28:29 don't remember his name I think he says
2:28:30 maybe
2:28:31 someone called the thrah maybe or
2:28:34 another guy from there from the this
2:28:36 cohort
2:28:37 they
2:28:39 he said
2:28:41 it must be established then we discuss
2:28:43 Hakeem
2:28:45 why
2:28:47 Festival is still enforce the opposition
2:28:49 possibly he has also a televisioned
2:28:52 meaning prevention Graves and leveling
2:28:54 them down things like that and then we
2:28:57 discuss hatimia
2:28:59 ignoring that Hakimi is the peak at the
2:29:01 the spinal cord of the heat the brain of
2:29:04 the Heat
2:29:10 and that's what the circular discipline
2:29:12 Distributing circularism
2:29:15 let's say guys I'm not discussing these
2:29:17 two deities or something or or something
2:29:19 with wings flying they're not bothered
2:29:21 about that they say maybe maybe not one
2:29:23 God because
2:29:29 declaring good and evil is for us
2:29:31 that's it we are the sovereign
2:29:45 it gets really ridiculous because even
2:29:47 for example I have no Bayer to Saudi
2:29:51 Saudi if me my family every single one
2:29:55 of us were to beg we can't become Saudi
2:29:57 citizen yeah if I was to say my MBs is a
2:30:00 it's a scumbag
2:30:03 apparently that's despite the fact he's
2:30:06 not even my ruler how can I have a Bayer
2:30:09 saying that if they're saying that
2:30:11 because they think they're there because
2:30:13 the only one ruling by Islam and the
2:30:15 automatic and everyone I don't know what
2:30:17 how they structure that I have no idea
2:30:19 how they structure
2:30:20 but definitely leave that that one in
2:30:23 Saudi Arabia and have have have
2:30:24 nationality and so on that's the
2:30:27 definition of follows is faulty it's
2:30:29 definitely faulty we have we have
2:30:31 decided what college is we mentioned the
2:30:32 story of this mysterious man we have
2:30:35 mentioned the well I mentioned Hadith
2:30:37 then we should only one of them actually
2:30:39 but there are tons of them all of them
2:30:41 said
2:30:42 they read the Quran they don't digest it
2:30:45 they
2:30:46 they accept the the the uh the community
2:30:51 or the dean it's your the word Dean is a
2:30:55 community it can be the Adidas could be
2:30:56 having several meaning the word Deen is
2:30:58 not only a religion or a Creed no like
2:31:01 like an arrow exiting the the bow
2:31:04 and they kill the Believers and leave
2:31:07 the pagans that's what the underwater
2:31:10 said if I reach him if I find them if I
2:31:13 meet them I will experiment the people
2:31:14 about
2:31:15 and he's saying commenting on July
2:31:18 another story of this message
2:31:21 will establish nobody arguing about his
2:31:24 establishment told him Muhammad your
2:31:26 unjust in distributing some some gold
2:31:35 prohibited him from killing him and then
2:31:37 he commented that that's it
2:31:41 when if if I catch them when they come
2:31:43 out there's one in front of you now
2:31:45 that's not coming out even a messenger
2:31:47 you are unjust
2:31:49 plain and clear cover is not
2:31:53 um
2:31:55 is blabbering nonsense
2:31:58 if I live until I see them
2:32:01 then I'll exterminate them it's one of
2:32:03 them no when they come out with a sword
2:32:09 so obvious
2:32:11 I'm so plain but these people are just
2:32:13 mockery of the same human being
2:32:16 of Quran
2:32:20 just to bring it back to the current
2:32:21 events as well
2:32:25 several of these statements are
2:32:27 statement of copper and himself but they
2:32:29 were not declared them covered because
2:32:31 that a statement of covert can be
2:32:33 uttered by someone who is blind
2:32:35 who is mentally deranged who does not
2:32:37 connect things properly but if you
2:32:39 connect verbally and persist that he
2:32:40 become a cafe in his individual capacity
2:32:45 but the statements are statement of
2:32:47 course
2:32:48 which specific statements or these
2:32:50 statement they say
2:32:52 that evening
2:33:03 so it's effectively if knowingly there
2:33:07 is Messenger
2:33:15 told you stated and fighting the
2:33:17 community is treated
2:33:22 the the punishment views of wage war I
2:33:25 guess Allah is messenger that's the one
2:33:26 who depart the community and fight
2:33:28 they're the one who will be killed
2:33:37 the word is very Central for Muslims and
2:33:40 wakes memories of people are fighting
2:33:42 Alibaba without him and they're killing
2:33:44 them they play this game making
2:33:46 Association
2:33:50 but this is a classical trick by all
2:33:52 deviants and by all people who want to
2:33:54 spread and
2:33:55 a Mischief like for example when when
2:33:59 people are discussing for example
2:34:01 punishment for uh let's say for
2:34:03 fornication say punishing love Is Just
2:34:06 rename fornication into love
2:34:09 foreign
2:34:39 foreign
2:34:57 specifically said it's really
2:35:00 Way Off the Mark he for example this
2:35:02 brother Riyad did this this
2:35:05 um video where he's talking about
2:35:06 somebody who's declaring allegiance to
2:35:08 King Charles
2:35:09 and he explained how that's you know
2:35:13 um Allah Hakim etc etc and then and he
2:35:17 made the false correlation with that and
2:35:20 uh this this person makes me quieter
2:35:23 just for having that mentality and then
2:35:24 his brother for example by extension
2:35:26 says but they've never advocated this
2:35:30 this one this one I think this one
2:35:31 there's nothing inside there inside the
2:35:33 flame of Islam because you cannot you
2:35:36 couldn't say anything
2:35:39 what can I say I have a cognitive
2:35:41 security with King Charles I'm living in
2:35:43 the domain oh that guy I don't attack
2:35:45 him I don't kill his population he
2:35:48 doesn't attack me he doesn't take my
2:35:50 money and we're already but I'm not
2:35:52 alleged to him in the sense that if he
2:35:54 calls me to join the Army and fight with
2:35:56 that I'm obliged to do that
2:35:59 I don't I cannot have Allegiance I have
2:36:02 only a limited governance of security
2:36:03 there's that you could call that some
2:36:05 part of our regions but because of you
2:36:07 you need it for yourself protection
2:36:09 according to the island but
2:36:12 you must technically call it Allegiance
2:36:15 because you behave as if you are the
2:36:17 citizen who have allegiance to a genuine
2:36:19 citizen who have allegiance to the king
2:36:20 for example
2:36:22 but only that says
2:36:24 the the word Allegiance
2:36:26 only that sense if it means more than
2:36:28 that like analysis to a Muslim ruler
2:36:32 or fighting him
2:36:34 whatever foreign
2:36:54 definitions you have to stick to them
2:36:56 you cannot mix the Sharia upside down
2:36:59 you think you'll get away
2:37:14 and fought against him and drained some
2:37:16 of his resources he would have finished
2:37:18 the the munafar cafe
2:37:21 that's what in people's minds generally
2:37:25 so it brings Association which is
2:37:26 extremely negative foreign
2:37:40 because they have the protection they
2:37:42 don't kill me I don't kill them they
2:37:43 don't attack me they start to attack
2:37:45 them
2:37:47 just to clarify this video so this video
2:37:49 originally this brother was commenting
2:37:50 on a person who's an MP and he's making
2:37:53 the oath of Allegiance and then the
2:37:55 contention was about his use of the word
2:37:57 of translations
2:38:00 we have nothing to hide we have a
2:38:02 structural point of view with this
2:38:04 arguments
2:38:09 what you have here as a Muslim even if
2:38:13 you're born in Britain you don't have
2:38:15 you're not allowed as a Muslim to have
2:38:16 full Allegiance you have only a limited
2:38:18 one which is called the Covenant of
2:38:19 security
2:38:23 if you do them
2:38:25 you are breaking the Covenant of
2:38:27 security
2:38:29 that's not true
2:38:33 exiting from the ummah
2:38:36 I'm going back fighting it with the
2:38:38 sword that's exiting from not even even
2:38:42 not even fighting the ruler we have the
2:38:44 Hadith for example I'm saying Allah said
2:38:49 Allah said
2:39:01 and then he said except for three what I
2:39:04 said I knew that he must receive
2:39:05 Revelation remind him you have to
2:39:07 mention something
2:39:09 clarify
2:39:11 as accept naxos
2:39:18 foreign
2:39:24 foreign
2:39:48 and then you turn back and fight him
2:39:50 with your sword so even fighting with
2:39:51 the sword is not so God
2:39:52 okay
2:39:54 and then
2:39:56 that you exit the community and fight
2:39:59 the Muslim with your soul so even let's
2:40:00 talk Christiana
2:40:04 but not Nexus
2:40:06 so tell the people stop it your game is
2:40:09 over
2:40:10 it's exposed the Hadith are here and you
2:40:13 are working with them and will build all
2:40:14 their channels and all weddings and
2:40:16 exposing who played games with a Hadith
2:40:18 from the classical Scholars following
2:40:21 his either mischievously or stupidly or
2:40:23 being blinded by the ideology like Ahmed
2:40:28 militant having injunction about how to
2:40:31 confront bad rulers and so on they have
2:40:34 usually tell what to do when to fight
2:40:36 them or not that tale is usually cut and
2:40:38 then you find this in bukhari you find
2:40:40 the theory you find the theory find it
2:40:41 here but in the Muslims we'll exploit
2:40:44 that also
2:40:46 they remind me of the yehud you know
2:40:48 when they cover that exactly so they do
2:40:51 the following they will not work first
2:40:52 of all they write the book of uh books
2:40:55 with or writing and climates from Allah
2:40:58 so they they make definition and they
2:41:00 make a writing essentially and claim
2:41:02 that's exactly what what it is saying
2:41:06 we're just translating it is just in an
2:41:08 easy language for the people
2:41:10 essentially saying this is from Allah
2:41:12 essentially
2:41:20 in the appendix of it or the later part
2:41:23 of it it claims that after the Exile and
2:41:25 after the punishment Allah will make a
2:41:27 covenant would stay forever for Israel
2:41:28 everyone will be having we know this is
2:41:30 a fabrication
2:41:32 Covenant was not renewed and they never
2:41:34 stayed happy and the Roman came and
2:41:36 kicked their butt we know that so it's a
2:41:38 fabrication
2:41:41 so this is genuinely attributed to
2:41:43 Jeremiah
2:41:44 to that level is not possible in Islam
2:41:46 because Quran is protected and soon
2:41:48 enter that is protected but still some
2:41:50 of the fabricata had it
2:41:53 one of the publication we usually shami
2:41:55 follower of and so on an Antarctic
2:41:58 Hadith reported the decides for one day
2:41:59 shall we analyze it and present it to
2:42:01 everyone he says
2:42:08 audacity with the one who fabricated
2:42:10 this Hadith because
2:42:12 you meet Allah
2:42:15 you meet Allah and you see
2:42:18 our Lord
2:42:19 no injustices
2:42:22 told us that we should obey
2:42:26 we have the benefit and the reward for
2:42:28 obedience and the ruler will have the
2:42:30 punishment for their misdeed you say
2:42:32 they are right I'm going to do that
2:42:35 that's a blatant cover the fabrication
2:42:39 so we have that also because if you say
2:42:41 it Hadith is from Allah
2:42:46 did not list that David and they don't
2:42:48 know everything that had it out trust me
2:42:50 we're still better than some of the
2:42:52 scholars in time but you might yeah
2:42:56 secondly
2:42:58 taking things out of context
2:43:01 if you take things out of cutest then
2:43:03 you twist the word from its meaning
2:43:05 because in the context shows demeanic
2:43:07 if you take them out
2:43:10 or cut part of the context then you have
2:43:13 Twisted the meaning
2:43:24 both even in simple verbs and sentences
2:43:26 and in structured information by taking
2:43:29 something also contest and change the
2:43:31 wording
2:43:32 give me things that that's the declaring
2:43:34 these things which are not maybe they
2:43:36 are serious I'm not saying they're not
2:43:38 serious but they're not it's not the
2:43:40 word which is not for that
2:43:43 foreign
2:43:54 will become will become a salad
2:43:59 and then cover will enter
2:44:00 particular welcome donkeys will come
2:44:03 pigs will come everyone enter it will
2:44:05 come an urban Garden everyone can graze
2:44:07 there
2:44:08 Nicki Minaj will come which is happening
2:44:10 now Halloween exactly
2:44:12 exactly so
2:44:14 so that's that's they have this we have
2:44:16 these all these characters
2:44:18 from that
2:44:20 he won't you never films that Hadith you
2:44:22 will follow the the methods of the
2:44:24 previous people even if they go in the
2:44:26 lizard hall and then another narration
2:44:28 is nice reminisce by the way
2:44:32 another one even if one of them have
2:44:34 ornicated his mother publicly you
2:44:37 someone of you will be doing that so
2:44:39 mention
2:44:40 the extent but he mentioned
2:44:43 is Visual and extreme so that everyone
2:44:45 understand even the symbols between they
2:44:47 would not have said if they would have
2:44:49 changed the Quran or changed words and
2:44:51 so on That's So too sophisticated but
2:44:53 there's example is clear if someone even
2:44:56 committed Zina with his mother publicly
2:44:59 someone of you will do the same you will
2:45:00 follow them
2:45:02 say yes in another narration he
2:45:05 mentioned president and the Romans most
2:45:07 like in matter of statecraft are running
2:45:09 the state
2:45:11 just to tell the future no to warn
2:45:15 blade don't follow their ways
2:45:18 keep distance keep
2:45:21 watching cautiously and ridiculously
2:45:24 don't fall in these traps
2:45:26 but the people decided to not listen
2:45:30 unfortunately because this is a domain
2:45:33 of testing
2:45:35 but does not justify that even instant
2:45:39 we ought not have done that and you will
2:45:41 be asked for that and you'll be
2:45:42 accounted for that
2:45:46 so it's really almost like the Jews and
2:45:48 also in other aspect like faculty
2:45:51 going extreme and piety abstaining upon
2:45:54 things which is just fearful and so on
2:45:58 creating things without evidence and so
2:46:00 on calling it being prior to you
2:46:04 avoid this this is suspicious this is
2:46:06 suspicion yes if you don't know about
2:46:07 something that's suspicious
2:46:09 but you have no certitude yes but in
2:46:12 itself there's nothing an unknown
2:46:18 maybe for an individual like the Hadith
2:46:20 famous Hadith
2:46:21 and this is between things which may be
2:46:24 confusing for certain people if it's
2:46:26 conclusion for you then avoid it but
2:46:30 for Scholars should not be should be
2:46:32 able to sort the confusion and then
2:46:34 guide the general public about the
2:46:35 confusion not the opposite I'd add
2:46:37 confusion to them to misguide them and
2:46:40 to benefit their oldest
2:46:42 my my statement is the most leader of
2:46:44 the Madrid are most likely monastic out
2:46:48 of the world of Islam unfortunately I
2:46:50 have to say that the followers are blind
2:46:52 idiots
2:46:54 the Sebastian can say about them
2:46:56 otherwise they will be covered
2:46:57 no it's better to be an idiot I don't
2:46:59 care that to be a couple in my
2:47:01 perception at least I don't know what
2:47:03 you'll taste in that but everywhere
2:47:05 thousand to be a donkey and to be
2:47:06 approved
2:47:09 a supposedly a stupid innocent animal
2:47:14 s
2:47:16 having read um gone to two-thirds of it
2:47:19 it destroys all of this honestly it's in
2:47:23 Arabic and Sergeant Libman
2:47:25 yeah
2:47:29 just a footnote and clarification
2:47:33 because I must have Hadith in that area
2:47:35 most not all are ahead
2:47:37 and I wouldn't go and say something
2:47:39 fundamental just when I had although
2:47:42 some of them are really the level of
2:47:43 motivated
2:47:47 and the reasoning is profound I saw the
2:47:49 all the all the all the discussions
2:47:53 please uh you and the other shabab
2:47:55 should uh accelerate and can completing
2:47:57 the review of that translation
2:48:00 and hopefully this will be because I
2:48:02 think the English reading public is is
2:48:04 more more sophisticated and more willing
2:48:06 to read than the Arabic public
2:48:07 unfortunately we have our book of
2:48:09 hakimiya in the market now
2:48:12 I would have an edited version coming a
2:48:14 more polished one inshallah but the one
2:48:15 is for 20 years
2:48:17 it doesn't seem to have anybody bothered
2:48:19 about really reading it or rebutting it
2:48:21 or or advising us about errors in it and
2:48:25 so on nobody unfortunately which is very
2:48:27 unfortunate so the at least the Arabic
2:48:30 section of the ummah is is
2:48:32 seemed to be in general in deep in deep
2:48:34 sleep snorling
2:48:38 they are like that mysterious man who
2:48:40 just say Sal hello and then proceed he
2:48:43 doesn't need to sit in a halaka he
2:48:44 doesn't need to make a book of massage
2:48:45 we have everything we have we have we
2:48:49 have us as the the people of Makkah say
2:48:51 we got the the wolf from its there why
2:48:53 we should model about something else and
2:48:56 this is the way of the downhill
2:48:59 the studies in many times I hear someone
2:49:01 wrote a book or something new in that
2:49:03 area I try to upload it and see it maybe
2:49:05 I did a new angle maybe he detected some
2:49:08 mistake in our link or something which
2:49:10 we will have overlooked and we have
2:49:12 corrected many things you see some of
2:49:13 our recent writing correct many other
2:49:15 all the mistakes which we were doing for
2:49:17 25 30 years thrusting some old driving
2:49:20 but then fine there's evidence
2:49:22 compelling evidence that it was wrong
2:49:24 and we corrected it
2:49:26 safely
2:49:30 most most significant one is that you
2:49:32 just mentioned that and then we will
2:49:33 conclude because I think we took a very
2:49:35 long time
2:49:36 most significant is the issue with when
2:49:38 where we're going today but the dash die
2:49:41 the Islamic State of your life before it
2:49:43 became Islamic State of Arkansas so it
2:49:44 was that he before it became daesh
2:49:47 that they can established state by
2:49:49 forceful and Foster People and buy and
2:49:51 all these things which is obviously
2:49:52 about it the principle of Surah the
2:49:54 principle of the authority of the ummah
2:49:58 they claim that we established the state
2:50:01 that the domain is empty so since we
2:50:03 established it we are the one who
2:50:04 created it we have to enforce it we
2:50:07 should have an Islamic State that's the
2:50:08 claim sounds very logical but that's not
2:50:11 the way I thought at the time that the
2:50:13 messenger established Islamic State and
2:50:15 the usual argument is
2:50:20 to show that he insisted that whoever
2:50:23 give him nusra
2:50:25 is is and people who have sufficient
2:50:28 Authority and self-protection like he
2:50:30 rejected those novels
2:50:32 because
2:50:35 although he has a high mountain and
2:50:37 massive fortification but his own people
2:50:40 do not seem to be giving support so if
2:50:42 you don't have support you don't have no
2:50:44 Surah your own people must must accept
2:50:47 that must be standing behind you and
2:50:48 behind me otherwise it's not so you
2:50:50 cannot enforce yourself from the people
2:50:52 and then during that study I noticed
2:50:56 that our perception is the stage as
2:50:59 healthy said of establishing state is
2:51:01 actually mistaken he was looking for
2:51:04 Nostra he was not looking for for
2:51:05 leadership and the Bay Area
2:51:08 the famous buyer which contained that
2:51:10 freso cover boy
2:51:13 actually enshrines that he is not a head
2:51:15 of state
2:51:16 and this is
2:51:18 established later as we have shown
2:51:21 inside Mr Medina
2:51:22 so he recognized this and they said
2:51:25 we were mistaken as that he was mistaken
2:51:28 the his thought was wrong we have to
2:51:29 collect it evidence is here
2:51:33 that's the reason if anyone writing
2:51:34 something in these areas
2:51:36 I tried to get the book
2:51:40 I'm trying to go through it as quickly
2:51:42 as possible maybe there's something new
2:51:44 maybe there's a new twist maybe there's
2:51:46 some deepening of a point
2:51:48 but these people are deciding no no no
2:51:50 no this is what they're there don't
2:51:52 treat them
2:51:53 they will never achieve anything okay
2:51:55 show us your reading of the Quran that
2:51:57 you have any depth
2:51:59 is completely
2:52:03 zero zilch nothing
2:52:08 I think we should conclude that but talk
2:52:10 about my manifestation is that
2:52:13 multiple people now according with the
2:52:15 party of the government or the
2:52:17 government party
2:52:24 and so on and these are people we know
2:52:27 there's intelligent Service agents these
2:52:29 are they are Traders and most likely I'm
2:52:31 sorry to say that but my personal I hate
2:52:33 use that term but for Ruby and this help
2:52:36 I doubt that they are in the fall of
2:52:38 Islam I think they are monarchy
2:52:40 the follower as I said again I still
2:52:43 think they are just blind
2:52:45 brainwashed idiots luckily so they are
2:52:48 not
2:52:49 but they're they're what they adopted
2:52:51 they think it's a statement of and they
2:52:53 should depart from that they should
2:52:55 study it and get rid of it
2:52:57 does not accelerate them that they are
2:52:59 stupid and because they're still having
2:53:01 enough human brain unless they don't
2:53:03 have a brain and they should they belong
2:53:05 with the mental institution not in the
2:53:07 YouTube I'm discussing with other people
2:53:09 if you are able to discuss with other
2:53:11 people you should be able to contribute
2:53:12 these things and go a little bit more
2:53:14 thoroughly than this rubbish
2:53:18 briefly so this was considered to be an
2:53:21 opening Salvo to people of uh Saudi ilk
2:53:25 and to assist people like brother rohaji
2:53:28 uh Mohammed hijab to basically destroy
2:53:32 this narrative and and give them a
2:53:35 better angle we said some of them are
2:53:36 still having some stains from the
2:53:39 wahhabi and madhali without they
2:53:41 noticing I made a commentary said yes
2:53:43 let me conclude that because they say we
2:53:44 conclude that just the final and we even
2:53:46 stop I I noticed uh that even they
2:53:50 translate there's no deity but Allah
2:53:52 there's no deity worth of Russia but
2:53:55 Allah and they made a comment in a video
2:53:56 of brother Muhammad hijab says stop this
2:53:59 translation because this transition go
2:54:01 to the falsehood that worship is
2:54:04 independently defined from deity no
2:54:07 worship is in his essential meaning as
2:54:09 we argue in the book to read even with
2:54:11 with Precision of mathematical equations
2:54:13 in chapter 7 I think we have the
2:54:15 discussed another informal mathematical
2:54:16 equations
2:54:18 to that level of sophistication
2:54:21 with the exact level of of work
2:54:24 is that worship meaning attributing
2:54:27 Divinity to something
2:54:28 its attribution of wind is worship it's
2:54:30 not standing or were lighting candles or
2:54:33 charity or Salah and so on you could
2:54:36 glean that if there's someone a little
2:54:37 bit of brain and go deeper and the
2:54:39 statement Allah said about the long
2:54:41 discussion which is depicted in the Old
2:54:43 Testament between Allah and Musa it's
2:54:45 summarizing the Quran very precisely
2:54:47 because there's no need for that long
2:54:49 discussion at that time it was needed
2:54:51 because even a Divine known was not
2:54:53 established yet and he mentioned what
2:54:55 the name used by Ibrahim and so on
2:54:57 that's all go and see it and then I
2:54:59 summarized that actually in the book of
2:55:01 David in the Quran summary
2:55:07 I am Allah now we have a Divine name so
2:55:10 no need to go about why h w what it
2:55:13 means Jehovah I am the one who is Ever
2:55:15 or things like that is all that Allah
2:55:17 going to contain all of that there's no
2:55:19 deity beside me
2:55:21 so what is worship
2:55:29 but we will usually as a player as
2:55:31 worship no
2:55:33 is All To Worship
2:55:35 meaning attribute all Divinity to me
2:55:37 there is no other deity just they
2:55:39 enforcing the word
2:55:41 this is a statement of fact
2:55:43 how it's reflects on your side does it
2:55:46 affect independent over here even if
2:55:48 Musa doesn't exist the holy resident
2:55:50 said there is no idea to beside Allah
2:55:52 but there is Hermosa
2:55:54 finite being with brain with
2:55:56 capabilities with understanding how
2:55:59 should he his his response to this fact
2:56:02 that there's only one deity is
2:56:04 acknowledging it and attributing the
2:56:06 deity only to Allah and rejecting
2:56:08 attribute to anybody else that's worship
2:56:20 The Human Side
2:56:22 worship only Allah it's the same thing
2:56:24 but seeing from the you see what I mean
2:56:27 from two sides
2:56:31 the side of the fact itself and how to
2:56:34 responds and deal with the fact
2:56:36 that's it Salah is certain acts in the
2:56:39 case of Musa is not like our accent
2:56:41 maybe we're like ours may be different
2:56:42 that's not a lot of the Jews maybe the
2:56:44 one we should have adopted Mouse I don't
2:56:46 know is standing in front of of
2:56:49 something and doing the famous movements
2:56:52 certain movies was the purpose of it is
2:56:55 it worship no
2:56:57 it is just to internalize and and
2:57:00 remember Allah because our mind cannot
2:57:03 be present by having Allah continuous
2:57:05 Impressions so you have to have certain
2:57:07 time in the day three times five times
2:57:09 no should
2:57:10 connect with him
2:57:12 to get the spiritual healing a spiritual
2:57:14 boost that's it so it's an enactment of
2:57:17 the command of the day Divine is
2:57:18 enactment that the the worship aspect of
2:57:21 the Salah is that you you do the Salah
2:57:23 the way you are ordered to do
2:57:25 Pleasant example
2:57:28 when Adam was created
2:57:31 He was ordered go in the world permitted
2:57:33 to do whatever he wants in the parade is
2:57:35 everything but do everything go naked no
2:57:37 no nothing like that only one command
2:57:40 don't touch this three
2:57:42 was he not Toshiba did not fulfill the
2:57:44 Pacific he didn't finish it
2:57:51 that's all that he and this is enough
2:57:53 that's a complete thing at the time
2:57:55 even
2:58:03 nothing at all except this one and still
2:58:05 he's a complete worshiper
2:58:07 and even a strongest point of view that
2:58:09 he was even a prophet
2:58:15 but he viewed that there's no date
2:58:16 except Allah he knew it and the
2:58:19 attributed all divisions to Allah
2:58:21 even in a simple way
2:58:22 like a great spirit of like the we see
2:58:25 by the Native Americans the great spirit
2:58:27 or by the native the native uh the
2:58:31 natives of Australia or the some Western
2:58:34 People claimed they don't have the
2:58:36 concept of God because the rest of you
2:58:38 are stupid they know they themselves
2:58:40 they have they have but they connect
2:58:43 with them through dreams and the
2:58:44 previous generations through mental
2:58:46 media experience but there's some some
2:58:48 overwhelming Universal spirit
2:58:50 and there's no other one that's it
2:58:52 that's all the way and they attribute
2:58:54 that to him that's the worship October
2:58:55 so he's perfectly washable
2:58:59 and has no other acts to do except that
2:59:02 one
2:59:02 that's all that ini has at this time
2:59:05 okay I think we overloaded that is none
2:59:08 and then we'll come back shall see what
2:59:09 people will come with and I hope we'll
2:59:12 see what will be the reaction which
2:59:13 questions will come and we address them
2:59:17 and that was supposedly you will have
2:59:18 done based on the question if we get
2:59:20 them early enough with what then I can't
2:59:22 give him Hadith about how to deal with
2:59:24 the rulers and so on like in the Arabic
2:59:27 version of black Arctic the rulers we
2:59:28 don't have it in English yet I think
2:59:30 said we did not start a translation
2:59:31 unfortunately I can summarize some of
2:59:35 them and give you how many it's not are
2:59:37 there just this number I will not read
2:59:39 that because this will be volume this
2:59:40 will feel easily a a reasonable size
2:59:43 volume I'll just give you that as a
2:59:45 complete is it is there is your draft
2:59:47 complete now
2:59:49 my husband will come
2:59:51 the old version is excellent but I'm
2:59:54 improving it and updating it
2:59:56 yeah there's no there's no translations
2:59:58 for that at the moment I said to the
3:00:01 translate to hold back because I think
3:00:03 we can do more substantial rearrangement
3:00:05 and Improvement and better study
3:00:07 obviousness
3:00:09 because that's why you know 20 years ago
3:00:11 she was very good by the way it's
3:00:13 relatively simple-minded it takes many a
3:00:15 Hadith at face value without discussing
3:00:17 their wedding more thoroughly was enough
3:00:21 but we discussed more slowly Things
3:00:22 become much sharper and would be more
3:00:24 damaging and destroying foreign
3:00:38 it undermined the meaning of Islam
3:00:40 you have it here folks
3:00:42 open discussions can be facilitated yeah
3:00:45 don't sit on this
3:00:46 Anytime Anyplace anywhere
3:00:49 it's on the ball's in your court
3:00:51 we will respond meaning
3:01:03 Music
3:01:14 foreign
3:01:15 Music
3:01:34 Music
3:01:44 foreign
3:01:47 Music
3:01:59 Music