0:00:09 foreign
0:00:12 Music
0:00:40 Music
0:00:43 welcome dear viewers brothers and
0:00:45 sisters to episode 114 of our Cafe
0:00:47 sessions of the noble Quran with
0:00:48 Professor Dr Muhammad Muhammad bin
0:00:52 Abdullah
0:00:54 these episodes are broadcast live on the
0:00:56 study Circles of Professor Dr Muhammad
0:00:57 YouTube channel every Sunday and please
0:01:00 note next week we will be changing to
0:01:02 1pm British summer time due to due to
0:01:05 changes in uh summer time to winter time
0:01:08 so that'll be 1pm UK time for everyone
0:01:11 else the time will remain the same
0:01:13 we invite you to subscribe to the
0:01:15 channel and activate the email for all
0:01:18 new content please note also the link to
0:01:20 the live broadcast for wider
0:01:22 dissemination do not forget to interact
0:01:24 with us during the broadcast by
0:01:25 participating in the comments and asking
0:01:27 a question through the chat box you find
0:01:28 via the broadcaster link next to the
0:01:30 video also do not forget to support our
0:01:32 activities by donating when asking
0:01:33 questions in the conversation or through
0:01:35 the thank you button
0:01:37 today is Sunday the 23rd of October
0:01:40 the doctor continues with the tester of
0:01:42 Surah al-anam we are starting a new
0:01:44 Surah from verse 1 so
0:01:48 and I will hand over to the doc now
0:01:53 because I
0:01:55 I did not open it yet
0:02:01 correctly
0:02:04 so now the end of my
0:02:07 go down
0:02:13 yes for this another now
0:02:19 so we similar man or him
0:02:23 foreign
0:03:01 I have 6 0 6 1 all praise is due to God
0:03:07 who has created the heavens and the
0:03:08 Earth and brought into being deep
0:03:10 Darkness as well as light and yet and
0:03:12 yet those who are bent on denying the
0:03:14 truth regard other powers as their
0:03:16 sustainers equals next translation
0:03:19 livestock praise be to God who created
0:03:22 the heavens and the Earth and made
0:03:24 Darkness and Light for the unbelievers
0:03:26 regard others as equal to their lord
0:03:30 so this is not very much document except
0:03:32 few fine points I don't want to go into
0:03:34 this it's a philosophical fine points
0:03:36 excessively for the general public is
0:03:37 not there but it's a bit for for the
0:03:41 people who are more inclined to logic
0:03:43 philosophy and metaphysics a little bit
0:03:46 so it sprays obviously to Allah and this
0:03:49 is using this the Divine name in Arabic
0:03:51 and in Arabic by the way I'm just says
0:03:55 several times like this one stupid
0:03:58 American say the the Muslims they have a
0:04:01 Masjid here where they pray to Allah
0:04:03 Allah not to the Lord
0:04:06 I've got this simple-minded idiot does
0:04:09 not know that the name the Divine name
0:04:11 also in Aramaic who shows used by uses
0:04:13 of Allah same thing but ignorance is a
0:04:16 bliss sometimes so anyway so praise to
0:04:19 Allah
0:04:20 as I said obviously the initially in the
0:04:23 time of the total Revelation when Musa
0:04:25 was addressed
0:04:26 he asked Allah specifically which name
0:04:29 should I use to describe you to that
0:04:31 there was no specific name for the
0:04:33 Supreme related
0:04:34 was so widespread that some sometimes
0:04:38 there's no Supreme deity or there's no
0:04:40 Supreme deity with various names
0:04:42 under the in the Old Testament it says I
0:04:44 was known to your grandfather Ibrahim
0:04:46 was
0:04:47 a strong God but if the people ask you
0:04:50 to tell them
0:04:51 he who is he the one who is the one who
0:04:54 exists the one who is necessarily
0:04:56 existing so Jehovah is actually he who
0:04:59 is he
0:05:00 I am the one I am the one who ever
0:05:03 existing so this is the Divine name
0:05:05 Allah we mentioned that so many times
0:05:07 let's go to the beginning of the Soul so
0:05:09 please do this who is he to Allah who
0:05:12 created heavens and death that's the
0:05:13 standard phrase the surround the
0:05:16 universe and what's in there in there
0:05:17 and then interestingly
0:05:20 and made Darkness and Light
0:05:24 the philosophical remarks that some some
0:05:26 people are simple-minded materialistic
0:05:28 really think okay darkness is the
0:05:30 absence of light so it should not be
0:05:33 made somehow light may be made so it's
0:05:37 the existence of light the presence of
0:05:39 photons if we want to use physics
0:05:41 language and so on but absence of
0:05:43 nothing of absence of light but still
0:05:45 darkness is attribute to the space which
0:05:48 does exist before which has no light in
0:05:51 it and that's that that entity is is
0:05:54 created it's it's made it is not before
0:05:57 creation even said there was nothing
0:05:58 there was no space and no Time and Time
0:06:00 started by the Divine activity and space
0:06:03 we will come to space in a few moments
0:06:05 with The Oddities of issue of space as I
0:06:08 said I will not go very deep in these
0:06:10 things because it may be disquieting for
0:06:12 many people and disturbing but you
0:06:15 cannot avoid especially with the with
0:06:17 our friends the salafi is standing on
0:06:19 the doors when you said asking the poor
0:06:21 symbol Pakistani who is Allah until he
0:06:23 says foreign
0:06:34 things like that the issue related to
0:06:36 space
0:06:37 and time time we settled out and
0:06:40 discussed out of the initial of Qatar
0:06:42 and so on and we we said the the
0:06:44 prophetic definition of time uh is is
0:06:47 the correct one as as explained by him
0:06:50 when when the famous Hadith which I
0:06:52 mentioned the authentic very strong
0:06:54 Hadith although it's a single Hadith but
0:06:56 because it's meaning and there's
0:06:57 synchronization of the Quran and with
0:06:59 the necessity of Reason make it really
0:07:01 uh an authority in itself otherwise a
0:07:04 single Hadith a single narration cannot
0:07:05 be an authority which you have to be
0:07:08 also absolute firmness but this is also
0:07:11 it's quite amazing because that's
0:07:12 concept does not exist in the previous
0:07:14 scripture nor was known to that time so
0:07:16 it's an unconceivable
0:07:19 would have taken it from the view of the
0:07:22 book like in some other places which we
0:07:24 can speak on it nor it is possible that
0:07:26 he would have speculated and invented
0:07:28 that it's just out completely odd and it
0:07:30 says that it begins innocently the son
0:07:32 of Adam hears me or insults me by saying
0:07:36 what a miserable time okay
0:07:40 but then the next next part as we
0:07:43 mentioned earlier and when we came to
0:07:45 that issue of the show of time and so on
0:07:47 he said I am the time actually I am a
0:07:51 Dar is more than just a time it is the
0:07:54 passing of the time the eons I am a
0:07:56 darling
0:08:00 day or night which we use as humans for
0:08:04 time keeping and clock keeping and so on
0:08:06 with my command with my decisions so my
0:08:10 decisions my commands my creative
0:08:12 activities is that what what for that
0:08:15 example hence they are not initiate
0:08:17 anything happening in the universe and
0:08:20 and I am the time I'm the one who would
0:08:22 invest I mean I have the time it's not
0:08:23 the time like watching the clocks
0:08:25 naturally that's not this is something
0:08:26 an obstruction of of a measurement no
0:08:29 but the passage of time the kick
0:08:31 starting of time is nothing than
0:08:33 expression of dinner for in a bit of
0:08:35 Physical Realm is a in our realm the
0:08:37 expression of the Divine our action and
0:08:41 The absoluted Sovereign Free Will
0:08:43 absolute spontaneity and we we mentioned
0:08:46 casually Steve Hawkins with his struggle
0:08:48 with the in his uh A Brief History of
0:08:51 Time and trying to to get time to emerge
0:08:54 suddenly a state of which is timeless
0:08:56 which we can make what eternity in which
0:08:59 only space existed which is again
0:09:01 privacy but let's assume it's existed
0:09:03 and then he did something which flip one
0:09:05 of the state space axes into time which
0:09:08 is Manifest three episode because the
0:09:10 one the things he proposed to flip it he
0:09:13 calls it the quantum fluctuation Cloud
0:09:15 confrontal equation by definition are
0:09:16 defined only in time they cannot exist
0:09:19 outside time so how come a fluctuation
0:09:21 which needs time create time this is
0:09:24 damn sense I should have said
0:09:26 a spontaneous Act of summary and will
0:09:29 which cannot explain further that it is
0:09:32 like that it is an act which is
0:09:34 absolutely spontaneous and Sovereign of
0:09:38 an entity we call it quantum fluctuation
0:09:40 or whatever you call it it's cheating
0:09:42 it's it's actually ideated that's the
0:09:44 division of a deity it's absolute civil
0:09:47 absolutely similar an acting entity
0:09:50 our initial is not acting by the by by
0:09:52 by Free Will and a choice is acting by
0:09:55 necessity
0:09:56 if you think if something like that
0:09:58 exists because nature can seems to be
0:10:00 that a necessarily existing being
0:10:02 maybe was unwelcome such a proof for now
0:10:05 for years but uh until now the problem
0:10:07 is not complete is that from the concept
0:10:09 of necessarily existing uh entity which
0:10:13 has no free will which is something we
0:10:16 can all necessary of either deity or a
0:10:18 nature such a nature cannot act so
0:10:21 claiming that we have either for
0:10:23 necessary existing beings either acting
0:10:25 by necessity which we can call nature or
0:10:27 acting by absolute freedom Sovereign
0:10:30 freedom unconditioned uh it was called
0:10:33 the deity uh this this is the necessary
0:10:37 division between these two is good as a
0:10:39 necessity but then it must be possible
0:10:42 to prove that the first category can't
0:10:44 exist as an internal contradiction so a
0:10:46 necessary existing being if it acts it
0:10:48 must be by absolute civilian Free Will
0:10:51 and not by and that's implicated it has
0:10:55 knowledge it has will it has power all
0:10:56 of these things which that will be less
0:10:59 something like an ontological proof of
0:11:00 God but we have the proof obviously we
0:11:03 shared the well-established room fees of
0:11:04 of tuning and fine tuning that's that's
0:11:07 sufficient that's sufficient for that
0:11:09 better but it would be intriguing to
0:11:11 develop with feather into ontological
0:11:12 proof because that's the well-known
0:11:15 anthological claimed roof of Santa
0:11:18 Anselm is obviously faulty it's not
0:11:20 persuasive as we know it has been
0:11:23 discussed over the centuries and proven
0:11:25 to be faulty
0:11:26 it's not abroad
0:11:28 uh because it it makes existence as a
0:11:32 tribute it's not necessarily as a mode
0:11:33 it's not there's a more than a more than
0:11:36 uh more than extra more than uh uh
0:11:39 concept and not alert and attribute so
0:11:42 it cannot the problem fails on this
0:11:45 ground otherwise would have been a
0:11:47 beautiful growth indeed
0:11:48 so that's the concerning time concerning
0:11:51 space
0:11:52 uh we will come into it but so Darkness
0:11:57 and and light I Was Made because
0:11:59 Darkness meaning a space which devoid of
0:12:01 photons and so on but that's that space
0:12:03 is is obviously have to be created
0:12:06 before or under the moment of the Big
0:12:09 Bang You're gonna talk about darkness
0:12:10 and uh and which way you can say it's a
0:12:13 well-established Beyond any approach
0:12:15 that this universe at least started with
0:12:18 the with the singularity and after
0:12:20 similarity we have a time where light
0:12:22 could not uh separate from matter and
0:12:25 the dark phase that's the darkness and
0:12:27 maybe this hinted in the Quran because
0:12:29 it starts with the rulomat and the light
0:12:31 comes after that then
0:12:33 than a certain moment in the after the
0:12:37 huge initial hyperinflation inflationary
0:12:40 phase later than actually millions of
0:12:44 years later I think my remember
0:12:46 correctly but anyway quite later because
0:12:48 the hypothered relational effects is
0:12:50 only micro seconds or milliseconds but
0:12:52 later on the light decoupled through
0:12:55 method and then we start we start having
0:12:57 then the background radiation which we
0:12:59 which is light it's a form of light
0:13:01 initiate was extremely bright light even
0:13:04 even to the X-ray level but to the
0:13:07 external of the universe it was shifted
0:13:09 redshifted for further and further to
0:13:11 microwave level so it's not visible for
0:13:13 us otherwise the sky would have been
0:13:15 very bright may have been bright a few
0:13:17 million years after the the decoupling
0:13:19 but after that it has became dark and
0:13:22 then we don't see this this background
0:13:25 radiation it is being seen now alsoever
0:13:27 in the telescopian being recorded and
0:13:30 analyzed and so on and we have we have
0:13:32 that background relation to thank for
0:13:35 considerable information about the
0:13:37 moment of the coupling and also the
0:13:38 before because the decoupling happened
0:13:40 that but the development before can be
0:13:43 studied theoretically various models can
0:13:45 be put forward and then from these
0:13:47 models we can compare them with that
0:13:50 what we observe in the black so-called
0:13:52 by background radiation and any model
0:13:55 which does not fit will be checked out
0:13:57 and then other models will prove
0:13:59 themselves and then will be refined and
0:14:00 so on at this ongoing is ongoing and
0:14:03 this latest
0:14:04 and the the James Webb James telescope
0:14:09 the one who just started recently a few
0:14:11 months ago is one of his main function
0:14:13 is really true to uh to settle some of
0:14:17 these issues although it's mostly
0:14:18 looking into in the infrared Spectrum
0:14:21 but it will have a certain import on the
0:14:24 issue of our current radiation and the
0:14:27 issues of the earliest or some things
0:14:29 like that but that's as I said that's in
0:14:33 progress but we can say that the Big
0:14:36 Bang user
0:14:38 is is done and dusted and the only
0:14:42 attempt challenging theory is the theory
0:14:44 of Penrose of the ever cycling Universe
0:14:46 it's it's manifestly absorbed it's
0:14:48 internally contradictory whatever
0:14:50 experiment shows anything he thinks the
0:14:52 experience May hint something like that
0:14:54 but even that clearly has been even
0:14:57 ruled out most of it there may be still
0:14:59 some issues here there's small issues
0:15:01 but they are essentially ruled out by
0:15:02 the observation and the observation is
0:15:04 the is the ultimate reference that what
0:15:06 we observe and we verify and compare
0:15:09 with theories that's what that's the
0:15:11 mean that's the meaning of science
0:15:12 science is based on either controlled
0:15:14 experiment or welcome well well
0:15:17 repeatable observation like issues with
0:15:19 a universal expansion and and the
0:15:22 various constants related to that
0:15:24 so there might be a hint when you say
0:15:26 the Quran States
0:15:27 Darkness and Light mentioning Darkness
0:15:30 ahead of light
0:15:32 but it is made both are made but the
0:15:34 darkness as before may be hinting
0:15:36 through the face before the decoupling
0:15:38 of the radiation from Mata and then
0:15:41 we start seeing
0:15:45 that light from the the faint light
0:15:48 remaining from that time but it has been
0:15:50 so weakened and redshifted because of
0:15:52 the expansion until now it is now in the
0:15:54 microwave range but as well established
0:15:57 this is not a mental dispute that this
0:15:58 is like that the only method of dispute
0:16:00 is that is this big bank is the
0:16:02 singularities that the absolute
0:16:04 beginning or is that after a crash of a
0:16:07 previous universe and it's not absolute
0:16:09 beginning and according to belrose clamp
0:16:12 you know is that a previous one and
0:16:13 especution due to a previous one
0:16:16 previous one and so on and this is
0:16:17 manifestly absorbed this contradictory
0:16:19 this can be proven to be contradicted
0:16:21 that's impossible although it it it it
0:16:24 is essentially in in walking or working
0:16:27 with the with the Hindu model of the
0:16:28 universe the ever recording universe but
0:16:30 this is also manifestly impossible and
0:16:33 absurd cannot be the case
0:16:35 but this is a more complicated proof
0:16:37 about infinite regression and other
0:16:38 things like that
0:16:40 so that's and then uh because here it's
0:16:43 a second Ayah but that's part of the eye
0:16:44 and that's right there and despite of
0:16:47 that I spread displays and this fact
0:16:49 which should become for anyone who
0:16:52 enlightens a look in the universe
0:16:53 obviously at that primitive level of the
0:16:56 previous time they will look at just a
0:16:58 symbol looking around
0:17:00 and they may not figure why is the
0:17:02 volume at Mission before North Darkness
0:17:05 this is all just a hint for the future
0:17:07 not for the people but they understand
0:17:09 they the night is dark and that the day
0:17:12 is having light they understand disabled
0:17:14 things and all who created that is uh
0:17:17 Allah they don't deny that basically the
0:17:19 original Creator or they deny is that
0:17:22 there are any relevant Partners either
0:17:26 in process of creation or in in the
0:17:30 Divinity nature natural Divinity like
0:17:32 offsprings and children and so the Quran
0:17:36 despite that based on that they should
0:17:40 have not associated with Allah any other
0:17:42 deities or any other Lords which we made
0:17:46 equal to him but also the word uses
0:17:48 they they they they they
0:17:53 are happy to us to adopt other Lords who
0:17:57 said their their the one who should be
0:17:59 the only Lord Allah and this in in does
0:18:03 not contain only Divine being who can
0:18:05 create and act 3D and not only Divine
0:18:08 beings who are supposed to be Offspring
0:18:10 server of the of the initial Divine the
0:18:13 father and the and entities but also
0:18:17 people or entities who have the right of
0:18:20 legislation this is one of the main
0:18:22 meaning of Rob like like a Scholars like
0:18:25 Chieftains and publisher who can enact
0:18:27 laws and so on and they are this way
0:18:29 they are supporting them to be divided
0:18:31 Lots so they're enactments and their
0:18:34 registration is Ultimate and Sovereign
0:18:36 and must be obeyed which is not true so
0:18:39 all that encompasses all of these kinds
0:18:42 of Lords
0:18:44 would the disbeliever associating with
0:18:46 Allah either that one one of divine type
0:18:48 creative type or those have Divine
0:18:51 entity or divine nature in themselves
0:18:54 all those who are having attributed to
0:18:57 them the right of the ultimate reference
0:19:01 or the right of legislation so all of
0:19:04 them including the Ayah so this
0:19:06 disbeliever still describes of this fact
0:19:08 that the one who created heavens and
0:19:09 earth and created Darkness at night is
0:19:12 still the associated them other Lords
0:19:14 should not be God the holy Lord is the
0:19:16 one who created that he's the Supreme
0:19:17 one he's the ultimate submarine he
0:19:20 should be the ultimate How can there be
0:19:21 any other Sovereign beside him who can
0:19:24 him at clothes that these laws are
0:19:25 binding not cannot be or legislative or
0:19:29 Define good and evil or Define
0:19:31 moralities or Divine even even patterns
0:19:34 of behavior no it is him no one who
0:19:37 ultimate
0:19:38 the ultimate 17.
0:19:41 then the next uh
0:19:44 Ayah in your account more select is also
0:19:46 in discount is
0:19:57 he it is who has created you out of clay
0:20:00 and then has a decreed has decreed a
0:20:03 term for you a term not only only to him
0:20:06 and yet you doubt next translation he
0:20:09 created you how to play and specified a
0:20:11 span of time for you a span known only
0:20:13 to him however you still doubt yeah so
0:20:17 that's again the creation story we have
0:20:19 discussed Adam so we may summarize it
0:20:21 again
0:20:23 this at the start of the of creation of
0:20:26 man is from clay from
0:20:29 cleaners is the wet soil is is the soil
0:20:32 which is the best for growing plants
0:20:35 that will be wet soil usually dark and
0:20:39 almost black that will be the most
0:20:41 optimal for growing plants I think the
0:20:43 last team
0:20:45 and he decreed the Satan appointed date
0:20:48 not saying for what and for whom so the
0:20:51 translator will say for you is not for
0:20:52 you he decided to set an appointed term
0:20:55 yes we're talking about human skin or
0:20:57 tea but maybe appointed them for the
0:20:58 universe for something else we don't
0:21:00 know so I said then he decided he
0:21:02 decided
0:21:04 accepted appointed time maybe he decided
0:21:07 this cliche occasion from clay will
0:21:09 evolve over billions of real than the
0:21:11 years and then in a certain due time
0:21:14 they will be done gaining Consciousness
0:21:16 maybe in a singular moment that Adam
0:21:19 became awake about his own Consciousness
0:21:21 and being and then the the beginning of
0:21:23 the human sister at that moment under
0:21:25 the scalability of language started with
0:21:27 a specific person which evolved through
0:21:29 a longer process Etc
0:21:32 and this is this disappointed it is
0:21:34 known to him and decided beforehand
0:21:36 version by him
0:21:38 and despite that obviously the people
0:21:40 will understand maybe that simply oh he
0:21:43 created uh adamant maybe in a second
0:21:46 like most most people above the
0:21:49 especially our Old Testament who take it
0:21:51 literally and simple mind and say it's
0:21:52 not that's what it is if you take the
0:21:54 Old Testament even even if you take it
0:21:58 literally it should not be concluded
0:21:59 that that the fashioning aftermath was
0:22:03 done in in a few days or a few hours a
0:22:05 few seconds it could be billions of
0:22:06 years but the people read the things
0:22:08 there according to our imagination and
0:22:10 their limited knowledge not according to
0:22:12 a theory the wording mean really
0:22:15 so but here it is clearly that from the
0:22:17 start creation until Adam emerged for
0:22:19 example this is appointed time and yet
0:22:21 how long it is it doesn't disclose here
0:22:24 you go and do your research you may find
0:22:26 it out
0:22:27 and still you are still disputing about
0:22:30 that and doubting about that so
0:22:32 concerning Adam Creation in some places
0:22:34 where I said something
0:22:36 and sometimes from salsa
0:22:38 that's a type of of
0:22:42 wet soil which if it's dries it becomes
0:22:45 like pottery which if you can knock on
0:22:48 it it become it sounds and other places
0:22:53 badly smelling mud
0:22:56 mud thin is actually the best smart soil
0:22:58 with soil mud but this bad smelling mud
0:23:01 with the initial creation hence to uh to
0:23:05 be like the the madhush we find in uh in
0:23:09 Volcan near the volcanic eruption it is
0:23:11 volcanic ashes mixed with water and rich
0:23:14 in Sulfur and sulfur gases and they
0:23:16 smell bad like found eggs so that maybe
0:23:19 that one hinted it may imagine the best
0:23:21 theory is available now is that the
0:23:24 beginning of test cell may have imaged
0:23:26 in such environment and use of them
0:23:29 under underwater volcanic eruption which
0:23:31 are not going until now you can you can
0:23:33 shake it in Indonesia and around and
0:23:35 also in Japanese
0:23:37 and these these volcanoes erupted the
0:23:40 ground they they dump huge amounts of
0:23:43 lava but also a huge amount of volcanic
0:23:45 dust and mix it with water and it is
0:23:48 also darkened by bad smelling Etc and
0:23:51 that's ongoing since the since we have a
0:23:53 crust of the earth and in ancient time
0:23:55 before we there was any life possible
0:23:57 that material is the starting one but
0:24:00 then
0:24:01 it's clarified another place from the
0:24:03 Quran that's created from from semen
0:24:05 from water that's obviously a letter
0:24:07 phase
0:24:08 and then we have instructed a clear
0:24:10 description of these three phases that
0:24:12 it is uh that it is initially from from
0:24:16 a sales history the creation fontin and
0:24:19 then made the offsprings of the steam
0:24:21 from from a Despicable semen drop and
0:24:25 then he was fashioned and made upright
0:24:27 and made for you the eye and Science and
0:24:29 the cautiousness so that's clear clear
0:24:32 description of the full scale of of
0:24:35 evolution going from four and a half
0:24:38 billion years to until today
0:24:40 summarized in three sentences starting
0:24:43 from mud
0:24:44 then from the mud obviously
0:24:47 cliche developed as mention the detail
0:24:50 because at that time nobody could have
0:24:51 even accepted that or even make any
0:24:53 sense out of it but they the offsprings
0:24:55 from that mud is from Ma and Mahin from
0:24:58 semen so we're talking about the level
0:25:00 where animal where obviously the
0:25:03 sexuality evolved and animals split in
0:25:06 prepared and familiar female Etc which
0:25:08 is maybe the LGBT do not like but
0:25:10 doesn't matter that's what has happened
0:25:12 especially in the animal kingdom but
0:25:14 also in the plant kingdom we have also a
0:25:17 specifically sexuality in certain trees
0:25:20 but it's not as strict as in the animal
0:25:21 kingdom so from the little one the
0:25:24 creation was evolving from semen in
0:25:26 Mahine and then later on that creation
0:25:30 which will be created from the over
0:25:32 generation millions of generations
0:25:33 became upright so it was a while
0:25:36 whenever him and blowing him his spirit
0:25:39 and then
0:25:41 made the sight and the hearing and the
0:25:44 hearts in here why it is after blowing
0:25:47 his spirit because these then are the
0:25:49 one who usually use in the Quran to to
0:25:52 describe faculties of understanding and
0:25:55 perception it's not the side tunnel of
0:25:57 the animals that's before but it's not
0:25:59 her but after exploring the spirit after
0:26:01 making him conscious what is even the
0:26:03 process it is is or it is most likely
0:26:06 when a certain specific person called
0:26:08 Adam
0:26:10 then that previous physiological site
0:26:13 become sight which leads to knowledge
0:26:16 the previous hearing became hearing
0:26:19 which can distinguish sounds and make
0:26:20 language and and
0:26:22 various pronunciation of letters and the
0:26:25 hearts which were before that
0:26:27 physiological pumps and so on and maybe
0:26:30 obviously reflecting the feeling because
0:26:32 if you if you attack for example in a
0:26:34 cat for example or terrify a cat if you
0:26:37 touch her chest you find the heart is
0:26:39 clearly there's a reaction in the heart
0:26:41 because of fear that was there but when
0:26:44 after Adam the heart become well placed
0:26:47 the physical heart reflects what happens
0:26:50 in the mind of thoughts and
0:26:52 understanding so after knowing the
0:26:54 spirit the eyes became very real and and
0:26:57 the hearing and the and the mind the
0:27:00 brain became then uh became became
0:27:03 conscious I became mind became something
0:27:06 which is a specific and significant for
0:27:09 humans not not before the one before was
0:27:11 just a biological instinctive Driven
0:27:14 Life faculties so that's absolutely
0:27:17 so this is the creation story expanded
0:27:20 in various places in the Quran bits and
0:27:22 pieces according to the situation what
0:27:24 needs to be addressed so if you most
0:27:27 advocacy agree that the original
0:27:28 creation of pre-bodies from from mud
0:27:32 initially maybe people do not agree but
0:27:35 they have to because even if they say oh
0:27:37 we come from our fathers okay and your
0:27:38 fathers and grandfathers and so on how
0:27:41 long ago back that was then how they get
0:27:43 stuck there must be somewhere a
0:27:45 beginning then they go to the people
0:27:47 with the book another people say well
0:27:48 what was your scripture and what what it
0:27:50 says it was so much or from something
0:27:52 like that
0:27:54 for the original mother of the Earth or
0:27:56 something like that almost everyone
0:27:58 agreed even if the people who don't be
0:28:00 leaving the scripture they'll get stuck
0:28:01 ultimately it has to go there it cannot
0:28:03 be that father's grandfathers are going
0:28:05 for all eternities back that's not
0:28:06 possible so that's what I start starting
0:28:08 why it cannot be a human can be
0:28:09 something else
0:28:11 which gets to the old question what is
0:28:13 first the the chicken or the egg
0:28:15 neither
0:28:18 they both go through the oh to the
0:28:20 fundamentals which is the Single Cell
0:28:23 the first single cell so things like
0:28:27 that or sometimes we seem to be
0:28:29 confusing but if you look at more more
0:28:31 thoroughly you will recognize what's
0:28:32 going on
0:28:34 but the
0:28:35 the beginning of the creation from that
0:28:38 it's began there but it was It was
0:28:41 decided then that it will take some time
0:28:43 to get there and this that time is known
0:28:46 to him but also maybe we decided that
0:28:48 even after you have been become upright
0:28:50 and become conscious being they will be
0:28:52 at the unappointed Entei in which then
0:28:55 the this this life on Earth as is the
0:28:57 human life and Earth will end and
0:28:59 Rihanna will come and there will be also
0:29:01 discussion about that medicine what is
0:29:03 universal for the universe or is the
0:29:06 first strike really the the for for each
0:29:10 each planet that's its own kriyama at
0:29:13 the beginning one and then the whole
0:29:14 universe really has selected there are
0:29:16 various theories about that it doesn't
0:29:18 test for Humanity there will be end of
0:29:21 humanity possibly maybe with an asteroid
0:29:23 strike maybe and then there will be
0:29:25 Resurrection is there distraction on
0:29:27 Earth or the selection of the whole
0:29:28 universe after a really really evolving
0:29:31 it again and folding it and expanding it
0:29:33 again maybe
0:29:35 that's left to
0:29:37 science depth observation the stress
0:29:39 theories to develop it doesn't make any
0:29:40 difference there will be an end
0:29:42 I'll be a certain time Gap how long it
0:29:45 is we don't know and then we are
0:29:46 Resurrection be it local be it not local
0:29:48 be it Universal doesn't matter there
0:29:50 will be a resurrection accounting
0:29:53 so that's all entailed in the in the
0:29:56 attempts uh he appointed a a certain
0:29:59 deadline a certain date and this date is
0:30:02 known to him only to him nobody else and
0:30:05 nevertheless you are still disputing
0:30:08 and then there's an interesting issue
0:30:09 now with computation of space and
0:30:13 location
0:30:14 and we'll dwell there a little bit maybe
0:30:16 the rest of the Holocaust before this
0:30:18 that says then
0:30:22 foreign
0:30:28 translate let us see how the translator
0:30:30 manage that one second
0:30:41 although he is God in the heavens and on
0:30:44 the earth knowing all that you keep
0:30:46 secret as well as all that you do openly
0:30:48 and knowing what you deserve next
0:30:50 translation he is God in the heavens and
0:30:52 on Earth he knows all your secrets and
0:30:55 what you reveal and he knows what you
0:30:57 earn
0:30:58 seriously also they are slightly they're
0:31:00 strugging even though
0:31:02 he's Allah he is god with capital G
0:31:07 in the heavens and in the Earth the
0:31:10 repeating fee will fill out
0:31:13 notice that there is usually some art
0:31:14 and are no need for feed yet but there
0:31:17 he is fear of
0:31:18 then follow me
0:31:21 know is what you do openly and what you
0:31:24 keep secretly and knows what you are
0:31:27 earning what you are doing and the
0:31:28 results of your actions foreign
0:31:59 not very intelligent actually it is a
0:32:01 possible explanation his name is there
0:32:04 Allah and Heavens are dead but we know
0:32:07 that the name Allah linguistically is is
0:32:10 a recent derivation it's a from Arabic
0:32:12 Maybe
0:32:14 from the time of Daniel or something
0:32:15 like that not even a time of Musa
0:32:18 so this this is not very persuasive but
0:32:21 it's a possibility
0:32:22 another said he is in heaven and death
0:32:25 with his knowledge he's present with him
0:32:27 his presence is there as a knowledge and
0:32:30 they say this is supported by the next
0:32:32 thing is
0:32:37 and it knows what is so it is he's he's
0:32:39 being there but with his knowledge
0:32:43 not to his being that's what they are so
0:32:45 if if someone says Allah is in heaven
0:32:48 you mean he's in the toilet and so on
0:32:51 and what I just mentioned earlier and
0:32:52 things like that
0:32:54 and there's a funny story happened with
0:32:56 that
0:32:57 uh in Maria in there's an eye in the
0:33:00 Quran said he is with you where you are
0:33:02 if you are truly favored if you if two
0:33:04 are are clotting secretly he's the third
0:33:07 and the three are pointing is the fourth
0:33:09 Etc and he would do everywhere and that
0:33:11 he will tell you your Motel what you
0:33:12 have done
0:33:14 and it says
0:33:16 it doesn't say with your his knowledge
0:33:18 or not his knowledge so
0:33:21 according to the general uh statement
0:33:24 the salary usually or the scholarity say
0:33:26 is that it should be kept as it is as it
0:33:29 is without further interpretation
0:33:33 and uh or any attack wheel so briefly
0:33:37 speaking we say he is with you with his
0:33:39 being with his knowledge in any way
0:33:41 which we may not know
0:33:44 okay
0:33:49 the issu states clearly he is with you
0:33:52 it doesn't say with your knowledge yes
0:33:55 it indicates that he will know what you
0:33:56 are doing and so on but that could be
0:33:58 because he is with you in some sense and
0:34:00 sometimes which can we cannot Envision
0:34:02 to understand metaphysically
0:34:04 and then he was obviously invited by by
0:34:07 the Messiah
0:34:09 and was forced to make a recantation and
0:34:12 signatoba a repentance that he repents
0:34:14 and withdraw his statement going back to
0:34:17 the statement of eventimia and the
0:34:19 salafi that is with you with his
0:34:21 knowledge
0:34:24 is their own principle that you should
0:34:27 leave things like that relating to the
0:34:29 Divine attribute as they are without
0:34:30 doing any attack wheel or takif or
0:34:33 something like that and they are doing
0:34:35 here manifestly and blatantly take you
0:34:37 so that the general rule they put on the
0:34:40 table they are violating it at least in
0:34:42 one one or two instances
0:34:45 because they concluded that if we say
0:34:47 Allah here somehow enter in space then
0:34:51 he must be in the what they call bad
0:34:52 places
0:34:54 while it's and so on and this seems to
0:34:56 be quite stinky nobody would like that
0:34:59 emotionally offensive
0:35:02 so how to deal with this but on the
0:35:05 other hand the philosophs
0:35:07 said
0:35:08 some of the philosophs we will see that
0:35:10 on the previous hit
0:35:11 these categories do not apply to Allah
0:35:13 we cannot say it's inside the universe
0:35:15 or outside the universe
0:35:18 does not make any sense
0:35:20 it's not a corporate being and the
0:35:23 universal entire and space
0:35:25 right left front back up and down three
0:35:28 dimensions face and possibly other
0:35:29 spaces which have been compactified away
0:35:31 whatever it is is essentially an
0:35:34 attribute of the created Universe it's
0:35:36 part of the creation it is not something
0:35:38 absolute which we can
0:35:40 we can put Allah in it but then even
0:35:45 tell me objectives and many others say
0:35:46 oh this means the salons are comparing
0:35:48 him or making him similar to nothing it
0:35:50 is but this is a mistake because nothing
0:35:52 in this is some different something
0:35:53 different than than a corvall or
0:35:56 non-core being so that's again a problem
0:35:58 there
0:35:59 another issue of that if they claim that
0:36:02 he is in heaven some code in in a in a
0:36:05 direction or in a space above the throne
0:36:07 or all these things we'll discuss some
0:36:09 of that when we will Attack Of course
0:36:12 then he is in space okay if he's in a
0:36:15 space then he must be necessary in every
0:36:17 possible space because otherwise he
0:36:19 would necessarily existing if he's only
0:36:21 in some space or not that space it is
0:36:23 then it's a contingency that's
0:36:25 contradict being this existing and
0:36:27 that's the argument of razi so it's
0:36:29 either everywhere or if he is nowhere
0:36:32 that's cannot work otherwise which is
0:36:34 again really enforcing and supporting
0:36:36 the argument of the philosophers
0:36:38 so they are at at loss in this issue and
0:36:41 they should be a close Edition
0:36:43 they should not have gone beyond their
0:36:45 role is good
0:36:47 he's in Heavens and he is in Earth in a
0:36:49 way we should not maybe are able to
0:36:52 receive what we perceive
0:36:54 if we use our normal sales experience
0:36:56 and we our experience and experience
0:36:58 with with a car or with a building and
0:37:01 so on that is in space but this is all
0:37:03 for limited being for unlimited being we
0:37:05 have no concept out there and the
0:37:07 argument that is the some spaces are bad
0:37:09 or something like that this is
0:37:10 nonsensical this is all relative to
0:37:12 human perception and Human Experience of
0:37:15 the the toilets may be stinky and bad
0:37:18 for humans but they're excellent for
0:37:20 watches so this is this is these
0:37:22 arguments are laughable they should not
0:37:24 be in method of existence and issues of
0:37:26 fundamental the structure of the
0:37:28 metaphysical realities
0:37:30 so
0:37:31 so if
0:37:34 conclusion
0:37:36 best conclusion would be really is is
0:37:39 that these categories don't apply to
0:37:42 Allah
0:37:43 and the issue of Thrones has to be
0:37:46 metaphorically integrated as we
0:37:47 discussed in the united currency that
0:37:49 accuracy is actually an irritable for
0:37:51 the knowledge and the throne is a
0:37:52 metaphor for the kingdom and this is
0:37:54 enforced by others uh issues of
0:37:57 importance
0:37:59 Etc uh in in the Quran Sunnah so that's
0:38:02 the best and possibly maybe the
0:38:04 expression of Newton but interpolated
0:38:07 probability say Allah or God is the
0:38:09 absolute Express
0:38:11 it has to be really inhibited the same
0:38:13 like like the prophet was done but he
0:38:15 did not explain further he used it just
0:38:17 to start with it and then start with the
0:38:19 with his mechanics and we did the
0:38:21 recording systems and so on and the
0:38:23 prophet did being unfollette was being
0:38:26 structured by the Divine when he said
0:38:27 Allah is the time he explained what this
0:38:30 means
0:38:31 in that case a Newton should have said
0:38:33 but he did not dare that because it's
0:38:35 again amid a physical statement which is
0:38:38 extremely uh difficult to assert and
0:38:41 extremely difficult to to uh to deal
0:38:43 with we should have said yes I say Allah
0:38:47 is the absolute space
0:38:48 in the sense that he is the one giving
0:38:51 the creation its own space in Ozone
0:38:53 Dimension so what you regard as right
0:38:55 left front back up down is a dimension
0:38:58 Dimensions given to the creation they
0:39:00 created with these attributes and all so
0:39:03 so being the absolute Spaceman he's the
0:39:06 one who gives the things their
0:39:08 attributes including space
0:39:10 in Arabic it would be actually quite
0:39:12 nice maybe that's part of the Arabic
0:39:15 wisdom of the Arabic language or maybe
0:39:16 it's by a Divine hand we have a language
0:39:19 developers space the lab is called Macan
0:39:21 and McCann is exactly the same root like
0:39:24 imkan possibilities contingency from the
0:39:28 same Lord makana so McCann so in Arabic
0:39:31 it fits nicely if we if someone would
0:39:33 there saying Allah is the absolutely
0:39:37 then in the sense that he is the one who
0:39:40 gives the the any created being its own
0:39:42 possibilities its own contingency its
0:39:45 own Dimensions his own attributes
0:39:50 moral of the story
0:39:52 when when a salafi confronts someone and
0:39:55 disturb his peaceful I'll explain this
0:39:58 extremely this eye and eye of Maria and
0:40:00 her what what will happen and just just
0:40:02 to embarrass them just stop embarrassing
0:40:04 the people that know the mask that's it
0:40:06 I I wouldn't go more than that and uh
0:40:09 and uh going more than that maybe maybe
0:40:12 problematic but human being would be us
0:40:14 so there was a Hadith but the problem
0:40:15 with the Hadith is weak and the
0:40:17 narrations
0:40:18 are are controversial
0:40:22 but still there's an interesting thing I
0:40:24 think to take a look let's look at this
0:40:26 Hadith it is
0:40:29 asking the messenger of Allah
0:40:33 where was Allah before he created the
0:40:35 creation that's one one reported version
0:40:37 another version the question was what is
0:40:40 the Our Lord Our God our
0:40:43 Lord was before he created Heavens death
0:40:47 most likely it will be before creating
0:40:50 Heaven and Earth because we have both
0:40:52 both of them with good church so it
0:40:54 means some narrators changed the
0:40:56 original wedding if there's any original
0:40:57 wedding
0:40:59 but then it can't be both so it's either
0:41:01 one of them I would get the balance to
0:41:03 creating because
0:41:07 not a graduate of of
0:41:09 uh of the academic of the athenier
0:41:14 Academy of philosophy who will make a
0:41:16 difference between heavens and red and
0:41:17 Creations where our Lord before he made
0:41:19 created we created the creation creative
0:41:21 learner we don't know what's the
0:41:22 original way most likely
0:41:28 Etc
0:41:29 is really using creating the creation
0:41:31 really
0:41:33 indirectly informal verbs in some places
0:41:35 we'll come to them so that's most likely
0:41:37 the question then the answer
0:41:40 clearly there's a little bit of a
0:41:42 question for my from unlimited finite
0:41:44 human being who is immersed in space and
0:41:46 time
0:41:48 but what do you expect the prophet to
0:41:50 answer him
0:41:52 you cannot ask a question because we ask
0:41:54 I that will not be that will not be a
0:41:56 problem
0:41:59 according to his perception of the
0:42:01 reality an answer is suitable for his
0:42:04 perception should be given the answer
0:42:06 persists of two main section allegedly
0:42:11 foreign
0:42:38 like that
0:42:40 if that's authentic the only way to say
0:42:43 that if you perceive him as like you
0:42:45 perceive a mountain or something like
0:42:47 that or imagine him like that that's the
0:42:49 only answer because iron is for
0:42:50 something where is the mountain the
0:42:51 mountain is there look at it so then
0:42:55 he is incompleted in in complete nothing
0:42:58 it is above him is nothing this Hawa is
0:43:00 is a is the next linguistic expression
0:43:03 for the nothingness because people feel
0:43:05 that the air around us is empty there's
0:43:07 nothing there it's real we know it's
0:43:08 full of air I follow fields and so on we
0:43:10 know that from physics Zone but for the
0:43:13 first approximation compared to the
0:43:15 walls and the table and so on it is
0:43:17 essentially empty
0:43:18 so in nothing surrounded by nothing
0:43:20 there's nothing be if you want to go
0:43:22 philosophical nothing around him exists
0:43:24 he is not in space that but that's
0:43:26 that's impossible for the prophet to
0:43:28 explain like that to anybody who is the
0:43:30 level of Brazil and the people of this
0:43:33 time that would be impossible so the
0:43:35 best approximation is that kind of
0:43:37 expression so that's okay that's what we
0:43:39 can say if we separated properly foreign
0:43:48 the imagination over and the next part
0:43:51 is that where the narrator
0:43:53 sharply disagree
0:43:57 one says then he created his throne on
0:44:01 the water
0:44:03 then he creates narration
0:44:12 another narration so indicating that
0:44:14 Throne has been created so the one who
0:44:16 who changed the original sentence God
0:44:18 knows what the original system have been
0:44:21 uh definitely has in his mind that the
0:44:24 throne is something created
0:44:26 but he did not solve the problem because
0:44:28 the Creator the Thrones Throne is
0:44:31 created on the water what's this water
0:44:32 so water is not created that
0:44:35 he ran away from one trouble ending
0:44:37 another trouble the other one narration
0:44:40 which is found in urban interestingly
0:44:42 only I think on some other narratives
0:44:46 because I said the people narrated
0:44:48 according to their understanding and
0:44:50 maybe their means that changed the word
0:44:51 a little bit you see
0:44:53 it says
0:44:57 what has there been major let me get
0:44:59 that magic exact wedding
0:45:03 very interesting it says
0:45:13 there was no Christians commenting on
0:45:16 the previous sentence that he was in in
0:45:18 Amma there was no creation nothingness
0:45:20 is there absolutely nothing in this is
0:45:22 there above him or below him if the word
0:45:24 above and below meaning meaning anything
0:45:26 no nothing exists behind beside him if
0:45:29 you if you want to have an imagination
0:45:31 and space space like imagination then
0:45:34 it's like like a mountain in an absolute
0:45:36 voice something like that
0:45:38 whatsoever
0:45:42 and they prefer this version because
0:45:44 this seems to be commenting on the
0:45:46 previous when he was before the creation
0:45:48 there was no creation above him nothing
0:45:50 below him nothing with him around him
0:45:53 um
0:45:54 nothing exists with him and if you
0:45:57 prefer to use the language of space
0:45:59 then
0:46:01 above and below can be used but it is
0:46:03 metaphorical it is language stress does
0:46:05 not apply and then
0:46:07 the next sentence is
0:46:10 a nominal since started his throne is
0:46:13 underwater so the throne is not created
0:46:15 so the people who got that original form
0:46:17 they Twisted it they dropped the Mata
0:46:20 Mahal which is a comment on the previous
0:46:21 part and then attributed
0:46:25 making the Arts being created being
0:46:28 acted upon by the verification but this
0:46:30 is definitely a plural form of this
0:46:34 assuming that this has a root why I'm
0:46:37 saying I'm discussing that because it is
0:46:40 rather unconceivable that that because
0:46:44 the narrator
0:46:49 is his nephew uh
0:46:51 very famous
0:46:54 most of them are nice there's no problem
0:46:57 with them including this I wouldn't say
0:46:59 regard that is not nice it is it's very
0:47:02 difficult to conceive that this man will
0:47:03 invent something like that it's not a
0:47:05 lot of difficult it's just out of his
0:47:06 League out of his world and aborazine is
0:47:09 known for asking too many questions
0:47:13 because he came to visit in Medina in
0:47:15 the 10th Year from from in a delegation
0:47:19 and because he did not give by and
0:47:21 there's nothing that he was allowed to
0:47:22 ask and even I think that if I remember
0:47:24 correctly people even try to bribe him
0:47:27 to ask questions because they were Brave
0:47:29 to trust we discussed the issue asking
0:47:31 too many questions in the book of the
0:47:32 Walid so he was known for many questions
0:47:35 it was a questioning might obviously
0:47:37 this guy's a man of course he asked
0:47:39 about Sharia for example my father is
0:47:41 too old to perform the message
0:47:45 that's one of the authorities is also
0:47:49 narrated from his nephew okay
0:47:52 Etc so I feel that it is it can't be
0:47:56 fabricated there must be some root there
0:48:02 an inquiring mind like clearly from the
0:48:05 very the plenty of questions are coming
0:48:08 from abrazin is that he's an inquiring
0:48:11 mind he asks he asked many questions
0:48:13 he's the one who isn't famous to be the
0:48:16 one who is asking plenty of questions so
0:48:18 why not asking such a question why
0:48:20 assume that it was never asked and
0:48:21 someone fabricated it I think it's a
0:48:24 tall order I think all these
0:48:26 circumstances indicate that must have a
0:48:28 root now we have to ascertain what's the
0:48:30 first part I think that's what we are
0:48:31 too and the second part that in the
0:48:34 urban manager got it right
0:48:36 and you could say that's because if
0:48:37 that's thicker than this the protection
0:48:40 there was no creation so above him is
0:48:43 nothing
0:48:45 he's in darkness or he's in in a cloud
0:48:47 or he's in a veil or something like that
0:48:51 blindness if you translate it literally
0:48:54 is a complete darkness with blindness
0:48:57 complete veiling nothing above him
0:48:59 nothing growing and no creation is there
0:49:01 whatsoever Mata Mahal there is no
0:49:03 creation then
0:49:06 uh his throne was on water when this is
0:49:08 essentially the world which is used in
0:49:10 the Quran in another place
0:49:14 the Quran speaks about creating Heaven
0:49:18 and Earth and so on uh all these things
0:49:20 and then mentioned and
0:49:22 his throne was on the water
0:49:25 we should which requires some deep
0:49:27 interpretation
0:49:29 I think I may have touched about that
0:49:31 you know but we'll touch it when you get
0:49:33 to that eye because this will get us
0:49:35 into another issue of the throne and the
0:49:37 car seat
0:49:38 and there's a real meaning of them
0:49:41 and this this requires a very deep
0:49:43 interpretation but the sensual Quran
0:49:46 I'll show his throne was on water it's
0:49:48 not not mention the word of the creation
0:49:50 obviously this is very offensive for
0:49:52 those who believe that Throne is some
0:49:53 kind of a creative being and they
0:49:56 mention various broken it's not Hadith
0:49:59 which are definitely not not correct
0:50:01 uh that the throne is created and of
0:50:04 course is created and so on but nothing
0:50:06 coming from sahaba at least from uh bus
0:50:09 indicated that the courses are created
0:50:11 because it's just a metaphor for
0:50:12 knowledge when the article consists his
0:50:15 courtesy of course he is share or
0:50:18 receipt and by encompasses Heavens are
0:50:20 there
0:50:22 his knowledge
0:50:24 comprehensively
0:50:26 knows everything in Heaven and Earth
0:50:28 that's it
0:50:30 in the famous actor so this is and it's
0:50:34 amazing that from someone like us in
0:50:37 that generation such an extremely
0:50:39 metaphorical and and
0:50:42 philosophical answer is given but
0:50:44 obviously he was compelled it doesn't
0:50:46 make any sense to talk about Cozy
0:50:48 so many scholars will claim that uh that
0:50:52 that the course is like the eighth
0:50:53 heaven or the eighth or the eighth uh
0:50:55 surrounding entity the ninth or
0:50:59 something is his own nonsense this is
0:51:01 most likely the Hadith about that
0:51:03 similar than definitely Moroccan and
0:51:05 fabricated without it I have no doubt
0:51:07 about that further but this one is just
0:51:10 repeating gun there was no creation
0:51:12 so Allah was in if we use the terms of
0:51:16 the language of space and time of time
0:51:18 space here he was in Amma blindness
0:51:22 cloudiness vileness
0:51:25 above him is nothing
0:51:30 mean nothing Abyss under him nothing
0:51:33 there was no creation
0:51:37 then
0:51:39 despite all of that his throne was on
0:51:41 the water
0:51:42 so the throne must be something not
0:51:44 created something else certainly started
0:51:46 to be interpreted and the water needs to
0:51:48 be intimate there's not a water you know
0:51:50 in the definitely not not the water we
0:51:52 have in there is absolutely something
0:51:53 different
0:51:56 I have some work on that which uh I will
0:52:00 finish soon inshallah because I think it
0:52:01 will have to be to be at least a
0:52:05 section in the book of David in chapter
0:52:08 11 about following the messages
0:52:10 attributes and things like that I
0:52:12 thought we cannot avoid addressing at
0:52:14 least some basic things that giving one
0:52:16 or two examples of the mistakes of
0:52:18 salafi and wahhabi and the claim of that
0:52:21 wheel and houses so they are mistaken
0:52:23 they are actually doing that will
0:52:24 they're just cheating it's just just an
0:52:27 expression which is empty of really any
0:52:29 and substantial meaning
0:52:30 but giving the example of pattern
0:52:32 because we have the reliable narration
0:52:34 from our bus that consuming knowledge
0:52:36 and we have the reliable interpretation
0:52:38 of arsh being the the kingdom and the
0:52:41 power and then we have to then find the
0:52:43 tradition for this water about which the
0:52:46 throne was resting what's it that will
0:52:48 come in in that message and also when we
0:52:50 get to the Irish has enough life to get
0:52:53 there I don't know why it's far down
0:52:56 then we will discuss that so so last
0:52:59 subject I've got a question so yeah so I
0:53:03 want if someone says regarding them as a
0:53:05 shabiha I believe in them as Allah meant
0:53:07 them with no further commentary is that
0:53:10 an acceptable approach to comments
0:53:15 not to claim that hope is not in Earth
0:53:18 on Earth he's not here he's only in
0:53:21 there up there no that's that's luck
0:53:24 that's wrong that's the Father which is
0:53:29 with you everywhere
0:53:31 so their claim is only with his
0:53:33 knowledge is just a is is a is narrowing
0:53:36 things which they should not have been
0:53:38 at all they're not complying with this
0:53:40 rule I believe it as Allah has meant it
0:53:42 to be that's perfectly fine but Allah
0:53:44 not necessarily you cannot conclude this
0:53:46 meant to be only by his knowledge but
0:53:48 not with his being what means with
0:53:49 knowledge of this being but he's there
0:53:51 with his knowledge he's there with his
0:53:53 power he can interfere if he wants so
0:53:55 what meaning goes only with his
0:53:56 knowledge you see what I mean so that
0:53:59 the way they specify they are violating
0:54:01 that truth and that's it which shows
0:54:04 that their role is is not persuasive
0:54:06 it's contradictory
0:54:07 the role is you I said we believe as
0:54:09 they have come without the will or takif
0:54:12 or tactile we don't deny it okay we
0:54:15 don't deny it but you are denying it
0:54:17 when you say oh Allah say no he's not in
0:54:20 it actually just maybe his name who said
0:54:23 that's only his name is Allah
0:54:26 and then his name is in other languages
0:54:30 okay
0:54:34 foreign
0:54:47 being included and contained is not
0:54:50 contained so his extent from heaven and
0:54:52 somehow
0:54:54 whatever it is in service on Earth which
0:54:56 called Allah
0:54:58 so if you if you say oh with the only
0:55:00 reason knowledge then you're violated
0:55:02 your own rule so either you stick to the
0:55:03 rule strictly
0:55:05 now don't condemn anybody and start
0:55:07 asking the people that those who knows
0:55:08 who is Allah in heaven no it's not
0:55:11 hitting that toilet or
0:55:14 you go you do some reasonable
0:55:16 interpretation by analyzing that should
0:55:18 be that philosophical discourse
0:55:19 analyzing space and time
0:55:21 and this concept that this will be deep
0:55:23 this would be not for the everyone the
0:55:25 best thing is just
0:55:27 if you imagine him like a buddy
0:55:30 but a human being that's the only way
0:55:32 you can imagine things that's fine no
0:55:33 problem but you must know Allah is
0:55:35 different than that it's just it's just
0:55:37 a mental image which makes you relate to
0:55:39 it somehow that's it one following thing
0:55:42 and also how about the common Muslim who
0:55:44 simply doesn't think about these issues
0:55:47 perfectly fine that's that's the reason
0:55:50 I opened it because the salaries are
0:55:52 standing on the doors I saw it here in
0:55:54 Wembley
0:55:55 and and picking the mind of the people
0:55:57 and making them terrified
0:56:01 so the question the fundamental thing is
0:56:04 you're not obliged to know about it so
0:56:06 just shut up no no no naturally not
0:56:08 actually not
0:56:10 we say I don't understand exactly what
0:56:12 is it there seems to be there is issues
0:56:13 of space and time which is a problematic
0:56:16 and philosophical discourse I don't want
0:56:18 to involve in that here's an answer for
0:56:20 them I don't know where he is but I know
0:56:22 where the American troops are in
0:56:23 Nigerian yeah
0:56:25 um yeah yeah with our River banking yeah
0:56:28 that's it that's that's what I'm
0:56:29 concerned I know and I know that obliged
0:56:31 to fight them and kick them out of the
0:56:32 Islamic domain yeah for example that's
0:56:34 that's what I'm obliged to do not to
0:56:36 know where it is in the sense of it if
0:56:38 it does he does does he is he in space
0:56:40 or he's not in space and so on but if
0:56:42 someone indulgent that then he has to be
0:56:44 consistent as well probably and that's
0:56:46 what the salafi are doing they're
0:56:47 indulging in that and they are not
0:56:48 consistent and they they end in
0:56:51 something there are some place
0:56:53 situations clearly metaphorical and they
0:56:55 still get stuck like for example when we
0:56:57 discuss when Allah
0:57:02 is chained to his neck
0:57:05 didn't mean that his hand was in here
0:57:07 they meant he's stingy he doesn't give
0:57:10 and he cares them with his hand are open
0:57:13 he is giving day and night
0:57:15 that's a meaning he's clearly the
0:57:17 meaning he is is being generous and and
0:57:20 because in it you know everyone said
0:57:24 this guy is having an opener sometimes
0:57:26 even his hand is having a hole he cannot
0:57:28 hold any money it leaks away
0:57:30 doesn't mean he's had having a whole
0:57:32 something that's obvious linguistic
0:57:34 expression who is certainly meaning he
0:57:36 doesn't hold money he is not stingy
0:57:39 so in that case the only way is to say
0:57:41 the claiming that Allah has a hand or
0:57:43 chained to a neck or not chained or open
0:57:45 or closed or that's all nonsensical
0:57:47 that's clearly the linguistic meaning
0:57:49 and the contextual that it is it is a
0:57:51 it's a it's a figure of speech and of
0:57:55 highest eloquence that's it
0:57:58 does not prove that Allah
0:58:00 even why did you not prostate to that
0:58:04 was that created with my other hand
0:58:05 addressing a bliss
0:58:18 with special attention with special care
0:58:22 foreign
0:58:47 just read the context and see it like
0:58:49 that that's these hand and these things
0:58:52 are are definitely not anything to do
0:58:54 with attributes they made it belonging
0:58:56 to attributes because because they are
0:58:58 either stupid
0:59:00 or or partisan to some of them myself
0:59:03 The Limited mind
0:59:08 whose inability to understand these
0:59:10 things as clear they should have shut
0:59:11 their mouth and not comment on it
0:59:14 it's a handy distraction yeah it's a
0:59:17 distraction it's a destruction and most
0:59:20 of the time it's used to divert people
0:59:22 from more relevant important things
0:59:26 like for example like for example the
0:59:27 famous question about what's meaning
0:59:29 mounted on the throne also set up on the
0:59:33 throne
0:59:35 and there was a question to my Malik and
0:59:40 the question to uh
0:59:44 is known in the language what it means
0:59:47 it's standing upright okay well caveman
0:59:50 how it is
0:59:55 not conceivable but most of him amen is
0:59:58 not not uh imaginable no not not not as
1:00:02 conceivable we can't conceive something
1:00:04 there but it's not about but at that
1:00:06 time this fine the the distinction of
1:00:09 the logic between conceivable or
1:00:11 imaginable and so on we're not there
1:00:13 already only beginning to be a clear
1:00:16 distinct distinct
1:00:18 uh and then I said uh why why women
1:00:22 Allah
1:00:25 women alike I mean I mean
1:00:30 gave us the message and we accept the
1:00:32 message
1:00:35 which is very very reasonable common
1:00:38 Malik was they usually invoke
1:00:41 stayed similar but less lesser better
1:00:43 language
1:00:48 that is not
1:01:00 may be possible that depending on what
1:01:03 the throne is for example
1:01:05 and then the blender comes
1:01:09 we are getting in the area of blunder
1:01:12 now this is a manifest catastrophic
1:01:14 blender no so Alan is not better
1:01:21 your time it's better for you to ask
1:01:24 about something else
1:01:25 like for example
1:01:27 is it is it a is it enough for me for
1:01:31 example to have just only the players
1:01:32 are not having even any sooner
1:01:34 whatsoever which we should ask for the
1:01:36 hanafi which have I think four nothing
1:01:37 to do this to this and doing your own
1:01:39 Zuma you see the people trying to
1:01:41 catching up with they have missed all
1:01:43 over the week
1:01:44 become almost like like a gymnastic
1:01:46 class there up and down up and down up
1:01:48 and down that would have been much more
1:01:50 productive question for example
1:01:54 so we between blunders of Scholars
1:01:56 between scholarship music expressing
1:01:57 themselves between
1:01:59 foreign
1:02:07 but give some some hints and and some
1:02:11 directions
1:02:12 yeah
1:02:14 um well you had a question as well or
1:02:15 something related to this yeah
1:02:19 um I belong to the camp where as an
1:02:22 ordinary Muslim my job is just to work
1:02:24 out what how many records I have to pay
1:02:26 how much I have to pay all the ah Come
1:02:29 these things we believe in it we will
1:02:31 just take it yeah so that's my belief
1:02:33 however you're very much right that
1:02:36 those who say uh from the salafis or
1:02:39 some hanabella as well who believe uh
1:02:43 who say no that will in some but then
1:02:47 they do massive table and other yeah
1:02:50 they're essentially they go against
1:02:51 their own principle and it's a known a
1:02:53 matter in Islam that whoever contradict
1:02:56 their own principle their their View and
1:02:59 opinions in that matter becomes null and
1:03:01 void yeah
1:03:03 when Allah
1:03:10 foreign
1:03:11 Music
1:03:46 everything will perish except this face
1:03:49 so why do you then give one meaning to
1:03:51 face and one Ayah and a completely
1:03:54 different face because means
1:03:57 Allah azzawajal himself and the entire
1:04:00 must-have of them is not to split Allah
1:04:03 into separate being giving illustrating
1:04:06 to one part and giving more rating to
1:04:09 another party but that's what they do
1:04:10 they say their knowledge is here and but
1:04:13 but there's no so you ask them okay so
1:04:15 there's the knowledge of Allah says
1:04:17 everything else every other attribute
1:04:18 perishes
1:04:20 is is clear in the context what it means
1:04:23 the direction of Allah direction of the
1:04:25 prayer to Allah that's all so this is if
1:04:27 you miss the Kaaba you make it hard you
1:04:30 missed and you prayed to the wrong
1:04:31 direction you don't need to repeat
1:04:33 because you have the direction Allah
1:04:34 anyway direction to the prayer which is
1:04:36 valid in the eye of Allah does not mean
1:04:38 that Allah is in east or west or not in
1:04:40 eastern West or in heaven or not in
1:04:42 heaven or in space or not in space has
1:04:44 nothing to do with that is that what you
1:04:46 hear his Direction
1:04:47 and the other watch his meaning face but
1:04:50 face also of human being face because
1:04:51 this is where when you say I met them I
1:04:55 met the faces of the people meaning the
1:04:56 people who are T which will be in front
1:04:59 of me when I want to discuss with the
1:05:01 people or the tribe and negotiate with
1:05:03 them I will negotiate with with a
1:05:05 Shepherd a young Shepherd who's standing
1:05:08 sheep of research with the leaders there
1:05:09 in the face of the of the nation they
1:05:11 are the face over I will have even a
1:05:13 program in in American I think it's ABC
1:05:15 or somebody Face the Nation
1:05:18 Face the Nation meet the Venetian
1:05:20 Festival nation has no Face to Face the
1:05:23 Nation
1:05:24 confronted put your face over their face
1:05:27 so this is this is this is I think this
1:05:29 is a this is all shows that I think this
1:05:33 is coming from the inability to be uh to
1:05:36 understand Arabic and be eloquent about
1:05:38 that but it shows some of them are even
1:05:41 heavy
1:05:42 are really miserable in that and or
1:05:45 unable or not willing to go on things
1:05:47 which are related Sharia for example one
1:05:50 of the disciples I know that humble will
1:05:52 be upset about that ask him what's about
1:05:55 the Hadith
1:05:56 what did he answer him
1:05:59 imagine say don't talk about that and
1:06:02 don't ask about that
1:06:04 as if you know it's talking about Divine
1:06:06 attributes
1:06:08 because he knew what the conclusion will
1:06:10 be has has beloved will become will
1:06:13 become an enemy of Allah
1:06:15 ran away from that
1:06:17 instead of solving the problem and
1:06:19 confronting the matter
1:06:21 is running away from it
1:06:22 so is this understanding of sharia is
1:06:25 like miserable issue of Dunya which we
1:06:27 know human beings how they be heaven or
1:06:29 their interaction which is well well
1:06:31 under our control of understanding and
1:06:34 description then how can you trust him
1:06:37 in issues like that well this is of
1:06:39 creation of the Quran of creation anyway
1:06:40 I don't want to malign anybody else but
1:06:43 but you should
1:06:45 you should start losing trust about
1:06:48 about many of these Scholars yeah don't
1:06:51 make them bigger than they are just put
1:06:53 them in the right place
1:06:57 with their understanding and so on and
1:06:59 that's the reason for example is
1:07:01 superior to them in irrationalism and
1:07:03 many other aspects they were very
1:07:04 hateful and they're attacking him his
1:07:06 weekend Hadith is this he is this he was
1:07:09 saying Quran he was doing that he was
1:07:11 doing this and so on because he's the
1:07:13 only after the fall who is really a man
1:07:15 of sufficiently high rationality
1:07:18 anyway we don't want to go into that um
1:07:20 yeah and the final thing and the final
1:07:23 part I wanted to mention is uh the
1:07:25 entire rubia being you know uh that the
1:07:28 others uh you know being held
1:07:30 so when it comes to the issue of uh they
1:07:34 would argue for hours saying the Irish
1:07:36 is not the creation even though the Ayah
1:07:38 says
1:07:40 no their main argument is that she's a
1:07:43 creation
1:07:47 that's the the most prevalent point of
1:07:50 view between salafi and so on
1:08:03 one day we give that some a bit of
1:08:05 discussion but that that's the demand
1:08:07 and the invoke the Hadith award that it
1:08:09 is uh it is the size of a desert Etc
1:08:12 compared to this and and then what
1:08:14 Hadith about it which is clearly
1:08:16 fabricated and broken the only Hadith
1:08:18 they have is that the uh that uh about
1:08:21 what is the currency we have one from
1:08:23 Hadith it's a small group that is the
1:08:26 place of the feet which doesn't make any
1:08:28 sense because kosi is where you sit not
1:08:30 where you put your feet so that the
1:08:32 steps in front of the uh of the uh
1:08:34 that's maybe a Jewish things because he
1:08:37 is his formula and the Judaism and
1:08:39 Jewish adaptation were prevalent there
1:08:41 and the other one attributed to to uh
1:08:45 that he was uh that he was uh asking
1:08:49 about three things and then the expanded
1:08:52 version of the Hadith mentioned that the
1:08:54 size of the throne
1:08:57 compared to the throne inside the throne
1:08:59 compared to the courtesy and then and
1:09:01 then model of the prophets and all of
1:09:03 this is now is not true all of this is
1:09:04 fabricated but this will come in another
1:09:06 session we don't want to disturb the
1:09:08 people now listening to the more
1:09:09 important things about that
1:09:11 so that's that that's the issue so the
1:09:13 the the the the the the the the matter
1:09:16 of fact is that uh the
1:09:19 their their their argument is generally
1:09:21 about ourselves it's like like a like a
1:09:25 a currency is like the eighth heaven or
1:09:28 if uh this is the surrounding
1:09:32 surrounding the universe and after the
1:09:34 surrounding there's another surrounding
1:09:35 called harsh and all are created somehow
1:09:38 argument
1:09:42 and they they they are invoked but this
1:09:46 is not an Evidence obviously but you
1:09:47 know that this does not be necessarily
1:09:50 create or could be meaning something
1:09:51 else and also we have that's good
1:09:53 because
1:09:58 it does not mean that it's creating guys
1:10:01 as is one of the most intrinsic
1:10:03 attributes of the Divine the exaltation
1:10:05 that it is a stability that is
1:10:07 essentially meaning the necessary
1:10:09 existing so that cannot be held the
1:10:11 short creation and so on
1:10:13 him is the one who belongs that
1:10:16 that's one of the meaning of Rob the
1:10:18 owner of something or that three one
1:10:20 attributed something
1:10:23 attributed to him not all who created it
1:10:25 and so on
1:10:27 anyway we've come to that shall another
1:10:28 occasion otherwise we'll go of tangent
1:10:31 of these things but fundamentally
1:10:33 their their approach
1:10:36 starts maybe making some sense in it it
1:10:38 started failing and when when it is
1:10:41 clearly metaphorical and a matter of
1:10:42 figure suicide eloquence they fail to
1:10:44 understand that we show that they are
1:10:46 coming back from rajma they have they
1:10:49 don't have the Arabic test they do not
1:10:50 understand and appreciate that the Quran
1:10:52 has come with his hand and Arabian movie
1:10:55 is like any other language because even
1:10:59 more having a low Queens in matter of
1:11:01 the figures of speech and matter of
1:11:03 metaphors of kinaya whatever uh
1:11:06 various other things which are known to
1:11:09 be under this orix uh that's that's the
1:11:12 same the majority of Hadith Scholars are
1:11:14 really failing in that the overwhelming
1:11:17 majority even those of Arabic origin
1:11:19 like Malik and hamburger hampers even
1:11:21 those they their their capability of the
1:11:24 Arabic States understanding it is
1:11:27 relatively poor
1:11:29 that's that's one secondly they put
1:11:31 general rules with their violating by
1:11:33 every step
1:11:35 okay but I think we should we should we
1:11:37 should just want a quick one you also
1:11:38 have mentioned before about
1:11:40 um and when the womb grabs the belt of
1:11:43 Allah
1:11:51 example if you can enjoy the vision when
1:11:55 there is the creation the the Rahim
1:11:59 the womb jumped on the Divine belt
1:12:02 hanging with the Divine belt
1:12:04 and then they say what's your problem
1:12:07 now jumping on a belt is that what what
1:12:09 people in time pass through tribal
1:12:11 shifting and kings are asking for Mercy
1:12:14 you jump on the belt and hold
1:12:17 you go on your knees and jump on his
1:12:18 belt or a hold your cloth kids do it to
1:12:22 their mother holding the scat jumping on
1:12:25 the bed
1:12:27 hey what is your problem why are doing
1:12:29 that we know that there's no Divine Way
1:12:32 divided absolutely figure of speech
1:12:36 metaphorical giving you a vegan will
1:12:38 essentially a
1:12:40 representation like like drawing a
1:12:42 picture
1:12:43 then you said this is I am I'm holding
1:12:47 this this is the the position of someone
1:12:49 who's uh taking a few stool from being
1:12:51 cut away
1:12:54 to being disowned to being neglected the
1:12:56 relation of kin say will it please you
1:12:59 that I will connect or connect you and
1:13:01 disconnect or disconnect you she said
1:13:03 yes say that that's for you let loose
1:13:05 now
1:13:06 it might enjoy the picture the moment
1:13:09 you start with this rubbish of belt and
1:13:11 not built and
1:13:19 you have lost the whole meaning of the
1:13:21 taste of the Hadith
1:13:25 says that the connecting that everything
1:13:28 giving the relation of kindergation of
1:13:30 womp is so fundamental
1:13:32 that Allah said I will connect who
1:13:34 connects you and they will disconnect
1:13:35 you obviously with the details of the
1:13:37 Sharia and so on that there are various
1:13:39 fine points there but
1:13:41 that's the general principle
1:13:42 fundamentally so in such a way that this
1:13:45 hologram has been presented to our eyes
1:13:47 and Hadith and then you find somebody
1:13:49 just coming there
1:13:51 obviously
1:13:54 I know but
1:14:02 we have someone is attributed to one of
1:14:05 the Shia they call because usually not
1:14:08 much they are more into the metaphorical
1:14:10 area and more like one casually style
1:14:12 over this course
1:14:15 or someone else or maybe
1:14:20 it may be the attribution maybe he's
1:14:22 doing it for mockery for salafi maybe
1:14:23 because it is so unbelievable
1:14:26 but maybe he said that he said he's
1:14:29 actually have have a body
1:14:31 of phase and so on and at the end of
1:14:35 time everything this appear except his
1:14:37 face his body even disappears
1:14:40 Laughter
1:14:43 I I cannot really I cannot really avoid
1:14:48 saying um people he must be mocking the
1:14:50 some some time nobody is even with a
1:14:54 also brain would say something right but
1:14:56 you never know some people become so
1:14:58 idiotic or stick to certain than the
1:14:59 ocean I say we stick to it
1:15:02 and they claimed that he was claiming
1:15:04 that Allah is a body and he has said it
1:15:06 asked me about everything except about
1:15:07 the genitals I cannot decide about the
1:15:09 genitals maybe it's a bad mouthing the
1:15:12 man because this sounds so absurd that
1:15:15 it's very difficult to to
1:15:18 uh to accept that
1:15:20 against yes pagans are known to have a
1:15:22 degree relativity bodies and so on and
1:15:25 issues like that and even genitals and
1:15:27 semen like in one of the myths of the of
1:15:30 the Medusa and so on is that one of the
1:15:32 deities was caught by other one and the
1:15:35 and in the fight he slit his his uh his
1:15:39 his testicles and then the the semen
1:15:41 fell down into the sea and that
1:15:43 fertilized the Sea and the creation oh
1:15:47 hahaha
1:15:50 okay if Pagan can go to that even the
1:15:53 Pagan May made that even metaphorically
1:15:59 so I I think I I think we should we
1:16:02 should anyway any attribution of
1:16:05 buddiness or something like that or
1:16:07 things like that to uh the Divine is
1:16:10 making him essentially an idol it's
1:16:11 idolatry and most Scholars we've done
1:16:13 said anything like that he's saying that
1:16:16 he said that Allah a part of her body or
1:16:19 he's in parts and so on is is covered
1:16:22 under the one saying that is is actually
1:16:23 Pagan that's not Islam that's not a
1:16:26 monotheism that's not what has been
1:16:28 revealed over a ham downwards through
1:16:29 the time
1:16:33 so so that's it that's it that's it so
1:16:36 one question you said that it's pain in
1:16:39 terms of he has parts or because they
1:16:41 say the real estate that he has a hand
1:16:43 but what that means you know how it
1:16:45 relates we don't ask questions was is
1:16:47 that by that admission of it being a
1:16:49 hand in a more physical sense and
1:16:51 admission of no they say it's not
1:16:53 physical it's not that it's not less a
1:16:56 journey has not a body but okay it's an
1:16:58 attribute
1:17:00 because the stupidity because hand is
1:17:02 clearly and every complex that God is
1:17:04 clearly what it means that means
1:17:05 sometimes you know the city it means
1:17:07 sometimes uh creating with a special
1:17:09 attention I do especially with a special
1:17:11 procedure which is not a common policy
1:17:13 or anything else like and if you check
1:17:16 the Quran that's the only places where
1:17:17 the hand has come
1:17:19 or a meaning confirming of covenantal
1:17:22 oath like those who give your give you
1:17:24 Bayer the Allah's hand is above their
1:17:27 hands that's very clear what that means
1:17:30 it means that if Allah would have a hand
1:17:32 that would be present like like human
1:17:34 bodies and so on his head will be there
1:17:35 but that's a meaning God he's part of
1:17:37 the Bayer he's part of the Covenant
1:17:39 and the secretary
1:17:42 to bury you know it's good to bury some
1:17:44 of these yes
1:17:48 I think the best burying of them is that
1:17:51 make sure that their governments call
1:17:53 out their traitors and when after
1:17:54 Capital that's it that's the best not
1:17:56 getting the regime the regime yeah yeah
1:17:58 yeah
1:18:02 the regime regime supporter
1:18:05 uh whatever the regime is it's going to
1:18:08 complete opposition and contradiction to
1:18:10 Quran and Sunnah that's that's why to
1:18:12 bury them and that's that area I would I
1:18:14 would really abstain from that area I I
1:18:16 wouldn't regard that area as of him
1:18:18 because it will revive some old things
1:18:20 so most of that has been really
1:18:22 overtaken and passed by the time like
1:18:25 for example like ashari and and
1:18:27 mathematri this is part of some
1:18:29 shortcomings and so on they have
1:18:30 essentially passed over that also the
1:18:32 philosophical discourse usually used
1:18:34 More Often by in the Shia as fast most
1:18:37 of that and this is most of that is is
1:18:39 being done even the philosophical
1:18:40 discourse in Europe has passed that over
1:18:42 that completely it's it's gone it's
1:18:44 forgotten
1:18:45 so it is Reviving like like digging out
1:18:48 Graves getting just dead ones which
1:18:50 don't benefit anything any contribution
1:18:53 sometimes you may need to do that to
1:18:55 watch them but I said that's not the
1:18:57 main issue lamination what's happening
1:18:59 really with State society and and
1:19:01 relation to government governance and so
1:19:04 on which is fundamental for human life
1:19:08 rights citizens rights limitations
1:19:10 strict prohibition of spying
1:19:13 take prohibition of usually all of these
1:19:15 things that's where we heard attack yeah
1:19:19 Okay so
1:19:21 I think we did a big Excursion let me
1:19:23 see if we can do one or two more eyes
1:19:25 but I think we did that a little bit so
1:19:27 that's that's the the issue of uh these
1:19:31 issues are unless you you are interested
1:19:34 in these issues will be obviously only a
1:19:37 small uh circle of muta can limit and
1:19:40 philosophy which is okay it has three
1:19:42 that's where this is part of philosophy
1:19:43 and philosophical studies
1:19:46 that's fine but be be cautious and aware
1:19:49 that that this is in in eloquent Arabic
1:19:52 which has also metaphor for resume it
1:19:54 has a it has kinaya it has majas it has
1:19:58 figures of speech and so on it has even
1:20:00 idiom setting idioms of the language Etc
1:20:05 so Allah is a light in Heavens and in
1:20:09 Earth he knows what you
1:20:11 that you express and what you keep
1:20:13 secret and he knows what you earn what
1:20:15 you do so what's the result of you doing
1:20:17 an ethnic
1:20:20 um
1:20:25 yet whenever any of their sustainers
1:20:28 messages come unto them they who are
1:20:30 bent or denying the truth turn their
1:20:32 backs on it next translation
1:20:34 yet every time one of their Lord's
1:20:35 messages come to them they ignored it
1:20:39 it seems to be both as a translates the
1:20:43 word Ayah as as message or verse but it
1:20:47 it here it seems to be from the coming
1:20:49 after that about miracles and so on and
1:20:51 asking for Americans it may be here I
1:20:53 because you know I has two main meaning
1:20:55 in the Quran one is a sign
1:20:58 proving that the one who did it is is a
1:21:00 Divine
1:21:01 being this is Miracle or miraculous
1:21:05 event and one is the version of the
1:21:08 Quran which are also miraculous in
1:21:10 themselves but this needs a very deep
1:21:12 obviously discourse
1:21:14 and this seems to be I'm more inclined
1:21:17 to say but it means both but the second
1:21:20 meaning should be stressed more than the
1:21:22 first meeting and the first meeting was
1:21:23 today by the board translated is that
1:21:25 meaning Ayah is a message or reverse
1:21:26 from the Lord then they ignore it and
1:21:29 then away from it but it seems to be
1:21:31 here well that's true that's definitely
1:21:34 true that's that's a that's a that's the
1:21:36 benefit that's the accomplish of the
1:21:38 Quran to have one sentence having
1:21:39 several meanings and all of them are
1:21:41 equally true but one of them is maybe
1:21:44 more befitting for the context and the
1:21:46 other ones are still correct and can be
1:21:48 used in other contexts
1:21:49 so whenever they receive a sign
1:21:52 of their lord let's keep the word seven
1:21:54 neutral it could be a sign being a
1:21:56 revealed verse and can be assigned be
1:21:57 like a miraculous event
1:22:00 from their lord from the sustainer from
1:22:02 their lord I don't like sustainable
1:22:04 because this is it sounds like like
1:22:06 salafi will have a translation there's
1:22:08 no it's not a correct one it's not the
1:22:09 standard Lord It's Lord
1:22:11 which is owner or master and ultimate
1:22:14 reference frame of authority and
1:22:16 legislation
1:22:20 none of these signs come except that
1:22:23 they turn away as if it has not come
1:22:28 foreign
1:22:48 if there's a reason for the revelation
1:22:50 of this Ayah it may be it has been
1:22:52 revealed after they have rejected for
1:22:54 example the splitting of the moon or
1:22:56 some other signs which they have of us
1:22:58 have some miracle sign in Mecca you find
1:23:02 a very common point of view by many
1:23:05 people uh I don't know what's their
1:23:07 motivation for that I I'm at close to
1:23:10 that many even some who seem to be
1:23:12 islamists and so on
1:23:15 is that that the profit has only the
1:23:17 only Miracle he has whatever they said
1:23:19 is is only the Quran or something like
1:23:22 that but this is nothing is
1:23:25 the Quran itself but also by testimony
1:23:27 of history and relatives it has many
1:23:29 miracles and even in Mecca who showed
1:23:31 many many uh Miracles the splitting with
1:23:35 the moon was one of the most public ones
1:23:37 Etc
1:23:39 so uh it is not true that's only the
1:23:41 Quran there were many other things
1:23:43 isn't it is it possible it's because
1:23:45 that's the one that you can verify most
1:23:48 accurately today in the sense that the
1:23:50 Quran because it's everywhere no I think
1:23:52 it's it's is is is caving in front of
1:23:55 materialism and the and empiricism
1:23:57 thinking that the laws of nature are
1:24:00 some of that's the reason they try to
1:24:02 find for example explanation for some uh
1:24:04 for some Miracles or things like that
1:24:06 and go off tangent with some some
1:24:08 scientific explanation which some of it
1:24:10 is simply not explainable scientifically
1:24:12 and this is a disease which I invested
1:24:15 in the West
1:24:16 because if they admit that the Miracles
1:24:18 mentioned in the Old testamentals Well
1:24:20 the West is not concerned about Quran
1:24:21 until very recently only this they start
1:24:23 really some of them start get serious
1:24:25 with it but in time positive of the Old
1:24:27 Testament
1:24:28 if that's true it happened historically
1:24:31 then uh then all their atheism and then
1:24:35 secularism will be undermined but they
1:24:37 don't want that
1:24:39 so for some reason or another
1:24:43 so they have to find if it has happened
1:24:45 like for example this is a so-called the
1:24:48 so-called they will come in Surat Arab
1:24:50 next to all inshallah the various
1:24:52 calamities hitting the people of pharaoh
1:24:56 uh the frogs the plague all of these
1:24:59 things they try to find they they try to
1:25:02 connect it to a volcanic eruption in
1:25:04 1650 before Christ and some gases under
1:25:08 the ground and the gases were killing
1:25:10 the firstborn because the firstborn was
1:25:12 leaving usually in the first floor uh in
1:25:14 the ground floor who are the younger and
1:25:16 soon where they get to the top floor or
1:25:18 to the ceiling or something there and
1:25:21 this way these were killed because of
1:25:22 this gods and so on and all some there
1:25:25 are videos about that and such funny
1:25:28 explanation obviously this will stand
1:25:30 and fall with although this explanation
1:25:33 is esoteric and there's no Pro for it
1:25:35 because they found really Mass Graves of
1:25:38 really male only or simply in young age
1:25:41 essentially first of all something like
1:25:43 that in the average
1:25:45 and the only explanation is that maybe
1:25:47 those who stuck with a break
1:25:49 uh we're stuck with the edit sale will
1:25:52 not break whether with the final Miracle
1:25:54 of Muslim which is Pharaoh gave up and
1:25:56 let the Jews go out yeah
1:25:58 when uh the Facebook according to Old
1:26:00 Testament the first one all of her born
1:26:02 of the Egypt was stuck and killed
1:26:04 died or night and the people say that
1:26:07 because we cannot let these people go
1:26:09 otherwise we will be extinct there's
1:26:11 nothing can be done
1:26:12 they found Musgraves which is fit
1:26:15 through that time somehow the problem
1:26:17 with that with this gas Theory and the
1:26:20 eruption that a volcanic eruption they
1:26:22 refer to setting in Crete or something
1:26:24 there was a volcanic eruption but
1:26:26 there's no way it can be the time of
1:26:27 Musa it is every dating dated like 16
1:26:32 something before Christ 16 25 1650 as
1:26:36 far as I remember I I did not study that
1:26:38 in debt it needs really meticulous study
1:26:40 you know that I'm not saying is hand
1:26:41 waving algorithmet will work no no these
1:26:43 things have to be smashed probably
1:26:46 but all dating is like 1650 something
1:26:48 like that all dating of Musa in in Egypt
1:26:51 cannot be earlier than 1450 but most
1:26:54 likely it's 1450 but possibly if 1250 is
1:26:58 it Trump since the great or it is
1:26:59 trotmus the second and before him the
1:27:02 the queen what's his name
1:27:04 um patches wood
1:27:06 that time I release all this
1:27:09 and the first one 1450 so there's two
1:27:11 centuries different well no guys is that
1:27:13 look at anybody or produce massive
1:27:16 amount of frogs and things like that
1:27:18 they're ancient and at that time there's
1:27:21 nothing volcanic and so so all of these
1:27:23 attempt to connect that disease trying
1:27:25 to attempt to explain all
1:27:27 all
1:27:29 uh
1:27:30 and also the the the the receding of the
1:27:33 sea and Dominic so all because of the
1:27:35 Volcan obviously it was a tsunami and
1:27:37 the tsunami advances and Retreats but it
1:27:40 could take hours in the advancing and
1:27:42 the treaty in the retreat
1:27:44 assuming that the crossing the red
1:27:46 system is not 33 is actually the
1:27:48 so-called the sold the lakes of the
1:27:50 crocodiles there
1:27:52 uh they are very shallow and they were
1:27:54 connected to the Sea at the time it
1:27:56 sucks all of them and they came across
1:27:58 that sounds good that sounds making good
1:28:00 sense and possibly even the wind which
1:28:02 is described there has become also the
1:28:04 experience what kind of explosion did
1:28:06 that but there's nothing at the time
1:28:08 whatsoever so they're trying to find
1:28:10 some natural phenomena of volcanic
1:28:12 eruption interconnected
1:28:14 you see so that disease has infected
1:28:17 many Muslims no no only that we have
1:28:19 only the Quran always uh we don't need
1:28:22 to to mention this this material or
1:28:24 these Miracles because they they are not
1:28:27 uh they are not fashionable it's out of
1:28:29 fashion
1:28:30 and these things are out of fashion we
1:28:31 should not we shouldn't invoke them but
1:28:33 this is not a professional person that
1:28:35 such Miracles are there and definitely
1:28:37 and narrated by the water or mentioned
1:28:40 in the Quran and so you can't escape
1:28:41 from them that's absolutely no way I'll
1:28:43 come to inshallah in Chicago course
1:28:47 to build all of this I mean ultimately
1:28:50 you need a strong narrative to make an
1:28:52 equivalence between the scientific
1:28:53 method today and the historical
1:28:55 Recreation so for example right now
1:28:58 if you could if you conduct an
1:28:59 experiment in real time now that makes
1:29:02 it that's what the scientists take
1:29:04 whereas anything in the past there will
1:29:06 be some skepticism around us it could be
1:29:09 a matter of narration and proving that
1:29:11 it has happened but
1:29:12 some categories of these uh are proven
1:29:16 by themselves like for example we
1:29:17 mentioned several times the Einstein
1:29:19 conditions for prophecies that's uh
1:29:22 someone claiming to be a prophet
1:29:24 bringing a structured Prophecy with a
1:29:27 structure is understood Theory the
1:29:29 prophecy is very well structured we can
1:29:31 fit only to one event in the universe it
1:29:33 is not like for example the whole family
1:29:35 that you go to the Prime leader in some
1:29:36 maybe when you go to to one of these
1:29:39 amusement parks there may be a family
1:29:41 that is wrong you will meet a nice girl
1:29:43 and you have three kids
1:29:46 maybe 10 percent one percent of humanity
1:29:48 will have this that's it but it says you
1:29:50 will meet the daughter of the leader of
1:29:52 the Communist party she will fall in
1:29:54 love with you she will deserve the party
1:29:55 and come with you and you have three
1:29:57 children and she her name is so and so
1:29:59 on that's a more significant things
1:30:01 that's that's a sexual obviously I'm
1:30:03 just mentioning what structure whatever
1:30:04 we mean secondly that prophecy must be
1:30:07 well established and written down
1:30:09 Einstein said must be written cannot be
1:30:11 orally because orally you cannot trust
1:30:13 hundred percent I would say it a lot or
1:30:15 similar to that but we have Prophecies
1:30:18 of the time written down like for
1:30:19 example Daniel prophecy about the coming
1:30:21 of the Messiah
1:30:22 which has some problems minimal problems
1:30:25 but they can be all resolved and I think
1:30:26 I have resolved all of them and then we
1:30:28 have the professional example with the
1:30:29 about the uh the
1:30:33 volcano near Medina and specifying the
1:30:35 place Etc and we have all of that
1:30:37 written recorded
1:30:41 scattered all over the horizon so it's
1:30:43 impossible to write it back in the box
1:30:45 that's it if it's written but I should
1:30:48 have said in such a way that's
1:30:49 impossible to write it back in the books
1:30:51 that's a point so it's just written in
1:30:53 one copy of a book it's not enough this
1:30:55 could be a fabricated copy so what he
1:30:57 mentioned really written meaning in a
1:30:59 book which is public like the Bible for
1:31:02 example Bible since that fourth century
1:31:04 is public
1:31:06 is in hand with the people over the
1:31:07 whole various attractions their
1:31:09 descriptions it's impossible to write
1:31:11 anything back at it before that it may
1:31:13 have been somebody had been written it
1:31:14 and fabricated but after that it's
1:31:16 impossible the second condition
1:31:19 third condition the Fulfillment of
1:31:21 policy should after the writing which
1:31:23 happens after that but also he will put
1:31:25 a good condition there but the
1:31:26 Fulfillment should be not depending of
1:31:29 any action of the Prophet himself or his
1:31:31 followers because they may the prophet
1:31:33 himself as well may try to make it a
1:31:35 self-fulfilling prophecy
1:31:38 you see so if it is if it is not for not
1:31:41 within human control like for example
1:31:43 the eruption of the volcano in near
1:31:45 Medina no no no human can initiate them
1:31:48 or a volcano eruption neither that then
1:31:51 nor now maybe millions of years down the
1:31:53 road we will have discoverability but
1:31:55 not at that time it's impossible
1:31:57 if this conditions are then this is must
1:31:59 be for metaphysical Source oh oh Supra
1:32:02 Supra natural source
1:32:08 this is good for the people coming later
1:32:11 but the people visit at that time
1:32:14 they see the the the American they have
1:32:18 no Liberty to deny
1:32:20 because it's clear from those situation
1:32:23 surrounding situation that it could
1:32:25 could not be uh enacted by human life
1:32:28 for example the sprinting of the moon
1:32:29 this regarding was realistic it's really
1:32:31 splitting in the physical mood or they
1:32:33 will visualize the moon splitting which
1:32:34 is only created in their mind because
1:32:37 the people who saw it is not only the
1:32:39 people that are pointed to the moon so
1:32:41 you could say he that he did on them
1:32:42 must have hypnosis
1:32:45 what they call Mass uh what they call it
1:32:49 if you can influence the masses by by
1:32:55 it has been seen by people outside
1:32:58 Makkah coming and trade and coming and
1:33:00 Reporting the same so they have seen it
1:33:02 all of these people and even what I said
1:33:04 check whether people come from outside
1:33:06 remember Muhammad wished you he took you
1:33:08 for a ride he was able to affect your
1:33:11 mind somehow because he pointed certain
1:33:13 people to present a number few number of
1:33:15 people maybe he took you for life maybe
1:33:17 he was able to maybe he put some some
1:33:20 weed which like magic mushrooms and
1:33:24 Qatar just blinded you that's possible
1:33:27 but check with the people coming from
1:33:29 outside Makkah far away behind the
1:33:31 Horizon there is physical reach and
1:33:34 influence of Muhammad with sentitude and
1:33:37 they reported the same
1:33:39 so they have such seen that now is it
1:33:42 really the body of the Moon splitting
1:33:45 possible
1:33:47 is it these people seeing that Allah
1:33:50 creating them in their mind possible
1:33:52 Allah creating an image in the sky which
1:33:54 is not the real moon all these
1:33:55 possibilities the mechanism is not
1:33:57 available is that the people as they
1:33:59 have seen it it's impossible for
1:34:02 Muhammad to have induced that to them by
1:34:04 using of any kind of drug or massage
1:34:09 and still after that they say oh
1:34:11 Muhammad is capable of bewitching all
1:34:13 people
1:34:14 including the one behind the whole eyes
1:34:18 meaning essentially has Supernatural
1:34:20 powers
1:34:22 but no it's not from our lives from him
1:34:25 or maybe the devil some of them was
1:34:27 India believing that the devil is equal
1:34:29 and power to Allah maybe the devil is
1:34:31 behind him foreign
1:34:37 people like that is
1:34:40 manifestly absorbed
1:34:43 people will get will get and the Quran
1:34:45 will address that I said today will not
1:34:47 get to there but so back to the is
1:34:50 better aside sign being politics versus
1:34:53 the Quran or miracles
1:34:56 the word used for both because really
1:34:58 the ways everywhere is having some kind
1:35:00 of miraculous nation in it but this is
1:35:02 not easy to clean immediately while the
1:35:04 other Miracles extend America's material
1:35:06 Miracles are manifestly evident and
1:35:09 immediately to be able to uh to be
1:35:11 dealing out
1:35:13 so here whenever they see a sign from
1:35:16 their load be the sign being Americans
1:35:19 or something Supernatural or
1:35:22 Ayah which is intrinsic and itself is
1:35:24 really Supernatural in some sense
1:35:25 another but it's more like a very social
1:35:28 cardi than you can understand or reject
1:35:30 or accept
1:35:31 coming from their lord they will turn
1:35:34 away from it
1:35:41 um
1:35:45 don't say this one and so they gave the
1:35:49 light to this truth now that it has come
1:35:51 unto them in time however they will come
1:35:54 to understand what it was that they were
1:35:56 want to deride in Translation they
1:35:59 denied the truth when it came to them
1:36:00 however in time they will come to
1:36:02 understand the very thing they ridiculed
1:36:05 I think the meaning is clear so is again
1:36:09 that can be related to verses in the
1:36:10 Quran so it applies to every Ayah and
1:36:13 when those retain away from an Ayah
1:36:15 which is from their lord so by with this
1:36:18 performance if assuming assuming let's
1:36:20 make an assumption assuming this is
1:36:21 really from their lord as the Quran
1:36:23 assets that has to be verified on
1:36:25 another source but according to Quran
1:36:28 statements for us to Quran is already
1:36:30 verified so it is a absolute Source but
1:36:33 let's assume we are not yet to that
1:36:34 level
1:36:35 if it is from there Lord
1:36:37 and they turned away from it then
1:36:39 definitely with this they have the the
1:36:40 declare the truth
1:36:43 what has come to them as a being a lie
1:36:45 as we're not the hackers not not the
1:36:47 reality itself it's just just it's just
1:36:50 uh uh just a confused mental image of
1:36:54 non-reality or something like that
1:36:56 but in time they will see the result of
1:36:59 that what they have been and the News
1:37:01 related to that what they have been
1:37:02 mocking this is the threat obviously you
1:37:06 will see what what will be the result
1:37:07 and also the messenger relax they will
1:37:10 see the result but these things need
1:37:12 their time I need the needs their own
1:37:14 Dynamics to develop properly they need
1:37:16 their own mechanism to work properly as
1:37:19 it should be generally Etc
1:37:22 so that's that's again can apply to
1:37:25 versions of the Quran or miraculous sign
1:37:27 to any sign
1:37:36 but not manifestly evident directly like
1:37:39 the supernatural one Russia but even the
1:37:42 Supernatural and have been rejected like
1:37:43 I mentioned the case of of the expecting
1:37:45 of them and which is recorded in the
1:37:47 Quran which will come inside
1:37:55 I think it's best to stop here because
1:37:57 next time at the challenging to look
1:38:00 around in the universe and to see what's
1:38:02 going on and so on so they can analyze
1:38:04 if this is true or not though doing the
1:38:07 scientific method look at the reality
1:38:09 look at the previous Nation look at what
1:38:12 around the universe look what's going on
1:38:14 Analyze That understand it
1:38:16 do your research do some work do analyze
1:38:19 it do compare it with what what you know
1:38:22 and see what where it's going on do what
1:38:24 see what what has come does it fit in
1:38:26 the reality or doesn't fit or is it is
1:38:29 your assumption more valid or this other
1:38:31 one so sending the people to the set but
1:38:33 we do that each other next time that
1:38:35 will be
1:38:36 you have the Ayah
1:38:38 on the second the higher that we're
1:38:41 currently on
1:38:43 is
1:38:45 basically the one we should start next
1:38:47 time yeah so next week will be ir6
1:38:51 starting with alum yellow camera didn't
1:38:55 say how many nations we destroyed before
1:38:57 then yeah
1:38:59 because
1:39:00 I don't have any questions currently um
1:39:03 does anyone have any questions on yes uh
1:39:07 yes sir
1:39:09 can I add something please uh if if we
1:39:12 have a time yeah so I I I think
1:39:16 the last um the last thing you mentioned
1:39:19 that um uh Ayah hears me here means
1:39:22 either uh uh a miracle sign or uh uh
1:39:27 Ayah verse of Quran but uh but I I I
1:39:31 exclusively think that Ayah here means a
1:39:34 miracle sign you know because the
1:39:36 following ayas
1:39:39 are exclusively talking about miracles
1:39:42 to the other uh Nations before Islam so
1:39:46 so for example
1:39:50 Allah
1:39:52 I said but it's not exclusively it's
1:39:55 it's probably don't entry from the
1:39:56 context but it could be also it fits it
1:39:59 gives a good meaning if it's foreign
1:40:32 and also after that
1:40:34 but that they have denied the truth
1:40:36 shows that what they have received being
1:40:38 Italian a vegetable Quran or being
1:40:40 American is really the truth it's really
1:40:42 Supernatural Theory divine revelation
1:40:45 but in due course they will see the
1:40:48 result of their mockery yeah yes okay so
1:40:51 okay uh one more thing please as well
1:40:53 going back to the Ayah maybe a little
1:40:56 bit
1:41:00 um yeah you know I I just checked the
1:41:02 tafsir of uh
1:41:04 and yeah he seems to have repented you
1:41:08 know he's going back to the uh yeah to
1:41:10 the traditional tafsir you know he's
1:41:13 saying it's either
1:41:16 meaning that he who we worship uh he he
1:41:21 who he who we give our uh worship to
1:41:27 uh so
1:41:29 he's being worshiped in in in the skies
1:41:33 and Earth so so he is so that's one of
1:41:36 sin he says and the other one which is
1:41:38 not I I don't find it compelling to be
1:41:40 honest which is also being said by the
1:41:42 previous callers before I mean
1:41:45 he's saying that
1:41:48 he he Allah who is in the skies or
1:41:51 heaven and then
1:41:53 we have to pose and in in Earth he knows
1:41:58 your secrets and okay that's it cannot
1:42:02 be inefficient it's the same because the
1:42:04 first one is even worse because it's not
1:42:07 the only there are there are we don't
1:42:09 know in Sky if there are planets but we
1:42:12 can't assure that there are plans with
1:42:14 with the with the conscious being who
1:42:15 are pagans so they were strict someone
1:42:17 else also so that's the first
1:42:19 explanation is also rubbish is no good
1:42:21 it doesn't help
1:42:23 no yes
1:42:25 unless he said he's the only truly
1:42:27 Worship in heaven and earth but this is
1:42:29 this is the meaning of Allah so this is
1:42:32 all going in circles it's only running
1:42:34 away from this in the word in where they
1:42:36 they they they they either
1:42:39 space and time in matter of space or not
1:42:42 space and then you indulge in these
1:42:44 things I try to comment a little bit and
1:42:45 show this Hadith always as I said it's
1:42:47 not wise not very compelling but if it
1:42:50 is intimidated probably it may it may
1:42:52 give some guiders right right so so the
1:42:56 second interpretation he said that you
1:42:58 know we have to pose after a samawat the
1:43:01 skies yeah and and then we we could
1:43:04 start waffle art in the earth he knows
1:43:06 your secrets and what you reveal but I I
1:43:08 don't think this is bad because it may
1:43:11 may hint that he only in it he knows
1:43:13 what you're doing but in Heavens he
1:43:14 doesn't know this is all is not going to
1:43:17 get us anywhere yes it's a possibility
1:43:19 you can't post somewhere you can because
1:43:21 the stress is Heroes this is here that's
1:43:23 a possible interpretation but it's not
1:43:25 the one who comprehensively give you the
1:43:27 full import of the eye
1:43:29 um yes because I also don't think that
1:43:32 there's a akara where we you know where
1:43:36 we can no that's that you can't have
1:43:38 Liberties in that like for example one
1:43:40 of the in uh one of the nice uh places
1:43:43 where uh one famously that Egypt used to
1:43:46 read I think it is is it I don't
1:43:48 remember him now when it is about uh uh
1:43:51 when he reads the insula Joseph when uh
1:43:54 the wife of the uh Aziz said
1:43:58 she said
1:44:00 now the truth has come apparent I am the
1:44:03 one who tried to seduce him and that
1:44:06 here is the furniture
1:44:11 then he goes back says
1:44:13 the truth is that I that's it so repeat
1:44:17 that in the beginning and repeat the
1:44:19 second so doubling no stops after the
1:44:22 hat and start before the hack normally
1:44:23 if you stop like
1:44:26 you stop it and allowed to understand
1:44:28 now the truth has come apparent indeed I
1:44:31 I have tries to seduce him
1:44:35 that's that's good you can stop there he
1:44:37 does he does in the first run Allah
1:44:54 such a nice flavoring things
1:44:58 it's permissible that's no problem where
1:45:01 you stop and go back do you go back to
1:45:03 the point of stop or you go a little bit
1:45:04 so connect the meaning you have the
1:45:07 Liberty that's that's one of the
1:45:08 Miracles nation of the Quran
1:45:10 yes yes because you know I I thought
1:45:13 that we should be strictly following
1:45:15 like uh one of them
1:45:18 the problem I think we discussed that
1:45:20 maybe you have not been president we
1:45:22 discussed at the beginning about the
1:45:23 karate
1:45:25 said the fundamental thing is which he
1:45:29 says
1:45:32 written without dots so any dotting
1:45:36 which is not completely nonsensical
1:45:38 making no sense non-arabic
1:45:40 any other thing which has Arabic sense
1:45:42 like for example he said about you
1:45:44 insult Joseph he wants to read he used
1:45:47 to read
1:45:49 and said reading of all the severeign
1:46:15 and then they gave up this man is not to
1:46:19 be persuaded
1:46:20 and then hello so when the day
1:46:25 when they were gave up they went
1:46:28 Whispering for each other plotting
1:46:31 and the oldest of them say you know that
1:46:33 your father took him over and it's from
1:46:35 Allah that you bring that son back and
1:46:38 you know what you have done to boost
1:46:40 Yusuf in time past you go to your father
1:46:43 and
1:46:45 tell him that I'm not going until he
1:46:47 gives you elusia to come back I'm just
1:46:48 going to go that's it so they were
1:46:49 discussing that that's the general
1:46:52 foreign
1:47:25 because it may hint to us
1:47:28 if we allow us to read that and the
1:47:30 thing is it may be because your
1:47:32 colonialism
1:47:34 meaning at that time they have because
1:47:36 there are theory that camels have been
1:47:38 domesticated after that there was a
1:47:40 theory going around I think it really is
1:47:42 killed because they did not find some
1:47:44 bones of comes in Palestine except in
1:47:46 like 13 uh World cries something before
1:47:49 that they were barely found there who
1:47:51 said you have to find bones to know that
1:47:53 the comments were demonstrated before
1:47:55 maybe they demonstrated Millennia before
1:47:57 but they were very very few in Palestine
1:48:00 and and we know that that they are
1:48:02 common so on we're living a Badu in life
1:48:05 so most most likely than there were very
1:48:09 few camels and they have very good
1:48:10 comments mostly came from their cousins
1:48:12 of that is my life from Arabia who are
1:48:14 the rest of Palestine they have cows
1:48:15 donkeys and Tony pigs and they don't
1:48:17 have comments badly comments so they
1:48:20 then find in 13 50 or so on any common
1:48:22 uh except after 1350 doesn't mean there
1:48:25 were no comments
1:48:27 so the Quran gave us a hint they have at
1:48:30 least the house of being Bedouin living
1:48:32 in Badoo they were living as bedrooms
1:48:36 so they were riding really well well
1:48:40 developed racing uh uh
1:48:44 comments so it gives a bit of
1:48:46 information which refuses these idiots
1:48:49 who claim that their comments were not
1:48:50 domesticated at least in Palestine until
1:48:52 1350 for Christ until we know Yakov is
1:48:55 definitely 1850 or something at least no
1:48:58 less than that
1:48:59 or something like that or maybe two
1:49:01 thousand no no 1850s that's a good
1:49:03 number of 19 before Christ 1900 yes no
1:49:06 1900 or 85. so so according to these
1:49:10 idiots of archeology because they didn't
1:49:11 find any camel bone
1:49:15 there were a few comments at the house
1:49:16 of world and they didn't leave anyone
1:49:19 the one who got extinct because to find
1:49:21 wounds you must have thousand times all
1:49:23 kinds of animals and few few bones
1:49:25 survive that is to get crashed against
1:49:27 either by Animals by by hyen Slice on
1:49:29 nothing remains but these idiots of
1:49:32 so-called archeology sometimes as
1:49:35 donkeys and the Quran is giving us a
1:49:37 hint that said that don't listen to
1:49:39 these donkeys and they have been
1:49:40 comments there few Maybe
1:49:42 a few first class but they were
1:49:45 so calling somebody
1:49:47 idiot I think it's a anyway the people
1:49:50 at the time they did not stomach that
1:49:52 and they made made a session of tawa and
1:49:56 they forced him to sign the tower
1:49:57 exactly like a birthday I mean
1:50:02 but I think they went overboard because
1:50:04 they did not recognize that the Quran is
1:50:07 revealed is such a as a text as that it
1:50:09 as a written without the dots
1:50:11 deliberately giving opportunity I have
1:50:13 also done some nice play with the
1:50:16 umidan different
1:50:29 you will be stunned with a result
1:50:34 that's that's that's maybe another layer
1:50:36 of the Quran which we start to detect
1:50:38 now
1:50:41 okay
1:50:42 good leave that with a good time we'll
1:50:45 have opportunity down the road and one
1:50:47 example of that in sorted araf we will
1:50:49 get to it inshallah
1:50:50 next time
1:50:53 which we will follow me will not follow
1:50:55 100 but we will maybe dare to do
1:50:58 something similar to a vision boot in
1:51:00 one place as a good alternative but
1:51:02 leave it to its good time but Allah
1:51:04 gives us life we'll get there if we die
1:51:06 before then that's it you have to get it
1:51:09 by yourself exactly
1:51:32 thank you
1:51:34 thank you
1:51:38 Music
1:51:46 Music
1:51:52 Music
1:51:58 latency is
1:52:01 Music
1:52:10 Music