0:00:06 Music
0:00:19 thank you
0:00:20 Music
0:00:35 welcome dear visit the viewers brothers
0:00:38 and sisters to episode 110 over the
0:00:40 first sessions of the noble Quran with
0:00:42 Professor Dr Muhammad al-masari these
0:00:46 episodes are broadcast live on the study
0:00:47 Circles of Professor Dr Mohammed the
0:00:50 Mastery YouTube channel every Sunday at
0:00:52 2PM British summer time we invite you to
0:00:55 subscribe to the channel and activate
0:00:56 the notification Bell for all new
0:00:58 content please note also the link to the
0:01:00 live broadcast for why the dissemination
0:01:02 do not forget to interact with us during
0:01:04 the broadcast by participating in the
0:01:06 comments and asking questions through
0:01:08 the chat box you will you will find via
0:01:10 the broadcast link next to the video
0:01:12 also do not forget to support our
0:01:13 activities by donating when asking
0:01:15 questions in the conversation or through
0:01:17 the thank you button under our video
0:01:19 today is Sunday the 25th of September
0:01:22 the doctor continues with interpretation
0:01:25 of the fears of Surat al-maida
0:01:29 Ayah 94.
0:01:33 at the end we'll have half an hour
0:01:35 discussing what's going on in Iran and
0:01:37 issues related the enforcement of the
0:01:38 state of certain regulations but that's
0:01:41 to the end
0:01:54 go ahead start sometimes Solutions
0:01:57 oh you who have attained to face most
0:01:59 certainly God will try you by means of
0:02:01 the game which may we come within the
0:02:04 reach of your hands and your weapons
0:02:06 while you are on pilgrimage for that God
0:02:09 might Mark out of the out those who fear
0:02:11 Him although he is beyond the reach of
0:02:14 human perception and as for him who
0:02:18 after all this transgresses the Browns
0:02:20 of what is Right Grievous suffering
0:02:23 awaits him next translation Believers
0:02:26 God it is sure to tempt you with Wild
0:02:28 games that come Within Reach of your
0:02:30 hands and weapon so he can identify
0:02:33 those who fear Him even though they
0:02:35 think he is not watching whoever
0:02:37 oversteps the limit will have a painful
0:02:39 punishment
0:02:41 okay a few things there that says okay
0:02:44 because the swallow started also they
0:02:46 showed hunting that in the in the in the
0:02:49 right sanctuary of Mecca which is well
0:02:52 marked and well known since the time of
0:02:54 Abraham has been tested by the certain
0:02:57 Market which have been a renewed and
0:02:59 repainted time of Rocket and well-being
0:03:01 will be will usually they're usually
0:03:04 renewed every few decades by painting
0:03:06 and enforcing that the stone so it is
0:03:08 like a block of stones on top of each
0:03:11 other no it's very firm and if they if
0:03:15 they are changing a little bit over the
0:03:17 generations people add more Stones there
0:03:19 and then paint it white you see this is
0:03:21 the holy Sanctuary inside the sanctuary
0:03:25 uh hunting is not permitted at all
0:03:27 whatsoever
0:03:29 or otherwise you are living there you
0:03:31 are settled not settled and also cutting
0:03:34 trees Etc without one exception or two
0:03:36 but also for those attending to uh to uh
0:03:40 to to Hajj the moment they are in the
0:03:44 state of Haram they put their clothing
0:03:47 then they are prohibiting prohibited
0:03:50 from hunting uh
0:03:52 land hunting not sea hunting we
0:03:55 discussed at the beginning with the
0:03:56 Surah and then the issue is really
0:03:58 reinforced again we say Allah will test
0:04:00 you now with some easy game which you
0:04:02 can easily issue your hands and with
0:04:04 your Spears so Allah will test you to
0:04:07 know who will reveal him the word will
0:04:09 ripe fear him without being being able
0:04:12 to perceive Allah by direct senses the
0:04:15 word meaning see it is hidden Allah is
0:04:17 hidden from the immediate sense
0:04:19 perception so because it is since since
0:04:24 perceptions human being tend to worry
0:04:26 about what they see and hear and
0:04:28 perceive immediately so because they
0:04:30 don't perceive Allah directly it may go
0:04:33 out of your mind I think he is not
0:04:34 watching you or not knowing what you do
0:04:36 but his Rock he wash and knows what you
0:04:38 are doing and
0:04:51 I'm now certain it is faulty because we
0:04:53 discussed it several times they said
0:04:55 this is uh
0:04:57 this has to be interpreted that because
0:05:00 according to the faulty theory of future
0:05:03 events and actions of humans and so on
0:05:05 and whatever it is never is known to
0:05:07 Allah in advance alleged by at the
0:05:11 beginning of the of time at the
0:05:13 beginning of uh but we have clarified I
0:05:16 think in various discussion that this is
0:05:18 wrong this is a this is because the
0:05:20 future is open and this is subject to
0:05:22 Allah creation so Allah knows these
0:05:25 things after they have happened and they
0:05:26 will not happen without his permission
0:05:28 so he knows the possibilities and the
0:05:30 contingency but will it happen or what
0:05:32 will happen exactly how it will happen
0:05:34 has to materialize in time and that
0:05:37 Allah knows that it has happened as
0:05:39 original known to be possible to happen
0:05:41 it's a bit complex but we discussed it
0:05:44 so there's no need to say that Allah may
0:05:47 know has to be reinterpreted that's
0:05:49 that's what Allah origin was come a
0:05:51 reality that's that's our wrong
0:05:52 interpretation which leads to joburg
0:05:55 meaning fatalism
0:05:58 the catastrophe of fatalities is not
0:06:01 that fatalism this is that Human Action
0:06:03 and human will is is just a an illusion
0:06:05 it's not true the worst aspect of it is
0:06:08 that Allah doesn't become become a free
0:06:10 agent he becomes like a dead nature
0:06:13 which acting by necessity I think we
0:06:15 discussed that several times that there
0:06:16 was various discussion in in various
0:06:19 Arabic but we did not have maybe we
0:06:22 should one day have a series of English
0:06:24 discussion about that and the best thing
0:06:27 is maybe to wait until I have completed
0:06:29 the book in Arabic we get it translated
0:06:31 uh about Qatar specifically and and then
0:06:35 outside the transition we may have
0:06:37 Holocaust related to that but definitely
0:06:39 all these old theories are based on
0:06:42 faulty assumptions about the nature of
0:06:45 divine knowledge not recognizing that
0:06:48 that the essential or most important
0:06:51 Divine attribute is necessarily existing
0:06:53 and absolute freedom and sovereignty and
0:06:56 the there's obviously definitely
0:06:58 knowledge knowledge related to anything
0:07:00 knowable but the future events are not
0:07:03 yet knowable until I decided that they
0:07:05 happen when they happen then they become
0:07:07 knowable not before because they don't
0:07:09 exist so it's impossible to know exactly
0:07:11 like the the Divine the unlimited and
0:07:14 comprehensive divine power does not
0:07:16 extend to the uh will essentially and
0:07:19 rationally impossible so it is a
0:07:22 question like can God split himself into
0:07:24 no that's that's a absolute question
0:07:27 because the divine power although
0:07:29 unlimited but it is relating only to
0:07:32 contingencies possible things impossible
0:07:35 things that is by themselves like no no
0:07:37 question like that can Allah negative
0:07:39 himself
0:07:41 a child of Divine Essence meaning he can
0:07:44 split some of his being and become a
0:07:47 civil right being all of these things
0:07:48 are impossibilities and the divine power
0:07:50 does not accent to that it's ill-defined
0:07:53 has nothing to do with power because it
0:07:55 will validate the fundamental necessity
0:07:58 of reasons and the Wonder necessity of
0:08:00 the meaning of power the meaning of will
0:08:03 so that's just a note you'll find the
0:08:05 Quran plenty of places and the other
0:08:06 classical schoolers
0:08:08 is already in advance but the element is
0:08:11 just has to be reinterpreted that it
0:08:13 becomes knowable for everyone else
0:08:15 that's not true it's really Adam because
0:08:17 it's not known who will fear him until
0:08:19 they fear him or not fear Him
0:08:21 individually the possibility is there
0:08:24 everyone everyone is possibly in the
0:08:26 future going to fear Allah or not to
0:08:28 fear Allah these possibilities are known
0:08:29 at every moment of time Allah knows all
0:08:31 the contingency next for the next moment
0:08:34 but which one will realize some of them
0:08:36 he decide to realize them by force some
0:08:39 he give give humans the ability to make
0:08:41 a free choice on that and then after
0:08:43 that then the result is known Etc so it
0:08:47 does not create any contradiction the
0:08:49 other point of view will make will
0:08:51 necessarily necessary that Allah is
0:08:54 becoming a a deaf-blind dead nature and
0:08:58 not a a free agent and by foreign
0:09:03 either he's absolutely free
0:09:07 behind any bound or any condition my
0:09:09 condition him or he is absolutely
0:09:11 non-free for the foreign
0:09:17 that can be for contingent being it's
0:09:20 very possible that animals have a
0:09:22 certain limited free will they can
0:09:23 choose between various food and so on or
0:09:26 instinctively but but there's still some
0:09:29 choice you can test even your own dog or
0:09:31 your cat about these things and you see
0:09:33 that they have some kind of choice and
0:09:35 that goes higher to a human who can show
0:09:37 his even Destiny can show his
0:09:39 show is can make his own future more
0:09:43 more effectively much more effectively
0:09:45 than animals animals are almost almost
0:09:47 mechanism but with a bit of choice
0:09:49 humans are not mechanisms with
0:09:52 considerable Choice yes it's limited by
0:09:54 whatever whatever in the universe
0:09:57 on the on the the necessities of nature
0:10:00 but it's still a genuinely free choice
0:10:03 so that's possible for contingent and
0:10:05 created being but for divine our first
0:10:07 system means either zero or Infinity
0:10:09 that's either he has free will or he has
0:10:12 none and free will will be that absolute
0:10:14 and Sovereign
0:10:19 setting of necessity there's no other
0:10:21 solution for the problem except one or
0:10:23 the two so the problem with this pretty
0:10:25 Divine prior knowledge prayer knowledge
0:10:27 and the so-called the cover not is
0:10:30 something else we discussed that several
0:10:31 times
0:10:32 fundamental problem of that is that
0:10:36 it's not that if there's issues of human
0:10:37 nature always is the humans are
0:10:39 compelled with the fatalism this is a
0:10:41 problem definitely which makes
0:10:42 Revelation and religion meaningless
0:10:45 what's the meaning of injunction if it's
0:10:47 already known that some people will
0:10:49 comply and some will not comply and they
0:10:50 cannot change anyway
0:10:52 because how can you change
0:10:55 Divine knowledge meaning that Divine
0:10:57 knowledge can we tend to be acknowledged
0:10:59 and still and ignorance that's not
0:11:01 possible so it's not possible there's no
0:11:02 way but the main problem is that for the
0:11:05 Divine being himself
0:11:07 the catastrophe is that he will be then
0:11:10 acting by necessity he will be enchanted
0:11:12 by his own knowledge
0:11:14 better say he has no knowledge he's not
0:11:16 just a mechanism he's a dead blind
0:11:20 a mute nature
0:11:22 so there's no that's not the definition
0:11:24 of divine being that's exactly what we
0:11:26 have who is being refuted when we
0:11:28 discuss the evidences for existence of
0:11:31 God is that that the universe
0:11:34 has certain option parameters at the
0:11:37 beginning which must be chosen yes them
0:11:39 have to be fine-tuned for this is this
0:11:41 is a that's indicate wisdom and
0:11:44 knowledge but what we need is just that
0:11:46 they have to be chosen and choice is not
0:11:49 possible for for a mechanism it has to
0:11:51 be a free agent choose a and b There's
0:11:54 No Escape
0:11:55 that the choices are almost infinite and
0:11:58 it has to be so fine-tuned as an extra
0:12:00 extra bonus so the fine-tuned argument
0:12:02 is good
0:12:03 but it goes over the boat it adds more
0:12:06 than what's needed what was needed is
0:12:07 just there's a choice
0:12:09 it's going to be a dead blind deaf
0:12:12 nature
0:12:13 that's all what you need for the proving
0:12:15 that there is an entity which can be
0:12:17 called divide meaning a free agent
0:12:18 that's a distinction between a dead
0:12:20 blind nature which acts by necessity
0:12:23 and then he said no this may doesn't
0:12:25 make any sense to attribute to this
0:12:27 nature anything like knowledge why
0:12:29 what's the purpose of attribution what
0:12:31 does knowledge mean for a dead blind
0:12:33 nature it acts by necessity no need for
0:12:35 any postulating any knowledge or the
0:12:37 other entity which has a choice then by
0:12:40 necessity concept of shows that
0:12:41 notifications until that entity is
0:12:43 having knowledge
0:12:45 but if it has knowledge because it's
0:12:46 necessary it must be knowledge which
0:12:48 extends to all contingencies you knows
0:12:51 in Eternity for the beginning of time he
0:12:53 knows all possible universes all
0:12:55 continues all Necessities you know
0:12:57 himself all these decisions or his own
0:13:00 nature sufficiently we should not say
0:13:03 comprehensively because comprehensive
0:13:04 will lead some logical problems right
0:13:06 sufficiently all of that's known to him
0:13:08 then the moment the universe is chosen
0:13:10 then thinks that's the that's the Qatar
0:13:13 a universal set instructions that's what
0:13:16 has been written before the creation or
0:13:20 whatever that I had to say about time of
0:13:22 the methods before the before the start
0:13:24 of time but together at the start of
0:13:26 time that's the macady the structure and
0:13:28 the nature of the universe our universe
0:13:30 is shows in such a way that they will be
0:13:32 in due course not immediately in due
0:13:35 course possibly immediately if angels
0:13:37 are a really free agent in the sense we
0:13:39 don't know but in due course there will
0:13:41 be being who have a genuine or the
0:13:44 limited but a genuine free choice
0:13:47 but this really shows that the Quran
0:13:49 says could not have happened except with
0:13:51 Allah permission and every Every Act of
0:13:54 choice Allah must permit them to choose
0:13:56 whatever they choose otherwise they
0:13:58 cannot choose but permit the choice so
0:14:01 by Every Act and all the in the design
0:14:03 in the beginning and also every act so
0:14:07 as it was so the Ayah is correct and the
0:14:10 the meaning is
0:14:12 whatever you choose you cannot choose
0:14:15 unless Allah make a choice that you
0:14:18 choose what you choose choose whatever
0:14:21 you choose that's that must be like that
0:14:24 otherwise it doesn't make any sense so
0:14:27 all the eyes of the Quran synchronize
0:14:29 probably and all these all problems of
0:14:32 fatalism are dissolved not because we
0:14:35 are worried about fatalism for human
0:14:37 being although you should be worried
0:14:38 because fatalism meaning Revelation and
0:14:40 injunction don't make any sense and even
0:14:42 all what the courts are doing and all of
0:14:44 this is empty doesn't make any sense
0:14:47 it's just nonsensical it's based on an
0:14:49 illusion that that can't be but worse
0:14:52 than that is that the Divine being is a
0:14:54 new mechanism then we are going back to
0:14:55 it is
0:14:56 but if you go back to the atheism then
0:14:59 they may be in the nation somehow free
0:15:02 will have emerged somehow in a
0:15:03 complicated way but they will be we
0:15:05 always doubt is this Free Will so an
0:15:07 atheist cannot really prove that Free
0:15:10 Will is genuine because this could be an
0:15:12 illusion
0:15:15 the only guarantee that this is what you
0:15:17 feel as a free will genuinely feel that
0:15:18 you can really generally use without
0:15:20 being compelled by any other Bye Bye Bye
0:15:23 Bye Bye by by the food you ate in the
0:15:26 morning or by but the action of your
0:15:28 parents or grandparents hundreds of
0:15:30 years ago that all did not merge such a
0:15:32 way that that show is which you think
0:15:34 history is not free that's genuinely
0:15:36 free is only by the guarantee of the
0:15:38 divide the excesses over there in Divine
0:15:41 being and the Revelation saying that you
0:15:42 have a free choice and you are
0:15:44 responsible for it which taking this
0:15:45 necess yet that it's a genuinely free
0:15:48 choice yes it's limited it's a Wide
0:15:50 Circle but but in that Circle you have a
0:15:53 free choice
0:15:54 it's a very white circle
0:15:56 but finite it's not like the Divine
0:15:59 being which has no sense infinite Circle
0:16:01 if you if you're allowed to use the word
0:16:04 in for the second there's no limitation
0:16:05 to his freedom but created being will
0:16:09 have a center limitation well I have a
0:16:11 very small circle like for some animals
0:16:12 barely recognizable as a free area or a
0:16:17 very wide range of of possibility of
0:16:20 choices but still in that range he is
0:16:22 really a free agent
0:16:24 over the limitation the only guarantee
0:16:27 for that is is existing of God and this
0:16:29 is Revelations otherwise we have no
0:16:31 guarantee the other one can be always
0:16:32 argued to be early illusion and this is
0:16:34 one of the problems as for abdulbasa's
0:16:36 brother I think but is it most likely
0:16:38 that's the one of the main problems we
0:16:40 have with the theory of relativity three
0:16:42 things at a time like like space and
0:16:45 going for minus infinity to plus
0:16:46 infinity so I essentially having no
0:16:48 beginning which is formally mathematical
0:16:50 you can design a space called link of
0:16:53 space for that in that case
0:16:55 everything is set the future and parts
0:16:57 are there but you don't see them you
0:16:59 advance to them they are there
0:17:02 so is so such such a vision of the
0:17:05 universe a vision of time will lead
0:17:07 necessarily to uh to fatalism
0:17:11 whatever you argue there's no way you
0:17:13 can't get out of fatalism with yourself
0:17:14 you'll have to you have to portray
0:17:15 something differently
0:17:17 that is the the reality approximately
0:17:19 maybe in our neighborhood of the earth
0:17:21 and so on I discussed that with Abdullah
0:17:23 there are other physicists in time past
0:17:26 that's approximately description but if
0:17:28 you look to the whole universe it is
0:17:29 invalid time has a direction that starts
0:17:32 with zero there's no negative time
0:17:34 absolutely does not exist and these
0:17:36 mathematical models for that but this is
0:17:38 too deep for the general public who are
0:17:40 not going to go there but if someone
0:17:41 interested in that inshallah will be
0:17:43 having that for the people who are
0:17:45 interested in that but in any case
0:17:48 foreign
0:17:51 time is an expression of the Divine
0:17:53 activities and absolute control of Allah
0:17:56 and all events happening
0:17:59 are contingent and they will not happen
0:18:01 at large experiment to happen and act or
0:18:03 a permit some actor to do them according
0:18:05 to his will it's impossible everything
0:18:08 otherwise and this mandates that the
0:18:11 so-called Divine foreknowledge in the
0:18:13 way the classic Summer Classic
0:18:14 understood that he knows that you next
0:18:17 year that Rush next year will be doing
0:18:19 Hajj in Mecca is not true
0:18:21 it's possible that you know that it's
0:18:23 possible but will it happen we limited
0:18:25 realize it depending on certain
0:18:26 condition we still will come in the
0:18:28 future and some of them depend upon
0:18:29 other things who may depend upon other
0:18:31 hits they've been through other things
0:18:32 and that's all under the Divine control
0:18:34 and possibility of directing
0:18:37 in certain things Allah may decide
0:18:39 something must happen in the future and
0:18:42 you put the condition aside from today
0:18:43 and enforce it because with his absolute
0:18:46 power yeah that's possible but not
0:18:48 everything in the future is closed
0:18:51 there's no absolute evidence that it is
0:18:54 uh it must come there no doubt it must
0:18:56 come that it has a specific date already
0:18:58 fixed now
0:19:03 is necessarily coming I am almost hiding
0:19:07 it says
0:19:09 hiding it from myself but this is not
0:19:12 the correct interpretation he said it is
0:19:13 still not decided which what is the
0:19:15 moment specifically but it will be and
0:19:17 due course decided and it must be
0:19:19 decided after some finite time without
0:19:22 any doubt so
0:19:25 so but also also that had you say that
0:19:28 are fighting between Heaven and Earth
0:19:30 forever
0:19:33 helps from that what has been already
0:19:35 come down or has happened what the
0:19:38 Futures what meaning the Dua can help so
0:19:40 for example I would say the cover may
0:19:42 come down
0:19:44 is coming that you should die but you
0:19:47 pray for this disease that you pray for
0:19:49 Allah for healing sincerely and deeply
0:19:51 and the Dua is is able even to to pursue
0:19:54 to change that this again
0:19:58 oh that's all clearly that it's open the
0:20:00 decisions changeable and the Quran says
0:20:06 writes and erases whatever he wants and
0:20:08 he has the master of the books
0:20:10 Masterworks is is a metaphor for uh for
0:20:15 uh the Divine knowledge so the theory of
0:20:18 the fixed Divine knowledge or the
0:20:20 four-dimensional space-time which
0:20:22 extends on all these theories will will
0:20:25 contradict the age of uh the the free
0:20:29 agent nature of Allah that is foreign
0:20:45 except few issues and so on and they can
0:20:48 be interpreted probably as I said like
0:20:51 for example some people ask somebody
0:20:55 came down
0:20:57 uh that he will be ending the Hellfire
0:21:00 how can we understood that by the
0:21:02 openness the future is open yeah because
0:21:04 the moment that I was revealed Allah
0:21:07 decided
0:21:09 is essentially dead he has the those of
0:21:13 terrible for him have been closed he
0:21:15 will be stuck in his comfort until he
0:21:17 dies and he will enter Hellfire that's
0:21:18 it Escape but the only one that I came
0:21:21 not before before that I are coming it
0:21:23 was still open when the IM came that's
0:21:25 the reason some old people they they are
0:21:28 they insult or are abused with the title
0:21:31 kadari meaning had nothing to do with
0:21:35 it if
0:21:38 the Divine knowledge before as the
0:21:41 people claim for the creation of time
0:21:42 then Allah has no argument against the
0:21:45 creation
0:21:45 this is already in your knowledge I know
0:21:48 your knowledge can obtain be false
0:21:50 this is impossible
0:21:52 and this is a very valid and deep
0:21:54 argument but the people
0:21:55 have usually mocked the certain
0:21:57 arguments
0:21:59 and claiming that Allah is not telling
0:22:02 you the truth and he doesn't know the
0:22:03 future because because they do not
0:22:05 analyze things deeply
0:22:08 so the way the phrase
0:22:09 so that Allah will know who feared him
0:22:12 who doesn't fear is correct doesn't need
0:22:15 to be reinterpreted and Allah is not
0:22:17 known the contingency the possibility is
0:22:20 not every human being when tested while
0:22:23 going to Hajj every pale girl or every
0:22:26 Pilgrim who's going to Hajj and who
0:22:29 faces the testing everyone is have the
0:22:32 opportunity of this and this and only
0:22:34 the test itself
0:22:37 genuinely and who doesn't fear and who
0:22:39 is conscious of Allah so that it will
0:22:41 prevent himself from the easy game and
0:22:43 the other who is not conscious of Allah
0:22:45 but this has to come a reality then this
0:22:48 one is known as recorded as as a sinful
0:22:50 violator and this one has as a as a
0:22:53 writers and Pious uh believer who
0:22:57 accumulated the Commandments anyway I
0:23:00 think we Kadar is a very complex issue
0:23:03 we cannot take like this
0:23:06 which has been said the beginning of
0:23:09 time that's finished that's the system
0:23:10 how it is understood and there's no way
0:23:12 it can be changed except sometimes Allah
0:23:15 decides to break the system of the
0:23:18 universe or the laws by performing or
0:23:20 letting his purpose for Americans that's
0:23:22 that that is the exception of the rules
0:23:24 but that's done and that's it that's not
0:23:27 going to change the universe is not
0:23:28 going to be revamped
0:23:30 even within the supplication of profit
0:23:32 like for example when when the prophet
0:23:34 was applicated that his ummah should not
0:23:36 be having an invites and conflicts Allah
0:23:39 said
0:23:44 I have already decreed that that human
0:23:47 nature human beings will have a
0:23:50 different point of view on there but but
0:23:52 what I can give you is that
0:23:55 no enemy will overcome them and
0:23:57 annihilate them until they fight against
0:23:59 each other and kill each other that's
0:24:01 what I can give you that one is not
0:24:02 possible it's done that's that's that
0:24:04 that's good that's done in the beginning
0:24:06 so even that is not accessible anymore
0:24:08 things like that
0:24:10 was accepted so I'll accept it he made
0:24:14 three like any Prophet has a three dawah
0:24:16 which will be responded to and he said
0:24:18 he since this one was not accepted he
0:24:21 postponded for shavai or Muslim say okay
0:24:23 then I will postpone this request for
0:24:25 you
0:24:26 also like I said that's fine I give that
0:24:28 to you
0:24:34 nothing for himself one is that they
0:24:36 should not be annihilated by by a mass
0:24:38 Calamity like like a mass drowning like
0:24:41 a people of new or like like earthquake
0:24:43 and anything all of them completely
0:24:45 that's it and another one of similar
0:24:48 type
0:24:49 the third one that they should not have
0:24:51 the spirit between accept us no
0:24:54 that's not possibly not possible
0:24:57 so even though I sometimes cannot be
0:24:59 because it some some people make it
0:25:01 which requires the system of their
0:25:04 inverse changes system of the universe
0:25:06 not the individual case like for example
0:25:09 if you're if you have if you have a
0:25:10 cancer for example the normal or other
0:25:13 things is that you die from it
0:25:15 but this thought is not a necessity it's
0:25:18 very possible that you may recover
0:25:19 spontaneously and so it's also once
0:25:22 application you may you you may you may
0:25:26 also recover or on the devotional act
0:25:28 there was one uh some one of my data is
0:25:30 in Florida in the 80s he was studying
0:25:33 there and they have they know
0:25:35 um they know a friend of them he said
0:25:37 yeah and he felt something strange and
0:25:40 his testicle so he went to the door I
0:25:42 think he was studying medicine
0:25:43 this is this kind of kind of sarcoma or
0:25:46 something a very evil type which is very
0:25:48 fast sorry nothing can be done and that
0:25:51 that is already it's already started and
0:25:53 the moment you feel it it should have
0:25:55 spread
0:25:56 and just write your will and manage your
0:25:59 Affairs because you have maximum three
0:26:01 three months so you say you have a three
0:26:03 months do you think you control the
0:26:04 invest I will show you that you are
0:26:05 wrong and he went to comra went to took
0:26:08 a plane took omra performance came back
0:26:12 no cancel zero zilch someone could say
0:26:15 that's not what I call this is a place
0:26:16 that's the mind control of the body
0:26:19 whatever it is
0:26:21 but dying from even the most evil type
0:26:24 of cancer is not a necessity it can be
0:26:26 it can be removed by Mind Body Control
0:26:29 will prevail the theory of placebo
0:26:31 families can use by divine intervention
0:26:33 this is all right we don't know what has
0:26:35 happened in the background
0:26:37 physically this cancer is gone today's
0:26:40 less nothing
0:26:42 no not even signal to Castle no not even
0:26:45 anyone with the indicators and the
0:26:46 enzymatic there are many things in
0:26:48 synthetic tests and blood tests will
0:26:50 show certain certain characteristic
0:26:52 materials which indicate cancer
0:26:53 Everything clean
0:26:55 and many years after that he still clean
0:26:59 so
0:27:00 Malacca Maybe
0:27:02 just Mind Body Control Maybe
0:27:06 that's right we don't know Aussie Allah
0:27:08 know what has happened there but I would
0:27:09 I would venture it is because of of him
0:27:13 perform a camera and insisting that
0:27:14 Allah is more powerful than your claims
0:27:16 and you don't know the future the one
0:27:18 who control the future and trusting with
0:27:21 that having the the Deep faith and that
0:27:24 and going even performing Umbra was
0:27:26 sufficient to get it done
0:27:28 mechanism Chef the physical mechanism we
0:27:31 don't know that's interesting because
0:27:33 I'm I've been reading this book called
0:27:35 yum you are the placebo making your mind
0:27:38 matter so there's a lot of anecdotal
0:27:40 evidence of people actually curing
0:27:42 themselves just through positive
0:27:43 thinking I know it sounds a bit bizarre
0:27:45 uh but there is whatever possible that's
0:27:48 very well possible
0:27:49 yeah that's it just because I think it's
0:27:53 not that he has the power is it he rely
0:27:55 on Allah and perform um so I would say
0:27:57 that maybe but it's still positive
0:27:59 thinking so you cannot use that as an
0:28:02 evidence for an atheist not that if I'm
0:28:04 being accepted definitely not definitely
0:28:06 not because I remember reading some one
0:28:10 atheist stupid guy he's biologist and he
0:28:13 was doing say strength going to hospital
0:28:14 and asking people to supplicate and
0:28:16 record who will recovers recover I said
0:28:19 this this man is an idiot they think
0:28:21 Allah is like a big rat you put it in a
0:28:23 in a box and do experimentation it's a
0:28:26 joke that's not the way it works
0:28:29 but he he he thought this way he would
0:28:33 be able to verify or or deny the
0:28:35 existence of Allah I said that let's
0:28:37 show us a stupidity and other
0:28:39 mindlessness
0:28:41 the Divine existence is not based on
0:28:44 that some people supplicate and get
0:28:45 cured no based on that the Universe
0:28:47 could not have kids started without
0:28:49 every agent that's it that's it what
0:28:52 happens the address after that is that
0:28:54 the power of the mind is the power of
0:28:55 the Divine maybe the power of the mind
0:28:57 is just just a physical side or the this
0:29:01 this side of the metaphysical reality of
0:29:03 Allah
0:29:05 right so you interpret it as the power
0:29:07 of the mind but where is the power of
0:29:08 mind come what's the meaning of mind
0:29:10 it's just a projection of the Divine
0:29:12 mind in the creative Realm
0:29:15 because their mind and Free Will in the
0:29:16 create in the created being is is quite
0:29:19 shocking it's very difficult to
0:29:20 understand
0:29:24 if there's something which is is is is
0:29:27 unique and and almost like the the
0:29:31 statement something exists
0:29:33 until this this is just you perceive it
0:29:35 as a success or not exist you're
0:29:37 perceiving yourself that you exist that
0:29:39 you could not have been possibly
0:29:40 recognizing yourself existence if you
0:29:42 did not exist it's the same with free
0:29:44 will it is there but you cannot explain
0:29:46 it
0:29:47 because we have a limited uh limited
0:29:50 mind an infinite mind would regard that
0:29:52 as so obvious as we regard existence and
0:29:55 uh the the impossibility of
0:29:57 contradiction as obvious but we cannot
0:29:59 say because it seems to be much deeper
0:30:01 that's related to issues of mind and
0:30:03 free will but this is
0:30:05 a little bit too deep Philosophy for for
0:30:07 that but it's enough just to touch her
0:30:09 so even with the effect of mind on the
0:30:12 body and the placebo effect
0:30:14 maybe like a shadow of the divine power
0:30:17 from the precipical side but we can say
0:30:20 it in the side to close orientation
0:30:22 those studies do statistics it turns out
0:30:25 that the placebo effect could even
0:30:27 account in the average about 30 percent
0:30:29 of the healing that's the reason they
0:30:31 have to to have really a persuasive
0:30:33 proof that this drug or this this diet
0:30:37 or this procedure is really uh is there
0:30:41 a cure you have to do to do a placebo
0:30:44 a double-blind placebo-controlled
0:30:47 experiment and for humans
0:30:50 but sometimes even for Animals the
0:30:52 reason is that because you as expectator
0:30:54 you may affect the animal behavior or
0:30:56 behave some in such a way that the
0:30:58 result comes out according to your your
0:31:00 wish so they have to do it even better
0:31:02 in the case of animals sometimes double
0:31:03 blind you don't know which animal is
0:31:05 getting that so you make a double blood
0:31:06 you don't know and the animals do not
0:31:08 know
0:31:09 in the case of humans you don't know and
0:31:11 the subject do not know and
0:31:14 it has been shown considerable with
0:31:17 considerable in many cases that that the
0:31:20 placebo group which is not achieving the
0:31:22 attack responded positively up to 30
0:31:25 percent so if if the other side does not
0:31:28 show 70 80 percent of cure then it says
0:31:31 the Cure may be just Placebo maybe just
0:31:32 a Mind Body Control
0:31:36 but this is these are interesting areas
0:31:38 you'll go a little bit deeper into into
0:31:40 issues of how the mind affects our body
0:31:43 and however the affect the mind how they
0:31:45 interact
0:31:46 and goes also on issues like these these
0:31:48 these these mushrooms and the drugs how
0:31:50 they affected
0:31:52 there's a very tight link uh of
0:31:56 considerable uh of considerable because
0:31:58 positive thinking for example there are
0:32:01 many people argue that positive thinking
0:32:03 or having a strong will to recover and
0:32:05 so on could persuade how it does we
0:32:09 don't know persuade the certain certain
0:32:11 uh certain grants and so on to produce
0:32:14 certain hormones which are very healing
0:32:17 like growth hormones and other things
0:32:18 like that or certain enzymes which which
0:32:23 cause some genes to be expressed and the
0:32:26 genes to be suppressed and then
0:32:27 contribute to the healing and vice versa
0:32:30 the side it affects like some drugs that
0:32:33 fix the brain and make you feel happy
0:32:34 and that feeling happy produce the other
0:32:37 other hormones and and enzymes which
0:32:40 affect other other so it will be like a
0:32:42 feedback loop it's very complicated
0:32:45 but there's an interesting area of
0:32:46 research for those who are interested in
0:32:48 in drug uh mind-body interaction and
0:32:52 Drug special Recreation drugs mushrooms
0:32:54 magic mushrooms all of these things
0:32:56 yes um but that's on this side of the
0:32:58 issue the Divine side of issue we don't
0:33:00 know it's right we have to wait for the
0:33:01 Revelation to clarify that for the
0:33:03 prophets we know it is it's not what the
0:33:06 prophets performed we know it is not
0:33:07 body it's not because of body control
0:33:09 it's because of divine intervention
0:33:11 relying on the Divine texts of the
0:33:13 Revelation the well-established Divine
0:33:15 text
0:33:16 check I'm just there's quite a bit of a
0:33:18 discussion on the YouTube channel so a
0:33:20 lot of people on YouTube they're not
0:33:22 familiar with previous telecast where
0:33:23 you've covered a lot of this issue so
0:33:25 there are I'm going to read some of the
0:33:27 comments if it's okay with you just on
0:33:28 this subject I know you've covered a lot
0:33:29 of them already anyway
0:33:31 um I think it's you know it'll be doing
0:33:32 a disservice if we don't so one question
0:33:35 is it's very hard mentally to accept the
0:33:37 doctor Theory so if I'll finish all the
0:33:39 comments and then if you get some eyes
0:33:41 or so it's very it's really very hard
0:33:43 mentally to accept the doctor Theory
0:33:45 because although I believe it is correct
0:33:46 because some people will say that Allah
0:33:48 is ignorant no there's nothing wrong
0:33:51 yeah
0:33:52 that's the same thing which if you would
0:33:54 say for example when you argue with some
0:33:56 question that the Divine being could
0:33:58 could not have from his own like seats
0:34:00 because he's
0:34:02 unspeletable cannot be composed it's
0:34:04 only one Divine being that cannot be
0:34:07 composed can't be split can be divided
0:34:09 they say that making Allah is unable to
0:34:12 do that no it's not anywhere that's
0:34:13 power does not extend that power the
0:34:15 definition of power our relates only to
0:34:17 contingency the impossibility is not
0:34:19 it's not a matter which power can relate
0:34:21 to although some philosophs a minority
0:34:23 of philosophers claim that that uh that
0:34:26 the divine power extend to The
0:34:27 Impossible like making one plus one
0:34:29 becomes equal three but this is another
0:34:31 rationally impossible because you can
0:34:33 then with the same argumentative proof
0:34:36 that Allah exists at the agent exist in
0:34:37 the same time that's that's obviously
0:34:39 completely
0:34:40 impossible rationally
0:34:43 impossible that nothing can be accepted
0:34:45 then Allah exists that doesn't exist at
0:34:47 the same time both are true both are
0:34:49 false does not make any sense
0:34:51 so that's the same the same but with
0:34:52 power people it can generally to absorb
0:34:56 that and come in the case of knowledge
0:34:58 they think that the future events
0:35:00 already happened somehow they have so in
0:35:03 the background because they were tuned
0:35:05 to think that uh no uh Allah is
0:35:07 comprehensive in knowledge is meaning
0:35:10 that everything even the future thing
0:35:11 but the future things are not things
0:35:13 that are impossible they are not here
0:35:14 they are not created Allah they do
0:35:16 desire them to come to come in existence
0:35:22 that's all that's possible the other
0:35:25 thing is impossible exactly like it's
0:35:27 impossible for Allah
0:35:28 suddenly to die
0:35:32 is the same level you have to persuade
0:35:34 yourself to get in this kind of of uh
0:35:37 thinking it's very difficult yes because
0:35:40 such statements
0:35:43 omnipotent or omniscient
0:35:47 easily summertize the Omni meaning
0:35:50 everything which you can okay you can
0:35:52 make a linguistic setting that like for
0:35:54 example you could say as I said many
0:35:57 times we can't talk very well and have a
0:35:59 statement which is linguistically
0:36:00 correct having no problem like like the
0:36:03 uh the the the square circle is very
0:36:06 beautiful this is linguistically very
0:36:08 valid but it's refers to nothing it's
0:36:10 referred to something impossible because
0:36:12 the square circle is a contradiction
0:36:14 itself is nothing which can exist or
0:36:16 even being created
0:36:19 if you know that that the linguistic
0:36:22 references could be completely empty and
0:36:24 absorbed
0:36:26 then you don't fall in the throne but in
0:36:28 this case in the case of Allah knowledge
0:36:30 Allah gave us already the keys in the
0:36:32 Quran many places
0:36:37 and then one at this the stunning ions
0:36:40 of the turbo which I mentioned Valentine
0:36:42 when Allah said that
0:36:43 that Allah has forgiven these and these
0:36:46 and these the one after the battle of
0:36:47 the book and he has
0:36:54 others are postponed to the Divine
0:36:56 command or Divine decision either he
0:36:59 punched them or
0:37:01 forgive them
0:37:04 that there's no other possible
0:37:06 interpretation they are postponed to the
0:37:08 Divine decision
0:37:09 either he will punish them or
0:37:12 forgive them and all the classical
0:37:14 scholar when you saw all book of tafsir
0:37:17 the mission is the three guys who
0:37:19 committed this untration I don't mention
0:37:21 that issue at all except
0:37:23 to say I actually this is okay from from
0:37:27 the human point of view it is postponed
0:37:29 that from God's view is not but Allah is
0:37:31 talking about himself
0:37:33 decision
0:37:40 he's talking about himself not about us
0:37:43 or how we see the reality we're talking
0:37:45 about his own decision
0:37:50 for the decision later
0:37:53 either they will be forgiven or will be
0:37:54 punished
0:37:56 there's no escape from that
0:37:58 so the Quran can I find that point so
0:38:00 you have to overcome this this this this
0:38:02 uh logical or Optical mental Optical
0:38:06 mental optical illusion that's a mental
0:38:08 optical illusion
0:38:11 you know the famous figures like which
0:38:14 you think the other two faces or it is
0:38:16 or it is a candle uh what they call it
0:38:20 uh what's it called candlestick or
0:38:22 something like that but they're very
0:38:23 famous things and many other famous
0:38:25 things you can't find the internet they
0:38:26 say yes yes Google optical illusion you
0:38:29 find things you would be you don't know
0:38:32 how to decide
0:38:33 about it because they are so confusing
0:38:36 for the eye and the Brain try to make
0:38:39 sense out of them there's a two two
0:38:41 faces uh facing each other in a bright
0:38:44 background or their Candlestick and this
0:38:46 is a a wise Candlestick in in a dark
0:38:50 room you cannot decide until you have
0:38:52 something giving you a balance the same
0:38:54 will have in the mind because our mind
0:38:56 is finite it's liable of optical or
0:38:59 mental Optical mint optical illusion
0:39:01 this element optical illusion ignorance
0:39:07 because it's not knowable in itself it's
0:39:08 impossible to know exactly like kind of
0:39:11 Lucky them said no is it not possible
0:39:13 the question is why it has nothing to do
0:39:15 with the power using the word Khan is is
0:39:17 just a it's just uh deceiving yourself
0:39:20 it says is a meant optical illusion
0:39:23 so there's two things that I had so one
0:39:24 is time relationship with time so as
0:39:27 human beings we you know we are subject
0:39:29 to the laws of time so you know the
0:39:31 question is in the Divine realm this
0:39:33 time of thing because you know like you
0:39:35 know the time is is the the time and the
0:39:39 passage of time is already defined by
0:39:40 those are some in a very unique Hadith
0:39:42 by the way I said the reason I say it's
0:39:44 Unique because nothing is that like that
0:39:46 in the previous scripture and nothing
0:39:48 like that the philosophers have fathomed
0:39:50 until very recently and possibly not
0:39:51 thankful and that it comes it comes in a
0:39:54 very strange context which shows that as
0:39:56 well I think it is one of the strong
0:39:57 evidences of that this is the messenger
0:39:59 of Allah now this is not this correct
0:40:01 and so on it's not much allotted so
0:40:02 you're gonna say it's by necessity but
0:40:04 he must have said that but there's no
0:40:05 reason to think anyone in the chain have
0:40:07 the Ingenuity to invent that not even
0:40:10 about
0:40:13 and take from him some Jewish knowledge
0:40:15 and may interfere in his mind but this
0:40:17 is not part of the Jewish knowledge no
0:40:19 that anyone in that time I do what does
0:40:21 it say say it start
0:40:25 the son of Adam helps me or insults me
0:40:29 or or annoys me
0:40:32 he says what a miserable time
0:40:35 is used which is essentially the passage
0:40:38 of eons it's not that it is the time the
0:40:41 other time the time they they think
0:40:44 which is called time the passage of them
0:40:46 the eons
0:40:48 was a miserable time
0:40:51 maybe the time because
0:40:55 God damn this day or something happen
0:40:58 you hear some people down to that
0:41:00 morning which I lost my child and under
0:41:02 the track or something like that he
0:41:03 curses the morning
0:41:06 and what is that that's okay people do
0:41:08 that why why it is hitting all of
0:41:09 Silence they said
0:41:11 I am the time I am a Dar and that he
0:41:14 explained what's meaning I have a dog
0:41:18 day and night by my command in my
0:41:21 activity appears to
0:41:24 other other beings as time and passage
0:41:27 of time
0:41:31 this is very unique let's clarify this
0:41:33 point
0:41:34 so when when people say Allah is not in
0:41:37 time or outside time so this is Allah is
0:41:40 it the time in the sense as explained by
0:41:42 the Hadith
0:41:45 you can make tears on that about the
0:41:48 space
0:41:48 makan
0:41:50 and the Arabic the word McCann is very
0:41:52 significant because McCann has to do
0:41:54 with possibilities than Tom Keen also
0:41:56 you could make players but scares the
0:41:58 strata Hadith say Allah is that is this
0:42:00 is
0:42:02 meaning he gives things there there with
0:42:05 their freedoms and their degrees of
0:42:07 freedom going right left front back up
0:42:09 and down so we give us the three degrees
0:42:11 of freedom
0:42:13 and he has all these contingencies All
0:42:15 Discount under his control that is
0:42:18 in Arabic luckily Arabic language by by
0:42:22 Divine Design if you wish to say it or
0:42:25 so developed but I I would say it has
0:42:27 developed that word in such a way
0:42:28 because Allah is behind the scene
0:42:30 directly this way so that's one day the
0:42:32 Quran will be will be written it
0:42:35 so when people say where is Allah is he
0:42:38 in Mecca he's in everywhere and they say
0:42:41 no he's not nomakan and Noma can is very
0:42:43 difficult to understand
0:42:45 but the reality is really he's the
0:42:48 McCann in the sense that he is the one
0:42:49 making Macan
0:42:51 and that's the reason even uh at the
0:42:53 time of of of of uh of Newton when he
0:42:57 was defining space and time he went to
0:42:59 the makan for the time and he said the
0:43:03 absolute space is God in success
0:43:06 so I think he's right in that sense if
0:43:08 you're interested properly
0:43:10 he's the one who gives the things their
0:43:12 their Dimensions right left front back
0:43:15 up down that's the three dimension on
0:43:17 the absolute space is the one who do
0:43:19 that so he is not in space nor outside
0:43:21 space
0:43:22 and the question I heard was discussed
0:43:24 even by philosophers and Timbers I don't
0:43:25 want to Bear them mostly it's maybe a
0:43:27 heavy a little bit heavier but I've been
0:43:29 see now discussed what's outside the
0:43:31 universe
0:43:34 is it for is it empty or or or full with
0:43:37 something he said no the evidence the
0:43:40 philosophical argument which he brings
0:43:41 which is stunning is that outside the
0:43:44 universe there's no emptiness and
0:43:46 there's no fullness there's nothing
0:43:47 there's no space spaces it's not defined
0:43:50 so it's divided in the universe
0:43:53 is to always overcome your imagination
0:43:55 power because your mental Optical or
0:43:57 Illusion you think that I can extend
0:43:59 extend extend and go without limit
0:44:01 that's as an imagination this
0:44:03 imagination can be controlled
0:44:04 mathematically as structurally that
0:44:06 produces a mathematics and the theory of
0:44:08 spaces the three dimensions phase
0:44:10 two-dimensional one-dimension space line
0:44:12 two lines
0:44:14 Surface three dimensions phase
0:44:17 multi-dimension space you can generalize
0:44:18 them to five seven which you cannot even
0:44:21 imagine I know some people have some
0:44:23 geometric imagination they can't imagine
0:44:24 four or five dimension maybe but anyway
0:44:27 majority of us were not able to imagine
0:44:29 anything more than three dimensions face
0:44:32 uh it's Etc
0:44:34 and it can be a generalized even to
0:44:36 infinite damage and spaces in
0:44:37 mathematics and so on in a consistent
0:44:39 way because it it depends upon certain
0:44:41 axioms and well-established procedures
0:44:43 that's true but that it is existing and
0:44:46 mathematical entity and can be free of
0:44:49 condition does not mean it can be set
0:44:51 outside the the mind at the mathematical
0:44:54 uh setups
0:44:56 the the reality is different than that
0:44:59 all the radical numbers but not all
0:45:02 things mathematical can be the reality
0:45:05 the same with the language not all
0:45:07 linguistic expression who looks
0:45:08 linguistically nice and sound represent
0:45:10 anything they may represent absolutely I
0:45:12 gave just the example of the square
0:45:14 circle
0:45:15 which is beautiful it's a very good
0:45:17 sentence no problem but it does it refer
0:45:20 to anything no it's absolutely doesn't
0:45:22 require not only does it fail to
0:45:23 anything another pointer now reference
0:45:26 it is it's referring to something
0:45:28 impossible so it will never not in this
0:45:31 universe or any other conceivable
0:45:33 reality will refer to anything in any
0:45:35 reality which we can define a circle and
0:45:37 square it will never refer to anything
0:45:40 and still linguistically it's very
0:45:42 beautiful I can give it to you and say
0:45:44 show me that causative and the dative
0:45:45 and then I get under genitive and all
0:45:47 these things and the and the
0:45:49 conjugations of the variables when you
0:45:51 can do all of that without this having
0:45:53 anything real either to work with
0:45:55 but you assume is something called the
0:45:57 square circle
0:45:58 and you call it
0:46:00 nominative requisitive etc etc
0:46:05 or subject and then predicate and things
0:46:07 like that but there's nothing there
0:46:09 so not everything which can be phrased
0:46:11 has any meaning or existence reality the
0:46:14 same with mathematics so language is
0:46:16 wider than mathematics most likely
0:46:19 that is that appears clearly if you go
0:46:21 to the episode those of you who have
0:46:22 studied set theory and maybe noticed
0:46:25 most people did not go to that level but
0:46:28 those study mathematics that krantor
0:46:30 faced the following problem is that such
0:46:32 a concept life because the set is a
0:46:34 collection of anything of which exists
0:46:36 outside our things of our mind so such a
0:46:39 collection then the question is uh
0:46:44 than the set of all sets does something
0:46:46 like that exists it's impossible because
0:46:48 if it is so that it must contain itself
0:46:50 as an element but they're not possible
0:46:52 because there's objects or thinking or
0:46:54 our linguistic expression
0:46:56 so it's impossible and but if it but but
0:46:58 if but if it contains selfishness but it
0:47:02 must contain a cell because it's a
0:47:03 collection of everything conceivable and
0:47:05 she is conceivable it must be an element
0:47:06 of itself so it's a contradiction so the
0:47:09 the phrase the set of all sets
0:47:14 is null
0:47:16 just a linguistic reference exactly the
0:47:19 X-ray Circle
0:47:20 understood obviously the conclusion of
0:47:23 set mathematical development so
0:47:25 mathematics relate to sets essentially
0:47:27 every mathematical uh area of the
0:47:31 discourse can be phrased in a language
0:47:33 of set theory
0:47:35 every
0:47:36 including even the old-fashioned
0:47:38 arithmetics one plus one is two Etc a
0:47:41 piano can be placed in an informal set
0:47:43 theory
0:47:44 still there are both things there which
0:47:47 can be expressed linguistically but they
0:47:48 don't exert anything mathematical even
0:47:50 in the mind
0:47:54 but I think it went a bit too deep for
0:47:56 the majority of the people it's not it
0:47:58 may be helpful for some it may be
0:47:59 helpful for some so don't be don't don't
0:48:03 in this situation you have a mental
0:48:05 mental Optical illusionment optical
0:48:07 illusion how to clarify it the book of
0:48:09 Allah helps in clarified it
0:48:12 so it must be the investment to be the
0:48:14 correct thing and my illusion is the
0:48:16 wrong thing again there is contention
0:48:18 because obviously the vast because over
0:48:21 a thousands of years the people went
0:48:22 through that channel yeah you know
0:48:28 that interpretation is is you know it
0:48:31 hasn't really been expanded so there's a
0:48:33 presupposition I said no classical
0:48:34 school I discussed that ever except and
0:48:36 he said claim that to run away from the
0:48:38 problem with half a sentence
0:48:40 as a matter of fact also the argument
0:48:42 about that assuming assuming that the
0:48:45 future is known as individual events
0:48:47 will make Allah not a free agent was
0:48:50 actually argued by someone in Hashem
0:48:54 they call some people tell the Shia
0:48:56 broadcast
0:48:59 the the movement the believer of the
0:49:01 park because it seems to be he was
0:49:04 sitting in a window and was discussing
0:49:05 with people in uh under the window in
0:49:08 the street I think that's the reason and
0:49:10 the the Sony the devil of the attack of
0:49:14 the Wind
0:49:16 anyway we don't care about the title he
0:49:19 made this argument
0:49:21 when razi and his tafsir which is really
0:49:24 good sometimes in issues of el mulkaram
0:49:26 and philosophy he mentioned this he
0:49:27 mentioned the argument of of uh of uh of
0:49:31 what that he what did he do he said how
0:49:35 come say this because of this and this
0:49:37 is usually he argues and enter into into
0:49:39 Kalam and philosophical argument here he
0:49:42 said but what what he said but what we
0:49:45 say is that for the rest of the ummah
0:49:47 and the previous scholar said that Allah
0:49:49 knows things in advance
0:49:52 instead of answering to that and the
0:49:55 argument of is absolutely irrefutable
0:50:00 and the threat to the Quran well his
0:50:02 other group does not fit to the Quran
0:50:03 needs need the Quran to be reinterpreted
0:50:06 in a something which is far away from
0:50:08 the reality
0:50:11 that is that that Allah may know who
0:50:13 feeds him or doesn't fear Him say no no
0:50:15 it's not his knowledge already
0:50:17 and Visually he knows already
0:50:21 but it becomes then by the action it
0:50:22 becomes apparent to everyone else which
0:50:25 is clearly not not what the what the
0:50:27 sentence saying
0:50:29 it's a very far away interpretation we
0:50:31 should not take the following
0:50:32 interpretation until you are forced to
0:50:34 by a compelling reason and the reason is
0:50:36 is not compelling
0:50:38 the reason actually
0:50:40 create contradiction create issues which
0:50:43 people were not aware
0:50:46 in time passed in recently I can just
0:50:48 say in the recent 50 years
0:50:50 in European philosophy when people
0:50:52 started going back to the issue because
0:50:54 the usual if the ethic argument seems to
0:50:57 be have failed it seems to be the genre
0:50:59 consensus between philosophers that the
0:51:01 atheistics arguments essentially have
0:51:03 failed in general and that's the
0:51:05 philosophies who deny enemy the physical
0:51:07 statement in making any sense like
0:51:09 so-called logical positivism and so on
0:51:12 and which is essentially an an attempt
0:51:15 to make that whatever scientifically
0:51:16 proven is that what's proven anything
0:51:18 else is just but it's just empty
0:51:20 metaphysics
0:51:21 expressed in common languages the formal
0:51:24 language is the is the form formulation
0:51:25 it's called logical positivism
0:51:28 uh that this has failed it collapsed
0:51:31 so they went back or said what what
0:51:33 could be said about the Divine being
0:51:36 what's possible to say that what can we
0:51:39 do there and then they went back to
0:51:41 reviewing the classical scholarship
0:51:42 because they most of these philosophical
0:51:44 discourses to that level uh has done
0:51:47 mostly in the West in the Islamic World
0:51:49 everyone is sleeping yes the Shia they
0:51:50 have a bit of philosophy but they stuck
0:51:52 to the classical and they don't have the
0:51:54 courage there to jump over the shadow
0:51:55 yet
0:51:56 but in the west they come then there's a
0:52:00 discussion coming up with the Divine
0:52:01 freedom and the Divine foreknowledge at
0:52:03 the compatible not compatible
0:52:05 but also things which have come also by
0:52:08 discussion is that they know the
0:52:11 concluding that the the Christian
0:52:13 fiction of that God is loves us all or
0:52:16 is all loving or all being reverent in
0:52:19 the Christian definition is
0:52:20 contradictory under some some of the
0:52:22 scholars of philosophy now say it's very
0:52:24 well possible that God does not love us
0:52:26 all it's not available
0:52:47 so that was always what is the Divine
0:52:50 being it is all-knowing omniscient and
0:52:53 all uh uh Omni or Omni good or or only
0:52:57 benevolent they have recognized that
0:52:59 there's the only volunteer is not
0:53:01 correct it can't be
0:53:03 it's not possible
0:53:09 so people are coming back now after but
0:53:12 that that for the for them here you know
0:53:14 it was to come to that they needed to
0:53:15 come through and be like several
0:53:17 centuries of predominantly materialistic
0:53:19 or idealistic but uh atheistic
0:53:23 philosophies
0:53:24 and then after all of that essentially
0:53:26 has shown to be to be weakening and
0:53:29 collapsing
0:53:31 it did not collapse completely still
0:53:32 some some aspects and arguments have to
0:53:34 be slaughtered to be as scrutinized
0:53:35 further further analyzed but I would say
0:53:38 for all practical bears that has
0:53:39 collapsed there's no escape from from
0:53:42 facing the reality that that the nation
0:53:45 of the universe and the nature of the
0:53:47 initial conditions will will make it
0:53:49 impossible except to to a frustrated
0:53:52 free agent and they escape the usual
0:53:54 escapes the two-star standard escapes
0:53:57 let's mention them one is that it is it
0:53:59 happens by accident but the oil accident
0:54:01 does not make any sense and they refer
0:54:03 to the theory of statistic but the
0:54:04 theory statistics does not does not
0:54:06 convert it discusses a field of events
0:54:10 which is given and there's a
0:54:12 distribution function give me a few new
0:54:14 events given on the distribution
0:54:17 function then I can calculate few
0:54:19 statistics I can't get to the so-called
0:54:21 chi chi text the t-test that shouldn't
0:54:24 test all of these tests but given is a
0:54:27 field already under distribution
0:54:29 but then when the universe started with
0:54:32 the big bang in Singularity there was no
0:54:33 field of events there was nothing there
0:54:35 and there's no distribution so they're
0:54:36 talking about statistics and so on is
0:54:38 utterly nonsensical
0:54:41 I can talk statistics about we will go
0:54:43 into brand Cross Shopping Center and
0:54:46 observe the people how many go to shoe
0:54:48 shops always then make a statistic make
0:54:50 a distribution function then I can
0:54:51 predict the future what will Behavior
0:54:53 will be based on that information but I
0:54:55 have I have already a given the reality
0:54:57 and I'm reducing from them things but
0:54:59 before the reality access to well what
0:55:01 how can anything be static identified
0:55:04 some some guys try to escape like good
0:55:07 so-called Multiverse he thought he
0:55:09 thought he will be a super intelligent
0:55:10 guy of the universe by saying they'll
0:55:12 actually infinite many universes which
0:55:14 you don't perceive
0:55:16 and in each one of them uh certain
0:55:19 parameters are fulfilled and we are in a
0:55:21 lucky one okay fine but I probably does
0:55:23 not solve that he made the problem which
0:55:25 is one in our universe how come that we
0:55:27 are in this one with these parameters
0:55:29 how did they come
0:55:31 frustrating infinite may be making the
0:55:33 problem of this universe become
0:55:35 infinitely multiplied so the
0:55:37 impossibility becomes infinitely more
0:55:40 impossible
0:55:42 he may say okay because they interact
0:55:44 with each other if they interact with
0:55:45 the United interaction how they didn't
0:55:47 actually produce that it doesn't solve
0:55:49 the problem so this is all these escapes
0:55:52 have essentially been been undermined
0:55:54 and become become laughable only only
0:55:57 where all the people of of limited mind
0:55:59 unlimited understanding of the physical
0:56:01 reality or people who play game so
0:56:04 quantum mechanics you can't have a
0:56:05 fluctuation
0:56:06 like the poor Hawkins would say the
0:56:09 space and time where everything was
0:56:11 there was no time there was four
0:56:12 dimensional and entity there and the
0:56:14 point is called eternity and then a
0:56:17 fluctuation happened and one of the
0:56:19 dimensions flipped
0:56:20 and became time
0:56:22 one space damage wrote four spaces
0:56:26 nothing there everything silent death
0:56:28 Falls for damage
0:56:31 and then one of them first of all
0:56:33 fluctuation
0:56:36 study it and Quantum mechanism for
0:56:38 Quantum filtration is at events in time
0:56:40 so time's already there in the
0:56:42 definition of work quite of fluctuation
0:56:44 so how come that's fluctuation there
0:56:46 unless it is a non-timed like
0:56:49 fluctuation which in that case Hawaii
0:56:52 known to call it a free agent
0:56:54 or what I call this a fluctuation
0:56:56 secondly even that when one time access
0:56:59 flipping and becoming time does not give
0:57:01 the nature of time because when it's
0:57:03 flipped what happened to the negative
0:57:05 axis it must have collapsed into the
0:57:07 negative into the positive axis so it's
0:57:09 not only flipping it's breaking so the
0:57:11 like this
0:57:13 doesn't work this way but it's just
0:57:15 rather impossible and inconceivable
0:57:19 novel fluctuation can do that even
0:57:21 Quantum fluctuation
0:57:24 because that they mentioned in the space
0:57:27 Dimension according to the mathematical
0:57:28 concept of a four-dimensional space
0:57:30 every Dimension goes from another 32
0:57:33 plus infinity time goes from zero to
0:57:35 Infinity never goes negative there's no
0:57:37 negative time
0:57:38 it has to represent a different tree so
0:57:40 even the mathematical levels are
0:57:42 possible to do that
0:57:44 neither fluctuation is not even a Divine
0:57:46 being can't do that this is not
0:57:48 something different completely as the
0:57:50 prophet explained is the desired
0:57:51 activity which is appears as time for us
0:57:54 and we measure then here with clocks and
0:57:56 so on that of major collection may be
0:57:58 relative related to how we measure the
0:58:01 clocks how we synchronize clocks also
0:58:02 that's what makes Theory really valid
0:58:05 here locally quite reasonably but if we
0:58:07 look to the whole university it has to
0:58:09 become invalid but this is no solution
0:58:11 this is your physics can be settled on
0:58:13 physics
0:58:15 so
0:58:18 all of that's collapsing now the after
0:58:20 that has started to become Manifesto
0:58:23 collapse collapsing
0:58:25 step people started daring going through
0:58:27 the like the prohibited zone so if we it
0:58:30 is obviously uh and that that it is
0:58:33 meaning essentially that the Universe uh
0:58:36 or originated from something uh like a
0:58:40 nature or a basic law or whatever basic
0:58:43 structure or something or a basic matter
0:58:45 call it whatever you want whatever name
0:58:47 you give it is it is dead blind deaf
0:58:51 it has no will nothing
0:58:53 that's impossible so so we're back to a
0:58:56 free agent now we're facing the problem
0:58:58 with the initial receiver what's the
0:59:00 what's the limitation what's the issues
0:59:01 and the first thing has to go is
0:59:03 obviously the issue of forward knowledge
0:59:05 because it's great contradiction to the
0:59:07 Divine Freedom secondly has to go this
0:59:10 uh uh the the all good or or benevolent
0:59:16 there's no definition omnip vitamins
0:59:18 which fits in a Divine being
0:59:20 he's benevolent but only in that sense
0:59:22 and this is of Christianity which is
0:59:24 where they're stuck for a thousand it is
0:59:25 is is is contradictory and ultimately we
0:59:29 have to we have to have the conclusion
0:59:31 that the way the universe is structured
0:59:33 assuming is done by a Divine being
0:59:35 that's a free agent
0:59:37 with the necessary knowledge and power
0:59:39 he could not be loving us all they
0:59:41 they're the way they expected he may not
0:59:43 he may not loving us all hold
0:59:46 that he loves all loves everything
0:59:49 is is love
0:59:51 in the sense of Thomas Aquinas is
0:59:53 contradictory it cannot produce ethnic
0:59:58 so people are graduating after a
0:59:59 thousand years of struggle
1:00:02 well and he's already ahead of that
1:00:10 so I I know it's very difficult to
1:00:12 overcome that what you have been with
1:00:13 you especially if people repel to some
1:00:16 faulty I had it like I was once in the
1:00:18 Masjid but I did not like it was Juma so
1:00:20 I wouldn't stand there say this Hadith
1:00:22 has faulty that would have caused it and
1:00:25 we need to educate the people a little
1:00:27 bit like the famous Hadith that the
1:00:29 creation of each one of you will be
1:00:31 collected in the belly of his mother you
1:00:33 know the Hadith for three for 40 days
1:00:37 I said 40 days
1:00:39 Etc
1:00:41 and then an angel comes and he asks
1:00:43 Allah what what is it is it male female
1:00:45 what is it is is it happy and happy it
1:00:48 is
1:00:49 but this is clearly the text is 40.
1:00:52 because it's 40 40 40 is a misleading
1:00:56 and misunderstanding of the correct one
1:00:57 is 40 41 42 like the other narration
1:01:00 luckily we have the other narration
1:01:01 there's also a Divine protection of the
1:01:03 liquor so 40 40 foot is long it's 40 41
1:01:06 42 after 42 the spirit is blown and the
1:01:10 Hadith of the 42 does not say writing of
1:01:12 Good and Evil or something like that so
1:01:15 this is not written
1:01:16 but abuser which would be jobber would
1:01:19 be fatalism no it's not written other
1:01:21 things other than health and things like
1:01:22 that yeah we know there's the genes how
1:01:24 the genes will be expressed that's maybe
1:01:26 and even only the only the system or
1:01:28 specific for specific dispersion is
1:01:31 written because the genes could be very
1:01:33 well not expressed by by sticking to a
1:01:35 good diet and a good a good lifestyle
1:01:38 and other people who do not stick to
1:01:40 that for whatever reason social reasons
1:01:42 unlucky situation and so on they will be
1:01:45 getting expressed and they become less
1:01:46 healthy and so on
1:01:47 but the starting point of the genes and
1:01:49 so on the capabilities are there that's
1:01:51 what we're being written and what the
1:01:53 what show you this Hadith was the famous
1:01:55 one in bukhari that it's faulty is that
1:01:59 I think I think this is disproves it
1:02:02 that is the reality is that uh if we are
1:02:05 assuming blowing the spirit meaning is
1:02:07 the starting of the heartbeats which is
1:02:09 seems to be synchronizing with the fact
1:02:11 now that after six weeks the heart start
1:02:13 beating and also what is the the state
1:02:16 of California and America enacted that
1:02:18 up to six weeks abortion is possible
1:02:20 after that's not possible because it's a
1:02:22 new life I started I think they they got
1:02:24 it right there by just by medical and
1:02:27 rational consideration uh that is that
1:02:30 the angel is supposed to say my Lord
1:02:32 tell me is it a male or female but we
1:02:35 know male and female as essentially some
1:02:37 people say the same odd cases
1:02:39 essentially decided with the weather
1:02:41 fertilization
1:02:43 because of the X Y and X X chromosome
1:02:46 or there may be some odd cases
1:02:49 and this is talking about humans with
1:02:51 certain animals it may be possible that
1:02:53 they switched sex
1:02:54 depending upon the environment
1:02:57 but they have another mechanism of
1:02:59 operationalization and things like that
1:03:02 so it's kind of said this in comments
1:03:05 the creation of one of you addressing
1:03:08 General Humanity so even the singular
1:03:10 cases which may be
1:03:12 there's an issue with the sex
1:03:14 determination a little bit later what is
1:03:15 extremely singular and rare the majority
1:03:18 or the overwhelming majority of the
1:03:20 standard is that it is with the moment
1:03:22 of fertilization as clear as a male or
1:03:24 female
1:03:27 so which kind of angels as your sergeant
1:03:29 Angel whatever the angel may be maybe a
1:03:31 natural force or something like that
1:03:32 doing that a metaphorical expression of
1:03:35 the Divine decision to start life or
1:03:37 something well whatever it is maybe
1:03:38 interpreted physically to to come by
1:03:43 with something spiritually and
1:03:44 metaphorically it's okay I have no
1:03:46 problem with that but definitely that
1:03:47 part is false so that Hadith get it out
1:03:51 and based on that because the Hadith is
1:03:54 only from
1:03:56 Abdullah Road
1:03:59 point of view about about creation and
1:04:02 what happened in the video of the womb
1:04:06 is also faulty but individual of that is
1:04:09 not the same so where did it gets that
1:04:10 got it maybe he was confused by someone
1:04:13 maybe because they Hadith and such an
1:04:15 important thing should have been
1:04:17 narrated by many people than just
1:04:19 outside so that's the reason I I am more
1:04:22 inclined that the world is not really a
1:04:24 reliable Authority generally we have to
1:04:25 be cautious of what is a Hadith so in
1:04:28 every other situation if it is
1:04:30 look again after the text and see if
1:04:33 that's if that's contradicts something
1:04:35 also because it seems to be this man
1:04:37 despite all everyone agree that he's is
1:04:39 honest in this is that he does not
1:04:41 fabricate or lies I'm not doubting that
1:04:43 but is his memory and his retention and
1:04:46 his exactness up to the standard we need
1:04:49 definitely not that Hadith proves that
1:04:51 for example
1:04:53 so this one give us so a series of good
1:04:57 things to analyze bukhari and other
1:04:58 places and without many other Hadith and
1:05:00 many other Hadith in the Quran will give
1:05:03 us a hint this director is weak or this
1:05:06 guy is a liar or this like that
1:05:08 that's how to also use Quran but we use
1:05:11 Quran only the well-established hardcore
1:05:14 facts not that what you think the Quran
1:05:16 saying but it's really hardcore
1:05:18 corroborated with many eyes together
1:05:20 like the issues of almila or this will
1:05:22 say it's corroborated by so many eyes in
1:05:24 the Quran it's unscaable
1:05:28 if you see what this classical Scholars
1:05:31 say they come with the Hadith which is
1:05:33 usually the 40 narration is is brought
1:05:36 forward not the correct one the correct
1:05:38 one is that that Allah
1:05:40 you find the very same hero to whatever
1:05:42 happens
1:05:45 whatever happens events no what has been
1:05:48 written is not events
1:05:50 proportion system
1:05:52 laws
1:05:56 how things will behave how things will
1:05:58 evolve
1:05:59 not the individual events which may or
1:06:02 may not happen
1:06:06 so relying on a forced wedding and
1:06:08 usually they narrate various weddings I
1:06:10 say there are many the same no it
1:06:12 doesn't mean the same is not the same
1:06:14 like everything
1:06:16 proportion that system of the universe
1:06:18 how this could be equivalent to and
1:06:21 whatever happens then because you
1:06:22 imagine it is that what it is but it's
1:06:24 not
1:06:27 if I design a car
1:06:29 and have all the capabilities you can
1:06:31 access to this does it mean that that is
1:06:33 already concluded that it will not have
1:06:36 an accident and over and and flip over
1:06:39 no it's not part of that but it's
1:06:42 possible it is there
1:06:43 if it takes a curve two with a certain
1:06:45 speed which is not supported by the well
1:06:47 but the wheels are balanced and and the
1:06:50 shock absorber so on it may flip over
1:06:54 but it doesn't mean that it has to
1:06:55 happen for this specific card no
1:06:58 this is still designed to have to have
1:07:00 this limitation and your won't don't
1:07:02 take curves at higher speed than that
1:07:04 and so on otherwise you may pay pay
1:07:06 penalty by by okay turning over
1:07:16 but the people go by their imagination
1:07:18 because they thought because meaning
1:07:20 everything including the impossible to
1:07:23 know and the nothingness which is not
1:07:24 correct they don't analyze things deeper
1:07:28 and they got stuck in it anyway I think
1:07:31 we took the issue today we did the same
1:07:33 more cuddle than hunting and so on but I
1:07:38 think this is one one instance in many
1:07:41 other places in some places it is even
1:07:44 in the the in the strong uh foreign
1:07:58 let's see this is the testing is
1:08:00 happening so that Allah may know for
1:08:02 certain who is monograph
1:08:08 and many other Expressions similarly
1:08:10 what she lives don't know very little
1:08:12 place for for these hand-waving
1:08:14 arguments that this is actually
1:08:17 who will be one of the country
1:08:19 individually but it becomes becomes
1:08:22 it becomes what is recorded becomes
1:08:24 reality that's all no that's not the way
1:08:26 the realm means
1:08:45 will see what you are doing the
1:08:47 messenger and the believer will see it
1:08:49 and then you will be returned to the to
1:08:51 the the one who knows everything who
1:08:53 will account you for what he did or
1:08:55 something like that
1:09:00 will see you
1:09:02 seeing is essentially no for Allah's
1:09:05 type of knowledge also it's the same
1:09:08 but here you could interpret see what
1:09:10 what he already do it will happen so it
1:09:12 becomes visible it could you could play
1:09:15 here a bit of game but the word the
1:09:16 alarm is very difficult to get away
1:09:18 except by very far away and the way we
1:09:21 got arguments and even that will not get
1:09:23 away from us like like the one in
1:09:25 solicitoba uh
1:09:31 there's no way this and the Constable
1:09:34 Escape is the only one who ever
1:09:35 commented I read all tafasir
1:09:37 specifically digging everywhere did
1:09:39 anyone notice anything there didn't want
1:09:41 it all of them it is XYZ who and then
1:09:45 later 50 days later when I came to the
1:09:48 messenger of Allah and he told he was in
1:09:51 the house of um Salim and said Allah has
1:09:53 been forgiven these three and so on um
1:09:56 Slow Down slow down if you go out now to
1:09:59 tell the people who either people will
1:10:01 be rushing through and will not be able
1:10:02 to sleep at night keep it until the
1:10:04 morning then you announce it
1:10:06 that's the story you mentioned very nice
1:10:09 stories all of these things but today
1:10:10 sure what's my what's the meaning
1:10:16 has no meaning
1:10:21 the only places used if I remember
1:10:23 correctly is when when when the mother
1:10:26 the uh the uh the other class of around
1:10:30 Pharaoh told him
1:10:33 and his brother and collect all possible
1:10:37 magicians and and trick players from all
1:10:40 cities and then let them challenge him
1:10:43 in a certain day
1:10:45 research
1:10:55 anyway the only reservation from that is
1:10:59 that is that
1:11:03 one
1:11:04 give him give him a give him one to give
1:11:07 him a hope give him some time is it was
1:11:10 only for Musa and using this Ayah
1:11:14 I I would never check that again see if
1:11:16 it has but if it has used with only the
1:11:18 meaning postponement
1:11:19 so the Divine is
1:11:21 one for the Divine decision the Evan
1:11:24 decision is not happening yet
1:11:26 and the Divine decisions that's what
1:11:27 kriya thinks and makes things
1:11:29 which then become knowable
1:11:33 for that they don't exist
1:11:36 they're not even enacted
1:11:38 they're not in existence they cannot
1:11:40 exist without the Divine combat and the
1:11:42 Divine permission to come to an
1:11:44 existence
1:11:48 okay I hope this uh at least elevate a
1:11:51 little bit of the mental optical
1:11:52 illusion that's what they have is a
1:11:54 mental optical illusion you have to
1:11:56 overcome it sometimes you can't overcome
1:11:58 it it holds you back and forth exactly
1:11:59 like looking onto the famous candlestick
1:12:03 see it is face no no it is it's not the
1:12:06 two faces actually look again no no it
1:12:08 is two faces the 360 set the trick the
1:12:10 faces are made designed so that it looks
1:12:12 like a nice Candlestick and then look
1:12:14 again and you will never be able to
1:12:16 unless you do a minimal change there
1:12:19 but then you have you are not looking at
1:12:21 that what you in front of you have made
1:12:22 a change to it by by analyzing things
1:12:25 like that you make a change to that what
1:12:26 what making you be an illusion maybe
1:12:28 slowly you will be able to overcome that
1:12:31 I I need that many years to overcome
1:12:33 that for me this method that don't come
1:12:36 anymore alas but this did not come in
1:12:39 one day
1:12:40 by reviewing the argumentary the
1:12:42 evidence going back and forth checking
1:12:44 for example the classical Arguments for
1:12:46 which I've not had come checking the the
1:12:48 objection of of uh
1:12:51 um they accused to be uh
1:12:55 deviant Undisputed on
1:13:01 and made a big breed out and so no I did
1:13:04 not make a bit there he did the right
1:13:05 thing but the majority of the others did
1:13:07 not did not came on board and they
1:13:09 started fabricating nasty stories about
1:13:11 him
1:13:12 and claiming that he used sometimes
1:13:14 nasty language
1:13:23 most of it is fabricated but it could be
1:13:25 sometimes people get to him in a heat of
1:13:27 argument use certain certain algorithm
1:13:31 about the Hadith
1:13:34 I said if I hear that from from from
1:13:37 this narrator I will tell you a liar and
1:13:40 if you if I hear it foreign
1:13:50 if that's true then the Covenant you
1:13:53 took us you took from us when before we
1:13:56 are born when you ask us who is your
1:13:59 lord and we said you are our Lord and
1:14:00 you will ask
1:14:01 it doesn't make any sense
1:14:04 so people regarded as like outrageous
1:14:06 how can you say if I I tell him my son
1:14:09 did not memorize probably how it is
1:14:19 what's the meaning of the Covenant then
1:14:22 it's that's not what they took a
1:14:24 covenant on it
1:14:25 essentially meaning they accuse him
1:14:27 saying that Allah you know what they're
1:14:29 saying that's going to take the Covenant
1:14:30 this cannot be from Allah but he
1:14:32 formulates in such a ways maybe some
1:14:34 people regard as offensive
1:14:36 and uh impolite it may be I don't think
1:14:39 he formulated this way because people
1:14:41 fabricate about him many things and many
1:14:44 lies
1:14:45 like for example that he lies and say
1:14:47 this is from al-hasan meaning this is
1:14:49 nice talk or is nice statement in
1:14:52 reality he wanted to deceive the people
1:14:54 that he had that woman
1:14:56 but this is most likely is is a
1:14:58 fabricated accusation because a very
1:15:01 critical scholar like well like uh uh
1:15:05 Alexa
1:15:06 who is one with the authority in his
1:15:09 time in Boston or all of the Muslim
1:15:11 World a matter of men and analyzing them
1:15:14 and if he narrassed from someone
1:15:17 then this is actually this is that
1:15:19 certification that this one is is really
1:15:21 really reliable and honest until that is
1:15:24 many narrations
1:15:27 and he is not an idiot but here so these
1:15:30 most of these stories are fabricated
1:15:31 under where there's really a trustworthy
1:15:33 verse cutter he went the highest and
1:15:35 reliable authorities that one has
1:15:37 obviously not like what has many other
1:15:40 simple-minded Hadith Scholars
1:15:42 claim but give you example how it's
1:15:45 difficult was for the People by the way
1:15:47 this theory of Qatar or this criteria of
1:15:50 kada or previous knowledge is it was
1:15:54 widespread actually in the first century
1:15:58 in that sense
1:16:00 uh
1:16:01 uh uh uh music
1:16:06 Etc but they were they were they were
1:16:07 hiding it because the bunny umayya were
1:16:09 trying to enforcing Jabbar
1:16:12 who I am say we could not have taken
1:16:15 power unless Allah will that and it must
1:16:18 happen there's no way escape from it
1:16:19 that's it so they they did not bother
1:16:23 about about deforming people's belief
1:16:25 and Destroy people's beliefs and and the
1:16:27 story they established and Miss with the
1:16:29 Islamic belief just to cement their
1:16:31 power and make themselves unattackable
1:16:33 so the people can become fatalists and
1:16:35 not give up in a revolutionary activity
1:16:37 that's most likely how it started this
1:16:39 job and then it became compounded and
1:16:41 became also the widespread in most
1:16:43 Hadith narrator because most of them are
1:16:45 relatively simple-minded they are
1:16:46 narrators they're like recording device
1:16:49 like a tape recorder tape recorder is
1:16:50 not appearance of or a thinker every
1:16:52 code is
1:16:53 the best and some of them even worse
1:16:57 than that
1:16:58 so that's how it come in history and
1:17:00 then was cemented when the bus came
1:17:03 they for them this theory of as a ruler
1:17:05 is good it's a good theory that if Allah
1:17:08 did not want I would not have come to
1:17:09 about shut up don't open your mouth it's
1:17:12 very good followers
1:17:13 fatalism is very good for worse for
1:17:15 especially for tyrants
1:17:22 that's why it has come so there was no
1:17:25 General
1:17:26 attack against that from only Moon
1:17:29 started something in that direction but
1:17:31 he for historic situations when he got
1:17:33 stuck in in some secondary issues
1:17:35 related from that and the spirit of the
1:17:39 time is that the head of state is having
1:17:41 like an authority to Winter we will
1:17:42 discuss that at the end alsocialable
1:17:44 part of that have the authority to to
1:17:47 force the people incentive beliefs and
1:17:49 that's a mistakes that's not the Islamic
1:17:50 way that's maybe the Christian way maybe
1:17:51 Hercules and others will call for a
1:17:54 World Council and then declare a certain
1:17:56 Creed and declare everyone has heretic
1:17:58 and self-prosecure them but it's not the
1:18:00 way Islam works this way
1:18:03 okay so this don't break this way
1:18:05 believe it or not there's not
1:18:07 enforcement of the people even in action
1:18:08 let alone accept that what is related to
1:18:10 the public domain which we'll discuss at
1:18:12 the end considering the area and
1:18:13 demonstrations
1:18:15 so he got stuck in this otherwise he
1:18:17 would have been an excellent ruler he
1:18:19 could have really revived the Islamic
1:18:21 command and pushed her several centuries
1:18:23 forward but unfortunately the
1:18:25 conversation degenerated in the issue is
1:18:27 the Quran created not created under this
1:18:30 this rubbish and nonsense
1:18:32 and all the achievements of uh
1:18:34 were under swept under the carpet
1:18:38 really and what would have been a
1:18:40 breakthrough but because of this but you
1:18:42 cannot blame him he's a man of his time
1:18:44 he's not a prophet a prophet will be
1:18:46 outside his time because he received
1:18:47 Revelation any other human being will be
1:18:49 affected by this at a time very
1:18:51 difficult to get yourself out of the
1:18:53 clutches of your time
1:18:56 oh it's possible it's not impossible
1:18:57 could not
1:18:59 until indulged in enforcing things
1:19:02 if you did not enforce things Bible
1:19:04 forced by whipping people that's
1:19:05 imprisoning people in later part of his
1:19:07 life
1:19:08 were encouraged by someone casually
1:19:10 idiots
1:19:12 it would have changed history radically
1:19:14 but unfortunately it was
1:19:17 it went this way otherwise the man is is
1:19:20 marvelous
1:19:23 a massive translation of of the
1:19:28 philosophies and the logic and the
1:19:30 Sciences of the Greek whether people
1:19:32 remember that he established this this
1:19:34 translating this translating
1:19:37 history and so on but also in other in
1:19:40 archeology he himself attended to the
1:19:42 big pyramid and tried to dig through it
1:19:43 and detect its nature yeah yeah but
1:19:46 people do not know that is an
1:19:48 exceptional personality in history
1:19:50 but unfortunately that that mistake of
1:19:54 is trying to enforce things and some
1:19:55 some people have had ease of reputation
1:19:58 resisted and became the big Imam
1:20:00 although they are they are not even one
1:20:03 percent of his his wisdom and their
1:20:05 knowledge and understanding of of
1:20:09 and he was then swept aside through
1:20:12 history unfortunately otherwise he could
1:20:14 have collected history considerably
1:20:16 anyway that's not our issue today so
1:20:19 that's that's the you have to you have
1:20:20 to really review that and see the
1:20:22 arguments and and also review I advise
1:20:24 also to go uh when you come to the to
1:20:27 the issues of khadron Song review also
1:20:29 special and how he discuss the issue I
1:20:33 will try to find around which Ayah and
1:20:35 which issue He was discussing that and
1:20:37 give it to you inshallah or put it in a
1:20:39 telegram so so that uh the shabab
1:20:43 especially Alaska distributed to
1:20:45 everyone in the next next after next
1:20:47 where he discussing
1:20:49 argument and without rebutting it or
1:20:51 discussing it
1:20:53 opposite to his usual Behavior usually
1:20:55 he go in depth and analyze things and go
1:20:57 thoroughly in that Center of what we say
1:21:00 whatever the rest of the omad our
1:21:02 previous scholar said
1:21:04 meaning I can't answer this but let me
1:21:07 stuck to that stick so that for the
1:21:08 majority are saying I am safe this way
1:21:10 otherwise I maybe get stored or
1:21:12 something like that
1:21:13 that's my interpretation obviously but
1:21:16 you would be surprised some people got
1:21:18 beaten up and stoned for these things
1:21:23 so it was not easy in time password
1:21:25 there was a intellectual Terror there
1:21:27 was there was the Hanabi that the humble
1:21:29 is
1:21:30 even Baghdad attacking some scholar even
1:21:33 that for example tabari himself They
1:21:35 seized his house and attacked him and so
1:21:37 on and prevent them because he said
1:21:40 he's a good is Hadith that's all they
1:21:43 were not happy with that
1:21:47 to be the one who has depth in
1:21:49 understanding and anyone just reading
1:21:51 someone said humble will recognize that
1:21:53 he has nothing to do with it neither
1:21:54 here nor there
1:21:56 almost every issue has two or three
1:21:58 different threat was
1:22:00 that is not fair
1:22:02 that's just narration he hit this for
1:22:04 once I have he said this is the first
1:22:05 one then another episode that is this
1:22:07 platform then he refuses
1:22:09 Etc
1:22:11 very poor in fact
1:22:13 yeah and even there he has some blanders
1:22:17 also but that's not our discussion today
1:22:19 so
1:22:20 that's what you have a comment over
1:22:22 history accumulated and hear from you at
1:22:23 the University and everywhere that's
1:22:25 obviously the the starting with the
1:22:28 mischief and then falsification of
1:22:31 history of his history of narratives and
1:22:33 thoughts and also was reinforced by
1:22:35 later Scholars because it became like
1:22:36 the mainstream which nobody can deviate
1:22:39 from exactly like for example with
1:22:41 having Christianity but after the new CN
1:22:43 conference
1:22:44 as a matter of fact that you see in
1:22:46 conference
1:22:47 uh I wish the the the energy or the
1:22:52 Divinity of Christ has been enshrined as
1:22:54 actually the real history is that the it
1:22:56 was called by by Constantine himself and
1:22:59 by him by the way he's a monotheist and
1:23:01 he took the last elements in his death
1:23:03 by uh by uh by uh former Bishop who is
1:23:06 uh who is from who do not believe in the
1:23:08 Dignity of Christ
1:23:10 and the conference was about thousand
1:23:12 Bishops they were disputed so badly that
1:23:14 there was no clear idea what they did so
1:23:16 he just discharged them to go
1:23:19 despite his discharge about 300
1:23:22 something met in in that was in
1:23:24 concerted outside because I told just
1:23:27 few miles outside
1:23:29 I think it's now part of Istanbul
1:23:32 because it was not far away but at the
1:23:33 time it was somebody by distance and
1:23:36 they met on their own and they were the
1:23:38 majority of one they decided of uh
1:23:41 Chrysler and that was recognized by all
1:23:44 other churches as except aliasi who
1:23:48 don't believe in the duty of Christ
1:23:50 under the indicator used to be heretic
1:23:52 and the prosecution started and history
1:23:55 run a ground of that time and never
1:23:58 never recovered back
1:24:01 so until that time they are used with
1:24:04 the majority
1:24:05 of the limit of Christ
1:24:09 you could be amazed if you see this
1:24:10 history up to 350 still the majority
1:24:13 were did not believe in the division of
1:24:15 Christ there they have a little bit
1:24:16 exaggeration about Christ and so on as
1:24:18 being the word and the mediated with
1:24:20 Allah in the world but it's not Divine
1:24:22 it's a created being
1:24:25 and then slowly that user were
1:24:28 persecuted so they were crawling a D in
1:24:30 the depth of Arabia here and there far
1:24:31 away and then almost completely
1:24:33 eliminated until Islam came when Islam
1:24:35 came they became more Muslim
1:24:36 aggressively
1:24:38 settled and Islam also saved another
1:24:40 sect of Christians who are obviously uh
1:24:43 believing in the duty of Christ at the
1:24:44 Egyptian church but they delivered with
1:24:46 the others about the nature of Crisis
1:24:48 true nature and tools or one nation one
1:24:50 will and they were under prosecuted to
1:24:53 be eliminated after the conference of
1:24:55 calcutonia
1:24:57 but then
1:25:00 Islam came and saved them so the
1:25:02 survival of the Egyptian and the Jewish
1:25:04 church and the Indian Church which
1:25:05 belongs from them is is thankful to
1:25:07 Islam others they would have been
1:25:08 exterminated and annihilated like all
1:25:11 others elsewhere in the domain of the
1:25:13 Byzantine Empire and in Europe as
1:25:16 Heretics all Heretics have been on the
1:25:19 edge of the sword eliminated
1:25:22 so that's that's the the that's how
1:25:25 history can run the ground by by such a
1:25:29 with such an action of a conference or
1:25:32 or a slight majority of Scholars and
1:25:34 they are not even a majority compared to
1:25:36 the Thousand who have been the dismissed
1:25:38 by Constantine where they didn't agree
1:25:40 anything reasonable
1:25:43 anyway this is maybe interesting let's
1:25:46 see if someone wants to go there and dig
1:25:47 these things but let's that's how things
1:25:49 sometimes develop historically and then
1:25:51 after a thousand years after that is
1:25:53 extremely difficult to pull yourself out
1:25:55 of all these accumulated History
1:25:56 Literature personalities which you have
1:26:00 learned from childhood to honor or
1:26:02 regardless big Scholars or great minds
1:26:04 and then ultimately when you dig all of
1:26:06 that and where you find many of them are
1:26:08 almost mindless
1:26:10 and many of the emologists is a disgrace
1:26:13 for the idea and problem but
1:26:16 there's no free lunch if you want to get
1:26:18 let's forget to that what it has been
1:26:20 revealed if the Quran is a revelation as
1:26:22 you said when we started we assume it's
1:26:24 a revelation and this recorded where
1:26:26 word for word letter for letter even the
1:26:29 script is recorded so they'll receive it
1:26:31 is revealed as a script not even as a
1:26:33 pronounced word in primarily what plants
1:26:36 with is following the script
1:26:37 we discussed that at the beginning if
1:26:39 you believe that starting it then there
1:26:41 must be some wisdom there to be learned
1:26:42 and for that you have to
1:26:44 you have to go to it and it was not only
1:26:46 one but I or a fraction of I have to
1:26:48 synchronize everything the column itself
1:26:50 says
1:26:54 if they are they not going to ponder
1:26:56 analyze the whole Quran Quran not when I
1:26:59 also all the Quran has to be
1:27:01 because
1:27:03 if there are contradictions or
1:27:04 asynchronity then it can't be from Allah
1:27:06 that's the Quran says that another place
1:27:11 other things should prevent you from the
1:27:13 double Quran is that you'll have the
1:27:15 sealed you have a lock layers I have
1:27:17 everything there I don't need to honor
1:27:19 already the scholars did that for me I'm
1:27:21 not going to review that again no no you
1:27:22 have to review it again you have to open
1:27:24 the lock
1:27:25 and review it again but leave it again
1:27:27 not one eye or a fraction over I
1:27:29 from A to Z all of it that's a double
1:27:31 column we try to do that obviously we
1:27:34 may use that we go I by I but to try to
1:27:36 sing link and synchronize with other
1:27:38 eyes otherwise we'll not get the
1:27:39 guidance
1:27:42 otherwise you'll not get a guidance
1:27:45 so back to I think we we got that issue
1:27:48 a bit of I think we we give it a very
1:27:51 good so let's finish this out
1:27:55 issue of hunting also today because that
1:27:58 issue that is about ruling as on so the
1:28:02 Thai Sanctuary out Makkah is
1:28:06 is a place of Peace where even hunting
1:28:08 is not allowed Bloodshed is not allowed
1:28:10 except of necessity like for example the
1:28:12 permission to kill certain certain uh
1:28:15 certain uh harmful animals like like
1:28:19 like Mouse rats and things like that
1:28:22 that's permitted but it's not hunting
1:28:24 actually but it's a place of Peace no
1:28:26 Bloodshed and in the state of isram when
1:28:29 you are the state of Minnesota
1:28:33 foreign
1:28:52 but some people uh Venture and put Haram
1:28:55 and make the intention of Haram outside
1:28:57 that area then you got yourself stuck
1:29:00 then you can't do the hunting also but
1:29:02 anyway when you reach the meerkat then
1:29:04 you must
1:29:05 obviously get that otherwise you are
1:29:07 liable of certain penalties so at least
1:29:09 in this wider sanctuary
1:29:11 anyone coming with the attention of
1:29:13 Hazard Ramadan
1:29:15 not necessarily this but make the
1:29:17 intentional
1:29:18 is bad from hunting
1:29:21 but people were thinking that not a
1:29:24 little bit lightly
1:29:25 somehow so Allah the early Prohibition
1:29:29 in the Surah which we passed long ago
1:29:32 they were not respecting that as it
1:29:35 should be
1:29:36 so Allah tested them I said this this is
1:29:39 this is the test next time we will be
1:29:41 tested so Allah will know who fears him
1:29:43 and respect his commandment and whoever
1:29:46 translates of that he will have a severe
1:29:48 punishment
1:29:49 then after the Civil punishment is not
1:29:51 as severe as black punishment for
1:29:52 confront so understands I clarify that
1:29:55 let's read it and then you translate
1:29:57 yeah
1:30:01 um
1:30:21 what's that oh you oh you have a tainted
1:30:24 Faith kill no game while you are in the
1:30:27 state of pilgrimage and whoever of you
1:30:29 kills it intentionally shall make amends
1:30:32 in cattle equivalent to what he has
1:30:34 killed with two persons of probability
1:30:36 of property giving their judgment
1:30:38 thereon to be bought as enough offering
1:30:41 to the Kaaba or else he may atone for
1:30:44 his sin by feeding the needy or by the
1:30:46 equivalent thereof in fasting this in
1:30:49 order that he takes the full gravity of
1:30:52 his deed while God shall have a face to
1:30:55 pass
1:30:56 but whoever does it again God will
1:30:58 inflict his retribution on him for God
1:31:00 is Almighty an Avenger of evil next
1:31:03 translation believers do not hunt while
1:31:06 you are in the state of in the state for
1:31:09 sanctity
1:31:10 whoever kills an animal intentionally
1:31:13 must make amends by offering an
1:31:14 equivalent domestic animal comparable to
1:31:17 what was killed as defined by two just
1:31:19 men and offering to be delivered to the
1:31:23 Kaaba
1:31:24 or he may atone for his sin by feeding
1:31:26 the needy or by fasting an equivalent
1:31:29 number of days so that he may understand
1:31:31 the seriousness of what he has done God
1:31:34 forgives what is past but is but if
1:31:37 anyone does it again God will punish him
1:31:39 severely God is mighty and capable of
1:31:42 exacting the penalty so just feel it's
1:31:45 clear what's there that just commentary
1:31:48 and tomorrow where you are from we are
1:31:49 in state of Iran and tomorrow either or
1:31:53 in the sanctuary
1:31:55 there you are in you are in the state of
1:31:58 even if you are not intending to go to
1:31:59 the Kaaba so until
1:32:02 Sanctuary
1:32:05 because you are in the tight Sanctuary
1:32:07 the sanctuary
1:32:10 which is well known and well marked
1:32:14 this one
1:32:15 and who does it deliberately sometimes
1:32:18 you don't know deliberately for example
1:32:19 you are you are
1:32:22 intending to Haram at you outside and
1:32:24 then maybe you are driving a car and you
1:32:26 you kill a game for example it crosses
1:32:29 and you the car kills it and then you
1:32:30 say oh let me let me uh let me uh
1:32:35 slot on it so so it doesn't go for Waste
1:32:38 you do not hunt it's not the ability and
1:32:41 there are other examples if you in a
1:32:43 comment maybe your camera will kick
1:32:44 Arabic and then you say oh this rabbit
1:32:46 is obviously dying now let me let me
1:32:49 shed its blood so it becomes edible
1:32:51 that's not hunting that's not what
1:32:52 happened but that's very clear that's it
1:32:54 but someone's seeing a game there and
1:32:56 they ride his horse and go with the
1:32:58 overall race with the card with a gun
1:33:00 and so on clearly
1:33:02 and then whatever you kill the two of
1:33:05 the weather and so again the the the
1:33:07 let's go the masculine mentality of
1:33:09 people say two of just men it's not two
1:33:11 years two two two people of Justice from
1:33:15 you which could be men
1:33:17 or or what is the name of this which is
1:33:20 neither man and woman which is a rare
1:33:22 event was called uh
1:33:25 the one who says neither a man or woman
1:33:27 what's his name transgender no no no the
1:33:30 in their case it's not sensation
1:33:33 I'm afraid of diet yeah somebody that it
1:33:37 must be just Justice yeah anyone two or
1:33:41 a Passover so two passers of you who
1:33:43 have the attribute of being just
1:33:44 unreasonable
1:33:46 you kill you kill for example uh let us
1:33:50 say uh uh you hunt a wild donkey a zebra
1:33:54 they will most likely say that's
1:33:56 equivalent to a cow
1:33:57 There's No Escape
1:34:00 Etc this should be Hadi to be taken
1:34:02 toward the Kaaba so you have to
1:34:04 appropriate by a Hadi or and take it to
1:34:08 the cover for the proposal the car
1:34:09 itself is not obviously a place of of
1:34:12 sacrifice like in the case of bunny is
1:34:14 they were sacrificing and shedding a
1:34:16 blood there on
1:34:17 in the temple no it's not had your bag
1:34:19 I'll cut meaning through the post around
1:34:21 the cup or if the if it's somehow not
1:34:24 available for example there's no
1:34:26 equivalent or as a substitute because
1:34:28 there's muscle circuit an equivalent a
1:34:31 number of skin which will be fed like
1:34:34 usually they say for example if it is
1:34:36 how many people could be eating
1:34:39 reasonably uh one sheep 10 persons maybe
1:34:43 if it is the natural 15 a cow will be
1:34:46 maybe 70 or 80 with rice and surface
1:34:49 because nobody would just eat meat alone
1:34:51 would be with rice bread and so on so
1:34:53 you have to feed like like for example
1:34:55 the case of a subject rental car maybe a
1:34:57 hundred machine for example instead of
1:35:00 of this
1:35:03 and if it's a a another possibility is
1:35:07 too fast in a equivalent to that what's
1:35:09 the equivalence some people say
1:35:10 equivalency that for example in in the
1:35:12 in the case we're also breaking if we
1:35:14 discussed uh uh you you you you you feed
1:35:18 and clothe the 10 skin 10 my skin
1:35:21 feeding uh-huh tell me skin feeding like
1:35:23 within three days so since we have a
1:35:25 hundred for a cow it will be like a
1:35:27 divide by 10 will be 10 times 3 30 days
1:35:29 fasting for example but this will be
1:35:32 judged by some people reasonable who
1:35:34 understand the various area injunctions
1:35:36 and make her so Allah did not specify
1:35:38 except either an equivalent animal
1:35:40 sometimes equivalent is clear for
1:35:42 example the scholars entire past
1:35:44 discussed if someone hands an ostrich
1:35:46 which is definitely a game then they
1:35:49 said that ostriches is a big animal it
1:35:52 is equivalent to a camel for example it
1:35:54 has features and capabilities on
1:35:56 simulated with the camera
1:35:58 Etc but what's a water habit some people
1:36:01 say it's referring to a chicken
1:36:03 I'm gonna say no no it's more it's maybe
1:36:05 we should go higher ship things like
1:36:07 that but this is buying points if
1:36:10 someone gets involved in something like
1:36:12 that ever then there are some old
1:36:14 equivalences already established in time
1:36:16 passed by just people
1:36:18 or
1:36:19 there's something done by omarada so you
1:36:22 can take these over or this is to be
1:36:25 done or no judgments because it's just
1:36:28 how to apply to the reality
1:36:30 and whoever did that in the before
1:36:32 Allah will forgive that what happened in
1:36:35 the past but who come back but beside
1:36:37 this penalty Allah will take revenge on
1:36:39 him because Allah is powerful and
1:36:41 capable of taking Revenge
1:36:44 and then click clarification after that
1:36:46 so that is that the anthem Forum does
1:36:49 not mean only that you are in the state
1:36:50 of Iran only but also you are in the
1:36:52 Holy Sanctuary the being in the holistic
1:36:55 should you understand you should be in a
1:36:56 state of Iowa and you should behave as
1:36:58 if you are in a state of Iran if you're
1:37:00 going to only for which is really an
1:37:03 Asia good strong strong injection the
1:37:05 people of Makkah specifically which
1:37:07 unfortunately most people do not comply
1:37:09 with it and in other aspects because
1:37:11 being in Makkah should should give you
1:37:13 other features of being a set of alarm
1:37:15 also not only on Hunting there are other
1:37:17 things but unfortunately people have
1:37:19 have not been brought up and you created
1:37:21 the proper way to regard that living in
1:37:23 makkai's theory is the area a very
1:37:26 demanding and they think it's they can
1:37:29 live like anywhere else no in Mecca
1:37:30 there's this Sanctuary should be life
1:37:33 should be their runners in a more in a
1:37:36 more more spiritual and and and less
1:37:39 violent way unfortunately it's not the
1:37:41 case because of negligence so I thought
1:37:43 it would say Scholars did not educate
1:37:45 the people about that sufficiently
1:37:46 thinking only about hunting that's not
1:37:49 that is a little bit more than that
1:37:53 and also the issue that the water the
1:37:55 translations say to just men no it is to
1:37:57 just persons from you
1:38:01 so you see how sometimes previous
1:38:04 conceptions are creep in the mind and
1:38:06 then you don't see it in the text
1:38:08 because when the text we want to specify
1:38:10 mirror and female it was pretty sorry if
1:38:12 it doesn't specify then you are not
1:38:14 allowed to specify from your own
1:38:16 imagination
1:38:18 uh the next I clarify that is not
1:38:21 applied to the the hunting of the sea
1:38:23 um
1:38:34 Translate
1:38:35 lawful to you is all water game and what
1:38:39 the sea brings forth as a provision for
1:38:41 you who are settled as well as for
1:38:43 travelers although you are forbidden to
1:38:45 hunt on land while you are in the state
1:38:47 of the pilgrimage and be conscious of
1:38:49 God unto whom you shall be gathered next
1:38:52 translation it is permitted for you to
1:38:54 catch and eat seafood seafood this is an
1:38:57 enjoyment for you as well as for
1:38:58 travelers although you are forbidden to
1:39:01 hunt on land while you are in the state
1:39:04 of sanctity be mindful of God to whom
1:39:06 you will be gathered
1:39:08 of this very clear that's that's the
1:39:10 obviously the bar
1:39:12 some people discuss the wisdom while
1:39:14 excluded not exclusion people say
1:39:16 because if you add a ship and it takes
1:39:18 long time then you need food and so on
1:39:20 and Etc and you may not have enough food
1:39:22 with you but this is not a very valid
1:39:25 argument actually because people are
1:39:27 traveling by sea uh usually have with
1:39:30 them
1:39:30 sufficient food that's not what for
1:39:32 beginning they have they have bread so
1:39:35 dried bread and things like that so they
1:39:36 can survive so that's not a good
1:39:39 secondly it's allowed even for those who
1:39:41 are settled now the one traveling fine
1:39:43 but say Allah settled at the seaside
1:39:46 within the holy Sanctuary or we were
1:39:48 living in Mecca they are not traveling
1:39:49 still is permitted for them so it is
1:39:52 something intrinsically there's
1:39:54 something interestingly
1:39:55 maybe the best side because that's
1:39:58 that's the hunting with the sea is
1:39:59 usually uh but also this is not a
1:40:02 universal there's no Bloodshed in that
1:40:04 sense but if you are hunting large fish
1:40:06 and so on there will be bloodshed
1:40:08 especially whales so that's all it does
1:40:11 not sound very very uh very persuasive
1:40:14 anyway but this is Allah decision
1:40:17 it's a c game is better hunting is
1:40:19 permitted but land game is not permitted
1:40:22 I the best thing to say is that because
1:40:24 it's because uh the the sea the the the
1:40:27 sanctuary the limits of the sanctuary
1:40:30 for example if you're coming by sea from
1:40:31 Egypt or from Sudan you will uh
1:40:35 when you reached
1:40:37 so the sea is outside of sanctuary
1:40:39 anyway so it's not at the domain of
1:40:41 sanctuary or the main of making era most
1:40:43 likely that's the better logic of it but
1:40:45 even that it's just a Divine injunction
1:40:47 which has to be respected
1:40:50 and oh that's that's the thing the
1:40:52 second idea that Hadith have clarified
1:40:54 that even said even the dead animals of
1:40:57 the sea as long as they are not rotten
1:40:59 are not edible but that's about this
1:41:01 will be the issue of being unhealthy and
1:41:03 or bad for for your health nobody would
1:41:06 do it obviously but otherwise uh even
1:41:09 they are dead if you find Fisheries
1:41:11 floating over there and it doesn't
1:41:13 there's no sign if it's bad or or
1:41:15 poisonous or anything you can you can
1:41:17 eat it and so on so the the animals of
1:41:20 the sea including even mammals like uh
1:41:22 like uh whale and so on even if it's
1:41:24 dead you find this way to sometimes the
1:41:27 sea drops somewhere else here then they
1:41:29 die there if you find it dead you can
1:41:31 eat it it's perfectly harder and also
1:41:33 the water of seal although salty it's
1:41:35 purifying you can use it Forward also
1:41:37 obviously nobody will use it for drink
1:41:39 because it's a if you drink the plenty
1:41:42 of vegetable it will kill you
1:41:44 essentially it will not exchange with
1:41:46 sales because of the content of salt it
1:41:48 would be deadly for imbalance that the
1:41:50 minerals in the body but it is purifying
1:41:53 but as I clarified by Hadith various
1:41:55 Hadith and various other injections
1:41:59 so that's the final ruling Seidel bar
1:42:02 hunting of the in the sanctuary on the
1:42:05 state of sanctity is physically
1:42:06 prohibited
1:42:07 and
1:42:09 said hunting of the sea and game of the
1:42:12 sea and even dead animals of the sea are
1:42:14 permitted both for the traveler and the
1:42:16 one on the seaside who are not traveling
1:42:18 and and said be conscious about Allah to
1:42:22 whom we will be recovered at the end of
1:42:25 the whole of the world
1:42:26 so I think we stopped here
1:42:29 because we but most of the time in the
1:42:31 issue of divine foreign
1:42:39 of
1:42:41 uh or sure
1:42:44 what's his name the interference of the
1:42:47 state in in in in Creed and and action
1:42:50 of the of the people uh what's the
1:42:53 limitation of the state Authority we
1:42:55 will address that in a few seconds after
1:42:58 having a small break of of 30 seconds or
1:43:01 something like that to separate that in
1:43:02 the recording and also in the Stream
1:43:04 we'll continue with this three I see I
1:43:06 suggest we continue with the stream so
1:43:08 that people can participate in that the
1:43:10 question is what is happening in Iran
1:43:11 allegedly because the the police
1:43:14 punished a woman or apprehended woman
1:43:17 which was not rejecting order to wearing
1:43:19 hijab and she was she died in police
1:43:21 custody or something like that so we
1:43:23 take
1:43:24 a few seconds break
1:43:27 with the recording and streaming going
1:43:29 on
1:43:30 and then we start with the running
1:43:32 question
1:43:36 so we continue next time by Ayah number
1:43:38 I think 99 in my account it's 98 miles
1:43:41 yeah
1:43:53 okay Bismillah what was the issue about
1:43:55 Iran's Russia you mentioned something
1:43:57 you had a certain question a certain
1:43:59 issue or for propagation so just in
1:44:03 relation to the job of the state is it
1:44:06 allowed to enforce things like hijab
1:44:08 Salah Etc in terms of for example
1:44:10 someone's Uncovered what's the
1:44:12 relationship with the state and
1:44:14 individuals who who do well basically
1:44:17 not comply with certain obligations that
1:44:19 Islam stipulates yeah this is this is
1:44:22 very importantly important question
1:44:24 because because the the definition of
1:44:27 the state which is uh had been
1:44:30 adopted by uh or in after after the
1:44:35 hijacking of the power and the
1:44:37 abolishment of the shoulder by marawi
1:44:38 and his ilk and after that essential
1:44:41 almost continuously
1:44:43 and then was codified by the scholars
1:44:45 later unfortunately
1:44:47 and sometimes to an extreme level
1:44:50 ing uncovered like what they called the
1:44:54 shami the relevant obedience which was
1:44:57 was spread in Syria and around
1:44:59 and which even they claim that you have
1:45:01 to obey the ruler even if he commands
1:45:03 Haram or command
1:45:06 he's responsible for that something like
1:45:07 some statement like that and the other
1:45:10 ruler is not accountable for anything
1:45:12 because because
1:45:13 there is a representing Allah on Earth
1:45:16 so it's above above questioning and
1:45:18 things like that this is all statements
1:45:20 and many of the people who advocated
1:45:22 that are essentially whenever Catherine
1:45:24 even if they're called Scholars few of
1:45:27 us will get there because of stupidity
1:45:28 and ignorance but this is very unlikely
1:45:30 to be the administration of scholar but
1:45:32 even some other importance like Jose
1:45:35 said one of them one of the way of
1:45:38 freaky way of the xiaomi which must be
1:45:41 forsaken is
1:45:44 obedience that's all what he said but
1:45:47 this is this is extremely uh
1:45:49 disappointing statement just say it has
1:45:51 to be forsaken it's not enough
1:45:53 but it's something like grave like that
1:45:55 should be clarified what it is
1:45:58 definitely as the claiming that it's a
1:46:01 Thai Champions legitimate is a statement
1:46:03 of cover without any doubt all right so
1:46:05 so such a weak statement is not really a
1:46:08 very honoring or or
1:46:12 making a respected outside very much
1:46:15 actually reduce considerably his respect
1:46:17 there are other issues also make him
1:46:19 easier make him really use in our uh our
1:46:22 should become reduced in our respect but
1:46:24 that's not the issue with a certain
1:46:26 person that the general stream was like
1:46:27 that in Syria but as general elsewhere
1:46:30 although nobody went to the level of
1:46:32 that the state is having widespread
1:46:35 authorities etc etc until mayor they
1:46:38 codified that in that sultania you find
1:46:40 scattered
1:46:42 here and there about Imam and Leadership
1:46:44 and the election maybe a couple of pages
1:46:47 but a complete write-up the only one the
1:46:51 first one is
1:46:56 as essentially
1:46:58 the the ruling about the state
1:47:01 in uh
1:47:03 in which he adopted or they did some
1:47:06 modification there totally total with
1:47:08 his daughter and the respect he did this
1:47:11 modification for the molarity
1:47:14 and his elk and after that
1:47:17 essentially adopted all of them all they
1:47:19 said you could say plagiarized it but
1:47:21 we'll change few things there according
1:47:23 to him
1:47:24 this is but nothing significant they
1:47:27 will say and the difference is that that
1:47:29 Imam head of state is a
1:47:34 general rulership of all Muslims in the
1:47:37 world
1:47:39 the the
1:47:41 for the management of Dunya and herasa
1:47:45 and the guardian of Dean guardian of
1:47:47 Dean
1:47:49 that's that's what guardian of Dean
1:47:53 adopted that
1:47:55 Dunya and did not use the word Guardian
1:47:57 for the that's that's in his favor I
1:48:00 don't know if he has used that or data
1:48:02 scorer but anyway that's the concept in
1:48:04 everyone's mind that the Imam is also
1:48:07 there to guard the Deen
1:48:10 but this is the driven foreign
1:48:21 except memories and stories but the the
1:48:25 Roman Empire the byzantia Roman Empire
1:48:28 was there and was everyone there Hill
1:48:30 State regard himself as the guardian of
1:48:32 the Deen even the Queen of England King
1:48:34 of England now one of his titles
1:48:36 Defensor of Faith huh defender of Faith
1:48:39 that's one of his major titles
1:48:41 read the full titles of Queen Elizabeth
1:48:43 or King Charles now say Empower
1:48:46 Etc obviously emperor of India is
1:48:48 removed there's nobody there but is
1:48:50 there a defender of Faith etc etc etc
1:48:53 and head of the Commonwealth Etc so
1:48:55 that's defender of Faith so it seems to
1:48:57 be from the early tradition since the
1:48:59 conversion of Constantine somehow the
1:49:02 Emperors thought that they are the one
1:49:04 who defend the faith unto God the faith
1:49:13 it did not come to that that they call
1:49:15 conferences and it acts things like that
1:49:17 this would have been outrageous nobody
1:49:19 would have accepted that but
1:49:22 almost although the formality was not
1:49:25 done but almost like that like so
1:49:27 there's a bunch of Scholars around the
1:49:29 Khalif or the head of state who uh if he
1:49:32 adopts their point of view he more often
1:49:35 than not he will try to enforce it and
1:49:36 broadcast it widely
1:49:39 and that's what's caused obviously
1:49:41 various issues about Creed and the
1:49:42 issues of vlogging issues of creation of
1:49:45 the Quran all of this because of this
1:49:46 attitude even from some an enlightened
1:49:48 man like like uh al-mahmoud as I said so
1:49:52 this is the way they got it if there's
1:49:54 anything in the Quran Sunnah or either
1:49:57 indicating that let's go back to see
1:50:00 what all of it was
1:50:03 was appointed to code
1:50:05 for beef and then Creed in Makkah
1:50:09 and even there he was not allowed to
1:50:12 have any dominance over the people see
1:50:14 foreign
1:50:27 because they were not really structured
1:50:29 as a state
1:50:36 no dominance or no control over them
1:50:39 however who turn away and become a cafe
1:50:42 Allah will punish him the severe
1:50:45 punishment is not for you
1:50:50 so he was not even
1:50:52 allowed to force belief on anybody
1:50:57 as a party leader let's say in Mecca
1:51:00 later on he were asking the try the
1:51:03 tribes for for nusra
1:51:05 which has Italian misunderstood that he
1:51:07 wanted to establish a state no don't
1:51:08 know
1:51:11 Etc I think it's translated read it and
1:51:14 if someone asked for it the translation
1:51:16 is being reviewed now finished and can
1:51:18 be publicized to the people or not yet
1:51:20 Arabic is available anyway for those who
1:51:22 hated Arabic the English one I think
1:51:24 it's just for final polishing if I'm not
1:51:27 mistaken
1:51:28 or it's already polished
1:51:32 he was asking them he was asking them
1:51:34 give me protection so I can bring the
1:51:36 word of Allah to everyone
1:51:39 because my people want to kill me so
1:51:41 protect me from being killed being
1:51:43 attacked so I combusted and I don't
1:51:46 force any one of you to follow what what
1:51:49 I have what I have brought
1:51:50 or even were to follow fine who does not
1:51:52 follow so meaning I am not going to
1:51:54 enforce anything on you just give me the
1:51:56 protection
1:51:57 be sufficiently open-minded to protect
1:52:00 me that's it you want to follow a
1:52:02 library fine if you don't want fine
1:52:03 that's perfectly fine just give me a
1:52:04 protection I'm essentially Asylum that's
1:52:07 it
1:52:08 and just want to be collaborated by
1:52:10 various narrations and so on and and so
1:52:12 it makes absolutely clear that he was
1:52:14 not looking after to establish a state
1:52:16 or have any Authority above them
1:52:19 then let's go and step forward so to
1:52:22 build the argument correctly we have to
1:52:24 start from zero that's the way to go
1:52:26 I think people starting maybe with the
1:52:29 with later time
1:52:31 even in a misunderstood way but let us
1:52:36 when you start this way even the
1:52:37 misunderstanding later would be
1:52:39 clarified
1:52:40 or there should be no message on
1:52:41 studying but they just ignore that and
1:52:43 this went what time a little bother
1:52:45 going back to Quran they just decided to
1:52:48 make to forsake the Quran put it behind
1:52:50 their back exactly like an issue of
1:52:51 cattle and so on and cover and foreign
1:52:55 behind their back and just we're happy
1:52:57 with their with the semi-philosophical
1:52:59 sophistry and claiming that this is the
1:53:02 truth that we have to even twist over
1:53:03 the Quran to fit it the same happened
1:53:05 there in a certain extent
1:53:09 when the answer came
1:53:11 back
1:53:12 which is
1:53:15 because he worked on that and did some
1:53:18 developed a theory but the theory is
1:53:20 again fault
1:53:21 because the bear sounds like that
1:53:23 he said with this
1:53:26 state was established but you look at
1:53:28 the way I said see
1:53:33 was famous in the silica of the book
1:53:37 we're talking about
1:53:41 they can buy on the following
1:53:45 they made a covenant to him that when he
1:53:47 comes to Madina they will protect
1:53:48 himself him in Medina and His companion
1:53:51 who will immigrate with him and get
1:53:53 ahead of him like they protect their own
1:53:56 dress meaning or their own hour their
1:53:58 own women and children
1:54:00 they're willing to fight unto death
1:54:03 that's all
1:54:04 and
1:54:06 we don't dispute the one in Authority
1:54:08 unless we see an evident cover what does
1:54:10 this mean
1:54:14 and it's been a covenant with the
1:54:16 prophet with this meaning no because the
1:54:17 prophet could not could could conceive
1:54:19 of having any open cover so the spirit
1:54:21 the one in Authority there so they have
1:54:23 their own authority their tribal Chef
1:54:25 tense or Stripes were like States so
1:54:26 they will have their own head of states
1:54:29 who part of the darker that by atom
1:54:32 Muhammad to protect him does not give
1:54:33 them an authority to dispute to lose an
1:54:35 authority and remove them unless they do
1:54:37 evidently
1:54:39 or combat Haram publicly which is the
1:54:42 same cover why from there from The
1:54:44 Authority is publicly otherwise they
1:54:47 should not dispute so this is clearly
1:54:49 what I'm saying they took this Covenant
1:54:51 with them I am not coming to be a ruler
1:54:54 I'll be just under your protection
1:54:57 I will be an asylum Seeker
1:54:59 you will continue with your ruler with
1:55:01 it and you don't speak to them the same
1:55:03 Muhammad is now here now we can remove
1:55:05 you and put Muhammad or what anybody
1:55:07 else know you can't
1:55:09 or put myself no it still gives you
1:55:11 Authority unless he command around
1:55:14 publicly or which is open cover
1:55:18 so it is clear there's no State there
1:55:20 and he is not a head of state
1:55:31 of Allah
1:55:33 not as a green star boss no so it is
1:55:36 impossible so the way I feel read it
1:55:38 carefully and we say the truth anywhere
1:55:40 even if we are not fearing no blame of
1:55:42 any blamer that's all have nothing to do
1:55:44 with being becoming head of state so
1:55:46 there's no state established and he had
1:55:47 no Authority when the American to Madina
1:55:50 he was allowed later to immigrate
1:55:52 as the last immigrant essentially
1:55:55 one of the last ones because Ali stayed
1:55:57 back to pay the debts and settle all the
1:56:00 accounts of awesome then he followed and
1:56:01 few others followed and some were
1:56:02 prevented but when they arrived by the
1:56:06 structure of the society which is the
1:56:08 tribal Society every tribe essentially
1:56:10 is like a state authority to like I said
1:56:11 like a state it's the daily estate it's
1:56:13 a state no doubt is a state
1:56:15 with all the meaning of State not the
1:56:17 Western definition of state but the
1:56:19 correct meaning legal definition of
1:56:20 State
1:56:21 which I always mentioned that that for
1:56:24 example the the Indian tribes in their
1:56:26 reservation has been there was a dispute
1:56:29 about what their status and so on and
1:56:31 the Supreme Court these are people of
1:56:33 the law who understand the law and
1:56:35 analyze it properly and so on see every
1:56:37 tribe is like any one of the singing
1:56:39 states of nasty to America they're part
1:56:40 of the village
1:56:42 even if they don't have a representative
1:56:44 in the parliament as Senator and so on
1:56:45 still they are they should be regarded
1:56:48 and treated as if they are states
1:56:50 members of the Union
1:56:52 that's what people of the law who
1:56:53 understand the meaning of the lower
1:56:55 meaning of state and authority and in
1:56:56 touch a relationship between a central
1:56:58 and Authority Federal Authority and and
1:57:00 members of the Federation Etc come to
1:57:03 which is dictated by the necessity of
1:57:04 the nature of real estate they don't
1:57:06 bother about the usual uh defunctive
1:57:09 definition of land and people at the no
1:57:11 no it says this tribe is having a
1:57:14 structure or running itself like a state
1:57:15 and they are state so that's that's the
1:57:17 reality of the state really
1:57:20 they were Qureshi they were in a college
1:57:22 state if there is a state in Croatia or
1:57:24 several States because there are several
1:57:25 competing tribes and then now in Medina
1:57:28 they have no tribe so they became like a
1:57:30 tribe they were called mahajarin and the
1:57:32 plural became their boss and their head
1:57:34 of state so the state of mahajarin by by
1:57:36 initial imaged by Nature he was the
1:57:39 leader of a party in Makkah but now they
1:57:41 are separated but they are not member of
1:57:42 these uh tribes in Medina so what they
1:57:45 are they become like became a state and
1:57:47 he is the head of them and that's the
1:57:50 reason if you look if you look carefully
1:57:52 uh all the
1:57:54 all the the uh the first battle
1:57:58 campaigns and the Saraya and so on sent
1:58:00 in the early time until butter
1:58:03 foreign
1:58:06 what does this mean
1:58:08 s
1:58:10 what does this mean
1:58:12 because the answer they were not part of
1:58:15 that state not under his command
1:58:17 absolutely not
1:58:19 and better he called people to come out
1:58:21 and whoever wants to come out even the
1:58:23 SR were invited but they were not
1:58:25 ordered
1:58:26 and that's the reason when because it
1:58:28 was a caravan to be hijacked and
1:58:30 obviously the the hijacking is to uh to
1:58:33 take revenge of the Quran which
1:58:35 confiscated almost
1:58:37 be confiscated but obviously a caravan
1:58:40 may have enough wealth to not only for
1:58:42 the mahaja room but there will be extra
1:58:43 the extra benefit and why not invite
1:58:46 them an answer to participate invited
1:58:49 but the Caravan escaped
1:58:54 so what to do he started asking the
1:58:56 people to for consultation
1:58:59 spoke and so on and he said
1:59:02 give me your point of view and not one
1:59:04 of the answer I think sadly nobody
1:59:06 outside of a wild notice
1:59:10 say yes what's your point of view what
1:59:13 do you suggest
1:59:15 what he was Consulting about the answer
1:59:17 is tell us because narration like that
1:59:19 are usually Abridged will not memorize
1:59:22 things which take Pages whether it's
1:59:24 only half a page but the answer rather
1:59:26 tell tell that essentially saying should
1:59:29 we go ahead and fight the quraishi army
1:59:31 which is now coming forward to fight us
1:59:33 now the Caravan is gone now it is
1:59:35 becoming a button it's a war
1:59:38 and the ansar had have no Covenant with
1:59:40 him to defend him and fight with him
1:59:41 outside Medina
1:59:43 they could have said they didn't say
1:59:45 that because they could have said listen
1:59:48 we gave you protection in Medina that's
1:59:50 that's the agreement that's the wording
1:59:51 of the agreement
1:59:52 we don't give you protection that you go
1:59:54 with
1:59:55 to battle campus outside and do
1:59:58 adventures and want us to protect you
2:00:00 there come back to Madina will be
2:00:01 protected but here wait for the Croatia
2:00:04 Army and fight no that's not our
2:00:05 obligation which is true it has been
2:00:07 true but what this partner said we're
2:00:11 not going to tell you like the people of
2:00:12 Musa go and fight with your lord we are
2:00:14 with you we'll fight with you here even
2:00:16 if you go to Berkeley ramad this place
2:00:18 near Ahmad we will be with you so our
2:00:21 agreement to protect you and fight with
2:00:23 you is extended everywhere it's not only
2:00:25 in Medina
2:00:27 was elated and say
2:00:32 let me tell you the good news Allah
2:00:34 promised me one of the two parties who
2:00:36 still the Caravan did not Escape 100 and
2:00:38 the Croatia Army is on the way maybe we
2:00:40 can catch one of them Allah said one of
2:00:41 the two would be yours
2:00:43 you have one of them
2:00:46 so we will get something
2:00:48 don't don't worry we'll be getting
2:00:50 something and then they've got obviously
2:00:52 the one which is financially not more
2:00:53 pleasing but the one which is for the
2:00:55 and the law said clearly you wish that
2:00:57 you have had the Caravan because it's
2:00:59 easy it's money easy money no no Allah
2:01:01 wish to get the quality and break their
2:01:03 back
2:01:05 that's what Allah has enforced and this
2:01:07 so even in discussion show it was not
2:01:09 the head of the answer
2:01:11 as I discussed later on after brother
2:01:15 and after the after the carbon National
2:01:17 started as a campaign against the
2:01:18 prophet and went to Mecca and Omen they
2:01:20 opened the make a big funeral and was
2:01:22 lamenting making a big lamentation she
2:01:24 was a very good at lamentation and
2:01:26 complaining about the bad luck and so on
2:01:28 they have even a book called The Book of
2:01:30 lamentation in the Bible
2:01:32 an Instagram
2:01:35 peaceful and there was no conflict and
2:01:38 everything couldn't do was nice and
2:01:39 smooth one of them became a warrior now
2:01:42 instigating what is a warrior
2:01:44 whenever some water and he started
2:01:47 insulting Muslim insulting and and
2:01:49 talking about Muslim women about issues
2:01:52 of Allah and things like that that's
2:01:53 very abusive but the instigating of the
2:01:55 world is the west but that other one is
2:01:57 just a footnote said the discount has
2:02:01 heard Allah in his messenger he's
2:02:02 insulting Allah who can take care of him
2:02:05 and some of the house volunteer to do
2:02:07 that
2:02:09 and this isn't heifer by the way
2:02:10 discussed in the sahib and he told them
2:02:13 go ahead and
2:02:15 consult with the with the side of him
2:02:18 take his permission why take his
2:02:19 permission if he's the head of state of
2:02:21 Laos because
2:02:22 still still not in the head
2:02:26 then after Karma was this partial we
2:02:28 know the story The stipher is there the
2:02:30 cypho is written and then now we have a
2:02:32 state established and which is a
2:02:34 federation between the uh and then seven
2:02:37 states of the ansar and Confederation
2:02:40 with with the Jews
2:02:43 now we have a state after that no that's
2:02:46 that's just to clarify the issue of
2:02:48 establishing a state and the mistake of
2:02:49 his battalions that's like that until
2:02:51 now he was not enforcing anything
2:02:53 not commanding anything and the
2:02:55 dispatching of Scarborough and killing
2:02:57 him is an act of War because he started
2:02:58 War he was integrated one he's a warrior
2:03:01 and his wife told him don't meet these
2:03:03 people you are a warrior now and in Wars
2:03:05 they may be deceiving you say no no they
2:03:07 are my brothers they will not received
2:03:08 me and he got I got to see as he should
2:03:10 be in war that's the way it works
2:03:12 okay after that versus obviously the
2:03:15 head of state in Medina and the head of
2:03:17 the Confederation
2:03:19 let us see what happens to the things
2:03:21 which are not related to the even the
2:03:23 sahiba mentioned about anything which is
2:03:25 which which is which which threatened to
2:03:28 be initial public security
2:03:30 must be referred to him uh for
2:03:33 settlement so it's issues of War and
2:03:35 Peace versus murder this is a thrift
2:03:38 things like that should be referred to
2:03:40 him for judgment but other issues were
2:03:42 never effect or never mentioned but
2:03:44 let's see what the reality the reality
2:03:46 in media for example concerning hijab
2:03:50 was never enforced by that but by uh by
2:03:53 the one I set up no no what he said went
2:03:56 out and telling the woman uh you have to
2:03:59 meet her with a day they complied the
2:04:01 Commandment out of their devotion and
2:04:03 there was no woman who should not come
2:04:05 back for example there was a woman
2:04:06 narrated
2:04:07 that uh that uh
2:04:10 said if I would be stoning anybody with
2:04:14 that without an Evidence I would Stone
2:04:15 her and if someone asked if that bus is
2:04:18 that a woman who did the say say no
2:04:20 there's a woman which is clearly showing
2:04:23 Sue in Islam she was working essentially
2:04:26 as a prostitute but no there was not
2:04:27 enough four Witnesses I'm guessing and
2:04:30 he did not stand no no no no did he go
2:04:33 and put gods in her house and look that
2:04:34 away that's number one as an example and
2:04:37 the example he had a boat woman which
2:04:39 ride horses and pretend to be a man so
2:04:42 genders you're doing a gender change
2:04:44 classical Style
2:04:53 may Allah
2:04:57 behave and turn themself into men and
2:04:59 the opposite men who are Muhammad who
2:05:01 are female female like not to tell him
2:05:04 they will be cast and nobody went to
2:05:06 that the people told that woman said
2:05:08 that and she seized Auto believe so he
2:05:11 didn't send him
2:05:13 all the things related to Bible order he
2:05:15 sent people to enforce like enforcing
2:05:17 her dude that's clear because this is a
2:05:19 matter of the state punishment nobody
2:05:21 should enforce them and accept except
2:05:23 him actually between the people said the
2:05:26 half you catch a thief for example
2:05:30 if you can
2:05:32 and you find a good reason then you
2:05:34 should release him before going to the
2:05:35 doctor if you go to the authority that
2:05:37 number that is out of your hand you
2:05:38 can't forgive him anymore you cannot you
2:05:39 can't intercede or bring away from him
2:05:42 anymore you do it before so meaning even
2:05:44 there you still do the people should be
2:05:47 forgiven between each other
2:05:49 not not reporting they want to report it
2:05:51 is
2:05:53 so that's that's another evidence
2:05:57 so it it's very clear even salad usually
2:06:00 the Hadith that we discussed that in the
2:06:02 issue with them
2:06:03 said that they say it was very angry
2:06:06 that people are missing Zuma is
2:06:12 if it were not for women and men and
2:06:15 children in the houses I would go and
2:06:16 burn the houses
2:06:20 we take the minimalist point of view but
2:06:23 they didn't do and then send anybody to
2:06:25 do not say they want to look at the door
2:06:27 or have a register asking about their
2:06:30 names
2:06:34 so he was only concerned and enforcing
2:06:36 things and sending people to enforce if
2:06:38 it is related to public order
2:06:40 for example the man who married the uh
2:06:43 despite the injection married the wife
2:06:45 of his father
2:06:47 has passed away he inherited that woman
2:06:49 and Humanity that was done in jail quite
2:06:51 often not very often that often well
2:06:54 allowed in Jalia on this entertainment
2:06:56 very disgusted to Allah
2:06:59 hateful to Allah completely
2:07:01 and he did it publicly and have a
2:07:03 wedding celebration so he's challenging
2:07:05 the public order so he's a warrior not
2:07:07 by spooling the sword actual word but by
2:07:11 law is a warrior so he sent him a couple
2:07:14 of men
2:07:15 who decapitated him took his money to
2:07:17 the treasury
2:07:19 do not leave the money for the for the
2:07:20 hairs because he is he's a confronting
2:07:22 the step the public order and the
2:07:24 ability
2:07:26 so he's a warrior
2:07:28 his wealth will not go through it was in
2:07:30 health because Muslim Jonathan had a
2:07:32 cover that goes through the treasury
2:07:36 something like that but nowhere is
2:07:38 something
2:07:39 in another matter of hijab or matter
2:07:42 people not attending Salah or something
2:07:44 like nothing
2:07:45 people miss David
2:07:50 he said that but he did not do it
2:07:55 and clearly this means that Allah Allah
2:07:59 he was upset about that but Allah
2:08:01 diverted his attention from doing
2:08:03 anything
2:08:04 and some people say oh but he mentioned
2:08:06 the reason that the houses said so
2:08:08 that's not a good reason because he
2:08:10 could you could go to these houses take
2:08:11 that woman's children out and bend out
2:08:15 or take them and punish them under give
2:08:18 their the ownership of the house to the
2:08:20 wife and the children and declare him to
2:08:21 be houseless homeless kick him out of
2:08:23 Medina
2:08:24 many things can be done nothing can be
2:08:26 done that so this is argument that he
2:08:28 did he did not do it because women are
2:08:30 children as he said
2:08:32 that's that's that's important that's
2:08:34 the way that's the way the bad and false
2:08:38 or Soul work
2:08:40 his his soul did not like that and he
2:08:42 was angry with it and and he almost did
2:08:46 it but he did not do it why because
2:08:47 Allah praying then we're doing it
2:08:49 because that's not within his authority
2:08:51 we have also other narration he's been a
2:08:53 trivia another issue perhaps I hated
2:08:55 that too that's anyone Walks Behind him
2:08:57 he prefers to be behind All His
2:08:58 companion
2:08:59 so it is the opposite of real why we
2:09:02 don't know the opposite of of rulers and
2:09:05 kings in the world usually in the front
2:09:08 and everyone is behind them so most
2:09:10 likely that's the reason
2:09:12 psychologically he hates in one so Jesus
2:09:15 I prefer that you are in front of me and
2:09:18 keep my back to the angels I don't need
2:09:20 anyone in my back the angels protect my
2:09:22 back you'll be in front go front go
2:09:25 ahead and one day some some people who
2:09:27 are not very new in Islam like a
2:09:29 delegation they will follow him say
2:09:31 don't follow me get away and then one of
2:09:34 them still continue following so he beat
2:09:36 him saying he beat me with a sticker or
2:09:39 a tooth a toothbrush which is made out
2:09:42 of some kind of plant stick or something
2:09:44 say a small a small slab which barely
2:09:48 had me
2:09:51 then in the evening when I was at home
2:09:53 about to sleep I asked myself
2:09:55 why the messenger Allah beat me that it
2:09:58 didn't help but this access is heading
2:10:01 symbolically I must have done something
2:10:03 very bad let me go tomorrow and ask him
2:10:06 what I did wrong so he beat me because
2:10:07 he did not comprehend that by walking
2:10:09 behind the prophet is bad he did not
2:10:11 understand the injunction if he didn't
2:10:12 understand it properly
2:10:14 and so that maybe just a prophet want to
2:10:17 be to be humble or something like that
2:10:18 to notice that he dislike it really
2:10:21 let's say I went through the machine
2:10:22 when I entered the Masjid let me see
2:10:24 your law was giving a sermon and saying
2:10:26 yesterday some of you were following me
2:10:30 and I
2:10:31 I was very upset because I don't want
2:10:33 any following me and some of them I
2:10:35 wanted to I I I I have beaten them with
2:10:39 a stick
2:10:41 Gabriel jabriel came to me and told me
2:10:44 Allah did not make you a compeller or a
2:10:46 tyrant why you are terrifying your
2:10:48 follower your nation
2:10:50 you should not have done that even this
2:10:52 that that touching with a stick which
2:10:53 did not hit the man
2:10:59 and then said I made an agreement with
2:11:01 my Lord if I had someone black and
2:11:03 dislike this situation or swear at him
2:11:06 or use harsh word with him make it for
2:11:08 him a forgiveness and a benefit
2:11:11 of agreed why not to do it as much as
2:11:15 you can
2:11:18 so I did not complete any major sin unto
2:11:21 his no Revelation came that a criminal
2:11:23 with your Beating or or insulting it is
2:11:25 it is
2:11:27 not like people but going bad and jibril
2:11:30 even came commenting on that so he was
2:11:33 released so even like that he did not
2:11:35 even he was not even allowed to
2:11:39 and this is another Hadith that he also
2:11:41 appointed with a stick to someone and
2:11:42 the minute you really can't say are you
2:11:44 joining the tyrants of the Roman and
2:11:46 Persian who arrested against your own
2:11:48 people
2:11:49 we not have said you like that so that's
2:11:51 the messenger
2:11:53 in his capacity as a head of state
2:11:55 because he was a head State at that time
2:11:56 and also other messenger so the
2:11:58 messenger does not give you this one nor
2:12:01 being ahead of State give you this one
2:12:03 until he died that's the day usual habit
2:12:05 there was no involved with anything
2:12:07 which is not related to the public or
2:12:08 the public security
2:12:10 none
2:12:15 public security for example if we get
2:12:17 example of things which were enforced
2:12:18 publicity he gave an order to kill the
2:12:20 dogs with the history does not tell us a
2:12:23 narration what was the reason because
2:12:24 before that to Hassan they have a puppy
2:12:27 they were playing with it
2:12:28 so the whole theory of najasa and so on
2:12:30 this is Imagination but they discussed
2:12:32 that another time it's not our time of
2:12:33 it so he gave an all that most likely he
2:12:36 received by our head that the dogs are
2:12:38 having possibly transmitted and
2:12:40 infectious disease we don't know
2:12:42 anyway he gave the order to kill the
2:12:44 dogs
2:12:46 so that the number is just considered
2:12:48 maybe that some of them were affected
2:12:49 with uh they were saying rapes or
2:12:51 rabbits or become rabbit or maybe at the
2:12:54 same time where we have in the Persian
2:12:55 Empire and in the north the plague the
2:12:58 big plague which killed
2:13:00 the son of of pervisa
2:13:03 the one who killed his father the scared
2:13:05 and they said find a really real emperor
2:13:09 or a real real
2:13:11 of the pleasure and part after that they
2:13:14 split unfortunate and today the Empire
2:13:16 of the singulated
2:13:18 maybe that's the that he's we don't know
2:13:20 anyway he was out there giving out to
2:13:22 kill all dogs
2:13:24 so he sent people he would proceeded in
2:13:26 dogs
2:13:27 I I I I almost sprinkle it almost almost
2:13:31 confident there must be something
2:13:32 related to disease and things like that
2:13:36 most likely I thought
2:13:38 and then he sent someone first pursuing
2:13:41 dogs and he said that the Habit said I
2:13:43 came to a remote like a remote Orca
2:13:46 enough
2:13:47 far away from Medina in the corner of
2:13:50 Medina and there were two ladies living
2:13:51 there with no man said please this dog
2:13:54 is the only combat company we have and
2:13:57 this barking zoo is officially
2:13:59 terrifying for thieves and animals and
2:14:01 so on so we will be very lonely and we
2:14:04 will feel less protected it's not
2:14:06 necessary for their survival but believe
2:14:08 it if he said without us we cannot we
2:14:10 cannot find ourselves from animals but
2:14:12 its company is is very highly desirable
2:14:16 for us
2:14:16 so he said augment was good so I went
2:14:19 back to all the messenger I said this is
2:14:20 not a special Go and Kill the dog until
2:14:22 I said must be killed and you kill the
2:14:24 dog
2:14:26 so this is most likely for public
2:14:28 protection from infection I I guess that
2:14:30 because it was the reason for getting
2:14:32 good then after that after obviously the
2:14:34 number has been reduced considerably and
2:14:35 then said
2:14:37 stop killing the dogs what's your
2:14:39 problem with dogs stop it now he did not
2:14:41 mention initially what's the reason not
2:14:43 in jail after that but she said stop
2:14:44 England and then was stopping killing
2:14:46 the dogs so that's public order
2:14:49 related to war
2:14:51 so he enforced eliminating the dogs
2:14:53 because but obviously to the rates most
2:14:55 likely Public Safety and Public Health
2:14:58 the thought where the state is
2:14:59 responsible so that's until he died
2:15:03 no enforcing because the state has to
2:15:07 collected and distribute it or they
2:15:09 distributed under supervision of the
2:15:10 state or they bring evidence that they
2:15:12 didn't distributed a legitimate way
2:15:14 otherwise it had to be collected and
2:15:16 there's no no if another that will be
2:15:18 enforced by the sport
2:15:19 this is because the cut is a social and
2:15:22 public and public commitment
2:15:25 yeah
2:15:29 you never checked anyone if you're doing
2:15:31 seriously
2:15:35 is the opposite
2:15:38 I will extreme opposite I'm just making
2:15:40 a bottom example he visited one lady
2:15:43 and ask her do you have anything to eat
2:15:45 to build something I said eat from it
2:15:47 take a bite from it said I'm fasting he
2:15:49 said maybe another or if I said and uh
2:15:54 said it is it will improve your ideal if
2:15:57 someone is if you are fasting and
2:15:58 someone eats in front of you it will
2:16:00 increase your value
2:16:02 so opposite what these these uh these
2:16:04 fake religious Saudi uh minister of
2:16:08 interior making an announcement whatever
2:16:09 that comes no one should be eat publicly
2:16:11 to to respect the feeling of the
2:16:13 Believers the only what they say doing
2:16:15 is relating the actions are declaring
2:16:17 the action obviously a lot to be wrong
2:16:19 and Reviving the belief of some of the
2:16:21 great reward to see someone eating while
2:16:22 you're fasting which gives you the
2:16:24 better feeling about what you are doing
2:16:26 and give you a feeling that yes I'm
2:16:29 fasting While others are eating
2:16:34 use a better internet commitment they're
2:16:36 just opposite all of these this behavior
2:16:38 of this government zone is either based
2:16:41 on fake in a definitely the order of
2:16:43 Ministry of interior of Saudi Arabia is
2:16:45 just just an act of hypocrisy to play
2:16:47 the religious card to full
2:16:49 disabled-minded people or we care about
2:16:51 us Islamic feeling we care about Siam
2:16:53 nobody should blame some publicly no I
2:16:55 just opened it that's what the
2:16:57 Protestants should be open and everyone
2:16:59 can eat if he wants it if he's a Muslim
2:17:02 then he is his comedic Haram and you
2:17:04 will punish them if he is a cafe that's
2:17:06 fine that says right or he should be
2:17:07 fasting
2:17:09 actually should encourage him because
2:17:10 fasting is healthy for him so he's he's
2:17:12 antibiotic his health to the hell with
2:17:14 him in his head
2:17:15 so that now we go through the what's
2:17:18 happening allegedly because of hijab
2:17:21 unless it is done in a demonstrative way
2:17:23 to challenge the public order but even
2:17:26 the shelter or that they should don't
2:17:27 know they shouldn't have been a public
2:17:29 order in the first place that hijab only
2:17:31 what should be enforced publicly is that
2:17:33 the minimum
2:17:35 which is enforced on everyone by
2:17:38 Solitaire
2:17:40 because it was not enforced by anybody
2:17:43 at the time Allah said
2:17:47 children of Adam take your Zina at
2:17:50 animasi at every Masjid every Masjid
2:17:53 again like like
2:17:57 a state of of Salah
2:18:00 or in the location of amasita
2:18:04 that addresses the fact that they have
2:18:06 the Pagan Habit to claim that
2:18:10 uh you should not make tawaf in the in
2:18:13 the clothing which you are committed sin
2:18:14 so either you get clothing from some
2:18:17 korashi which are supposed to be the
2:18:19 noble ones for sinless
2:18:22 and this will become a good business for
2:18:23 the quraishi if I leave that aside
2:18:25 that's the way your religion is always
2:18:27 abused Pagan or otherwise or if you
2:18:30 don't have then you'll make the love
2:18:31 naked at night men completely naked malt
2:18:35 nothing
2:18:38 with Janet has everything exposed and
2:18:40 women having uh
2:18:43 something almost like the Brazilian
2:18:46 bikini just like like something like a
2:18:48 strip covering the vagina and the anus
2:18:51 that's it
2:18:52 and all the rest of the well the bomb is
2:18:55 is exposed
2:18:56 so they will Auto take their Xena
2:19:01 later explanation
2:19:03 shows that the Xena for many will be
2:19:05 just to cover these anus and the other
2:19:07 from genitals the penis and the genital
2:19:09 for men cover more than that now more
2:19:11 than that otherwise goes usually from
2:19:13 from joint to joint or from a separation
2:19:16 but it's very so since uh covering the
2:19:19 the the
2:19:20 the the vagina and the answer is not
2:19:23 enough
2:19:24 which address to the Quran should not be
2:19:26 like that for women it should be more so
2:19:28 it should be covered all the tides and
2:19:30 so on but since we have obviously two
2:19:32 two significant body parts one starting
2:19:35 from below the anavel uh and the top
2:19:39 bone level of the of the hip there's a
2:19:43 bone there of the the end of spinal cord
2:19:46 essentially the bone all the way to the
2:19:49 next joint which is the knee so this
2:19:50 area or in between must be covered so
2:19:53 something like a shot
2:19:55 then you add then you have to take the
2:19:57 minimum absolute minimum
2:19:59 and for men as I said even like the
2:20:02 cabal resilient bikini or like the like
2:20:04 the address of these Japanese huge
2:20:07 wrestler that should be enough
2:20:09 they were not having that that's what
2:20:12 that's what all evidences about our also
2:20:16 indicate in public life how do we know
2:20:18 that's in public life they have to be
2:20:19 enforced because they adjusted too many
2:20:21 atoms so the obviously
2:20:23 because many many other are not
2:20:25 believers
2:20:28 nobody we don't believe that's from God
2:20:32 this is essentially meaning for those if
2:20:34 you have authority you should enforce in
2:20:35 public and this was done essentially in
2:20:37 the ninth year
2:20:38 in the last year of Hijra
2:20:44 was sent to it with uh and with certain
2:20:47 Commandments Allah was the commander of
2:20:50 the Hajj and the leader of the Hajj
2:20:51 delegation
2:20:52 and on behalf of the Prophet because of
2:20:54 us did not want to provide that here for
2:20:56 better scenes some people said one
2:20:57 reason is that says they were that still
2:20:59 mushiken were doing Hajj as obviously
2:21:01 because hajjad that year was the last
2:21:03 time Western because they were Shifting
2:21:05 the month and playing with with the
2:21:07 sanctuary so they're playing games with
2:21:09 the sanctuary but next year it would be
2:21:11 in the legend which is the time it will
2:21:13 be fixed until
2:21:14 you postponed history
2:21:17 went any whatever the reason and he sent
2:21:20 Ali with the opening of Bara and
2:21:22 announcing to everyone the open variety
2:21:24 and also announcing two things
2:21:27 and
2:21:38 no one will perform a throw off around
2:21:41 the Kaaba while he is naked
2:21:44 is prohibited now even if he's a Muslim
2:21:48 Muslim will not do that obviously
2:21:51 so
2:21:58 which is not generally allowed according
2:22:02 to uh to no compassionate religion you
2:22:06 should not enforce anyone something
2:22:07 which against his Creed
2:22:09 but this is excluded well because for
2:22:11 the public order and especially in the
2:22:13 Holy Sanctuary being naked is not
2:22:15 allowed
2:22:16 was enforced nobody will live you know
2:22:18 so that would be punished so that was
2:22:20 enforced publicly but only the minimum
2:22:22 as described how do we know minimum we
2:22:25 have to study all the issues
2:22:27 after that are for Muslims but also for
2:22:31 Muslims there was no evidence and no
2:22:33 story of enforcing anybody who was
2:22:34 deserted even when browser saw some
2:22:36 women who are not that is probably he
2:22:38 turned away he did not say and I should
2:22:40 ask him why it's supposed to be a three
2:22:43 asthma better be back up until don't you
2:22:45 see how she is dressed pigeons to he did
2:22:48 not beat her Italian takes it then
2:22:50 everything I just turned away showing
2:22:51 that he's just disapproving that a woman
2:22:54 should not show with me than the face
2:22:55 and the hands in public or some people
2:22:57 have discussed this Hadith and so on but
2:22:59 this is irrelevant but this is the
2:23:01 relevant is that he did not do any
2:23:02 action or all that anyone to go around
2:23:04 until the people don't do that and so on
2:23:10 or enforce it even you're telling maybe
2:23:12 telling is okay just announce it around
2:23:14 although there's people announce it for
2:23:17 both of Martin onion what needs to be
2:23:19 announced publicly is that for example
2:23:20 when one time there was a very thick
2:23:23 clouds and the people thought the sun
2:23:24 has said in Ramadan and they started
2:23:26 eating and then it cleared and their
2:23:29 sound was not set
2:23:30 let me see Allah send someone on a horse
2:23:32 going around in Medina quickly Allah
2:23:34 told you stop eating and then your
2:23:37 breakfast and that's it don't worry this
2:23:39 is this is a gift from Allah don't worry
2:23:42 about that but stop now eating until the
2:23:43 sun sets that's it that's the melody and
2:23:46 there was a necessity to send someone a
2:23:48 horse because there's no time to wait
2:23:49 for that for a wedding month so that's
2:23:51 that's all that has happened and then
2:23:53 forcing Ibraham I said not checking
2:23:56 anyone if he did it or legit then if a
2:23:58 second everyone if you're fast enough so
2:24:00 that's right from Allah whatever happens
2:24:02 after that
2:24:09 and things like that
2:24:12 and some people take that as Authority
2:24:13 it's not an authority
2:24:15 neither of them nor a worker nor anybody
2:24:17 after this is your last Authority it
2:24:19 can't be is
2:24:21 what you may approve you may disapprove
2:24:23 but it is instead but the fact that it
2:24:26 was not done by the prophet and this
2:24:27 Hadith I mentioned about the real coming
2:24:29 shining the prophet about beating some
2:24:31 people in a non-healthy way and in
2:24:34 another occasion shows that Omar's
2:24:36 adopting the Dora is a mistake
2:24:39 and you have to visit
2:24:40 but with that mistake you see that's a
2:24:42 mistake like that some people take it as
2:24:44 an outgoing if it's true some people
2:24:45 even argue this is all fabricated later
2:24:48 some some
2:24:50 rulers were interested to to attach to
2:24:53 attributorial many harsh actions and so
2:24:55 on which are not true
2:24:57 and and
2:25:00 this this way they they can they can't
2:25:04 have an argument for their own whips and
2:25:06 or their mortality but maybe anyway even
2:25:08 if it's happened for Mama I I wouldn't
2:25:11 be really bother very much studying that
2:25:12 or do it really or a CSM application
2:25:14 because even if you did it it's not an
2:25:17 authority we should get to that level to
2:25:19 see things like that for example here
2:25:21 that a woman uh have some certain
2:25:24 Behavior so he sends someone calling her
2:25:27 she was terrified and she aborted she
2:25:30 was pregnant
2:25:32 and the normal was in State of Shock
2:25:36 say what to do in this situation
2:25:38 and that's how I said you are you are a
2:25:40 head of state and you are an educator
2:25:42 tomorrow I did you have the right to
2:25:44 discipline like Father something like
2:25:46 that they are coming with a father
2:25:48 through the head of state
2:25:50 father
2:25:55 and that Ali was start silent
2:25:57 then say I see you I'm not saying
2:25:59 anything other commenting say that if
2:26:01 they give you fatwa according to your
2:26:03 desire are you going to take it say so
2:26:04 what's with the correct title you caused
2:26:07 here you you've terrified here you did
2:26:10 the you did the wrong action you
2:26:12 terrified there and she lost help me
2:26:13 because that you have to pay the DIA at
2:26:15 least
2:26:16 you did not do it intentionally you do
2:26:18 not want opposite this would be a
2:26:19 criminal act hypothesis but this is a
2:26:22 killing under for in the case and that's
2:26:24 that the job one was born alive and he
2:26:27 screamed and died so it's born alive and
2:26:29 died after that and the other cause of
2:26:31 his death
2:26:32 by your behavior it's a deal in you from
2:26:35 your money
2:26:37 so I almost paid the deal from his money
2:26:39 and his his uh next token because the
2:26:42 idea in in the case of killing of error
2:26:44 is on your money and the next stop can
2:26:45 not for my surgery
2:26:47 so clearly ideas regarded calling the
2:26:50 woman and terrifying her it's not
2:26:51 legitimate
2:26:54 or not warranted
2:26:57 because if it would have been legitimate
2:26:58 and a good act and this happened
2:27:00 accidentally that would be but the acts
2:27:02 itself well caught here I hear something
2:27:05 about here why
2:27:07 if someone's claims something bring your
2:27:09 evidence to come in a quarter low that's
2:27:11 the way to go
2:27:13 so it's short is like that they take
2:27:15 sometimes
2:27:20 he's the father of the of the of the
2:27:23 people yes in the meaning of care not
2:27:25 the meaning of punishment it's
2:27:27 punishment is only limited to the
2:27:29 prescribed punishment and prescribed
2:27:32 the same with the father by the people
2:27:34 think the father has a wide range of
2:27:37 punishments it's not true
2:27:39 even his own writer and even though
2:27:42 invoke something over here had you
2:27:43 thought that's not true
2:27:45 that's not true
2:27:46 he's not allowed also to be touching
2:27:48 them without any Justified reason to Etc
2:27:53 in The Sibling The Sibling does not
2:27:55 cover by beating and things like that
2:27:56 especially injurious meeting which is a
2:27:58 criminal act even for my father so this
2:28:01 is chaos from something which is best
2:28:03 wrong
2:28:04 so that's it so all of these issues
2:28:06 except really that there are moral of us
2:28:09 restrict Aura which should be enforced
2:28:10 in public even so for example there are
2:28:13 certain things also genie in India their
2:28:17 monks they go naked in the market that
2:28:20 should be prevented even if it is
2:28:21 obviously important you want to go and
2:28:23 record go in your Monastery and walk
2:28:25 naked around but in the market you have
2:28:27 to put at least as a man you have taught
2:28:29 at least something like the like the
2:28:31 Japanese wrestler or like the like the
2:28:34 Brazilian uh
2:28:37 what's his name the balazilian uh woman
2:28:41 or something similar from it and if it
2:28:44 is a woman you have to cover more maybe
2:28:46 from the knee up to the uh below below
2:28:49 that level
2:28:51 that's the meaning one thing about it
2:28:52 that has can be enforced publicly
2:28:54 because this will will will be a public
2:28:56 area of the issue
2:28:58 how it is probably called the issue by
2:28:59 the by the statement of the Quran
2:29:02 not by any philosophical consideration
2:29:03 but you will recognize that it will be
2:29:05 also completed because the majority of
2:29:07 human beings will be will be either
2:29:09 offended or diverted or someone driving
2:29:11 the car may be diverts his attention
2:29:13 make an accident soon so it touches a
2:29:16 public order
2:29:17 definitely
2:29:20 but we don't need to it's argument about
2:29:22 it it's enough that there is a Divine
2:29:24 injection
2:29:26 and the colon we should be established
2:29:29 by with certitude by all narrations that
2:29:31 that no one can do stuff around the holy
2:29:35 Sanctuary while being naked
2:29:38 which is obviously
2:29:41 and undermine with no compulsory and
2:29:43 religion but that is
2:29:45 so so it should be excluded from public
2:29:48 life that's the best argument you can
2:29:50 have but only that to that limit to that
2:29:52 minimum as I described the details of
2:29:55 the whole argument is is in some
2:29:57 research I started many years back but I
2:29:59 thought this is not around our priority
2:30:01 leave that aside you know that we need
2:30:04 to understand so many things to be
2:30:06 addressed which are accumulated over
2:30:07 history so sometimes I feel desperate
2:30:10 that when we overloaded by sometimes
2:30:12 issues which should have been mine or
2:30:14 should not have been a matter but
2:30:15 unfortunately they have become now the
2:30:17 regime in Iran
2:30:18 is as Dark Age mentality and backward as
2:30:22 that's how it is they're slightly better
2:30:24 and all of them are a bad example of
2:30:27 Islam let's be face on it in their
2:30:29 practices the ideology itself is
2:30:32 fundamentally flawed
2:30:35 is fundamentally float
2:30:42 but also the the monarchines of the
2:30:45 Arabia the claim that model case
2:30:46 possible as soon as is the same with the
2:30:49 word there's some people would say
2:30:50 letter clock is also a corporation
2:30:51 really because it it assumes that for
2:30:55 the hidden Iman which is also an
2:30:57 imaginary Theory which are completely a
2:30:59 fundamentally also flawed contradicting
2:31:02 Islam the the in the time the absence of
2:31:05 the so-called Imam
2:31:08 if he ever existed
2:31:11 that the vocal house substitute for him
2:31:13 based on on a on a almost certainly
2:31:16 fabricated narration almost certainly
2:31:19 fabricated
2:31:24 they claimed that a couple of guys in in
2:31:27 in in in in Samara and Baghdad also
2:31:30 claimed that they were able for 70 years
2:31:32 after the death of Muhammad
2:31:34 who who is well established historical
2:31:37 that he has not of offsprings and
2:31:39 there's a recorded the court records and
2:31:41 judges had attended to that and so it's
2:31:43 a well-established fact and many people
2:31:45 witnessed that Shia and Sunni and so on
2:31:47 nevertheless some people claim no there
2:31:49 was actually there was actually a child
2:31:51 born by his by his mistress so and so on
2:31:53 I don't know her name and the child
2:31:55 crawled in a in an under tunnel and
2:31:57 disappeared
2:31:58 and this is the 12th Imam
2:32:01 constructing a 121 who doesn't exist
2:32:03 whatsoever and he is there and these
2:32:06 guys claim for the last 70 years it's
2:32:08 called the ribosora the the small
2:32:12 absenteeism that they were going there
2:32:14 and writing uh a piece of paper or
2:32:17 another a notebook but I think for him
2:32:20 leaving it and they kill him next day we
2:32:22 come and find the answer to the question
2:32:24 claims
2:32:28 now I will see is answering your
2:32:30 questions that's after 70 years after
2:32:32 this disappearance I see that's a good
2:32:34 question I will be raiba Cobra until
2:32:37 Allah allows me to appear
2:32:39 in my rival cobra the authority on you
2:32:42 is one of those who narrates our
2:32:45 our Hadith
2:32:53 they are the authority and there
2:32:57 and they take that how many take that
2:32:59 and few other as evidences the Imam is
2:33:02 absent we cannot wait for him to come
2:33:04 that the general Doctrine was for a
2:33:06 thousand years or more is that anyone
2:33:09 trying to become an Imam is sinful and
2:33:11 Criminal
2:33:12 and anyone who is taking Imam actually
2:33:15 with money is a tyrant
2:33:17 the violating he's transgressing with
2:33:19 the episode so a theory which is
2:33:21 untenable made the Shia completely
2:33:24 decapacitated politically
2:33:27 although they were quite well well well
2:33:29 knit surgery but politically they have
2:33:33 completely capacitated and then the
2:33:35 recent memories done so some serious
2:33:37 specifically developed the theory that
2:33:39 it can't collect that forever
2:33:44 authority of the reports
2:33:51 our our stories and our injunctions
2:33:54 either they they should have the
2:33:56 authority they will answer the question
2:33:58 meaning that that's it not be
2:33:59 competitive State and be established
2:34:01 anyway a state based on on the virtues
2:34:05 of scholarship is is a is a church like
2:34:08 State it's a church it's another state
2:34:11 that's not the way the Islamic State
2:34:12 works neither in tablet or profit as I
2:34:15 explained knowledge
2:34:17 with small deviation and mistakes in
2:34:20 time of Washington and then massive
2:34:21 violation and transgression from
2:34:23 starting from one hour onward
2:34:26 so but this is all quite deep under
2:34:30 under and need to be developed from
2:34:34 scratch from the past principled I think
2:34:37 that's the reason we started that we
2:34:39 started with
2:34:40 and we based on that one on on
2:34:44 the Constitution but there are a few
2:34:47 things to be added for example to the
2:34:48 Confederation like the Treaty of najaran
2:34:51 which improves and and
2:34:56 further further information about the
2:34:59 status of Confederates who are not
2:35:01 Muslims like with the Jews because the
2:35:04 Jews were expelled unfortunately because
2:35:06 of uh various various War acts and and
2:35:09 betrayals but the najrani were there
2:35:13 under the with the treaty with them and
2:35:14 they were there until the time and so on
2:35:17 so this and that the treaty was made
2:35:19 then by the prophet Salama this is
2:35:21 available in a record in writing until
2:35:23 then
2:35:24 wrote it down and so the original one
2:35:27 with the signature under his writing in
2:35:29 it so this is this is a absolute
2:35:32 Authority supporting the sahiba and
2:35:34 improving the issue the only sister
2:35:35 there is a little bit more injunction
2:35:37 about the respect for cherishes for
2:35:39 crosses for all these things and also
2:35:41 the prohibition even in the
2:35:43 confederation of usury
2:35:46 so establishing like a common basic
2:35:48 common uh Financial system
2:35:51 but again
2:35:53 all the public order things that are
2:35:56 interfere to by by the authorities in
2:35:59 Islam that's that's it
2:36:00 and then and the best thing is that is
2:36:02 this issue every issue is not an issue
2:36:05 of State until proven to be a racial
2:36:06 State because generally
2:36:10 every issue is related to somebody is in
2:36:13 the Divine injunction all of them are
2:36:15 holding another word for you have no
2:36:18 dominance
2:36:19 clarified by these two Hadith and others
2:36:23 you should not use a stick you should
2:36:25 not use that you need that
2:36:28 so all of this is very clear that that
2:36:30 so the basically that whatever people
2:36:32 and do soon
2:36:34 in matter of creed whatever the
2:36:36 publicize there's not it's not a matter
2:36:37 of the state to inter 300 unless there
2:36:39 is real evidence that it is within the
2:36:42 state Authority
2:36:44 has here's the question so can we say
2:36:45 that the Islamic State can enforce the
2:36:47 minimum to be covered to be what you
2:36:49 have to cover in prayer
2:36:51 okay
2:36:52 that's in prayer
2:36:54 foreign
2:37:02 that's it that's what he said
2:37:04 Whenever there was never a generation
2:37:06 that he sent people everywhere to make
2:37:08 sure that women praying with Hema or
2:37:10 beating them up or not beating them
2:37:12 because they were doing it
2:37:13 we know that we're doing it but any
2:37:15 enforcing but yeah
2:37:18 but in the case of prayers clearly
2:37:20 because if you are praying and you want
2:37:22 your prayer to be accepted then you have
2:37:23 to would you know this injunction you
2:37:25 have to comply with the injunction
2:37:26 that's it
2:37:32 that's it
2:37:33 it may help for example president so a
2:37:36 young girl which shows signs that she
2:37:39 coming out of age obviously with with
2:37:41 with the breaststroke being said being
2:37:44 expressed and things like that and he
2:37:46 told the thing I think this girl is
2:37:48 coming out of age and he gave her when
2:37:51 he is out when he was essay because they
2:37:53 shot obvious and money and shortened
2:37:54 clothing cut from here
2:37:57 tell her to to use to start using hammer
2:38:00 that's in there in the public lab she
2:38:01 was playing without these things
2:38:03 I think she she's now out of which so
2:38:05 meaning to make a meaning check if she's
2:38:07 out of age really by being menstruating
2:38:09 and give her the trimmer and if you
2:38:11 don't have a fabric available cut from
2:38:13 my gay very easier to cut from that
2:38:16 so this state should provide the camera
2:38:18 if anyone asks for it what appears to be
2:38:20 there that's it
2:38:22 so someone could say okay if sue someone
2:38:24 or system to be success with a woman
2:38:27 definitely a woman that's very clear
2:38:29 secondly she's three years seem to be a
2:38:31 Muslim
2:38:32 why you're not wearing a hamar are
2:38:34 either here we have a hamar for you as a
2:38:36 gift that's all that you can do
2:38:38 if you want to upload this Hadith
2:38:41 that's it no need to take police and so
2:38:43 on I said except people doing
2:38:45 demonstrating and doing like burning the
2:38:47 hammer publicly or or like like
2:38:50 insulting the public order
2:38:55 yeah I'm not carrying I don't believe it
2:38:57 is good and so that's you can say but
2:38:58 doing it for in such a demonstrative way
2:39:01 to to be insulting
2:39:03 that will be an act of War but it has to
2:39:05 be something which shows really
2:39:07 objection and and rejection and uh in
2:39:10 such a way that uh a judge will analyze
2:39:13 say would if this person hadn't had a
2:39:16 power and and arms and an army and tanks
2:39:18 would he use them for that yes he would
2:39:20 do then he but he didn't have them so
2:39:22 he's div so he's the jure although not
2:39:25 de facto it's not factual Warrior but
2:39:27 he's
2:39:28 legally a warrior
2:39:31 and he will be in a judge will judge the
2:39:34 situation according to the to the
2:39:35 maximum because declare someone to be a
2:39:37 warrior needs he needs a company of
2:39:39 himself someone is pulling the sword and
2:39:40 fighting you don't need this clearly
2:39:42 he's fighting but someone is not pulling
2:39:44 the sword you have to have all the
2:39:46 subconscious showing like this one who
2:39:48 married the this is the prime example
2:39:50 because he he he he had drums and he has
2:39:54 a wedding celebration and if there at
2:39:56 that time the fireworks if he had a
2:39:58 fireworks he would shot them in heaven
2:40:00 and so on
2:40:01 public demonstration that you
2:40:03 disrespecting the other not only to
2:40:06 marry other questions and this one is a
2:40:08 Muslim if you would not be a Muslim it
2:40:10 may maybe nothing was in because I I
2:40:12 know that in najib for example
2:40:15 adopted the the majusi belief
2:40:19 allows to marry maybe not I think I
2:40:21 think he allows the money the the wife
2:40:23 of your father but even more allow us to
2:40:25 marry your own daughter and so on and
2:40:27 some of them did that before Islam and
2:40:30 we have never narration type of the
2:40:31 Prophet or after him that anyone went
2:40:34 there and enforce anything otherwise for
2:40:36 those who estimate remain juicy
2:40:39 and there's a narration for Roma that he
2:40:42 that he ordered the one who collected
2:40:44 jizier from the museum
2:40:46 that that he should order them to stop
2:40:50 the zamzama the zamzama is that a way of
2:40:53 they mention Allah by by squeezing their
2:40:57 teeth and something like that
2:41:00 if it happens
2:41:02 he's not commenting what Rama did
2:41:05 because he did not want to be to be seen
2:41:08 as criticism
2:41:09 stepped over his limit
2:41:11 although it has to do with your zamzama
2:41:14 even if it's the carloof
2:41:17 but seems to be normal has some some
2:41:19 inclination to be more like an sometimes
2:41:21 regarding himself as educator or as an
2:41:23 enforcer of things
2:41:25 but he's mistaken in that blatantly
2:41:27 mistake
2:41:34 in this instance you've got you've got
2:41:36 an illegitimate regime to start with
2:41:39 um
2:41:40 in this instance in Iran you've got an
2:41:42 illegitimate regime because the other
2:41:44 half bear no besides that beside that
2:41:46 but assuming it is limit or that people
2:41:49 think it's legitimate something like
2:41:51 that still
2:41:52 and they sometimes they use that for the
2:41:55 legitimacy because they appeal to save
2:41:57 more worthy and these Scholars and uh
2:41:59 and uh
2:42:01 uh this this scholar and this Ayatollah
2:42:04 and this one or these classical Scholars
2:42:06 like uh uh like the one who collected
2:42:09 the famous psychoculaini or the some
2:42:11 others were not to be fatigue and so on
2:42:14 um
2:42:15 many many of us Scholars who are having
2:42:17 great Fame and and they have the same
2:42:19 messy point of view about the state and
2:42:21 the enforcement uh similar to
2:42:25 although they should they should not be
2:42:27 there because the Imam is not there and
2:42:29 anyone's doing anything is a tyrant so
2:42:31 how come the the the tyrants are allowed
2:42:33 to do that maybe we'll say this is part
2:42:35 of the Tyranny anyway so we don't bother
2:42:38 about it so the Shia is even in worse
2:42:40 position like that because even this
2:42:42 type of regime many of them declare to
2:42:44 be tyranny anyway but it's made
2:42:46 existence
2:42:49 but let's go generally take away from
2:42:51 this sunnishi and the sectarian go to
2:42:54 the Islamic Court position there's
2:42:55 nothing there uh enforces that
2:42:58 foreign absolutely nothing
2:43:01 so to recap to the other four man is
2:43:04 basically the the private parts on the
2:43:06 button
2:43:07 the state the state Authority extends
2:43:09 only to to defending the borders to
2:43:12 military Affairs and security related to
2:43:14 that to collecting taxes and fail and
2:43:17 and zakat
2:43:20 possibly the mint minting currency and
2:43:23 so on you know make it a legal tender in
2:43:25 that sense all the currency could be the
2:43:28 people choose their own currency by the
2:43:29 way so if they should not have even
2:43:31 prohibited Bitcoin or people having
2:43:33 using gold so something like what what
2:43:36 Roosevelt did in the 30s prohibiting
2:43:38 Americans from having gold and
2:43:40 confiscated with all gold Fort Knox
2:43:41 would have been an act of couple an
2:43:43 Islamic domain
2:43:44 but the state May mean something
2:43:47 soldiers so that we will have have a
2:43:49 reliable uh dinar we say ah this is have
2:43:52 this weight guaranteed by the state
2:43:54 doing it in a proper way and even that
2:43:56 money um
2:43:58 he starts inventing uh they call the
2:44:01 Islamic or the Arabic dinner people
2:44:03 praised that for him but why why did he
2:44:05 do that because he did not want the one
2:44:08 coming from the Romans from the Roman
2:44:11 from Byzantine Empire and but but I I
2:44:14 doubt that there's a limited because the
2:44:16 Byzantine dinar until the time of the
2:44:18 Prophet will show the legal dinner known
2:44:19 all over the world because it's gold
2:44:21 pure gold is was 4.7 gram
2:44:25 made his dinner
2:44:27 4.25 so he snatched like half a gram in
2:44:32 his belly and the people thought it's
2:44:33 4.7
2:44:35 it's a major criminal act from his side
2:44:37 but the people do not see that yet we
2:44:39 have to dig all of that to dig them we
2:44:41 have to dig the dirt out of Islamic
2:44:43 history
2:44:46 so even there he was not trustworthy
2:44:50 if you would have to say this is the
2:44:52 modified dinner with this weight but he
2:44:53 did not say this is the dinner that's
2:44:55 not true
2:44:58 the one who was at the time there was of
2:45:00 course approved it and it was
2:45:02 this is this is a Ford's dinner this is
2:45:05 a counterfeit dinner
2:45:10 here's a question so so non-muslims I
2:45:13 can understand more Muslims they can go
2:45:15 out as willy-nilly pardon the punt so
2:45:18 for women it's um you know I can
2:45:22 understand it uh there are accounts of
2:45:24 like subbies and whatever but
2:45:26 a Muslim woman going being allowed to go
2:45:29 out like that I mean there's no reason
2:45:31 because I loved it's not allowed but the
2:45:32 state does not enforce okay
2:45:35 did we say it's a loud
2:45:42 I did not see them yet
2:45:49 the enforcement police of tyrants and
2:45:52 women who are covered are not covered
2:45:54 naked are not naked and they walk
2:45:57 like dancing and they have their hair up
2:46:00 like like a camel Etc you know the
2:46:04 famous description
2:46:06 and he what does he say
2:46:08 s
2:46:10 that's it
2:46:12 why
2:46:19 which is not even the best way sir if
2:46:22 you think she's almost gonna say sister
2:46:24 she's not allowed to do that she said no
2:46:26 no I am following another school I am
2:46:27 not a muslim okay fine myself
2:46:29 I'm not listening to you just get lost
2:46:32 then you can't cut his head Refuge but I
2:46:34 wouldn't advise even Casey button 127 as
2:46:36 a general principle they are worthy of
2:46:38 character so kill them
2:46:40 you could have said prevent them beat
2:46:41 them up
2:46:42 look them away
2:46:45 so without you know intervention with
2:46:47 the state they can go to the beach
2:46:48 wearing a bikini and his United States
2:46:51 wouldn't be able to prevent that in any
2:46:52 respect
2:46:53 if it's if the key if the lower part is
2:46:56 as is described
2:46:59 all the naked beaches will be
2:47:01 essentially prohibited public that they
2:47:03 have to do it then in their own and
2:47:05 their own uh private land with the
2:47:08 behind the sufficiently high walls their
2:47:10 own swimming pools and they're on
2:47:12 swimming pools Behind the Walls they
2:47:13 can't be naked there have a son but
2:47:16 that's that's not the public life but in
2:47:18 the public domain Industries or the
2:47:19 beach it will be it will be uh not
2:47:22 really that many more
2:47:23 so the genuine bikini will not allow
2:47:26 them for a woman so it has to be more be
2:47:27 like a shot
2:47:29 but the top the top part is irrelevant
2:47:31 does the Western understanding of Aura
2:47:34 that's not actually understanding of
2:47:39 we've got a brother who wanted to
2:47:41 comment on uh on Zoom uh related to
2:47:45 um the previous discussion around Qatar
2:47:47 uh I can ask him do you want to speak
2:47:51 now yeah
2:47:53 uh so so uh unrelated to my question so
2:47:57 uh just the final thing that you said uh
2:48:01 going topless you know it's banned and
2:48:04 it's it's it's for the Western principle
2:48:07 it's like disgusting for for women to Go
2:48:09 Topless but are you saying that it's
2:48:12 permissible
2:48:13 for women if they want like in in in in
2:48:16 in in in a format that outrage the whole
2:48:18 body except face on a for Muslim
2:48:20 movement for non-muslim woman or for
2:48:22 sinful Muslim women they they had the
2:48:24 state will not enforce I'm talking about
2:48:26 imposing on the state prevention oh okay
2:48:28 yes I think it was talking very clear
2:48:31 there yes Muslim woman it is to explore
2:48:34 anything besides the face and the hand
2:48:38 yes yes
2:48:41 and they have a description of that in
2:48:44 this research about Julius what is what
2:48:47 is the minimum or those I have made a
2:48:50 recording and whether I mock like for
2:48:52 example sometimes
2:48:59 for example the the Jill Bob in Iran
2:49:02 which women have to to hold cannot hold
2:49:04 them please except by biting it with
2:49:06 their own teeth
2:49:07 this is disgusting but it still is a
2:49:10 jailbreak but it's going again so
2:49:13 extreme but what's the real minimum
2:49:14 there are many very nice
2:49:18 developed in Egypt
2:49:21 this is
2:49:22 very nice and even aesthetically
2:49:25 pleasing
2:49:27 with various nice colors not in this
2:49:29 black bleak
2:49:32 as all discussed in that research but
2:49:34 these are fine points because it's
2:49:35 addressing the Muslim woman as Muslim
2:49:38 not for the state or influence you are
2:49:41 wearing uh your your babies is red or or
2:49:45 uh
2:49:46 having multi-colored or having flower
2:49:49 there absolutely perfect no problem it's
2:49:51 none of the state issues whatsoever
2:49:53 anyway this is a moment so if the state
2:49:56 stable in that it will be stepping way
2:49:58 overbound
2:50:00 will be breaking even the Lord we
2:50:02 believe
2:50:02 from the stateside but I'm talking about
2:50:05 someone violating the injunction of
2:50:07 Muslim women she being a Muslim or being
2:50:09 a catheter being a catheter she is not
2:50:11 addressed with this injunction
2:50:12 so the issue for example the assumpty I
2:50:14 said that the hour of the cafe is like
2:50:17 out of a donkey she can't even go with
2:50:19 all the vagina is not Aura it's not
2:50:22 correct because
2:50:24 that has to be covered in the public
2:50:27 life
2:50:30 yes I think I think it's clear uh I I
2:50:33 have three quick points here
2:50:36 um yeah so so when when you corrected
2:50:39 the narrative that when Prophet Allah
2:50:43 made Hijra to Medina he did not become
2:50:46 immediately a head of state and you
2:50:48 mentioned uh some um some some proofs
2:50:52 for that I just want to add to this as
2:50:54 well that in in the pledge of Aqaba the
2:50:58 prophet did not ask them to uh to give
2:51:01 them they are to become the head of
2:51:03 state No in fact the contrary he asked
2:51:06 him actually he told them you uh
2:51:09 um
2:51:13 which means that you are responsible for
2:51:17 your people and I'm responsible
2:51:21 exactly so so he did not ask them to you
2:51:24 know make by other to when I come to
2:51:26 Medina I'll become uh
2:51:28 even if we
2:51:30 not have this sentence the wedding with
2:51:33 advisor the wire is very clear that they
2:51:36 have their own head upstairs and nobody
2:51:37 will will will argue that now we give
2:51:40 Muhammad of protection that we can jump
2:51:42 on our rulers unless they show the
2:51:45 command clear cover or do clear cover no
2:51:47 you have no Liberty you have to commit
2:51:49 to that you have to keep the system in
2:51:50 place you have to be to have the the
2:51:52 organizational structure of the
2:51:54 community as it is unlisted the cover
2:51:56 which allows that obviously to end that
2:51:58 but otherwise Muhammad and the
2:52:01 protection for him does not undermine
2:52:03 that in order to contradicts that nor it
2:52:05 is designed to unlock to to obligate
2:52:07 that
2:52:08 yeah yeah uh so uh the second thing I
2:52:13 want to add is something nice uh when
2:52:16 you said that living in Makkah was
2:52:19 demanding and like a huge responsibility
2:52:21 for people who live in Medina for in in
2:52:23 Mecca because they have to uh avoid sins
2:52:27 because the sins is like uh
2:52:30 multiplied by the way the same thing for
2:52:34 rewards uh for Good Deeds the reward is
2:52:37 Amplified as well and and the nice thing
2:52:42 about it is a uh some tabies in the past
2:52:45 I I cannot remember the name but they
2:52:48 they actually migrated from Mecca and
2:52:51 went to live someone else because they
2:52:53 were afraid uh that uh absolutely
2:52:57 they could not they could not live
2:52:59 properly in Makkah and they did they
2:53:02 would like they would mix since they
2:53:04 would commit sins so instead of
2:53:07 committing since the like they they
2:53:09 completely feared doing that so they
2:53:11 migrated some somewhere else they'll be
2:53:13 always from sahaba and terrain people of
2:53:15 High sensitivity exactly
2:53:18 yes yeah
2:53:20 but such a high rank will not reach but
2:53:23 at least the minimum we should try to
2:53:25 strive to get
2:53:27 peaceful and more gentle and more
2:53:29 accommodating and more pressure more
2:53:32 spiritual yeah more spiritual more
2:53:33 peacefully like mostly more peaceful not
2:53:36 violent lesson that elsewhere it seems
2:53:38 to be the opposite many monkeys are
2:53:40 known to be vicious and very sharp
2:53:42 tongue then like a sword yes seem to
2:53:46 have complied with that much better
2:53:47 because Medina is also having similar
2:53:49 injunction like Mecca
2:53:52 and despite of that is not expressed
2:53:55 very clearly and sharply in the
2:53:56 workbooks automatically expressed that
2:53:59 very strongly they even say Madina is
2:54:01 better than Mecca but the people of
2:54:03 Madina seems to be they have tuned like
2:54:05 that because the majorities have over
2:54:07 there so they inherited these things
2:54:09 over generation while Lama K are quite
2:54:11 nasty in many aspects but anyways
2:54:15 to get the people becoming angry with us
2:54:18 today so leave us
2:54:20 yes okay okay the third thing the third
2:54:24 and final thing the third and final
2:54:26 thing uh going back to the issue of of
2:54:28 qadar
2:54:30 I have a question here is it fair to say
2:54:34 that Allah
2:54:36 does not necessarily uh know uh know
2:54:41 your choice in the past time but he
2:54:44 knows all possibilities of your choices
2:54:47 and whatever you choose he will not be
2:54:50 surprised by it yes that's something to
2:54:52 say between the past time no what has
2:54:54 happened in the past has done and
2:54:56 finished that's gone that's known but
2:54:58 what is to be done in the future yes
2:55:01 that that's that's that that's the the
2:55:04 specifically not known otherwise if it
2:55:07 is if it's known
2:55:08 if it it would it would it would mean
2:55:12 you you're because his knowledge kind of
2:55:14 turned into ignorance so if you know
2:55:15 this guy will will uh they will fail
2:55:20 that test and he choose to fail that if
2:55:22 he knew that in advance then the word
2:55:24 chooses is empty because he knew that he
2:55:27 never said his choice cannot undermine
2:55:28 Allah knowledge it's impossible
2:55:31 foreign
2:55:58 it could have been otherwise but that's
2:56:00 the choice right this will have to live
2:56:02 with that choice that's how it is done
2:56:03 and that should always give you this
2:56:05 option and that show is made the future
2:56:07 events
2:56:09 with the majority of them unknowable and
2:56:12 un non-existent until they are done
2:56:15 so they are unknowable
2:56:17 now you could say phrase differences
2:56:19 future events
2:56:22 are made by Allah or allowed to happen
2:56:24 by Allah then they become knowable
2:56:26 because of that because before that they
2:56:28 don't exist they're impossible taxes
2:56:30 without Allah's permission
2:56:33 if the ummah does not come it doesn't it
2:56:36 will never happen it's impossible
2:56:39 yes because because you know the
2:56:41 traditional uh the tradition the
2:56:44 traditional thinking for Muslim Scholars
2:56:46 they say that Allah knows things but but
2:56:49 his knowledge is not here his knowledge
2:56:52 is usually give the example his
2:56:53 knowledge does not enforce anything but
2:56:55 yeah they usually give the example you
2:56:58 know for example from the behavior of
2:56:59 the son so that he would fail in school
2:57:01 and so on but the mistake with that is
2:57:03 that this the one who knows about his
2:57:06 son that is not is not a comprehensively
2:57:07 in control of the universe he's not
2:57:10 controlled preconditional after
2:57:11 condition but the one in the case of
2:57:13 Allah it is not possible his knowledge
2:57:15 must cannot contain wrong
2:57:17 is knowledge enforces so it must happen
2:57:19 like that so
2:57:22 meaning essentially uh that he he has no
2:57:26 choice and the other one has no choice
2:57:27 it must be like that
2:57:29 then he turns out to be a mechanism if
2:57:31 we go from the beginning of time again
2:57:33 so that's what they have over there the
2:57:35 Allah says
2:57:37 the Divine knowledge is
2:57:41 enforcing our knowledge isn't enforce it
2:57:44 I could guess that if I see a car
2:57:45 driving speed say most likely he will
2:57:48 have an accident I cannot do anything
2:57:50 about that but the one who controlled
2:57:52 the whole universe and can prevent it
2:57:53 from happening and not happening
2:57:55 his his knowledge that it will happen
2:57:57 many guy has decided that it will happen
2:57:59 I allowed to happen
2:58:03 so there's a difference between the
2:58:05 necessarily existing absolute
2:58:07 surveillance of the universe and
2:58:08 contingent being who can go and their
2:58:10 knowledge is never with certainty but
2:58:12 let's assume it's near certainty still
2:58:14 it is not enforcing because they are not
2:58:16 the controller they invest they're not
2:58:17 controlled the whole thing from its zero
2:58:20 point start
2:58:21 but the one who is since control from
2:58:23 zero point until now and continuously
2:58:26 the future will but also the theory is
2:58:28 faulty that when they come to Antonio
2:58:30 say this all of this and clouds after
2:58:34 that what's happening
2:58:36 is not clear what's happening there so
2:58:39 the theory is faulty so if the
2:58:42 pre-knowledge is corrected we'll go for
2:58:43 an Infinity which again create infinite
2:58:46 contradictions that's all this nonsense
2:58:48 it will stand no no philosophical
2:58:51 scrutiny no mathematical scrutiny
2:58:54 head of all forget about all these
2:58:57 philosophical and mathematical models
2:58:59 just read the Quran and say that's as it
2:59:02 says that Allah will know it is not
2:59:04 known before the Quran says clearly and
2:59:06 there's no good for compelling reason to
2:59:08 deviate from that because some some
2:59:10 people claim that he must know
2:59:12 everything
2:59:15 was about eternity after that
2:59:21 um yeah but we'll write that inshallah
2:59:24 we write that in detail each other with
2:59:26 many examples of boring examples
2:59:28 inshallah but Allah he knows all
2:59:31 possibilities of naturally a few choices
2:59:34 all possibilities are known to him yes
2:59:37 all contingencies are not today
2:59:40 yes got it got it okay that's not the
2:59:42 usual formula the usual format they use
2:59:44 we read in the book of the haters in
2:59:47 Saudi Arabia
2:59:49 um
3:00:04 because this is the possibility things
3:00:06 in the past which did not happen but
3:00:08 could have been otherwise he would have
3:00:10 known that time passed they could have
3:00:13 been that what doesn't happen is gone
3:00:18 um
3:00:22 this is an addition we don't need this
3:00:25 yes yes
3:00:30 um
3:00:31 because it it is it's not knowable
3:00:33 because it does not exist yet it has to
3:00:35 a decision has to make it to come into
3:00:37 existence then knowledge will follow
3:00:38 that
3:00:40 yes yes got it I think I think now it's
3:00:42 clear thank you sir thank you I think we
3:00:45 we did a bit longer than usual but uh
3:00:47 because we have actually two major
3:00:49 topics
3:00:50 in terms okay
3:00:54 next weekend
3:01:04 for next week
3:01:05 definitely
3:01:07 Music
3:01:34 Music
3:01:39 Music
3:01:43 foreign
3:01:49 Music
3:01:57 Music