0:00:09 Music
0:00:23 thank you
0:00:31 and then continue
0:00:42 unknown okay okay
0:00:44 it's listening so
0:01:17 welcome Dave views brothers and sisters
0:01:20 to episode 120 of our the first sessions
0:01:22 of the noble Quran with Professor Dr
0:01:25 Mohammed bin Abdullah al-masri
0:01:27 these episodes of broadcast live on the
0:01:29 study Circles of Professor Dr Muhammad
0:01:31 YouTube channel every Sunday at 1pm
0:01:35 UK time we invite you to subscribe to
0:01:38 the channel and activate the
0:01:39 notification Bell for all new content
0:01:41 please note also the link to the live
0:01:43 broadcast for Mighty dissemination
0:01:45 do not forget to interact with us during
0:01:47 the broadcast by participating in the
0:01:49 comments and asking questions through
0:01:51 the chat box you find via the broadcast
0:01:52 link next to the video
0:01:54 also do not forget to support our
0:01:56 activities by donating when asking
0:01:58 questions in the conversation or through
0:02:00 the thank you button under our video
0:02:02 today is Sunday the 11th of December the
0:02:06 professor continues his interpretation
0:02:07 of the fear of Surah we are now on Ayah
0:02:11 58.
0:02:14 um
0:02:22 it just says uh gets a couple of
0:02:25 translations let us invest
0:02:28 say if that were you so hastily demand
0:02:30 were in my power everything would indeed
0:02:32 have been decided between me and you God
0:02:35 knows best as to what as to who is doing
0:02:37 wrong yes translation say if what you
0:02:39 seek to rush were in my power everything
0:02:41 would have been decided between you and
0:02:43 me but God knows best who does wrong
0:02:46 most likely what's addressed here is
0:02:48 that they were asking
0:02:50 bring us the punishment you are
0:02:52 promising that's it so it would have
0:02:54 been to me I am already fed up with you
0:02:56 that's his meaning but Allah's message
0:02:58 is bigger than my mercy and his patience
0:03:00 is infinite not like my patients I will
0:03:03 try to have them at habit already inside
0:03:04 it and if even if they were asking for
0:03:07 for miracles we I would have asked for
0:03:11 or brought a miracle which force you to
0:03:14 believe or like with the Quran and one
0:03:15 but I said if we wished we could bring
0:03:17 some
0:03:18 Ayah which will break their necks down
0:03:20 the verga have no way except to submit
0:03:22 like for example an iron law comes from
0:03:25 heaven and squeeze your neck down say
0:03:27 believe otherwise you'll be your neck
0:03:28 will be broken and squeeze a bit a bit
0:03:30 and then you are forced them to lose it
0:03:31 yes I admit I believe that's that's easy
0:03:34 for Allah and if the messenger had
0:03:35 access to that he would have done it
0:03:37 long ago he doesn't have the patience
0:03:38 the Divine patience
0:03:40 but you are lucky that real lord of the
0:03:43 universes is much more patient much more
0:03:45 forgiving than you than you imagine and
0:03:48 he knows that I'm just one he knows who
0:03:50 had the wrong so that's just just then
0:03:53 it goes down with issues which they said
0:03:55 will be getting us a little bit deep
0:03:57 I'll start to go not extremely deep for
0:04:00 the general public but we we cannot
0:04:02 avoid being deep in that because it has
0:04:04 implications with Theology and other
0:04:06 things thanks Aya
0:04:08 foreign
0:04:35 and in the sea and not to leaf falls but
0:04:38 he knows it and neither is there a grain
0:04:40 in the Earth the Deep Darkness nor
0:04:42 anything living or dead but is recorded
0:04:45 in his clear decree next translation
0:04:48 he holds the keys to the unknown no one
0:04:52 knows those keys but him he knows all
0:04:55 that is on land and in Sea and not a
0:04:58 leaf falls without him knowing about it
0:04:59 there is not a grain in the earth deep
0:05:01 Darkness or anything living or dead that
0:05:04 is not written in a clear record so this
0:05:06 is very complex
0:05:09 series of symptoms the first one is that
0:05:11 he has the keys of the Unseen or the
0:05:13 things which Beyond human conception
0:05:15 here's the keys the note is the word
0:05:17 keys
0:05:19 doesn't say the knowledge of right
0:05:21 that's not an issue the issue is the
0:05:23 keys so there are keys of right keys for
0:05:25 that or Beyond real conception the
0:05:28 things which he has the initial
0:05:29 capabilities and power to access those
0:05:32 either as a knowledge or as a mode of
0:05:35 action so restricting it to only the
0:05:37 knowledge is a mistake
0:05:39 people
0:05:41 and these keys
0:05:43 only he knows
0:05:44 and nobody otherwise will be able to
0:05:46 know we may describe them verbally with
0:05:49 some sentences but it's just a
0:05:50 description trying to bring something
0:05:53 which is really beyond the common
0:05:54 combination itself
0:05:57 and in in some few sentences should
0:06:00 explain a little bit of things so we
0:06:02 have some some rudimentary conceptual or
0:06:05 mental image we may but nobody knows
0:06:09 them really in the reality except the
0:06:11 one who knows himself
0:06:12 we'll discuss with these kids there's
0:06:15 one Hadith which explains
0:06:26 in the famous eye and the Hadith says
0:06:30 R5 those fives and this is usually
0:06:34 misinterpreted we are not mentioning
0:06:36 that here this just casually just to
0:06:38 really revive and remind The Listener
0:06:41 especially the one who was scholarly
0:06:42 oriented first of all
0:06:44 5 and mention these things
0:06:48 this is only an example because the
0:06:50 number five doesn't matter is only five
0:06:51 so it does not say it's five or no more
0:06:53 than that it's there's five of them this
0:06:55 there and interestingly there some of
0:06:59 them one of it is related to knowledge
0:07:01 Allah related to action
0:07:05 he has the knowledge when the hour will
0:07:08 strike
0:07:09 and the other one is not only the
0:07:11 knowledge but the action
0:07:13 he brings down the rain let's notice
0:07:16 that Hadith mentioning that right five
0:07:21 I'm just reminding everyone who admit
0:07:23 most people have heard about that Hadith
0:07:25 and they think oh yeah it is only these
0:07:27 five with the message
0:07:32 does not mean it is exclusive and it is
0:07:35 no more than that and that's very
0:07:37 obvious uh like in many a Hadith for
0:07:40 example the the destructive sins are
0:07:42 seven
0:07:44 seven miss another Hadith another has
0:07:47 mentioned another seven on a some people
0:07:50 got stuck to say how come that actually
0:07:52 is more than seven yeah it's more than
0:07:54 seven when you say that there are
0:07:55 mentioning seven for you now another
0:07:57 time when we shall be most of them again
0:07:59 and maybe another one added another one
0:08:01 subtracted if you add all of them will
0:08:04 be 14 15 17 maybe 20. destructive sin
0:08:08 because numbers do not mean as limited
0:08:10 unless you have a form which so is no
0:08:13 more than that it must be clearly stated
0:08:16 it's no more than that then we have a
0:08:18 restriction in numbers so that's the
0:08:19 general rule about numbers both in the
0:08:21 Arabic language in the prophetic Hadith
0:08:24 so that that Hadith which claims that
0:08:27 virtual level 5 and he mentioned read
0:08:29 that Ayah in the other Surah is not a
0:08:32 resection and secondly is also there
0:08:34 some people say you know the right
0:08:36 meaning some some simple-minded usually
0:08:38 will have you eat yourself
0:08:40 how come that there's weather forecast
0:08:42 because Allah says
0:08:45 okay but because they don't treat people
0:08:47 do not read with it they don't open
0:08:49 their eyes very because the ISS clearly
0:08:52 has the knowledge of the hour
0:08:55 exclusively nobody has the knowledge you
0:08:57 wanted to go into strike well you know
0:08:59 the right he brings down
0:09:01 about knowing but also the conditions of
0:09:03 making the rain under the condition he
0:09:05 controls the condition of the rate not
0:09:07 only knowledge but also condition he
0:09:09 brings down the raid not the knowledge
0:09:11 of the rain he brings down the rage you
0:09:13 can do very well weather forecast and
0:09:15 estimate with great probability or
0:09:17 sometimes with certainty that rain will
0:09:19 come but this is not you know right you
0:09:22 are not the one playing with that you're
0:09:23 just doing a weather forecast so there's
0:09:25 no contradiction with that therefore why
0:09:27 Adam you know how come that they claim
0:09:30 they can know the sex of them bye bye
0:09:33 bye by ultrasound
0:09:35 for example
0:09:40 he's exploded the one who lives with
0:09:42 that huh sometimes you know abubakar
0:09:44 knew that when he was wife before he
0:09:46 died that his wife is pregnant with a
0:09:48 girl and he advised to give her a name
0:09:50 by vision
0:09:52 yeah so he knew Bible giving him the
0:09:54 knowledge now Allah giving us the
0:09:56 knowledge by uh ultrasound to
0:09:58 distinguish between male and female
0:10:00 possibly but do we know everything in
0:10:03 the Arham completely and communicable
0:10:04 you know we know some facts about that
0:10:09 and with some facts about it we could
0:10:10 even know some some things about about
0:10:12 diseases and so on by by taking
0:10:14 cautiously some of the of the placenta
0:10:16 fluid and do some analysis but we have
0:10:19 to be inclusive at least to have more
0:10:21 than than just the sex or the shape of
0:10:23 the baby things like that so that's just
0:10:25 clarifying these things
0:10:27 is not only knowledge is something more
0:10:30 than that all of these Keys which
0:10:32 control that what we enter our human
0:10:34 perception and call the issues which are
0:10:36 known but all issues which are an under
0:10:39 nobody control the script Allah like
0:10:42 creating the universe like controlling
0:10:44 the whole system like there is changing
0:10:46 the future based on the changing cover
0:10:48 will come to that
0:10:50 foreign
0:11:03 knowledge you have to have to be to
0:11:05 understand the the the Allah himself and
0:11:08 nobody allows itself understand Allah
0:11:11 accept himself
0:11:12 you may not have some some information
0:11:14 you may have some attributes and so on
0:11:16 but understanding him and comprehending
0:11:18 him is out of question
0:11:21 then here we'll come then issue of
0:11:23 knowledge which which is uh uh it became
0:11:26 a stumbling block for many theologians
0:11:29 and so on my feelings okay he knows
0:11:33 whatever is in the sea and because
0:11:35 Hawaii is successing C and then and and
0:11:38 and uh and uh land is because uh the
0:11:43 idol worshiper they believe for example
0:11:45 that the Satan gods are responsible for
0:11:48 the sea well again you just go to the
0:11:50 Greek mythology Poseidon is that I think
0:11:52 that the sea god
0:11:53 and in the Land There are other gods and
0:11:55 so on and in the domain of poison not
0:11:57 only he knows just go and get that this
0:11:59 hill he hasn't control the others cannot
0:12:00 interfere there and things like that so
0:12:02 no no that's not true it's he's the one
0:12:04 who knows so this is but meaning
0:12:07 everywhere on Earth
0:12:10 and then with an interesting point
0:12:16 now let's stop a little bit
0:12:18 No Leaf over three would fall unless he
0:12:21 knows it
0:12:23 so what did you know about the fall of
0:12:25 today
0:12:26 it he knows when it falls that it has
0:12:28 fallen but who knows when it has image
0:12:30 because that we know that the the leaf
0:12:33 is not a 10 now it's not existing from
0:12:35 eternity from the zero point of time
0:12:37 absolutely zero of time the point of
0:12:39 Eternity it existed maybe a few months
0:12:42 fluids few decades back at best even for
0:12:46 ancient trees it may be a couple of
0:12:48 thousand years like these redwoods in
0:12:50 California but before that was not there
0:12:51 it has grown there in place and
0:12:54 possesses for Thousand Years like for it
0:12:56 would now would become aged and old and
0:12:59 it has and yellow and it's falling
0:13:03 knowledge about these things but the
0:13:05 point is that is mentioning when it
0:13:07 falls
0:13:08 oh I mentioned explicitlyn with false
0:13:13 because when it falls Allah must know
0:13:15 that it has fallen
0:13:17 and that's what caused a major problem
0:13:19 in understanding of the Divine knowledge
0:13:21 they said because
0:13:23 I mean got stuck in a theory that the
0:13:27 Divine being there's no events can
0:13:29 happen in that Divine because anything
0:13:30 which have events must be created that's
0:13:33 the statement they made which is a false
0:13:35 statement it can be proven to be so
0:13:36 false
0:13:40 so the device May kind of have any
0:13:42 events in himself any change in him and
0:13:44 this means the knowledge changes
0:13:48 that cannot be a Divine attribute
0:13:51 according to their their the the fallacy
0:13:54 they they started with
0:13:56 and say because if they start the Quran
0:13:58 they would have recognized that what
0:14:00 week that was some philosophers claim
0:14:02 that whatever has evented itself must be
0:14:04 created must be wrong there must be some
0:14:06 an issue there I have to dig a diva and
0:14:08 see what what where is the mistake but
0:14:10 they didn't do that if they would have
0:14:11 done that they would have started More
0:14:13 Than Mathematics long ago but they did
0:14:15 not do
0:14:17 so they do not take the Quran as a guide
0:14:21 although they claim they believe in the
0:14:23 Quran that's a revelation say oh it is
0:14:25 metaphorical or it's actually it is
0:14:27 falling all the time for maternity to
0:14:28 Eternity which is manifestly absorbed
0:14:31 say Allah is outside of the time such
0:14:34 statements do not make any sense
0:14:36 by the way issue of time women let's
0:14:39 mentioned it again that's solved by The
0:14:41 Miracles
0:14:43 Hadith I had but it does not reflect
0:14:47 anything which can formatized by
0:14:49 horrible it's not this accident no doubt
0:14:50 about that
0:14:52 it's going to be but but like taking it
0:14:54 from the people of the book because they
0:14:55 don't have that concept it cannot be
0:14:59 for Muhammad's Ingenuity because not in
0:15:01 Germany attack if you remember that the
0:15:04 Hadith I mean is the following
0:15:06 it starts very innocently
0:15:08 it's Hadith Allah says the son of a
0:15:11 hadam is is slandering me or hurting me
0:15:14 he says what a miserable time
0:15:17 May the time fail or something catch the
0:15:20 time and start the time
0:15:23 but the reality is insulting me
0:15:28 what an adult I am the time I am the
0:15:30 passage of time and then he gives the
0:15:32 explanation what's the meaning of God
0:15:36 by my commander
0:15:39 the change of events which we could
0:15:42 associate with time and but make the day
0:15:44 and night is that what we uh and the
0:15:46 rotation of the earth Etc in the
0:15:48 universe and even until now the best
0:15:50 time King is still based on the rotation
0:15:52 of the earth and which we observe
0:15:55 certain stars when they come exactly in
0:15:57 the transit point and the more stars
0:16:00 more field stars we use and further away
0:16:02 stars and more more fence Stars we use
0:16:04 until they got minus 24 degree Etc and
0:16:08 matter of factness actually accuracy
0:16:11 this way is higher than the accuracy of
0:16:12 atomic clocks
0:16:20 events the rotation of the Earth all of
0:16:22 these events and so on are by Divine
0:16:25 command so the meaning I am the time
0:16:28 meaning I am the one controlling the
0:16:30 events the passage of the events is what
0:16:32 people call time as measured by their
0:16:34 clocks but this have some absolute sense
0:16:36 meaning it's it's Allah he himself at
0:16:39 the time he is the controller of the
0:16:41 events from the beginning the starting
0:16:43 event until all eternities that's it
0:16:46 once
0:16:49 by my command then I'll tell you bye bye
0:16:51 by myself
0:16:52 yes we know there's physical reason for
0:16:55 that etc etc again as usual we go back
0:16:58 and back and back until the big bang and
0:16:59 then the fixing of the system the qadar
0:17:01 at the beginning and it was June so that
0:17:04 one day it will develop this way
0:17:09 so that's the concept of time in in
0:17:11 Islam
0:17:12 it's not that's the end of it it's Allah
0:17:16 with the explicit description of the
0:17:19 prophetic explanation that the passage
0:17:22 of the events is done by the Divine
0:17:24 action
0:17:25 either immediately in the case of
0:17:27 molecules or as in as instituted by the
0:17:31 qadar at the beginning of the universe
0:17:36 so
0:17:38 by necessity he knows what's going on at
0:17:41 the time appropriately in if we Define
0:17:43 an absolute time as not to Allah which
0:17:46 our clock May reflect or approximate
0:17:48 somehow thus for other buses and for the
0:17:51 reactivity Theory to be discussed leave
0:17:53 that at aside at the moment but
0:17:56 definitely when I leave Falls
0:17:59 after it has fallen
0:18:01 it wasn't falling before by necessity
0:18:03 because it fell by a Divine permission
0:18:04 refine command after it has fallen he
0:18:07 must know that it has fallen
0:18:09 otherwise he's ignored
0:18:11 so there's a change in the Divine
0:18:13 knowledge so that he remains always
0:18:15 completely comprehensive in knowledge
0:18:17 always otherwise will become ignorant if
0:18:20 he doesn't know if you look at the from
0:18:23 the window now I'm looking at the window
0:18:24 we have trees there and obviously all of
0:18:28 them are almost now naked but a couple
0:18:31 of months ago when we fall started
0:18:33 Philip started falling when I looked at
0:18:35 the set and leave
0:18:37 the monitor Falls I know if this has
0:18:39 fallen now
0:18:40 so if I know it has fallen then F430 I
0:18:43 should know even more than that more
0:18:45 comprehensively and more details than I
0:18:47 know but then we just add this as one so
0:18:50 much
0:18:51 so the claim then we must conclude from
0:18:54 that
0:18:55 that claim that what is is having some
0:18:57 events in itself cannot be necessary
0:18:59 existing on eternally it's false it can
0:19:01 be because Allah has has such events yes
0:19:04 they are under his control but
0:19:06 outside
0:19:10 and that's the crucial point they Supply
0:19:13 his own controlled by his absolute
0:19:15 Sovereign free will
0:19:19 so this settles the issue of
0:19:22 events and so on and forces them to look
0:19:25 for the right evidences for but the
0:19:27 problem they stuck with that and they
0:19:28 thought that's the only way to prove the
0:19:30 existence of Allah is by saying
0:19:32 everything you will see in the universe
0:19:33 is having events itself it
0:19:36 develops it passes away it
0:19:39 disintegration so these are events even
0:19:40 it moves before it was not moving you
0:19:42 said all of that
0:19:44 we must conclude from that because of
0:19:46 their faulty rule that it must be
0:19:49 itself created
0:19:52 but this is a false conclusion they they
0:19:54 confiscate the certain step there which
0:19:56 if they have done it properly it would
0:19:58 have led them to a magnificent theory of
0:20:00 of differentiation and integration and a
0:20:04 theory of numbers and so on
0:20:06 and if you are interested we may make a
0:20:08 special session for that discussing how
0:20:10 how we can go start from the finite
0:20:13 domain around us extend space into the
0:20:16 usual euclidean space which is which is
0:20:19 a construction of the mind doesn't exist
0:20:21 outside and also from a limited amount
0:20:23 like for the unlimited interval how I
0:20:25 can divide it down until we get two
0:20:27 points
0:20:28 and points which are shoulder on
0:20:30 shoulder in some sense
0:20:33 but so so that the the the the the the
0:20:36 interval problem let's say from zero one
0:20:39 is completely full there's no gaps there
0:20:42 and then we see how someone will develop
0:20:44 that by by rational numbers and they are
0:20:47 they don't fill everything or they are
0:20:49 very dense but they don't feel
0:20:50 everything then someone say oh well
0:20:51 actually it can't be because we have
0:20:53 so-called algebraic numbers like the
0:20:55 square root of two the symbol equation x
0:20:57 square equal to does not have a solution
0:20:59 in in the form of rational number
0:21:01 rational number of course a fraction p
0:21:04 over Q it doesn't have a solution like
0:21:06 it can be proven easily still line proof
0:21:08 very simple
0:21:10 so there must be some algebraic numbers
0:21:12 though they fit everything no they don't
0:21:14 fit there are other Circle transcendants
0:21:16 or only when you take alternative
0:21:18 numbers and you find them properly then
0:21:20 we fail the entire shoulder to shoulder
0:21:22 no gaps
0:21:23 but this is an enormous mathematical
0:21:25 developments it started let's say in the
0:21:27 18th 19 yeah 17 no 17 maybe 18th century
0:21:32 and became more mature late part of the
0:21:34 19th century then we have more than
0:21:36 mathematics it could have started
0:21:38 if Muslim Scholars started with these
0:21:41 issues at that time but they don't start
0:21:43 unfortunately maybe they exclude maybe
0:21:44 the historics required but they could
0:21:46 have if they taken the whole amplus they
0:21:48 Hadith as a guidance
0:21:50 and rejected other statement and
0:21:52 scrutinized them on light of the
0:21:54 Revelation they would have achieved much
0:21:56 more maybe they would have reached the
0:21:58 the total differential integration they
0:22:01 may have achieved that possibly they may
0:22:03 have assumed that but unfortunately they
0:22:05 did not do
0:22:08 so the claim that no events can have in
0:22:11 the in the Divine is a false because
0:22:14 whatever have events must be created is
0:22:16 not correct that's not correct I'll do a
0:22:19 result then Allah is not a is not a free
0:22:22 agent that becomes an a dead blind uh
0:22:25 nature but initial we don't need to
0:22:28 attribute any knowledge your nation so
0:22:30 no it doesn't make any sense Nation
0:22:33 knows anything doesn't know anything it
0:22:34 acts by necessity and the concept of
0:22:36 knowledge does not make any sense for an
0:22:38 introduce asked by necessity so and then
0:22:41 a contradiction
0:22:42 it's just mechanism which works from
0:22:44 within the eternity
0:22:46 which can be proven by cosmological
0:22:48 proof that it's impossible but most
0:22:50 likely it can be problematological proof
0:22:53 independent from any cosmological proof
0:22:55 that need to be fleshed out I think I
0:22:57 have some skeleton but I'm still working
0:22:59 on it
0:23:00 not the sand and cell improved sand and
0:23:02 selling does not work but going from the
0:23:04 from this angle
0:23:06 that a necessarily existing beam which
0:23:08 is acting by necessity
0:23:13 naturally is like that that's such a
0:23:16 such an entity cannot exist is
0:23:17 impossible it's internally contradictory
0:23:19 but this needs some some hard work we're
0:23:22 still on their own and process of that
0:23:23 so leave it at that but we have the
0:23:26 cosmological proof is enough how will
0:23:28 you have the customer request I remind
0:23:29 you again
0:23:30 we'll go to the beginning of the
0:23:31 universe all the way to the big bank or
0:23:33 the near point zero
0:23:35 we find that there was certain initial
0:23:37 parameters condition must be fixed that
0:23:39 they would but there are three issues
0:23:41 about freely choosable and there's no
0:23:44 way
0:23:45 a
0:23:46 mechanism a necessarily existing nature
0:23:51 can can make a choice
0:23:54 if it would have been like that it would
0:23:55 have all parameters must have been fixed
0:23:57 by the way by the necessity of the
0:23:59 equation of the system itself but they
0:24:01 are not fixed they can be they can be
0:24:03 valid and you if you vary them
0:24:06 differently you get another universe and
0:24:08 you on the third universe and the fourth
0:24:10 universe or the same fundamental
0:24:12 structure like in various various
0:24:14 developments and you it has to be tuned
0:24:17 that's the fine tuning argument it has
0:24:19 to be tuned so fine that we get
0:24:23 life on Earth and we get even this size
0:24:25 of brain and we give Consciousness if
0:24:27 it's not tuned to
0:24:29 unbelievably high that level of accuracy
0:24:32 we will not get that
0:24:34 and this cannot be by accident because
0:24:35 accident does not make any sense
0:24:37 the home is zero there's nothing called
0:24:39 accent Accident Happens for example or
0:24:42 the probability is happening if we are
0:24:44 studying like a bunch of thousands of
0:24:45 people going to the Brent Cross Shopping
0:24:47 Center and then we observe them and see
0:24:49 how many quotes will show you buying
0:24:51 shoes and said and they'll make
0:24:52 statistics and make a distribution we
0:24:54 have already existing things and many
0:24:56 people making choices and then summarize
0:24:58 everything informs called statistical
0:25:00 analysis that's that's what they call by
0:25:03 accident as well
0:25:05 but when you start from absolute zero
0:25:07 there's nothing to do the term accident
0:25:08 this is just another time for free
0:25:10 choice for absolute Sovereign
0:25:12 unconditional free choice
0:25:14 so from the beginning either we have a
0:25:16 mechanism which is impossible with this
0:25:19 universe at least but actually
0:25:21 this will be the ontological Finish is
0:25:23 complete it is
0:25:24 internally contradictory or an entity
0:25:27 which is acting by absolute Sovereign
0:25:29 Free Will absolute spontaneity
0:25:33 does not make any sense until your two
0:25:35 became comprehensive knowledge
0:25:37 and obviously he must have the power to
0:25:40 bring out what his knowledge has has
0:25:43 perceived or found out as being possible
0:25:47 and and creatable
0:25:49 so these are the major things which we
0:25:51 have Step by by establish for for the
0:25:54 for the deity that is it is uh
0:25:57 necessarily existing that's kayum it is
0:25:59 living meaning it has knowledge and have
0:26:01 absolutely free so The Sovereign will
0:26:11 it can be a dead blind deaf nature no
0:26:15 it's not possible
0:26:16 for this universe but also by the
0:26:18 autologism proof in any frequency
0:26:21 conceivable or imaginable reality or
0:26:23 State of Affairs is not possible
0:26:25 but that otherwise autological proof is
0:26:27 not complete yet in that form for this
0:26:30 form not that and and selling proof
0:26:32 which doesn't work
0:26:34 so we shall we start from that then it
0:26:37 doesn't matter
0:26:38 it doesn't because that necessary
0:26:40 existing means having absolute
0:26:42 surveillance if you pretend Day and
0:26:44 Night 10 events by his will and this is
0:26:46 a passage of time
0:26:48 which we measure here maybe with clocks
0:26:50 and so on and Earth rotation
0:26:53 but it refers somehow and it's connected
0:26:55 somehow we perceive it somehow connected
0:26:57 to the The Divide action in the whole
0:27:00 universe it's so called absolute time
0:27:02 and this also solves the problem with
0:27:04 the physicists are wavering and going
0:27:06 back and forth without finding any any
0:27:08 solution or the is is really the second
0:27:12 law of tribunal result of the opacity of
0:27:14 time or the positive time is Just an
0:27:16 Illusion because of second law of
0:27:17 Thermodynamics many of thermodynamics
0:27:20 they put the courage in front of the
0:27:22 whole snow Second Law firmness is a
0:27:25 behavior of many particles and systems
0:27:27 should be extremely dynamically and the
0:27:29 ones we have this situation then we have
0:27:31 the second then we have the system the
0:27:33 the equations of thermodynamics and so
0:27:35 on and then we have the second law is
0:27:38 that can be actually derived by by a
0:27:40 statistical analysis of the of large
0:27:43 systems and so on and some strict
0:27:46 results have been achieved already
0:27:47 almost mid of the 20th century and
0:27:49 ongoing
0:27:51 uh if you want to start in this area
0:27:53 there's a book from from a Furniture
0:27:56 assist called the the David Rowell he
0:28:00 wrote statistical mechanism rigorous
0:28:02 results which is thick mathematical
0:28:04 proof studying from statistical
0:28:06 mechanics and quantum physics problem
0:28:09 many of the phenomena and the issues
0:28:11 related to to thermodynamics for Life
0:28:15 systems very small systems
0:28:17 thermodynamically so claiming that this
0:28:20 is this that we are dealing with that
0:28:22 the second long-term Dynamic is really
0:28:24 the reality while our time perception is
0:28:27 a delusion is a long way upside down and
0:28:30 proven what mathematical is not to be
0:28:32 like that but said to find many
0:28:34 so-called physicists who did not have
0:28:36 the philosophical training not even the
0:28:37 antibiotical training to be able to
0:28:39 reach like books like David Royal
0:28:41 claiming otherwise just to save their
0:28:44 atheists sometimes so sometimes because
0:28:45 they just ignore them but there's not do
0:28:47 not care about the issue they think it's
0:28:49 not a scientific issue it's it's part of
0:28:51 the British identification what partisan
0:28:53 metaphysical issue too but the
0:28:55 scientific what should at least been
0:28:56 done properly it's not done probably by
0:28:58 manifest anyway
0:29:01 so that that's the point I want to say
0:29:04 here that's when Lee Falls Allah knows
0:29:06 it has fallen
0:29:08 so
0:29:09 all this all uh hocus workers on all
0:29:12 these there's nonsense and these claims
0:29:14 of some of the kalimine or Australia
0:29:17 that allies above time and and this is
0:29:19 uh and nothing changing him as it is not
0:29:22 I said they must confuse that that Allah
0:29:26 knows that her belief has fallen after
0:29:28 it has fallen with events which means
0:29:31 he's affected or influenced by others
0:29:34 it's his own action it's his own action
0:29:37 which express itself in the universe and
0:29:39 he knows that is out of his own action
0:29:41 also
0:29:42 foreign
0:30:06 analysis based usually on on imaginary
0:30:10 uh process which has not been that
0:30:13 meticulously what the emerging process
0:30:14 is that for example if we divide Mata
0:30:17 we cannot go at Infinity so it must be
0:30:20 something like an atom this
0:30:22 consolidation makes good sense in some
0:30:24 in something but it has to be qualified
0:30:27 it has to be verified experimentally and
0:30:29 has been qualified rationally
0:30:31 because if we divide like a negative
0:30:34 space between 0 and 1 on a scale and go
0:30:37 down will go even to a point which has
0:30:39 no extension
0:30:40 and we have dense point but this forces
0:30:42 have to be done so meticulously
0:30:44 otherwise you will end having
0:30:45 contradictions and problem and that was
0:30:48 achieved only essentially 200 years ago
0:30:50 but we're getting 200 and picked at the
0:30:53 end of 19th century by Cantor and the
0:30:56 set theory
0:30:57 which of the new avenues of research and
0:30:59 all the new available issues of
0:31:01 contradictions which need to be
0:31:02 controlled and and brought under control
0:31:05 they brought more mostly under control
0:31:06 not hundred percent not too many
0:31:08 satisfaction but mostly under control
0:31:11 so you can't start with that
0:31:14 you first start with the Revelation
0:31:16 which you have evidence that because you
0:31:18 have evidence not depending upon such
0:31:20 esoteric philosophical issues
0:31:22 and depending upon the militants of the
0:31:24 messenger his his announcing of future
0:31:26 events is miraculousness of the Quran
0:31:29 challenge to the pagans or to bring the
0:31:31 Quran historic issues which have been
0:31:33 exposed by Quran which will clarify and
0:31:36 clears and unclean's mess made by by
0:31:39 previous Nations and Fabrication and so
0:31:41 on all of these taken together they are
0:31:43 they are continuously improving more and
0:31:45 more and the Quran is another place we
0:31:47 will show them our eyes in the Horizon
0:31:50 and themselves until they know it is the
0:31:52 truth
0:31:56 the is will come bit by bit one by one
0:31:59 it will take time it needs development
0:32:01 it's in hundreds of years maybe a
0:32:03 thousand years and more until more and
0:32:06 more information comes which forces
0:32:07 people to see that's the Revelation that
0:32:09 cannot be from Muhammad but only at that
0:32:11 time there was enough evidence so they
0:32:14 should have referred to that instead
0:32:16 what they say that's actually just for
0:32:18 human knowledge but actually let's say
0:32:20 Allah is above time time events is not
0:32:22 apply to him and they go and search
0:32:24 statements not always mean a lot of time
0:32:27 in time above time out of time I'm
0:32:29 Messenger to solve the problem he is the
0:32:32 time he is the massages time in the
0:32:34 meeting that he's the one who attend
0:32:36 they anointed events by his free
0:32:39 absolutely Sovereign action and with by
0:32:41 his command which is based on absolute
0:32:44 civilian free
0:32:45 action himself is the time is the
0:32:49 controller of time with which he is the
0:32:51 type and that's it so if they all
0:32:54 started there they would have been
0:32:55 guided much better and many issues of
0:32:59 Qatar and many issues of Destiny would
0:33:02 have been resolved nicely and cleanly
0:33:06 and clearly but instead they got stuck
0:33:08 with some
0:33:09 statement they thought it is a valid
0:33:11 statement
0:33:12 and it went in the Quran and tried to
0:33:14 interpret it
0:33:15 according according to their their
0:33:18 wishes or give it a remote
0:33:20 interpretation like for example we will
0:33:22 test you
0:33:23 Quran we'll come later we didn't have
0:33:25 any one of those maybe it will come down
0:33:27 there in the Surah I'm not sure we will
0:33:30 test you until we know
0:33:34 so that Allah will know the True
0:33:36 Believer
0:33:38 they say no no it's actually he knows
0:33:40 them already not from eternity but
0:33:43 but listen the meaning is that what is
0:33:46 his knowledge will come
0:33:48 through the daylight
0:33:50 so instead of the clear meaning which is
0:33:52 every other very simple-minded person
0:33:54 and if you deep mind we will conclude
0:33:56 that the testing will bring out what you
0:33:58 actually reality and the reality will
0:34:00 become known to Allah because it's not
0:34:02 known now it was not known before
0:34:04 because depends upon your referral and
0:34:05 your action
0:34:08 which demolishes all theories of
0:34:11 fatalism and jumper
0:34:13 foreign
0:34:19 and try to find the strange
0:34:21 interpretation but here which
0:34:23 intervention they can do for this one if
0:34:26 I leave false he knows that it has
0:34:27 fallen
0:34:29 how can you fix this
0:34:37 when it has fallen
0:34:39 he knew well before that it will forward
0:34:42 and possibly even the time it will fall
0:34:44 that's no problem
0:34:46 but if it has fallen
0:34:48 that he persists that it has become past
0:34:50 now it's gone and forgotten let's enter
0:34:53 in the records
0:34:54 and he must know it has happened
0:34:56 has happened
0:34:58 so whatever you do here just to the
0:35:01 right left up down I'm not going to get
0:35:03 away from the fact that he knows he that
0:35:06 he knows that it has fallen
0:35:08 that's why his knowledge his
0:35:10 combinations impossible
0:35:16 so keep that in mind
0:35:18 make the Quran the valid authentic will
0:35:21 established and then things which have
0:35:24 scrutinized access Hadith I mentioned
0:35:26 yes it's an ahat but at least with all
0:35:28 possible issues we should come in your
0:35:31 mind secondly it is unique because it's
0:35:33 no I I I'm not aware about any historic
0:35:36 president anywhere in the old new
0:35:38 testament which claim that Allah says
0:35:42 the son of Adam or anything like that is
0:35:45 islamed at the time say what a miserable
0:35:47 time because I am that's the cause
0:35:49 that's a possible that meaning is an
0:35:51 injunction don't say what a miserable
0:35:53 type that's not that's not correct
0:35:55 because actually outstanding essentially
0:35:58 because he said I am the time and he
0:36:01 explained what is meaning I am the time
0:36:02 and a doubt
0:36:04 he gives the explanation
0:36:06 Day and Night by my comment
0:36:09 you don't find anywhere in the future of
0:36:11 saying something like that nowhere in
0:36:12 the New Testament so it's no way could
0:36:16 have taken it from from uh let us say
0:36:18 from or from Jewish Scholars which he
0:36:21 used to frequently sit with them
0:36:23 there's no way
0:36:25 and there's no way that's a simple mind
0:36:26 that what I would have invited that from
0:36:28 his mind
0:36:29 foreign
0:37:14 it's a fourth statement it has it can be
0:37:16 refuted if you analyze it properly but
0:37:18 only if you start with this when you see
0:37:20 the max must be false let me analyze
0:37:22 more
0:37:24 let me put doubt on it and analyze it
0:37:26 more done
0:37:28 you progress forward unfortunately it's
0:37:31 not done by muslimit Academy
0:37:32 Unfortunately they keep to keep kept
0:37:35 beating around the bush
0:37:38 I kept trying to escape the problem
0:37:43 and then I'll continue very exciting
0:37:46 cruise ship
0:37:47 which people have called people concept
0:37:50 of especially the Pagan civil minders
0:37:51 that distinguishes the darkness of the
0:37:53 earth like under the soil which is in
0:37:55 the dark because they cannot see it and
0:37:58 most
0:37:59 entities in the universe do not seem to
0:38:01 be know where it is and so on
0:38:03 even those who claim they communicate
0:38:05 with Jinn who are searching for some
0:38:06 lost things the genes are not able to
0:38:08 communicate them but there's a treasure
0:38:10 there or something like that so what's
0:38:11 something in the darkness of the Earth
0:38:14 it seems to be unknowable no no it's not
0:38:16 always
0:38:18 you so after this thing the highest
0:38:20 level of sophistication in a simple
0:38:22 example of the relief leave over three
0:38:25 folding it goes to even whatever in the
0:38:28 darkness of the earth what's it
0:38:30 definitely everything from anything
0:38:31 under the soil going down
0:38:33 and nothing soft or hot or hot
0:38:37 the colors
0:38:39 in Arabic for all Goods all Goods
0:38:45 hard goods and things which can be
0:38:47 stored
0:38:48 like we eat barley and so on is
0:38:51 something like like fruits and
0:38:52 vegetables they will not survive they
0:38:55 can be stored for example but anything
0:38:57 about money Alps living beings are more
0:39:00 serious
0:39:01 they're soft they disintegrate the
0:39:03 moment they die
0:39:05 they can't be stored because they have
0:39:07 to continuously be fed and giving air
0:39:09 and so on if you block them somewhere
0:39:10 they will die and disintegrate
0:39:13 a piece of iron is the ABS
0:39:16 a gold a gold coin is the abyss etc etc
0:39:19 everything everything in your mind you
0:39:21 secretary
0:39:25 none of this everything which you could
0:39:28 imagine or classify whatever you
0:39:30 character classify choosing few things
0:39:32 which represent others
0:39:41 even wider that that's just kind of
0:39:43 important so it's weird look hold on but
0:39:45 this is enough if that's known then
0:39:47 everything up for surely else would be
0:39:48 not
0:39:52 everything is in an evident book
0:39:56 or an
0:39:58 manifest book
0:40:00 this is a metaphorical device it doesn't
0:40:03 need to be written somewhere
0:40:04 I remember always
0:40:08 it's a good good job it's a
0:40:11 simple-minded to a hobby he said hello
0:40:14 you know you know the famous story is
0:40:17 about to love him
0:40:18 and uh he said all these things
0:40:23 is made out of one cut out One
0:40:28 that's a one piece of of jewel
0:40:31 I think he said it measured Emerald or
0:40:33 something like that and this is 70 years
0:40:35 long in heaven and the pen roads think
0:40:38 like that
0:40:39 I said okay
0:40:42 Allah said Allah created the pin Fest
0:40:46 and wrote
0:40:47 foreign
0:40:56 foreign
0:41:06 space
0:41:13 make your mind a little bit bigger this
0:41:16 is just to give you a metaphor that if
0:41:19 you say Allah is a protected tablet for
0:41:22 the Quran is something different we'll
0:41:23 discuss that but it means it is such a
0:41:26 firm Divine knowledge because human
0:41:27 beings have the most firm and well
0:41:30 established knowledge if it's recorded
0:41:31 in a book we don't rely on a memory you
0:41:33 record things in a book
0:41:35 and the Divine knowledge is a
0:41:37 metaphorically represented as a book it
0:41:39 is so Fairman and immutable if Quran is
0:41:42 revealed now it would use the blockchain
0:41:44 immutable and unchangeable
0:41:47 it is the metaphor which is available to
0:41:49 build that one will be in a firm
0:41:52 established knowledge doesn't need to be
0:41:54 books or or several physical entities
0:41:55 Reckoning them it's not like that no
0:41:57 need for that
0:42:00 Divine mind is enough for that on this
0:42:02 absolute and immutable and can't be
0:42:04 changed
0:42:08 Way Beyond any book imaginable but which
0:42:11 which things in in the universe you can
0:42:13 use to express that for everyone from
0:42:15 the symbol between on a backward camel
0:42:17 to the philosoph in the Athenian Academy
0:42:20 of philosophy of plateau
0:42:24 which is clearly display what is what it
0:42:28 contains in evident and manifest work
0:42:32 so last time we fixed up a movie
0:42:34 everything is written now it's
0:42:35 everything is known to Allah without
0:42:37 serious attitude
0:42:39 as things known to you in if they are
0:42:41 written down with a certitude suitable
0:42:43 for you
0:42:44 well like the suit of that is his one
0:42:46 his one being his his audience his
0:42:49 knowledge his own book
0:42:51 he's not he's just one book
0:42:55 actually humans use that for example
0:42:57 some blind Scholars they memorize they
0:43:00 cannot write anything so uh
0:43:04 Muhammad the brothers
0:43:09 he is specialized especially in tafsir
0:43:12 so one scholar of Hadith went to him
0:43:15 said that I want to hear that you have
0:43:17 that of women Abbas or someone a
0:43:20 previous scholar you have the stuff you
0:43:22 bring me the book out so I can't copy
0:43:24 say my book is in my chest
0:43:27 I can't dictate it to you so he dictated
0:43:28 to him
0:43:30 the first day half the book it's a small
0:43:32 book
0:43:34 and then with next day and he continued
0:43:36 exactly my point he stopped so he's not
0:43:38 only have his book is he knows the
0:43:40 marker where it stops
0:43:44 then
0:43:46 by infinite margin
0:43:48 it must be like that follows from a
0:43:49 child and much more
0:43:51 in his knowledge I'm gonna say in his
0:43:53 chest obviously it does is not repeating
0:43:56 another problem
0:44:00 storage device because we have chests we
0:44:03 have let's see the brain is called the
0:44:04 metaphorical chest it's really historic
0:44:06 device but there it is something else
0:44:08 which unfathomable we can have no
0:44:11 concept of it we have only the finite
0:44:13 projection we see and we can't get the
0:44:15 concepts that's all that we can
0:44:20 so that's it is important point to take
0:44:23 on board
0:44:24 every event when it happens Allah knows
0:44:26 it has happened
0:44:27 he knows before it happens that it will
0:44:29 happen if it's snowable if it's not
0:44:32 knowable impossible to do then
0:44:34 it'll happen like we discussed
0:44:37 like action really depending upon upon
0:44:40 human activity like for example when I
0:44:44 test the creation
0:44:45 emission which will come many eyes like
0:44:48 that to the Quran and they will try to
0:44:49 interpret it and play around with it so
0:44:51 it will test you until we know
0:44:54 the True Believer and then when I have a
0:44:56 team but you come out only after testing
0:44:59 doesn't exist now it cannot be existing
0:45:02 now while I was testing does not make
0:45:03 any sense
0:45:06 and this fatalism which is impossible
0:45:08 which makes Allah again to a mechanism
0:45:12 they'll go back to atheism essentially
0:45:14 no it can't be it's not like that
0:45:17 then it will come out
0:45:22 it's not
0:45:31 contingencies are not but which one will
0:45:33 realize after testing
0:45:36 that will come out it's impossible to
0:45:38 learn advice which one specifically the
0:45:40 spectrum is not the system is known the
0:45:43 Qatar is known but not
0:45:48 the system
0:45:50 the system has been fixed at the
0:45:51 beginning of the universe by this
0:45:53 parameters chosen at the beginning in
0:45:54 the case of issues the cosmological
0:45:56 model as an approximation it may be even
0:45:59 deeper than that but we don't got much
0:46:04 and how even this proportion affect even
0:46:06 the social behavior of a big Gathering
0:46:08 of people and so on there are also there
0:46:12 this is all complex all the Sciences in
0:46:15 the overarm were trying to work out how
0:46:17 this these things work
0:46:19 and how they relate and attack how the
0:46:21 human society relate to individual human
0:46:23 behavior and so on and how statistical
0:46:25 things work and then how this human
0:46:27 behavior relates to uh human limitation
0:46:30 and The Inheritance I think that but how
0:46:32 Freedom emerged out of that all of these
0:46:35 things some parts of its powerfully
0:46:37 difficult possibly impossible possibly
0:46:39 impossible to fight them and maybe you
0:46:41 will never be found out
0:46:43 except that maybe the brain being of
0:46:46 such extremely complex structure and
0:46:48 they're going to Connected it's not a
0:46:50 number of cells the number of cells were
0:46:52 only few trillions the number of
0:46:53 connections across links is 10 to the
0:46:56 lower point is a bit quiet 10 to the
0:46:58 hundred maybe that number is needed to
0:47:01 bring the brain into a level of
0:47:04 classical like in a Quantum suspension
0:47:06 to the big entities of immacula
0:47:08 microscopic are being into the brain is
0:47:11 about one kill one half kilo I think I
0:47:12 don't know that number maybe someone can
0:47:14 tell us the number is known in average
0:47:17 but the interconnection is the crucial
0:47:19 point and this number of integration
0:47:21 made that macroscopic body
0:47:23 behaves different than a ball
0:47:27 the ball behaved in Newtonian mechanics
0:47:28 this one behaves quantum mechanics
0:47:32 that can suspend decisions
0:47:34 how it's extremely difficult to even to
0:47:37 bring in our mind
0:47:39 but we can speak on it like that but
0:47:41 that's that's the size we can't work all
0:47:43 that study it no problem go ahead
0:47:50 but this is all this system this
0:47:52 structure goes to initial parameters
0:47:55 beginning with the universe that's the
0:47:56 color
0:47:58 which is so chosen that the Universe
0:48:01 have free agent and they can have free
0:48:03 will and that even a decision can be
0:48:06 suspended
0:48:08 that foreign
0:48:26 so the best formula about knowledge is
0:48:29 that Allah knows what has been what is
0:48:31 and what can possibly come in the future
0:48:35 and what has not happened in the past if
0:48:37 it has happened how it would have
0:48:38 happened that contingency was there but
0:48:41 it's finished it will never happen again
0:48:42 it's gone but every time it would have
0:48:44 happened how the development would
0:48:46 happen all these conditions are not
0:48:49 that's the correct formula
0:48:51 the usual for me to say Allah knows what
0:48:53 has been what is and what will happen no
0:48:55 that's not true
0:48:58 what may happen all the possibilities of
0:49:00 public
0:49:01 but this is why that actually Divine
0:49:03 knowledge is more important
0:49:04 comprehensive than these people these
0:49:06 fatalists kill him based on their faulty
0:49:11 philosophy of Kaaba and philosophical
0:49:13 philosophy of divine knowledge no
0:49:15 develop which is much more wider
0:49:17 and Wilson colonized and connected with
0:49:20 the Divine will and the Divine being
0:49:22 blessed them except to be so that's
0:49:24 that's what we take from this desire at
0:49:27 least
0:49:28 I think enough of that
0:49:30 if if someone is interested in
0:49:32 discussing how how this extension into
0:49:34 into the so-called euclidean space and
0:49:38 so on there's people of physics
0:49:39 background and how the the numbers uh
0:49:42 filling the the the and the issues of
0:49:45 limit and so on the problems of time
0:49:46 pass out they are welcome I can't give a
0:49:48 session for that if needed to see where
0:49:51 the pitfalls and how to avoid them
0:49:54 foreign
0:50:03 just to clarify your statements are you
0:50:05 saying that Allah has knowledge of past
0:50:06 and present only are you trying to build
0:50:09 a lot of things in the future that's
0:50:11 again the same question all contentions
0:50:13 in the future
0:50:15 all contingencies some of the future is
0:50:17 known fixed already decided by Allah it
0:50:19 will happen
0:50:20 that will happen as Allah decided as
0:50:22 Allah decided and he's in control of the
0:50:24 events and he will force all events to
0:50:26 go in that direction
0:50:28 so many other events which lead to that
0:50:30 are forced too and they will go in that
0:50:32 direction
0:50:34 but other things are open
0:50:37 they may happen but they're not happen
0:50:38 and this indicated many Hadith I wonder
0:50:40 why the people get stuck with this point
0:50:43 it's because they have been friends in
0:50:45 childhood Allah knows what's vast
0:50:46 present and what will happen no
0:50:49 what all possibilities of happening are
0:50:51 known to him all contingencies with the
0:50:54 future
0:50:55 all contingencies
0:50:58 but which one individually will emerge
0:51:00 depends on his condition and his
0:51:03 decision at the moment of the condition
0:51:12 that is the question so how would you
0:51:14 explain
0:51:16 that's it has nothing to do with the
0:51:19 Divine knowledge that's really divinely
0:51:21 sense because he's the he's the his oh
0:51:25 let's go through that when when
0:51:28 was asked uh some people came from Yemen
0:51:31 and said we did not come they were
0:51:33 people were asked about various things
0:51:34 and so on trivial things there typically
0:51:36 and then and then
0:51:39 and they ask for some trivial things and
0:51:41 then yesterday people we haven't said we
0:51:43 came from Yemen to ask you about how
0:51:45 this matter began the State of Affair
0:51:47 this universe
0:51:49 and they understood that question
0:51:51 Allah
0:52:01 Allah existed and there was nothing
0:52:03 before him and some others will say with
0:52:06 him so you say at him
0:52:08 and his drone was on the on the water
0:52:11 and they wrote everything in the Liquors
0:52:13 in the remembrance
0:52:18 now
0:52:21 I mean I got stuck with this and many
0:52:23 people because they did not control the
0:52:25 imagination with analyze time I don't
0:52:26 want to end going through that today but
0:52:28 okay let's go to it
0:52:33 Alexa here's the award is the beginning
0:52:35 in existence
0:52:37 and that point is a point it's called
0:52:39 eternity the problem many people have
0:52:41 difficulty imagining it that they accept
0:52:42 as being infinitely extended
0:52:45 it's not it's only one point
0:52:47 the problem is that for many people is
0:52:50 that when they stem look they cannot
0:52:52 envisage or make a sense of
0:52:54 if we take absolute time that there's a
0:52:57 negative time there is nothing out there
0:52:58 the verse I said well well under the
0:53:00 word
0:53:02 is the correct one supporting whether
0:53:04 Hadith
0:53:10 you are the the first nothing is before
0:53:13 you
0:53:15 face it looks like there's something
0:53:17 before there's some time before him at
0:53:18 this at first time but it's impossible
0:53:20 there's no time before him the concept
0:53:22 of time does not exist absent or being
0:53:24 does not exist negative the absolute
0:53:26 time does not exist meaning that Allah
0:53:29 does not exist has no existence or cease
0:53:33 to exist sometime in vast is not
0:53:34 possible he existed always
0:53:36 but if we work with time from our
0:53:40 advantage and go back to the zero point
0:53:42 that zero point is essentially from our
0:53:44 Android is a is a point it's called the
0:53:47 point of Eternity non-negative time is
0:53:49 there someone say this seems to be
0:53:51 impossible because we are used to when
0:53:54 we study time we are used to
0:53:55 parameterize it with real numbers
0:53:58 so the future is from our Timeless at
0:54:00 this moment is regarded as zero point
0:54:02 and then the future is one hour later
0:54:04 plus plus plus and the negative number
0:54:06 plus is minus minus minus virus and then
0:54:09 if you let your imagination and be
0:54:11 deceived like Einstein deceived and many
0:54:12 physicists are deceived that it goes to
0:54:14 minus infinity
0:54:16 and they said the same access is like
0:54:18 the real axis but it's of another type a
0:54:20 little bit goes to minus infinity you'll
0:54:23 get in trouble
0:54:24 because reality that cannot be the case
0:54:27 because of the principle of infinite
0:54:29 exist because the the extension because
0:54:32 the time in the past has is uniquely
0:54:35 different than the than the the
0:54:37 extension of the space in my left let's
0:54:39 say I Define my left as being negative I
0:54:42 got negative one meter through my left
0:54:44 two meter and you say left is mean to
0:54:45 minus and right mean positive plus
0:54:48 because when I say minus one meter to
0:54:50 the left one means that left two meters
0:54:51 left or minus one minus two I'm starting
0:54:53 with one meter and I'm just starting one
0:54:55 one I'm starting here and stop selecting
0:54:58 and extending that in my imagination and
0:55:00 if I do it correctly for space no
0:55:02 problem I end with a so called
0:55:05 one dimensional two damages three
0:55:07 dimensional spaces with the eucalid and
0:55:09 geometry that's correct and they can't
0:55:11 control that mathematically is it
0:55:12 outside space like that there's another
0:55:14 that's an accidental physical issue but
0:55:16 intellectually and mentally it can be
0:55:19 done in a controller if it's done in the
0:55:21 proper way the limits should be done and
0:55:23 Mathematics should be done
0:55:25 then you don't have any contradiction
0:55:26 but if time
0:55:28 you may be fooled things that are going
0:55:30 minus once our one is not true because
0:55:33 the time my time now is conditioned on
0:55:36 the day before if the day before did not
0:55:38 happen I would not have been here and if
0:55:41 the one before wouldn't happen and if my
0:55:43 grandparents did not exist and married
0:55:45 my father would not have been born I'm a
0:55:48 mother and so on so you see time starts
0:55:50 from there not from here
0:55:55 start back and it has to have a
0:55:58 beginning in this concept of time being
0:56:00 represented by real numbers that we can
0:56:03 deal with we cannot deal with anything
0:56:05 else and that's what about messenger
0:56:07 Allah said
0:56:08 I am that's the time with the people say
0:56:11 what a miserable time what a passage of
0:56:13 time it made the time fail or he means
0:56:17 that one
0:56:19 so it has to have a beginning
0:56:22 there's no negative time in the sense so
0:56:24 the absolute zero there's no there's a
0:56:26 there's examples for that to comprehend
0:56:28 that nobody having a problem to
0:56:31 understand that when we cool things
0:56:33 that the so-called cell 0 is arbitrary
0:56:36 that's the freezing point of water is
0:56:38 arbitrary actually
0:56:40 so we can Define so-called absolute
0:56:42 scale we go down down we've never reach
0:56:44 the absolute zero because it's mean
0:56:46 absolute zero million there's no no
0:56:48 movement whatsoever that's impossible it
0:56:50 means that matter has been annihilated
0:56:52 coming absolutely nothing that's not
0:56:54 possible there's no negative absolutely
0:56:57 I understand in in solid state some
0:57:00 states are induced by this or they're
0:57:02 called negative temperature because if
0:57:03 they want to if you want to work with
0:57:05 them and tell me dynamically it looks
0:57:06 like the temperature is negative but
0:57:08 this is just a mathematical
0:57:09 representation but in in gases and
0:57:12 liquids and so on in the real universe
0:57:14 is absolute zero is there's nothing but
0:57:17 there's no negative absolute temperature
0:57:21 we accept that we don't have any problem
0:57:23 with that which means everything
0:57:24 vanishes why not accept that it's not a
0:57:27 negative absolute type
0:57:28 there's no negative Allah doesn't exist
0:57:31 is the internal contradictory concept
0:57:33 another example look at the definition
0:57:35 domain of the of the logarithm
0:57:38 anyway
0:57:41 it's defined for positive numbers no
0:57:43 doubt about that
0:57:49 but it cannot be defined for negative
0:57:50 energy it's impossible to Define
0:57:52 it's even possible to extend the
0:57:54 logarithm definition in the complex
0:57:55 plane real and imaginary part in the
0:57:58 whole plane but if you do that correct
0:58:00 mathematically way
0:58:02 then you will find that the negative
0:58:04 axis that not is not in the path of the
0:58:06 domain it must be cut out the domain so
0:58:08 the definition domain of the logarithm
0:58:11 is the whole complex axis if we Define
0:58:13 the logarithm for complex numbers let's
0:58:15 define what can be done by by power
0:58:17 series X 100 that's not a problem it's
0:58:19 easy
0:58:21 but you have to cut the negative axis
0:58:26 it's impossible to having an accident
0:58:27 there
0:58:30 and the limiter is even worse than that
0:58:31 they try to fix that by circular
0:58:33 demanding surface so if you try to 10
0:58:36 and then you come to the negative axis
0:58:38 from the tablet say
0:58:40 then you face that's the following
0:58:42 situation you come to the negative axis
0:58:45 which looks like an infinitely deep
0:58:48 is cut away so it's infinitely deep
0:58:51 Canyon
0:58:53 and infinitely narrow
0:58:55 and then you think because it's Infinity
0:58:58 level may be able to jump but if you
0:59:00 look to the outside you don't find the
0:59:01 the same level like you have what you
0:59:04 said just infinitely level of levels in
0:59:07 front of you you have to choose one to
0:59:08 jump onto it Infinity up and down
0:59:12 yeah as the mathematician the difference
0:59:15 between the two Pi 2 pi I
0:59:18 just assume you make the jump
0:59:21 you'll be there and you chose one of
0:59:22 those should we jump
0:59:24 it's a swim succeed in Jump which is
0:59:26 impossible let's succeed inside jumping
0:59:27 when you turn back
0:59:30 then you don't find the
0:59:32 the the platform you have to jump from
0:59:34 you find infinite mini level again
0:59:37 if we jump again we don't know if you
0:59:39 land in that initial or another one
0:59:40 completely impossible
0:59:43 that's how it works and the management
0:59:45 should do that and work in the money
0:59:46 interface but it has to be done
0:59:48 extremely ridiculously and carefully
0:59:51 otherwise you break your neck there you
0:59:53 commit you commit blunders and Indian
0:59:56 culturation but the negative access is
0:59:58 out
0:59:59 and the studies require the negative
1:00:00 axis and the zero point is called a
1:00:03 branching point of infinite or high of
1:00:05 infinite orders not finite orders
1:00:09 there's so many leaves on top of each
1:00:12 other up and down on both sides at the
1:00:14 negative and the positive everything is
1:00:15 now is foreign nice word especially a
1:00:18 positive real accent everything perfect
1:00:21 even kids can play with it at school not
1:00:24 the government school high school when
1:00:26 we're in time password we're studying uh
1:00:28 I don't forget that you caught that time
1:00:30 because you're all born in the time of
1:00:32 of the calculating ruler and then the
1:00:35 the calculator and time before we didn't
1:00:39 have what
1:00:40 what we had to to work with the
1:00:41 logarithmic tables to do complicated
1:00:43 multiplications that's that's all for
1:00:46 positive numbers
1:00:49 so there's quite a few questions on this
1:00:51 one um so I'm going to go through
1:00:53 um you can determine if it's been
1:00:55 answered I'm just kind of playing
1:00:56 dribbles I've got a lot of this stuff so
1:00:58 events and and times don't have a
1:01:00 beginning
1:01:01 is the first in existence before that
1:01:04 there's no there's no concept of before
1:01:06 and that oh well there's a complexity
1:01:08 but for you there's nothing absolute
1:01:09 nothingness no existence no concept
1:01:12 nothing whatsoever but the only way
1:01:14 success is in any language say before
1:01:15 you there is nothing
1:01:18 okay so I'm just going to go through
1:01:19 them and determine if they've been
1:01:21 answered I'm just kind of relaying here
1:01:23 so there were there are various verses
1:01:25 in the Quran that talk about the future
1:01:27 in the sense that it talks about some of
1:01:28 the actions of the unbelievers in the
1:01:30 future how can we understand that
1:01:32 um
1:01:36 Surah 16 verse 3500 bring it down now
1:01:40 give me a second
1:01:45 I'll bring that in a second but let me
1:01:47 just uh read read the rest of the
1:01:49 comments yeah we have an example so we
1:01:51 can scrutinize this properly
1:01:53 will not neither work for the question
1:01:56 or not for me
1:01:58 okay
1:02:01 okay so I'm digging that up in the
1:02:04 background and also so also I'd like to
1:02:06 say regarding Allah being time since
1:02:07 Allah is the time meaning that he
1:02:09 changes the day of the night doesn't
1:02:10 that mean that he is independent from
1:02:13 time
1:02:15 that's what the prophet said I am the
1:02:17 time and the explanation of that I am I
1:02:19 am the general with my command I am in
1:02:21 control of the changes which you call
1:02:23 time
1:02:26 by my command by my decisions
1:02:28 which ultimately absolutely free and
1:02:32 sovereign
1:02:36 because absolute freedom and sovereignty
1:02:38 is a fundamental concept looking
1:02:40 yourself close your eyes and try to
1:02:42 analyze the mathematical problems say no
1:02:44 I am fed up with this problem you need
1:02:45 to go study another problem that
1:02:47 decision that freedom you have
1:02:49 imagine that going to an infinite level
1:02:53 that's all that you have nothing can be
1:02:55 more than that this is one primary
1:02:56 things like to close your eye and you
1:02:58 perceive yourself as existing as a
1:03:00 conscious being not as a body and so on
1:03:02 that's external it's conscious B
1:03:06 that's absolutely zero beginning then
1:03:09 you recognize the fundamental principle
1:03:11 of your own existence
1:03:14 and then you will recognize your own
1:03:15 contingency requires your recognize that
1:03:18 you have a free will even in your
1:03:19 thoughts you can control those and
1:03:20 decide no no this problem is boring now
1:03:22 if we go to another problem
1:03:24 and you can deliberately say should I
1:03:26 continue with this problem whether you
1:03:27 can't ask this question make that
1:03:28 self-experimation that's that's the
1:03:31 ultimate that's zero absolute zero point
1:03:32 we cannot go any further than that
1:03:36 is
1:03:39 um
1:03:40 foreign
1:03:47 Music
1:04:06 yeah
1:04:07 if Allah will
1:04:10 they want to say that we commented
1:04:13 because Allah permitted it to happen
1:04:16 so are not responsible Allah is
1:04:17 responsible
1:04:20 and Allah that's not true it's your
1:04:23 choice
1:04:24 so this is not a good example now let me
1:04:26 give an example of him have in his mind
1:04:27 and view his real future even does not
1:04:30 have you save it thus contingency which
1:04:32 has happened in the past
1:04:33 no no that's his cover this is finished
1:04:35 no no this is done and forgotten no here
1:04:38 he refused to declare that's not true
1:04:40 Allah permitted to happen but you have
1:04:42 they made the choice I permitted you to
1:04:44 to make your choices whatever you choose
1:04:47 and you should show yourself the the
1:04:48 misguidance is not it's not it's not
1:04:52 Allah who is forced to throw is on you
1:04:53 and the and he is responsible to that is
1:04:56 not
1:04:57 that's that's actually enforces our
1:04:58 point of view let's go over there I'll
1:05:00 give you a an example like for example
1:05:03 uh what he most likely meant is not the
1:05:06 British believe or believer whatever
1:05:08 generally like for example happy what's
1:05:11 up
1:05:20 he will be
1:05:22 cast in a burning fire
1:05:25 so his his Destiny is is fixed he's
1:05:28 going to hell
1:05:32 that's that's that's that's a valid one
1:05:35 Allah knows
1:05:38 he's going to head there's no Escape I
1:05:40 lost finish he's sealed and they
1:05:42 explained that I think several times
1:05:43 before let me explain again
1:05:47 to become a believer
1:05:51 but he forgot them and he was one of
1:05:53 them I've been home most hating the
1:05:55 messenger Allah
1:05:56 especially when he was going through the
1:05:57 tribes in in in in in pilgrimage and so
1:06:00 on talking to them then abujah pursue
1:06:03 him and uh
1:06:06 possibly Stone him oh no I'll just
1:06:08 insult him
1:06:11 follow him and still even the stone said
1:06:13 this is my cousin I know him he's a liar
1:06:15 oh my nephew I know him he's a liar
1:06:17 don't put that about him
1:06:20 so ultimately
1:06:23 Allah's Destiny decided he got all the
1:06:26 testing he needs
1:06:30 now he is distant to the Hellfire this
1:06:32 could be done by two ways kill him so he
1:06:34 dies or keep him alive and I'm making a
1:06:36 miracle and seal him so that he cannot
1:06:38 choose anymore
1:06:40 as if he's dead
1:06:42 steal his Destiny and revealed the Ayah
1:06:47 as a miracle foreign
1:06:55 foreign
1:07:09 get me out of the Hellfire
1:07:12 oscarash did not think about that all
1:07:14 that they've thought about every
1:07:15 possible trick they played every trick
1:07:18 in the book they went to the Jews but
1:07:20 bringing questions
1:07:21 they even developed poetry singing the
1:07:25 praise of the Persian and the Roma
1:07:26 saying Muhammad is telling you stories
1:07:28 about ancient Nations only God knows if
1:07:30 they ever existed pharaoh and so now
1:07:33 here here we have the Empire here Empire
1:07:35 here and we have their stories and we
1:07:37 have people singing them even hymns and
1:07:39 so on here and so every trick in the
1:07:41 book but this simple trick did not come
1:07:43 in their mind how it didn't come in mind
1:07:45 Allah made it not come in their mind
1:07:47 prevented from their mind
1:07:51 action so the future was determined for
1:07:54 this was specific one and
1:07:56 here's to be sure he died
1:07:59 I never do that that symbol uh
1:08:07 the same for example seven people who
1:08:08 inside them
1:08:10 he was once praying in Mecca and Kaaba
1:08:13 at the Kaaba and then they were sitting
1:08:16 and laughing and then they told they
1:08:19 told one of them listen that family they
1:08:21 have a wedding yesterday they have
1:08:22 slaughtered a camel the intestines of
1:08:24 the camel is they are thrown away stinky
1:08:26 and so on get it and put it on Muhammad
1:08:28 back while he's in sujut
1:08:31 so the most evil one of them went there
1:08:33 and got it and put it back in the back
1:08:39 and then
1:08:40 let me see Allah did not move for me
1:08:42 until Fatima came we bring us on and
1:08:44 they moved it from him and then when he
1:08:46 lifted his his voice he made the
1:08:48 supplicate Allah take care of and
1:08:51 mention seven nibs I don't have the
1:08:53 names at the moment but there's no
1:08:54 needless here
1:08:55 and all of him was killed in by the way
1:08:57 at that moment Allah accepted his Dua is
1:09:00 not revealed to us that he accepted or
1:09:02 told him you are drives accepted but
1:09:03 these were the one Allah decided at the
1:09:06 moment I will seal them they will not
1:09:07 accept them I lost this they've done it
1:09:09 they are done but still stayed alive
1:09:11 until they came in better and they were
1:09:13 killed even in the battlefield as Cafe
1:09:15 so the decision was made Allah you at
1:09:17 that moment that these guys are gone
1:09:19 because he decided they are gone
1:09:21 but he controls the future and based on
1:09:23 the control he knows the future in this
1:09:25 specific events
1:09:29 to your point
1:09:31 before that maybe it was a contingency
1:09:33 weather
1:09:36 you don't know maybe you're not maybe
1:09:38 some decisions have been happening
1:09:45 so analyze things in this in this spirit
1:09:47 in this understanding
1:09:49 thank you
1:09:50 when the first people decide that will
1:09:52 be from Hub sale this Valley near Medina
1:09:54 Southeastern Medina about half a day
1:09:56 travel 20 kilometer for the daytime at
1:09:59 that time and certainly on foot or back
1:10:01 of a camel and so on is Caravans about
1:10:04 45 so 22 kilometers have sale
1:10:08 and he asked what happens in the
1:10:10 workbook of the hills
1:10:11 one of the evidence that I expanded on
1:10:14 that and he said anyone you know have
1:10:16 cellular University
1:10:18 let me finish the story this is also one
1:10:20 of the American
1:10:21 it's good maybe for some listener anyone
1:10:24 so I said no nobody knows a small value
1:10:26 and significant
1:10:27 and then once a hobby was going to to
1:10:30 buy uh to buy a sheep
1:10:33 and he was late in the day
1:10:35 like afternoon not very late
1:10:38 but late usually because you go in the
1:10:40 market for Shiva things like early in
1:10:42 the morning both The Riddles come in the
1:10:43 morning then our surrounding bedrooms
1:10:45 and they said really and leave unless we
1:10:47 don't seems to have come late or
1:10:49 something like that and then and he was
1:10:50 driving some sheep going out of mud say
1:10:53 why always say I was in the market but
1:10:55 now time is becoming very timely it's
1:10:57 noon time roughly
1:10:59 and if I don't move now
1:11:02 I cannot say in the market any longer if
1:11:04 I don't move now I cannot catch my Pivot
1:11:13 your place say I can't catch within a
1:11:16 half day so you say I am living in habit
1:11:18 oh we held him come on here you catch
1:11:21 don't don't worry about half sale we'll
1:11:24 get you there maybe in horseback or
1:11:26 something come from asking about have
1:11:28 sale come so he get him to them he said
1:11:31 you are from have sex yes safe
1:11:35 beware
1:11:36 be alet is best that you move your
1:11:38 family away because sooner or later
1:11:40 there will be a fire coming up to half
1:11:42 sale so enormous that the camel next
1:11:45 will become bright or become visible as
1:11:48 far away as Syria
1:11:57 so that it that there's a maybe at the
1:12:00 time before the magma chamber is boiling
1:12:03 us definitely was boiling it out
1:12:07 for Millions years but nobody can know
1:12:10 that at that time no geology was there I
1:12:12 thought surely Muhammad does not know
1:12:14 that
1:12:14 this one day it will come he does not
1:12:17 give him the time almost
1:12:19 could be a thousand years like
1:12:23 mentioning the coming of Isa yoshik we
1:12:25 have not 1400 years and has not come yet
1:12:28 but this one took 650 years or 630 of 20
1:12:34 solar years
1:12:38 so he won the man and this was narrated
1:12:40 that's in the Box attributed everywhere
1:12:42 in the world and every book in the world
1:12:43 and long before and even the place of
1:12:45 half sale was visited by some geographer
1:12:48 like yakut and he went there so I went
1:12:50 to have sail to see the place where the
1:12:51 person there will be a fire which will
1:12:53 be Illuminating the next of the
1:12:55 commission and the hotel and check the
1:13:00 distance and say it's a half day and it
1:13:01 is on the way to this and this
1:13:03 essentially south south east of Medina
1:13:07 Etc
1:13:08 foreign
1:13:40 there was a big crack and there's seven
1:13:43 points in which we have seven mountains
1:13:45 all of them made out of volcanic ashes
1:13:47 they're called scoria cones seven of
1:13:50 them
1:13:51 and this is in in the book of David I
1:13:53 think their images and pictures are
1:13:54 there also the Arabic one
1:13:59 so that's not
1:14:02 to Allah at that moment either because
1:14:04 the physical process which will develop
1:14:06 a a eventually or
1:14:09 Allah made it so to happen either one it
1:14:12 doesn't matter
1:14:13 we support under his control
1:14:18 okay so this is quite a detail subject
1:14:21 it does work its own uh discussion also
1:14:23 if you have anything written if you have
1:14:25 anything written on it that is
1:14:26 translated written the America itself
1:14:29 not discussing the issue issue of God
1:14:32 it certainly comes there's gonna be
1:14:34 loads of questions also what you're
1:14:35 doing is you provide you're proposing a
1:14:37 different point of view towards before
1:14:39 so there'll always be loads of questions
1:14:41 on it
1:14:42 um but I would suggest this anyone who's
1:14:44 on this taken out of the zoom that's the
1:14:47 link you want to join so you can ask
1:14:48 directly we can be we want to be as open
1:14:50 and transparently I think so we have for
1:14:52 example some I've been there for example
1:14:54 the various
1:14:57 specifically are confusing and
1:14:59 contradictory and so on and we sorted
1:15:01 out what is the wrong one of them with
1:15:02 the correct one of them and all of them
1:15:04 fit with that fit to the Quran correctly
1:15:06 and the other ones turn out to be 40
1:15:09 alhamdulillah even by narratives but
1:15:11 that's not what the classical Scholars
1:15:13 unfortunately did because they started
1:15:14 with that point we started with Jabber
1:15:17 perpetuated so we'll just refer back to
1:15:21 our to our discussion
1:15:24 because one of their arguments said if
1:15:26 Allah did not want us to have the power
1:15:28 he would not have allowed us to have the
1:15:30 power that's the same argument
1:15:34 so that's the subdue and anyone without
1:15:36 doubting that I'm discussing the issue
1:15:37 of jabber and so on was persecuted by
1:15:40 the major Authority they are the one who
1:15:42 introduced Jabber
1:15:44 it seems to be that sahaba did not have
1:15:46 that
1:15:49 they don't have that and the issue was
1:15:51 confused by mixing issue of qadar with
1:15:53 kada
1:15:55 is clearly but the definition of it is
1:15:58 completely clear and we say that is not
1:16:01 defined what it is
1:16:02 clearly
1:16:04 and this is that that the system of the
1:16:06 universe is fixed level and whatever has
1:16:08 happened in the past
1:16:09 could not have happened otherwise
1:16:11 Allah permission and it's done at
1:16:14 forgotten cannot be changed and he
1:16:16 warned about falling into lamentation
1:16:18 but let me discuss this one you said
1:16:22 in full you see usually the part the
1:16:25 second part of Harris escorted but the
1:16:27 restaurant is ignored and there's again
1:16:29 one of the the way of twisting words out
1:16:31 of the transition all this not twisting
1:16:33 that Quran but through the Hadith is
1:16:35 supposed to be next to the quranian
1:16:37 authorities originally a revelation so
1:16:39 if you cut the Hadith in two parts are
1:16:41 not quarter then full you will fall into
1:16:43 misguidance
1:16:44 if they cut their eyes in two parts
1:16:48 so or even the whole Quran in bits and
1:16:51 pieces and strike this one against this
1:16:52 one instead of putting them together and
1:16:54 let them snag perfectly together like we
1:16:57 do alhamdulillah or try to do at least
1:16:59 so that he says
1:17:05 be Keen be greedy to achieve what would
1:17:08 benefit you
1:17:11 rely on Allah and don't be a failure
1:17:15 don't attribute failure and shortcoming
1:17:17 to yourself do do your due diligence
1:17:20 but if it doesn't work
1:17:22 don't say
1:17:24 if it has been so and so it would have
1:17:28 been so and so because the word love I
1:17:31 will use the word then translate because
1:17:33 there's no English equivalent of Lao in
1:17:35 Arabic is though is different than if
1:17:38 now it opens the door of the devil
1:17:41 so what does the messenger is since
1:17:42 extracted love first is for
1:17:44 international impossibility
1:17:46 something is impossible you say with
1:17:48 love
1:17:50 not if
1:17:52 notice that with the messenger use like
1:17:54 what I use in one place for example
1:17:58 if Allah would have ever the desire to
1:18:01 have Offspring so which is impossible
1:18:02 now
1:18:04 he would the only thing possible
1:18:07 because the Divine Offspring is
1:18:08 impossible to be created to be produced
1:18:12 because a Divine cannot be producible
1:18:14 the ultimate truth can happen if he has
1:18:17 that desire which is impossible is to
1:18:20 adopt a miscreation
1:18:24 and lift them to a higher level than
1:18:25 other there's a special adoption that's
1:18:27 all that is there foreign
1:18:34 that's used by many negligent rulers and
1:18:36 other people to say oh
1:18:38 I should not study and I should not
1:18:41 study we could have where they don't
1:18:44 know does not mean to study at Calamity
1:18:45 and how it's happened and see where I
1:18:47 put wrong in my due diligence what
1:18:49 shortcomings in my study because they
1:18:51 can't teach us in the case which we
1:18:53 passed in so little uh
1:18:55 Ali Imran the Calamity he said clearly
1:18:59 after you have been Victorious and did
1:19:01 everything you have this weight and the
1:19:03 result is the catastrophe
1:19:05 so learn from that
1:19:08 however
1:19:10 if you always allowed there to
1:19:12 understand that it has happened it
1:19:13 cannot be changed it's gone for identity
1:19:15 finish forget about it you will study it
1:19:18 but not using law
1:19:20 using IF
1:19:22 if you did not if you did not commit the
1:19:25 sea obedience if you learn from that in
1:19:27 the future to be obedient and compliance
1:19:30 with their commanders and holding your
1:19:31 position of protection and covering the
1:19:33 back of the army things like that may
1:19:36 not happen but in the process don't open
1:19:38 a lamentation that's not adamantation in
1:19:40 such a case it's a study case for the
1:19:42 future so the Hadith does not seclude
1:19:44 like many people thought to say
1:19:47 secludes studying the cases
1:19:51 what is it secluded from it
1:19:54 and and
1:19:57 try to bring in your mind and warn you
1:19:59 from it is that to indulge into
1:20:01 lamentation because love is the
1:20:03 limitation if it doesn't if it is a
1:20:05 under what is the door of the devil the
1:20:07 devil is no no we did everything well
1:20:08 you know it's Allah will let you down
1:20:11 foreign
1:20:17 that's what the devil wants if you
1:20:19 indulgee lamentation
1:20:25 when they melted and say they said we
1:20:29 killed him with the sword of his
1:20:30 grandfather his grandfather instructed
1:20:33 us to anyone rebellious to be killed on
1:20:35 his rebellious
1:20:36 so premises
1:20:46 or to be killed by the sword of his
1:20:48 grandfather
1:20:50 the same Twisted mentality that's how
1:20:52 the Devil comes in and this satanic
1:20:55 argument played with many people of
1:20:57 nasibi and he was somewhat happy now
1:21:00 what's wrong and going out but they say
1:21:03 because his room Jannah and the prophet
1:21:05 so we we know about that he's one of the
1:21:08 shabab of Jannah and so on it's forgiven
1:21:10 as well that's what they say
1:21:12 the same thing and the Other Extreme of
1:21:14 the sabbah isia they go into lamentation
1:21:18 doing nothing
1:21:20 instead of looking at himself how they
1:21:22 failed Hussein
1:21:25 promise him would instructed into his
1:21:27 side
1:21:28 you are a failure then from your failure
1:21:31 and be be non-failure but they remain
1:21:33 failure until today
1:21:44 that's how they do that they will come
1:21:45 that's the law
1:21:47 studying it historically whatever the
1:21:50 mistake which blenders have been made
1:21:51 what should have been done or should
1:21:53 have been done that's okay
1:21:55 so that in the future you apply not the
1:21:58 limitation not till the Indulgence
1:22:00 saying
1:22:01 something is wrong why Allah is not
1:22:03 supporting me why is letting me down
1:22:05 that's what the devil wants the devil
1:22:08 wants just to dig between you uh
1:22:12 a deep Canyon uncorsable that's what you
1:22:15 want doesn't want anything else
1:22:17 just to wrap up some of the other
1:22:19 questions Jack though yeah
1:22:21 um
1:22:23 so so sorry
1:22:26 definition of starting point invalidates
1:22:29 Infinity definition I'm not sure what
1:22:31 this means
1:22:32 um
1:22:35 the infinity definition
1:22:37 what's infinity definition I don't know
1:22:39 what's mean
1:22:40 God being infinite maybe I don't know no
1:22:43 these terms do not make any sense God is
1:22:45 necessarily existing and
1:22:48 before him there's no existence no time
1:22:51 nothing absolute nothingness
1:22:53 meaning existence and time having a
1:22:55 beginning
1:22:57 with Allah he's the first nothing is
1:23:01 before him like Hadith says exactly
1:23:03 until Allah
1:23:08 with the difference between the two the
1:23:10 hours because someone could imagination
1:23:13 could run wild like every time he has
1:23:14 said there are events without beginning
1:23:16 and the Penrose by the way he got a well
1:23:20 prized for certain of his symptoms he
1:23:22 tried to escape the problem of creation
1:23:24 of the Big Bang say that's why big bank
1:23:26 is is really emergence from Another
1:23:28 Universe before that
1:23:30 okay and that doesn't help him because
1:23:32 he's he's trying to save his atheism and
1:23:35 they say this is one from another verse
1:23:36 before the for that and before that and
1:23:38 before that Without End
1:23:40 which is essentially a Hindu philosophy
1:23:43 of of uh eternally the color Universe
1:23:45 with no beginning
1:23:47 essentially a circular Universe it must
1:23:49 be circular there's no other way it can
1:23:50 be like but it's a but as a hidden
1:23:52 circularity which is impossible the
1:23:54 second is impossible but it's a hidden
1:23:56 circularity we should have been proven
1:23:58 by by the intertex theorem that is that
1:24:01 cannot be like that it's impossible
1:24:04 and he's trying hoping that that
1:24:07 observing the background radiation by by
1:24:09 the James Webb of the scope was
1:24:12 justify him I think it has already
1:24:15 failed but anyway individual observation
1:24:17 whatever it is it's impossible it can be
1:24:19 legible mathematically it's important
1:24:22 every time you fell in that club say
1:24:24 events could be without beginning and
1:24:25 their Universe after Universe after you
1:24:27 missed before that before that before
1:24:28 that because Allah must be active in
1:24:30 creation for eternity and Eternity
1:24:32 because he did not understand
1:24:33 meaningless then there's a beginning
1:24:37 in the past is the beginning in the
1:24:39 future there is no end because the
1:24:41 future is open again with it
1:24:48 so it's hard to interpret it properly
1:24:50 you are the first nothing is before you
1:24:53 okay that's already happened he's here
1:24:55 and the whole creation is here
1:24:57 and that's it there's nothing before
1:24:59 that absolutely nothing none no but the
1:25:02 only way to express it in any language
1:25:03 say nothing before you absolute
1:25:06 nothingness no time no existence nothing
1:25:08 impossibility
1:25:10 that's that's the that's the correct
1:25:12 meaning of it and if you look from our
1:25:14 advantage and go back then this is a
1:25:17 zero point there's no negative absolute
1:25:19 time
1:25:20 doesn't exist it's an impossibility
1:25:23 in the future
1:25:26 nothing is after you has to be completed
1:25:28 probably in the nation of future is open
1:25:31 meaning whatever comes you are after it
1:25:35 but there's no end of the comic you will
1:25:37 not come to everyone through a movie
1:25:40 where where some people are
1:25:44 going in time forward and then they come
1:25:46 to a world say End of Time Stop yes no
1:25:48 morals think about that that doesn't
1:25:50 exist
1:25:51 there's no end of that
1:25:54 his time is open-ended in the future
1:25:57 because you build from now and add more
1:25:59 and add more and more there's nothing
1:26:01 for that of course and never ends
1:26:04 doesn't create any confliction but going
1:26:06 back at create confirmations
1:26:10 so you have tool that is that
1:26:11 interpreted with with the necessity of
1:26:13 visa and with all these achievements of
1:26:15 of the of the
1:26:17 uh scrutinizing mind of the
1:26:20 mathematician and the logician and the
1:26:23 rationalist
1:26:27 we have to we have to take you have to
1:26:29 take on board mathematics and
1:26:30 rationalism is just experimental physics
1:26:32 is not enough it gives you
1:26:35 a tool in your hand but it isn't
1:26:38 it doesn't solve your problem
1:26:43 or Hawkins try to solve the problem by
1:26:46 disability because they have time
1:26:48 and then he ended that there's a zero
1:26:51 point and then there's there is no time
1:26:53 Passage
1:26:54 and there are four dimensions or
1:26:55 whatever number of Dimensions one of
1:26:57 them flips that became time but how can
1:26:58 it flip by itself
1:27:00 there's a Quantum fluctuation but
1:27:03 Quantum fluctuations are impossible to
1:27:04 Divine except if we have a concept of
1:27:06 time before that
1:27:11 so with the reality what they call
1:27:12 Quantic question is something which is
1:27:14 absolutely sovereign
1:27:17 God
1:27:18 he's running away from God and falling
1:27:20 in Gods are arms
1:27:24 besides in that case you don't need to
1:27:26 have a one-dimension freebing because
1:27:29 observed time is fundamentally different
1:27:31 than stress Dimensions it was not as
1:27:33 fast damage or anything
1:27:35 okay
1:27:37 even those phase Dimensions may be
1:27:39 created just what we perceive as we're
1:27:41 free
1:27:43 what they call degrees of freedom we
1:27:46 have three degrees we can't go right
1:27:47 left that's one degree Freedom forward
1:27:49 back that's the second up and down
1:27:51 that's three
1:27:53 time is not is not of this type
1:27:55 we can't go back and forth and so on but
1:27:58 it always it is the Divine action
1:28:01 forcing everything to go in its way
1:28:04 while giving considerable freedom for
1:28:06 setting creative being which is almost
1:28:08 miraculous but that's what the reality
1:28:10 it is and the reality of the universe as
1:28:12 we perceive it and the reality of the
1:28:14 Quran and the Revelation which has
1:28:16 clearly stated that
1:28:18 that's a democracy more things that I
1:28:20 thought the Ayah in the example the I
1:28:23 believe is saying that they did not say
1:28:25 something yet and Allah blaming them for
1:28:27 their choices how does Allah know what
1:28:29 they will say do you know that Ayah that
1:28:31 was 1635 that was mentioned before
1:28:36 saying no
1:28:39 they're saying no he may be meaning that
1:28:42 that in in your camera they say they
1:28:44 some they say
1:28:47 that by our Lord
1:28:50 say that
1:28:55 so how does Allah know what they will
1:28:57 say in the Hereafter it's a Hereafter
1:28:59 some of them would say but there's a
1:29:00 possibility there are many possibilities
1:29:02 some argue that's some some kind of
1:29:04 argue somebody being silent
1:29:07 that's a contingency
1:29:11 some of them say that not everyone will
1:29:13 say that
1:29:15 so he's prophesizing that God is
1:29:18 prophesied in that or is it recounting
1:29:20 it in retrospect
1:29:23 how was how did what does the Ayah mean
1:29:26 that is Allah recounting your story that
1:29:28 hasn't happened yet and it's in
1:29:30 retrospect as in almost like if you had
1:29:32 a time machine that's that's what
1:29:34 happened because the condition at that
1:29:35 time will valante people will be
1:29:37 defending himself with various kinds of
1:29:38 events some will kill him
1:29:41 and they were like well I said and some
1:29:45 of this all this will happen some of
1:29:46 this will happen these are contingencies
1:29:49 with the number of people in the um
1:29:51 there will be so many options and
1:29:53 variations and they will be all realized
1:30:00 that's not the XYZ specifically will say
1:30:03 that
1:30:05 that will be prophesizing
1:30:13 there's a contingency that's a
1:30:15 possibility to have there's a
1:30:16 possibility and all of these
1:30:17 possibilities will happen in America all
1:30:19 kinds of arguments all kinds of of uh
1:30:22 defensing oneself
1:30:25 and we mentioned once you remember I
1:30:26 mentioned the story of the barrister is
1:30:29 it only a specific one he didn't mention
1:30:30 a person say a man will come like that
1:30:32 and that there will be people like that
1:30:34 and all of these phenomena will happen
1:30:37 there are so many humans and so billions
1:30:39 of humans and all kinds of options are
1:30:41 there available for them still
1:30:42 but to get away
1:30:44 and some will be just perplexed saying
1:30:46 nothing and say we should be turned into
1:30:48 dust for example
1:30:50 all of that will happen
1:30:51 this contingency that's not a specific
1:30:53 prophecy
1:30:56 peroxide they said in the passage of
1:30:59 time your your piety will disintegrate I
1:31:01 will be fighting on power and wealth and
1:31:03 so on this is this is a Social
1:31:05 Development which is going to have an
1:31:07 inevitably based on the kind of
1:31:09 condition
1:31:10 back
1:31:21 from them your friend oh yeah
1:31:24 and they may succeed they may fail
1:31:25 usually they will some of some one or
1:31:27 another will succeed
1:31:30 but if he mentioned certain names like
1:31:32 summer of Legend of and so on because at
1:31:34 that time in the case of Samara it's
1:31:35 mentioned especially that cell options
1:31:37 are open
1:31:43 who looked in a room and said one one of
1:31:46 you the last one to die of you
1:31:48 will die in fire
1:31:51 a hellkoma the last one to die will be
1:31:53 in fire
1:31:55 that's the wedding exactly
1:31:58 to die in fire
1:32:00 this could be integrated he will end in
1:32:02 the Hellfire or he die in a fire in his
1:32:04 house
1:32:06 my interpretation for that I didn't
1:32:09 write it in the record I don't know I
1:32:11 didn't want to abandon that that there's
1:32:12 a historic recessions owned by by issues
1:32:15 of Qatar and so on he said at that time
1:32:17 the man was wavering at monafith
1:32:20 gave him the option through them because
1:32:23 he knew that he will be the addressee he
1:32:25 knew that later on all indication that
1:32:27 he knew that was that the sea that he
1:32:30 would overcome his nifak and overcome
1:32:32 his internal even
1:32:34 so give us the option this way Allah
1:32:37 himself if he meant his ways and would
1:32:41 do good
1:32:42 first of all he will be the last to die
1:32:44 there's no doubt about that from The
1:32:45 Goldberg and the last remaining was
1:32:49 always checking about who that if
1:32:52 someone died and some soul teasing him
1:32:55 they said him somehow died we used to
1:32:58 fall unconscious thinking that he's the
1:33:00 last one and this may hurt
1:33:02 him because he his interpretation that
1:33:05 is meaning Hellfire but I think he is
1:33:07 also mistaken in that no no the
1:33:08 accusations could be right otherwise if
1:33:11 Samurai would have mended his way and
1:33:13 lose the last to die there would have
1:33:15 been a fire in his house and he would
1:33:17 have would have died in fire and it
1:33:18 would have been the Fulfillment of the
1:33:20 prophecies that he died in a fire
1:33:21 accident
1:33:22 and possibly commercial heat but if he
1:33:25 doesn't hit Midway it doesn't die in a
1:33:27 fire which is the historic reality with
1:33:29 certitude
1:33:31 then he will end in the Hellfire
1:33:33 and that's what happened unfortunately
1:33:36 or fortunately unfortunately for him
1:33:38 obviously but that's not his choice
1:33:46 yeah
1:33:47 so it's formulated so that it has two
1:33:49 two options still open
1:33:51 but other people while I knew that they
1:33:54 are in
1:33:55 Fair many
1:33:59 and they will stay in effect until they
1:34:00 die it's the people who plotted to call
1:34:03 the message
1:34:06 the way back from tabuk
1:34:08 and he said about 10 of them
1:34:11 three was executed three were we did not
1:34:13 know and they just joined the school
1:34:15 going up the mountain they did not hear
1:34:17 the command nobody go up the
1:34:19 mountains so they follow them
1:34:22 they're telling the truth they are not
1:34:24 they didn't know about that
1:34:26 but then
1:34:28 you say the element of Allah and his
1:34:31 messenger in Dunya under the day of
1:34:33 Resurrection
1:34:35 and then he said
1:34:36 one of them will be an old and become
1:34:38 blind the most likely is Abu Sofia Ah
1:34:40 that's my guess I'm not supposed
1:34:43 and for other other of them one of them
1:34:46 is Enough from the dubail I will take
1:34:49 care of him the Dubai is a disease like
1:34:50 like a like a deep a deep a deep
1:34:57 acceleration of the skin in the back
1:34:59 which goes so deep the fish almost the
1:35:02 heart and the and the major veins and
1:35:04 kill him and it is the good narration
1:35:06 that my away died this way maybe he was
1:35:08 what's going on with them there
1:35:11 but he said that the Destiny's silver
1:35:13 colors finish
1:35:18 by this action Allah sealed them finish
1:35:20 them
1:35:22 they can live as long as they wish not
1:35:24 going to go back
1:35:28 they have forgotten all opportunities
1:35:29 which given to them
1:35:32 they are dead while they are alive
1:35:34 their hearts are dead while they
1:35:36 physically they're alive they go and eat
1:35:38 and even they even use our power
1:35:39 possibly is one of them that I'm not
1:35:42 making this attitude but I assume based
1:35:45 on other evidences and
1:35:48 and uh there's no escape from that
1:35:52 I know it came from from on my way down
1:35:55 to the Dubai we have narration for that
1:35:56 and he showed it to some people
1:36:01 um
1:36:02 so it's very complex yeah because
1:36:05 keep in mind the fusion is under Allah
1:36:08 controls that's the important point
1:36:11 so he decide things and they are done
1:36:13 not by certitude at the moment other
1:36:15 things are suspended they were known it
1:36:17 will be known in due course
1:36:19 like the ones insulted when we will come
1:36:22 to it which is the Striking one which
1:36:24 gives the strike to all jabri point of
1:36:27 view that is the following week
1:36:32 and others
1:36:36 postponed to the decision of Allah
1:36:38 either he punished them or he forgive
1:36:41 them Allah
1:36:44 and we know who are these people they
1:36:46 were postponed the people who failed to
1:36:48 go without the story is well known in
1:36:49 fact they never see it but none of us
1:36:51 had ever did touching the issue there
1:36:54 that they'll postponed to the decision
1:36:55 of Allah except and he'd have a waving
1:36:59 and said ah this actually could send a
1:37:01 human angle point to it but what Allah
1:37:02 is different it's already decided
1:37:04 because he's Germany he's stuck with the
1:37:06 Ethereal everything known for maternity
1:37:09 which is false
1:37:12 because Allah talks about himself
1:37:14 there was one to the command of Allah
1:37:19 so it can't be in your perception and
1:37:21 perception
1:37:23 just just
1:37:25 intellectual acrobatic bothering on The
1:37:28 observed
1:37:31 no decision has been made
1:37:34 the theme will be made later
1:37:37 to punish them or to forgive them
1:37:40 as quarter was actually saying Allah
1:37:42 Islamic he already decided to forgive
1:37:43 because they was forgiven later but but
1:37:45 he did not tell us that which is just
1:37:46 just fooling us
1:37:50 keeping us in suspense
1:37:52 like a movie having like a knot we don't
1:37:55 know who is the criminal until later
1:37:56 it's not like that it's not right it's
1:37:59 not the way Quran works
1:38:04 what do you think of achieving
1:38:07 teleportation on the macro level
1:38:10 to similar to activity we see occurs on
1:38:13 the quantum level teleportation
1:38:15 basically I don't know some people argue
1:38:17 that with the bringing of the arsha of
1:38:19 the Throne of the queen of sabbah to uh
1:38:22 to uh Suleiman is maybe an actual
1:38:24 teleportation
1:38:29 we don't know
1:38:32 is it accessible to the divine power
1:38:34 definitely is accessible
1:38:36 Allah can copy you from here and make
1:38:39 another copy there and edit this copy
1:38:45 that's exactly what happened to the
1:38:46 resurrection we are copied from the
1:38:49 divine all your memories and sword
1:38:50 copied from the Divine knowledge into a
1:38:52 new physical device
1:38:54 some people think this is that the body
1:38:56 in the grave also this is obviously
1:38:58 stable minded we don't want to indulge
1:39:00 in that too much
1:39:01 but the Quran clarify that in my place
1:39:06 you don't know
1:39:10 some other body and even hence that
1:39:12 hence in the Sunnah but the craft are
1:39:14 being extended that his side is as big
1:39:16 the mountain of varkan near Medina says
1:39:18 Mountain
1:39:19 and his his skin is 40 is 40 uh is 40 uh
1:39:25 there are almost 20 meters thick so that
1:39:28 he takes the punishment
1:39:30 is a huge entity
1:39:32 but all Consciousness our low
1:39:34 personality is in that body
1:39:38 so he can create you in something else
1:39:58 I'm gonna keep it simple give simple
1:40:01 example uh so to my understanding is uh
1:40:04 uh Allah has systemized uh things and
1:40:08 organized or put things in order uh in
1:40:13 in in the pre I mean
1:40:17 pre-distant in the time past so uh so
1:40:22 all principles and all our orders in in
1:40:26 in the universe Allah has created uh in
1:40:30 the time past and he knows
1:40:32 here is it that universe that we live in
1:40:36 now originates from an initial design of
1:40:39 Allah's knowledge
1:40:40 yes decided with a certain structure of
1:40:43 the fundamentals which will develop the
1:40:45 way it is now which entails all the
1:40:48 contingencies in that Universe
1:40:53 Allah decided this system in the time
1:40:55 passed like like
1:40:57 eternity
1:40:59 yes exactly before before universe but
1:41:02 uh so so so this uh this uh exactly what
1:41:08 Allah I think what Allah means when the
1:41:10 Ayah says
1:41:16 Allah has created you so that some of
1:41:19 you will will believe and some of you
1:41:21 will disbelieve so so
1:41:23 in the time past before the creation of
1:41:26 people Allah knows because he put this
1:41:29 system this way that some people when I
1:41:31 create them some people will disbelieve
1:41:33 and some people will become Believers
1:41:36 right but then uh the the when it comes
1:41:40 to the level of of the individual
1:41:42 himself he has to be created that
1:41:47 specific individual the created human
1:41:49 being he has to be created then he has
1:41:52 to face the test so that Allah then
1:41:55 knows that he uh if if he will believe
1:41:58 of he or he will uh if he passes the
1:42:02 test or if he doesn't pass the test but
1:42:05 right what you just mentioned the system
1:42:07 already saw that there will be creatures
1:42:09 who have free will and and the universe
1:42:11 is chosen to be a testing universes
1:42:13 clearly that's the design of the
1:42:14 Universe from the beginning it could
1:42:16 have been another universe but that's
1:42:17 not the show they show the testing
1:42:19 Universe whether conscious being who
1:42:21 have sufficient Free Will and sufficient
1:42:22 responsibility and bye bye bye bye bye
1:42:26 by by the natural of the
1:42:30 huge numbers and so on there will be
1:42:32 covered there will be movement mm-hmm
1:42:34 yes yes so yes exactly that's what I'm
1:42:38 what I meant so what is the problem in
1:42:41 that the possibility is there the
1:42:43 contingency is there that's it that's
1:42:44 what the eye exists exactly so uh so the
1:42:48 matter is uh or my question is when it
1:42:50 comes to the level of individual for
1:42:53 example
1:42:54 um
1:42:55 Allah will knows Allah will know that I
1:42:59 will pass I I will believe or disbelieve
1:43:02 when he when he give me the test right
1:43:05 after this what's your reaction to the
1:43:07 test would be exactly like for the case
1:43:10 of of of Abu lab for example Allah uh
1:43:13 Allah gave him the test after after he
1:43:17 created him
1:43:18 there's no doubt about that the issue
1:43:21 was that he is going to the Hellfire
1:43:23 that was decided at that moment the
1:43:24 issue is not the issue of the al-jabbari
1:43:26 and what uh
1:43:31 decided already in eternity if this
1:43:37 written as it is now already before the
1:43:40 creation of the universe which is a
1:43:42 fantastic claim then Allah cannot have
1:43:45 argument the creation will defeat Allah
1:43:47 is already there there's no free will oh
1:43:50 there's nothing will so that's that's
1:43:52 devastating that's a completely
1:43:54 devastating argument against any any job
1:43:56 yes yes that's that's it it's just
1:43:59 clarify it this way after that is
1:44:01 dynamic and Allah is an absolute control
1:44:03 of everything exactly exactly look at
1:44:07 every moment past finish recorded cannot
1:44:10 be changed any physical Theory which
1:44:13 entails that coming back in the past
1:44:15 month we approximately take it from me
1:44:17 I'll guarantee you that all the general
1:44:20 relativity theory in that formulation
1:44:22 which admits Solutions either we find
1:44:24 the interpretation of the solution no
1:44:26 iteration has been found I mentioned
1:44:28 that joke about girdle someone said that
1:44:30 you have he is the one who uh showed
1:44:32 that one of the solutions of the general
1:44:33 theory of relativity one of the
1:44:35 universes
1:44:36 possible universes is a rotating
1:44:38 Universe in which the closer time looks
1:44:40 meaning you can't go back in time
1:44:44 and uh someone as good on Google is a
1:44:47 very very
1:44:48 sneaky and sophisticated thinker and
1:44:51 feel so
1:44:52 they asked him but this means that you
1:44:55 can't go back in time this possibility
1:44:56 exists that you are working with the
1:44:58 time and you can't kill your
1:45:00 grandfather's grandfather and you cannot
1:45:03 then you don't exist or how to get that
1:45:06 valid question and then he smiled you
1:45:09 say the narrator say he smiled missively
1:45:11 and say God has sustained and prevent
1:45:13 that actually is correct answer we see
1:45:15 this means that the theory of relatively
1:45:18 at The Stance is approximate we must
1:45:20 have other terms and must enter so that
1:45:22 such a solution does not come or find
1:45:24 another interpretation for that but they
1:45:26 obviously he wanted to tease the one
1:45:27 refer to him because he believes in God
1:45:29 and believe in the identity of the Soul
1:45:31 good the famous mathematician at the
1:45:33 logician so that's that's just to teach
1:45:36 some people but that's it and every
1:45:39 moment you have it my past it's gone
1:45:40 hard forget about it that says
1:45:43 that what have before you could not have
1:45:46 been not missed you and it's already
1:45:48 done and put and it could not have
1:45:50 happened except for Allah permitted me
1:45:52 to have it like that forget about that
1:45:54 look forward in the future that you have
1:45:56 some control and that one is under Allah
1:45:58 dominance over the overall
1:46:01 if you look at this one and get out of
1:46:04 the fiction that Allah knows the events
1:46:06 in the future because this is a fiction
1:46:07 it's not cannot be correct it's
1:46:09 impossible it's impossible
1:46:12 because then then he became a mechanism
1:46:14 he does he must know than what he will
1:46:16 do in the future
1:46:18 yes all of it
1:46:20 then he has no free choice
1:46:22 and this one argued by some and even
1:46:25 even one of the multically means of of
1:46:28 the Shia I think they call it shaytan
1:46:32 anyway uh his name will come in my mind
1:46:36 was arguing this way andar razi was
1:46:38 famous for the uh especially a
1:46:41 theological discussion in his tafsir
1:46:43 mathem which is a huge stuff seriously
1:46:47 he discussed various points of you and
1:46:48 he mentioned the Poetry of this man
1:46:51 and he explained it and then he got
1:46:54 stuck so whatever you say see but we we
1:46:57 just say what the scholar the major
1:46:59 School of the ummah said that's this and
1:47:01 this and this repeating the same what
1:47:03 they are missing all the time instead of
1:47:05 saying this argument is a stunning
1:47:07 argument it is that argument the man is
1:47:09 arguing that this means Allah is a
1:47:11 mechanism it can't be
1:47:13 it can't be
1:47:15 it's a mechanism and then then there's
1:47:18 no then if it's a mechanism that did not
1:47:19 even talk about knowledge in the first
1:47:21 place it's just produces by mechanical
1:47:23 myths and have no no no no no sense
1:47:26 about cooking free will or knowledge
1:47:27 anyway it become nature that blind
1:47:30 definition It's not that it's a high uh
1:47:35 but that's not Allah it's nature
1:47:38 according to the atheist but that's such
1:47:40 an entity cannot exist
1:47:42 it actually does not exist because of
1:47:44 the cosmological proof I think the
1:47:45 problem is
1:47:47 I think it is has to surrender that's
1:47:50 that's not escape from that or because
1:47:52 of the ontological proof which is
1:47:54 underdevelopment yet that's it finish
1:47:56 that's it and all of these are accesses
1:47:59 are just imagination people think this
1:48:01 is undermining Allah knowledge all of
1:48:03 this this is all nonsensical it's not
1:48:05 true
1:48:06 yes the future is fundamentally over
1:48:09 uh-huh Professor
1:48:11 it becomes clear for me now when we when
1:48:15 we are talking about the uh conscious
1:48:17 human beings like for example Homo
1:48:21 sapiens but the problem still persists
1:48:24 with me when we talk for example to a
1:48:27 non-conscious
1:48:28 non-conscious non-conscious uh uh things
1:48:32 or beings for example yes like for
1:48:36 example we discussed the Ayah a woman
1:48:42 so so unless there is that
1:48:52 so Allah knows when it falls uh when
1:48:56 when it's when it is when it is falling
1:48:59 or when it has or he knows
1:49:02 no no no he went far away then my point
1:49:05 was that if it has fallen he must know
1:49:08 that it has fallen
1:49:10 otherwise that's my point it's not cover
1:49:13 or cut anything just knowledge
1:49:20 his outside time time is only for our
1:49:23 point of view meaning the the leaf is
1:49:25 falling for all eternity and it's not
1:49:27 falling this is nonsense the same would
1:49:29 if you extend the theory of relativity
1:49:31 and Extended space and time and say the
1:49:34 fusion password all presents somehow but
1:49:36 will it not accessible to us it's
1:49:38 nonsense because the space time is the
1:49:40 Continuum but there are events there so
1:49:42 how come the events is is happening and
1:49:45 happening in the past in the future
1:49:47 happening are not happening
1:49:49 does not make any sense this is just
1:49:51 using words to access something which
1:49:53 does not exist
1:49:54 exactly like saying this uh this round
1:49:58 circle is beautiful
1:49:59 so it's a valid linguistic sentence but
1:50:02 this time doesn't refer to anything it's
1:50:04 impossible to refer to an impossible
1:50:06 entity
1:50:07 yeah so the floor the Fallen leave
1:50:11 knowledge and so on got it got it yes
1:50:15 yes
1:50:17 that's another issue
1:50:19 um uh I I don't know why why did you put
1:50:22 that this is a matter of knowledge
1:50:24 purely
1:50:25 yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes and no
1:50:29 no it is clear that you know
1:50:32 when you said that the Fallen Leaf you
1:50:35 know we're talking about my point has
1:50:38 fallen and Allah that was my time is
1:50:41 that how it failed is it predestined
1:50:43 this is irrelevant
1:50:47 are the conditions sufficient to to
1:50:50 bring the effect on this known in
1:50:51 advance or it is not that's very
1:50:53 complicated maybe they're not sufficient
1:50:55 maybe
1:50:56 fluctuation we don't know
1:50:58 yes but ultimately it's a different
1:51:01 matter yeah
1:51:07 they claim that there cannot be events
1:51:10 where they call events in the Divine
1:51:11 being no
1:51:12 if that's so then they will kind of be a
1:51:15 free will of the Divine being then we
1:51:16 are back to the dead deafblind nature it
1:51:21 can't it can't yeah
1:51:29 does not make any sense but the people
1:51:31 did not pursue that properly
1:51:33 but they just went without my mind this
1:51:36 is only from our Vantage Point that's
1:51:37 from a Divine vantage point or Allah is
1:51:39 not in time without time or all of this
1:51:41 and let me say you have explained to you
1:51:42 clearly what's time mean what meaning
1:51:44 Allah is the time explain that perfectly
1:51:48 yes yes
1:51:50 absolutely satisfactory it doesn't leave
1:51:52 anything else
1:51:54 yes yes yes a hundred percent now is
1:51:57 clear profit thank you so much thanks
1:51:59 thanks a lot so this is issue this is an
1:52:01 issue there's an issue but ultimately it
1:52:03 goes to the fundamental Divine activist
1:52:05 that Allah is living
1:52:10 meaning free agent absolute but because
1:52:13 he is necessarily existing then his
1:52:15 freedom must be absolutely unconditioned
1:52:17 by anything else absolutely because if
1:52:19 it's conditioned anything then he is not
1:52:21 conditional and then cannot be
1:52:22 necessarily existing
1:52:24 because an assistant me either is
1:52:26 absolutely free The Sovereign
1:52:29 whatsoever is a mechanism
1:52:31 the question remaining is it possible
1:52:34 that this is accepting is a mechanism
1:52:35 only that would be an ontological proof
1:52:38 we don't need to look at the universe
1:52:39 Big Bang or not bother about anything
1:52:41 else
1:52:42 last issue
1:52:44 I think a draft a rough proof is
1:52:47 developing slowly in my mind and
1:52:49 somebody writing here and there but that
1:52:51 is maybe life will end before we achieve
1:52:53 anything this may take may take Humanity
1:52:56 essentially but we have the cosmological
1:52:58 book
1:52:59 better than Christmas we have the
1:53:01 evidences of the prophethood
1:53:03 that their Prophets
1:53:05 and they're referring to Supernatural
1:53:06 being who gave them the information so
1:53:08 they refer to a being which is
1:53:11 super to the universe in control and
1:53:14 knowledge in a in a way which we don't
1:53:16 need to go into detail it's not in the
1:53:18 universe it's outside the universe in
1:53:19 control and knowledge so these
1:53:21 Messengers could not have get that that
1:53:24 information from the universe from
1:53:25 outside of it it's super natural so some
1:53:28 Supernatural thing exists
1:53:32 and that's enough
1:53:33 the moment it exists and we scored rise
1:53:36 it says it is attributed
1:53:37 then this is necessarily existing that
1:53:39 this then it is this that this and then
1:53:41 we enter we end the physical right
1:53:43 things properly
1:53:45 and he talks about himself if that's
1:53:46 really a messenger he talks about
1:53:48 himself now that's what what he's
1:53:49 talking about himself and he's Messier
1:53:51 reporting is the correct one and what
1:53:52 you imagine we're dividing the time and
1:53:54 saying events are nonsense is nonsense
1:53:56 it's mistaken something you did not do
1:53:58 the analysis very thoroughly and reality
1:54:00 they do not do that already because they
1:54:03 relied on issues of dividing time and
1:54:05 dividing sales and so on which are not
1:54:07 completely deficient are not very
1:54:08 systematic
1:54:10 and a neglecting issues by concerning
1:54:13 Infinities and so on which has to be
1:54:15 done with Extreme Caution
1:54:16 otherwise you'll end in the difficulties
1:54:18 and contradictions like the famous
1:54:20 contradiction the arrow problem like say
1:54:22 if I say I send an arrow to a Target
1:54:26 but the arrow has to spend to go to a
1:54:28 half distances to the certain time then
1:54:30 half the remaining distance another time
1:54:32 Etc if we add all of that to become
1:54:34 infinite so it will never reach this is
1:54:36 a mistake because actually the times
1:54:37 becomes smaller smaller you can add them
1:54:39 at the time they would not have the
1:54:41 tools to add infinite series
1:54:43 but we now know how to Identity series
1:54:45 and how to define that properly and
1:54:47 there's no problem there are reaches
1:54:49 but at that time until very until all
1:54:52 Middle Ages that our problem was was
1:54:54 bugging people which is no problem
1:54:56 because clearly the outreaches
1:54:59 so your division in like half and half
1:55:01 there must be some fault there but
1:55:03 what's the fault
1:55:04 that was initiated and forced to the
1:55:06 study Infinity Series and how to add a
1:55:09 time half time call the time and so on
1:55:11 and we can add them and it ends to be
1:55:13 exactly the same full-time one time one
1:55:16 hour if it takes one hour to apply
1:55:18 foreign
1:55:25 analysis about events and things like
1:55:28 that which has not been done thoroughly
1:55:30 and meticulously especially if it goes
1:55:32 to subdividing to infinity and extending
1:55:34 to Infinity the moment you go to
1:55:35 infinities
1:55:36 then you go to the Limit area then you
1:55:39 are in a dangerous area you have to do a
1:55:40 very strict and very systematic
1:55:42 mathematics building step by step from
1:55:44 the finite in a very cautious and
1:55:46 well-controlled steps then you achieve
1:55:49 something
1:55:49 very cautious and very meticulous
1:55:51 otherwise you will make a mistake
1:55:54 like the mistake of related Theory
1:55:56 making time is just because well
1:55:58 regarding my time as my clock time as
1:56:01 zero and extending bus to minus infinity
1:56:03 canopy is impossible and they treated
1:56:05 the access as if the space accident they
1:56:08 say it has another metric there's
1:56:09 another sign in The Matrix or an i in a
1:56:12 okay but still it's fundamentally
1:56:13 different it can't be extended one's
1:56:16 Infinity it's fundamentally different
1:56:18 structure
1:56:19 gonna be a joint space approximately yes
1:56:22 locally in events around us in
1:56:24 observation of the Stars we can do we
1:56:25 can't use the minkowsky transformation
1:56:27 and tolerance transformation but that's
1:56:30 construct which Einstein took as a base
1:56:32 for a special relativity using minkov's
1:56:34 key space formulation and also for
1:56:36 generativity that construct his only
1:56:38 approximation
1:56:39 and has fundamental philosophical fault
1:56:43 but it's clearly by experimentation now
1:56:45 when we go to fundamental Theory it's
1:56:48 all experiences have now showed that the
1:56:49 adaptivity theory General and special is
1:56:52 not a fundamental one quantum theory is
1:56:54 the fundamental one which relies on an
1:56:56 absolute time
1:56:59 and there's the problems who are the
1:57:01 most physicists are struggling with that
1:57:02 in the last 70 80 years and still most
1:57:05 of it is not settled yet still ongoing
1:57:07 and that I argue with you now for today
1:57:10 and and make a statement it will never
1:57:12 visited until that problem that
1:57:13 fundamental error has been corrected
1:57:21 transformation and the Michaelson more
1:57:23 the experiment
1:57:25 better in the interpretation matrimony
1:57:27 is an experiment if it has been done
1:57:29 probably a lot some people even doubt
1:57:31 that that the result have been really
1:57:33 reported correctly but even surgical
1:57:35 assuming they have done that is an
1:57:38 experimental equation with debilitation
1:57:39 and translating that in into
1:57:41 mathematical language
1:57:43 and invariables and things that and we
1:57:46 recognize the district nature of
1:57:48 different things and so on
1:57:52 yeah I think
1:57:54 anyway today we did we did some heavy
1:57:56 stuff I was hoping to avoid it as much
1:57:59 as possible just give a hint but you
1:58:01 insisted okay you get since you insist
1:58:04 you get the heavy stuff you should have
1:58:06 avoided maybe you should not have
1:58:07 avoided maybe it's good it's good to
1:58:10 have sometimes sometimes some heavy
1:58:11 stuff to be digested okay I think I'll
1:58:14 stop here
1:58:21 foreign
1:58:37 Music
1:59:01 foreign
1:59:03 Music
1:59:09 Music
1:59:18 Music
1:59:26 Music
1:59:33 thank you
1:59:38 Music