0:00:08 Music
0:00:22 thank you
0:00:34 foreign
0:01:04 these episodes are broadcast live on the
0:01:07 study Circles of Dr Muhammad al-masri
0:01:09 YouTube channel every Sunday at 2PM
0:01:12 British summer time we invite you to
0:01:14 subscribe to the channel and activate
0:01:15 the notification Bell for all new
0:01:17 content
0:01:18 please note also the link to the live
0:01:20 broadcast or by dissemination do not
0:01:22 forget to interact with us during the
0:01:23 broadcast by participating in the
0:01:24 comments and asking questions through
0:01:25 the chat box you will find via the
0:01:27 broadcast link next to the video also do
0:01:29 not forget to support our activities by
0:01:31 donating when asking questions in the
0:01:32 conversation or through the thank you
0:01:33 button under our video today is Sunday
0:01:36 the 2nd of October the doctor continues
0:01:39 the interpretation of historical maida
0:01:41 verse 97.
0:01:44 foreign
0:02:15 God has laid down that the Kaaba the
0:02:18 inviable temple shall be a symbol for
0:02:20 All Mankind and so too the sacred month
0:02:22 of pilgrimage and the godlin offering
0:02:24 our symbols meant to make you aware that
0:02:26 God is aware of all that is in the
0:02:28 heavens and all that is on the earth and
0:02:30 that God has full knowledge of
0:02:31 everything a translation God has made
0:02:33 the Kaaba the sacred house a sanctuary
0:02:35 for human beings and the sacred monster
0:02:37 the animals were sacrifice and their
0:02:39 garlands so that you will be aware that
0:02:41 God has knowledge about all that is the
0:02:43 heavens and the Earth God knows about
0:02:45 everything
0:02:46 yeah I think the meaning is very clear
0:02:48 but the only interesting thing is here
0:02:49 that we commented on is that that Allah
0:02:53 established the Kaaba that's the holy
0:02:56 sanctuary in Mecca and also as a as a
0:02:59 symbol or a reference for people and uh
0:03:03 same with the sanctuary months to
0:03:05 abstain from fighting because it was
0:03:07 restricted to the Arabs essentially and
0:03:10 the the offerings Central Kaaba and also
0:03:13 these garments and the ornamentation of
0:03:16 the Hadi when going into Kaaba oh that's
0:03:19 very clear that's uh but why it says
0:03:21 after that that you may know that Allah
0:03:23 knows everything in every Earth and
0:03:25 Allah
0:03:27 all things that Allah is
0:03:32 knows everything in heaven is it Allah
0:03:35 knows everything everything knowable but
0:03:38 as we discussed with the connection
0:03:40 between this and this seems to be
0:03:42 strange jumping from an issue of
0:03:43 Regulation set regulations and to
0:03:47 Allah's knowledge of whatever and Earth
0:03:49 and the energy of everything conceivable
0:03:52 and contingent
0:03:55 the connection is most likely our Adam
0:03:57 is that these things are essentially uh
0:04:00 when their essence of symbolism that
0:04:03 fixing the certain months for
0:04:04 non-fighting is why these months
0:04:06 specifically is symbolic while the
0:04:09 sanctuary it could be in the North Pole
0:04:11 is also symbolic why there's a Kibler in
0:04:13 that direction or not the North Pole is
0:04:15 also symbolic and hernia Khalid why why
0:04:19 all all of this connected to the by
0:04:21 knowledge because Allah knows from the
0:04:22 structure of the human nature and the
0:04:25 human mind and brain and the nature of
0:04:29 finite being is that who are always
0:04:31 Limited in knowledge they need they
0:04:34 cannot just relate to a lot of
0:04:36 completely abstract they need some
0:04:38 references they need some points of
0:04:40 Direction so these symbolisms are chosen
0:04:44 carefully to satisfy these needs of
0:04:46 humans otherwise there was no need for
0:04:49 it
0:04:50 and it has also other things for example
0:04:51 there to give their people a sense of
0:04:54 unity you make them spray into unwind
0:04:56 Direction not just scattered any
0:04:58 Direction they should so they have a
0:04:59 sense of community things like so all
0:05:01 these symbolism
0:05:02 although this looks at that face as the
0:05:06 meaning not very much they have the
0:05:08 purpose of satisfying the need of humans
0:05:11 who are bound obviously limited with the
0:05:13 in the in in their world of sense
0:05:16 experience obviously they have also the
0:05:19 rationality and the word of imagination
0:05:22 but the organization of how far it may
0:05:24 go it still have to derive things from
0:05:27 sense experience and develop models from
0:05:29 there and ideas and so on
0:05:32 so Allah has established all of that
0:05:34 knowing that by necessity these
0:05:36 contingent beings need these references
0:05:38 and these so this is the connection why
0:05:41 is that establishing that is dedicated
0:05:42 that that you may know Allah knows
0:05:45 everything in a decade I did not read uh
0:05:48 for this uh what the classical Scholars
0:05:51 how they connected the two issues
0:05:53 um I will read this shall I give you a
0:05:55 reporter they have another point of view
0:05:56 about that but clearly it's uh that's
0:06:00 the only really deep meaning which could
0:06:02 be conclude from that the establishing
0:06:04 of these things not only because of the
0:06:06 utility that they are connected to
0:06:08 material things connected to the set
0:06:10 location at whatever the location that
0:06:11 allocation which is the place where
0:06:14 Abraham built the place that's obviously
0:06:16 a good good connection with the ram as a
0:06:18 leader of mankind that's good but it
0:06:20 could be towards Dhaka it could be to
0:06:22 the North Pole that's not me the carb
0:06:25 itself is directed selected to the
0:06:27 northwest
0:06:29 Northwest what what was it maybe for
0:06:32 example that direction at that time was
0:06:34 facing a certain Star constellation uh
0:06:37 like if we do the calculation probably
0:06:40 and see maybe we can get the exact time
0:06:43 when the cab was established but at
0:06:45 least plus minus one or two years
0:06:47 many things like that symbolism which
0:06:49 also relate to certain knowledge so
0:06:51 Allah knows all these things and all of
0:06:53 them are chosen to reflect Allah's
0:06:55 knowledge and your need for material and
0:06:58 symbolic references
0:07:01 so that's that's my interpretation for
0:07:03 this why the connection that you may
0:07:04 know what has this to do that we know
0:07:07 that Allah knows everything in Heaven
0:07:09 and Earth and allies no no Omni or Omni
0:07:13 uh siens of all things
0:07:16 the next uh another thing so should we
0:07:19 know but this is the common form of
0:07:21 commentary and we'll give you more
0:07:22 information
0:07:30 know that God is surveying retribution
0:07:33 and that God is much forgiving a
0:07:34 dispenser of Grace next translation know
0:07:37 that God is surveying with his
0:07:38 punishment and yet he is most forgiving
0:07:41 and merciful to all yeah we don't need
0:07:44 to do it very much but that's proceed is
0:07:48 foreign
0:07:54 not to know that and when when you bring
0:07:57 your children up you should educate them
0:07:59 about these information it's not like
0:08:00 you don't need to educate them without a
0:08:02 story of yourself they may come along
0:08:03 the way and read it and then when they
0:08:05 believe in the qurans from Allah they
0:08:07 will believe it that's something that's
0:08:08 not an Article of Faith but that Allah
0:08:11 is severeign
0:08:21 that has to be broadcast
0:08:23 not not other stories in the Quran for
0:08:25 example but the people of art you may
0:08:27 live all your life and you never know
0:08:29 you about the people about because you
0:08:31 never read that Surah you have just you
0:08:33 know only a simple Muslim process
0:08:35 somewhere in a village in Bangladesh is
0:08:37 enough for him to fight
0:08:43 but if he doesn't know that Allah is
0:08:45 civilian punishment and Allah for Rahim
0:08:47 he has a deficiency in his belief
0:08:49 actually it's unconceivable that he does
0:08:52 notice basic things of creed and about
0:08:54 Allah and knowing that Allah meaning he
0:08:58 will account and punish so don't don't
0:09:00 be complacent and also don't give up
0:09:04 there will be always the balance between
0:09:06 fear and Hope
0:09:09 yeah
0:09:10 so this is there's an obligation to know
0:09:13 and to educate everyone about that not
0:09:15 to educate them over to find details of
0:09:17 uh of of uh like uh what hobby standing
0:09:21 on the coast and the entrance so much
0:09:22 you say hi tell me who is Allah
0:09:25 keep pushing the people to be terrified
0:09:28 and confused about these things no
0:09:29 that's another blessed to know I thought
0:09:32 to know the answer of this question it
0:09:33 doesn't make any even that question but
0:09:35 I said but independent of that we are
0:09:37 not obliged to know that and we are not
0:09:39 ordered to to be indigenous
0:09:41 if we indulge because of good reason
0:09:43 that's maybe but it's not the obligation
0:09:45 for everyone who is a Believer or Muslim
0:09:48 next time
0:09:55 no more is that possible
0:09:58 bound to do then deliver the message
0:10:00 entrusted to him and God knows all that
0:10:02 you do openly and all that you would
0:10:04 conceal this translation the messenger
0:10:06 only has a duty to deliver the message
0:10:08 as God knows what you reveal and what
0:10:10 you hide yeah so this is listened lesson
0:10:13 that's clarifying what's important
0:10:15 without the job of the messenger job
0:10:16 with the messenger is is to deliver the
0:10:19 message that's his excellent job and uh
0:10:21 yeah your duty is there is to comply
0:10:24 although and if you fail to comply Allah
0:10:26 knows what to accept
0:10:33 and you will know if you have complied
0:10:36 or not if you have believed or not and
0:10:37 all of these things but also clarify
0:10:39 that that don't think the messenger is
0:10:42 obliged to to go and get you as a head
0:10:45 of state yes you go and collected zakat
0:10:47 because it's a duty of the state to
0:10:48 collect and distribute but pale will not
0:10:51 go and check for you Salah you will not
0:10:53 go check if you are fasting or not it
0:10:54 will tell you half the verse if you
0:10:56 don't fast you are committing a grave
0:10:58 sin or even against sitting after the
0:10:59 holders now that's what he has he's not
0:11:01 going to check that that's for you to do
0:11:03 and for you to comply with but also
0:11:05 shows uh if that's his duty as a
0:11:09 messenger and obviously he will
0:11:11 excluding few of these things at the
0:11:13 head of state then all these theories
0:11:15 that the state has to enforce public
0:11:17 morality the state is the guardian of
0:11:19 the faith or like the title of the king
0:11:21 a queen or the king defender of it all
0:11:24 these nonsense there is no defender of
0:11:26 it Allah a guardian of the book and
0:11:28 every believer has to defend his faith
0:11:31 according to his situation actually it's
0:11:32 not it's not a duty of state and
0:11:34 obligation if it's not the duty of the
0:11:35 messenger or his obligation then it's
0:11:37 not yours
0:11:38 so so that's that's also undermines many
0:11:41 of these uh uh like authoritarian views
0:11:45 of the state we should fight for some
0:11:46 Italian because he followed the
0:11:48 classical View and I'm already and so on
0:11:50 which has nothing to do really how the
0:11:52 state was run at the time
0:11:56 vastly different
0:11:58 but that's what is hinted here and has
0:12:00 it has to build also in that spirit
0:12:08 the other things you attribute to him is
0:12:11 not true
0:12:12 it's not true and if he has the
0:12:13 obligation to broadcast a message and he
0:12:16 did this and these two certain people
0:12:18 and sinful people and didn't do to other
0:12:20 meaning that's all your obligation to
0:12:22 manage that according to what you have
0:12:24 received as a message it's not the
0:12:25 obligation of him and they read he was
0:12:27 fulfilling some of the obligation as a
0:12:29 head of state and was also limited by
0:12:32 his obligations to broadcast a message
0:12:34 so there was a few questions from last
0:12:36 week which kind of came up after this so
0:12:38 on the subject of uh State intervention
0:12:40 yeah you have the concept of
0:12:44 is obviously you've got if you see
0:12:46 something
0:12:47 by your hand if you can't do that then
0:12:50 speak out against it if you can't do
0:12:51 that then patient in your heart that's
0:12:52 the least of them up some people use the
0:12:54 argument of that state is capable the
0:12:58 state is physically capable to do that
0:13:00 that's the first one second question is
0:13:02 this in the example where you said
0:13:04 something could be a Donald Hijra so for
0:13:06 example I'm the narrative around Taliban
0:13:08 let's get the first point first okay the
0:13:11 first point first okay what what is
0:13:13 their argument about that so for example
0:13:16 how does as as a human being I'm in the
0:13:20 state how do I enforce a physical
0:13:22 removal of a monkey if I'm not in a
0:13:24 position of authority it's almost like
0:13:26 it
0:13:28 depends uh the time of the Moon if it is
0:13:30 if it is neat authority to be removed
0:13:33 like for example you are not you're not
0:13:35 you're not even allowed to to implement
0:13:39 that's for the set
0:13:40 and for the judges
0:13:45 as much as possible we have discussed
0:13:47 that sometime that's number one secondly
0:13:50 uh certain monkeys you can stop for
0:13:53 example you see yourself a car stopping
0:13:55 people jumping out couple of guys
0:13:57 jumping out and the driving a woman
0:14:00 inside or a boy for example
0:14:02 or or
0:14:04 repair or write them or maybe extract uh
0:14:08 uh Ransom from his family it looks like
0:14:11 that you see it and you are capable of
0:14:13 stopping them for example by taking a
0:14:15 gun out shoot them or drive your car and
0:14:18 block the way so they are stuck
0:14:24 preventing it from being completed
0:14:26 but the moment is completed and done and
0:14:28 they escaped and so on and then
0:14:30 apprehended and this is for the state
0:14:32 then to do that the administer because
0:14:34 the damage is already done change that
0:14:36 in that case it's Administration is not
0:14:38 changing remarkable people misunderstand
0:14:40 that
0:14:41 it's not it's administering the
0:14:42 punishment
0:14:44 which will be deterring for other people
0:14:46 in the future Etc and all the unsettling
0:14:48 the rights and obligation of various
0:14:49 parties in this situation that's one
0:14:52 example another example is that if you
0:14:56 uh if you have if you see for example a
0:14:59 Muslim having for example a Muslim local
0:15:01 one of the people of the book of having
0:15:03 a bottle of ham
0:15:05 are you able to to unseal the water
0:15:08 bottle and uh and
0:15:10 and
0:15:13 let it go running that ground so empty
0:15:16 the bottle tell them you should not have
0:15:18 that and you should not have wanted that
0:15:20 if you're capable of doing that
0:15:22 that's things like that which you can
0:15:24 preventing him from drinking taking the
0:15:26 glass and throwing the content away but
0:15:29 even think of you without it obviously
0:15:31 whether all the issues or precautions
0:15:33 that you don't go over limited it
0:15:35 doesn't develop into a fight and
0:15:37 bloodshed which is worse than than that
0:15:39 they can come for example
0:15:41 that's it but let me just give you a
0:15:44 general rule hold these eyes in the
0:15:46 Quran about commanding good and favorite
0:15:47 thing evil especially that is
0:15:51 Russia they have the same citizenship
0:15:53 they come out good and probably evil
0:15:55 most of it 99 is actually towards the
0:15:58 state like in our book accounting the
0:16:00 ruler which will is already
0:16:02 clearly in the old Edition but in the
0:16:05 new edition when I improving it as soon
0:16:07 it will become even stunningly clear but
0:16:09 it was already clear in the old one
0:16:11 so this this is the handwaving argument
0:16:13 also one of the hand weapons are going
0:16:15 to find for example like some scholar
0:16:17 said that that the commander good and
0:16:21 for the reading able is the is the is
0:16:23 the is the album the main pole of the
0:16:26 main pillar or pivot of the Dean this is
0:16:29 this is poetry okay let's write a
0:16:30 million and they claim the the messenger
0:16:33 have been sent for commanding good and
0:16:35 preview no this is
0:16:36 defined it was good and and and and and
0:16:39 what what's evil and they were sometimes
0:16:42 barred even from changing it by hand
0:16:44 like and all of these things so this is
0:16:47 such hand-waving arguments and and point
0:16:49 uh poetry like like statements do not
0:16:53 bring us forward legality
0:16:57 is criticism that's definitely available
0:17:00 to everyone because
0:17:02 mostly what should be exercised the
0:17:04 monkey of the rulers that's
0:17:06 commands majority and all that had
0:17:09 almost every even is the famous how you
0:17:12 say actually
0:17:18 about the rulers
0:17:21 not about the individuals
0:17:23 like for example you have a neighbor who
0:17:26 is his drunkard all the time
0:17:28 your your obligation is really to advise
0:17:30 him between you and cover him up not
0:17:32 call the police for him
0:17:34 people don't understand that they think
0:17:36 oh when I have to jump over the wall and
0:17:38 take the company in them and get them
0:17:40 propagation no
0:17:41 that's the opposite of the instructions
0:17:43 because the misunderstanding of being a
0:17:45 common ingredients but this will be some
0:17:48 of these we'll discussed in the book and
0:17:50 it needs more a new reading because it
0:17:52 has been diverted why it has been
0:17:54 diverted from the time uh
0:17:57 um the Mona 13 jumped overpowered like
0:17:59 after that would build a few exceptions
0:18:02 which is good spots in history
0:18:04 they were they were obviously trying to
0:18:07 divert the people from with Rising them
0:18:08 so that everything that people about uh
0:18:10 ran behind those are having a musical
0:18:12 instrument I do that and their policies
0:18:15 full of music as well obviously I run
0:18:16 behind those you think well they have
0:18:18 even my uh alcohol manufacturing their
0:18:21 own houses run behind this so that
0:18:23 people are diverted and getting busy
0:18:24 with each other
0:18:26 part of that is because of this
0:18:27 tradition and the government scholar
0:18:29 doing that to decide the people emotions
0:18:31 against each other I guess not toward
0:18:34 what where they should be in the first
0:18:35 place and for instance being directed
0:18:38 that's how how you can you can twist and
0:18:41 change the meaning of of the Revelation
0:18:43 so that the Revelation becomes becomes
0:18:46 uh self-defeating
0:18:50 yeah so that's concerning this point but
0:18:53 this needs really more because it has
0:18:55 been clouded like for example if the
0:18:57 example uh for example if I uh at that
0:19:01 regret scholar but they said he can't
0:19:02 get out of classical point of view we
0:19:04 discussed uh I think double Thermo
0:19:06 heading in the Far West which supported
0:19:08 oral murability which supported Spain
0:19:11 the Muslim Spain and prevented the
0:19:13 collapse for a few hundred years okay
0:19:14 and say when it was founded it was good
0:19:17 combined with Sharia and things like
0:19:19 that then later on they started
0:19:21 deviating and they have started started
0:19:23 drinking we never addresses how much
0:19:26 even before that there was oppression
0:19:27 and transcription of of rights of the
0:19:30 people and so on it's not in his work
0:19:31 that this is a monkey and it should be
0:19:33 addressed by the people
0:19:35 in in single persons and in an organized
0:19:38 organization because even the idea of
0:19:39 organized command completely slipped out
0:19:42 of the people divide let alone even an
0:19:45 armed Rebellion which have all agreed no
0:19:47 no it's a big No-No because certain
0:19:49 already billions in the past failed it
0:19:53 will be failure and things like that
0:19:56 no theory of I'm the president of any
0:19:58 significance will accept oh this will
0:20:00 lead to fit now stop don't do it
0:20:07 and why it failed what was the mistakes
0:20:10 made at the beginning and middle at the
0:20:12 end
0:20:13 mistakes in Syria interpretation but
0:20:15 they have been and mistakes in in
0:20:17 management and tactics that's good for
0:20:19 knowing history and then for my mistakes
0:20:21 because this management the battlefield
0:20:24 is management I have to establish this
0:20:27 is this battlefield legitimate can I
0:20:29 fight this guy what a reputation of the
0:20:30 fight
0:20:31 is the fight like Against The kofar
0:20:33 Exterminating him completely and and the
0:20:36 finishing of the injured one and
0:20:37 finishing off the the prisoners war or
0:20:39 it is different what are the limits of
0:20:41 that we know the regulation for money
0:20:44 fine but now in the battlefield you have
0:20:47 to manage the tactics when you advance
0:20:48 when to retreat which position to take
0:20:51 take the mountain or take the value of
0:20:53 these things
0:20:54 mistakes happening they know a little
0:20:55 bit nobody studied that because I was
0:20:57 about it
0:20:58 Rebellion is just inviting Fitness stop
0:21:02 it no no no leave it
0:21:06 at most just secretly advise the ruler
0:21:08 or something so nobody knows that the
0:21:10 word that was advised or didn't advice
0:21:12 so the whole issue has been messed up
0:21:14 that's it now the second person about
0:21:17 Taliban
0:21:18 so for example you mentioned that
0:21:32 it doesn't prevent someone from marrying
0:21:35 more than one wife however if a wife
0:21:37 stipulates in her car contract I do not
0:21:39 want you to yeah yeah what has that so
0:21:42 that's an example of something which is
0:21:46 would public order fall into that
0:21:49 category for example you did you
0:21:50 stipulate nearly Allah for a woman is
0:21:52 basically from the navel to her knees or
0:21:54 you know as in the state has to mandate
0:22:09 starting next year this year they will
0:22:12 that's the last year and nobody from now
0:22:15 on should do about about the Holy
0:22:18 sanctuary of the Kaaba when he is naked
0:22:21 and what is naked and so only defined by
0:22:23 and there's a study about that obviously
0:22:25 for men it has to be the severe Aura the
0:22:29 the the the anus and the penis for women
0:22:32 it's a little bit bigger between us
0:22:33 that's that's what has to be and that
0:22:36 this has to be enforced in public life
0:22:37 is because it has been enforced about
0:22:39 anyone who is coming for religious
0:22:41 reason doing it because what do we get
0:22:42 foreign and forcing it against the
0:22:45 general commandment no compulsion
0:22:47 religion meaning it has to be enforce in
0:22:49 a public life disregarding what the
0:22:51 religion of the people that's it
0:22:52 anything else can reinforced so the said
0:22:56 this is what a lot of people want to say
0:22:58 it's kind of difficult to enforce
0:22:59 practically you would never have people
0:23:01 coming in because you'll have a less uh
0:23:03 permissive Society anyway however it was
0:23:05 difficult for so what I was saying is
0:23:06 that if for example tell you about they
0:23:07 are forced for example they are forced
0:23:09 is on the classical way of the scholars
0:23:12 which have been deviated we discussed
0:23:14 earlier
0:23:15 so they can't for example they are they
0:23:19 decided they're just
0:23:20 uh foreign
0:23:29 you cannot put that in law so you cannot
0:23:31 enforce as a state no
0:23:35 no it's not of the character of like for
0:23:37 example the CAR contract where you can
0:23:39 take some an agreement between two
0:23:40 people no this is because there's a
0:23:42 contract and this the general permission
0:23:43 of contractual contraction
0:23:50 does it within the general General
0:23:52 permissibility and and right of
0:23:54 contractual or uh concluding quarter
0:23:57 because the contract and any age party
0:24:00 of the contract can can can
0:24:03 stipulate something in the contract
0:24:05 according which is not violating Syria
0:24:07 for example our wife could simulate that
0:24:10 you don't marry any any another woman
0:24:12 Etc with my permission because you
0:24:14 cannot marry any other way that's it
0:24:15 this is this is an invalid simulation
0:24:18 without my permission must be there
0:24:24 with my permission only with my
0:24:26 permission
0:24:28 for example
0:24:31 I see yeah for the state it's not in in
0:24:35 interfering with the mobile which is
0:24:37 always rights for the people is only if
0:24:40 there is a there's a need for the public
0:24:42 order and so on like for example you
0:24:44 have the right to to drive the streets
0:24:46 with any speed riding your comment but
0:24:49 obviously people are all using the seat
0:24:51 together and the right driving with
0:24:53 certain excessive speeds will and it has
0:24:56 been proven by history and has been seen
0:24:58 clearly will lead to accidents some
0:25:00 people will get pickled in the general
0:25:02 context not all people will be killed
0:25:04 but enough that one is being killed that
0:25:06 would be an accident by certain speed
0:25:08 obviously you're gonna say don't use any
0:25:11 speed at all even with the low slow
0:25:12 speed there will be some vehicle but
0:25:14 there's a necessity in the universe to
0:25:16 take that and on board otherwise there
0:25:18 will be no traffic so what the defining
0:25:20 a limit of speed or defining like the
0:25:23 same when a red signal appears you have
0:25:26 to stop there
0:25:27 although in participant you have the
0:25:29 right to continue but then the others
0:25:31 have also the right to continue and then
0:25:33 we have a Crossing are we going to
0:25:34 manage that then you respect that
0:25:36 because it will experience have shown
0:25:39 that it will be uh it will uh there will
0:25:43 be a in in the in in the big numbers
0:25:46 will be a certainty but for every single
0:25:48 finger you get the probability of an
0:25:50 accident and we want to reduce that and
0:25:52 protect people people's health and as
0:25:55 much as possible
0:25:56 you can't carry for example a gun which
0:25:58 is loaded in a chamber like in time past
0:26:01 people were carrying their hours of
0:26:03 course if you carry your arrows in the
0:26:05 in the market the
0:26:07 bag of the role it has a special name
0:26:10 what's the name of it in the back behind
0:26:12 your back then either you carry the
0:26:15 either you cover the sharp heads either
0:26:18 with your hand temporally if you don't
0:26:20 have or you should have the same black
0:26:21 like a like a like a cover for them
0:26:24 people have something like a small bag
0:26:26 on top of this you can you can analyze
0:26:29 that for for guns or you can carry it
0:26:31 again and say I love but not not
0:26:33 chambered while you are in Marcus and
0:26:35 mixing with people
0:26:37 you chamber it only if you're just about
0:26:39 to shoot for a hunt or something like
0:26:41 that
0:26:42 the state can stipulate that
0:26:46 otherwise it's permissible to carry the
0:26:48 gun with with the firing chamber but
0:26:51 there are incidents clearly in history
0:26:53 and so on there was someone carrying
0:26:55 arrows under his back that he may that
0:26:57 may hit uh an identity that someone
0:27:00 collide with him and get injured in the
0:27:02 arrows and the way to prevent that is to
0:27:05 cover the house the sharp ends of the
0:27:06 arrowsy
0:27:07 yeah that's an example
0:27:10 but we have also complete writing about
0:27:12 about respecting the adoption of the
0:27:15 state
0:27:16 okay so there's more more detail than
0:27:18 that but in principle I understand and
0:27:19 the person I think is cleared so even
0:27:21 though the other thing said actually
0:27:24 they accept people commenting center
0:27:25 with private since and so on the general
0:27:27 perception of the scholars is that the
0:27:29 head of state is the guardian of the
0:27:30 dean and like and the idea is not that's
0:27:33 not his his eyes
0:27:36 and to protect the borders
0:27:39 and collect the taxes and there's a cut
0:27:41 and distribute them rightly uh
0:27:43 reasonably and evenly it is not even
0:27:45 obliged and is
0:27:47 that he will establish School social
0:27:49 available for everyone in that case say
0:27:51 okay but in that case I have an
0:27:53 authority to leave if the other incomes
0:27:56 are not sufficient which is extremely
0:27:58 unlikely but if it's done properly
0:28:00 including the public ownership and so on
0:28:02 of of all the
0:28:04 manual resources but leave that aside
0:28:06 then if you want to let me to be obliged
0:28:10 to have uh obligated schooling and
0:28:13 schooling available for everyone this
0:28:15 must be financed guys so we will have to
0:28:17 add a little bit more taxes for that you
0:28:19 can't escape from that
0:28:20 thus this will be the agreement it's not
0:28:23 giving buyer to check free with aura or
0:28:26 to check what they are doing at home no
0:28:29 if you're given by if someone is
0:28:30 apprehended if someone a four Witnesses
0:28:33 come that they have seen someone
0:28:35 comedical fornication and so the the
0:28:37 real act and goal character gets to the
0:28:39 court then he has to administer the
0:28:41 punishment that's it
0:28:42 it's not that he jumped the walls and
0:28:44 try to to take cameras and uh and and
0:28:47 check for that no actually it will be a
0:28:50 criminal act actually and to introduce a
0:28:51 house like that but this has this has
0:28:54 disappeared from his uh Islamic mind
0:28:59 lastly it didn't go to the extreme but
0:29:02 many of these so-called commands good
0:29:03 and very evil like Saudi Arabia are now
0:29:05 in Afghanistan they even jump walls
0:29:07 sometimes
0:29:08 oh we hear some some maybe maybe there's
0:29:10 some people there or some prostitutes
0:29:12 are fornicating close your ears continue
0:29:15 if they come in the street and they do
0:29:18 the foreign
0:29:29 this way that people look good uh look
0:29:32 at it you'll see here for example most
0:29:33 Muslims here practice Muslim or a Muslim
0:29:36 lady they are having better hijab than
0:29:38 most women in Saudi Arabia for example
0:29:41 despite of all the prosecution and this
0:29:43 nonsense
0:29:44 and even many here are nakabi if you go
0:29:46 for example set certain certain cities
0:29:48 in the North like the one which is the
0:29:50 uh uh the next Halifax was his name
0:29:53 where the tablished
0:29:58 you think you are you you see more than
0:30:02 you see in Karachi
0:30:05 without the state even intervening if
0:30:07 the set may be discouraging
0:30:09 in a subtle way at least nothing but an
0:30:12 influence which is a obviously a
0:30:14 fighting against that
0:30:16 so this will will not get the people to
0:30:18 commit to say but it's just opposite it
0:30:20 will get people you know that's what the
0:30:21 demonstration allegedly because
0:30:24 some people claim it's different it's
0:30:26 another issue anyway
0:30:30 it will it's bound one day to backfire
0:30:39 there's enough for example woman a woman
0:30:41 is a you think she's a Muslim because
0:30:42 the cafe is not obliged at the moment
0:30:44 she is not it's not there is probably
0:30:46 according to thinking just just stand
0:30:49 away from here just tell your sister
0:30:51 you're going to test their time you are
0:30:52 a Muslim that's not a whole Muslim woman
0:30:54 being there anyway give her back don't
0:30:57 intellectually don't buy and sell with
0:30:58 her there'll be enough public pressure
0:31:00 and general morality this way
0:31:04 no need for other state actually coming
0:31:05 with sticks and then and when when when
0:31:08 the cars coming with Saturday and
0:31:10 running to catch someone
0:31:14 but what happened in Iran some people
0:31:15 kill him she banned the hijab publicly
0:31:17 as like like a like public offense that
0:31:20 has to be done obvious thought about
0:31:21 analyzing carefully what what does this
0:31:24 mean is this yes as I said the declaring
0:31:27 war on the Islamic system that will be
0:31:29 an act of War there's something else
0:31:31 or is it just because you say that your
0:31:33 command is not binding for me should not
0:31:35 have been done it's not a duty of set to
0:31:38 interview that may be a point there but
0:31:40 this has to be synchronized by a court
0:31:41 of law
0:31:43 the moment you enter in that area
0:31:45 without actually a justification for the
0:31:47 state act you enter in a devil's kitchen
0:31:49 and you will get yourself a problem
0:31:52 and that's what has happened through
0:31:53 history these mutilated understanding of
0:31:56 the power of the state and extending it
0:31:57 over its model
0:31:59 and not limiting it where it should be
0:32:01 limited has messed up Islamic history
0:32:03 through time until now
0:32:05 and led to slowly and like poison a
0:32:08 steady decline yes the in the first
0:32:11 phase of decline from the peak of the
0:32:13 time of sahaba slowly until the time
0:32:15 when the corazettes came a bit of
0:32:17 recovery happened but it was only a
0:32:18 temporary recovery and the Corazon were
0:32:20 pushed back with difficulties should not
0:32:22 have taken that many 100 years and more
0:32:25 then the decline continued because
0:32:27 there's no real fundamental repair of
0:32:30 the state structure society structure
0:32:32 and then the Mongols came and then
0:32:34 everything the collapse for one or two
0:32:36 centuries until the Earth money
0:32:37 recovered a little bit but there are
0:32:39 more militaristic and more conquered in
0:32:41 Europe and trying to save Spain rather
0:32:43 than doing it and also the protected
0:32:45 obviously Muslim
0:32:47 from the from the Portuguese the the
0:32:50 Portuguese Turkish Wars are massive you
0:32:55 know you don't be landed or school but
0:32:57 the only the the only thing which broke
0:32:59 the back of the Portuguese and the
0:33:01 Spanish when they almost occupied the
0:33:03 elephant process even an army approached
0:33:05 almost near Mecca and they were smashed
0:33:07 just close nearby and hit it and then
0:33:10 their armies and ships were destroyed in
0:33:11 the Red Sea not in what day not in even
0:33:14 one decade it took almost a century and
0:33:17 that they were forced always just to to
0:33:18 go as far away as uh Indian and
0:33:21 Philippine trying to to avoid the
0:33:24 competition with Osman so they did the
0:33:25 great service in this respect but any
0:33:27 renewal really of of intellectual
0:33:30 thoughts or something or no
0:33:33 or any Revival of the meaning of the
0:33:36 state and its limitation no
0:33:39 because everyone run aground the moment
0:33:42 every one accepted that Molly what he's
0:33:44 doing is right and he says
0:33:46 the damage is done there's nothing can
0:33:49 be done about that except to go to
0:33:51 square zero and expose all of that as a
0:33:53 fallacy
0:33:54 and study that I knew which we are doing
0:33:56 in alhamdulillah doing it but we did a
0:33:58 bit of it
0:33:59 okay Does this answer but some of the
0:34:03 questions essentially if there's any
0:34:04 question related to that comes related
0:34:05 to die so the messenger have only the
0:34:07 duty for balance even for Jihad Quran
0:34:09 says clearly
0:34:11 foreign
0:34:21 maybe then Allah will stop the the
0:34:24 strength of the disbeliever and Allah is
0:34:26 more stronger and more more punishing
0:34:29 but that's it
0:34:33 even an episode enforcing that in heaven
0:34:36 when everyone ran away
0:34:39 because they were overwhelmed with the
0:34:41 with the with the enormous salvos of
0:34:44 others said so that the sky almost
0:34:47 became black from the others of horizon
0:34:49 obviously this is a metaphorical
0:34:51 exaggeration now we know that but and
0:34:54 everyone on the set of shock and
0:34:55 everyone ran away almost everyone except
0:34:57 few of them
0:34:59 and few of the House of the Prophet Ali
0:35:02 Abu Sofia
0:35:05 under Abbas and so on holding the camera
0:35:07 also charging against the enemy and
0:35:10 they're holding him back I mean he was
0:35:12 then then yeah like like having a little
0:35:15 like uh like uh it's not a poetry but
0:35:19 it's what they call italages
0:35:25 then the the then Abbas called everyone
0:35:28 back and the people walk up after the
0:35:30 shock and they came back and then um the
0:35:33 mother of Ernest told them is you should
0:35:36 be executing those who run away from you
0:35:38 the person only smiled because she
0:35:40 thinking she's thinking the same
0:35:42 mentality of the Roman and and and and
0:35:45 the Virgin or the mentality even and the
0:35:47 British Empire until the first world war
0:35:49 how many people have been exploited
0:35:51 because they they run away from the
0:35:53 ditches under the hammering of of the
0:35:56 artillery we know it's called shell
0:35:58 shock and then they were executed that
0:36:00 way because of because of uh card is it
0:36:03 called this in front of the enemy
0:36:05 and now the glance sons are still
0:36:08 pursuing issues to get them accelerated
0:36:12 because they could not do anything if
0:36:13 you have just a heavy heavy artillery
0:36:16 bomb menu then most people who lose
0:36:18 their mind they just run
0:36:20 and they got executed for that and with
0:36:22 them
0:36:24 Allah is more sufficient we don't need
0:36:27 that
0:36:30 that's not how a prophet manages the
0:36:32 affairs
0:36:34 foreign
0:36:39 they came back
0:36:41 hollas and even the one where I never
0:36:43 came back
0:36:44 became almost almost
0:36:50 unless he's going to another
0:36:53 company or or taking a refuse to restart
0:36:57 the attack again and he will he will
0:36:59 turn out to the wrath of Allah and he
0:37:01 would end in the Hell Fire
0:37:04 you don't need to have to have a
0:37:07 course martial than shooting them on the
0:37:10 spot like the British army did for
0:37:12 thousands of Shell Shocked poor guys in
0:37:14 in the first World War
0:37:18 it's a different world of thinking
0:37:21 that had disappeared yes there was not
0:37:23 in Islam because of the summer long ago
0:37:25 we would be killed the things that yes
0:37:26 they did not go through that miserable
0:37:28 extreme of the British Empire but it it
0:37:31 was there was nasty things of this type
0:37:34 or list that type of other types
0:37:36 everywhere here and there and so on
0:37:43 but this has to be formulated has to be
0:37:45 fought has to be insulin in the law and
0:37:46 the Constitution it has to be made clear
0:37:51 it was never made clear
0:37:54 because I always have the term of the
0:37:56 power was reserved by starting with
0:37:58 Mojave
0:37:59 nobody bothered before that there were
0:38:01 really Traditions from a worker um
0:38:05 flown away and everything depending upon
0:38:08 the Tyrant decided whatever he wants and
0:38:11 playing games with the people moving
0:38:13 WhatsApp action against another that's
0:38:15 all what Mario was doing in that 20
0:38:16 years
0:38:20 attacking Islam and Muslim from their
0:38:22 back in a sneaky way because he could
0:38:24 not do it up open them publicly but
0:38:25 anyway
0:38:27 I know what he did even he prohibited
0:38:29 people from from reporting a Hadith and
0:38:31 so on and Marazzi
0:38:32 without his permission because he did
0:38:34 not want her because if the people are
0:38:36 reported a Hadith and so on they will
0:38:37 report everything including things
0:38:39 Representatives
0:38:41 undermine his power
0:38:43 hmm
0:38:45 if you see our book system you will see
0:38:46 that translation many of these things
0:38:48 will come soon
0:38:51 that has to be cleaned
0:38:53 from Taliban
0:38:55 high school graduates at best and one or
0:38:59 two chefs who are still living in the
0:39:01 7th century
0:39:03 I served in Islamic Century like 1814
0:39:07 that the bottom of Islamic thought when
0:39:09 everything follows and then we can
0:39:10 become calcified that's right
0:39:13 for example the one who regard them as
0:39:15 the Allama and the Chief Justice
0:39:17 may be a great fighter and great mujahid
0:39:20 but if you he has tweets I think he has
0:39:23 a tweet accounting and tweeting and
0:39:24 obviously he's formula that's reason
0:39:25 give it to someone true I don't think
0:39:27 he's even know how to manage a Twitter
0:39:28 but anyway independent that he is doing
0:39:30 it by himself for someone and the and
0:39:33 there's a list of just called Jewels
0:39:35 okay from the jewels I counted about 40
0:39:38 or 50 Jewels 30 of them about three
0:39:41 Mexicans
0:39:42 this is a jewels
0:39:46 so what to expect
0:39:49 yeah 10 minutes
0:39:52 it's good that they click the American
0:39:53 but I'll get them out and clean the
0:39:56 country from the more successes and
0:39:58 still actually because the hanafi
0:40:00 background they're not like a hobby
0:40:01 branded they're much better for example
0:40:04 demonstrations hormones are being
0:40:06 managed reasonably the the claim that
0:40:08 they have been beaten women Devastation
0:40:10 has to prove it to be false is always
0:40:12 time for vacation they protected the
0:40:14 demonstrating woman and guard them and
0:40:16 go along with them
0:40:30 Etc
0:40:32 but it's a process that can be done they
0:40:36 cannot be taken as a model for the how
0:40:38 the Islamic State should be run in the
0:40:39 idiot situation
0:40:42 okay
0:40:43 any other very many question in that
0:40:45 issue so we can finish it
0:40:47 no one's mentioned anything yeah that's
0:40:49 it so the messenger is obliged only for
0:40:52 broadcasting the message not even
0:40:54 protecting a message
0:40:55 protected
0:41:05 protection Is this different obviously
0:41:07 if it's time than the protection of the
0:41:08 Sunnah but that's what we know until
0:41:12 he is not
0:41:15 definitely certainly not
0:41:18 when a man told him you are unjust
0:41:21 This Man became Buddhism
0:41:26 don't touch him
0:41:30 people will tell you what no this is not
0:41:31 particular benefits no
0:41:35 God that's not that's not not neither
0:41:37 neither and his authorities Head of
0:41:38 State Northern over there
0:41:42 and he committed on that man say there
0:41:43 will be people like that with this type
0:41:45 of table not understanding the Quran not
0:41:47 digesting it properly when they come out
0:41:50 exterminate them when they come out what
0:41:53 a minute come out
0:41:54 with force with the sword when they
0:41:56 fight for that then they will be
0:41:58 extremitted before that no
0:42:06 but this has to be read again and
0:42:07 analyzed differently but we are doing a
0:42:09 bit of that inshallah
0:42:11 okay next area
0:42:13 I think we I did enough in this point
0:42:16 so when the messenger side only
0:42:18 obligation of broadcasting let me see
0:42:19 nothing else
0:42:22 and when he became a head of state it
0:42:24 became by the way now to cause is the
0:42:27 messenger
0:42:28 because of Baya
0:42:31 doesn't make a bit of State
0:42:34 evidence for that abound in the Quran
0:42:36 soon
0:42:39 finally editing that's number one
0:42:41 secondly in the Surah the Montana when
0:42:44 the believing women are migrating to
0:42:46 Medina their believer gonna say they
0:42:48 believe that they believe in him as a
0:42:49 messenger
0:42:50 and they became and you may give him
0:42:52 what or dancing in a dance club no but I
0:42:56 had to become citizen if they become
0:42:58 citizen they have to obey him as a head
0:42:59 of state how would you know it is that
0:43:02 the bear is not on Islam because they
0:43:03 are already believable
0:43:05 in Makkah which has been cutting the
0:43:07 dawah because now we have a state that
0:43:10 the state is carrying that our
0:43:11 instruction way and every Muslim so the
0:43:14 bias is what is about being a citizen of
0:43:17 the state and obeying in the commands
0:43:35 like for example after they give the guy
0:43:38 I become citizen he may say you uh for
0:43:42 example you are very skilled in in in
0:43:44 treating uh treating sick people and so
0:43:47 on and you have your mother in your
0:43:49 house and so on other family can take
0:43:51 care of kids in the next battle campaign
0:43:53 I'm I'm ordering you to join us as a
0:43:56 nurse
0:43:58 you you'll not be for your husband your
0:44:00 husband can can endure for a few days
0:44:02 without you number one or he has another
0:44:03 wife your mother and your auntie is
0:44:05 available to attend to the kids in your
0:44:07 absence so it is not a burden for you
0:44:09 excessively so it's my roof is
0:44:11 reasonable and you have the skills you
0:44:12 have to comment about it I hope then you
0:44:15 have to obey because you give Bayer to
0:44:16 obey him as a head of state
0:44:20 yeah
0:44:22 last minute I've seen like a few model
0:44:24 and evening
0:44:29 but the formulation is so that it
0:44:31 applies to any head of state the
0:44:33 formation is universal for the messenger
0:44:36 he will never
0:44:38 ask if you think excessive or not
0:44:40 tomorrow because it's infallible but
0:44:42 other Rich may ask and then if it is not
0:44:44 roof you can't for example they say come
0:44:47 everyone with this agents on like the
0:44:49 Putin doing General mobilization has to
0:44:52 join the Army
0:44:53 you could say so no I'm not going to
0:44:55 obey because my parents are old and they
0:44:57 need me to attend to them I must be
0:44:59 excluded
0:45:01 your order is not proper should have
0:45:03 been structured in other way
0:45:05 nah
0:45:07 but otherwise
0:45:08 if he's really limited State and scoring
0:45:10 foreign
0:45:42 what's going on
0:45:44 so because you have distributed pieces
0:45:46 of clothes there's another story and
0:45:49 everyone before us got a piece of cloth
0:45:51 that's fine
0:45:53 but apparently you have you have a dress
0:45:57 which is made out of two pieces
0:45:59 I gave everyone three meters you tell if
0:46:01 2.56 meters that's not acceptable
0:46:05 and that was
0:46:09 saying you know my father is shoulders
0:46:12 is a tall man very well but his his
0:46:16 piece of cloth is not enough to make a
0:46:18 reasonable dress so he took my I took
0:46:21 Abdullah I was confiscated
0:46:24 heals his fatherly power and his armor
0:46:27 was very good intimidating Abdullah and
0:46:29 and playing his psychology and soft's
0:46:31 heart and took that I didn't say that in
0:46:34 this occasion but another occasion we
0:46:35 know he was using that
0:46:37 and then I said now we obey Anderson
0:46:41 in my roof
0:46:43 so this way so he doesn't become a head
0:46:45 state by causing the messenger
0:46:47 so the claim of the Shia that Imam of
0:46:49 the atmosphere of a Divine appointment
0:46:50 is fundamentally faulty because the
0:46:53 messenger himself was not head of state
0:46:55 and Iran is a meaning of a head of state
0:46:57 by uh by except by Bayer not by by being
0:47:01 a prophet not by Divine appointment but
0:47:03 people appointment
0:47:05 even there's a very significant Health
0:47:07 investing Hadith we show that Ali was
0:47:09 right believing that he's the most
0:47:10 qualified for hilafa the Hadith says the
0:47:12 messenger says
0:47:21 what happens after him then you will
0:47:24 find him he's weak in his body but
0:47:25 strong in his faith and having no
0:47:28 interest
0:47:29 okay
0:47:33 you will find him very tough
0:47:36 has ordered and he don't fear any blame
0:47:39 of the blame he is very rough and very
0:47:40 harsh
0:47:47 know the social issues related to Ali
0:47:51 and so on and how much hate and many
0:47:53 factions about him because he killed
0:47:54 massively and their fathers and
0:47:57 grandfathers and people are human beings
0:47:58 even the one who became believer some of
0:48:01 them
0:48:02 but even the believer it still hates you
0:48:06 that this man killed my uncle my
0:48:07 grandfather and so on and decapitates so
0:48:09 many people it's very it's still here
0:48:11 you're not a human being you can't just
0:48:13 separate from all these feelings
0:48:22 guided properly and guiding properly and
0:48:25 carrying on the right path so he's more
0:48:27 qualified to do that job in that sense
0:48:29 and still the messenger said but what my
0:48:32 evidence is not this is
0:48:36 Omar he is not appointing anybody for
0:48:39 God's sake
0:48:41 because he himself was not was appointed
0:48:43 by the people so he's addressing the
0:48:45 people who have the power to appoint the
0:48:46 head of state and the Amelia
0:48:51 so even that's by the point of the
0:48:52 people and the appointment happens in
0:48:54 that time in the Bible even by shaking
0:48:57 hand people number small and so on or at
0:49:00 least the people in the central uh
0:49:02 facility or the people representing them
0:49:04 like either by a natural situation like
0:49:07 the Cyber Queen and badri were
0:49:09 representing the rest of the Muslim a
0:49:11 later on obviously it should be done by
0:49:13 election because nobody is better than
0:49:14 anybody and everyone is equal to anybody
0:49:16 and the best procedure will be election
0:49:18 and so on but there's procedure issues
0:49:20 it's not really but
0:49:22 if you appoint if you appoint if you
0:49:24 appoint
0:49:24 because he himself was appointed by the
0:49:26 people
0:49:28 and also in sahiba we discuss that issue
0:49:32 so the whole vision of the states is
0:49:34 this this
0:49:35 is fundamentally faulty fundamentally
0:49:39 wrong
0:49:41 but it stuck so deep that no nobody
0:49:44 there's even thinking about it I think
0:49:47 it's natural and they added even instead
0:49:49 of injury making him even the defender
0:49:52 of the fifth most likely they are they
0:49:55 imported that from the Jews and
0:49:56 Christian
0:49:57 what's it
0:49:59 but it's it's going to happen it's a
0:50:02 famous artist you will follow the the
0:50:04 sun no the
0:50:06 the way of life of the previous people
0:50:09 even if they go into Elizabeth Hall
0:50:11 you'll go to elect them because this is
0:50:12 like a normal history this is both a
0:50:15 warning and statement of fact
0:50:20 meaning don't do that although he knows
0:50:23 it will happen because
0:50:24 capabilities and so on and every
0:50:27 Revolution Will usually having a
0:50:28 counter-revolution people have
0:50:30 difficulty complying with such a high
0:50:32 she massive change historic break of
0:50:35 history complete break of History which
0:50:37 Islam wrote It's a complete break of
0:50:39 History
0:50:40 previous complete break
0:50:44 you will have difficulty enduring with
0:50:45 that and they endured in the case of
0:50:47 Islam massively
0:50:50 don't understand 30 years after project
0:50:52 until I tell Ali was assassinated and as
0:50:55 an abdicated uh that is the 30 years
0:50:58 equal 300 years by other nations because
0:51:01 in this 30 years Islam expanded almost
0:51:02 covering these two continents and
0:51:05 reaching Europe
0:51:09 50 60 100 000 people we ended with 40 50
0:51:13 million so we need to educate it need to
0:51:15 be taken Abode need to be polished and
0:51:16 this cannot be done in 30 years
0:51:19 but what is with the Islam and Islamic
0:51:21 state has achieved achieved in that is
0:51:23 enormous
0:51:24 this completely by the way the side is
0:51:27 the maximum side of the Islamic State
0:51:29 was rich in in the terms of Harbor not
0:51:31 in Temple of Mayas you may hear their
0:51:33 fake stories and so no there is
0:51:38 you don't read in the history book that
0:51:40 you think they stand by you know
0:51:43 and reached all Afghanistan was taken
0:51:46 over by that time and all the way to the
0:51:48 border of the Turkish areas because the
0:51:50 whole Persian Empire was absorbed
0:51:52 completely and stopped only where there
0:51:54 is no no situation of war was there like
0:51:57 with India and China and other Turks
0:52:00 and uh I'll be seen and so on
0:52:03 only the Roman and the Persian and there
0:52:05 are vassals and there are Nexus whatever
0:52:06 are you completely destroyed like the
0:52:08 Persian or seized and squeezed out or
0:52:11 for the Romans up to the European limit
0:52:15 so that's that was the situation this is
0:52:17 an achievement which done in 30 years
0:52:18 the United States of America did not
0:52:20 reach its current size except after
0:52:22 almost 200 years
0:52:25 Hawaii is just showing now oh okay let's
0:52:27 see how is your certain appendix and
0:52:29 this mode they started with 13 states
0:52:32 and they did not reach uh any
0:52:34 significant number of states which made
0:52:36 them really a real power until the first
0:52:37 world war at least a century has gone
0:52:40 for that plus century plus
0:52:43 slow progress and so on
0:52:45 and still they didn't absorb the
0:52:47 democracy and probably capitalists and
0:52:50 so on did the counter-revolution
0:52:51 hijacked the currency exactly but that's
0:52:54 not our discussion of History some
0:52:55 people say oh Islam was only Islamic
0:52:58 State was not successful only 30 years
0:52:59 no
0:53:00 30 years has to be scaled a matter of
0:53:03 the expansion of the state but human
0:53:04 beings cannot be skilled they are
0:53:06 lethargic they are slow and the human
0:53:08 generation is the same at that time it's
0:53:10 it's 30 40 years you have several
0:53:12 Generations until the people are tuned
0:53:14 unfortunately until the people attuned
0:53:16 to Islam or they did a central Authority
0:53:18 was corrupted and become Muslim in
0:53:21 Africa and they diverted people into
0:53:24 ibadata and so on symbolism and so on
0:53:27 and the genuine thing is related to
0:53:29 State and Society have been neglected
0:53:32 because it's already interested of the
0:53:33 rulers I started with Mojave he started
0:53:36 instigating confrontation between tribes
0:53:39 starting bribing by giving money to to
0:53:42 avoid certain points it will insult for
0:53:46 themselves
0:53:50 they they asked when there was some
0:53:52 conflict between his son yazid and some
0:53:54 Ansari
0:53:56 and then they asked someone from from
0:53:58 buddy who is I think a Muslim
0:54:04 this is impossible nobody can do that to
0:54:06 have you lost mine but there is one
0:54:08 young Christian boy called he doesn't
0:54:11 care just give him good money he will do
0:54:14 it and he started doing and he's famous
0:54:15 for her boyfriend instantly down south
0:54:17 and behalf of Mario and yazid or what
0:54:19 have the amount of time to do nothing he
0:54:22 comes from the far north of the Iraq and
0:54:24 Syria nothing to do with the outside of
0:54:26 Medina and for the money coming from and
0:54:29 so on and the instigating conflict
0:54:30 between the yemeni and the uh Northern
0:54:34 Arabia and the north Arabian between
0:54:35 Karachi and between Arabia Arabia so
0:54:39 authenticated by Mario and his cronies
0:54:43 instead of establishing public peace and
0:54:45 managing the tribes and bringing
0:54:47 everyone together
0:54:50 putting the ummah together to become
0:54:52 more really a unified Society they have
0:54:55 splitter because as a tyrant you need to
0:54:58 split the society tool play factions
0:55:02 this factions do this against you on the
0:55:04 next day this one is with you inside
0:55:05 against you
0:55:06 so you can play the faction and Wing
0:55:08 fights yeah that's what talents do
0:55:10 anyway I'm not going to Western history
0:55:13 that this is we will hold us back from
0:55:16 continuity but this is what has happened
0:55:17 historically
0:55:19 and that's accommodated and when the
0:55:21 major books have written like
0:55:23 which is essentially the reference
0:55:27 because he's the one who developed some
0:55:29 reasonable theory in the 50s of the last
0:55:31 century Muslim Brotherhood didn't have
0:55:33 they are just amorphous statement and
0:55:35 they don't know what they are saying
0:55:36 let's face
0:55:38 let's face it they they they they don't
0:55:41 know what they are saying and they have
0:55:42 no clear picture of they said even they
0:55:43 they think monarchies are permissible
0:55:45 they don't know even what the meaning of
0:55:47 being a head of state or whatever who
0:55:49 appoints who who has the ultimate
0:55:50 Authority in in in on Earth versus the
0:55:53 people
0:55:54 not a king not anybody not even the
0:55:57 authority not even the prophet he has
0:55:59 already the prophetic office
0:56:03 that's the reason it's important to what
0:56:05 we complete these things with with the
0:56:08 uh with sativa on the previous
0:56:11 and then few other things will be added
0:56:13 to that to make a picture different
0:56:16 but until the people observe that and
0:56:18 comply with it as well with the
0:56:19 extraordinator to read that and
0:56:21 understand it anytime soon it will take
0:56:23 some time
0:56:25 okay
0:56:26 so next item so this is the messenger
0:56:28 has only the obligation of broadcasting
0:56:30 is not he's not appointed to to be a
0:56:33 head of state the people appointed him
0:56:34 by Bayer because we obviously that by
0:56:37 default is the most suitable and most
0:56:39 reasonable man for that situation and as
0:56:42 you check myself emergency there were
0:56:45 heads of state before before the before
0:56:47 the Islamic Federation would established
0:56:49 and the Confederation with the Jews now
0:56:52 you see how the real developed
0:56:53 historically and correctly secondly the
0:56:57 the the the the the the protection of
0:57:01 the liquidity
0:57:03 Muslim has to protect his own Deen and
0:57:06 the defending Us by educating himself on
0:57:08 knowing how to argue with Islam and the
0:57:10 the future that that's that's it the
0:57:12 only thing which I get to them to
0:57:14 protect
0:57:15 in that sense and protect his his belief
0:57:18 by by educating himself about Islam
0:57:20 properly and and cleaning his head from
0:57:22 from
0:57:24 not by by pursuing someone who is who is
0:57:28 bearing a Quran or someone who is the
0:57:30 dropping hijab if it
0:57:33 Islamic State that's initial Act of War
0:57:36 that's something else anything else is
0:57:38 not hard
0:57:39 Allah is protecting that in Allah is the
0:57:41 one who who revealed the Dicker and his
0:57:43 heart and he's protecting it from being
0:57:45 lost and protecting it and will bring
0:57:47 people who will if people fail to do the
0:57:50 his bedding he will get
0:57:52 he will get other people and a
0:57:54 generation to to carry the message
0:57:56 and so on
0:58:00 next Ayah Allah
0:58:08 foreign
0:58:12 let's start it 30 seconds
0:58:19 say there is no comparison between the
0:58:21 bad things and the good things even
0:58:22 though very many of the bad things may
0:58:24 plead the greatly but then
0:58:26 be then conscious of God and all you who
0:58:29 are endowed with Insight so that you
0:58:31 might attain to a happy state next
0:58:33 translation
0:58:34 take profit the Bad and the good are not
0:58:36 equal even though many of the bad things
0:58:38 may greatly please you people of
0:58:40 understanding people mind mindful of God
0:58:42 so that you may prosper
0:58:44 so actually you said what's the second
0:58:47 session about the bad things to say if
0:58:49 the the the size of the Habit that has
0:58:52 been plenty of that's plenty like for
0:58:54 example that most likely came related to
0:58:57 a simple incident that some people when
0:58:59 they would bring sodaka instead of being
0:59:01 for example they bring
0:59:03 a bunch of dates and they take a bunch
0:59:07 which is not that good but a big bunch
0:59:09 is not good the low class day at all
0:59:11 they did not mature yet and so on and
0:59:13 hang it in the in the in the Masjid so
0:59:15 that the people poor people can take
0:59:17 everyone take whatever it needs at least
0:59:19 from it directly or take a bit home
0:59:21 and then they were they were choosing
0:59:24 the the bunches which are the low low
0:59:26 class and they were admonish no you
0:59:29 should you should not
0:59:30 obliged to shoot the highest and the
0:59:32 best
0:59:33 go to the reasonable method and also
0:59:35 instructed his his tax collector he's
0:59:39 the cat collector avoid the the noble
0:59:42 and the most precious of their of their
0:59:43 wealth when you go and for example and
0:59:46 someone is having so many comments that
0:59:48 one one camel is due we don't go to the
0:59:51 best camel he has and take it
0:59:54 and not to the West
0:59:56 take a reasonable and middle one an
0:59:58 average one
1:00:00 be reasonable exactly here the same fuel
1:00:04 then so so don't don't think that's a
1:00:07 that the bad things and the evil things
1:00:09 are equal to the good things even if the
1:00:11 bad things are so numerals and plenty
1:00:13 like a huge Bunch like this is the most
1:00:16 simple simple-minded
1:00:18 materialistic example but it is this
1:00:21 place displays the idea
1:00:24 then like for example we can give it for
1:00:27 the writing many people write for
1:00:28 example many many articles and books and
1:00:30 so on and uh there's nothing but slow
1:00:34 class nothing there just negotiating
1:00:36 what other people said and repeating it
1:00:38 and so on and not adding anything really
1:00:39 to knowledge and they may have plenty of
1:00:41 writing
1:00:42 volumes
1:00:44 and someone else's maybe having few
1:00:46 writings but these are having really
1:00:47 some hard work and there's some
1:00:49 referencing some floral research so
1:00:52 don't be impressed by this essay I have
1:00:53 100 Publications someone have only three
1:00:56 don't be impressed by that if this
1:00:58 application are low class
1:01:00 or possibly outright evil like bad or
1:01:03 confusing if you like for example you
1:01:05 have find so many small pamphlets and
1:01:07 books as well publicized by by madhali
1:01:09 which all has only one purpose making
1:01:12 the people slaves to the rulers
1:01:15 you're an easy you have it everywhere
1:01:17 tons of books and factors a huge amount
1:01:22 why the one critical to the rulers who
1:01:24 educate the people what's the limitation
1:01:25 where it is we have very few writings
1:01:28 and these are barely available and you
1:01:30 cannot print them anywhere
1:01:32 most likely because it will be will be
1:01:34 taken out of the market and burned out
1:01:36 Etc and even if it's available to
1:01:38 internet the people are too easy to
1:01:39 download them like what we are doing for
1:01:41 example we're not talking with that
1:01:42 plays like ourselves but I think this is
1:01:44 a reality anyone who looks carefully
1:01:46 would see that and we have only few we
1:01:48 have a few books we don't have the
1:01:49 handles volumes
1:01:52 and the collection of the Fatal 1sd and
1:01:55 so on which is full of of evil
1:01:58 statements and and and mistakes that
1:02:00 blend us
1:02:02 and they distributed to give them their
1:02:04 color whatever we are doing we have a
1:02:06 massive publication we are covering all
1:02:08 these salary points of view and so on
1:02:10 educating a reality it is it would have
1:02:13 been better that this was not publicized
1:02:15 and
1:02:16 don't be impressed by the way by the
1:02:18 volume
1:02:19 if it is if the quality is low yes
1:02:23 the the the low quality will never be
1:02:27 equal to the high quality even if the
1:02:29 even if the low quality is is is having
1:02:32 a huge quantity yeah it will never be
1:02:35 equal don't be fooled by the quantity
1:02:37 uh this is a good translation looked at
1:02:41 quality don't look at quantity
1:02:44 ever
1:02:46 cautious of Allah obviously addressing
1:02:49 the people who are in the case of these
1:02:51 Bunches of dates and so on but a general
1:02:53 be conscious of Allah because if you if
1:02:55 you don't
1:02:56 if we don't stick to that fundamental
1:02:59 principle that quality has to be known
1:03:00 you will classify things according not
1:03:03 quantity
1:03:05 but quantity with quality accent and the
1:03:08 letters will be great but quantity and
1:03:10 fair in disregard and even a discount of
1:03:13 quality is not acceptable and for that
1:03:16 to be like a general principle the way
1:03:18 you evaluate things you have to be
1:03:20 conscious of Allah
1:03:22 and who I'll address with that the
1:03:23 people who have Insight the people who
1:03:25 have mind
1:03:26 is that we will have a core
1:03:29 you have you have a well-balanced
1:03:31 internal inside and mind that's all so
1:03:34 that you may Prosper that you may
1:03:36 succeed because if you don't do that
1:03:38 this the probability are very small that
1:03:40 you succeed
1:03:42 because you will be fooled with the with
1:03:44 the low class because it's numerous
1:03:46 and then low class of the local and
1:03:49 solar you will sink in a low class
1:03:55 foreign
1:03:56 Ty
1:04:02 quantity is minus especially quantity
1:04:05 with low quality should be should not be
1:04:07 admired and should be Forsaken and
1:04:09 forgotten and remember that Allahu
1:04:11 that's what he wants from you if you and
1:04:13 you should have inside a deep inside and
1:04:15 the reality that will show you that
1:04:17 that's the right way to go
1:04:21 and then
1:04:23 related maybe would will there and
1:04:25 discuss the issue of basic performance
1:04:26 ability is the Ayah which has also
1:04:29 discussed in casual basically yeah
1:04:38 foreign
1:04:42 Music
1:04:51 might cause you hardship but if you
1:04:54 should ask about them while the Quran is
1:04:55 being revealed they might indeed be
1:04:57 manifest to you as laws
1:04:59 God has abloved you from any obligation
1:05:01 in this respect God is much forgiving
1:05:03 for Mary next translation believers do
1:05:06 not ask about matters that would trouble
1:05:07 you if you disclose if disclosed to you
1:05:10 but if you ask about them while the
1:05:12 Quran is being revealed they will be
1:05:14 made known to you God has absolved you
1:05:16 from any obligation in this respect God
1:05:19 is most forgiving and long-suffering so
1:05:21 so as long as I think about the correct
1:05:24 translation you know I said
1:05:27 translated with forbearing which is
1:05:29 wrong I think the main the main meaning
1:05:31 is mindful
1:05:34 something more comprehensive than
1:05:36 rational
1:05:39 mindful aware about fully aware for the
1:05:42 conscious and aware of all all
1:05:44 contingencies all necessities
1:05:48 because this here this fits also here
1:05:50 better than the RAV4 or 4 is forgiving
1:05:52 okay he will forgive you neutralization
1:05:54 and your limitation and your desire to
1:05:56 ask questions but it was usually but
1:05:58 also this is because he's
1:06:00 mindful of all repercussion things
1:06:03 related to that has nothing to do with
1:06:04 forbearing it for being would be good
1:06:07 but therefore will cover that
1:06:10 the 14th century is is is as good as a
1:06:13 better than forbearing but haleem will
1:06:15 be of the mindfulness for the Elijah
1:06:17 fully mindful so you see that one
1:06:19 translator is making it only cause any
1:06:21 laws the first one second one make it so
1:06:23 things which maybe uh I don't know what
1:06:25 what he said he just thinks
1:06:27 and actually discover both so the first
1:06:30 translator is uh is is is trying to
1:06:33 enforce the principles we have
1:06:34 established in book of the heat yes by
1:06:37 translating it in a hurry in the
1:06:39 direction but it's not warranted because
1:06:40 there's no way talking about her but
1:06:42 Allah says don't ask about things
1:06:44 whichever exposed to you it will be
1:06:47 displeasing you
1:06:50 and if you ask it about in time when the
1:06:52 Quran is being revealed it may be I
1:06:54 would most likely will be exposed to you
1:06:56 Allah has
1:06:58 turned away from them has decided to
1:07:00 forgive that and not not address it
1:07:02 Allah decided to make up not address it
1:07:06 it's our decision no trouble
1:07:08 and Allah has forgiven most forgiveness
1:07:12 most Mindful and knowledgeable but
1:07:15 comprehensively aware and knowledgeable
1:07:17 and there are what these things be there
1:07:19 are two types
1:07:21 in our distinction to his claimed this
1:07:24 is only that's like for example the man
1:07:25 who asked who is my father
1:07:27 but the reason for this is that one day
1:07:30 there were people asking
1:07:33 too many questions
1:07:34 things are what rape thinks about this
1:07:36 it's a to deliver that
1:07:38 the Habit that anyone coming from Medina
1:07:41 for immigration for uh for uh giving
1:07:44 Bayer
1:07:45 in Dubai I said that they don't ask
1:07:47 anything do not ask
1:07:52 unless we have the Hadith over this if
1:07:54 you go back to it's available with the
1:07:55 volume which is in the
1:07:57 usually available in Amazon
1:08:00 and we have the PDF available for free
1:08:02 for the stingy or the poor ones as I
1:08:04 said but that's available and you have
1:08:08 it I think and you have that income
1:08:09 everything there anyway
1:08:12 and notice of surrounding one has said
1:08:14 that I stayed in Medina one year
1:08:17 this is very interesting
1:08:19 without not immigrating because you
1:08:22 cannot immigrate until you make by all
1:08:25 that you don't ask about any so I'll ask
1:08:26 about everything because I wasn't
1:08:28 America I was not sitting on by the
1:08:29 Universe I can't ask questions anybody
1:08:32 you're gonna say you obliged yourself no
1:08:34 no he cannot so he'd use this he thinks
1:08:36 a little boy it's not a local this is
1:08:38 the that's that's the the way the states
1:08:40 Islam's structures
1:08:42 and after then at the end he was asked
1:08:45 about about uh
1:08:48 evil and and virtue what's it
1:08:51 ultimately that's final question that's
1:08:53 how this is famous Hardy anyway let's
1:08:55 ask your heart Etc leave that part of
1:08:57 that if that's not our concern today
1:08:59 but let us go to
1:09:02 uh the the point there there are various
1:09:05 points first of all it was part of the
1:09:06 way out to stop the viewers from because
1:09:08 they said oh this is a messenger we can
1:09:09 ask about things maybe maybe my great
1:09:12 grandfather lost a bag of gold somewhere
1:09:14 in the mountain can you tell me where it
1:09:16 is well things like that stupid things
1:09:17 like that
1:09:20 Etc
1:09:21 but also people have asked about things
1:09:23 Haram and house things which I know
1:09:24 Revelation has come ignoring the basic
1:09:27 now we come to the basically so they
1:09:30 were prohibited that so all of that is
1:09:31 covered the first translation cover only
1:09:34 the issues of law the other ones so the
1:09:37 person was in one day stood was good the
1:09:39 people were complaining we're not
1:09:40 allowed to ask their people are just
1:09:42 never stop asking and most of the
1:09:45 question asking are just stupid like for
1:09:47 example some of them are not really
1:09:49 needed like for example famous classical
1:09:51 example is when Israel when they are
1:09:53 most of them
1:09:55 you have to slow that account what has
1:09:57 the card to do with that well someone
1:09:59 was killed who are trying to find the
1:10:00 killer why the cow has to do that so
1:10:02 instead of respecting that and he
1:10:04 doesn't say I ordered you say Allah
1:10:05 order you to slow
1:10:08 they say are you making a joke with us
1:10:09 are you are you joking I'm sure that
1:10:11 they they have no respect to their
1:10:13 Messengers
1:10:14 Musa is not an idiot he knows that we
1:10:16 are now checking the this dead so we
1:10:18 just compile the command get a calendar
1:10:21 and also was upset and he said
1:10:24 confusion Allah that I I I'm from the
1:10:26 ignorance to make a joke about that we
1:10:28 are sitting in a in a court low too far
1:10:30 on an investigating uh investigating who
1:10:33 killed this guy whose body is in front
1:10:36 of us
1:10:37 and Allah revealed to me
1:10:39 and you I come with such a stupid
1:10:42 counter question and then after that
1:10:44 said oh okay but if Allah has ordered a
1:10:46 cow it must be some significant special
1:10:48 cow
1:10:50 and Allah said slaughter a cow
1:10:53 so you know everything and they kept
1:10:56 digging deeper and deeper until the only
1:10:58 cow in the universe which fulfilled that
1:11:00 was some a cow by a young Israeli who
1:11:05 ordered its weight in gold and became a
1:11:07 millionaire this way
1:11:15 this kind of stupid question which got
1:11:17 them so
1:11:20 ask Lord to explain with the worst type
1:11:23 of account which is which that which
1:11:25 color
1:11:26 until they got themselves in the corner
1:11:29 that's obviously about legislation but
1:11:31 the specifically Jesus a specific thing
1:11:34 specifically
1:11:37 the same what we were asking about uh
1:11:39 that is it so from that we did use
1:11:42 another Hadith not only that obviously
1:11:43 and other evidence is that the basic
1:11:46 ruining is it I mean I will tell you
1:11:48 what Salama has just whatever whatever
1:11:51 you do whatever contract do I will tell
1:11:54 you don't worry I will be apt I'm not
1:11:56 going I'm you don't need to come to ask
1:11:58 me I'll preempt you and the Quran is
1:12:00 there already told you it's Haram until
1:12:02 that moment of Revelation and then just
1:12:04 do whatever you think all your Action
1:12:06 News is
1:12:08 that's the correct meaning of that but
1:12:10 but the incident is the prophet answered
1:12:12 people were obviously complaining and
1:12:14 and and and moaning
1:12:18 Etc and one day he said obviously they
1:12:20 were they were asking and trying I tried
1:12:22 all kinds of texts Etc like for example
1:12:25 one of the tricks is that they they they
1:12:27 they wait for between coming to Medina
1:12:30 and even sometimes they bribe him give
1:12:31 him that we give you we'll give you a
1:12:33 new dress we give you uh so and so much
1:12:36 uh dates and so on and go and discuss
1:12:38 the profitable at this point because we
1:12:40 are not allowed to ask
1:12:45 get the price it went through that XT
1:12:47 because they they refused to use their
1:12:49 mind and use the general principle if
1:12:51 someone tells you the sahaba we're like
1:12:53 Angel the moment they meet up of it they
1:12:55 grow wings and fly in heaven he's like
1:12:56 it's not true some of them were
1:12:59 and this the the story of David when
1:13:01 they gave him give him a bribe it's
1:13:03 called bribe it's not a bribe really
1:13:04 it's like if you do that for me I would
1:13:07 give you I will give you uh uh I'll give
1:13:10 you a gift or something I'll compensate
1:13:11 it's a composition it's not a bribe
1:13:14 um I think the question was that I don't
1:13:17 remember now it's exactly I think it's
1:13:18 something about Hajj is written every
1:13:19 year or not every year or something like
1:13:21 that
1:13:32 just stupid question which would just
1:13:34 make any sense anyway so it was the stud
1:13:36 said
1:13:37 okay today I'm going to answer any
1:13:40 question you want he was quite angry
1:13:43 and other people started asking various
1:13:45 things mostly private things like one
1:13:47 one man stood and say who is my father
1:13:49 because people claiming that he is not
1:13:52 the son of the man to whom he is usually
1:13:54 attributed and also says so and so on
1:13:57 his real fan and his mother rebuked him
1:13:58 who went home say
1:14:00 how can you be certain that maybe before
1:14:02 Islam because it's born before Islam is
1:14:04 a man now what Islam that I committed
1:14:07 something with the people who are doing
1:14:08 in jahlia and they are not the son of
1:14:09 your father
1:14:11 what Peter you would have scandalized me
1:14:13 and scandalized yourself publicly say
1:14:16 scandalization
1:14:22 scandalizing me it's no problem if he
1:14:24 tell your father is a donkey somewhere I
1:14:26 will save my father I'm a fan of the
1:14:27 donkey I will accept
1:14:36 but most people would be embarrassed to
1:14:38 be catastrophic
1:14:40 or another one I think in that occasion
1:14:42 should then say what happened to my
1:14:43 father where is he and the person that
1:14:45 is in the Hellfire and the man who's
1:14:46 upset
1:14:48 why are you asking the first place
1:14:50 just make dwell for him for God's sake
1:14:52 finish don't get in that and things like
1:14:54 that and as they ask about that until
1:14:57 Umar noticed the prophet is becoming
1:14:58 more and more angry and he he needs on
1:15:00 his knees and said we are we we take
1:15:04 refuge to Allah making his messenger
1:15:05 angry message we don't need we don't ask
1:15:08 anything anymore is enough
1:15:12 so that was the occasion but it relates
1:15:15 to most questions that they were
1:15:17 definitely in in in in
1:15:20 a private issue like the tour is my
1:15:22 father where is it these things what it
1:15:23 is something like that but
1:15:26 uh uh but uh what what made the prophet
1:15:30 angry is not only the question but most
1:15:31 likely some people say look he
1:15:34 prohibited people from asking him
1:15:35 because he doesn't know he is shielding
1:15:37 himself a question that's that's a very
1:15:39 easy argument for a Hypocrites like in
1:15:41 the at the Battle of the book uh the the
1:15:44 she comment of the Prophet while grazing
1:15:47 went deep in a valley and she was lost
1:15:49 no and when they were about to break out
1:15:51 they were collecting the comments or
1:15:53 calling them because every company knows
1:15:54 the voice of his Guardian so on well
1:15:56 come on they give you even come
1:15:59 and the common nose as you know the pets
1:16:02 are thrown they know their names
1:16:04 they caused that the kaswa did not and
1:16:07 they sent people Church to get various I
1:16:08 say
1:16:10 this Muhammad claims that the Universe
1:16:12 comes from Heaven through stupid this
1:16:15 doesn't know where this is coming he's
1:16:17 exposed now and I'm saying Allah says
1:16:20 some people said that
1:16:22 I am a human like anybody and I am I am
1:16:25 very bashful to ask my Lord to tell me
1:16:27 where is the camel but you believed him
1:16:28 down and told me what they say and told
1:16:30 me she is in that body hanging at that
1:16:32 tree go and get it and they go and got
1:16:34 it
1:16:36 so most likely in Medina
1:16:37 this man doesn't know what he's getting
1:16:40 out of his head so he's trying to Shield
1:16:43 himself from question that's all that
1:16:44 it's lying because he's not a prophet
1:16:46 he's a liar that's most likely admit him
1:16:48 mostly angry but also that the people
1:16:49 were so simple-minded that follow this
1:16:52 line despite many give them giving back
1:16:54 or trying kind of tricks made him angry
1:16:57 but anyway that's the incident and the
1:16:59 Quran comment is in a neutrality then
1:17:01 this address of the shortcomings say
1:17:03 don't ask about things which
1:17:05 uh which if they exposed to you it may
1:17:08 displease you it could the less also
1:17:10 especially you might ask about something
1:17:12 with halal
1:17:13 and then Allah has a punishment for
1:17:16 those who are asking because it is
1:17:19 what destroyed your previous nation is
1:17:21 that they go back and forth we're never
1:17:23 ending to their prophets one of the
1:17:25 biggest incident we discussed when they
1:17:28 go went back and forth and they said I
1:17:29 told you what are and also suggested you
1:17:31 to go to the Old Testament the book of
1:17:33 Samuel number one when they went to the
1:17:34 prophet asking for appointing back and
1:17:37 forth back and forth back and forth back
1:17:39 and forth arguing that we want to draw
1:17:41 for Jihad and so on despite the warning
1:17:43 that Kings would not be like that Kings
1:17:45 would be Terror the Kings will be
1:17:46 oppressive King will enslave you and
1:17:48 they came back and forth no no I
1:17:50 actually will know how to control the
1:17:52 situation but we need someone to lead us
1:17:53 in Jihad a point someone of you as a
1:17:56 leader and do the jihadiator and then
1:17:59 ultimately they fail to comply with the
1:18:00 chat
1:18:02 so take this one incident then the other
1:18:04 incident there instead of bakra is a
1:18:05 minor one but this one was
1:18:08 they they got they got the the the
1:18:11 monarchy
1:18:13 which ended maybe that generation did
1:18:15 not by the later generation it was
1:18:17 extremely displeasing it is destructive
1:18:20 so the school could be related to the
1:18:21 registration but also asking about who
1:18:23 is my father
1:18:25 let's keep things as they are keep the
1:18:27 secret
1:18:28 if there's any benefit for you that
1:18:30 Indonesia
1:18:31 I say your father so and so on be good
1:18:34 to him
1:18:36 or he will settle the question
1:18:41 so so it covers all of these things but
1:18:43 as in the book of the thoroughly discuss
1:18:46 the Ayah and also all stories related to
1:18:49 it and also the supporting evidence that
1:18:51 it is it applies for both things don't
1:18:53 ask about this about these things the
1:18:55 family seek the things which has gone
1:18:57 and Allah has covered them up so that
1:18:59 nobody is scandalized leave that away no
1:19:02 need to mention that
1:19:04 but also don't ask about things which
1:19:07 Allah did not reveal to bihara and
1:19:09 foreign
1:19:32 did also and prohibited them what I've
1:19:35 allowed them so the satans are
1:19:37 prohibiting what Allah not allowing with
1:19:39 Allah Satan is too intelligent to do
1:19:41 that no it's not a way to get you misled
1:19:46 that's not always missed it
1:19:50 is
1:19:53 cautious this might be oh you're this
1:19:56 until you make what Allah has made and
1:20:00 all the bounty in the universe which
1:20:01 Allah gave to you becomes
1:20:03 and there are many examples like that
1:20:05 when you know you do not recognize that
1:20:07 everything in the universe is basically
1:20:09 had hard and pure and you should use it
1:20:10 a benefit of it that's the same thing we
1:20:13 should get to the mentality for example
1:20:14 prohibiting the politics
1:20:18 and maybe the books will be falsified
1:20:20 maybe we'll lose that it's not maybe
1:20:22 we'll just most of that is fake
1:20:24 the the ones will give the fatwa
1:20:28 blatant idiots majority of them are like
1:20:31 that or
1:20:33 they wanted to keep power because if the
1:20:35 political principle will make the people
1:20:36 will make books become in thousands and
1:20:38 hundreds of thousands of copies
1:20:40 a while before that by by copying by
1:20:43 hand you need to go to the one who has
1:20:45 the master book and the reference and
1:20:46 copy from him ah
1:20:48 and you can exercise power because
1:20:50 there's control
1:20:52 um exactly like church exactly like
1:20:55 exactly yeah
1:20:57 some of them are this I'm looking at all
1:20:59 Scholars but some of them some of them
1:21:01 all are some of uh even Islam and they
1:21:04 persisted on this falsehood for three
1:21:06 centuries putting us 300 years back
1:21:08 behind Europe
1:21:13 it's unbelievable if you read it you
1:21:15 can't really reply because they miss
1:21:17 that that's a fundamental I think so is
1:21:20 it showed out to be very destructive
1:21:24 but anyway the company's argument about
1:21:25 the basic rolling of permissibility in
1:21:27 the universe is expanded completely in
1:21:31 in our uh I think it should become a
1:21:36 fundamental and a major issue
1:21:38 uh we should everything in the universe
1:21:41 is halal everything in the universe is
1:21:43 pure until proven otherwise specifically
1:21:46 with compelling evidence everything
1:21:48 Universe you can look at it because
1:21:50 Allah gives you I look at everything and
1:21:52 everything is not Aura it's good to look
1:21:54 at it's beautiful
1:21:56 so no I guess because when you have
1:21:59 small application it doesn't make any
1:22:01 sense to ask what's the evidence that a
1:22:03 Muslim woman or any woman
1:22:05 can can show her face don't need
1:22:08 everything is not our
1:22:12 social interfaces mobile
1:22:14 even showing the bum is mobile until the
1:22:16 events came you have to cover
1:22:19 you are reversing things upside down
1:22:26 making the universe Aura and then the
1:22:28 opposite has to be a proven no
1:22:31 Universe human bodies human face human
1:22:33 legs everything is not our until proven
1:22:36 Arduino is by the evidence of the
1:22:39 Prophet so you don't need to ask our
1:22:40 interface at all
1:22:42 and you said you don't need to discuss
1:22:44 it in the first place but it has been
1:22:46 discussed and they're grinding for
1:22:47 centuries about it
1:22:50 and even clearly Express that type is
1:22:53 not Aura they're still grinding
1:22:55 it's not there's a questionable mother
1:22:57 we don't know about this is it really he
1:23:00 hated from that now the all the battery
1:23:02 of analyzing reference chains and so on
1:23:04 is Marshall we don't need we don't need
1:23:06 even this ahead
1:23:08 we don't need it
1:23:14 that's all comes from this from this I
1:23:16 mean the sick mindset which which is the
1:23:20 best way for the Devils to work
1:23:22 to get you in trouble so that what Allah
1:23:25 has revealed which should make your life
1:23:27 reasonable and well-balanced and human
1:23:28 life and Elevate you from the level of
1:23:31 the Beast
1:23:32 you you sink into become ultimately uh
1:23:37 so Shackled like the Jews and so on and
1:23:41 then then all the the only small
1:23:43 minority can come by with belief and the
1:23:45 rest will say to the hell with this Dean
1:23:46 to the hell with this that cannot be we
1:23:49 cannot compilize that subtle question I
1:23:51 say possible let's shout leave it forget
1:23:53 about it
1:23:54 the same individual was we discussed
1:23:56 earlier about the state if the state is
1:23:57 doing this any fearing it's interfering
1:23:59 with this then even a kaffir State a
1:24:01 liberal state is much better
1:24:04 you will find many people know they say
1:24:06 I prefer to be in America or in Britain
1:24:10 having at least breathing space than
1:24:12 being in the Taliban and Saudi Arabia or
1:24:14 Iran in fact many people and many people
1:24:16 of you listen to us may have that
1:24:18 feeling maybe they are ashamed to
1:24:20 express it but this is there's no
1:24:22 it's true it's better to live here and
1:24:24 you are more well-balanced than and
1:24:26 authentic your Affairs and for us it's
1:24:28 bad because they're protruder in the
1:24:30 other side
1:24:31 but still maybe maybe there you are
1:24:33 better off then then under Saudi Arabia
1:24:36 and so on at least you have a bit of
1:24:38 breathe out of the space
1:24:42 so that's the end result of something
1:24:43 like that
1:24:45 it may not appear immediately but it
1:24:47 will come like the Lego monarchy chosen
1:24:49 by by uh by Buddy Israel in their
1:24:54 painful algorithms or counter argument
1:24:56 that counter instruction given by Allah
1:24:59 to them
1:25:02 sister they've got it maybe the first
1:25:05 two third couple of monarchs were good A
1:25:07 bit different that would answer their
1:25:09 mind where profits are very good
1:25:11 but even these
1:25:13 the majority of you the Jews do not
1:25:16 recognize the word as a prophet it's
1:25:17 just a king good King
1:25:19 Suleiman
1:25:20 started good and ended bad and becoming
1:25:23 mushrika and kaffir and worshiping idols
1:25:25 and Obey obeying his Bush requires Etc
1:25:27 imagine I would care after that then
1:25:30 don't discuss everyone agree that they
1:25:32 are Terrence and satans
1:25:38 this is this is a theory if you if you
1:25:41 see that and how it happened the hit
1:25:42 promise history Etc and previous Nations
1:25:44 you understand really the deep meaning
1:25:47 of what myself said this it what
1:25:49 destroyed the people before you is that
1:25:50 they were going back and forth on
1:25:52 messenger asking back and forth by
1:25:54 asking back and forth leave me as I
1:25:57 leave you
1:26:00 and accepts from Allah's forgiveness and
1:26:03 his Allah did not forget anything
1:26:06 meaning everything is permissible do
1:26:08 whatever you want look at everything do
1:26:10 whatever thing
1:26:11 the way all activities struggle in life
1:26:15 whatever halam I will tell you don't
1:26:16 worry I will tell you what is how I will
1:26:19 I will step in and tell you what is Hara
1:26:22 do not worry I will bring you with what
1:26:24 Allah wants from you
1:26:30 so that's these are a significant in
1:26:32 that but it's important to recognize
1:26:34 that it covers both sides not though the
1:26:37 first translator claim is only
1:26:38 legislation no the other one who may be
1:26:41 an incidents which I don't feel made it
1:26:43 clear that it covers both aspects both
1:26:45 legislation so but the first one is
1:26:48 right but he went to extreme it covers
1:26:49 even other things
1:26:53 it covers even everything
1:27:02 and and what what shows clearly that
1:27:05 sometimes it ends in a misery either
1:27:08 either rejecting the law or rejecting
1:27:10 the information which is not pleasing to
1:27:12 you say no no I can't accept that then
1:27:15 because the messenger told you for
1:27:16 example the one who asked my father is
1:27:18 your father is not our father is with
1:27:21 some unknown person who fornicated or
1:27:24 committed artery with your mother
1:27:26 he may be so upset that he becomes
1:27:28 second and I cannot accept that message
1:27:30 is dying then you are stuck then you're
1:27:32 becoming a cat
1:27:33 so that I addressed that
1:27:36 is
1:27:50 sorry
1:27:53 before your time have indeed us people
1:27:56 before your time have you need to ask us
1:27:57 questions and in the result thereof have
1:27:59 come to deny the truth this translation
1:28:01 people before your time have asked such
1:28:04 questions would then later rejected
1:28:06 their answers yeah and became and then
1:28:08 rejected it came uh
1:28:11 they became Catherine because of the of
1:28:14 the of the rejection and the answer not
1:28:16 I just rejected the answer just straight
1:28:18 but it's worse it became to the level of
1:28:21 like let's say the monarchive one is
1:28:23 soil later on many of them rejected that
1:28:26 even they rejected to recognize that
1:28:27 that uh that sudaiman uh is a is a is a
1:28:32 prophet and because they because in
1:28:35 exercising his his Royal Privileges and
1:28:37 so on which they asked and insisted upon
1:28:39 and he was not transgressable and unjust
1:28:42 the opposite was very wise and he will
1:28:44 build their first temple they could not
1:28:46 stomach that
1:28:48 and they became disbelieval
1:28:51 so don't do that and I think that's how
1:28:54 it's generally complied with that with
1:28:55 few exceptions and so on and mistakes
1:28:57 and things like that
1:29:00 and then again example of the water
1:29:02 people in jail invented certain
1:29:03 invention
1:29:04 which uh which is uh not enacted by
1:29:08 Allah
1:29:09 the various things he mentioned I read
1:29:12 various stuff I see there's nothing
1:29:13 really satisfactory about these various
1:29:15 terms
1:29:16 presented here but certain allocations
1:29:19 for the idols and let me read the IRS
1:29:30 it is not of God's ordaining that
1:29:34 certain kinds of cattle should be marked
1:29:36 out by superstitions and set aside from
1:29:39 the use of man yet those who are bent on
1:29:42 denying the truth contribute their own
1:29:43 lying inventions to God and most of them
1:29:46 never use their reason their translation
1:29:48 God has not ordained that certain kinds
1:29:50 of cattle should be designated a hero
1:29:53 cyber wasila or ham or of Hami and set
1:29:57 aside from the use of man
1:29:59 yet the Believers invent lies about God
1:30:02 many of them do not use reason yeah so
1:30:06 another Thursday
1:30:13 left alone I seems to be the claim for
1:30:16 example when when uh she Kamil has a 10
1:30:21 10 female children because the female
1:30:23 camel is more valuable than the male you
1:30:25 need only few males to do the necessary
1:30:28 fertilization but female is the best
1:30:31 that's one which produce if she produces
1:30:37 then she is prohibited of being abused
1:30:39 or killed or on sloth or anything like
1:30:41 that from their own imagination
1:30:44 I think that they cut their ear and
1:30:46 things
1:30:47 if a female female
1:30:51 gives gives birth for for uh uh
1:30:56 a female and then a female and a female
1:30:59 in or gives a better male and then a
1:31:02 female then a female then it's called
1:31:04 the second one the the she connected to
1:31:06 her brother and then that she is having
1:31:09 a certain regulation and ham is the bull
1:31:12 camel
1:31:13 uh who who has produced 10 girls or
1:31:16 something like that then she comes or
1:31:18 something like that and then he said he
1:31:20 has protected his back nobody can ride
1:31:22 him that's all of that invention and
1:31:23 some traces what in the time when the
1:31:25 part was in his pilgrimage the last one
1:31:28 obviously the only one because the one
1:31:29 in Makkah was just was it was according
1:31:33 to the religion of Ibraham so it's not
1:31:34 obligatory
1:31:39 and for that he stayed only a few months
1:31:42 alive and then
1:31:44 so when he was riding
1:31:47 and he saw a man driving a camel
1:31:51 obviously this is Hadi because you see
1:31:53 the Hadith they have the their necklaces
1:31:55 and these things on the who's
1:31:57 showing that it's a Hadi and he's
1:31:58 walking said
1:32:01 uh
1:32:02 we are walking moment is coming
1:32:05 the messenger of Allah this is this is
1:32:08 a Hadi going through them
1:32:12 I'm sorry
1:32:15 mounted ride it
1:32:17 and he said it's better than I say why
1:32:20 won't you all right even if it's bad
1:32:23 enough who said that but then I cannot
1:32:25 be written
1:32:26 it's marked to go there by Sahara you
1:32:29 have the necklace as we we few I say
1:32:32 back we said these assemble this man so
1:32:35 on to please the need of humans of
1:32:37 symbolism and things like that they need
1:32:39 some material material differences or
1:32:41 material examples that's fine but if
1:32:43 it's bad enough it's a good right animal
1:32:49 the same way if you're if you are
1:32:51 getting sheeps for example to Mr Haram
1:32:54 on the way and this happened that they
1:32:56 were not sure maybe it was uh it was the
1:32:59 because the Pelican Mrs God goes through
1:33:02 the years from winter to summer and this
1:33:05 may be uh accumulated wall and but the
1:33:08 the one the one who sold them for the
1:33:11 one who taking them to Haram did not
1:33:13 show them did not cut away their head
1:33:15 and obviously the hair became more
1:33:17 loneliness and just Troublesome for the
1:33:19 animals who said you cannot show you
1:33:21 cannot short attend and even benefit for
1:33:23 it also sorry for what sake I relieve
1:33:26 the poor animal
1:33:28 and things like that they invent things
1:33:30 from their imagination ah this is some
1:33:33 kind this has a sanctity if it's going
1:33:35 to Holy the holy sanctuary and because
1:33:38 it has sanctity should not be ridden no
1:33:41 that's not true
1:33:43 if it's going there to be slaughtered
1:33:45 how come that's contributed then this is
1:33:47 just just irrational things going from
1:33:50 symbolism from a reasonable level will
1:33:52 satisfy the basic news organization to
1:33:54 extreme levels
1:33:58 Allah did not establish anybody or
1:34:00 whatever they said I can't read for you
1:34:02 whatever but it is contradicting
1:34:03 definition so I don't think I swear it's
1:34:05 some kind of animals that shown devoted
1:34:07 to go to the Kaaba or animals who have
1:34:10 produced certain other a number of
1:34:11 certain animals or something like that
1:34:13 and then they uh their uh their their or
1:34:16 for example animals who have been this
1:34:18 animal is devoted to the idol it is
1:34:21 relief free as if you like what a
1:34:23 Wilderness and it goes and grazers and
1:34:25 nobody touches it and so on obviously
1:34:27 they Market a certain way but this this
1:34:29 is very clear it's usually uh for one of
1:34:32 their gods and the scripture capacity
1:34:35 but other things are very difficult to
1:34:37 Define you find various contradicting
1:34:39 definition because they've got extinct
1:34:40 completely alhamdulillah and nothing
1:34:42 remaining in Arabia but I can't get it
1:34:44 for you if anyone is interested but
1:34:46 anyway it's certain devotional animals
1:34:48 and with certain symbolism which Allah
1:34:50 did not Allah said
1:34:52 did not establish any one of these but
1:34:55 the believer claiming that's coming from
1:34:56 Allah somehow from time was married and
1:34:59 they are fabricating their dying about
1:35:00 Allah and they have no no mind to
1:35:03 recognize that this is a it is so stupid
1:35:06 it should not be attributed to their own
1:35:08 parents they tell them to Allah
1:35:10 this is too late about the whole search
1:35:14 it's almost a parallel with going back
1:35:16 to yeah
1:35:18 that's a good aspect of that also it
1:35:20 smashes all of that definitely
1:35:27 Translate
1:35:40 it is not of God's ordaining that
1:35:42 certain kinds of cattle should be marked
1:35:43 out oh sorry yeah
1:35:47 well when they are told come on do that
1:35:49 which God has bestowed from and high and
1:35:51 unto the Apostle they answer enough
1:35:53 enough for us is that we found our
1:35:55 fathers believing and doing why even
1:35:58 though their fathers knew nothing and
1:36:00 were devoid of all guidance and that's
1:36:02 translation but they are told except
1:36:04 what God has sent down and the messenger
1:36:06 they answer what we inherited for are
1:36:08 from our forefathers is enough for us
1:36:10 therefore forefathers knew nothing and
1:36:13 were not guided that's applies also to
1:36:15 Muslim in the other sense that they
1:36:17 wouldn't foreign
1:36:47 ceremony I think so that's fine so I
1:36:49 think so having a nice structure could
1:36:51 be managed by probably and so on that's
1:36:53 okay but if it gets to issue with the
1:36:55 trading thing to be Haram or Halal or
1:36:57 things like that then we may have a a
1:37:00 severe difficulty there and we're
1:37:02 getting in the border of both danger and
1:37:04 but it's more common when it comes to
1:37:06 scholar so our scholar said that but
1:37:08 this is clearly contradicting what your
1:37:10 scholar saying clearly and evidently
1:37:16 um
1:37:16 but our scholar no better than you
1:37:18 that's all
1:37:20 okay ask yourself
1:37:22 how to interpret that why did the how
1:37:24 can we desire suddenly became abrogated
1:37:30 where did you get that from
1:37:34 that's then it can be more than
1:37:36 appointing Scholars and scribes and
1:37:38 monks the Lord Allah it can get to the
1:37:41 level that
1:37:43 here is the conference company said what
1:37:45 we found from our parents and so on life
1:37:47 was managing nicely for Generation
1:37:50 said well as long as you comply with
1:37:53 British values so some British values is
1:37:55 that what they inherited over
1:37:56 Generations if anything there is to be
1:37:59 inherited because even the British
1:38:00 values have changed in the last century
1:38:03 in such a way you cannot related to
1:38:05 Britain 70 I I know someone I think he's
1:38:08 still alive and he is now he left
1:38:11 working in the media he was working with
1:38:13 us as a media advisor with myself at the
1:38:15 result okay when we came very nice man I
1:38:18 will not mention his name okay just just
1:38:20 out of respect he's a very nice
1:38:22 personality
1:38:24 and then then he got fed up with me
1:38:26 there soon I decided to settle in
1:38:28 as he loved those who is a dog breeder
1:38:31 and said okay and his wife is having
1:38:34 some problems and so on she was most of
1:38:36 the time obviously clearly not drinking
1:38:38 and things that and he was yeah and he
1:38:40 was caring for him and and sometimes she
1:38:43 doesn't sit probably so he pulls her
1:38:45 clothes down through the knee I know
1:38:46 what I said your exception is jealous
1:38:49 for the Englishman say doctor just my my
1:38:52 father generation I said you remember we
1:38:54 were talking the 90s now was in the 90s
1:38:56 I thought so 40 years ago and he's in
1:38:59 his 50s something I remember as a child
1:39:01 and that it was a big shame in our area
1:39:03 in the village if the woman comes with
1:39:05 with the with
1:39:07 the with the with the half sleeve it has
1:39:11 to be fall asleep half sleep make but
1:39:12 without sleeves the people will be
1:39:14 shocked in in our okay it's not like
1:39:17 what you see that becoming a loose now
1:39:19 and this was coming maybe except maybe
1:39:22 areas in London so now we've got a bit
1:39:24 where everyone is regarded as a virtual
1:39:26 to run around neck naked
1:39:29 so
1:39:30 even British values let's leave the
1:39:33 average values the same with these what
1:39:34 you found your father sorry what you
1:39:37 found for others we've got from their
1:39:38 grandfathers may have changed before
1:39:39 that but because they're living with the
1:39:42 their life somehow in a certain way you
1:39:45 think that's the optimal and uh and the
1:39:47 correct way especially with the message
1:39:49 you're telling you that's not correct
1:39:53 you are looking at about you are
1:39:55 disturbing our our peace and our social
1:39:57 uh uh Conformity no no no no get lost we
1:40:02 don't want you
1:40:03 ready
1:40:06 even if they if the evidence is clear
1:40:09 that their parents did not know anything
1:40:11 they are ignorance
1:40:13 and they were not guided and the same
1:40:15 Applause
1:40:17 what I mean is that for example you look
1:40:19 at British values if you have to go to
1:40:20 them the only British value that has
1:40:22 really gone through the generations it's
1:40:24 really just a monarchy effectively these
1:40:26 are just yeah it serves it's the thing
1:40:29 that actually goes against their entire
1:40:31 Creed that you you know the idea that a
1:40:33 human being basically a serial rapist
1:40:36 potentially could be your your Sovereign
1:40:41 but that's the only Remnant that applies
1:40:44 how is it possible you know like it for
1:40:46 example Bridge values it wasn't gave
1:40:48 this was it wasn't contrary to them that
1:40:51 is closer to their values
1:40:53 just after the world war the the one who
1:40:56 in uh helped cracking the code of the
1:40:59 German uh touring and then touring yes
1:41:02 he was he was he was detained and tried
1:41:05 and died in prison I think or the you
1:41:07 know that I've studied this from prison
1:41:09 because he was found to be homosexual so
1:41:11 it was punishable
1:41:13 no it is almost a virtue
1:41:16 one statistics that that uh about 25
1:41:19 percent of the British men are
1:41:21 homosexual that's an old statistics now
1:41:23 okay fine no problem but this means 25
1:41:26 percent of the of the of the ministers
1:41:28 and the Parliament because the average
1:41:30 like the average of the nation let's say
1:41:32 or maybe even more I'm more sexual and
1:41:35 40 years ago some guy died in prison
1:41:37 because of that
1:41:39 and even in the 70s by the way just a
1:41:42 small joke about well even in the 70s
1:41:45 was still regarded as a crime I don't
1:41:47 think the punishment may have been
1:41:48 reduced it was regarded as a crime and
1:41:50 those who were infested with this
1:41:52 disease they were going to Dubai where
1:41:54 they were homosexual clubs in Dubai so
1:41:56 overseas it's okay oh no no so they were
1:41:59 going there anyway
1:42:02 we don't want to avoid this in any
1:42:05 further but that's that's essentially
1:42:07 the same it's the same the same mindset
1:42:10 Etc but obviously the one with is worse
1:42:12 because they they are they're going to
1:42:14 the border which Allah says
1:42:17 they appointed the among subscribed as
1:42:20 Lords beside Allah they gave them
1:42:22 registering power but actually it's the
1:42:24 same obligated for their parents as well
1:42:26 because many of these social norms are
1:42:28 having the meaning and the power of
1:42:30 legislation
1:42:32 and uh and if they have the quality
1:42:36 legislation it doesn't matter if it is
1:42:37 reinforced by a state or by Society or
1:42:39 by thriving shift ends it's a
1:42:41 legislation and they they have appointed
1:42:43 your parents and on a private shift
1:42:45 things and say Lord beside Allah and
1:42:48 this is very much alive in Pakistan very
1:42:51 much so to the extent uh you know this
1:42:54 this horrific privacies
1:42:56 absolutely and then someone and there's
1:42:59 a bunch of Scholars there they never
1:43:01 opened their mouth all the days if
1:43:02 there's a flooding like 20 years ago not
1:43:04 not this one the Mufti of the country
1:43:07 advise people to do 70 000 rule Sharif
1:43:10 that's his solution for the flood my
1:43:13 situation is very miserable for the
1:43:14 Muslim leadership so-called scholarship
1:43:17 was on it is very miserable
1:43:19 anyway we will work on that to change
1:43:21 that yeah hopefully this is what we are
1:43:24 discussing now will he'll be hit by some
1:43:25 people and they start awaking waking up
1:43:30 I think we have now almost uh one hour
1:43:33 45 we start after that Witnesses from
1:43:35 the case of death and so on I think we
1:43:37 should leave that for next time because
1:43:39 he said is a issue with the with the
1:43:41 with the with the witnesses and the
1:43:46 witnesses for non-muslim Witnesses is a
1:43:49 is a meaty issue is with postponic so we
1:43:52 can start afresh at that point
1:43:54 I've enabled it for open question
1:43:57 answers anyone yeah
1:43:59 now there's no question Scott uh there's
1:44:01 no questions on the
1:44:03 um what you call it on the YouTube
1:44:08 yeah okay
1:44:10 uh Professor uh I just want to add a few
1:44:14 things and then maybe ask a question so
1:44:17 regarding the first half of the of the
1:44:19 lesson we were talking about the uh the
1:44:23 state and being in an intervention in
1:44:26 society so uh as so as I understand it
1:44:29 that is that in Islam the the state is a
1:44:34 minimal State yeah right so so it only
1:44:37 provides uh like the security and the uh
1:44:42 uh uh and the safety of the society but
1:44:46 I think uh I I think from Reading
1:44:49 history I mean during the time of profit
1:44:52 and uh
1:44:54 we we also know that um the state at
1:44:59 that time provided more than just that I
1:45:02 mean the state during the time of
1:45:05 prophet and provided like the yeah
1:45:08 mental
1:45:10 economic and social needs for society
1:45:13 not only security so I think the state
1:45:16 in Islam is is balanced between uh the
1:45:20 minimal State and what the Americans
1:45:23 call it today the welfare state right so
1:45:27 yeah it's actually still it is a minimal
1:45:31 State because the the caring for for the
1:45:34 needy and those is a social obligation
1:45:36 There's No Escape of it it has to be
1:45:39 done by 30 and the enactment of the
1:45:41 zakah and that is it shows this
1:45:44 necessity because the human beings are
1:45:45 social beings they are not they are not
1:45:48 uh they are not like like tigers or
1:45:51 leopards they are more like lions lions
1:45:53 live in Pride and they should share
1:45:55 things like that but obviously the
1:45:56 applied is limited in size like a family
1:45:59 level and that's enough for the lion
1:46:01 level of their development and and
1:46:03 sophistication for humans it will be
1:46:06 bigger becomes like cities and tribes
1:46:08 and things like that and that's a state
1:46:09 that's the type of a city can be a state
1:46:11 in ancient times there are states where
1:46:13 they have that size and then there is a
1:46:15 necessity for for clearing and also
1:46:17 obviously the parents care for the
1:46:18 children until they come out of age
1:46:20 that's 15 years and so on so the
1:46:22 enactment of zakat and also the
1:46:24 necessity of managing the resources we
1:46:26 shared by everyone like minimal
1:46:28 resources like uh like energy resources
1:46:32 like water like I said it's quite a set
1:46:35 to attend that in managing it and
1:46:36 distributed it justly and manage it in
1:46:39 behalf of the community in an optimal
1:46:41 way but this is not making making an
1:46:44 Interventional state
1:46:45 it doesn't make it anytime video
1:46:47 intervention in the intervention State
1:46:49 like for example look at the American
1:46:51 state they they can't conceive and
1:46:54 accept like for example something which
1:46:56 I think if it happened in the Muslim
1:46:57 world even in the lowest of the time it
1:47:00 would lead to a revolution like for
1:47:01 example by by by
1:47:03 a presidential order the Americans were
1:47:07 prohibited in the theaters from owning
1:47:08 gold that old gold were confiscated
1:47:11 not confiscated but they were
1:47:13 conversated with printed dollars so the
1:47:15 equivalent to the world but they were
1:47:16 not allowed to buy and sell gold except
1:47:17 very low level 14 karat and lower for
1:47:20 example by not even by hello
1:47:22 and they stomach that they did not see
1:47:24 anything wrong in it
1:47:28 because this is ultimately some have
1:47:30 have some Divine characteristic of the
1:47:32 power of legislation so because the word
1:47:35 Jesus is the hand of Allah and even
1:47:37 restricting is very strict limitation
1:47:39 and so on and procedures Etc we should
1:47:42 discussed in some of our work I would
1:47:45 say it is still a minimal State this
1:47:47 because this is this is by its
1:47:48 definition because why it does exist to
1:47:51 keep the peace and keep the people in a
1:47:53 society and there is the necessity since
1:47:56 the Sharia has enacted that you have to
1:47:58 support the others in matter of the
1:48:00 needy the orphan etc etc etc as as
1:48:03 obviously about the state has to attend
1:48:07 to that so it does not violate really
1:48:09 the minimality and it is well it is by
1:48:12 this one by being a welfare state in
1:48:14 that sense
1:48:15 right so so this definition is a
1:48:18 separate it could be very minimalistic
1:48:20 and welfare state at the same time
1:48:22 we'll go where the capitalistic state is
1:48:24 not welfare state because it is based on
1:48:26 individualism and the American people
1:48:28 say it is an American uh that uh that
1:48:30 you should care about the others you you
1:48:32 care for the others by caring for
1:48:33 yourself that's not the way uh an
1:48:36 Islamic State works
1:48:38 right right so so attending for the
1:48:41 needy and providing uh fundamental is a
1:48:44 necessity problem of societal there will
1:48:46 be no peace that people will be
1:48:47 attacking each other eating each other
1:48:48 devouring each other right but but is it
1:48:52 an obligation for the state or for the
1:48:54 people as a collector it's originated
1:48:56 but all that's obligation for the
1:48:57 society and the staff
1:49:00 but what a people cannot manage before
1:49:01 in Islam if you say they were managing
1:49:03 that they were managing they have their
1:49:04 own funds the other club they're on
1:49:06 schools they are universities and the
1:49:08 state or they left the state because
1:49:10 they even distrusted the state but if
1:49:12 they transferred by as I mentioned
1:49:14 they say in Dubai we want to we want a
1:49:18 compulsory free schooling then the head
1:49:20 of state or the state can say listen
1:49:22 guys there's no free lunch the the funds
1:49:25 coming from various resources
1:49:27 for that situation which we are now is
1:49:30 not enough to have uh to have schooling
1:49:33 for everyone or university for everyone
1:49:34 for free we have to leave some taxes
1:49:37 there's no freelance that's that's okay
1:49:39 but but they were doing that so that
1:49:42 they were doing that
1:49:43 it may situation may arrive that the
1:49:45 society cannot do that it becomes at a
1:49:47 very complex and widespread it needs to
1:49:50 be or it's not doing it in such a way
1:49:52 that clearly that state has to say but
1:49:54 do then step minimally as needed to do
1:50:05 the principle
1:50:07 the state this alternative State the
1:50:10 state has no Authority unless proven by
1:50:12 by text that's it
1:50:15 it's not it's not that the western or
1:50:17 even the liberal State and the West it
1:50:19 is like is a substitute for a king which
1:50:21 has Divine rights no it has no Diva
1:50:23 rights it's Jessica this is the will of
1:50:25 the people for living together
1:50:27 peacefully and management
1:50:28 and only what is necessary for that and
1:50:31 this test inside in the text clearly
1:50:33 like Jihad like War like Etc even though
1:50:40 you're obliged only to care for yourself
1:50:42 in Jihad but just excited we leave at
1:50:45 all to arise with you call them to rise
1:50:48 with you
1:50:50 a theory of that someone should set on
1:50:53 all of these things and develop a more
1:50:55 comprehensive detailed consistent Theory
1:50:59 is related to that it is obligatory for
1:51:03 the society by Divine injunction
1:51:05 is obligated for them to to uh to bring
1:51:12 out the zakat and the zakat is not for
1:51:13 for whom for the needy for ETC for ETC
1:51:16 and also Jihad and also they will be
1:51:19 they will be in the universe around you
1:51:21 enemies Who attack you or plan to attack
1:51:23 you or try to occupy your country
1:51:25 because not everyone will be a good
1:51:26 believer and even somebody who would be
1:51:28 bad people run by bad governments and
1:51:31 they may attack you so you have to be
1:51:32 having enough strength to defend against
1:51:34 anyone who attacks
1:51:36 so from that you can develop that
1:51:38 message but ultimately the philosophy is
1:51:41 that it's minimalistic it's gonna do
1:51:43 things unless sanctioned by by uh by uh
1:51:46 by uh by the Sharia
1:51:49 check the example of uh to
1:51:53 um Ali versus uh let's clarify even
1:51:55 there is president in terms of they were
1:51:58 given the option of would would he yeah
1:52:00 yeah that's that's the method of
1:52:01 agreement that's very clear that this is
1:52:03 this is by fundamental uh rule over
1:52:06 because the way is
1:52:08 conditions which they say every
1:52:10 condition is
1:52:11 clear it's not permissible so no need
1:52:13 for heads foreign
1:52:26 ahead of you but they have one condition
1:52:28 they want you to comply with the with
1:52:31 the uh with the Sunnah
1:52:34 I already said no I have my orange they
1:52:35 had Earthman complied
1:52:38 well your first one is not around here
1:52:40 and they will have other other evidences
1:52:43 and other narrations which enforce that
1:52:45 indirectly and directly leave that now
1:52:47 I'm not discussing the matter of
1:52:48 agreement with the state that will be
1:52:50 slide in a detailed Constitution but at
1:52:52 the fundamental principle in the eye of
1:52:55 power
1:52:56 soon this is fundamental
1:52:58 yeah this is based on the Divine
1:53:01 sovereign
1:53:30 in charge
1:53:33 was appointed obviously originally
1:53:35 because of the eye of Surah and the
1:53:37 well-established other principles which
1:53:39 we have discussed if the these people
1:53:41 say oh we have this Authority but let's
1:53:42 say no no we don't have
1:53:44 messenger say if you have this Authority
1:53:47 simply like that
1:53:49 so but before any dispute happened a
1:53:52 reality someone could imagine situation
1:53:54 and strive to develop a theory
1:53:58 yes uh Professor I think I think you you
1:54:00 answered my question I just want to add
1:54:02 as a small note here is that you know
1:54:05 when mentioning the uh the liberal state
1:54:08 in in in the west especially like
1:54:10 looking at the United States and some
1:54:13 countries in Europe like France I don't
1:54:15 think they they have reached the minimal
1:54:18 state or they have succeed in it you
1:54:20 know because as you said it turned out
1:54:21 uh they would never be capitalistic a
1:54:24 capitalistic State and even more
1:54:26 authoritarian State because they were
1:54:29 because they will never because if for
1:54:31 the registration no no ultimate the
1:54:33 reference frame
1:54:35 to refer to then you become Divine and
1:54:38 there's no way you'll become
1:54:39 minimalistic yes exactly so so what
1:54:42 happened in in the United States is that
1:54:44 the the government told the society we
1:54:46 will provide you security but you have
1:54:49 to surrender some of your rights to us
1:54:51 you know like like for example I
1:54:54 remember the what's it called the
1:54:56 Patriot Act you know the the the
1:54:59 government told them like we're gonna
1:55:01 infringe on your rights we're gonna spy
1:55:03 on your phones on your camera and but we
1:55:06 will provide you security and we will
1:55:08 not let the government and they can't do
1:55:11 that because the state is ultimately
1:55:13 carrying that people super annotate
1:55:14 something abstraction there and the
1:55:17 people are somehow have Divine Powers
1:55:18 which they don't have in Islam
1:55:21 yes yes the fundamental is that the
1:55:24 fundamental is that man-made law they
1:55:26 say we have rule of law but the law is
1:55:27 made by man so man ruling himself as a
1:55:30 contradiction that you have to have the
1:55:32 source of the law and all the disclaim
1:55:34 man will make his Lord referring to
1:55:38 moral principles and rationality but
1:55:40 this is not well defined what
1:55:41 salvationality was more on presidentials
1:55:46 yes because rationality cannot Define
1:55:48 even the with the all attempts of Grant
1:55:51 and so on to define the so-called
1:55:53 category imperative uh do whatever what
1:55:56 what uh whatever the dictates or what
1:55:59 what you think is you are obliged to do
1:56:01 and things like that is internally and
1:56:04 the example he gives is that fulfilling
1:56:07 contracts But ultimately conquers
1:56:09 according to his discussion otherwise
1:56:11 people will not be able to in a contract
1:56:12 is a social agreement
1:56:15 there's the normal there's a from a few
1:56:17 reasons there's no if you if you break
1:56:19 your contact contract and you benefit
1:56:21 for yourself selfishly you may do it
1:56:24 if you are willing to confront the
1:56:26 society if they apprehend you and put
1:56:28 you in prison say I don't care I'm going
1:56:29 to benefit and I will do my best not to
1:56:31 be apprehended you cannot even
1:56:34 construct anything against murder
1:56:37 and even the the soccer anarchisted the
1:56:39 19th century model is morally acceptable
1:56:42 no problem but the society may come back
1:56:44 and hang you for that or cut your neck
1:56:46 in the guillotine fine if you're ready
1:56:47 for that and you know how to do it do it
1:56:53 there's no no absolute reference frame
1:56:56 yeah so the view will become the
1:56:58 reference frame and become internally
1:56:59 contradictory under reality they will
1:57:01 never be able and few countries that we
1:57:04 have they have widespread uh like a
1:57:07 proper Wars like in Switzerland the
1:57:09 exercise somehow and it seems to be a
1:57:11 little bit straining But ultimately it
1:57:13 will lead also to contradictions
1:57:19 but the fundamental point is that if
1:57:23 there is an ultimate reference frame
1:57:25 which is an absolute dictated by
1:57:27 supervision which is a Divine being or
1:57:29 nature for the atheist nature is meaning
1:57:32 the law of the jungle
1:57:34 the strong devours the weak that's it
1:57:37 that's the law of the jungle
1:57:39 or social agreement the social elements
1:57:41 can be broken by some people who can't
1:57:43 get away and jump on Power and do a coup
1:57:45 d'etat
1:57:46 there's no moral they have just to be
1:57:47 continuously alert and holding the Gun
1:57:50 and shooting them in the face of
1:57:51 necessary
1:57:53 it's okay even even if you have a
1:57:56 fundamental difference frame and the
1:57:57 majority of people start not respecting
1:58:00 that and complaining it or the Rules
1:58:02 start playing game and doing that wheel
1:58:03 and playing and twisting the words from
1:58:06 other places like having this time
1:58:07 because we started with Mahalia you may
1:58:09 get deviations also but if you look in
1:58:11 Islamic history the the the operation of
1:58:14 the state in general and missing of life
1:58:18 does not come anywhere close what we
1:58:20 have from from your European States
1:58:22 since the time of kings and even look at
1:58:25 what this liberal system and is how how
1:58:28 many were killed in Wars I said through
1:58:30 history
1:58:31 massive
1:58:33 doesn't compare with any religious wars
1:58:37 users say oh religion are the reason for
1:58:39 Wars between people is not true
1:58:42 these liberal states and so on had
1:58:44 killed and they had inherited so many
1:58:46 humans and before that when they were in
1:58:47 the in development stage as capitalists
1:58:49 they have committed genocide eliminated
1:58:51 the Native Americans eliminated the Inca
1:58:54 eliminated the Maya even in internally
1:58:57 the the English almost eliminated but
1:59:00 they didn't succeed ultimately Island
1:59:03 itself they didn't bother they let the
1:59:06 people die and getting the potatoes and
1:59:08 selling a potato somewhere and in the
1:59:10 farming of 18 was 1840 physically anyway
1:59:13 in the 19th century I didn't bother
1:59:18 it's a fundamental problem there but in
1:59:20 in despite all human shortcomings having
1:59:22 an absolute reference frame and giving
1:59:25 the people only the authority not the
1:59:26 sovereignty and the legislative power
1:59:28 like what Islam has by necessity because
1:59:31 by Divine being is the
1:59:39 sovereignty to implement that under the
1:59:42 sufficient scripture that they can
1:59:44 deduct from it the various laws either
1:59:46 very very much details or wide range of
1:59:49 procedures and and administrative loops
1:59:53 but also there were certain fundamental
1:59:55 limitations
1:59:58 check we've got a question from the so
2:00:00 you've covered this before what do you
2:00:02 think about the succession about
2:00:04 succession and self-determination can a
2:00:07 tribe or a certain ethnicity separate
2:00:09 from a state
2:00:13 domain of Islam and they and they decide
2:00:16 as a tribe in a peaceful Way by voting
2:00:19 for example because if they are offered
2:00:21 in initially in the compounding with the
2:00:23 state according to the Hadith which will
2:00:24 come soon
2:00:25 and give us a translation if they are
2:00:28 offered
2:00:29 said to if you meet your enemy your
2:00:33 enemies
2:00:35 of the disbelievable the word enemy
2:00:37 meaning the animated with them and
2:00:38 there's war before so there have been
2:00:40 fighting against Islam before that
2:00:41 that's that's the issue of jihad Al said
2:00:44 but if you meet them then give them give
2:00:46 them an opportunity of one one of the
2:00:48 following one
2:00:50 remember this Islam if they accept and
2:00:53 give them two options they either
2:00:54 immigrate and join the the
2:00:58 meaning you joined the Federation
2:01:00 does not mean that they have to move
2:01:02 physically that's a mistake on people
2:01:03 and just with this discuss very
2:01:05 in boring detail
2:01:07 in in the in the recession
2:01:10 if we obey that's fine then they are
2:01:12 becoming and they have joined the
2:01:14 Federation and they say no we stay in
2:01:16 independent but that's then you can stay
2:01:18 they will be like it's called arrival
2:01:20 Muslim The Outsider or the Bedouins or
2:01:23 the Muslim Arab is not bedroom something
2:01:25 else explained there also Arab
2:01:27 muslimited and all the rules of Islam
2:01:30 applied to them but they don't have
2:01:32 anything in that region they don't have
2:01:33 it unless they fight on us it's very
2:01:35 well possible that that you are engaged
2:01:38 in fight against an enemy and another
2:01:40 Muslim Emirate is send you participate
2:01:43 with you with the armies and support
2:01:44 then they get a share of their body they
2:01:47 get compensated for that otherwise they
2:01:48 get nothing that's it that's it after
2:01:51 that if not then learn so we don't want
2:01:53 Islam then they they become in a
2:01:58 Confederation and Pages here that's
2:01:59 maybe there will be something with the
2:02:01 relationship because this religious will
2:02:03 be balanced by protection and so on and
2:02:06 certain Alliance without being an
2:02:08 Islamic Alliance but General allies
2:02:10 that's it and the third one third one is
2:02:13 fight them if they refuse that but also
2:02:17 there is an option in the case of fight
2:02:19 which is not mentioned the local answer
2:02:21 you cannot just uh take the Hadith or
2:02:24 take the Hadith
2:02:27 when you have to take all of them all
2:02:29 evidence to Allah has to be taken
2:02:30 equally but well balanced
2:02:33 in that case they may set it in the
2:02:35 fight say listen we offer complete peace
2:02:37 complete peace meaning hostility will
2:02:40 cease completely you have to do that on
2:02:42 our domain and we conversate for ill and
2:02:45 if they have like if they have occupied
2:02:47 they take a Muslim land like Israel they
2:02:49 they decide to board the ships and go
2:02:52 back very completely then this can stop
2:02:54 the world
2:02:55 that's based on the Ayah in general
2:02:58 and in the case of a Siege of a castle
2:03:01 and now you are unable to take them down
2:03:03 to take them out and they they negotiate
2:03:07 with you to to accept a settlement with
2:03:09 you but they said if they ask you the
2:03:12 only the Only Rule there if they ask who
2:03:14 we want to we won't come down on a
2:03:16 settlement which is accepted by Allah by
2:03:18 God tell them I cannot guarantee that we
2:03:20 are settlement we accepted or what I'm
2:03:22 offering you the accepted by God I give
2:03:24 you the Covenant my Covenant and my word
2:03:26 I cannot tell you the Covenant of God
2:03:29 I I cannot call convene and behalf of
2:03:31 God and convey about myself
2:03:33 in the case some anyone break the
2:03:35 Covenant and so on they knew it is is is
2:03:37 outrageous to break the Covenant of
2:03:39 Allah but breaking your Covenant is
2:03:41 outrageous but a less severe number so
2:03:43 this had it explain all of these things
2:03:45 all options are there
2:03:47 so if they initially in the initiation
2:03:49 of such entities started by
2:03:52 like that for example the one who
2:03:53 started like that which were before that
2:03:55 they were liable of War
2:03:57 and they are allowed to uh to uh to uh
2:04:01 to to keep their own independence like
2:04:03 this which we could call it the right of
2:04:05 self-determination fine if that's it
2:04:08 then later on it's very well possible
2:04:10 who somehow joined and immigrated to say
2:04:12 listen
2:04:13 being in the in the Federation does not
2:04:15 serve our things I'm not happy with this
2:04:16 situation but usually it will not happen
2:04:18 unless there's a reason not to be
2:04:20 unhappy but assume it happens
2:04:22 but we do it as a
2:04:24 um
2:04:25 as a society by voting I think there's
2:04:29 no uh they uh there's no uh there is no
2:04:32 objects to that and this is hinted
2:04:34 actually that maybe one case or two
2:04:36 indicates
2:04:38 was like that because we have a
2:04:40 narration a good narration Forum are
2:04:41 saying say I wish I would have as the
2:04:43 messenger Allah about various things one
2:04:46 of them is what I mentioned now
2:04:47 obviously also will say it many times
2:04:49 they wish to ask about kalada but he
2:04:51 asked I never understood let me
2:04:54 discussed that already in about it and
2:04:56 ask about uh if if there's any any
2:04:59 allocation of the of the power after him
2:05:01 anyone is being appointed after him and
2:05:04 we no need to ask we know it is not we
2:05:06 have all the Hadith and evidence of
2:05:07 nobody because whenever appointing is
2:05:09 the Oma so that's not the third one an
2:05:11 interesting question and there's a
2:05:13 fourth four or five issues to do with
2:05:14 that and that's it I wish I would have
2:05:16 said him if some people say
2:05:19 probably there because the fight of the
2:05:21 red that was about zaka if they say we
2:05:23 we bring out the zakah
2:05:27 and we distributed but we didn't give it
2:05:29 to you a minute
2:05:30 there seem to be some people offered
2:05:32 that
2:05:33 I wish I have I have asked him are we
2:05:36 then allowed to fight them or not so
2:05:39 Roma was doubting about this point
2:05:43 which shows that in matter of
2:05:45 understanding State and say is much
2:05:47 better than the majority of sahaba he
2:05:49 understood
2:05:51 there's something there
2:05:54 but also I don't understand
2:05:57 they have a head of state and they
2:05:59 declared him to be covered under
2:06:01 and he told them will not prevent you
2:06:03 for coming to the machine unless you
2:06:05 fight us
2:06:12 so they can they can succeed
2:06:15 but they have to do it the properly say
2:06:17 we're not fighting but we are we we
2:06:19 decided that we're not happy with this
2:06:21 Federation we are out whatever it is
2:06:23 provided they as a community both
2:06:26 properly or do the shoulder probably
2:06:28 not some shift and they are enforcer
2:06:30 with their people
2:06:32 like for example what Cottage are doing
2:06:34 now by by looking for a vote and things
2:06:37 like that
2:06:41 completely destroys daesh yeah yeah
2:06:44 let's go to the career
2:06:46 poor guys they they're relying on on
2:06:49 mutilated understanding of toheed and so
2:06:52 on from wahhabi and this is the rely on
2:06:54 events and all of these of this
2:06:58 accommodated over history you cannot
2:07:01 believe them that's the level of
2:07:02 understanding you blame it that because
2:07:04 of that level standing they're pulling
2:07:05 the sword and killing others they create
2:07:06 them together
2:07:08 that's a blame
2:07:10 but uh but you cannot really blame many
2:07:13 people over
2:07:15 I I saw recently justifying a comment
2:07:17 before we close I saw recently a video
2:07:20 in Colorado admitting that he hid
2:07:22 something for 20 years that was what was
2:07:23 he hiding let me listen to
2:07:25 and the thing out that says he came to
2:07:27 the conclusion I even part of his
2:07:29 conclusion Rock said 20 years ago I came
2:07:31 to the conclusion that stoning is not
2:07:34 Islamic as a Jewish is a Jewish
2:07:37 Jewish law
2:07:40 approved by the prophet that's a mistake
2:07:43 a small mistake there but look at his
2:07:44 goals
2:07:45 and the letter is abrogated by by the
2:07:48 solar and he didn't they are seeing it
2:07:50 20 years and now before his death he
2:07:52 said it that we are saying that long ago
2:07:55 and we Derek to say it long ago but even
2:07:58 he said it was approved that of it no it
2:08:00 was the the Eye of stoning
2:08:04 abrogated the eye of holding woman until
2:08:06 they die who committed adultery and the
2:08:09 eye of stoning came down
2:08:12 which is a better than the the ruling of
2:08:14 the president because it is it has
2:08:16 become general for men and women so it's
2:08:18 smashed away these these masculine
2:08:20 masculinism patriarchy Society
2:08:22 completely and shortly that that
2:08:25 adultery and fornication is as bad for
2:08:27 woman as bad for a woman no difference
2:08:29 whatsoever secondly it made the
2:08:31 difference for married men and women
2:08:32 they they will have stoning but the the
2:08:35 non-married and whatever it is what
2:08:37 definition of and Baker they have a
2:08:40 milder treatment so there was enough
2:08:43 deterrence for a certain time and even
2:08:45 it was applied for a couple of cases and
2:08:47 then before the the Ayah was lifted and
2:08:49 this ruling was gone and they
2:08:51 substituted so that's so that's the
2:08:54 secret he has holding so if a man of
2:08:55 that which has such a public standing of
2:08:58 kalawi and have even platforms and so on
2:09:01 did not have the courage and that's
2:09:03 supposed to be a classical scholar
2:09:05 to say that then you know what's the
2:09:08 level of our scholarship has has
2:09:09 happened
2:09:11 his argument is is impeccable with a
2:09:14 small modification but essentially
2:09:15 fundamentally correct
2:09:18 but he did not they're saying it
2:09:22 anyway alhamdulillah we were there
2:09:24 saying what we think really the evidence
2:09:26 but Buffs are really doing the hard work
2:09:28 not not it is it's not it's not boiling
2:09:31 eggs it's much much more complex than
2:09:33 deeper than that but if we do it
2:09:34 properly we would say
2:09:36 uh interestingly uh we uh there's
2:09:39 there's the appendix of the Constitution
2:09:41 of the party of the party is the
2:09:43 appendix called the basic rules of
2:09:46 deduction deducing outcome and so on is
2:09:48 about 11 places by itself we have
2:09:50 reviewed at recently had edited I think
2:09:52 we have published and also that is
2:09:53 mentioned as an example as a small
2:09:55 example just short in it and other
2:09:58 things and this will be uh this will be
2:10:01 I think in the intro uh maybe I will
2:10:04 give it I'll give it to you in a few
2:10:05 days together with the one about
2:10:07 immigration National States belongings
2:10:11 and the right of self-determination
2:10:14 should be here in a couple of days and
2:10:16 then we start translating it inshallah
2:10:19 and they will give this one to also be
2:10:21 it for translation also the other one
2:10:23 all this part of the Constitution of the
2:10:25 head of the party but because it has
2:10:27 really significance and summarized
2:10:29 things I think very concisely and nicely
2:10:30 I think
2:10:32 it's worth I mentioned all these
2:10:35 principles without all the arguments
2:10:37 arguments and details
2:10:39 is just a summary it's like a article
2:10:42 one article two article three is about
2:10:44 20 articles which symbolizes most of
2:10:46 these researchers also I think we should
2:10:48 we should look in translating that also
2:10:50 uh making it available for the wider
2:10:53 public here okay
2:10:55 foreign
2:11:17 Music
2:11:28 foreign
2:11:33 Music
2:11:42 Music
2:11:47 Music
2:11:58 foreign
2:12:05 Music