0:00:06 Music
0:00:19 thank you
0:00:21 Music
0:00:41 foreign
0:00:55 these episodes of broadcast live on the
0:00:57 study Circles of Professor Dr Muhammad
0:00:59 al-masri YouTube channel every Sunday on
0:01:01 the new 1pm UK time
0:01:04 we invite you to subscribe to the
0:01:05 channel and activate the notification
0:01:07 Bell for all new content
0:01:09 please note also the link to the live
0:01:10 broadcast for widely dissemination do
0:01:13 not forget to interact with us during
0:01:14 the broadcast by participating in the
0:01:16 comments and asking questions through
0:01:17 the chat box you find via the broadcast
0:01:19 link next to the video
0:01:21 also do not forget to support our
0:01:23 activities by donating when asking
0:01:24 questions in the conversation or through
0:01:26 the thank you button under
0:01:29 our video
0:01:30 today is Sunday the 27th of November
0:01:34 the professor continues the
0:01:36 interpretation of Surah we are on Ayah
0:01:40 38.
0:01:42 sorry sort of
0:01:44 my apologies certain maida 38. it's
0:01:48 correct
0:01:50 oh yeah sorry yeah yes you're right yes
0:02:13 although there is no Beast that walks on
0:02:15 Earth and no bird that flies on its two
0:02:18 Wings which is not God's creature like
0:02:20 yourselves no thing or thing have we
0:02:23 neglected in our decree and once again
0:02:25 unto their sustainer they all they shall
0:02:28 all be gathered next translation
0:02:31 every Beast that crawls on the earth and
0:02:34 every birds that fly with its two Wings
0:02:36 have formed communities like you we have
0:02:39 left nothing out of the book they will
0:02:41 be gathered through their lord yeah so
0:02:44 let's just the meaning is very clear but
0:02:47 there's some some issues which are the
0:02:49 odd so Beast or is actually the word dab
0:02:52 from the beep from the when you walk the
0:02:55 sound is the beep so any any material
0:02:57 being which is made out of metal
0:02:59 uh
0:03:05 obviously we know now that even light is
0:03:08 having uh in that sense can be affected
0:03:10 by a tissue but there's so many that can
0:03:12 be ignored so things which are having
0:03:14 weight have right and if they walk they
0:03:16 sort of make a sound this is a dab that
0:03:19 to distinguish them from angels and
0:03:20 spirits and demos and things like that
0:03:22 so whatever daba is in it or a bird
0:03:25 Which flies with two wings
0:03:28 it's interesting to think why you
0:03:30 mentioned a bit better flying with his
0:03:31 two wings uh evidently all bears have
0:03:34 two wings but maybe a hint that being
0:03:37 winged with two Wings is a minimum
0:03:39 there's no way you can fly with one week
0:03:40 it may be it may be uh One Wing will
0:03:43 have two or two branches left a left and
0:03:45 right that is actually two Wings this
0:03:46 Wing is is a Double Wing like the
0:03:49 so-called flying wing it looks like but
0:03:51 it's actually shaped uh as a really has
0:03:55 two wings of a joint together so the
0:03:57 appears they call the flying goodness
0:03:58 cycle the flying two Wings join together
0:04:01 but anyway that's a secondary point
0:04:03 and the things that I see that they
0:04:05 thought it has struggling with the
0:04:07 translation
0:04:09 usually people will translate as Nations
0:04:12 or communities but the word Imam wrote
0:04:15 amama in Arabic is having very rich
0:04:17 meanings
0:04:19 first of all it is uh
0:04:22 it means that something was leading of
0:04:23 the forehead or the one who leads the
0:04:26 Imam the leader the leader Community for
0:04:29 example
0:04:31 let's ask him uh uh he tested him
0:04:34 certain tests and they said I'm going to
0:04:36 appoint you Adidas foreign
0:04:43 why why I'm saying that because uh in
0:04:46 some deal with she I said Ibrahim was
0:04:48 appointed Imam Muhammad Imam and they
0:04:50 might also have to be appointed I say
0:04:52 every minute luxury leaders that's fine
0:04:54 now we're not discussing that that's not
0:04:55 an issue that's not a major issue if you
0:04:58 mean a head of state he was not head of
0:04:59 state and Muhammad was ahead of himself
0:05:00 sometime and they were upside him does
0:05:02 not necessary to be head of state
0:05:04 one of them became 100 state or two Ali
0:05:07 and Hassan and the other not so that's
0:05:08 just a side note
0:05:10 is a community and I mean it's something
0:05:13 connected to certain connecting
0:05:15 principle like for example when uh when
0:05:19 when Musa came to the water of media the
0:05:22 world of Wonder he found that um
0:05:25 a collection of people
0:05:27 which have something binding them what's
0:05:29 binding them is that they come to uh to
0:05:32 uh water or give water to the the
0:05:34 animals so this the spirit was making
0:05:37 them coming together in that place
0:05:39 otherwise they are scattered everyone
0:05:40 Grazing In His Valley elsewhere but now
0:05:42 they become after being scattered yes
0:05:45 scattered people they became like an
0:05:47 ummah but through the nation is just a
0:05:49 group which having a certain activity at
0:05:51 a certain time and it means also a time
0:05:54 which is connected one piece of one long
0:05:56 time which has no gaps a well example
0:05:59 for that is in Surah Yusuf when he
0:06:02 interpreted the dreams of the two
0:06:03 companions in jail
0:06:05 and told the one the one who I believe
0:06:10 they would be surviving because in the
0:06:11 vision one dream that bears will be
0:06:14 eating from his head so it keeps it is
0:06:16 it is to assume that it's this one is
0:06:18 the one who will be crucified and the
0:06:20 Bears will it is his head
0:06:24 and the other one was was was uh was a
0:06:28 pouring hammer or squeezinger and making
0:06:31 use of hormones experimenting and this
0:06:33 one is the one who will be giving a
0:06:35 drink to his Lord and this one was over
0:06:37 it was most likely before that employed
0:06:39 in the Royal Palace
0:06:41 but by is it not necessary sometimes you
0:06:44 see a dream for someone else and someone
0:06:45 say for you so
0:06:47 it may be possible that the one who saw
0:06:49 that he is crucified is not the one who
0:06:51 will crucified the one who will be saved
0:06:52 and so on and that's a possibility is
0:06:53 there keep that in mind for dreams it's
0:06:55 not 33 in dream is appealing to me for
0:06:57 you is not necessary for you maybe for
0:06:59 your cousin for someone else and vice
0:07:01 versa but this is one one possibility
0:07:04 and the product as you mentioned that in
0:07:06 Hadith saying
0:07:11 for him
0:07:13 so that's it and he will be representing
0:07:16 that moment in the dream so this
0:07:17 possibility but obviously Joseph knew or
0:07:19 uh with with on the balance of privacy
0:07:22 who will be surviving and then he told
0:07:24 the one who will survive remember to
0:07:27 tell your lord my situation that I am
0:07:29 imprisoned and justifying that's what
0:07:31 but this one was jubilant when he was
0:07:33 released and when the Lord is the king
0:07:35 appointed him again as a chief the drink
0:07:38 or something like that and he forget
0:07:41 completely
0:07:42 completely it's amazing that this
0:07:44 happens
0:07:45 he completely how do we know that when
0:07:49 the king saw his vision
0:07:50 suddenly as if waking up to a dream he
0:07:53 remembered after
0:07:59 um
0:08:00 after prolonged time with no break in
0:08:03 that time there was Allah that he did
0:08:05 not even have any second and which
0:08:07 remembered what what she also told him
0:08:09 otherwise he would have approached his
0:08:11 King but we complete it was erased from
0:08:13 his mind until the vision that's
0:08:15 obviously most likely by Allah but this
0:08:17 can't happen it can happen very well
0:08:19 that you remember something
0:08:21 completely or you forget something
0:08:23 completely and remembered maybe years
0:08:26 after
0:08:28 you remember that has happened to me for
0:08:31 example it's a in a secondary issue but
0:08:33 it's not a second in some sense I
0:08:35 remember wearing everyone's traveling in
0:08:37 Germany in my in the 60s and uh and uh I
0:08:42 I decided for some reason I want to do
0:08:43 I'll do also later
0:08:45 yeah
0:08:46 and I forgot to do that
0:08:50 until recently
0:08:52 I remember the story did I do it no I
0:08:55 remember that family I didn't do it
0:08:57 after that until that day I made it up
0:08:59 50 years later so hey anyway so it can
0:09:03 happen it kind of Israel that can happen
0:09:04 in that case maybe by Allah's
0:09:06 intervention he wanted to keep Yusuf in
0:09:08 prison for this time so that he can
0:09:10 develop his character and Dodge in
0:09:12 meditation indulging Dua and Elgin
0:09:13 prayer being in prison sometimes in a
0:09:16 considerable time of self-improvement
0:09:18 and self-portion so don't take prison is
0:09:20 always negative it's negative for
0:09:22 negative people but this could be
0:09:25 correcting an improvements for people
0:09:27 who have a core of goodness that they
0:09:29 can grow it while being in prison
0:09:30 because you have nothing else to do
0:09:31 except maybe some work and some
0:09:33 imprisonment that they are obliged to do
0:09:35 some work and so on for earning or for
0:09:37 not earning depending about the
0:09:38 different system but there's an
0:09:39 opportunity to reflect and think about
0:09:41 yourself and analyze further and develop
0:09:43 further anyway
0:09:44 whatever the reason Allah Allah Knows
0:09:47 Best
0:09:48 that remembered after um
0:09:52 leadership no
0:09:55 is connected
0:09:57 with a thread of complete forgetfulness
0:10:00 through that so it is it so all these
0:10:04 animals and birds
0:10:05 are umam
0:10:07 communities having something connecting
0:10:10 them obviously we know how it's
0:10:12 connected genetically they have the same
0:10:14 the same number of chromosomes and other
0:10:17 features a certain uh joint uh genetic
0:10:21 markups and so on even if they have the
0:10:23 same number of chromosome like another
0:10:24 species they have distinct which
0:10:26 distinguishing
0:10:28 uh my uh Marcus from the other Etc
0:10:32 but also they have certain joint
0:10:36 type of instinct and so on classifying
0:10:38 them and possibly there are even smaller
0:10:41 groups living in one area like from
0:10:43 Lions they live like in Prides and their
0:10:45 scattered we have lines up here we have
0:10:47 Lions still in India it's smaller than
0:10:49 the lands of Africa and there were lands
0:10:51 in between all the way but because of
0:10:52 the advanced
0:10:54 desertification in the last three four
0:10:57 thousand years uh the Arabian Peninsula
0:11:00 has lost its lines the same with Iraq
0:11:02 and Persia and also there were Barbers
0:11:05 were really Tigers uh like power power
0:11:07 Indian tigers no not not not the bats
0:11:10 they were there and even levels were
0:11:13 there so there's no connection but
0:11:15 through the community there or there's a
0:11:16 community various Community they're
0:11:17 separated by long distances so Community
0:11:19 or something like that anyway they have
0:11:22 also features they have certain certain
0:11:24 instinctive and possibly certain
0:11:26 injunction we don't know how what level
0:11:28 of of responsibility injection they have
0:11:31 there are some Hadith which hence that
0:11:33 someone could say it is metaphorical for
0:11:36 the exactness and the conclusiveness of
0:11:38 accounting like for example all our
0:11:42 scores in the Dunya will be settled even
0:11:45 the the uh the the sheep or the goat
0:11:50 which has no horn being honed or being
0:11:52 headbutted by another Hornet he will
0:11:56 have a retribution
0:11:57 he will have a distribution
0:11:59 but all narration indicate that the
0:12:02 Beast all of the beasts with few
0:12:03 exceptions will turn into dust so the
0:12:05 accounting will be just setting the
0:12:07 account between themselves do they have
0:12:08 certain is the Instinct enough
0:12:10 responsibility so that the account to
0:12:12 that ground do they have enough
0:12:13 distinction distinction of right and
0:12:15 wrong in this limited sense that uh
0:12:18 a goat which has massive massive horns
0:12:21 recognize that it should not be
0:12:23 head-butting a horn uh got on the same
0:12:26 species which doesn't have uh maybe by
0:12:29 Instinct and if it does nevertheless so
0:12:31 it has like a minimal free will we don't
0:12:33 know but if that Hadith is at face and
0:12:35 not metaphorical many people say it's
0:12:38 metaphorical the settling of account is
0:12:40 so extreme and so exactly that even if
0:12:43 goats would be resurrected this would be
0:12:45 settled that's one possible anyway
0:12:47 there's a hint here that there may be
0:12:49 somehow uh will be gathered to the Lord
0:12:52 the Gathering to the Lord does not mean
0:12:53 that will be resurrected careful
0:12:55 Gathering is something different that
0:12:56 migrants affected because after the
0:12:58 selection there may be Agame after
0:13:00 Gathering memory Resurrection Maybe not
0:13:01 maybe they gather through the load and
0:13:03 then he declares him you did your path
0:13:05 in the universe now just be erased from
0:13:09 history or something else we don't know
0:13:11 but there are some kind of community
0:13:13 with certain structure and so on which
0:13:14 have similar to the human community and
0:13:16 the human Gatherings and so on
0:13:18 and everything is under under record by
0:13:20 Alpha that's the most important point
0:13:21 with the ISS smartphones we have not
0:13:25 neglected anything in the book
0:13:27 that's a metaphorical nothing is
0:13:29 escaping Allah's knowledge everything is
0:13:31 recorded Allah
0:13:33 so if you think
0:13:34 God's sake look at the ant colony
0:13:39 and ant colony we may have easily
0:13:41 Millions I think and there are big
0:13:42 colonies which stretch somewhere into
0:13:44 billions
0:13:45 so we have all over the world maybe
0:13:47 trillions of ants
0:13:49 doesn't seem to be possible to keep
0:13:51 track of that
0:13:52 no no
0:13:54 every one of them has kept track of
0:13:56 don't worry every one of them
0:13:59 and even there may be in other planets
0:14:02 similar cliche like ants most likely
0:14:04 similar there will be some there will
0:14:05 always will be somehow similar other
0:14:07 Christian there there may be other ants
0:14:09 in another galaxy
0:14:11 trillions of them and another there who
0:14:14 is able to keep track of that
0:14:16 nothing is be is off record everything
0:14:19 is on record so don't don't worry about
0:14:21 that all is all record
0:14:23 there's a nice note about that but ant
0:14:25 colonies and there's a Hadith
0:14:27 related to that nothing is upside from
0:14:30 Allah's knowledge
0:14:34 is it a profit settled down in you know
0:14:37 in a battle Cambrian or that travel
0:14:39 campaign and there are three to have an
0:14:41 app
0:14:42 but they don't notice that there's an
0:14:44 ant colony nearby
0:14:46 so when Aunt beat him
0:14:48 so he woke up obviously upset he said
0:14:58 maybe another one
0:15:00 and so many prophets we have no record
0:15:02 whatsoever
0:15:03 and then he was so angry he ordered the
0:15:05 whole and couldn't be bad
0:15:07 Allah shaded him see because one ant bit
0:15:12 you you exterminated the complete colony
0:15:14 of ants complete nation of ants who are
0:15:17 busy glorifying me
0:15:20 if you must take revenge it should have
0:15:22 been one hand
0:15:24 but the one who bought it with you
0:15:26 that's all that's only one bit don't
0:15:28 kill one one for one one for a colony
0:15:31 which kind of excesses that it was
0:15:34 a lot of what was going on what was
0:15:37 happening all of that happening I said
0:15:38 no don't think it's not that well only
0:15:40 the materialists who think is only an
0:15:42 issue with a dead blind and so on I
0:15:44 think everything is in vain I think
0:15:45 would inspired whether it's no it's not
0:15:48 a little bit for what foreign
0:16:11 they say because he sees what happened
0:16:13 to the animal that they attend us so who
0:16:15 should be like the animals maybe we
0:16:17 don't know there's nothing really
0:16:18 compelling so that we make it parts of
0:16:20 Akita no but they are gathered to the
0:16:23 Lord for whatever purpose
0:16:24 a type of gathering it means
0:16:29 so they would be gathered today a lot
0:16:33 foreign
0:16:58 something like that
0:17:00 uh and that one obviously you cannot
0:17:02 have a distribution because you cannot
0:17:04 control injuries to the other this way
0:17:05 if it's just a facial injury you may
0:17:07 resist to aim to be surface the injured
0:17:09 but if it goes deep that is not
0:17:11 controllable so you have just to get
0:17:13 happy with the financial conversation
0:17:15 and things like that so movement is the
0:17:18 one here which hits the head that set
0:17:20 away
0:17:21 so this is
0:17:25 and the other aspects is most of it is
0:17:28 metaphysical we don't know what this
0:17:29 Gathering is all about and also the
0:17:31 north Divine knowledge is obviously
0:17:32 something which is not accessible to our
0:17:34 immediate uh
0:17:36 perception or even imagination how it
0:17:39 appear so comprehensive and enormous
0:17:46 um
0:17:52 translate and they who give the light to
0:17:55 our messages are deaf and dumb in
0:17:58 darkness deep who whomever God Wills he
0:18:01 let's go astray and whomever he Wills
0:18:04 he places upon a straight path next
0:18:06 translation those who reject our
0:18:07 messages are dumb are deaf dumb and deep
0:18:10 in darkness whomever God Wills he lets
0:18:13 go astray and who remember whomever he
0:18:15 Wills he places upon a straight path
0:18:17 yeah so they the the what's wrong says
0:18:21 especially in going astray they they
0:18:23 admitted the right things say let him go
0:18:26 astray or the Quran say he whoever Allah
0:18:29 he will go astray say it as willing
0:18:32 there is willing not saying but
0:18:33 everything to go astray but that's the
0:18:35 correct meaning that translation is
0:18:36 correct
0:18:37 definitely correctly because of the
0:18:39 evidences of the Quran but you find many
0:18:41 even
0:18:43 most other breeder from from some
0:18:46 so-called Sunnah persuasion mostly and
0:18:48 madhali and wahhabi and so on they think
0:18:50 SRI Allah will someone to go astray in
0:18:52 the same that winning to do an act not
0:18:55 permitting him to go astray according to
0:18:56 his own reason and because they don't
0:18:58 read the rest of the Quran and they
0:19:00 don't have a clear idea about the Qatar
0:19:02 and they are wavering they go sometimes
0:19:03 to extreme right except
0:19:05 left and they never find any way because
0:19:09 they do not read they read the Quran
0:19:12 without digesting it and that's that's
0:19:15 what made them
0:19:17 so that's also secondary that's a
0:19:19 mistake of the scholars so all of this
0:19:21 is it I'm reading the Quran without
0:19:23 digesting it is a disease of also most
0:19:26 human beings but if it has become so
0:19:27 fundamental that such issues are not
0:19:29 digested properly then you become halaji
0:19:32 minor issues everyone will have that we
0:19:35 will not nobody would be able to they
0:19:37 just solve the Quran no doubt the depth
0:19:40 of it and the various layers of meaning
0:19:42 did we discuss at the beginning the
0:19:44 Hadith ruled that the Quran is having an
0:19:47 affair of meaning a deep meaning or
0:19:48 button to several depths to Seven Levels
0:19:51 so we didn't discuss it
0:19:53 you have discussed our questions
0:19:55 and so on so
0:20:00 the best Scholars they may got most of
0:20:04 their and maybe one button what about
0:20:07 the other buttons total depth
0:20:10 so we'll not be able to digest
0:20:12 everything but at least just the most
0:20:14 fundamental things the most important
0:20:15 things
0:20:17 then
0:20:18 if you don't adjust that
0:20:20 by well that happened by by taking this
0:20:23 eye out of the out of this context but
0:20:25 also not available
0:20:51 this is an interesting subject so if you
0:20:54 look at how schools developed
0:20:56 when you've got the hanafi school then
0:20:58 the Reliance on righty and then if you
0:21:01 look at the nudgley school and it's it's
0:21:02 it's unlikely to be a coincidence in
0:21:05 terms of
0:21:05 how they have a very regimented approach
0:21:08 and because they don't have the
0:21:10 conceptual depth they always used to
0:21:12 rebuke The Other Side by saying that
0:21:14 they're just using Russian and all that
0:21:17 kind of stuff is it it's not
0:21:18 coincidental that the the level of depth
0:21:21 that you get from the nudge the wahhabi
0:21:23 school is is that superficial uh it's
0:21:26 it's fantastic I saw a video recently
0:21:28 just a couple of days ago when when
0:21:31 uh Egyptian someone asked him uh what's
0:21:36 about the Earth is it a flat Orca or or
0:21:38 around say you should ask only about
0:21:41 things to benefit you
0:21:43 and then he mentioned various elements
0:21:45 say
0:21:45 always available of the saying that
0:21:48 there is is quite as wood-shaped or
0:21:51 egg-shaped all what they have is of NASA
0:21:53 and the picture is that an authority
0:21:56 should we live if we take a Quran for
0:21:58 there and they mentioned the various
0:22:00 straightforward eyes which they invoke
0:22:02 which is completely miseried
0:22:06 like for example image of the following
0:22:07 uh let's mention that quickly because
0:22:09 maybe some of these uh we call them
0:22:11 obviously
0:22:14 Russia
0:22:20 um
0:22:22 I didn't understand you said what you
0:22:24 call them
0:22:26 someone laying flat to say yeah just to
0:22:29 promote them okay
0:22:32 you said you faster to the land
0:22:38 anyway he mentioned Russia the famous
0:22:42 one is
0:22:49 equivalent to being flat no salt has the
0:22:52 surface everything has a surface your
0:22:54 body has a surface if I say look at this
0:22:56 Man how he is selfish how the skin fits
0:22:59 on his body in this way
0:23:01 you you may you you make sense of that's
0:23:04 a question because we don't think about
0:23:06 that because everyone is have skin snack
0:23:07 but there's a certain diseases where the
0:23:09 skin separate from the body and start
0:23:11 hanging then you can say look how this
0:23:14 has been surfaced
0:23:15 it's an odd disease but that's another
0:23:18 set of physique and a pathological
0:23:20 surfacing so that's that's one and
0:23:22 there's another recording for Zakir Naik
0:23:24 the the Indian diary although he comes
0:23:27 from like like I had it back around it
0:23:29 because he is a medical doctor
0:23:30 originally and has some brain the man so
0:23:33 he mentioned the eye of uh attending the
0:23:36 day around the night and night as my
0:23:38 necessity it must be and also the issue
0:23:40 that he and he entered the night in the
0:23:42 day bit by bit ulich and the opposite it
0:23:45 can be impossible for Flat Earth so
0:23:47 sorry
0:23:48 about this
0:23:52 is actually the Egg of the ostrich which
0:23:55 is exactly similar to the Airship is
0:23:56 that if it's exaggerated obviously so
0:23:58 you can see it but this
0:24:00 so this donkey and says we're not going
0:24:03 to take the pictures and what NASA and
0:24:05 the other civilian Authority completely
0:24:08 Undead these people are completely dead
0:24:09 completely brain dead
0:24:13 because that happens when you divide the
0:24:16 Quran section and read one Ayah without
0:24:18 reading the other Ayah without comparing
0:24:20 with all other eyes to the Quran and you
0:24:22 should do it deliberately Allah said to
0:24:24 construct a possible contradiction so
0:24:26 that the world is not from Allah and
0:24:28 he's challenging you you will not find
0:24:29 that you will not fight any country but
0:24:31 by doing this when I convention to what
0:24:34 your imagination to what we will say in
0:24:36 the street no to another Ayah or can I
0:24:39 develop and yeah but this comes from
0:24:42 reading a Quran
0:24:43 with a sealed heart a
0:24:47 residents
0:24:52 management they manage the economics
0:24:54 managing the Quran if you manage a book
0:24:56 meaning you work with it
0:24:59 you put it together you sort of explain
0:25:00 this with this that's management I
0:25:02 really think it's just nice voices maybe
0:25:04 you can you can sing it very nicely
0:25:06 that's not a double the double
0:25:12 they decided and then even he mentioned
0:25:14 after they say and some of the sellers
0:25:16 declared whatever say the essence is is
0:25:18 a ball as a kaffir and insult to injury
0:25:21 make himself an utter utter disgrace
0:25:24 I couldn't comment on that video except
0:25:25 saying really you are a donkey that's
0:25:27 all right I couldn't say I think
0:25:29 it was
0:25:33 so let's go back to our issues so that's
0:25:35 that's uh that's
0:25:37 translator luckily have passed that
0:25:41 stage in the issue of valara because
0:25:43 obviously it's as impossible for Allah
0:25:45 to to will someone to go astray no he
0:25:48 ever met him but it says the reason and
0:25:51 rest of the Quran but the same actually
0:25:59 because it's a bonus he may help in that
0:26:03 enlightened open his mind for more
0:26:05 things that's perfectly fine there's no
0:26:06 ingested there but fundamentally he has
0:26:10 to do the first step then Allah will add
0:26:13 bonus in the case of the Lara he never
0:26:15 had anything
0:26:16 but here here is also allowed to
0:26:19 um
0:26:22 he will permit him to be on on that
0:26:25 right path because he started the job
0:26:27 and did that did the work
0:26:29 and then he can add more that is
0:26:33 like a Highway uh uh a big Highway with
0:26:38 many lanes you just get into
0:26:41 we are left arriving in English or to
0:26:43 the left lane with a slower speed Allah
0:26:44 can step in and give you
0:26:46 boost so you can go to the right more
0:26:48 right lens for Speedy and speedier more
0:26:50 guidance more speed but you are already
0:26:51 in the late you enter the name you enter
0:26:54 the highway first do that then I will
0:26:56 give you a boost to to go from the left
0:26:59 lane to the more right lanes with higher
0:27:01 speed
0:27:03 that's the way it works
0:27:04 so
0:27:05 but these people most people who are
0:27:08 stuck in Java and so on there and you
0:27:09 saying
0:27:11 because they they are Blended but they
0:27:14 did not even read the eyes of example in
0:27:16 and Surah the or Samsung
0:27:20 about the sword honestly
0:27:23 he inspired them with their old soul
0:27:26 with his with its translation and with
0:27:28 righteousness
0:27:30 I mean it's capable of both as I mean
0:27:32 you could have free will for both and
0:27:34 then the next exercise
0:27:35 successful would be the one who purify
0:27:38 himself now attribute amplification to
0:27:40 the man himself
0:27:42 we should be must be a correct as
0:27:44 tribulation because too far enough being
0:27:45 as we discussed many times
0:27:50 the other metaphorical meaning must must
0:27:52 be clear from the context so he's the
0:27:55 one who does the purification
0:28:08 to synchronize her soul and self down
0:28:10 instead of purifying he he is staying it
0:28:13 with Phil said
0:28:15 Philippines the action filthy thoughts
0:28:17 full theater or another also no thinking
0:28:20 no working nothing just say I don't want
0:28:21 to know about I'm just busy now making
0:28:23 money and stability that's that's what
0:28:26 it makes you filthy make your mind and
0:28:28 your heart filthy and get you doubt for
0:28:29 example
0:28:31 but we discussed in many cases but this
0:28:32 is what the example so that's the
0:28:34 question so the translator at least for
0:28:35 the first one they did it with that and
0:28:37 the other one they say that made it
0:28:38 attributed to the Divine because they
0:28:40 felt
0:28:41 somehow but they could have also
0:28:44 well a lot instead of saying
0:28:48 Allah allows him to be understood also
0:28:51 but later on after being on the set path
0:28:54 as I said giving the metaphor of the
0:28:56 highway with many lanes
0:28:58 he entered the highway when you enter
0:28:59 the highway where you enter and then if
0:29:01 the Indian land for example left left
0:29:03 driving country and they left mostly
0:29:05 because the other slow speed
0:29:07 now would be able to accelerate and
0:29:09 compete with the others and go to higher
0:29:10 lanes and have higher speed that in that
0:29:13 case Allah may have an input
0:29:15 directly or miraculously
0:29:17 sometimes even through the system
0:29:19 because the moment you get on the right
0:29:22 path the conditions around you
0:29:25 with some effort on your side I'll make
0:29:28 it right for you to have it to uh to
0:29:31 accelerate and so on you are already in
0:29:33 the in in the right in the right path on
0:29:36 the highway all it's just getting better
0:29:38 and better and better
0:29:39 in that case either way we're on doing
0:29:41 or are not doing so through the system
0:29:43 of the universal the system is so tuned
0:29:45 that in that case you can improve
0:29:49 by the design facility where you are
0:29:50 encouraged to improving Etc or by direct
0:29:53 action of Allah by Visions by dreams you
0:29:56 have no no hand in them which strengthen
0:29:58 you and Faith get you further and so on
0:30:01 good
0:30:03 I think I think we discussed harder many
0:30:05 times and discussed it because of the
0:30:06 realization question before you continue
0:30:08 um so I've got one question in relation
0:30:09 to the story of the answer
0:30:12 well uh bear with me there may be some
0:30:15 follow-on questions you may have from
0:30:16 this uh can we take hukum from the
0:30:19 stories of the animals and the past
0:30:21 Nations
0:30:22 depends on how the prophets have
0:30:24 mentioned it clearly he mentioned that
0:30:25 in in in in context that that uh that it
0:30:30 is it is uh worthy of shedding at least
0:30:33 of prohibition to destroy the untimes uh
0:30:36 especially with fire he said there are
0:30:38 many commands that the fire should not
0:30:40 be used to kill or destroy anything
0:30:42 secondly in retribution you should not
0:30:45 go excessive but establish that so the
0:30:46 stories enforce that and give you like a
0:30:48 visual like a drama which makes things
0:30:51 more more suitable closer to the heart
0:30:55 so we can't take okay it's that guidance
0:30:57 but that's that's not because it's a
0:30:59 previous Nation it's not that Authority
0:31:01 in itself
0:31:02 it may be an obligated Sharia yeah
0:31:06 that's a general question but there are
0:31:07 there must be some hints
0:31:09 there must be some hence there which you
0:31:11 have to guide you to think about the
0:31:13 mother and look for further evidence and
0:31:14 see what's happening and things like
0:31:16 that
0:31:18 good yeah
0:31:20 but they directly take home directly in
0:31:22 that sense form it's like this no that
0:31:24 would be not the correct way well I want
0:31:26 to always say that for the for for the
0:31:28 for for the sharing out of this prophet
0:31:32 he he he he stepped over over the bomb
0:31:37 and he committed that which is possibly
0:31:39 Hala which means the action of prophets
0:31:41 and so on are known to say and father
0:31:42 but unless we have extra evidence that's
0:31:44 you can take that in that because it's
0:31:46 about a statement of the fact what's the
0:31:48 nature of the universe only his
0:31:50 reporting from Allah which has leave no
0:31:52 doubt that is he reporting from Allah is
0:31:54 that valuable one anything else as long
0:31:55 as he's a prophet anything else because
0:31:57 we come and sort of to the one who who
0:32:00 is who jumped out of prophet and became
0:32:03 a shaytan I will come to that inshallah
0:32:06 but as long as I saw a prophet and we
0:32:08 read the story in the Old Testament
0:32:09 until the last moment when he failed
0:32:12 and sunk down he was truthful
0:32:15 but his action became miserable and then
0:32:17 that action was set so so grave that it
0:32:20 pulled him down and he lost forth
0:32:23 and then he will follow the shepherd and
0:32:25 became satanic then you cannot trust
0:32:26 anything chemical him neither words nor
0:32:28 anything
0:32:29 you can argue this way it needs it is
0:32:32 more of analytical things yeah
0:32:36 good
0:32:38 it is
0:32:39 no you cannot generally take a no no
0:32:42 evidences in a sense of sharia
0:32:44 injunction but but you can't take hints
0:32:47 and then you look for other evidences
0:32:48 then and most likely the stories
0:32:51 especially in the Quran the main
0:32:52 features there are very clear what they
0:32:55 entail what they mean although mostly is
0:32:58 forever and take lessons rather than
0:33:00 take Sherry eye Junction
0:33:03 like for example when Yusuf received
0:33:05 then the message of the king say come to
0:33:07 the king he said no I'm going to come
0:33:09 until I'm exonerated let's go back to
0:33:12 your lord and ask him another as I was
0:33:14 praising this I'd say if I were in the
0:33:16 place of Joseph and the messenger came
0:33:18 to me I would have one right away he's
0:33:20 praising Joseph it's this high rank it's
0:33:22 very difficult to achieve after so many
0:33:24 years in prison they can't say come
0:33:27 yeah you are your your you you are
0:33:29 released say no no I'm not going to come
0:33:31 first settle the court case check this
0:33:34 woman what they said is it true or not
0:33:36 clean my clean my my the record
0:33:39 completely I'm not going just bye bye
0:33:40 bye Royal Grace or just uh but no
0:33:43 on my ground that too and the kingdom
0:33:46 was held a court of law and the woman
0:33:49 admitted that that they fabricated and
0:33:52 so on so
0:33:54 and they will have
0:33:55 regretfully etc etc and then based on
0:33:58 that then Yusuf came after that
0:34:00 extermination he got a report everything
0:34:02 has been settled the king is absolutely
0:34:04 convinced
0:34:06 that this woman have light under the
0:34:08 fabricated stories this committed
0:34:10 perjury so the initial order to detain
0:34:14 you like any good law system is null and
0:34:16 void any issue as if you've never been
0:34:19 enacted we are sorry come now
0:34:21 I came in all honors but I love it too
0:34:23 is that also to praise Yusuf and put him
0:34:25 in a high rank and Automotive I think he
0:34:29 would have done better than Yusuf but
0:34:30 anyway he said if I were in the place of
0:34:32 Yusuf and the messenger of the king came
0:34:34 saying get out because I've gotten out
0:34:36 right away
0:34:38 okay so we can take from this set and
0:34:40 things certain hint set and uh issues
0:34:43 which is of issues of Aesthetics issues
0:34:45 of preferability and so on thus
0:34:47 appraising of the act of Yusuf and
0:34:49 definitely this is the show this is
0:34:51 highly desirable it's not obligatory
0:34:53 because he said I would have done it but
0:34:56 he said I would have done it and then
0:34:58 argue in the court case later that's no
0:34:59 problem but you should say no no I'm not
0:35:01 even going to step from the door until
0:35:03 this metal is settled I refuse to get
0:35:05 out I remember also certain cases I
0:35:07 don't know if there's some activities in
0:35:09 Saudi Arabia they will say you can't go
0:35:11 out now since I'm not going out open the
0:35:13 door instead he sat in and could listen
0:35:15 listen this is settled
0:35:17 something that happens so we have people
0:35:19 who who can get up to the level of user
0:35:22 Frank yeah so the message would have
0:35:24 been higher than that anyway but because
0:35:25 of modesty was to give us the hints what
0:35:28 should be done what could be done the
0:35:30 story is like that so with the Jews from
0:35:31 that something like that
0:35:33 from the comment of the Prophet not from
0:35:35 the story as mentioned in the Quran as
0:35:37 it is this is history
0:35:40 but it's clear what is it there for
0:35:42 example so from these stories we can
0:35:44 take head of certain things and analyze
0:35:46 but it needs sometimes a little bit
0:35:48 deeper look than than uh than the
0:35:51 shallow way of most uh foreign
0:36:07 flag there's some problem there not only
0:36:10 it's not only the whole I should be
0:36:11 mentioned maybe the whole context from
0:36:13 the beginning like today we started from
0:36:15 a new context about every bear that
0:36:17 animals are nations and so on this seems
0:36:19 to be relatively simulated context from
0:36:22 the previous one all this connected in a
0:36:24 deep sense but in method of legalistic
0:36:26 and and philosophical aspect is can't be
0:36:29 regarded as a Blockbuster if you don't
0:36:31 if he doesn't take the whole block from
0:36:33 beginning to end he will and then in
0:36:35 catastrophic results and that's helping
0:36:37 history look for example usually when
0:36:39 the invoke the will come to that
0:36:41 inshallah in due course the so-called
0:36:43 the Ayah of the sword in Surat uh
0:37:02 is even worse than that
0:37:05 if you read that
0:37:07 and there's other enemies of Islam take
0:37:08 that or something you can say oh they
0:37:10 called to kill everyone yes
0:37:12 that's catastrophic because you're free
0:37:15 the whole context we change the whole
0:37:17 story and the whole legal aspects
0:37:19 completely
0:37:30 from that
0:37:32 so
0:37:33 that could be catastrophic
0:37:35 genuinely catastrophic
0:37:38 and there in that ironic discussion I
0:37:41 didn't discuss only that either with the
0:37:42 context but all the various eyes and
0:37:43 bakara later Ayah right left under those
0:37:47 had made fighting conditioned on people
0:37:50 committing aggression against us that's
0:37:52 the specification the specific cannot be
0:37:55 obligated by The General
0:37:58 by the absolute it's not impossible even
0:38:00 if that one is later
0:38:02 but the one at the solar test
0:38:06 does it it is even it's not General but
0:38:10 even if you play General it gives you
0:38:11 only the club
0:38:13 it will mean go back to what I told you
0:38:15 what to do with the machine right all
0:38:17 you do so start the fight
0:38:19 that's still the Restriction is still
0:38:21 valid until today until tomorrow until I
0:38:23 see you until until I tell you fight
0:38:25 anyone even if they won't fight you it
0:38:27 must be specified like that to remove
0:38:29 the Restriction there's no it can be
0:38:32 abrogated that is a restriction or a
0:38:34 specification without another
0:38:36 specification negating that clearly and
0:38:38 outside just a general does not forget
0:38:40 that
0:38:43 foreign
0:38:54 and even in important things like war
0:38:57 and bees and and the fundamental things
0:38:59 about this belief and belief not only
0:39:01 that only that one context but other
0:39:03 other context which will like this one
0:39:05 if we see this he misguided anyone who
0:39:08 wants but to at least I look at
0:39:10 Solitaire
0:39:12 no no it is not the meaning is allow him
0:39:15 to go astray because if Allah does not
0:39:17 allow you to go astray or to be guided
0:39:19 you will never be able to achieve
0:39:21 anything unless permission must be so
0:39:22 that your will can work but the allowing
0:39:25 will be essentially allow you to choose
0:39:28 whatever you want to choose
0:39:30 this must be that long because if it
0:39:32 allows you only to choose guidance you
0:39:35 can't choose otherwise if it allows you
0:39:36 only to go astray you will go straight
0:39:38 there's no way so it will be the
0:39:40 fundamental point is that all these
0:39:43 actual humans who and other people who
0:39:46 are less sufficiently Free Will and so
0:39:48 on which which are a matter of the
0:39:50 subjects of accounting and
0:39:52 responsibility
0:39:53 the the the entity the finite into the
0:39:56 limited entity cannot perform it with
0:39:57 with its free will generally free will
0:40:00 even it's a limited one except by Allah
0:40:02 allowing them to choose whatever they
0:40:05 choose not allow them to make a certain
0:40:06 Choice otherwise it will be forcing you
0:40:09 to assess your choice because nothing
0:40:10 can happen the University of permission
0:40:12 so he he permits
0:40:15 let let that person choose whatever he
0:40:17 wants
0:40:19 done it can materialize otherwise we'll
0:40:22 never be materializing ever
0:40:26 ever because of the overwhelming
0:40:28 absolute dominance and control the
0:40:30 railways
0:40:32 okay so keep that hold that to your iron
0:40:35 fist
0:40:36 s
0:40:38 um
0:40:49 this one
0:40:51 say can you see yourselves invoking any
0:40:54 but God when God's chastisement befalls
0:40:57 of you in this world or the last hour
0:40:59 comes upon you tell me this if you are
0:41:01 men of Truth in Translation can you see
0:41:04 yourselves invoking any blood God when
0:41:06 God's punishment falls on you in this
0:41:08 world or when the last hour comes upon
0:41:10 you if you are truthful
0:41:12 and and that's that's that's a clear in
0:41:15 all nation in all situation even we we
0:41:18 have atheists for example in a big
0:41:19 Calamity like a car rolling over or
0:41:21 something like that if you can hear what
0:41:23 they're screaming some some people
0:41:24 survive or sometimes it's recorded
0:41:27 nowadays some people having own recorder
0:41:29 so you see them say oh God oh God oh God
0:41:33 foreign
0:41:45 even Hindus they will call just God
0:41:49 bhagwan without mentioning any space he
0:41:51 got one so it's a blim one
0:41:55 my Lord something like that
0:41:59 meaning the Supreme ones the mysterious
0:42:01 one
0:42:02 that would identify now or something
0:42:05 like the secret forced in the universe
0:42:06 or something like that in the moment of
0:42:07 distress and even the biggest desert
0:42:09 will be if they say if the hour comes
0:42:11 hour comes most likely will be such a
0:42:13 major event uh usually I somehow I I
0:42:17 cannot really get out of my mind that
0:42:19 maybe like an extra I throw it striking
0:42:21 the Earth
0:42:23 imagine a story striking death and you
0:42:26 say boom and you hear that no it will
0:42:28 happen only a few minutes before the
0:42:30 tidal wave comes and finishes everything
0:42:32 off
0:42:34 like the poor dinosaurs have that it
0:42:36 happened also before that I think at the
0:42:38 end of the permium and that one is in in
0:42:40 the Indian Ocean the one of the
0:42:41 dinosaurs is in Mexico they have they
0:42:44 have very good reasons to believe that's
0:42:46 over there and there are places of the
0:42:48 of the asteroid that would be the SA
0:42:53 help stood it it's gone
0:42:56 but in reality the only action will be
0:42:58 like that so next time
0:43:07 alone that you will evoke whereupon he
0:43:10 may if he so Wills remove that ill which
0:43:12 caused you to call unto him and you will
0:43:15 have forgotten all that to which you now
0:43:17 ascribe Divinity side by side with him
0:43:19 the translation no it is him alone that
0:43:23 you would call if it were his will he
0:43:25 may remove whatever harm that caused you
0:43:28 to call on him and you would have
0:43:29 forgotten all that you now associate
0:43:31 with him yeah so that new quality that's
0:43:34 your code and then he may kindly respond
0:43:38 but by by
0:43:42 by granting that what you want sometimes
0:43:45 he does no difference
0:43:48 but before before that
0:43:52 other list I think he can very well
0:43:54 accept on this one if he was insha
0:43:57 depending upon the machine and the
0:43:59 condition at that moment and the system
0:44:00 in the universe and the visit Tessa or
0:44:03 not and so on and in any case you will
0:44:04 forget what what you have a shared you
0:44:07 will always think about the Supreme
0:44:10 deity if you have various deities or
0:44:12 about the the force the secret force in
0:44:15 the universe which they call brahmana
0:44:17 not Brahma Brahma Vishnu Shiva no these
0:44:21 are three I could emerged from this
0:44:23 brahmana the secret force in the
0:44:25 universe this void is something
0:44:28 which has no structures but so most
0:44:32 likely the Hindus you say you say in the
0:44:35 movies when Calamity or bhagwan
0:44:38 oh my God
0:44:40 for example in I saw various various
0:44:44 things I said a woman is
0:44:49 respected up my respected Lord without
0:44:52 mentioning any name so it's the one in
0:44:54 the mind the Supreme one the one they
0:44:55 point to the finger sometimes that's the
0:44:57 one even there although they have tons
0:45:00 of Idols family Idols Village Idols this
0:45:02 Idol but ultimate it will be this one
0:45:04 that was a supreme one the one who's not
0:45:07 giving a name just sub G or bug one
0:45:10 check I've got a question on this so
0:45:13 is this alluding to it's an automatic
0:45:15 response or is it
0:45:19 that's a subconscious working that's the
0:45:21 mind working
0:45:23 if you say some mind working is it
0:45:25 almost in a sense that the person
0:45:27 subconsciously
0:45:29 has happened yeah this is what they call
0:45:31 the God complex
0:45:32 okay okay so well that would indicate
0:45:34 that it's an automatic response rather
0:45:35 than something conceptual because what I
0:45:37 mean to make a distinction if someone
0:45:39 this is not the time to think which one
0:45:42 I'm calling which one will be able to
0:45:43 just the Supreme one will do it that's
0:45:45 Allah
0:45:47 is this a thought out thing or is it
0:45:50 something that's as interesting then
0:45:52 then we have to accept guys psychiatrist
0:45:55 and kill yourself and so on but that's
0:45:58 what happened or could we see it they
0:46:00 may be exceptional people of extreme
0:46:02 stubbornness who refused to uh
0:46:05 to acknowledge it as a God or something
0:46:07 like that but that's usually not in a
0:46:09 Calamity like for example uh the famous
0:46:11 actor Henry Fonda I think he was an
0:46:13 atheist Church
0:46:16 even after his deathbed they say just to
0:46:19 him too to get a priest and have
0:46:20 sacraments he refused stability
0:46:23 because he knows that this is inevitable
0:46:26 and it cannot be prevented and delayed
0:46:29 and he refused her to believe her and
0:46:31 got generally God or whatever I don't
0:46:33 know his detail I don't know a family of
0:46:35 his life but it's definitely important
0:46:37 that he refused strictly don't bring any
0:46:39 priests in his story whatever reason I
0:46:40 don't know
0:46:42 so there's something else but in a
0:46:43 Calamity like falling or or a firestorm
0:46:46 or the nuclear explosion in good
0:46:48 forbidden Central London and we see the
0:46:50 fireball advancing there's nothing else
0:46:54 yeah look at that like that or a car
0:46:57 starting to turn over
0:47:00 or a plane obviously the pilot tell you
0:47:02 sorry we lost we lost we lost all the
0:47:04 engines we will try to somehow to land
0:47:07 on and if we wind up as a water so the
0:47:09 landing will be soft up then you know
0:47:11 it's gone
0:47:23 take it simple as that going on the
0:47:26 depth of psychology and the God complex
0:47:28 the brain and you can excited electrical
0:47:30 leave that for the theater session
0:47:32 but clearly is that what what experience
0:47:34 shown and especially in the Arabs
0:47:36 because the Arabs their shark is
0:47:37 relatively late the northern Arab the
0:47:40 shark is relatively late and imported so
0:47:43 uh became like like a shared or is a
0:47:46 share called City copper but a layer
0:47:48 over the fundamental way they're still
0:47:50 the major deity the central Advantage
0:47:52 there
0:47:54 mentioned various places when they are
0:47:56 in in at Sea and the storm comes then
0:48:01 Allah
0:48:03 because it's the only one who can manage
0:48:04 this bad situation at one side maybe
0:48:07 other God can help in some issues
0:48:09 getting a Camelback sorry with that see
0:48:12 only the big one can do the big work
0:48:15 in that sense in a more simple-minded
0:48:17 way okay so let's assemble by the level
0:48:20 and then you can go to higher level into
0:48:22 into psychology and the God complex in
0:48:24 the brain and how it is implemented in
0:48:26 the genes we can't go all of these
0:48:28 levels that may be part of that water
0:48:30 the larger muscle would say is this is
0:48:33 but at first is that what the alarms you
0:48:35 and this is pretty many to the Arabs but
0:48:38 we see it applies to other nations also
0:48:40 probably today even extreme uh Pagan
0:48:45 like like Hindus still there is some
0:48:48 kind of central mysterious force or
0:48:51 something Supreme thinks something
0:48:52 somewhere which was only invoked in the
0:48:55 major calamities or the State of Shock
0:48:59 yeah
0:49:01 okay agreed
0:49:03 so it has various levels
0:49:05 and most likely it is the reaction and
0:49:07 invoking the major deity or the major
0:49:09 force in the universe or something like
0:49:11 that is is
0:49:13 not based up because in such a major
0:49:16 Calamity like like you're seeing the
0:49:18 fireball advancing view of a nuclear
0:49:20 explosion or the ship is about to sink
0:49:22 and so on there's no time to analyze
0:49:24 which one God will be suitable for that
0:49:26 you know what by by instinct
0:49:29 it must be the major deity if any and
0:49:32 even some atheists may may even
0:49:33 distorted that oh God help me or
0:49:36 something like that
0:49:37 even all the thin layer layer of atheism
0:49:40 just evil bodies
0:49:43 good well
0:49:47 um
0:49:53 this is him alone that you will invoke
0:49:55 whereupon he may if he so Wills remove
0:49:58 that ill
0:50:01 yeah next one
0:50:03 and indeed we sent our messages on to
0:50:06 people before thy time a prophet and
0:50:07 visited them with Misfortune and
0:50:09 hardship so that they might humble
0:50:10 themselves this translation we sent our
0:50:13 messages unto people before your time
0:50:15 profit and Afflicted the people with
0:50:17 Misfortune and hardship so that they
0:50:19 might humble themselves yeah that's this
0:50:21 is their General habit that most humans
0:50:24 will be will live will reject the
0:50:27 message is because of arrogance and
0:50:29 stubbornness and feeling that they are
0:50:31 powerful and capable so visiting them
0:50:34 with with the hardship and like the
0:50:36 people foreign
0:50:52 and should be persuasive in itself but
0:50:54 they refuse to to submit to that and
0:50:56 also foreign
0:51:03 which would have done in any value and
0:51:06 that's the sultan which is he feels that
0:51:08 nobody knows about the people were
0:51:10 wondering what's happening why not oh
0:51:12 they have to be executed right away in
0:51:14 reality that's Sultan that that Horror
0:51:17 in his heart when he sees Musa is is
0:51:19 only known to him obviously you read
0:51:22 sometimes in some of that that he was so
0:51:25 terrified from Musa that he was even not
0:51:27 controlling his urine who is this as
0:51:28 some kind of exaggeration people imagine
0:51:30 things and that the stories I'm not sex
0:51:33 is impossible and even they say he was
0:51:36 urinating like a donkey anyway
0:51:39 will invent such a stories but clearly
0:51:43 he was he was so intimidated that he is
0:51:44 unable to give any comment
0:51:46 and that's it that's responsible from
0:51:48 that he said well we're afraid that we
0:51:50 don't want to open our mouth he will
0:51:52 immediately order us to executed
0:51:55 I said no no I will make an I will give
0:51:57 you an authority over him and I'm
0:51:58 listening with you
0:52:00 Allah telling them go don't worry that
0:52:03 will not happen so this is where Allah
0:52:05 is stepping in miraculously and for all
0:52:06 I felt that in himself he should
0:52:08 recognize that but that did not help so
0:52:10 all the other Miracles after that are
0:52:12 all really connected within investor
0:52:16 visiting them with hardship with
0:52:18 suffering and so on frogs uh floods and
0:52:23 the last one that the death of all first
0:52:25 born or most of us born are catastrophic
0:52:28 things
0:52:30 and the purpose of that is that here is
0:52:32 a powerful entity which can harm you or
0:52:34 put you down by by material Force
0:52:37 but
0:52:39 you have to put yourself down by your
0:52:41 own choice
0:52:44 you have to do it there's no way to do
0:52:46 it the universe is not structured
0:52:47 otherwise it doesn't work this way
0:52:51 so that you have to make a choice
0:52:55 unfortunately from day one because
0:52:57 created without any real will or the
0:52:59 will only for the good and the father
0:53:00 but no that's not the joy but there is
0:53:02 that so all of this external hardship to
0:53:05 push you down materially so that you
0:53:08 push yourself down
0:53:10 uh spiritually and submit to Allah ask
0:53:15 for Relief please remove that we
0:53:18 acknowledge that we that your other
0:53:19 ultimate sovereign
0:53:30 wanted not to
0:53:33 unfortunately unfortunately
0:53:37 so so so stubbornness and then her
0:53:40 heart-heartedness can get to that level
0:53:41 that is
0:53:52 one second
0:53:58 yet when Misfortune decreed by us befell
0:54:00 them they did not humble themselves
0:54:02 rather their hearts grew hard for Satan
0:54:04 had made all their doing sing goodly to
0:54:06 them in Translation when The Misfortune
0:54:10 fell on them they did not humble
0:54:11 themselves but instead their hearts
0:54:14 became hardened and Satan made their bad
0:54:16 Deeds alluring two of them to them
0:54:18 exactly and as we see in history
0:54:20 essentially rarely any
0:54:23 Any Nation just came to their senses by
0:54:25 themselves except the people of of Jonas
0:54:32 for some reason we don't have the taste
0:54:35 in the Quran
0:54:36 but they when when units left
0:54:40 and then According to some narrative I
0:54:41 don't know if it's not from the prophet
0:54:42 or from the from the stories of the Old
0:54:44 Testament I don't know I didn't check it
0:54:46 I don't bother checking it they have
0:54:48 been engulfed by some kind of a folk or
0:54:51 smoke
0:54:56 nowadays obviously this is a civilized
0:54:59 area and people are sophisticated and
0:55:02 Heritage civilization Russia and they
0:55:04 recognize this must be because Eunice
0:55:06 was angry and left now the punishment is
0:55:09 coming and they came to the sense and
0:55:10 they asked a lot to to relieve
0:55:13 remove that and there will be believer
0:55:15 and ask him to return units to them and
0:55:17 that has happened that's the only
0:55:18 exception of what I mentioned even
0:55:20 Muhammad
0:55:22 the majority of quraishi did not until
0:55:24 the sword took them until they were
0:55:25 defeated in in in the caucus of Mecca
0:55:29 and more but some of them even embraced
0:55:32 Islam as monafithi
0:55:34 it didn't help
0:55:37 so that's that's and that's all because
0:55:40 their heart became hot they could they
0:55:43 were able to uh and and their misdeed a
0:55:47 piece of them reasonable we are the
0:55:49 reasonable to be able this Prophet or
0:55:50 they say is what is bringing is
0:55:51 unreasonably not acceptable
0:55:53 he is the for example the case of people
0:55:55 following said this is a slave Nation we
0:55:57 are supposed to be give them leadership
0:55:59 and made
0:56:01 regard them as equal and we have a
0:56:03 civilization going for thousands of
0:56:05 years at times already that the pyramids
0:56:07 have been standing there for maybe a
0:56:09 thousand thousand and a half years
0:56:11 because if Musa is 1450 before Christ
0:56:13 say 1500 the pyramids at three thousand
0:56:16 plus so we are talking about almost two
0:56:18 thousand years before ancient generation
0:56:21 for Generation we have this order and
0:56:23 then a couple of guys with the slave
0:56:25 Nation are going to change our way of
0:56:27 life completely upside down
0:56:30 that's that's the that's not that's not
0:56:33 the way most likely the scholar said
0:56:34 that's not the way your social
0:56:35 engineering should be done this should
0:56:37 be done bit by bit to stay in my stages
0:56:39 nicely on what like the psychologist now
0:56:41 say by enacting law after law maybe over
0:56:44 500 years not excitedly no this doesn't
0:56:46 work this way his God must be must be
0:56:49 mental who asked her to do that suddenly
0:56:51 no it's not right that's the way you
0:56:52 will persuade yourself through something
0:56:53 all these things may be a good a good
0:56:55 thing but it can't be that immediately
0:56:57 like that no no that's not acceptable
0:56:58 and the other one say no no until I said
0:57:01 I'm not going through to give up
0:57:03 Divinity and absolute sovereignty no no
0:57:05 no before someone in heaven I don't know
0:57:07 and the one in heaven is not even
0:57:09 talking to me he's talking through the
0:57:10 slave no no
0:57:12 and even worse talking through a man who
0:57:15 doesn't even express him say Well he has
0:57:16 a problem in his tongue he has to tell
0:57:19 his brother and his brother explain what
0:57:20 he wants
0:57:21 people come on be sensible how we can
0:57:24 follow this that's the way they thought
0:57:27 they developed it in such a way that it
0:57:29 looks
0:57:30 it looks Washington
0:57:32 they will make it to their evil forces
0:57:35 on himself as an entity or the shaytan
0:57:38 could mean that the evil force of the
0:57:39 evil inclination the gaps in the in the
0:57:42 gaps in in the in the structure of the
0:57:44 mind and the structure of the heart
0:57:46 that's the shaytan
0:57:49 accommodating for him
0:57:51 two thousand years ago even more of this
0:57:54 realization development was supposed to
0:57:56 change in one day yeah you catchy it's
0:57:58 easy change your attitude and rework
0:58:01 things around it it will work in a few
0:58:03 days and months it will work no problem
0:58:05 all that you need to change that here
0:58:07 inside your inside your heart and bread
0:58:09 nobody said to demolish the building
0:58:11 nobody said to anything
0:58:13 even Idols for the Majesty's artifact
0:58:16 and an historical artifact that's it
0:58:19 it's easier than people think
0:58:22 what are the philosophers and social uh
0:58:25 professors will come with all kind of
0:58:27 philosophical developments no no no it's
0:58:28 not the way it develops history
0:58:30 development doesn't develop this way I'm
0:58:32 using the model language or recent
0:58:34 language must have been something else
0:58:39 yeah and the same as well same with the
0:58:40 Qureshi
0:58:43 we are the guardian of the sanctuary we
0:58:46 we are the best in Arabia we are the
0:58:48 banking of Arabia we are the leader of
0:58:50 Arabia
0:58:52 and this guy is coming to tell us that
0:58:54 our way of life is because we have some
0:58:57 some symbolic Idols that's not the way
0:58:59 to go
0:59:03 and most likely that's because he
0:59:04 advised for power because many Hashem
0:59:06 are weakening now and losing power so he
0:59:08 started to establish power faking this
0:59:10 well we'll give you this analysis
0:59:12 there's a better analysis than believing
0:59:14 that receiving something from heaven and
0:59:16 things like that all kind of arguments
0:59:17 suitable to the current situation of the
0:59:19 time
0:59:25 foreign
0:59:36 closer and then when they had forgotten
0:59:40 all that they had been told to take to
0:59:42 heart we threw open to them the gates of
0:59:44 all good things until even as they were
0:59:47 rejoicing in what they had been granted
0:59:49 we suddenly took them to task and load
0:59:52 they were broken in spirit next
0:59:54 translation
0:59:55 well they had forgotten all that they
0:59:57 had been told to take to heart we opened
1:00:00 the gates to everything they wanted then
1:00:02 as they rejoiced in what had been
1:00:04 granted we struck them suddenly and they
1:00:06 were held and they were in despair yeah
1:00:08 after the peso of tribulation and they
1:00:11 said then my for example hardship like
1:00:13 Noreen like in the case of Yusuf and so
1:00:15 on
1:00:18 oh this is actually how the world Works
1:00:21 farming's exchange with rain time and so
1:00:23 on that's that's what what what have
1:00:25 been visited on us is actually the
1:00:28 normal cause of things it goes in Cycles
1:00:31 it is in Cycles now the cycle is gone
1:00:34 now we aren't fine and nice if
1:00:36 everything is fine no problem so don't
1:00:39 don't bother very much about thinking
1:00:41 whatever this profit or this this
1:00:43 message you have sold you with us is all
1:00:44 from God he's Imagining the guy is the
1:00:46 poor guy is misguided he's mentally
1:00:48 dressed it just happened accidentally to
1:00:50 be in a time which is a type of Pharmacy
1:00:52 the rain is being held by the Lord from
1:00:54 you ah it's not it's just just cycles of
1:00:57 weather of changes and so on nowadays
1:00:59 say the jits today was going south and
1:01:01 more than
1:01:02 about him and then maybe Good Times come
1:01:05 and the people forget about that and
1:01:06 then suddenly academic comes which is
1:01:08 finishing them where they are then in a
1:01:10 State of Shock a little bit unto it
1:01:13 that's the way it works in the universe
1:01:15 which people may call it cycle
1:01:17 but some of his man-made Cycles when
1:01:19 someone is divinely made sex or
1:01:21 somebody's psychics in the world because
1:01:22 the days over and the world dictates up
1:01:24 and down the Quran says that it's where
1:01:26 but in that case with case of a
1:01:27 messenger and so on don't assume it is
1:01:29 just a normal cause of things it may be
1:01:32 not you should think about it
1:01:39 so if they've taken that suddenly so
1:01:42 they are in a state of shotgun Mobley
1:01:43 soon you don't know what to do with
1:01:45 Community because
1:01:50 it has happened several times in history
1:01:52 like the people of nowhere the people of
1:01:55 of
1:01:56 uh
1:01:58 of hood Etc
1:02:00 uh the people of Saudi they have come
1:02:03 through these stages and the end stage
1:02:05 was that everything is fine they tell
1:02:06 them come on
1:02:08 let your lord bring that what he has
1:02:10 been threatening or love because
1:02:11 especially important people of wood it
1:02:13 was a long time of knowing and famine
1:02:16 and he's warning them and so on to bring
1:02:18 you all kind of we don't know which
1:02:20 evidence because the colanders it's
1:02:22 interestingly it doesn't mention any
1:02:23 specific Miracle robot
1:02:26 he must have something else we don't
1:02:27 know we don't know anyway
1:02:29 then ultimately
1:02:31 I didn't start it will come and so on
1:02:33 and then increase
1:02:35 and then they saw this huge Cloud coming
1:02:38 converter that's no that's that's a
1:02:40 cloud which will really refill the wells
1:02:42 and the Earth will be wet
1:02:45 and all the time of the hardship family
1:02:47 will be over and that cloud is that what
1:02:49 was really super hurricane or super
1:02:52 typhoon this is the Indian Ocean they
1:02:54 call them typhoon or a cyclone Super
1:02:57 Cyclone because in the India also they
1:02:59 called Cyclone I think in the Pacific
1:03:01 they are called typhoons and in the in
1:03:03 the Caribbean they are called hurricanes
1:03:04 so that must have been a super
1:03:10 Cyclone which exterminated them
1:03:15 so it can happen like that and luckily
1:03:17 after Musa and harun this this this this
1:03:20 system has been changed underneath the
1:03:23 taking over and the extermination is
1:03:25 taken by the hand of the Believers in
1:03:26 the battlefield against rustaman hostile
1:03:29 murder cover what would this happen to
1:03:32 the party for the quality
1:03:34 they were cut in pieces by with by with
1:03:36 an ultimately defeated in the Corpus
1:03:38 actually the conquest of Mecca because
1:03:39 of Allah's mercy and the things have
1:03:42 this enacted even the time of Abraham is
1:03:45 a place of security what the the
1:03:47 Bloodshed was minimal only few suffered
1:03:49 and the rest just corroded there in
1:03:51 their houses and some became one African
1:03:53 became believer and converted and so on
1:03:55 but generally in other nations the the
1:03:59 believing Nation
1:04:00 which the messenger immigrated to will
1:04:04 be in case of Visa
1:04:06 he was lifted up before that but was
1:04:08 already announced in the Old Testament
1:04:09 so since most had agreement this this
1:04:11 system uh has been changed or was
1:04:13 mentioned in in other occasions which
1:04:16 will come to that I'll translate this
1:04:18 now yeah and in the end The Last Remnant
1:04:21 of those folk who had been bent on evil
1:04:23 doing was wiped out
1:04:25 for all praise is due to God the same
1:04:28 the sustainer of all the worlds next
1:04:30 translation
1:04:31 the evil doers will wiped out all
1:04:33 Praises do to God the lord of the worlds
1:04:36 is
1:04:37 just Lord could be a sustainer could be
1:04:40 a lawmaker and it's both
1:04:42 so that's that's the Lord is the correct
1:04:44 one another because translation as Lord
1:04:47 is the better one than sister
1:04:50 because
1:04:57 Translate
1:05:02 say what do you think if God should take
1:05:05 away your hearing and your sight and
1:05:07 seal your hearts what deity but God is
1:05:10 there that could bring it all back to
1:05:11 you
1:05:12 behold how many facets we give to our
1:05:15 messages and yet they turn away in
1:05:17 disdain yeah next translation
1:05:19 say consider this what
1:05:22 a lot of his friends are considered this
1:05:24 what if God should take away your
1:05:26 hearing and your sight and your and seal
1:05:29 your hearts
1:05:30 what God other than God is there that
1:05:33 could bring it all back to you
1:05:35 see how we explain our revelations in
1:05:37 many ways and yet still they turn away
1:05:40 in disdain okay not certainly clear but
1:05:42 I just have one one important comment
1:05:44 obviously when you say which God beside
1:05:47 God so that one is a smaller cabinet is
1:05:49 better so we should deity inside God
1:05:51 will come to the jewel inside Allah
1:05:53 that's okay
1:05:54 now this
1:05:57 just refused completely what our happy
1:05:59 Claim about that that God is something
1:06:01 which is worshiped he's not they're not
1:06:02 talking about worship or submission
1:06:03 anything at all it is which deity will
1:06:06 bring you beside Allah except Allah will
1:06:09 bring you back the site and the and the
1:06:12 open the hearts and open your ears after
1:06:16 that taken by Allah the same same let's
1:06:18 assume Allah blind you yeah
1:06:21 and make you make a deaf
1:06:25 leave the heart because that's intent
1:06:27 about this externally
1:06:28 that happened from Allah which of your
1:06:31 deities is capable of reversing it
1:06:34 which meaning that the definition of
1:06:36 deity is an entity which can reverse
1:06:38 that or can do that can take it away and
1:06:40 bring it back
1:06:43 as intrinsically has this capability
1:06:46 thus alone shows that the definition of
1:06:48 is something which worship is faulty
1:06:51 under but that the people did not read
1:06:52 the Quran from begin to end
1:06:54 they have a fixed idea
1:06:57 starting with the mistake of intimia
1:06:58 with blunder actually but they sharpened
1:07:01 it until it became the energy
1:07:02 devastating
1:07:04 a devastating uh it was like a blunt
1:07:07 Hammer used sparingly a little bit but
1:07:10 the sharp knitted became that assault
1:07:11 used everywhere to cut everything into
1:07:13 pieces
1:07:14 so this is when one characteristic idea
1:07:16 that he can't do that
1:07:18 if they would was worshiping these these
1:07:21 idols and so on just just as that hobby
1:07:23 think they are just touching and kissing
1:07:25 them I love you and so on and that's it
1:07:27 then the argument would make no sense
1:07:32 they they must have been believing and
1:07:35 they think that they could do something
1:07:36 like that or the other branch of deity
1:07:39 the secondary branch is that they
1:07:41 descend at the offsprings over that
1:07:42 another Duty so they have the honor or
1:07:44 the genes or the genealogy of deity
1:07:46 leave this aside you could say these do
1:07:49 not have enough Authority but usually
1:07:51 even those because the Beloved girls
1:07:52 daughters and sons of Allah must have
1:07:54 set in power another thing can't be just
1:07:57 just plainly just being nice Divine and
1:07:59 they will have some a King's Children
1:08:02 even if they are not participating in
1:08:03 the government they still have the
1:08:05 respectability and something to say and
1:08:07 they can advise and direct them so they
1:08:09 can do something
1:08:10 definitely
1:08:12 by virtual being of divine origin
1:08:14 especially in time past when the king is
1:08:16 really absolute and also the offsprings
1:08:18 are also have some kind of absolute
1:08:19 power but the exercises with the
1:08:21 limitation of their father Yes but they
1:08:22 are so
1:08:25 so the claim that uh deity meaning
1:08:28 something which is worship does not make
1:08:30 any sense because they told him no we
1:08:32 never say that they have discoverability
1:08:34 that's not our gods are not of this side
1:08:36 this type no no the gods of this type
1:08:39 either of divine origin or independently
1:08:42 capable of creating and blinding and
1:08:44 taking up giving them outside back Etc
1:08:48 that's exactly what and it was a famous
1:08:50 story that when one of the sahabi early
1:08:52 Muslims she had some some eye problem
1:08:56 and uh she became blind whatever you
1:08:59 know maybe it's a temporal problem
1:09:01 anyway but that's what the report says
1:09:03 she became
1:09:05 we warned you Allah will take your love
1:09:08 with your eye aware away I said by Allah
1:09:12 Allah I said away or bring it back it's
1:09:15 Allah who took it for whatever reason
1:09:17 and he is the one will be able to and
1:09:19 the report said she'll get again
1:09:21 someone could say this is a placebo
1:09:23 effect because she's very very confident
1:09:26 I believe yes but but this is the
1:09:28 reality a lot kind of bring us because
1:09:30 Allah doesn't exist it does not have
1:09:31 that's supposed to be the the consort a
1:09:34 life of Allah Allah being accepted about
1:09:36 this nonsense I cannot do anything it's
1:09:38 just it's just a name you have created
1:09:40 in your mind doesn't exist so she
1:09:42 couldn't have been possibly taken my
1:09:43 eyesight or back and maybe he has things
1:09:45 of Faith or a miracle from Allah
1:09:51 so let's say this means genuine they
1:09:54 believe that Allah can do that
1:09:57 that's good but that's what's making a
1:09:59 Divine being all this is that Allah is
1:10:01 actually from a satanic origin not from
1:10:03 because uh kalash was the belief that
1:10:07 the ability is two branches the good one
1:10:10 Allah and the bad one the evil one is
1:10:12 everything so they have this dualism
1:10:13 which is called zandaka and uh and then
1:10:17 after that long ages of War peace was
1:10:21 settled and then a lot which is a
1:10:24 according to also the old babylonic
1:10:26 beliefs is is a under underworld goddess
1:10:28 was sent to heaven to become the wife of
1:10:30 Allah so that no peace and settled the
1:10:33 same way King settled disputes in the
1:10:35 Dunya just marry your daughter to the
1:10:37 skin and things get settled nicely
1:10:41 so that's what they were believing but
1:10:43 they are Divine beings worship not
1:10:45 worshiped irrelevant
1:10:47 Divine being of good time bad time but
1:10:50 Divine big
1:10:51 worship yeah worship would be based on
1:10:54 that automatically it's clear
1:10:56 it's clear but that's that's that's
1:10:58 that's that's that's by as it stands see
1:11:01 the adity is the one who can take sight
1:11:03 and give sight creating the abilities
1:11:05 and he's telling them which deity of
1:11:07 your deities claim deities can retain
1:11:09 the eyesight
1:11:11 when if Allah has taken the eyesight
1:11:12 away tell me which one none and the
1:11:15 story of that woman is an example of
1:11:16 that and many other examples is there is
1:11:18 no way
1:11:19 and also in normal life people go blind
1:11:22 to get diseases get their leg cut in an
1:11:24 accident and so on any one of these they
1:11:27 can carry attend that back show me
1:11:29 has never happened
1:11:31 have ever ever happened
1:11:34 never ever
1:11:37 so they take a take from that is that
1:11:39 this shows what what the meaning of
1:11:41 illah in the in the context of the Quran
1:11:44 at the time maybe the word Eli in
1:11:46 ancient time had another meaning
1:11:47 actually
1:11:48 in the time of Musa and in Old Kanai
1:11:52 language is almost
1:11:55 and that's the reason Old Testament to
1:11:57 say it says in the discussion in
1:12:01 in more cine assuming it is it's true
1:12:04 there's no reason to believe it's
1:12:05 fabricated
1:12:06 he said I will be your Musa and you I
1:12:10 will give you your brother alone to be
1:12:12 with you but he will under you I will be
1:12:14 your illah and you will be meaning the
1:12:16 Lord or Master leader
1:12:19 at the time he did not have that meaning
1:12:21 it was developed further but over the
1:12:23 time and Allah was given them the
1:12:24 constructed name yehovah I think at this
1:12:27 what is Jehovah means I think I think it
1:12:29 is meaning essential it is a sentence it
1:12:32 is not abbreviation
1:12:33 as they liked it it looks like but so
1:12:35 many he who is he
1:12:38 he who is he no that is then there is a
1:12:40 city existing that's translated in
1:12:42 symbol common my language at that time
1:12:44 things like necessarily existing and and
1:12:47 contingent were not developed yet that
1:12:49 discussion so the best what you can
1:12:51 describe that is he who is he
1:12:55 when I when I asked how much does the
1:12:57 people who is the one sending me because
1:12:58 we will have so many gods and so on God
1:13:00 of ram I'm on which one what's your name
1:13:03 I should tell say and in your previous
1:13:06 generation Abraham and after they called
1:13:08 me illah should die the strong Lord the
1:13:12 strongest one the structure one but now
1:13:15 we'll have advanced in history obviously
1:13:17 if they ask yourself he who is he send
1:13:20 me
1:13:22 later on than the word ill was was made
1:13:25 and made with the article
1:13:28 the god
1:13:30 and then merge together
1:13:32 Allah and then we no need for that so
1:13:36 then the Quran
1:13:38 anyway let's say we just say Allah told
1:13:40 him
1:13:43 I am Allah that's after all these
1:13:46 development and the linguistic
1:13:47 development there's now a name no need
1:13:49 to use Jehovah anymore we have than a
1:13:51 personal name for Allah Allah
1:13:54 but this is what originally at that time
1:13:56 was constructed as a sentence
1:13:59 and so that's in time passed and then
1:14:01 became then with this definition with
1:14:03 the Quran clarify with this various
1:14:04 question and the most clear definition
1:14:06 and sharpness is the insert the momentum
1:14:08 welcome one day inshallah the Ayah of
1:14:10 so-called
1:14:11 Mutual Mutual exclusion that Allah no
1:14:17 Offspring wallet
1:14:21 would have taken their the creation and
1:14:24 went away or they could try to overcome
1:14:26 each other so that's a deity is either
1:14:28 of spring over deity
1:14:30 or something intrinsically capable of
1:14:33 creating and having his own career on
1:14:34 his own power on his own sign his own
1:14:37 will and take it away or defeat the
1:14:39 others overcome them
1:14:41 try to defend that's that's that that's
1:14:43 that's all types of deities which exist
1:14:45 genuinely
1:14:47 in a precise form which people simple
1:14:50 people like simple hinders so don't have
1:14:52 a clear picture in their mind but like
1:14:54 like something uh amorphous something
1:14:58 nebulous in their mind but it was to do
1:15:01 three things either of spring of a deity
1:15:03 or a deity in that definition which is
1:15:05 capable acting well with intrinsic power
1:15:09 and absolute superiority
1:15:12 and this definition is perfect it's like
1:15:14 if you remember the people who had
1:15:15 programming they have so-called
1:15:16 recursive definition
1:15:18 because you say it's either offswing a
1:15:21 deity
1:15:22 or the deity with this characteristic so
1:15:24 if similarity is a deity it may be
1:15:27 assuming another option at ultimately
1:15:28 ends to the fundamental one which is the
1:15:30 one which I think in Sovereign intrinsic
1:15:33 power and three words
1:15:36 and this is examined with applying to
1:15:38 taking eyesight blinding and things like
1:15:40 that
1:15:41 nothing with worship or neurotype but
1:15:43 worshiper here no worshiper is available
1:15:44 it's an intrinsic attributes of a
1:15:47 divinity
1:15:50 okay clear so that's that's one that's
1:15:52 that's one part of the just for for
1:15:55 these uh
1:15:57 blinded heretical Hobby and the
1:15:59 definition of divinity
1:16:01 because of the definition then you have
1:16:03 something called grave worship
1:16:05 initially
1:16:07 because people go to the game and touch
1:16:09 it and kiss it and it became a deity
1:16:11 that no that's impossible it can't be
1:16:13 but there's no great worship
1:16:15 that's not good
1:16:17 one quick one there I just I missed this
1:16:19 one somebody's asked
1:16:20 um the issue of the shape of the earth
1:16:21 what about geocentricism versus
1:16:25 heliocentrism acute crane hmar on the
1:16:28 former
1:16:31 they said the same pencil the Quran are
1:16:33 there also
1:16:35 these things are these things are
1:16:38 in the Quran hence set and things
1:16:41 sometimes same thing
1:16:42 and sometimes it is uh like for example
1:16:46 they usually invoke that the the sun is
1:16:48 running to to a place of settlement and
1:16:52 the killing settlements under the throne
1:16:53 and all this thing we'll discuss that in
1:16:55 some recessions which will come but that
1:16:57 running through a place of settlement
1:16:58 cannot be the the apparent motion around
1:17:01 death because it never settles out a
1:17:03 matter of fact and this Hadith under the
1:17:05 throne is most likely fabricated but
1:17:07 even if it is must be metaphorical so
1:17:09 because we know by this is the Earth is
1:17:12 is egg-shaped and and by the Quran and
1:17:15 by the by the observation by ancestral
1:17:17 perception then there will be no Citrus
1:17:19 so the sun in the sense of being under
1:17:21 the throne prostrating is continuously
1:17:24 at one point of the earth any time in
1:17:26 any time on on in in that passage of
1:17:30 time there's a place on the Earth where
1:17:31 the sun is like in the deer in the
1:17:33 bottom so it blows it under the throne
1:17:35 meaning under Allah's control fine
1:17:37 so this is this is destination which is
1:17:40 cities but this destination is
1:17:41 continuously she is always settling
1:17:42 somewhere so that meaning
1:17:45 is running to a place of settlement
1:17:48 cannot be the meaning of that so maybe
1:17:50 it's movement
1:17:51 so not the apparent movement let's say
1:17:53 so the apart movies is really apparent
1:17:55 but leave that the sun moves also around
1:17:59 the center of the Galaxy actually it
1:18:00 moves relative to the local globe of
1:18:02 that that's a certain movement then the
1:18:05 whole block local block moves around the
1:18:07 center of the Galaxy there's another
1:18:09 movement
1:18:10 etc etc
1:18:11 so that's that's the so you have to take
1:18:14 all these evidences and to to get to
1:18:16 this thing my advice don't integrate
1:18:18 involved in that leave it to the people
1:18:20 of Science and so on simply because it
1:18:22 needs to take various evidences and
1:18:24 analyze which reference frame we are
1:18:26 looking from if you are looking Forum of
1:18:28 the Earth
1:18:29 then obviously the whole heaven and sky
1:18:31 is the
1:18:32 socospherical astronomy work with that
1:18:34 at the end as if the Earth is is is not
1:18:38 rotating and the whole sky is rotate and
1:18:40 they do the geometry and the calculation
1:18:42 it works the same way
1:18:44 is it real or is it the sky the Earth is
1:18:47 rotating and the sky is actually not
1:18:48 rotating it relative to the air in any
1:18:50 great extent there may be some Far Away
1:18:52 rotation that somebody but let's say go
1:18:54 the nearby area
1:18:55 that's what's well established for
1:18:57 various reasons because various
1:18:59 observations show that and various
1:19:01 places uh between winter and summer
1:19:03 various it should actually show that it
1:19:05 cannot be that that uh that uh the sky
1:19:08 is rotating actually we are rotating
1:19:10 let's just say an apartheid movement but
1:19:12 in astronomy and aesthetical astronomy
1:19:13 it doesn't make any difference in the
1:19:15 same geometry can be applied
1:19:17 secondly issues related that if it's so
1:19:20 then the remotes the remote starts
1:19:22 because they rotate to the same angular
1:19:23 speed they must be there their their
1:19:26 their physical the tangential speed must
1:19:29 be enormous
1:19:30 which is impossible because we know
1:19:32 there's a limit of speeds which is the
1:19:34 speed of light so they must exceed the
1:19:36 space like that a reality but that's
1:19:38 impossible so it must be only apparent
1:19:40 this is your matricat by by refusing the
1:19:43 reference frame so this thing is better
1:19:44 left to the specialist Bush will Design
1:19:47 the reference frames and work on it and
1:19:49 so on
1:19:50 probably
1:19:52 so just so that's it this is no problem
1:19:54 with that there's absolutely no problem
1:19:56 it can be worked out in detail but it
1:19:58 needs some some kind of graphic
1:19:59 representation some kind of maybe
1:20:01 representation Now by by uh by Holograms
1:20:04 and things like that so it can be easily
1:20:06 appreciated
1:20:07 and everywhere look to the reference
1:20:10 frame
1:20:11 reactive to whom you are talking
1:20:14 to the one who is talking to the Center
1:20:17 of the Earth or to the center of the Sun
1:20:19 or the central of the solar system which
1:20:21 is different than the central Sun a
1:20:22 little bit or the center of the Galaxy
1:20:24 or if there's any Center of areas or the
1:20:27 points of the big bank which we don't
1:20:28 know where it is now at the moment
1:20:31 you see so there's there's many issues
1:20:33 there related to the reference frame and
1:20:35 we delete the issues of Relativity is
1:20:37 absolute not absolute and so on deep
1:20:39 issues and the hints of the Quran held
1:20:41 many of these issues
1:20:43 good
1:20:46 but that's an issue by said it may be
1:20:47 worth maybe one day addressing it but I
1:20:49 think I don't think it's worth
1:20:50 addressing because all of these which
1:20:52 come with that it must be flat because
1:20:54 of his eyes as I mentioned that example
1:20:56 is just after stupidity they don't even
1:20:57 have the basic linguistic understanding
1:20:59 of the medical difference between plane
1:21:02 and surface a surface service for
1:21:05 anybody has its own self a sphere has a
1:21:07 surface which is the external Shield uh
1:21:10 uh a cube has a surface which is this
1:21:13 how much one two three four six sides
1:21:15 this is the surface and internet and so
1:21:18 on so that when a foreign says look at
1:21:21 this house has been uh
1:21:24 selfish how the self is shaped
1:21:28 look at some more things have been made
1:21:30 up right or stuck up right is used for
1:21:34 them for the tent yeah
1:21:36 the tent is is made upright by an
1:21:39 internal pillar clear the mountain is
1:21:41 not of this type but also we say the
1:21:43 banner is upright
1:21:45 there's a both famous box world
1:21:49 of the banner
1:21:51 that by a by a pillar and the LIE is to
1:21:54 the side it's not like the tent another
1:21:57 type of nurse the mountain is being must
1:22:00 be made not being said like that by some
1:22:03 other mechanism so what's the meaning
1:22:04 look how it is being us what is the way
1:22:06 of nasu the the the type of nose what's
1:22:09 the type let's mean assembly look at the
1:22:12 mountains study its shape that's
1:22:13 geography
1:22:15 do measurements the co-dc
1:22:18 but you have to dig insight to see
1:22:19 what's going on for God's sake do
1:22:21 geology meaning addressee
1:22:25 study these Sciences don't be idiots
1:22:27 that's it
1:22:29 not that it is like the tent or like the
1:22:32 like like the like the the the the the
1:22:35 the pillar of a panel this is to another
1:22:38 type we must
1:22:45 the how is not clearly visible
1:22:47 don't say don't you see like that but
1:22:50 meaning it
1:22:51 now we see they're standing there but we
1:22:52 don't know how it is okay so go ahead
1:22:54 study it
1:22:55 don't remain like animals and donkeys
1:22:57 animals cannot study you can study go
1:22:59 ahead and study go to geography
1:23:02 geophysics your chemistry and geology
1:23:07 the same days have been however there
1:23:08 have been surfaced look at the surface
1:23:10 how it's cheap how it's related to
1:23:12 technology movements plate movements and
1:23:14 so on
1:23:15 again start geography study study
1:23:18 tectonic strategiology
1:23:21 but instead of doing that they say oh
1:23:24 it's actually flat
1:23:26 flat brains or no brains in the first
1:23:29 place
1:23:31 see my point
1:23:32 so it directs you to look and do not do
1:23:34 knowledge and do science
1:23:38 and the same with other things
1:23:41 in time past some people started like
1:23:43 this
1:23:45 even there's a reading from it is
1:23:51 she doesn't settle anywhere
1:23:53 and this is a permissible reading
1:23:55 because adding an alif the Quran shows
1:23:57 that they're adding alif is permissible
1:23:59 in certain places
1:24:02 this addition may be maybe a possible
1:24:04 reading
1:24:05 and it's from Prince Road by the way
1:24:07 from
1:24:09 salafi they will get stuck obviously
1:24:11 because somehow having wings and become
1:24:14 angels and know everything but
1:24:17 I I wouldn't adopt that that one I mean
1:24:19 I think the meaning is that but maybe
1:24:20 that's intended because adding an
1:24:22 elephant so in the Quran is well
1:24:23 established everywhere so this is one
1:24:25 way the rasm of the Quran can be
1:24:26 extended by adding alifs and Hamza these
1:24:30 four can be added in appropriate place
1:24:32 you can't add this anywhere let's see
1:24:33 does it make new sense yeah in this year
1:24:35 makes sense
1:24:37 is running with no place of rest
1:24:43 and then all the issues about where it
1:24:45 is and so prosthetic under the Irish is
1:24:48 gone for example so you have to have to
1:24:50 have to do a little bit more hard work
1:24:52 in these things
1:24:54 then that's just the shallow uh this uh
1:24:56 shallow idiots of Egypt I saw recently
1:24:58 says uh some declarative fear anyways to
1:25:01 claiming the S is not flat
1:25:04 just plain
1:25:06 I've been couldn't find any committee
1:25:08 such as indeed you are a donkey
1:25:11 say the words I couldn't what I'm
1:25:14 supposed to say
1:25:15 the comment there in YouTube recommended
1:25:18 cannot go Pages explain all what they're
1:25:20 saying now so the only things that you
1:25:22 are indeed a donkey that's all that
1:25:24 sorry I can't say anything more than
1:25:25 that or something like that
1:25:28 very unfortunate
1:25:32 good
1:25:34 so I think we can maybe see if we can
1:25:36 finish this block of context let me see
1:25:39 what's today
1:25:45 another challenge which other deity can
1:25:48 do something else let us see
1:25:50 Music
1:25:52 if we have this taking the eyesight and
1:25:54 so on and then they turn away from the
1:25:56 ayat and the next
1:25:58 attack oh
1:26:03 hello
1:26:05 yeah let's continue with the same
1:26:09 can you imagine what your condition will
1:26:11 be if God's chastisement befalls you
1:26:13 either suddenly or in again gradually
1:26:16 perceptible manner but then will any but
1:26:19 evil doing folk ever be destroyed next
1:26:22 translation say consider this what if
1:26:25 the punishment of God should come to you
1:26:26 suddenly or gradually would anyone but
1:26:29 the evil do as be destroyed yeah
1:26:31 according to previous energy obviously
1:26:33 uh it will come through the tablets it
1:26:36 doesn't have a doculation that sadly
1:26:38 came like that uh it came on the hand of
1:26:41 the believer when they when they
1:26:42 defeated them in butter and other
1:26:44 battles and then ultimately in
1:26:45 conquering Mecca then some who was
1:26:48 taught to the sword were exterminated
1:26:49 and some ran away and the rest coronated
1:26:52 their houses
1:26:53 so they were defeated and to survived
1:26:55 because they didn't report the sword
1:26:57 like Abu Sofia and others and some of
1:26:59 them became hypocrite for their life but
1:27:01 some became the believer and recognized
1:27:03 that this proves with this attitude that
1:27:06 this man is a messenger and we have been
1:27:08 wrong and Alpha and uh and and and
1:27:12 foreign
1:27:31 with my sword
1:27:33 and then later on in Madina he told the
1:27:35 people some of your mercurysm people
1:27:37 because some people objected that that
1:27:39 abubakaran were receiving Bilal and the
1:27:41 other slaves the glory be what exactly
1:27:43 are people from the law class people and
1:27:46 they say they are not giving us a face
1:27:47 as we deserve and you told them Listen
1:27:49 People
1:27:50 and the others they accelerated to Islam
1:27:53 where do you stand back you are the
1:27:55 reason for your low class now if you
1:27:58 want to catch with them up
1:28:00 show your Iman and go to now say I'm not
1:28:03 just saying that I am doing it I am
1:28:05 going to go to Sham and pass away in the
1:28:06 battle and I think he was murdered in
1:28:08 any artwork that's the way things said
1:28:10 that's the way to get honor you don't
1:28:12 get honored by by complaining about
1:28:14 Bilal and others being admitted for us
1:28:16 in the audience with Abu Bakr because
1:28:18 they were fast you are in detail stay in
1:28:21 detail as you would if you want to come
1:28:22 forward do something to show Allah that
1:28:25 you are worthy I am going to go and go
1:28:27 for Jihad and he went he packed his
1:28:29 luggage went and was murdered in shop
1:28:31 that's the same for Halloween
1:28:33 so we can't conclude with almost
1:28:35 attitude Allah that is a True Believer
1:28:38 why the opposite Allah
1:28:41 for example
1:28:44 Etc
1:28:46 but they were they saw that and still
1:28:48 even perseverance seeing that he thought
1:28:50 oh that is just the way that they are
1:28:52 knighted and because there's a Sofia
1:28:54 most likely believed in in the two
1:28:55 deities believing in a good evil and God
1:28:58 oh yes the the force of evil or the
1:29:01 force of good has this time succeeded
1:29:03 next time the possible evil this is back
1:29:04 and forth it will go like that
1:29:07 and he said another occasion I have I
1:29:09 don't know about Hellfire on Paradise
1:29:11 but we'll have another asthma with
1:29:13 electricity but this is an opportunity
1:29:15 to to play with with the government with
1:29:18 the with the rule with the rulership
1:29:20 like playing with it with a ball
1:29:22 everyone I throw the ball to you you
1:29:23 throw it to me and we play ball with it
1:29:25 that's it forget about Jannah and none
1:29:28 of that existed
1:29:29 so we have it that's exam we have this
1:29:31 example
1:29:32 although he saw
1:29:33 the demise of the Quran standing on the
1:29:37 kingdom but it didn't it didn't help
1:29:40 and some so but concerning the previous
1:29:43 Nation when the Allah's punishment came
1:29:44 especially if it is a the physical
1:29:46 punishment the one the Believers have
1:29:49 been always saved taken out out of the
1:29:51 Hill the people of wood they left the
1:29:53 the place before the the Cyclone hit the
1:29:58 people of sarda he told them you will
1:30:00 enjoy your life for three days and they
1:30:02 will be extremulated and he left with
1:30:03 his own people and they were excavated
1:30:05 and they was laughing at mocking after
1:30:07 the three days
1:30:09 the earthquake was wasability with
1:30:12 lightning I think it's talking about
1:30:13 destroying them and so on and the same
1:30:16 with the people of of uh of madian etc
1:30:19 etc
1:30:22 so that is how it works and even if it
1:30:25 works in a more Gentle Way like after
1:30:27 Musa essentially it became gentler it's
1:30:30 usually in the hand of the believer in
1:30:32 the battlefield so that there will be
1:30:33 remaining people enough people who may
1:30:35 benefit and take hit
1:30:37 which is amazing for my kind actually
1:30:39 this videos are banished in the hand of
1:30:41 the Hostile one the belligerent one the
1:30:43 one who oppressed and kill and and maim
1:30:47 they are fought by the Believers thus
1:30:49 usually will never be an extermination
1:30:51 War
1:30:52 that the chiefs of coverage eliminated
1:30:56 possibly most of them and some of their
1:30:59 armies are destroyed and the rest would
1:31:01 May majority of them may come to their
1:31:03 sets let's say merciful models what they
1:31:05 had it's no more volcanoes hurricanes
1:31:08 and things like that finishing the job
1:31:10 that's a mercy after the time of Musa
1:31:12 essentially said that's the way it is
1:31:15 being done
1:31:18 okay I think this after that it starts
1:31:20 essentially a new context so let us let
1:31:22 us stop here and catch also
1:31:30 Music
1:31:34 on you uh
1:31:38 so first of all uh let me start with the
1:31:42 the Ayah that you just finished uh uh uh
1:31:46 you know the the people of uh previous
1:31:48 uh prophets uh the Believers of them
1:31:51 Allah had saved but he exterminated the
1:31:55 those who who did not believe right
1:31:57 generally before yeah exactly but I
1:32:00 think uh this treatment is is only for
1:32:04 for the uh for those people uh of the
1:32:08 previous prophets because in general I
1:32:10 mean nowadays we see that uh any type of
1:32:13 uh of natural uh catastrophe you know
1:32:17 you can call it uh uh you can call it
1:32:21 like earthquakes or volcano eruptions
1:32:23 you know we see that it takes all all
1:32:27 people bad or good so okay I see what
1:32:30 you're assuming let me just quickly get
1:32:33 at some points of these first of all
1:32:35 these National academies which had
1:32:38 and they have two-sided because they are
1:32:41 not in response to denying a messenger
1:32:43 which are present that's that's gone the
1:32:45 last messenger Muhammad is gone after
1:32:46 that no one who claimed to be a
1:32:48 messenger of any respectability has come
1:32:50 and with those who have come have been
1:32:51 explored as Liars we know that for a
1:32:53 fact
1:32:54 yeah agreed now now these calamities
1:32:59 of national academies they are then a
1:33:03 punishment for the disbeliever and the
1:33:05 mercy and murdered for the Believers so
1:33:06 Allah made them like that so but because
1:33:08 that system of the universe because you
1:33:10 are living an area which is unstable
1:33:13 because two plates are one place is
1:33:16 going under another place like andarada
1:33:17 Himalayan like in in West Iran or
1:33:21 Northwest Iran like in Turkey and so on
1:33:23 this will go on and off over and over
1:33:25 and over it does not it may be
1:33:27 punishment for some people and mess with
1:33:28 other people that's the General
1:33:30 Adaptation but also the interesting
1:33:33 Hadith is that about the plague
1:33:36 originally the first time the plague hit
1:33:38 Earth was a punishment for certain
1:33:40 people
1:33:41 possibly an ancient prostitution out of
1:33:43 a recording history maybe in the Far
1:33:45 East because simply plague has imagined
1:33:46 in China and the Far East
1:33:51 then after that it stayed in Earth
1:33:53 meaning it's encirculating going here
1:33:56 appearing coming inside
1:33:57 Allah made it after that
1:34:00 a punishment and done your punishment
1:34:02 for the disbeliever and the murderer
1:34:05 because it has staying Earth is a
1:34:07 bacteria it's a one type of bacillus I
1:34:11 don't know
1:34:12 whatever what type of bacteria it is and
1:34:16 it is now circulating it hides sometimes
1:34:19 in in rodents and come again and back
1:34:21 and forth and still somewhere hidden in
1:34:24 some places and erupts inside if the
1:34:26 conditions are right now with the vagina
1:34:27 hygiene is less dangerous less there and
1:34:30 also with antibiotics the danger is less
1:34:32 but still it may erupt one day
1:34:35 since that's not the initial of the
1:34:36 universe the bacterium it has to stay
1:34:38 and survive
1:34:41 it would hit some people
1:34:43 on some places the clinical objective
1:34:46 conditions then it will be in that
1:34:48 context when it happens of a punishment
1:34:50 for the disbelievers
1:34:53 by making a bonus for the believer it is
1:34:55 that I murdered them for the Believers
1:34:58 it's not just a normal death it's a
1:35:00 mercedon for the Believers
1:35:02 which becomes like a reward for the
1:35:04 Believers
1:35:05 so things were became well balanced yeah
1:35:07 is that what you mean that's it but
1:35:09 there was all it is National event and
1:35:11 so on like for example if you remember
1:35:12 in with the famous tsunami in was 2004
1:35:16 .
1:35:19 and some people speculating how could
1:35:22 God allowed I said are these people are
1:35:24 just the people are stuck with the same
1:35:26 problem of the and that's usually you
1:35:28 find these claims coming from so-called
1:35:30 Christian side because
1:35:31 their definition of the deity is faulty
1:35:34 they say there's extreme goodness
1:35:36 because they have to persuade something
1:35:38 like that to justify that he sacrificed
1:35:40 his own son for the people sin which is
1:35:43 nonsense
1:35:44 that's not that's all these nonsense
1:35:45 that's not that's not uh that's not the
1:35:48 way uh The Divide attributes are and not
1:35:51 the way they open University structured
1:35:53 that's a doctor if if I could just add
1:35:55 one more thing please before going to
1:35:57 the second point so uh so Allah also for
1:36:00 the previous Nations the previous
1:36:01 nations of the prophets Allah I think
1:36:04 what I believe is that Allah had saved
1:36:06 the Believers so they can become the
1:36:08 eyewitnesses of what happened to those
1:36:11 who got exterminated so this so by being
1:36:15 eyewitnesses they could they could till
1:36:17 the next Generations see the see those
1:36:20 who disbelieved uh don't be like them or
1:36:22 other otherwise that's one of it was one
1:36:25 of the benefits of it but it's just a
1:36:27 punishment by itself but they be they
1:36:28 believe that the Believers are safe
1:36:30 because that punishment Was Won by a
1:36:32 prophet that you will be destroyed and
1:36:34 the believer will be saved so Allah has
1:36:36 to fulfill his purpose that's the
1:36:37 fundamental point that there will be
1:36:38 eyewitnesses they report further that's
1:36:40 all okay that's all extras hey things
1:36:43 and investors do not have one word
1:36:44 they're very complex and very interwoven
1:36:46 yeah that's true yes okay excellent
1:36:49 excellent uh second point please is that
1:36:52 you know you touched up on the
1:36:53 abrogation and you were talking about
1:36:56 the eye of Sword and the error committed
1:36:58 by Imam Shafi
1:37:01 exactly I I also read this in in in in
1:37:04 your last research the citizenship
1:37:08 that's by the way that's just a casual a
1:37:11 casual mentioning the whole research
1:37:12 yeah several things will come out so
1:37:15 wait for it okay okay got it I I haven't
1:37:18 read there's the whole research by the
1:37:20 way but no it's not out yet the big one
1:37:22 is is coming out that's that's
1:37:24 theoretically for this issue I mentioned
1:37:26 that casually there in the issue of
1:37:27 citization
1:37:31 is sufficient Enough by itself but the
1:37:34 other one is completely comprehensive
1:37:36 including you are studying all the
1:37:38 confrontation between the sahaba and
1:37:40 Persia and roma and show that there it
1:37:42 is really not an offensive Jihad in the
1:37:45 sense
1:37:49 is ultimately a defensive
1:37:51 yes I just want to focus on on
1:37:53 abrogation itself you know because uh
1:37:55 Imam Sharif he says that the or or
1:37:58 people like him Scholars like him they
1:38:00 say that the latter can abrogate the
1:38:03 former and I don't know performer the
1:38:06 point is that the latter usually
1:38:07 obligated from it but the general will
1:38:10 never abrogate the the expression and
1:38:13 the absolute the the absolute will never
1:38:15 obligate the restricted warmer or not
1:38:18 formal but if it's like for example uh
1:38:21 facing facing vital mark this
1:38:24 was obligated by facing Mecca
1:38:26 that's a specific specific on Facebook
1:38:33 so that's the application but you take a
1:38:36 look in a matter of abrogation and
1:38:38 general and special in in the in the
1:38:40 appendix to the constitution of uh uh uh
1:38:43 uh Islamic renewal party yeah and then
1:38:46 the appendix about concluding and
1:38:48 deriving have you seen that it is
1:38:50 available in uh yes
1:38:54 yes I read it
1:39:01 issue in various obligations various
1:39:03 restrictions
1:39:04 yes but this is this is because of the
1:39:07 logical problem there
1:39:09 is that he he did not they did not say
1:39:13 he did not
1:39:14 clearly so uh
1:39:17 he did not establish this principle in
1:39:19 all colority
1:39:21 in all clarity
1:39:23 um in some places he applies it some he
1:39:25 doesn't apply it is not consistent
1:39:28 yes I see actually doctor I just want to
1:39:31 make the make the last point is you see
1:39:33 these these fine details uh even a
1:39:37 modern Judiciary systems they they
1:39:40 completely neglect I mean I I checked
1:39:43 many penal code in different countries
1:39:47 you know they say in in in the articles
1:39:50 is that if the if a new uh law uh
1:39:53 becomes uh you know becomes established
1:39:56 and passes by the parliament it
1:39:58 abrogates uh the previous law even even
1:40:02 if it was uh General so so the the so so
1:40:06 they so they have the same problem with
1:40:08 I don't if they say that or if they have
1:40:11 even an idea about abrogation in general
1:40:13 specific this this static technicalities
1:40:17 have developed essentially about Islamic
1:40:19 scholars Islamic
1:40:25 has these two unique unique system first
1:40:28 system is the unique system of of isnat
1:40:30 and Hadith
1:40:32 and the second unique system which
1:40:33 nobody has had is
1:40:35 and if you did not participate with us
1:40:37 in the Holocaust I think we have
1:40:38 recording of the halach and so on and
1:40:41 the discussion about ahmedi rash may
1:40:43 remember a recording and so on and the
1:40:45 the Western scholar who said that said
1:40:47 this is an approach to law and so on or
1:40:50 is not known to any other Nation but not
1:40:52 even to the West now
1:40:54 oh
1:40:57 because because from my reading from my
1:41:00 understanding is that I think it now
1:41:02 nowadays in the modern state it becomes
1:41:04 like a fixed principle uh to all
1:41:08 lawmakers they say that whatever law
1:41:11 becomes uh passes in the parliament it
1:41:14 becomes the uh the the acting law so so
1:41:19 so all lawmakers so all lawyers and
1:41:22 judges
1:41:24 what you are saying probably mistake
1:41:26 about law to be applied but we are
1:41:27 talking here about Revelation statements
1:41:29 of the revelation
1:41:31 oh yeah it's different here how to drive
1:41:33 from a statement's law and regulations
1:41:35 and fact so we are taking another level
1:41:37 of deduction not not a law is just a
1:41:40 final conclusion like if you conclude
1:41:42 from that elect what shafri said that's
1:41:44 now the law according to chatri that is
1:41:47 wrong the Jews from the relation that's
1:41:49 the problem it's not that it is because
1:41:51 I said he said it's because abrogated
1:41:53 now you can fight at Michigan even if
1:41:55 they are peaceful they never started
1:41:57 anything they opened the doors for that
1:41:58 one and so on I say that's wrong your
1:42:00 deduction is wrong but his law is that
1:42:03 if you adopt a chef hello you will apply
1:42:05 the snow like that but how it is derived
1:42:07 because the law in in in our in our case
1:42:10 the first
1:42:11 in our case is derived from the
1:42:14 Revelation and the Revelation is coming
1:42:16 in textual wording and action of the
1:42:19 Prophet describe the words
1:42:20 so this has to be analyzed and this
1:42:22 place will have developed to reduce from
1:42:24 the Revelation the law or the freak
1:42:27 for The Other Guys the law is the act of
1:42:29 the parliament the will of the
1:42:30 parliament and if in doubt you can go to
1:42:32 see the the notes of the of the
1:42:34 discussion of the communities where they
1:42:36 discussed and explained so they cannot
1:42:38 be blamed because the act of the
1:42:40 sovereign already enacted as a law
1:42:43 so you don't see this problem there's no
1:42:45 problem there in some sense although it
1:42:47 may be some some places there may be
1:42:49 some some issues of problem there maybe
1:42:50 but generally in the application maybe
1:42:53 some problem like for example the I'll
1:42:55 give you a relatively terrible example
1:42:57 and we close this because we catch
1:42:58 household is that uh some some policeman
1:43:02 used to for example to to give give a
1:43:05 ticket and uh and uh and the take points
1:43:09 from driver whom he say who we see
1:43:12 eating a sandwich while driving say
1:43:14 eating a sandwich similar he make a
1:43:15 class similar to to uh to listening to
1:43:19 the phone and you know listening to the
1:43:21 phone you take points off and so on as
1:43:22 well not by actual problem say there's
1:43:24 no difference for that in his
1:43:26 application now the question is he right
1:43:28 or wrongly that's on the application of
1:43:29 individual cases
1:43:32 clearly from the reason that this
1:43:35 prohibited to use the phone is that is
1:43:36 is that you have the full Focus not on
1:43:38 the street and you may cause accident
1:43:40 pushes have been proven by a fact
1:43:42 so the you are punished by points and
1:43:44 and maybe a monetary penalty is eating
1:43:48 similar to that taking your your
1:43:51 attention from the street that's not to
1:43:53 be analyzed because obviously law has
1:43:55 been acted with that intention does it
1:43:57 apply here it has to be analyzed how
1:43:59 much being chewing and eating divert you
1:44:01 from poking the focusing on the state I
1:44:04 would say most likely he is wrong
1:44:06 because uh eating putting up biting a
1:44:08 piece and chewing and watching the state
1:44:09 it will not interfere because this is
1:44:11 almost like a mechanical act it's not
1:44:13 like talking in the telephone or texting
1:44:15 definitely not
1:44:17 yes so he's not but on that ground
1:44:21 yes yes the reason for chaos is not
1:44:24 there
1:44:25 lastly I just want to mention the last
1:44:28 thing and maybe we'll close after this
1:44:29 uh you you actually responded to
1:44:33 Scholars like Imam shafri by saying by
1:44:36 mentioning the Ayah
1:44:41 and you like you highlighted
1:44:44 those who uh fight you so and and your
1:44:49 argument is that this Ayah cannot be
1:44:51 abrogated I I also want to add a a small
1:44:55 note
1:44:57 it can be abrogated the sovereign
1:45:20 Music
1:45:26 Define differently
1:45:28 Allah changed
1:45:30 the reality of things like for example
1:45:33 to eat it's not that it's by Divine
1:45:37 permission
1:45:38 yes yes
1:45:40 let us take don't go in in the Deep
1:45:43 philosophical issues about what is uh
1:45:45 how the surveillance subhanallah uh in
1:45:48 ultimately inequitable he wants and so
1:45:51 on the only limitation related to the
1:45:53 Divine attributes that's all but let's
1:45:55 leave that the follow says will come
1:45:57 Michelle and all these points will be
1:45:58 discussed
1:46:00 thank you so much thank you
1:46:16 finished this
1:46:19 okay yeah
1:46:21 Music
1:46:37 foreign
1:46:39 Music
1:46:48 Music
1:46:54 Music
1:47:03 Music
1:47:11 Music
1:47:20 foreign
1:47:23 Music