Preservation of Qur’an- Ust Abdul Rahman Hassan MH podcast #3 (2020-06-14)

## Description

Some vital information discussed about the preservation of the Qur'an with Ustad Abdul Rahman Hassan.

Twitter: https://twitter.com/mohammed_hijab?s=20 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mohammedhijabofficial/?hl=en Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/brothermohammedhijab/ Soundcloud: https://soundcloud.com/mohammed-hijab-465985305

Summary of Preservation of Qur’an- Ust Abdul Rahman Hassan MH podcast #3

This summary is AI generated - there may be inaccuracies. *

00:00:00 [01:00:00

discusses the importance of learning Qur'an, and how it can be learned in a deep and lasting way. It features Assalamualaikum Warahmatullahi wa Barakatu speaker Mohammed Salameh, who discusses the various aspects of Qur'an learning, from pronunciation to meaning. He also recommends reading books on Qur'an learning, as well as attending Qur'an classes and clubs.

00:00:00 Discusses the importance of learning Qur'an, and how it can be learned in a deep and lasting way. It features Assalamualaikum Warahmatullahi wa Barakatu speaker Mohammed Salameh, who discusses the various aspects of Qur'an learning, from pronunciation to meaning. He also recommends reading books on Qur'an learning, as well as attending Qur'an classes and clubs. If someone wants to start learning Qur'an now, Salameh recommends starting with the pronunciation and articulation aspects, followed by the meaning.

00:05:00 The presenter discusses how his research into Quran has led him to study Animal Care Art more specifically. He discusses how the Quran was sent down from Allah, who is the source of its authenticity. He also discusses how doubts about the Quran have existed for a long time, and how these doubts are not new.
00:10:00 Discusses how the Quran is a revelation from Allah, and how Muhammad tried to change a letter here and there but ultimately failed. He also mentions that there are scholars who believe that the Quran is in poetic form, and that it was passed down from Prophet Muhammad in an oral format.
00:15:00 Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi discusses the concept of Quran preservation and how it applies to Muslims. He notes that the authorities of Islam were of the same opinion and that the Quran is protected from time till now. He also speaks about how the Prophet was still commanded to convey the message first and how the believers should ignore the disbelievers.
00:20:00 The presenter discusses the different readings of the Quran and how these readings are explained through the Prophet Muhammad's interactions with the people. He argues that all of the variant readings within the Islamic tradition are not something which is additional to the text, but are explained through the Prophet's interactions with the people.
00:25:00 Discusses the different ways Qur'anic verses can be read, with some verses having multiple meanings that are revealed depending on the context. One example given is the omission of the word "mother" in Surah Al-Muminun, which has a different meaning depending on the situation. There is disagreement among Islamic scholars as to whether this specific detail is a matter of revealed masala or whether it is a matter of the text itself having different meanings.
00:30:00 Discusses the different opinions on the preservation of the Quran, noting that there is no disagreement about its transmission, but there is disagreement about its meaning. He goes on to explain that, even if one view is weaker, it is still inconsequential to the Quran's preservation because it does not affect the fact that it was revealed in a way that was intended to be easy to understand for the people. He mentions a course he is teaching on the preservation of the Quran, which he plans to include a detailed presentation of each of the forty-something views on the matter, with evidence and criticism for each. He ends by noting that, even if one takes the weakest view, it is still correct to believe that the Quran is preserved.
00:35:00 The presenter discusses the differences between Quranic transmission and Old Testament transmission, noting that Quranic transmission is not reliant on a chain of narration like Old Testament transmission is. He also points out that there are variants within Quranic discourse because of Sabah, an explanation for which is provided by comparative religion. He argues that it is important to approach Quranic transmission from a text criticism perspective in order to understand the variations between the Quran and other texts. Finally, the presenter argues that there is a lack of harmonizing method in Quranic transmission, which is a weakness compared to Old Testament transmission.
00:40:00 Discusses the importance of memorizing the Quran, and the difference between a pillar and a half. He also discusses why people commonly confuse these terms.
00:45:00 The caller discusses the different ways in which the Koran can be recited, and how the different recitations are motivated by multiple factors. He also mentions some of the Imams who have spoken about the preservation of the Quran.
00:50:00 Discusses the importance of the triangulating method for determining whether a text is authentic, and how this method applies to the Quran. Jerry notes that not all texts from older authors are authentic, and that there are operational texts that are different from the continental skeletal structure.
00:55:00 The narrator discusses the various Qur'anic readings, including Abdullah Nuhmin's recitation which is the most authoritative. He also notes that the Prophet gave instructions to follow the whole of the Quran, which is religiously authoritative.

01:00:00 [01:30:00

, Imam Abdul Rahman Hassan discusses the preservation of the Qur'an and how Islamic scholars have played a vital role in keeping it accurate. He also talks about the importance of studying the Qur'an and how it is the final message from Allah to mankind.

01:00:00 Discusses how the Quran is preserved and how different readings are all based on the authentic interpretation of the Prophet Muhammad.

01:05:00 Discusses the importance of preserving the Quran, and discussing how Muslims have distance themselves from learning the religion. The narrator tells a story of meeting a non-Muslim who was surprised to learn that the Quran was originally written in Arabic. The non-Muslim asked the narrator to read a verse from the Quran aloud. The narrator was taken aback when he realized that the non-Muslim was referring to the same verse that he was. The non-Muslim explained that this is because the Quran is filled with beautiful and powerful words that appeal to everyone. The narrator points out that many non-Muslims are able to understand and appreciate the Quran because they have been raised on a foundation of Islamic knowledge.
01:10:00 Discusses the preservation of the Qur'an and how scholars study it to try and find errors. Ella Healy, who is from the U.S., talks about her experience studying the Qur'an and how she believes that it is the final message from Allah to mankind. She also discusses how this message is preserved in a way that no other book has been preserved.
01:15:00 Discusses the variants of the Qur'an and how to ensure they are not the result of the Sahaba themselves. He also discusses the concept of coatl, or the water means the halo, and how it limits the number of people who can agree on a particular variant. He concludes by discussing the Bedouins and how they were a part of the early Muslims.
01:20:00 Discusses the concept of "truce" in karate, and how the Quran supports it. He also discusses the research he has done on the topic.
01:25:00 Discusses the preservation of the Qur'an, with Imam Abdul Rahman Hassan discussing the importance of Islamic scholars preserving the Qur'an. Imam Hassan talks about how Islamic scholars from the past were able to correct other Orientalists, and how we need to be careful not to doubt our events. He also mentions Canadian scholar Nikolai Sinai, who debunked the myths of Renaissance figure Casanova.
01:30:00 Discusses some of the issues surrounding Quranic studies in the West and how Orientalists often dominate the discourse. He also discusses how the Annabelle Room, a YouTube channel devoted to the study of the Qur'an, is free and open to anyone.

Full transcript with timestamps: CLICK TO EXPAND

0:00:00 assalamualaikum warahmatullahi 0:00:01 wabarakatu and welcome to the third 0:00:03 podcast here with a lot of Manhattan how 0:00:07 are you is dead who's been in the UAE 0:00:14 research and education is doing there 0:00:17 and marshal life in instructor for very 0:00:21 long time is known online before we get 0:00:24 started 0:00:25 this is just a good place to start with 0:00:27 the podcast I mean you've been involved 0:00:29 in many kind of educational programs 0:00:30 teaching and learning for some years how 0:00:35 would you advise a beginner student of 0:00:37 knowledge did you die hard I mean the 0:00:42 whole Hum Dil Hassan what's the net will 0:00:44 Jamil or I should do a yahoodi' shitty 0:00:47 killer why should you and I say then I 0:00:48 want to be and i'm mohammed salameh re 0:00:50 he were early he was Harvey with Derby 0:00:53 arena learning in a young Medina mother 0:00:55 the path to knowledge is a very deep and 0:01:00 the scholars they say it's battler Sahil 0:01:02 Allahu it's an ocean that doesn't have a 0:01:05 shore so you're going to spend the rest 0:01:07 of your life learning once you take this 0:01:10 path you will never feel like you've 0:01:13 learned enough rather the more you learn 0:01:15 the more it becomes clear to you that 0:01:17 you don't know and every time you read 0:01:21 the Quran you remember the ayah or folk 0:01:23 will be there in Manali that every 0:01:26 knowledge that you may have accumulated 0:01:28 and gathered Allahu Allah 0:01:31 is more knowledgeable than you and knows 0:01:33 more when the scholars define a rhythm 0:01:37 they say that reading is in the Rock 0:01:39 will show you a drama who re in rock and 0:01:40 jazz EEMA 0:01:41 it is to know something as it is with 0:01:44 certainty so is to perceive something as 0:01:47 it is with certainty so the knowledge 0:01:52 that really a person should give a lot 0:01:56 of time to is a real monk or annual 0:01:58 Sunnah an e-learning the speech of Allah 0:02:00 who subhana wa ta'ala and the tradition 0:02:03 of the prophet sallallahu alayhi wa 0:02:04 sallam ah I mean those are the two which 0:02:07 our salvation and our prosperity is 0:02:10 connected to Allah 0:02:12 Hana wa'ta'ala he says in the head of 0:02:15 Khurana here nearly lady here up one 0:02:17 more you Bushiroad mean and latina yeah 0:02:18 I'm a-gonna sorry Hardwick 0:02:20 a la semana each other he says in had an 0:02:23 ASD ility here aqua well you best she 0:02:26 don't wear Bashir al mumineen alladhina 0:02:29 amanu no sorry hockey and neuron Kabira 0:02:32 final Edina liability I didn't allahumma 0:02:35 Devin other man Alima 0:02:37 so this aura on guides to the best of 0:02:40 affairs it saves you from many 0:02:44 destruction and many pain and it also 0:02:49 guides you when mothers feel misguided 0:02:52 and when people are in darkness is if 0:02:54 you have this Quran you feel joy but I 0:02:58 delicately mama shot to me he says and 0:03:00 he's captured with Emanuel what return 0:03:01 if your karate Saba he says that what I 0:03:06 do for in about do for Hubble of life in 0:03:09 Akita boohoo Vijaya he'd be similarly 0:03:11 damaja billah al Aug Dayton the Adamu 0:03:15 Ali allergy demo villa re all marble 0:03:18 karma mr. Liu who cut you geology marie 0:03:21 hangemuhl machina 0:03:22 well more tapa a man-eater can imagine 0:03:25 like him until he says in the key table 0:03:29 he also crucial fear in Havana in well 0:03:32 hidden motive Abdullah 0:03:33 a huge Ellison Lajamanu hadiza who with 0:03:36 her dad was defeated a mullah -0:03:39 photography lumati min al-kibriya Elka 0:03:42 who sang with Helena so the Quran I say 0:03:46 that it's the best thing a person gets 0:03:48 tried to focuses on reads Ponder's on 0:03:51 and also the sunnah of the prophet 0:03:53 alayhi salatu salam no resources books 0:03:59 would you recommend further so if 0:04:04 someone wants to get started now in the 0:04:06 city of knowledge they want to start 0:04:08 like reading the Quran being able to 0:04:11 read being able to understand that being 0:04:15 able to kind of equate themselves with 0:04:16 the soul of the hadith 0:04:17 what kind of program would you I mean 0:04:20 like yourself if you had someone a 0:04:22 student of yours what kind of program 0:04:24 would you give for them 0:04:26 the Quran in terms of learning it 0:04:29 divides it in divided into two in terms 0:04:31 of learning its growth its pronunciation 0:04:33 and articulation and also learning in 0:04:36 terms of its meaning so I would 0:04:38 encourage the person to read books like 0:04:40 photo op file in order to perfect that a 0:04:42 tweet and until in terms of the meaning 0:04:45 go to like tertiary McAteer to 0 del la 0:04:48 these clubs in terms of Tessier it gives 0:04:51 a person understanding as for the hadith 0:04:54 of the Prophet the habits are divided 0:04:57 also into two a hadith or a cam like 0:04:59 under to document bloom Alam and also 0:05:02 koutou which are Johanna like the other 0:05:04 Saudi hain and Lulu and margin FEMA 0:05:07 traffic re shahad and these two in the 0:05:13 hadith definitely definitely better to 0:05:15 benefit the student knowledge long have 0:05:20 you been doing any particular research 0:05:21 now I know you in the UAE now and you're 0:05:25 engaged in a lot of research extra 0:05:27 degrees so what can we do and right now 0:05:33 there's a lot of sciences I always open 0:05:36 up when it comes to researches I look 0:05:39 into our research if you're in this side 0:05:42 of the world generally you look into 0:05:44 things related to Islamic finance and 0:05:46 things like that but there was a 0:05:48 research that was ongoing for me or for 0:05:52 a while now which is a lumen Quran and 0:05:56 normal Quran of course is a big science 0:05:59 it's you're talking about tej weed 0:06:03 you're talking about anyone was Bob Dole 0:06:07 Quran and I they're talking about 0:06:10 inverter art and so I've been looking 0:06:14 specifically at Animal Care art a bit 0:06:17 more and try to have a good 0:06:21 understanding regarding it now 0:06:24 interesting because the second podcast 0:06:26 I've done which is the last one we 0:06:28 actually had a conversation about about 0:06:30 that and some of you know Western 0:06:32 academics are actually again involved in 0:06:35 Quran if you like but from the 0:06:37 Orientalism we called an outsider's 0:06:39 perspective and I mean the standard 0:06:43 discussions about often cannot and are 0:06:45 trickling down to us naked email I'm not 0:06:47 saying that or an studies are so 0:06:50 saturated as is something which people 0:06:54 have side to talk about are you aware of 0:06:55 some of the kind of Western academic 0:06:58 works and so in terms of when it comes 0:07:04 to studying at science the the path 0:07:07 which is arepa to musalla the correct 0:07:09 way to do things 0:07:11 and I always encourage students of 0:07:13 knowledge to do is first of all learn 0:07:15 what is for you before you think about 0:07:17 observing what is against you because a 0:07:20 lot of harm comes from that you start 0:07:22 gaining doubts speculations so equip 0:07:25 yourself for what is I heard you for you 0:07:28 rather than first looking at what is 0:07:30 against you so alhamdulillah 0:07:32 a great portion of of my research I've 0:07:36 been looking at the kalaam of the ulema 0:07:39 of al-islam what they've said grounding 0:07:41 myself with their understanding and 0:07:43 their writings and alhamdulillah then I 0:07:49 stepped forward in looking at the shoe 0:07:52 who had the doubts and the word sugar if 0:07:55 you look at in Arabic it actually means 0:07:58 to make something look like something so 0:08:01 it's basically making the truth 0:08:04 look so the falsehood look like the 0:08:06 truth it's actually not true but it's 0:08:08 you know you're trying to make it look 0:08:10 like it's the it's the truth so 0:08:14 alhamdulillah 0:08:15 whether we Orientalist or whether it be 0:08:18 people claim to be muslims their works 0:08:21 and what they've said but what I really 0:08:25 want to say inshallah is the research 0:08:27 that you know a true sincere Muslim will 0:08:30 always come back to is to know that the 0:08:32 Quran is minimally life this poor honest 0:08:35 from Allah subhana WA Ta'ala 0:08:37 and the mustard the source in which the 0:08:39 Quran comes from is Allah who spanner 0:08:41 with Allah Allah Allah Allah says in the 0:08:43 Quran in oullette indeed or bill I mean 0:08:46 Nadella be he wrote I mean and I can't 0:08:49 be can eat a food I mean and Irina Billy 0:08:51 Cernan Arabiya mabini Allah mentions 0:08:53 that the Quran has been sent down from 0:08:56 Allah who subhana wa ta'ala and it was 0:08:57 sent down to the Prophet Allah Allah 0:08:59 cinema through Gabriel also Allah 0:09:01 subhana WA Ta'ala he says to the Prophet 0:09:02 or my own support and in our in Hua 0:09:05 Allah was her you knew her we do the 0:09:09 appeal is the one who taught him so the 0:09:10 Quran came to the prophet sallallaahu in 0:09:13 cinema through the prophets or through G 0:09:15 bill so the argument from Allah Azza WA 0:09:19 Jalla to the prophet through jbeil also 0:09:21 Allah subhana WA Ta'ala he says were in 0:09:23 Nutella - economy Lagoon hockey mineral 0:09:25 in the Dysport and Muhammad it has been 0:09:28 given to given to you from the wise the 0:09:33 most knowledgeable one and he's from 0:09:35 allahu subhanahu China and the the 0:09:39 doubts that have been open regarding the 0:09:41 Quran are not new like even at the time 0:09:43 of the Prophet Elias and people try to 0:09:47 speak about the Quran and say things 0:09:49 about it 0:09:50 they said about Alamo in the homeo Aluna 0:09:54 in the Rio a limo bus shop and it is 0:09:56 Commons are teaching you it they said 0:09:59 that to him also 0:10:01 they said to him muhammad sallallahu 0:10:04 alayhi wa sallam when he read the Quran 0:10:06 on them either to telling him to not be 0:10:09 enacting : lady in Allah or to Allah car 0:10:11 an activity has opened Alou all my Acuna 0:10:14 leandroop modena home until NFC in a 0:10:17 tabular in la mujer a in a half an hour 0:10:20 say traviata a human are they cool 0:10:22 allahu allah allahumma la can be forged 0:10:25 allah bestow human Cubberley he a fella 0:10:28 started on this ayah they said to the 0:10:30 prophet sallallaahu assalamu you and you 0:10:35 know it and he said to them so Allah are 0:10:38 you a cinema that the changing of the 0:10:39 Quran is is not something I can do you 0:10:42 know I can't change it from my own self 0:10:44 like this is again teaching us that the 0:10:47 Quran is Allah your Rabbani and it's a 0:10:50 revelation 0:10:51 and Allah Azza WA Jalla well in Arica 0:10:54 when the Quran first came down an 0:10:56 ability muhammad sallah allahu cinema as 0:10:58 I derive my best mentioned in sahih 0:11:00 bukhari that he he Sun Alliance element 0:11:05 he used to receive from it when he beam 0:11:07 would come to him and he would listen to 0:11:09 him 0:11:10 you're a determinate NZD should that and 0:11:12 he would find hardship from it because 0:11:15 the Prophet solid cinema wanted to 0:11:16 memorize quickly and so he would try it 0:11:18 would move his lips in order to memorize 0:11:20 and he was commanded not to have it be 0:11:23 Healy sana colita Adela be in Noreen 0:11:26 idea ahoo oo karana energy America 0:11:28 factorial karana if the Quran is recited 0:11:31 on you Mohammed just listen we're gonna 0:11:35 pour it into your heart so from this we 0:11:38 really take an understanding which is 0:11:40 this Quran is from Allah 0:11:42 even if Muhammad sallallahu said have I 0:11:44 tried to change the Quran a letter a lot 0:11:46 told us that he's gonna destroy him 0:11:48 erase or - Salam well in about akka will 0:11:51 hardly I mean who Billy I mean to 0:11:54 Malacca bottom Malik Appa and I mean 0:11:55 Hulu a team if Muhammad SAW Allah Allahu 0:11:58 Salima 0:11:59 he tried to say something about half 0:12:01 worried one letter a loss from Hanoi to 0:12:03 Allah he says la copa and min will with 0:12:06 him destroy Mahan who harm him for try 0:12:11 for trying to add or subtract from the 0:12:15 Quran Allah delicate was narrated from 0:12:17 America Bob and they didn't know 13 that 0:12:20 they said al Quran are too soon 0:12:21 Netanyahu Doha hero and a wali Farah who 0:12:24 come out limit remember bands even with 0:12:29 everything both said that the Quran is a 0:12:31 Sunnah taken one the early passes on to 0:12:35 the one that comes after he went from a 0:12:39 larger Prophet Muhammad and now you're 0:12:41 very similar to their companions the 0:12:43 companions and they administer because 0:12:47 both saying who read the Quran come a 0:12:51 limb - moo-hoo the way you was talk to 0:12:53 you and it's showing us that the Quran 0:12:56 is an a clue 0:12:57 its submission transmission sorry it's 0:13:00 what it's transmission it's passed on 0:13:02 it's not I like 0:13:03 this way so I'm gonna read it that way 0:13:06 I've did I've misread you know his 0:13:07 famous statement it tell you well I tell 0:13:09 you if a cat who fetal follow do not 0:13:11 innovate in a recitation of the Quran 0:13:12 he's been suffice also I didn't every 0:13:15 Italian said something very powerful he 0:13:16 said in a rasoolallah romantic Rahul 0:13:19 Khurana your Prophet Muhammad is 0:13:22 commanding you to read the Quran come 0:13:24 out a limit to the way it was taught in 0:13:26 lingerie and I'm revealing I'm not Danny 0:13:28 rahimullah I'm Danny and he's furious 0:13:34 Jesse's both of whom are said to be 0:13:54 images that is called mohaka 0:13:56 of this field I'm using his Karen's 0:14:00 considered to be a Phrygia in the file 0:14:06 statements are considered to be a proof 0:14:08 in the science done 0:14:10 he's a desert or Dinah and as we call it 0:14:15 a milkshake holy slamming in in the 0:14:18 science of Islam emerges early is the 0:14:20 shake holy some of these science around 0:14:26 the 8th century man and I'm gonna 0:14:33 Danny's a scholar in which an imam was 0:14:35 shot the Veera him Allah he basically 0:14:38 done then another mom he's kicked up at 0:14:40 a seat so he need another of two of 0:14:41 these books now that he made a poet 0:14:44 poetic form of his garage book a shout 0:14:48 to me as a key table called Immanuel 0:14:51 which we can occur karate Sarah which he 0:14:53 took from the authorities here of Ali 0:14:55 Mahmoud any where the same two 0:14:58 individuals are heavyweight authorities 0:15:00 in this field of preservation and 0:15:03 recitation yeah and Abu Bakr back in 0:15:08 Rani who also wrote in that booth I 0:15:10 think you saw and Asha re just to the 0:15:14 reason why I mention it is because it's 0:15:16 to show you 0:15:17 this issue has nothing to do with a 0:15:19 particular group it's actually it's it's 0:15:21 an idea and it's also a belief agreed 0:15:27 and it's all over 0:15:28 so this issue touches this issue that 0:15:31 I'm mentioning that the Quran is not 0:15:33 preserved it touches anybody who is a 0:15:37 Muslim who believes in Allah and the day 0:15:40 of judgement whether you're a Hanafy or 0:15:42 share freely or maliki whether you're a 0:15:47 whether you are any other group in Islam 0:15:50 yeah I mean other than America zerah 0:15:57 yeah but I this concept there there's a 0:16:00 discussion with them some issues even as 0:16:04 preservation of the Quran there's 0:16:05 discussion with them on some issues we 0:16:07 shouldn't generalize the old for them 0:16:08 but ala kulli mama shout to me you rahim 0:16:11 allah in his own emmanuel what return he 0:16:13 said something very powerful he said why 0:16:15 morality are sinful cara a timid Harun 0:16:18 fat noon eternity here Lavar Mitaka Fela 0:16:20 he says that in the Quran art there is 0:16:24 nothing which is HT hat is no 0:16:26 independent reasoning in karate and it's 0:16:28 all taken from the prophet and Allah and 0:16:30 it's from the Mutara it's before you get 0:16:33 a because this might get a lot of people 0:16:36 not listening here I just wanna make 0:16:37 sure that right so beginning what you 0:16:41 were showing was that there's the 0:16:43 impossibility the in conceivability that 0:16:47 the Muslim could say something other 0:16:50 than that which Allah had transmitted to 0:16:53 him based on the quranic text and then 0:16:56 you showed okay so the Companions their 0:16:59 understanding was that there's no way 0:17:01 that they could recite okay something or 0:17:05 transmit this you to transmit something 0:17:07 as pour on yeah which is other than that 0:17:10 which the Prophet transmitted to them 0:17:13 Ali thought to Sonya with me so far now 0:17:16 you on the stage where you're trying to 0:17:18 show that the authorities the Islamic 0:17:20 authorities were also of the same 0:17:22 opinion so you've mentioned in Missouri 0:17:23 and I'm about with Danny that's that's 0:17:26 where you're right okay and 0:17:29 this concept of the Quran being 0:17:32 preserved is something a lot of promised 0:17:33 us that he's going to take it upon 0:17:35 himself to protect the Quran Allah says 0:17:36 in the Quran in an eternity clock well 0:17:40 in that Allah hath alone and this is 0:17:43 that this distinct unique thing Allah 0:17:45 gave to Omar - Omar to Muhammad over the 0:17:47 other nations the other previous nations 0:17:50 Allah khabar català he tells us that 0:17:52 there were losses from Hannah to Allah 0:17:55 what a robbery you know well about be 0:17:57 masterful o makki table in Iraq an array 0:17:59 Shahada and in the previous nations 0:18:01 their rabbis and the amongst it was a 0:18:04 responsibility on them to protect their 0:18:07 books and he never told take care of 0:18:09 your book and what did they do the 0:18:11 Christians in the Jews 0:18:12 what did they do you have a phone and 0:18:13 tell him I am elderly it started to 0:18:15 tamper around with it and change it in 0:18:17 order in accordance to their own whims 0:18:19 and desires as for only to Muhammad 0:18:21 Allah as they were Delaware did he do he 0:18:24 said that I am the one who was going to 0:18:26 take it upon myself to protect it Allah 0:18:29 has some hono akari is protected it from 0:18:30 that time till now how am i sorry Ursula 0:18:35 our messenger ali salat wa salam the 0:18:39 people he came to with the quran they 0:18:45 questioned the Quran and they doubted 0:18:52 the Quran from the messenger alia salat 0:18:54 wa salam 0:18:55 but with that said the Prophet was still 0:18:57 commanded to convey the message first a 0:18:59 lot I told this matter first da Bao 0:19:02 Marable re mushrikeen Muhammad go 0:19:05 forward convey your message and ignore 0:19:07 the apologists and the Christian the 0:19:09 disbelievers ignore them and he you've 0:19:12 got the truth with you 0:19:13 these people have a preconceived notion 0:19:15 they haven't belief if you come with 0:19:18 anything they're not we need to take it 0:19:20 that's what I'm not told of the Prophet 0:19:21 sometimes becomes that and they wouldn't 0:19:23 take the message salam ala a DIN with 0:19:25 cinema and i lost about a collector ala 0:19:26 he said to him well in kanikapila area 0:19:29 home for in stop and her battalion f 0:19:32 uckin feel or do suleiman fisherman 0:19:33 faculty on B ayah voila Khadija Robles 0:19:37 unlike America to Allah he says well you 0:19:40 can a couple Erica our album if these 0:19:42 peoples turning away from Islam has 0:19:44 become heavy on you Muhammad in China 0:19:45 Cobra album in Stata and temporarily 0:19:48 another config are the old cinema Fisher 0:19:50 my effect at Giambi aya if you want to 0:19:54 have me to take a ladder to go up to the 0:19:56 sky and to bring them the guidance but 0:19:58 you won't do so leave it to us we're the 0:20:00 ones that were gonna guide who we want 0:20:02 and we're gonna leave the one we weren't 0:20:04 misguided what I'm trying to get from 0:20:06 there is so what I'm trying to get from 0:20:10 there is that there are always going to 0:20:12 be people who are going to question the 0:20:13 authority of the Quran and whether the 0:20:16 Quran is preserved 0:20:17 we cannot convince every single body 0:20:20 because of the nature of some people 0:20:22 it's not me play devil's advocate for a 0:20:25 while and since you want to 0:20:27 I mean clearly now and one of the 0:20:30 arguments that Muslims use with 0:20:33 non-muslims for the truth of Islam and 0:20:35 for the truth on the prophethood of 0:20:37 Muhammad is if not one of the main 0:20:40 arguments is that we have it preserved 0:20:42 book whereas the Christians and Jews 0:20:45 their traditions have not been preserved 0:20:48 that the Old Testament is not preserved 0:20:51 that the New Testament is not preserved 0:20:55 so the first question is how you've kind 0:20:58 of gone about showing us the Quran how 0:21:01 it's that the Prophet couldn't have 0:21:04 taken it from said something from 0:21:08 himself that arm that the Sahaba 0:21:10 couldn't have said something from their 0:21:11 own selves now the question how would 0:21:13 you go about explaining why there are 0:21:16 differences in some readings because 0:21:18 someone could argue okay that's fine but 0:21:22 there's a lot of variance you know you 0:21:24 have some variant readings like Melek 0:21:26 and Melek you have these variants like 0:21:28 you can be born actually born December 2 0:21:30 the way yellow all of these are variant 0:21:31 readings which actually do have an 0:21:33 impact on the the meaning so if it's 0:21:38 meant to be one text which is 0:21:40 unchangeable and how comes we have these 0:21:43 variants beautiful now we go to an issue 0:21:47 called the there art of the Quran we 0:21:50 have 0:21:51 the very different types of recitation 0:21:53 of the Quran 0:21:54 you see these clear art that we have 0:21:57 today as I said it's the Quran that we 0:22:00 have the most prominent of those clear 0:22:06 art is the seven that I mentioned 0:22:08 Alabama shout to be collected in his 0:22:10 kitab heads with a mani or what retain 0:22:13 the seven I mentioned when he said when 0:22:21 he said as a law bill hierarchy and 0:22:22 imitate Lennon a colossal Sarah Furman 0:22:26 who do Rho sub attend katawa Sadat 0:22:28 Samaria well at least over local mela 0:22:30 he's only 17 and then he goes to each 0:22:33 and every one of those seven the 0:22:35 scholars in his lab all unanimously 0:22:39 agree that these seven are taken from 0:22:45 nebula in Mohammed who took from debris 0:22:47 from Allah Azza WA Jalla I'm gonna 0:22:49 quickly go through the name before 0:22:51 before we continue what you're saying is 0:22:53 that all of the variant readings all of 0:22:56 the very readings within the Islamic 0:22:59 tradition within the Quran it's not 0:23:01 something which is additional to the 0:23:04 text but is explained through the 0:23:07 Prophet Muhammad SAW sermons interaction 0:23:09 with a line you're gonna tell us what 0:23:10 the 77 actual okay so now we have a 0:23:14 discussion of some ask and they put 0:23:18 forward regarding the issue of you know 0:23:21 the Allah Hafiz Sabah I'm going to try 0:23:24 to simplify a long ongoing you're the 0:23:30 expert you taught me what's the best 0:23:31 translation may be modes I don't know 0:23:33 seven it's probably best to keep as is 0:23:36 yeah I like I like to leave it as it is 0:23:39 and in explaining for people now let me 0:23:41 explain let me explain something 0:23:42 the the the 7f and it's a clear left 0:23:50 amongst the scholars what is actually 0:23:51 meant by let me actually go through the 0:23:53 hadith of the pasta madre cinema where 0:23:55 he it's all about he speaks about some 0:23:57 other the seventh the professor larry 0:23:59 Salima he said in a hadith unzila for 0:24:03 the Quran 0:24:04 sent down in seven hours Kulu her chef 0:24:07 in Katherine all of them are what 0:24:09 sufficient and all of them are enough 0:24:12 I'm either sufficing and enough and 0:24:15 curing good in another rewire when the 0:24:20 professor Larry said I'm an argument 0:24:22 happened between Hisham you know Hakim 0:24:26 and Mahabharata on who the Prophet Allah 0:24:30 really mean he told both of them in the 0:24:32 huddle Quran in surah al-ahzab a roofing 0:24:35 estimate is salami no I want to mention 0:24:37 a benefit here but even not though the 0:24:40 sub the sub roof was motivated from the 0:24:45 messenger re salat WA Salam 0:24:47 Ramar didn't know one and Hisham didn't 0:24:50 know one which the scholars take from 0:24:52 the Ottawa Toluca Diablo Coleman do 0:24:54 Nicole mean important something could be 0:24:58 motivated in one land and not in another 0:25:01 land 0:25:01 does this debunks on this story here 0:25:04 just to kind of I think it's a very 0:25:05 important story just to kind of break it 0:25:08 down so what you're saying is that our 0:25:10 local table was praying and and Shimon 0:25:13 Hakim was praying and the reciting Susan 0:25:15 for pond and a bomb in this generation 0:25:19 any girl from room here 0:25:21 it was listening to show saying some 0:25:25 things which are slightly different from 0:25:27 what he had been taught to her and so 0:25:32 wanted to cease Sharon happy me want to 0:25:35 grab him you know because of he thought 0:25:38 that he was distorting the Quran or 0:25:39 something like this after the prayer 0:25:41 finished he took him to perform Salah 0:25:44 solemn and then he said he said you read 0:25:46 you read your way of reciting surah 0:25:50 Furqan chapter 25 of Quran so he read it 0:25:53 and then he said you read and then he 0:25:55 read it right and then the Prophet he 0:25:57 affirmed that both of them are correct 0:26:01 readings they're they're both true 0:26:03 readings they're both something which 0:26:05 was revealed together Nazareth or Xena 0:26:07 yeah so this is the way kind of came 0:26:10 down like this and so what you're saying 0:26:13 here just so sorry if correct me from 0:26:15 wrong is you're saying the Quran 0:26:17 omission 0:26:18 has a multi formal basis in other words 0:26:23 there are some words not all words the 0:26:25 storyline will remain the same the 0:26:27 narrative will remain the same 0:26:28 well there are some select words which 0:26:30 will be revealed in slightly varied 0:26:33 meanings and that's not despite the text 0:26:36 that's because of the masala making 0:26:39 director to Allah and then the it 0:26:42 subsequently Allah revealing certain 0:26:44 words in varied ways but if you would 0:26:48 say they all point in the same direction 0:26:49 and they're all from and one either 0:26:51 complement wise this is this what yeah 0:26:54 correct correct correct yeah so they all 0:26:56 complement one another and by the way 0:26:58 this topic of a lot of the Saba it's not 0:27:03 a topic I can really talk about in 0:27:05 details you know in this podcast because 0:27:06 I'm just gonna mention I'll a severely 0:27:08 come teeny little house from it's gonna 0:27:10 give some examples of the scholars 0:27:11 who've written books early mammal 0:27:13 related customers salon who died here 0:27:16 224 he Julia here's the key table on the 0:27:19 surface Abba if you put a button Allah 0:27:21 is a key tab on it I will father Lord 0:27:24 Ozzy has a key carbonic mohammed el 0:27:25 Makdessi 0:27:26 has a kick up on it jay-z has a kick up 0:27:29 on Sheikh Mohammed behead theory has a 0:27:31 key table on it 0:27:33 the from the more a theory a dr 0:27:35 abdulaziz al khali who's analytically to 0:27:37 Quran and creamy German Lamia madina 0:27:38 munawwara 0:27:39 he's written a book on it and and has 0:27:41 only a demon writer and he we're talking 0:27:44 about thousands of pages recording this 0:27:46 whole discussion are you saying this is 0:27:48 no secret this is not something we're 0:27:50 trying to hide all that 0:27:59 I'm not not to mention 0:28:01 scholars have mentioned when they came 0:28:03 to this hadith if they didn't understand 0:28:05 it properly and if they didn't know what 0:28:08 it meant they didn't lie and say well 0:28:10 this is what it means for example any 0:28:12 mammal just earlier him Allah he said 0:28:14 when I was able to study Callahan hadith 0:28:15 oh well you see here another I mean 0:28:18 they even with the Athena Senna had a 0:28:20 factor Halawa Aria be my um Catania 0:28:22 Kunis Robin Sharma and he pondered over 0:28:24 the hadith he tried to understand it and 0:28:27 he brought out the definition and the 0:28:28 meaning for it 0:28:29 Irie man even really rahim allah 0:28:32 Michelle Kennedy mom Geraldine astutely 0:28:36 he mentioned 40 views in regards to what 0:28:38 it means what I want to say is that 0:28:41 these views these views are divided into 0:28:44 two now and in the reviews regarding a 0:28:47 lot of this table are are categorized 0:28:49 into two the first view is this small 0:28:52 area tend to be views that we don't give 0:28:55 any consideration to judoka Adam its 0:28:58 presence is like its absence 0:29:00 you see yeah the second one is Allah 0:29:06 Allah is your to be here we give it 0:29:09 weight and we say it has the needful 0:29:14 Joomla generally has evidences or super 0:29:17 super to Delhi they believe kind of 0:29:21 points that direct continue hey just to 0:29:24 kind of once again consolidate food 0:29:26 because a lot of viewers just want some 0:29:29 reason and because this is something 0:29:30 that my experience they are they've 0:29:32 asked for what you're saying is that yes 0:29:36 in regards to the apples which are the 0:29:39 different ways we said slightly 0:29:42 different ways in which some places on 0:29:43 the person is manifests in the text what 0:29:53 that exactly means this specific notion 0:29:56 is something that there is disagreement 0:29:58 upon among the scholars that we don't 0:30:00 hide that disagreement there is this 0:30:01 agree but what a chunk of that 0:30:03 disagreement is not connected to the 0:30:05 actual evidences and it's just guesswork 0:30:08 from non-specialists so it shouldn't be 0:30:10 seen as I counted as among the 40 you 0:30:13 know prominent opinions is that what 0:30:15 you're saying sorry let me give an 0:30:17 example of something that I tend to find 0:30:19 with ATS sometimes when we talk about 0:30:20 issue of voodoo the shuttle the 0:30:22 existence of evil sometimes you see some 0:30:26 of the most we mentioned the existence 0:30:27 of evil or evil being there and then 0:30:29 they they jump to the existence of God 0:30:33 from evil being there to the existence 0:30:36 of God Danny if hypothetically I say 0:30:39 there is only evil there is no good on 0:30:40 this earth everything is evil that does 0:30:43 not in any way shape or form 0:30:44 conclude to the issue of 0:30:46 God exists or not the connection is far 0:30:49 yeah Nina what I say is the definition 0:30:52 of the arrow facade ah ha and what the 0:30:55 scholars the forty views and Malakar is 0:30:57 making it a be one extra view making it 0:31:00 41 views whichever of those views you 0:31:03 take however weak that view is it 0:31:05 doesn't in any way shape or form have 0:31:08 any effect on the preservation of the 0:31:11 poor on right 0:31:12 so what you're saying of those views 0:31:15 whatever view you have on what the house 0:31:18 is it I'm gonna make and if it's not 0:31:21 gonna have an impact 0:31:22 it's not gonna have an impact on the 0:31:24 fact that the Quran is itself preserved 0:31:27 so hey so this is of opinion is doesn't 0:31:30 there's not much at stake here with this 0:31:32 difference of opinion is well it's not 0:31:36 true there isn't so a lot of the times 0:31:40 people generally start to think oh 0:31:42 because it's not known what it means 0:31:43 whichever view I take in my effect me 0:31:46 believing the Quran is preserved or not 0:31:47 and to be honest I actually received the 0:31:49 email from someone who actually did say 0:31:50 that to me or even ask me that question 0:31:52 so after explaining that to them and 0:31:54 giving them a bit more details which is 0:31:58 shallower I want to say that I'm not 0:32:00 trying to avoid answering this question 0:32:02 of what a lot officer I means and which 0:32:04 view is strongest but it's a it requires 0:32:07 a more detailed session a course in 0:32:11 Charlotte era I'm going to be doing a 0:32:13 memory inshallah where I'm gonna bring 0:32:16 all of the forty-something views I'm 0:32:18 gonna present each view and what their 0:32:20 argument is and what the evidence that 0:32:21 they used and then if someone I'm going 0:32:23 to show why this view was critiqued why 0:32:26 this critique view was critiqued and 0:32:28 insha'Allah Allah then come to a 0:32:30 conclusion which we believe to be the 0:32:32 closest to that being right in Xiamen I 0:32:35 just want to name some scholars who all 0:32:37 said that the Quran preservation is by 0:32:42 itamar and it there's no difference of 0:32:43 opinion if I can just quickly name those 0:32:46 scholars so but we've I think we can 0:32:50 move on from the issue of Allah the fact 0:32:52 that the issue that let's just do a 0:32:55 quick summary once again on this 0:32:57 so to summarize and once 0:32:59 you know anything just let me know 0:33:01 anything you're saying yeah he made the 0:33:10 act to a loss of hano time that the 0:33:12 Quran is revealed in some slightly 0:33:16 different ways to facilitate a see at 0:33:18 ease for the people that was done and 0:33:22 then the Quran was revealed an offensive 0:33:24 and yeah in 7f which the scholars 0:33:27 disagreed the meaning of we can't say 0:33:29 okay this one opinion in Islam and 0:33:30 everything is however there is this 0:33:32 disagreement but that disagreement 0:33:34 there's nothing at stake with it because 0:33:35 what we're talking about is the type of 0:33:38 difference between the variations we 0:33:41 don't know exactly what the type of 0:33:43 difference is but we do know there's 0:33:44 some kind of variation like if you look 0:33:46 at the kilowatt you see that there's 0:33:48 some kind of variation the exact 0:33:49 categorization and specific notion of 0:33:52 what that categorization is or that that 0:33:55 variation is is not something scholars 0:33:57 have United upon and therefore ever 0:34:00 opinion you take for am under forty 0:34:01 opinions so cooled opinions which I mean 0:34:04 you agree that what most of them are not 0:34:06 about a Muslim not to the MS Ella and 0:34:09 even if you take the weakest of those 0:34:10 fourteen there were no weaken the 0:34:12 weakest one the the one that has the 0:34:14 most implications and consequences 0:34:16 really it's inconsequential because it's 0:34:19 not going to affect the fact that the 0:34:21 Quran is transmitted in the way you've 0:34:23 described the being in the show is to to 0:34:27 to the table and chose transmitted form 0:34:29 they went with its preservation a last 0:34:33 altima entrusted what they transmitted 0:34:35 everything the way they heard it and so 0:34:37 there's nothing at stake with that and 0:34:40 one more thing I think is very important 0:34:42 to our outline with that for for someone 0:34:44 for anyone from it is that there's a big 0:34:46 misconception you know in some of the 0:34:48 comparative religious work I do we speak 0:34:51 to Christians and Jews whatever it is 0:34:53 yeah and we say look our book is 0:34:55 protected and it's preserved and yours 0:34:57 clearly isn't and when we then ask to 0:35:00 show why is it that your book is not 0:35:02 protect protectors and ours is things we 0:35:05 definitely put forward not know what is 0:35:07 the change of transmission so we put 0:35:09 forward the fact as you've mentioned 0:35:11 that there is 0:35:13 people a multiplicity of people and on 0:35:16 the top-level transmitting that evidence 0:35:18 that same Quran the same message to the 0:35:21 next generation and it keeps going like 0:35:22 that but there's a chain of narration 0:35:24 whereas with the Old Testament in the 0:35:26 New Testament there's no chain of 0:35:27 narration such notion doesn't exist and 0:35:29 the second we say is that a lot of you 0:35:33 know apologists and Muslim still I don't 0:35:36 that just just add another point which 0:35:37 is that any man has a Muhammad - kitab 0:35:40 and Fissel familiar film it went away 0:35:42 when had he mentioned that this concept 0:35:46 overly snide and chaining is the house 0:35:48 is house to Muhammad this is a big thing 0:35:51 that we have so much to be said 0:35:54 umma to be snug hmm did Erica some of 0:35:58 the Imam or do they used to say Lola is 0:36:00 now doula column and share I'm Asha and 0:36:02 it's not immunity or all at least not 0:36:04 dual apartment sure I'm Asha that is not 0:36:06 is the religion and without it you need 0:36:09 a chain and if without it anybody would 0:36:11 have claimed what they want it now so 0:36:13 that's the first thing and so and the 0:36:15 second thing is this that the variants 0:36:18 that exist within the Quranic discourse 0:36:21 they exist because of Sabah they 0:36:27 explained the variants in fact there was 0:36:30 no hope of Sabah and the assumption was 0:36:32 there is a fixed text that I should read 0:36:35 in one way and then there was variants 0:36:38 that were found that would be 0:36:39 problematic but in fact thing is the 0:36:41 fact that Sabah are in there that is an 0:36:46 explanatory mechanism to show why in 0:36:49 fact this variation between a Quran R&B 0:36:52 of Clara and so on and so it all goes 0:36:53 back to the professor whether you read 0:36:55 at malakoma Dean the day of judgment or 0:36:57 Medicare would be in the king of the Day 0:36:58 of Judgment both of that goes back to 0:37:01 approve Mohammed Buddha is legitimized 0:37:03 but as the backing of the Quran the 0:37:06 backing of Allah the backing of the 0:37:07 Prophet yeah 0:37:08 and so if if if this is a very important 0:37:12 thing from comparative religion 0:37:13 perspective the assumption with the four 0:37:16 Gospels is that it's a fixed text that 0:37:19 this mission that's the same where is 0:37:22 the Assumption with the Quranic 0:37:24 discourse is that it's not a fixed text 0:37:26 it's a functional text it has multi 0:37:32 different multi-variant text and has 0:37:34 different kinds of variants in each word 0:37:36 you know so in so therefore if the 0:37:39 assumption was the same then the 0:37:41 standard could be the same of 0:37:43 measurement so if we find variants for 0:37:45 the Bible it's not the same finding 0:37:47 variants for the parameter I think there 0:37:49 is no commands explained through this 0:37:51 about of a server whereas in the Bible 0:37:54 baba equivalent went in so I think it's 0:37:57 very important that because it's not 0:37:59 like for like here is what we try to 0:38:01 communicate the fact that the profiles 0:38:03 are Salim he authenticated and 0:38:05 authorized legitimize the the charata 0:38:09 of sham hacking and also a new hot tub 0:38:12 and he said both of them was revealed 0:38:15 like that hadith he actually asked Allah 0:38:18 to facilitate ease for the Ummah by 0:38:21 revealing certain words in certain 0:38:22 different ways that is in fact already 0:38:26 telling us that this these systems are 0:38:28 different so now just to just to kind of 0:38:33 survive instead of being a problem for 0:38:35 us there's a solution because in fact 0:38:39 with the Bible it's a fixed text and you 0:38:41 have variants so how can you explain 0:38:42 that us it's not a fixed text however 0:38:44 having said that even though it's not a 0:38:46 fixed text it all goes in one direction 0:38:47 so I think it's very important that we 0:38:49 outlined the fact that even those 0:38:52 variants are slack saying blue and dark 0:38:54 blue is going in the same exact 0:38:56 direction it's not like is narrative 0:38:58 altering direction yep 0:39:01 and so that's that's an important thing 0:39:04 the third thing I want to say is that on 0:39:07 all right we call text criticism 0:39:09 perspective like the biblical dispose 0:39:11 there's no harmonizing method which is 0:39:14 very important gigantic text criticism 0:39:17 when they say the Bible in there saying 0:39:19 okay what verse should we put in what 0:39:20 verse should we're not going they don't 0:39:22 have for us we have the seventh circle 0:39:25 mobile or something is dying it's not 0:39:27 gonna be ready no such thing they have 0:39:32 to have any harmonizing method it's 0:39:35 Russian equivalent so we have a 0:39:37 consonant 0:39:37 skeleton which is not many 0:39:40 and then the the text many texts and 0:39:44 they don't have that so it's a poor so 0:39:46 far that we're saying that these are the 0:39:47 differences between our tradition and 0:39:50 their tradition it's not it's not a lot 0:39:52 for like comparison so when they say 0:39:53 well you got variance as well say well 0:39:55 we play not very said okay for that well 0:39:58 how do you explain your variance that's 0:40:00 important 0:40:01 I think closes the door now add to it 0:40:04 another thing I think that's generally 0:40:06 detached from the discussion as well is 0:40:08 that the nature of these people was 0:40:10 Kadir to him these people not just they 0:40:14 were memorizes they memorized poetry by 0:40:16 hearing it once 0:40:17 honey every one place would come to the 0:40:19 car bar and stand and read his mana card 0:40:21 okay fair enough comedic raha beeping 0:40:23 woman dealing basically Robin yeah and 0:40:25 he would read it from memory and people 0:40:29 would memorize it and they will transmit 0:40:30 that to each other this book so I really 0:40:35 apologize 0:40:36 well this man could also be seen in some 0:40:39 of his works he's actually he's got this 0:40:47 one the scribes are the profile he's 0:40:48 also got another one of preservation so 0:40:52 they can I mentioned in the Quran and I 0:40:59 had to be in at Rufus who do the lady 0:41:01 Naruto lady and in the Quran is I mean 0:41:04 it's something that's in the chest so 0:41:05 memory memorization from the beginning 0:41:08 of an Islam it was something I was 0:41:10 getting given a lot of consideration to 0:41:11 I want to bring to the people's 0:41:13 attention it's not just even the issue 0:41:15 is nad and transmission I said if you 0:41:17 add the issue of memorization and the 0:41:19 issue of number and it's not just you 0:41:23 know and the process of transmitting 0:41:24 this information or transmitting this 0:41:26 recitation he's actually passing it to a 0:41:28 large quantity of people yes on Ilario 0:41:30 cinnamon 0:41:31 there's a large quantity of people were 0:41:33 transmitted I wanna remember Hardy 0:41:35 narrated in his sorry I mean I have 0:41:37 eaten our best and enemies saliva so 0:41:39 hard I feel my body mean el-medina to a 0:41:41 Chaba to LFE 0:41:42 Danny the postal on my left in Roma Bahn 0:41:45 from Medina and there was only 10,000 0:41:47 people with and that's not all of his 0:41:49 companions he just wanted to leave 0:41:50 Medina 0:41:52 with his companions and 10,000 people 0:41:54 followed him so la la la with cinema now 0:41:56 you can imagine these 10,000 people 0:41:58 they're gonna pray with him mother 0:42:00 Asia and Federer and I specifically 0:42:03 mentioned three Sorrell three solos 0:42:05 another one yeah loud and so the process 0:42:10 Aaron was known to recite for example 0:42:11 somewhat on Monday he was recite 60 0:42:14 verse ezel I mean I'm sort of long 0:42:16 swords but lead McRib very long and so 0:42:20 they hear the Quran from him early salat 0:42:22 wa salam and they memorize it from him 0:42:23 and this is doing 23 years 23 years very 0:42:28 I mean that's a quarter of a century 0:42:29 almost I mean people we have to really 0:42:31 consider that I mean 23 years 0:42:33 it's not like a day or two or a week or 0:42:35 a year that's a long time for people to 0:42:38 continuously being exposed to the same 0:42:39 material 0:42:40 now what's mind-boggling that really 0:42:43 took me is that I came across study for 0:42:45 the massacre last year couple years back 0:42:47 when I was reading it Terasaki it made 0:42:50 he mentioned something really took me 0:42:51 about a year to find this book that is 0:42:56 nice ankl deal yeah yeah so it's most 0:43:00 historic history history history book 0:43:02 yeah as I could I will cost him an even 0:43:05 has a cure he mentioned something very 0:43:08 powerful very powerful he said and I 0:43:12 will repay I will redo lie Muslim you 0:43:14 know Mike Shanin he said call le Abu 0:43:16 Darda of the allah and i will remain 0:43:21 muslim with new mission in he said that 0:43:24 i woulda said to him so this weight is 0:43:28 saying the companion abu durga commanded 0:43:31 me to do something you know what he told 0:43:33 him to do he said dude man you crawl in 0:43:35 there and count the students who are 0:43:38 present who are listening to my Quran 0:43:40 I'm teaching them about the blessings so 0:43:43 I will remain Muslim even a mix I mean 0:43:45 he said I stood up to count the students 0:43:47 of Abu Darda who had taken the Quran 0:43:50 from him I mean he said I counted and I 0:43:52 reached for a debt to elfin was it to me 0:43:55 at Lee when a even 1600 and something 0:44:01 hmmm let's just say 1,600 you know who 0:44:05 was in that gathering even where I am it 0:44:08 mm whoosh am one of the Kirara 0:44:11 somehow we take he was sitting in that 0:44:14 gathering taking the Quran from him so 0:44:16 you have to understand that even though 0:44:18 I'm Emily said it it's not a Hadiya by 0:44:20 himself when you look at it 0:44:21 he's got 1599 students are taking the 0:44:27 quran with him 0:44:28 this is a really good piece of 0:44:29 information and at this point well I 0:44:31 think we need to clarify is the 0:44:33 difference between a pillar and a half 0:44:35 so the cotton asana or lash the ten or 0:44:39 seven pierot are different by consensus 0:44:43 to the do you know why people actually 0:44:48 do that mistake and they actually 0:44:49 confuse the two 0:44:50 you know why that even 0:45:00 action of making it into seven was where 0:45:03 the issue came from me if if he did what 0:45:06 a bloke a local goon did local goon made 0:45:10 it eight if it just made it eight or so 0:45:13 on or six people will not confused it so 0:45:17 this is really important now because I 0:45:18 think a lot of people have this 0:45:20 misconception the pirata why is it this 0:45:24 is a very important question because 0:45:26 people are completely confused on this 0:45:27 one why is the Koran different from the 0:45:31 half now let me give you my short answer 0:45:34 and can you expand on it and correct if 0:45:36 it needs to crush direction the short 0:45:39 answer is because the caller who is the 0:45:43 reciter whether a seven or ten or twenty 0:45:46 or a thousand it doesn't matter how many 0:45:48 there are is simply listening to the tab 0:45:51 on his teacher 0:45:53 and he's listening to how he's reciting 0:45:55 the Quran he might have listened to it 0:45:58 for more than one share and he's 0:46:01 choosing the clutter is choosing I the 0:46:05 animal caught it is choosing either I'm 0:46:07 gonna put Malik Oh Malik I'm gonna 0:46:10 recite because you cannot recite in two 0:46:11 different ways you can only recite one 0:46:12 way one time so you think okay so there 0:46:16 is a choice that is made by the product 0:46:18 the cauda is choosing to either recite 0:46:21 Malik or which means owner or King Malik 0:46:25 it's the are you caught it now this 0:46:27 choice is limited to the available 0:46:30 options all of which have been 0:46:32 legitimized by prefer male Salah all of 0:46:34 which are motivated as well and all of 0:46:36 which are motivated which have a perfect 0:46:38 salad of multiple multiplicity of people 0:46:42 a plethora of individuals at each stage 0:46:43 so he's making a choice yes the caller 0:46:46 is making a choice I'm gonna say either 0:46:48 medical you can't say mannequin 0:46:49 mannequin the same time in the prayer 0:46:50 he's choosing either got to say Manik 0:46:53 which means oh now I'm gonna say King 0:46:55 and that choice that he's making is 0:46:58 limited by the available options this 0:47:01 example of Malik Malik of the 10th color 0:47:04 as that Eden Jerry mentioned in his 0:47:06 nature and you know six of them recites 0:47:11 her as manic as King and four of them 0:47:13 recites as Malik so in that of 10 P over 0:47:16 they had a decision to make I don't 0:47:20 gonna recite asthmatic which is legit oh 0:47:22 we're gonna recite says Malik which is 0:47:24 also legit four of them made one 0:47:27 decision to recite as owner and six made 0:47:30 another site as king but both of those 0:47:33 and a complementary country distinct 0:47:36 tree so they don't contradict each other 0:47:37 and they both have elite the prophetic 0:47:40 backing they are both masculine and 0:47:43 authorized the stunt will prove our 0:47:44 Messiah and able to at this current 0:47:47 motivator so that therefore the 0:47:49 difference between the card or Clara and 0:47:51 the house is that the caller is choosing 0:47:55 the the very legitimate variant he's 0:47:59 choosing which variant to go in there is 0:48:03 a choice to be made now we can't make a 0:48:05 choice like the parameter because 0:48:07 it's already been standardized and folk 0:48:09 has been the formula has been laid and 0:48:11 this is round korat they've been left so 0:48:15 many times but in in theory I mean if 0:48:18 some in theory if someone wanted to mix 0:48:20 the Korat and they pray in their own 0:48:22 homes 0:48:23 I read in him Jesse he said this fine I 0:48:25 mean it's not it's not fit is another 0:48:28 Messiah idea because someone will say 0:48:31 okay why not mix but it's not a problem 0:48:32 exactly it's not an issue for us that 0:48:34 the point what I'm making is that all of 0:48:37 it is Quran all of it legitimate all of 0:48:40 it goes back to performances and all of 0:48:42 it is authentic yes there was a decision 0:48:44 that the caller had to make but it was 0:48:46 limited by the available options 0:48:49 therefore the available healthy options 0:48:51 they were there and the collet St Ankara 0:48:54 it shows something which was and limited 0:48:57 and had would you act for the chorus I 0:49:03 wanted to read manikins summit is a 0:49:05 system of care and if tiara let me 0:49:07 mention some of the Imams who mentioned 0:49:09 the preservation of the Quran to be 0:49:11 motivated remember Noah will rahamallah 0:49:13 any mama was serrated no loopy I 0:49:15 remember Dean and movie and ye you I 0:49:18 would Hassan a new reuse of ARCA see you 0:49:21 I'm a sifaka see you an imam abu bakr 0:49:24 IBN arabi a romantic e UD any blue 0:49:25 taenia 0:49:26 I remember Tina circa she had you Dina 0:49:28 Suki whether you Dina was rocky even a 0:49:30 middle tele-dentistry ot she had 0:49:33 with Dean Armadale Banda and Imam even 0:49:35 hasn't in 0:49:36 remember haramein about my linguine I 0:49:38 would worry diminution reject a theory 0:49:40 denied na Hyun Jung Cedeno Jerry and I 0:49:43 were best al Lewis Alwyn Shari see these 0:49:47 Imams all have said once they look at 0:49:51 the Quran they said that this is motor 0:49:53 water maybe a manatee 0:49:58 yeah to be fair in our transmission 0:50:02 Marine Mammal Jerry needs a discussion 0:50:04 the cola very much a jury has to 0:50:08 makalah the one he says indeed umma 0:50:10 Korean and the one he says in his 0:50:11 national but as I shall Allah promised 0:50:15 that in my host that I will be doing I 0:50:17 will shallow lob tackling yes 0:50:20 I think this point of the two questions 0:50:24 we asked one question is hell eh Danny 0:50:27 pool and ketamine in the second car who 0:50:30 is in order for Katya here does and the 0:50:37 other question is is there a motivator 0:50:38 these questions are not the same for 0:50:40 example Han does it for karate be 0:50:43 correct and sound does it need to have 0:50:45 to watch it stopped 0:50:47 that's what Jesse was discussing some 0:50:50 say sugar I started to show however and 0:50:52 some say no but the question of is it 0:50:54 turbo to writer I have not seen he less 0:50:56 like some people say this is not enough 0:51:01 he does mention in his body but inertia 0:51:03 which is a poetry of his inertia he says 0:51:05 for hulu maracas watchin are we what 0:51:07 Colonel it was me Tim Allen are we 0:51:09 what's AHA is not and who al-quran oh 0:51:11 very Hitler to our Channel hi to my 0:51:14 gurukul HBT 0:51:15 to do the hula and know who FISA battle 0:51:17 so here was my snare then when he says 0:51:20 for example yes ah hi Schneider so this 0:51:23 mostella of the river from allah and 0:51:26 also abu sharma tell McGee see and their 0:51:28 collab inshallah 0:51:31 I really want to go in details regarding 0:51:33 it because I have a research on that 0:51:34 this is very important just to translate 0:51:36 what you say is probably the foremost 0:51:42 authority in the last thousand years 0:51:45 but let me let me just say something 0:51:47 sorry I'm sorry sorry to interrupt your 0:51:49 media story interrupting there's two 0:51:51 things in New Jersey rahim allah has in 0:51:53 his inertial ignore jazeera him hola 0:51:55 see how to mislead so how to listen add 0:51:58 that the robot are bobby'll in the 0:52:01 transmission yeah no 30 cities not and 0:52:08 the water reliable eccentric secure and 0:52:11 in his kitab and he mentions 0:52:14 schwa the image guitar which really 0:52:16 means as we very popular popular you 0:52:20 know in his mockery in he added another 0:52:22 condition which is Omaha's to accept it 0:52:27 with acceptance or something which wide 0:52:30 sprint why it's not it so it's team into 0:52:32 two things 0:52:33 had to be snack yeah sure 0:52:37 translate please so happiness that means 0:52:39 authentically transmitted yeah 0:52:41 the second thing is mentioned in surah 0:52:42 that is famous copy long and Kabul that 0:52:48 the Ummah are unanimously in agreement 0:52:50 regarding it 0:52:51 yeah iijima yeah so this is that is the 0:52:58 triangulating method because the 0:53:00 triangulating method that even Jerry 0:53:02 mentioned he was it has to be in like a 0:53:06 little structure of dr. anak script it 0:53:10 has that chain of narration which is 0:53:12 authentic and it also has to have be in 0:53:16 line with the Arabic language so with 0:53:18 the with the first high Arabic language 0:53:19 and these three conditions must be met 0:53:21 in order for it to be and that I which 0:53:24 is Nakamura ICT for it to be read in the 0:53:26 prayer and to be remove refer to as 0:53:28 Quran this look a lot of people know 0:53:30 because let me tell you let me play 0:53:32 those haven't come clean I think will be 0:53:34 bouncing from each other about so you 0:53:35 solve the things that people have been 0:53:36 saying someone says okay well fine 0:53:38 that's no problem what we've seen that 0:53:39 it must hold and even our best and obey 0:53:41 beam cab and the Sahaba 0:53:43 many of them yeah they have this is a 0:53:46 put the show ahead to you and this is 0:53:47 the kind of thing we'll hear from 0:53:49 missionaries and uneducated they'll 0:53:52 say look how could it be the case if 0:53:56 this is what the Quran is so the Quran 0:53:58 is that which corresponds with that 0:53:59 triangulating method then you have some 0:54:03 of the color art of it not best of them 0:54:06 it must although this person gather and 0:54:09 they differ in the consonant to 0:54:12 structure not just in Carrara may have 0:54:15 tamil who Russian what the what the 0:54:17 actual Continental structure can contain 0:54:19 but theyíve differ from the continental 0:54:23 skeletal structure from that which is 0:54:25 mention the Quran so how can you square 0:54:27 that circle a sense that you're saying 0:54:29 that whatever you're saying that the 0:54:31 Quran is a veracious you're saying it's 0:54:33 robust you're saying is transmitted and 0:54:35 is transmitted with all of these 0:54:37 authorities then how is it that you have 0:54:39 these operational texts of even much 0:54:43 older 0:54:44 which clearly are differentiated from 0:54:47 the continental skeletal structure on 0:54:49 Batman Achmed a script and let me add 0:54:53 extra thing on the Rizzo just to make it 0:54:54 even more make the issue even more 0:54:57 heavier on those people who say it life 0:54:59 example some add on to that and say look 0:55:01 I believe Miss Reed is the same guy that 0:55:02 the process rallies and I'm I said the 0:55:04 same so happy that the prophecy sets on 0:55:05 my Mario sorry man 0:55:06 anyone who wants to meet for an album 0:55:08 Bunny and Cameroon Zilpha rock karate 0:55:12 I mean karate even though I was the 0:55:15 foremost heavyweight you know yeah 0:55:17 especially just in authority but the 0:55:23 fact that the prophecy said anyone wants 0:55:24 to read the Quranic in the way comes 0:55:26 down the way it's the purity of the 0:55:28 Quran reading reading like a blood drive 0:55:30 miss route so somebody would like you're 0:55:32 telling me that some of his recitations 0:55:33 being eliminated absolutely let me break 0:55:41 the answer Allah Ta'ala into to them if 0:55:43 my aim and objective is not really to go 0:55:46 into this room has because they deserve 0:55:49 a entire course just two or three that 0:55:54 are very popular yeah Abdullah minimus 0:55:56 Buddhist when the processor has said 0:55:57 that he was referring to his 0:55:58 pronunciation is articulation of the 0:56:00 future to eat and the way he read it but 0:56:02 it wasn't referring to his I hope I'm at 0:56:04 the the the the the style of the Quran 0:56:07 he was reciting it was Todd Reed and his 0:56:10 mihari that's what the Prophet was 0:56:11 referring to when he said if you want to 0:56:13 read the Quran the way he came down 0:56:14 because the Prophet only had a dragon is 0:56:16 written in a prayer and he didn't hear 0:56:17 his whole entire him pray and then he 0:56:31 looked listen to his voice and he was 0:56:32 amazed by it and then he said anyone who 0:56:35 wants to read the Quran the way he came 0:56:36 down and let me lay him read in the 0:56:38 rewire the Quran the way of Abdullah 0:56:41 numerous group the second part which is 0:56:43 the clear art of some of the Companions 0:56:47 like a dynamic Whitman he recited the 0:56:49 goal of Allah subhana WA Ta'ala 0:56:52 Shahani mutashabihat he returned yet he 0:56:55 added on to it 0:56:56 these are Clara 0:56:58 which was something it was from the 0:57:02 Prophet the Prophet assigned to be like 0:57:04 that but the most half of man it chose 0:57:07 this the reason why earth man's 0:57:09 objective was to compile the Quran was 0:57:12 not the goal of baka this is where many 0:57:14 people get confused 0:57:15 Abu Bakr was Mujahideen job is to bring 0:57:18 the whole Quran together 0:57:19 Larrick in verse man's reasoning of 0:57:22 bringing the Quran together was the 0:57:24 issue of the Gila that was told to him 0:57:27 people were preferring their readings 0:57:30 over there other people's readings and 0:57:32 which we're not saying that some were 0:57:34 right were wrong because remark and 0:57:36 Hisham be but a Hakim had a but they at 0:57:39 least had the Prophet with them many 0:57:41 thought the Prophet is telling who's 0:57:42 right from wrong but man was scared at 0:57:44 this yeah yeah but there might come a 0:57:52 time when there is there is no one who 0:57:54 has knowledge enough to know so this man 0:57:56 chose to resolve this whole situation by 0:58:00 bringing a most half that brings and 0:58:03 unites everyone onto this so every other 0:58:06 recitation that the sahabas had this was 0:58:09 the final conclusion this is the only 0:58:11 one that the OMA are unanimously in 0:58:13 agreement the sahabas all agreed upon it 0:58:15 even finally I believe me miss root took 0:58:17 this Ravi a long time 0:58:19 I know Danny as Authority but it man's 0:58:21 most awful era of derive enormous route 0:58:26 it was taken from the messenger Ali 0:58:28 salat wa salam it was a recitation i was 0:58:30 taken from it but it wasn't added to the 0:58:36 so you'll say why should we follow one 0:58:40 man has ordered anyway yeah when he 0:58:48 wrote the committee he gave it to 0:58:50 everybody and he became an agreement 0:58:51 amongst everybody that's number one 0:58:53 number two the prosperity sermon 0:58:55 commanded us he said are they can be 0:58:56 thrown at you as soon as you qualify 0:58:57 Rashi Dean already in I'm already having 0:58:59 alleged 0:59:01 so we were instructed to follow up with 0:59:03 morality alarm I just because the other 0:59:07 hadith says forty years isn't it 0:59:09 actually there will be 40 years and if 0:59:11 you add up 0:59:11 the four key levers is actually four 0:59:14 years that you know was a half and I'd 0:59:20 leave me one for four years and a half 0:59:21 and and so yeah I'm for ten years and 0:59:23 six months four years and a half are 0:59:25 easily months well that's all that's 0:59:27 four years so what you're saying is that 0:59:28 the Prophet gave us instruction to 0:59:30 follow the whole of Russia Dean and so 0:59:34 earth man's decision is religiously 0:59:37 authoritative and add to that in fact he 0:59:40 had the itch malbim as well 0:59:42 he had the edge mother's including in 0:59:44 the Mossad including all of these people 0:59:46 who had varied cars not to say that 0:59:48 their cars became invalid but it's to 0:59:51 say that this was the standard reading 0:59:53 that then transmitted it you could say 0:59:58 for convenience purposes it wasn't the 1:00:00 fact that even Mossad and Quran has now 1:00:03 become null and void because it's what 1:00:07 we can say that that I'm not a fan his 1:00:11 standardization his damage to the OMA 1:00:13 has agreed upon and we are sure that 1:00:15 whatever that is this Quran we are sure 1:00:18 yeah whereas the Senate could be 1:00:21 distorted the chain could be distorted 1:00:23 it's the Russian it's non-compliance 1:00:26 which means that could be go back to 1:00:28 some kind of it could be tough see it I 1:00:30 mean even even just he says I read this 1:00:33 in and in his flight was a mission that 1:00:36 actually Massoud a lot of the stuff is 1:00:38 very difficult to differentiate 1:00:39 sometimes between what actually saying 1:00:41 and reciting as Quran and ambassador and 1:00:45 so to avoid all of that confusion of man 1:00:48 a fan but I checked earlier King you 1:00:51 made sure that anything that goes into 1:00:52 this must have is gonna be that which is 1:00:55 the most authoritative 1:00:56 the most legitimate that everyone agrees 1:00:59 goes back to the Ramallah 1:01:00 not to say that all of the other 1:01:03 companions were wrong to aside the way 1:01:04 they did or to do the things they did 1:01:06 that's true and at the end of the day 1:01:09 what we as Muslims always have to 1:01:11 remember is the non-muslims because they 1:01:16 became they got exposed for their 1:01:18 religion and their script becoming you 1:01:20 know contradicting and not being 1:01:22 preserved they now want to point fingers 1:01:24 at other people 1:01:25 say oh you guys know one is not 1:01:27 preserved that's the truth 1:01:29 and I hamdulillah the fact that the 1:01:32 Muslims today see in Ramadan para we 1:01:35 have been read by a 14 year old 15 year 1:01:38 old 20 year old leaving Korea all over 1:01:41 the world people reading from memory and 1:01:43 this is I think enough to to show how 1:01:46 this book has been preserved - living 1:01:49 tradition is something which is 1:01:51 something just packed up in books and 1:01:53 and it's a very cliche when you say 1:01:55 they're gonna throw all the books in the 1:01:57 world how quickly will retrieve the 1:01:59 Quran compared to other ones well if I 1:02:04 would just to throw in a couple of who 1:02:06 had now not - it's causing it down to 1:02:09 people but just some of the most kind of 1:02:12 Wired worriedly circulating things 1:02:16 misconceptions that on this on this 1:02:18 mission so we talked about just to 1:02:19 summarize so far we talked about how 1:02:21 it's impossible for the Prophet to have 1:02:23 said something which is not from Allah 1:02:25 and how the Companions is impossible for 1:02:28 them to have said something which is not 1:02:30 from the Prophet and everything all the 1:02:32 variant readings go back to Prophet 1:02:36 Muhammad a solemn and are legitimized by 1:02:38 him I would the fact that everything 1:02:42 therefore from a light goes back to a 1:02:43 lost - idea I will said yeah we also 1:02:46 said that the misconception that's meant 1:02:49 to be a fixed text is one which has led 1:02:51 to a lot of confusion and what racism 1:02:53 all these are variants we know that 1:02:55 there are variants for those variants 1:02:56 playing through the act of the Saba that 1:02:58 of seven mode whatever is types of 1:03:01 reputation recitations which I mentioned 1:03:03 with specific verses where you can 1:03:05 recite this verse like this and I like 1:03:06 that it's a concession a serial Omar 1:03:09 something to ease and facilitate from 1:03:10 all my sorrow sighs some kind of thing 1:03:12 which helps some people the Muslim now 1:03:14 there is a difference we said between 1:03:16 the roof and the Quran we said that that 1:03:18 roof ah the types of differences and the 1:03:21 kurata 1:03:21 so it's possible that you can have a 1:03:25 thousand a million Cara it's not a 1:03:27 problem because all is is a combination 1:03:30 of choices made from the available pool 1:03:35 of differences which were all adjustment 1:03:36 math Ursula and mathematical you can 1:03:38 so many of those problem the point is 1:03:41 that all of those cars all of those 1:03:43 recitations are so here how authentic 1:03:45 and we will say matter which are mass 1:03:49 transmitted in addition to being in line 1:03:52 with the rasam of many the skeletal 1:03:54 Continental structure of the earth many 1:03:57 which there was each man on DOMA and 1:04:00 also the fact so this is this is the 1:04:03 narrative of putting food and this can't 1:04:05 be compared we said with with 1:04:06 Christianity when there's a fixed text 1:04:08 and variants and there's not even a 1:04:09 standard that there's no even 1:04:10 transmission I mean how can they how 1:04:12 could someone even compare that to you I 1:04:13 don't think even what's the studies 1:04:15 comparison I don't think anyone makes 1:04:17 that comparison even in Western 1:04:18 societies yeah even the third century in 1:04:21 Islam are only been once an hour and I 1:04:24 will read cosmic Salem and I were hard 1:04:25 to miss attorney and a medieval debater 1:04:28 goofy and oh god it's madness Huckle 1:04:30 Maliki you know would jar for it 1:04:32 material poverty and all it is until 1:04:34 them and said in the fourth century 1:04:35 scholars in Islam they Oh straight away 1:04:38 Danny Harun was an hour he died 200 1:04:42 before 200 so he documented other care 1:04:46 are at more than seven red cosmic serum 1:04:50 came after him with idat 224 Hadrian I 1:04:52 mean he took directly from our 1:04:54 even-handed Turkish Ally you see and he 1:04:58 compiled all the Quran so it was it 1:05:00 wasn't just memorized it was documented 1:05:03 at a very early stage any different or 1:05:05 ah their names who they took from it was 1:05:07 documented and if you actually go to Le 1:05:11 Monde and they're happy for example 1:05:12 remember Debbie you know him 1:05:14 a man with that we had 1000 teachers 1:05:17 even remember judge that he mentions 1:05:19 that 1000 in oral a man who taught him 1:05:23 we took knowledge from the Quran and 1:05:24 their science is he took from them and 1:05:26 he learned from them so and he has the 1:05:29 keto tautomer control Quran it talks 1:05:31 about the different recite if you go to 1:05:32 in a normal Jerry how many how many 1:05:35 Messiah he has and he took from them you 1:05:37 will see this issue is it's not one or 1:05:39 two or three or peaceful I know brother 1:05:41 right now he's got in 200 teachers they 1:05:45 to the whole Antrim me it has that is 1:05:47 now is alive so this issue of the press 1:05:52 the Quran Allah subhana WA Ta'ala took 1:05:55 it upon himself he is going to protect 1:05:58 it from Chanukah Allah cannot these 1:06:00 non-muslims and his orientalist and his 1:06:02 Christian apologist and all of them 1:06:03 cannot suffer at animal vu he aha 1:06:06 hello me about how oh ha karna who are 1:06:07 you if you're just gonna you're hanging 1:06:09 you're hitting your head against the 1:06:12 mountain don't be nice to the mountain 1:06:15 you're just gonna hurt your head that's 1:06:16 why this religion is going to stand you 1:06:20 know these people you have to understand 1:06:23 let alone feeling out of the weather 1:06:25 idea on fee sauna national hosting or 1:06:28 the well addict Rollo is a man they are 1:06:30 not mentioned in the sama in good and in 1:06:33 this world they have they have no 1:06:35 authority honey we Muslims I sincerely 1:06:38 say this to the Muslims who are 1:06:39 listening we've become foreigners from 1:06:42 our own religion and when we've become 1:06:44 foreigners and we've taken a step back 1:06:46 it leaves that vacuum for non-muslims to 1:06:48 come and start to tell you about your 1:06:50 religion I've told this story so many 1:06:52 times but when I was studying in the UK 1:06:54 I was studying at birtwick University I 1:06:56 was studying linguistics I used to go to 1:06:59 the British Library and I sometimes used 1:07:01 to take from there man you see yeah some 1:07:04 books and manuscripts slamming 1:07:05 manuscripts over there I state from I 1:07:07 was taken back when I went there one 1:07:10 time and I met a non-muslim guy and he 1:07:13 asked I came to the place and I was 1:07:15 looking for some of the most all tattoo 1:07:17 written by Suraj we didn't work any 1:07:19 sardine ok let's get up come on new room 1:07:21 I'm a Moroccan room and which is about 1:07:26 Oromo quran but i was looking for some 1:07:29 of some of his other works and other 1:07:32 scholars I was looking at for their 1:07:33 works i luckily had when I got there he 1:07:36 corrected me he said to me it's not so 1:07:38 loud you didn't pay me Radha is sahaja 1:07:40 demon bull failing was the first time I 1:07:42 ever heard it and in order Muslim you're 1:07:46 English UK dude telling you that this is 1:07:51 how it's pronounced and we had a back 1:07:53 and forth discussion and I was really 1:07:55 taken back that subhanAllah 1:07:58 you know we've distance ourselves from 1:08:00 learning the religion and also the Dean 1:08:04 so what I say is that 1:08:06 hematology the first thing that came 1:08:08 down in Islam the first telling me that 1:08:11 came down in Islam was it read it sweet 1:08:15 and he go and read and a lot about Allah 1:08:18 Allah 1:08:19 he praised us his humans I'm a raised as 1:08:22 humans based on that knowledge of 1:08:24 knowing adam alayhis-salam was risen 1:08:27 from all of the other creation for what 1:08:29 reason and they prostrated to him for 1:08:32 what reason well Anna aired MLS macula 1:08:35 there Allah towards him Subhan Allah Ya 1:08:38 Allah Allahu Lavina I mean come on 1:08:40 Ladino to until my daughter gets a lot 1:08:42 raises a person that when they learn and 1:08:44 they study so well I I look at the a 1:08:50 brother Xu hat of the non-muslims that 1:08:53 would Islam I sit down I actually try to 1:08:55 give them a chance ok when you have to 1:08:57 say and when you look at it there should 1:09:00 have oh honey bacon and commute now you 1:09:03 some you know what are you gonna enjoy 1:09:04 when you look at it and you really do in 1:09:06 another and you observe it you don't 1:09:09 find much to it but the only thing they 1:09:11 have is the ability to articulate it 1:09:13 properly which of previous articulation 1:09:16 isn't this mission against the mountain 1:09:18 yeah so it's nothing when you look at 1:09:22 it's nothing substantial that's that's 1:09:24 actually there there's an example I came 1:09:27 across some Hannah like yeah I was 1:09:29 having a discussion with one of the 1:09:30 non-muslims about the or on being going 1:09:34 against the Arabic language the fact 1:09:36 that it goes against Arabic language and 1:09:38 he brought the ayah for me carotid hums 1:09:40 it moves a yet I'm over here Eddie I 1:09:44 become enough see where he de Oaxaca 1:09:47 mean haha well best I mean who Mary 1:09:49 yellan Katina when he said what a lady I 1:09:52 wanna be he well Aloha is what we read 1:09:55 it like in hamza here is it as well or 1:09:58 her me as a customer right and these are 1:10:01 miss eligible American is elfia he talks 1:10:03 about it were all too confident and 1:10:04 Amelia coffee less similar ELISA and 1:10:06 Eliza much better 1:10:09 it not only one left Lisa must Ellen 1:10:12 know very well in grammar which I don't 1:10:15 wanna go in I'm gonna explain I shall 1:10:16 retire in my course honey 1:10:18 what 1:10:19 takes me back is that they would even 1:10:21 study a mess error in grammar just to 1:10:25 prove the Quran being wrong and but not 1:10:27 really understanding in deep and have a 1:10:29 very good understanding you know why 1:10:31 they don't have it because they don't 1:10:32 have a you know when you're studying 1:10:34 grandma you don't just rip a page out of 1:10:35 a book and say this is them you have to 1:10:38 read it from beginning to end and 1:10:39 understand how one of those science is 1:10:42 where you have to have a very deep 1:10:44 understanding from a local I'm will 1:10:47 often wore a cabin filled with water of 1:10:48 some with the rest it's more generally 1:10:50 managed from that beginning to the last 1:10:53 miss Ella is so connected it's building 1:10:55 apology on each other so I am Delina 1:11:00 Islam in sha Allah Allah 1:11:02 it's Scripture the Quran and the Sunnah 1:11:05 the Sun has been protected by its people 1:11:07 the Sunnah to Nibiru him turning away he 1:11:10 mechanical Wahine in America Riku Hari 1:11:13 Raya first acara lady Raya cehotina Maru 1:11:16 you are rasoi leader aluminum are due to 1:11:18 mimic buoy Nacional in the tamahagane 1:11:20 fittin well M see if can habit in every 1:11:22 student in the radical EEMA the Hitmen 1:11:25 tavini one ostrich uma from a Azusa hija 1:11:28 Harman Mustafa Muhammad Allah Brian 1:11:32 Burke when they told him that there's a 1:11:34 hadith which are mobile they said to 1:11:37 Alan Burdick 1:11:37 there's fabricated a hadith and then he 1:11:39 said yeah really shoulda held jihad on 1:11:41 the jet scholars are gonna live for that 1:11:43 you have Billa 1:11:44 the big beasts like a drama with Maddie 1:11:47 and Hamady be humble and it's happy 1:11:50 Rahu you abou hottie Molossia a boozer a 1:11:52 taraji an animal Buhari they they're 1:11:55 gonna live with ritual hell jacobina the 1:11:58 other day I was reading the life of 1:11:59 Abdullah of Mubarak and I came across a 1:12:02 line Barack saying Lola I'm certain if 1:12:06 it wasn't for five men rhetoric to tiara 1:12:08 I would have left and working and doing 1:12:11 mighty Jarrah and my training of my 1:12:13 business five men for their sake as I'm 1:12:16 working I want to provide for these five 1:12:18 men who are they 1:12:20 Sofia named an associate authorities of 1:12:23 Yerevan arena I work for them he pleased 1:12:26 to pay for them and it will layer and it 1:12:30 will submerge 1:12:31 I keep forgetting who the fifth one is 1:12:33 Annie these five I work for them or else 1:12:37 I would have left my job why does he 1:12:38 work for them he doesn't want them to 1:12:40 take no money from no government they're 1:12:42 free men they they sit in their house 1:12:45 they they work for them they get their 1:12:47 risk they don't worry about that and 1:12:48 they're able to defend a religion which 1:12:51 gives us the great incentives to do the 1:12:53 same thing with one of these brothers 1:12:55 and great causes that are doing all that 1:12:57 work and so yes to be honest but the 1:13:04 point is that he just wanted the related 1:13:07 to be defended by those great scholars 1:13:08 and and he shall Torana one thing I took 1:13:11 from Cheryl santini statement really 1:13:13 touched me he said in our other law in 1:13:15 hora de a common may you are you do for 1:13:18 your Haeckel hakka became a key to my 1:13:20 accord of a bill hakka all about that if 1:13:21 I had modified Ahuja's I shall Allah 1:13:27 make his religion Stanton Omar developer 1:13:29 to other wants this religion to prevail 1:13:31 he actually sometimes does it in a way 1:13:33 where he brings somebody who speaks 1:13:34 against the religion you see wrong 1:13:36 things about the religion and then 1:13:38 through ducks Allah makes a person stand 1:13:40 up and we feed him and debunk his 1:13:42 argument and that's beautiful and I 1:13:45 think it's a beautiful place to stop 1:13:47 this this podcast but I tell you 1:13:49 something it's for those who are really 1:13:51 sincere and we've heard you present all 1:13:54 of those evidences and break it down 1:13:58 there's nothing to hide nothing in a 1:14:00 scholarly works that we're trying to 1:14:02 keep hidden away there's nothing that 1:14:05 there's no great secret anywhere 1:14:08 and everyone's works are available 1:14:10 everything is more time nowadays nothing 1:14:11 can be hidden and the truth is also what 1:14:14 I the truth is also available and this 1:14:17 is something we call non-muslims that 1:14:19 are listening to this to the truth of 1:14:21 Islam the hack of Islam which is to 1:14:23 believe in Leila had Allah Muhammad 1:14:25 Allah soon the Quran the final message 1:14:27 to him a message to mankind to believe 1:14:29 that this is the unaltered speech the 1:14:32 wine verbatim speech of Allah 1:14:34 subhanAllah Anna which has been 1:14:35 preserved by the - in a way that no book 1:14:38 in the medieval period or a book in 1:14:39 antiquity a notebook and ancient history 1:14:41 has ever been preserved you know 1:14:44 the book is continually moving now it's 1:14:47 it's an armistice in our hearts it's in 1:14:50 our tongues as you said in our prayers 1:14:53 quite literally in our prayers 1:14:55 so it's you know I was funny I just like 1:15:01 go back to your articulation trying to 1:15:03 attack this it's like smashing your head 1:15:05 against a mountain that's true you know 1:15:08 what happened I was reading in the ayah 1:15:10 in surah surah to mérida where losses 1:15:13 what's adequate article 2 fact or idea 1:15:15 my desert be Mahadevan Academy namah 1:15:16 well no as usual Hakim the American 1:15:19 right he said I recited this ayah when I 1:15:22 recited the ayah he said I recited it as 1:15:25 at the ending of the Iowa over for him 1:15:28 and a Bedouin man said repeat that again 1:15:34 and I repeated it and he said Koran 1:15:37 woman who speeches this and then he said 1:15:39 it's the speech of Allah and the medical 1:15:41 new arrival is a loss Mary the great 1:15:43 Imam load away then he said to him whose 1:15:47 speech is this and he said it's Allah he 1:15:49 said well I this is not speech of Allah 1:15:50 the Bedouin man said I've been medica 1:15:54 before I lost my a straightaway 1:15:56 understood that he did something wrong 1:15:57 he recited the ayah as well as his own 1:15:59 Hakim then he said that's correct then I 1:16:03 lost my research in a man do you finish 1:16:05 the Quran are you know the Quran the 1:16:09 Bedouin man said no no I don't know the 1:16:10 plan he said how do you know that it 1:16:12 wasn't well now before Rahim and then he 1:16:15 said the siak and the context doesn't 1:16:17 allow that granny why I mean is that if 1:16:23 the prophet sallallaahu ceramic aim with 1:16:25 the Quran and it was something that 1:16:28 didn't make sense to the Arabs at that 1:16:31 time they would have demolished a 1:16:32 prophet sallallaahu said they would have 1:16:33 insulted him they would have ridiculed 1:16:35 him but they realized what he came with 1:16:38 his new urges and after the prophets 1:16:40 Allah mala ali wa sallam had died 1:16:42 because they couldn't respond to it the 1:16:44 poet he said yeah and maybe you know 1:16:45 Bill I acted on Solomon which it can be 1:16:47 Hakeem in Roman sorry me I had to Kalama 1:16:49 Almeida I do that you begin wounded 1:16:51 America to endure the prophets before 1:16:54 the miracles they came with a died with 1:16:56 them and Moses Morocco died with him 1:16:58 the other prophets their miracles died 1:17:00 with them Risa's Miroku went with him 1:17:02 because it was not dead it went with him 1:17:04 but never like Muhammad's the only 1:17:06 prophet who is miracle is still standing 1:17:09 it's still amongst us we're looking at 1:17:11 it we're challenging people not on an 1:17:13 absent miracle like we're saying the 1:17:17 miracle is not here challenging if you 1:17:18 can so it's kind of for every shout out 1:17:22 I'll be preserved Allah is going to 1:17:24 preserve this religion 1:17:26 one last question I think we should go 1:17:29 back to the variants in leather you've 1:17:30 mentioned that reminded me of something 1:17:32 now before I end with you as a question 1:17:34 someone else okay so you've got all 1:17:36 these variants you've got the seven of 1:17:38 which are the ways in which the 1:17:41 multiform ways that we can explain the 1:17:44 variants it's not fixed text we 1:17:46 understand that now but how can we 1:17:48 assure this is the question how can we 1:17:51 assure that their variants were not the 1:17:53 product of the Sahaba themselves how can 1:17:56 we assure this all of the para all the 1:18:00 ruin or anybody who has dealt with the 1:18:03 firaon right how can you be sure that in 1:18:06 fact that those variants are not as a 1:18:08 result because the sheer number of them 1:18:10 they would argue even though frankly 1:18:13 it's not that as many they make out to 1:18:15 be how can you assure that those 1:18:17 variants are in fact not from from the 1:18:23 Sahara or from the what this thing 1:18:29 that's the this is where the issue goes 1:18:32 back to the concept of coatl the water 1:18:34 means the halo so automatically the 1:18:39 definition of tatl means these people 1:18:41 cannot agree on this is too large in 1:18:43 number and we're saying the processor 1:18:45 has 120,000 companions Janna yes the 1:18:48 field of 1200 that make all agree that 1:18:51 this is because there's a bigger one who 1:18:53 comes once to the cross cinema and then 1:18:55 he goes he never comes back again when 1:18:58 they all agreed upon it was the Bedouins 1:19:00 there as well and when he comes back and 1:19:01 he supposed to find a question just 1:19:03 supposed to find a question I think what 1:19:04 they would say is that or actually once 1:19:06 again pretty women push back you know is 1:19:09 that it was do something I look at him 1:19:11 at best they don't collage and how did 1:19:15 you know that that pillar I wasn't 1:19:16 something which they both of edom 1:19:26 generally speaking you won't find it 1:19:28 there are or I come across a tiara was 1:19:31 only gonna be a blemish with at all it's 1:19:33 gonna be other peoples that are but 1:19:34 these are the only people are gonna be 1:19:36 mentioned there's a difference between 1:19:38 who's mentioned and who stated because 1:19:41 right now 1:19:42 Abraham and Nahor it was against the 1:19:44 concept of saying Cara are too full and 1:19:46 he hated that because this problem came 1:19:49 from people saying the Quran is not 1:19:51 motivated because they say I'm gonna be 1:19:53 no dude he's one person 1:19:54 this is the problem the paralyzed 1:19:56 attribution to one person doesn't mean 1:19:58 only one person ready like this yes I 1:20:01 cannot Betty daddy very good and and 1:20:04 secondarily so I would say here that's 1:20:06 number one number two is what I was 1:20:09 thinking about this interrogation I was 1:20:11 thinking about quite deeply and some 1:20:12 what you think of it you've got the head 1:20:14 of Russian let's take as an example the 1:20:16 ten Walter White's have come out that 1:20:18 everyone is agreed upon normally yeah 1:20:23 except for some of the so-called those 1:20:30 corrupts the lion's share like the vast 1:20:34 majority of meetings are exactly the 1:20:37 same so if you read cannot have some 1:20:42 awesome versus what some method just to 1:20:44 give to popular examples yeah then all 1:20:47 the storylines will be the same there'll 1:20:48 be no translational sense difference in 1:20:51 translation for 98% of the of the 1:20:54 content maybe 99% in fact where there is 1:20:57 a difference in translation will be in 1:21:00 things which are very similar like blue 1:21:02 and dark blue I don't know things which 1:21:05 are very very similar December to Taba 1:21:07 Yahoo oh there's a point is very 1:21:12 important to understand I'm not about 1:21:14 with a laser variety the balloon are 1:21:15 Quran awoken I mean in derailer you know 1:21:18 whether to feel in a fantasy era he 1:21:20 laughs here means this ski rocks two 1:21:23 times you're very well aware 1:21:25 if they laugh telework a nifty refer 1:21:27 come on if the a laugh the differences 1:21:30 can be brought together that's not the 1:21:31 discussion here 1:21:32 we've never cleaned that we've claimed 1:21:35 there's no contradiction you guys have 1:21:38 to prove to us that the Quran 1:21:39 contradicts itself if there's a manner 1:21:41 here and there's a man is the idea in 1:21:43 the other kurata Wesley hmm 1:21:45 what shall I try again inshallah in mind 1:21:48 mr. Murray of course I'm going to expand 1:21:50 on some of the where it is mentioned in 1:21:54 the Quran like for example taratata 1:21:55 Helen her aunt in Thailand huh there's a 1:21:59 Giada yeah this Giada one of the 1:22:03 benefits in it is that I get 20 reward 1:22:05 by reading the Quran Arthur says Mita 1:22:08 Ilana by the mimin the noon and the 1:22:11 Quran that doesn't have it has less 1:22:12 because of the famous hadith there are 1:22:15 good Alif Lam Meem - when I can elephant 1:22:17 heart phone when I'm gonna have some 1:22:18 women heart phone so totally tan and her 1:22:21 whoever reads it and the one who reads 1:22:23 it as Jerry me tacky Alana the one who 1:22:26 reads it as mintage Alana is got 20 1:22:28 extra more than you do one of the 1:22:30 benefits that you get from the Korat and 1:22:32 I thought about so just to happiness as 1:22:35 a means of as a means of the demolishing 1:22:39 this idea in fact yeah is if you find if 1:22:42 you look at some of the construction 1:22:43 some of the lexical constructions like 1:22:45 for example Malik and Malik we said that 1:22:47 you can recite Medicare medic so in fact 1:22:49 I like this Malik is king 1:22:51 sorry medic is on a manic is king right 1:22:53 while insulting Ernest is smelling 1:22:56 there's no different Quran if the Sahaba 1:22:59 were playing around as they wished and 1:23:00 they should have made that medical 1:23:02 miracles all right it's not just even 1:23:03 that if there are of Hisham and Hisham 1:23:06 when he recites Abraham and Ibrahim yes 1:23:10 the word Brahim in the come 99 times 1:23:13 yeah okay the largest times Vedas 1:23:17 Ibrahim feel anything and there's some 1:23:19 other religious Ibrahim why idea of I'm 1:23:27 gonna read it as I want even though I 1:23:31 was told 1:23:32 Akira of economy the Michel 1:23:36 if Muhammad was given 1:23:38 Karara and then he said I'm not gonna 1:23:41 read it like that and then they said him 1:23:43 but if somebody came to you and told you 1:23:45 I heard it from the Prophet he said I 1:23:46 would never take it from them he said 1:23:48 because at AHIMA we're free 1:23:50 I suspect one person but that Kira I was 1:23:53 actually motivated for someone other 1:23:55 email but to implore a marine because it 1:23:58 wasn't muta what he never reached him in 1:23:59 motivated he rejected it especially we 1:24:03 were talking about the concept of truce 1:24:04 in karate 1:24:04 this must Allah I really have prepared 1:24:07 for it 1:24:08 I have a long mashallah written research 1:24:11 on different scales and maybe ninety 1:24:17 like a team is gonna research in general 1:24:24 yeah when we come here inshallah this 1:24:28 week we got a release of the video 1:24:29 inshallah this week we're gonna release 1:24:30 it you know where you reset your 1:24:31 research isn't writing the right I've 1:24:35 actually it's nearly nearly 600 pages so 1:24:38 inshallah to Allah 1:24:39 some of you I have left in in UK I don't 1:24:41 have all of it and some I have it here 1:24:43 that I've added on to it so inshallah 1:24:45 once it's finished and I've got it all 1:24:47 written every time you find something 1:24:49 new to be honest every day you'll find 1:24:51 something new that you didn't see so I'm 1:24:55 just trying to add on to that someday I 1:24:59 shall do I be like taffy or Maha Badu 1:25:01 didn't either who has Fela shelter 1:25:03 myself so I'm just gonna hope from Allah 1:25:06 subhana WA Ta'ala that he aids me with 1:25:07 it and he allows me to be able to fully 1:25:11 do it in sha la donna again like 1:25:15 allocated for evening opportunity - sha 1:25:19 la ila humbly proved the Quran is 1:25:21 preservation and how it's that every 1:25:24 Muslim around the world has to be 1:25:27 inshallah to Allah happy and content 1:25:30 that their religion is being preserved 1:25:33 it's a great imam al Rahman island you 1:25:35 know the great amount of Hardy he was he 1:25:38 said about the previous image that came 1:25:39 before him he said rocky Mahalo ma'am 1:25:45 and he said latter he said ma'am he said 1:25:49 manejando FEMEN mother in 1:25:51 but clean fuel in R&D one man a new 1:25:54 female mother 1:25:55 what are we compared to those great 1:25:57 Imams that came before us like a 1:25:59 mushroom is like under a tree under a 1:26:03 tree yeah I mean when you look at him um 1:26:06 I'm I'm right Danny you look at shout 1:26:09 baby I was did you actually know I would 1:26:11 cost him a shot to me the size of a 1:26:13 manual to tanni it was actually said 1:26:16 cannibal abuse our own Andrew Scott 1:26:18 el-bahari I mean Heavy D he he was blind 1:26:21 you know that because he was blind 1:26:23 the students will come and they read 1:26:25 sahih bukhari and he's blind he sits 1:26:27 there and they correct their copies from 1:26:30 his memory 1:26:31 Danny they read on him and he said 1:26:33 that's copies wrong corrected are you 1:26:36 there 1:26:36 and so what I mean is that when you look 1:26:39 at these amounts the way they were the 1:26:41 way their life is and you look at these 1:26:45 Orientalists and what type of people 1:26:49 they are money it's not even fair it's 1:26:51 not fair in any way shape or form 1:26:54 to even mention I will cost him a shout 1:26:57 to me you in the context of you name any 1:27:01 Orientalist why I say is that the karate 1:27:12 is a science that comes from the knowing 1:27:14 the Arabic language and it Kadiatu ish 1:27:16 man for example Kadir to each man of the 1:27:19 Quran if numeric when he speaks about it 1:27:21 he and he says walk through I wish 1:27:23 Memphis he says works or I wish I wish I 1:27:26 wish MIM 1:27:27 fair as to Latino relearn I mean and 1:27:30 well done moon Jack a more alpha to me 1:27:32 in a narrow the issue of ish man and the 1:27:38 way that is read it's not something 1:27:40 that's known in Naju it's taken from 1:27:41 where it's taken from karate like they 1:27:43 they complement one another 1:27:44 so these oriental ease are not masters 1:27:48 in the Arabic language they are not less 1:27:51 to be an original lucu listener who 1:27:53 where I can easily peel okuru for abou 1:27:56 they are foreigners from the Arabic 1:27:58 language we Muslims have to have thicker 1:28:01 in our amounts like Ebru malik when hero 1:28:03 is l fear 1:28:05 even though he believes he's al feels 1:28:07 the best he's a column muhammadun who 1:28:08 abnormally qiyamah Dorabella Hiram 1:28:10 Maliki most ugly and our enemy in most 1:28:12 of our early in was tuck Molina sharafa 1:28:14 why stir in Allah feel fear Mikasa 1:28:16 dinner will be on Maria to carry will 1:28:18 AXA beloved in New Jersey what I was 1:28:20 told better be ready man Jesse 1:28:22 what acted on be ready shortly at n L 1:28:25 theater tomorrow t wahoo 1:28:27 we supped inhabitant of Lyra was told 1:28:29 you internet l Jamila my key tab is 1:28:31 better than the L fear of abnormality 1:28:33 he's saying that but even what is better 1:28:37 better than me because he came before me 1:28:38 I'm taking from him I honor him because 1:28:43 if he's a self to me and I miss her 1:28:45 shoes the love he has for his scholars 1:28:49 that Canadian a gentleman by being a 1:28:50 coruña rabbinical era when I mean and 1:28:53 Adina Saba could have been a man shelter 1:28:56 business since remarried judge Allah who 1:28:58 built hierarchy and imagine Lenin a 1:29:00 cologne or Anna as Ben Massell Sarah may 1:29:02 Allah reward the great scholars who 1:29:04 transmitted ease or unfroze for us so 1:29:06 it's not a time where we doubt our 1:29:09 events and we question them and we put 1:29:14 them down over Oahu and non-muslim an 1:29:16 Orientalist who doesn't know much about 1:29:18 the religion and even if we gave him the 1:29:21 chance to hear him out doesn't have much 1:29:25 to be found alone their works and all of 1:29:28 them are very I mean none of them are 1:29:30 the same very some of them like a firm 1:29:37 the the research should correct 1:29:39 themselves 1:29:39 I mean mentioning names now 1:29:43 nikolai sinai he done a great job in 1:29:44 dispelling the myths of fool Casanova 1:29:47 became before him he said that the Quran 1:29:49 came in the eighth century and he said 1:29:51 no this is not correct in a thematic 1:29:53 recession seventh centuries actually or 1:29:55 the Islamic narrative is correct they 1:29:57 and he corrected the other orientalist 1:30:00 because of sonar manuscripts and the 1:30:02 palimpsest and all these things and my 1:30:04 father radio cover accuracy and all that 1:30:06 stuff so to be fair it's kind of like 1:30:09 okay a lot more incidents 100 years ago 1:30:11 you said X and now you're saying why 1:30:14 you've come to the Islamic narrative 1:30:16 after a hundred years of toil 1:30:18 we've only been saying this for a 1:30:19 thousand four hundred years and the 1:30:21 thing is because to be honest with the 1:30:23 other side like I'll be honest Quranic 1:30:26 studies in the West is not a massive 1:30:28 field 1:30:28 there's not like thousands of people 1:30:30 involved they're probably the big names 1:30:32 that's not just the in in the it's not 1:30:36 just in the West's like if you look at 1:30:38 an anon Sarkozy in his kitab boron when 1:30:43 he spoke about for example to Syria he 1:30:45 said it's in moon let me on Goodwin I'm 1:30:48 your hot Eric it's like a science that 1:30:51 hasn't been nurtured and it hasn't even 1:30:52 reap you haven't been read yet 1:30:53 so even if you look at the early 1:30:55 scholars they kind of alleged that lumen 1:30:57 Quran is a side that hasn't been fully 1:31:00 given like a lot have to say is that 1:31:07 maybe because now the thing we have to 1:31:09 do with in academia is the new 1:31:12 manuscripts and radiocarbon dating 1:31:15 things which did not existed on set up 1:31:17 we still have to combat it within the 1:31:19 sphere we have to refute them but no we 1:31:32 have to refute them and of course could 1:31:33 have to hide a comb is for everybody 1:31:35 anyone who'd had to go to Saudi Muslim 1:31:39 being evidence is forward but example I 1:31:42 was trying to study the kita I feel at 1:31:43 Treblinka site by Ali men shot together 1:31:47 home a lot and I struggle to fight 1:31:51 anyone who can actually go through with 1:31:53 me this cab and explain to me this key 1:31:56 table indeed and it was table is an 1:31:59 awesome oh sorry yeah I mean I struggled 1:32:01 to find it and it's not even a it's not 1:32:03 even a big like book is just small 200 1:32:06 something lines of poetry it's rare to 1:32:09 find today if you look at the people the 1:32:11 scholars who are grounded in normal 1:32:13 Quran and have understanding of it 1:32:15 that's why the Orientalist are going 1:32:18 direction they find it as a place where 1:32:21 they could 1:32:29 so what kind of open real specialist 1:32:36 especially in that let's be frank in the 1:32:38 Western down not any one who can say oh 1:32:40 this is the guy we can't we don't 1:32:42 actually have this is the have to say in 1:32:46 accordance to our knowledge with 1:32:47 everybody in the West so we say 1:32:49 according to our knowledge yeah I mean 1:32:51 we don't see a lot of people are at the 1:32:53 forefront when it comes to normal so 1:33:02 unless I must leaving us a little bit 1:33:04 open so we have to be open about that 1:33:05 and say you know your is true and the 1:33:07 Orientalists we can't wait for number 1:33:09 ten years before they get strong enough 1:33:11 to be able to to deal with us 1:33:13 some knowledge which reduces the more 1:33:16 that they don't start saying more things 1:33:19 issue when in Charlotte either as I said 1:33:21 at the land buttocks said sorry so your 1:33:22 ritual diameter we always think higher 1:33:25 of this on man they're always going to 1:33:26 be people who are going to stand up for 1:33:29 the deal and that's gonna revive the 1:33:32 religion for the people there's always 1:33:33 going to be people in Charlotte that's 1:33:35 mean sure you always welcome to come and 1:33:40 I think many people would have really 1:33:42 benefited from this exposition and again 1:33:47 for having me there's a lot of things 1:33:49 that I felt I wanted to speak about but 1:33:52 I left it because of it not been the 1:33:56 most sensible place to speak about it 1:33:58 it's not my place I am going to go 1:34:01 through it all in great details the 1:34:03 Annabelle room being details 1:34:05 inshallah era for any student of 1:34:07 knowledge whether even if they have a 1:34:09 ulterior motive they have you know their 1:34:12 belief and they don't wanna if you're 1:34:13 looking for something to to use even 1:34:16 watch it I will present you the 1:34:18 arguments for us inshallah I like the 1:34:24 YouTube in Charlotte Anna is the 1:34:25 madrasah to Maria 1:34:26 YouTube channel in Charlotte it's gonna 1:34:29 be there it's free you don't have to pay 1:34:31 a penny in Charlotte Anna 1:34:33 no shadow la la la la I started oka what 1:34:39 a two-wheeler

Preservation of Qur’an- Ust Abdul Rahman Hassan MH podcast #3 (2020-06-14) ​

Summary of Preservation of Qur’an- Ust Abdul Rahman Hassan MH podcast #3 ​

00:00:00 [01:00:00 ​

01:00:00 [01:30:00 ​

Full transcript with timestamps: CLICK TO EXPAND

Preservation of Qur’an- Ust Abdul Rahman Hassan MH podcast #3 (2020-06-14)

Summary of Preservation of Qur’an- Ust Abdul Rahman Hassan MH podcast #3

00:00:00 [01:00:00

01:00:00 [01:30:00