Reacting to Indian Media Wion on Hijab (2021-09-21) ​

0:00:00 [Music]
0:00:05 go to quranilli.app inshallah the app
0:00:07 tracks versus pages and time spent
0:00:10 reading and the verses to pages function
0:00:12 takes you from reading a few verses a
0:00:14 day to a few pages a day this project is
0:00:17 for the real enthusiasts if there's
0:00:19 enough of us out there this will become
0:00:21 the future of quran apps and support the
0:00:24 project if you can inshaallah may allah
0:00:26 bless all of you jazakallahu
0:00:32 um a lot of people have been contacting
0:00:33 me especially from the subcontinent in
0:00:35 india pakistan and these kinds of
0:00:36 countries
0:00:38 masha'allah you know really appreciate
0:00:40 your support
0:00:41 um
0:00:42 to tell me that you know you should do a
0:00:44 lot more refutations of these kinds of
0:00:46 people like we on the the presenter that
0:00:47 i refuted in the previous uh
0:00:49 in the in the previous video i'll be
0:00:51 honest with you
0:00:52 um
0:00:54 she's a very easy target she was and the
0:00:56 entire organization were very easy and i
0:00:58 think to myself do these people even
0:01:00 think about what they're saying before
0:01:02 they say it because what i'm going to
0:01:04 present to you today
0:01:06 is pathetic it's really pathetic you'll
0:01:08 remember in the previous episode
0:01:10 that one of her main concerns if you
0:01:12 want to put it in that language
0:01:14 with the taliban taking control
0:01:16 or other countries in the in general
0:01:19 actually
0:01:20 was
0:01:21 um this uh women being forced to wear
0:01:24 hijab or head covering and so on in
0:01:25 afghanistan
0:01:27 now we'll talk about that and the
0:01:29 legitimacy of that or lack thereof
0:01:31 in a bit but before we do that i just
0:01:34 want you guys to see
0:01:37 this particular video where she's
0:01:39 talking about
0:01:41 ataturk let's see what she says not too
0:01:44 long ago turkey used to be a modern and
0:01:46 secular state an islamic republic with a
0:01:48 progressive approach thanks to the
0:01:50 policies of mustafa kamal
0:01:54 the father of modern day turkey a
0:01:56 reformer who brought his country at par
0:01:58 with the european world he replaced
0:02:01 arabic with the latin script the islamic
0:02:03 calendar with the western calendar
0:02:05 mosques were under state control faith
0:02:08 was a private matter christians and jews
0:02:10 could freely worship their gods in
0:02:12 turkey turkish men were forbidden from
0:02:14 wearing a headgear turkish women
0:02:16 forbidden from wearing head scarves but
0:02:18 the turkey of today is very different
0:02:21 now turkey is ruled by a leader who
0:02:23 wants to take his country back to its
0:02:25 ottoman ambitions
0:02:27 i was listening to this thinking is this
0:02:28 woman for real
0:02:30 is this woman for real she mentioned a
0:02:33 few things
0:02:34 the ataturk dumb in his premiership
0:02:38 and one of those things was that he
0:02:40 banned hijab
0:02:42 and i want to say something
0:02:44 the silence
0:02:45 is deafening
0:02:48 the acquiescence
0:02:50 is clear
0:02:51 and in fact the tone was encouraging
0:02:53 from your perspective
0:02:55 why when it comes to
0:02:57 a nationalist secularist
0:03:00 if your paradigm
0:03:02 is a liberal one
0:03:04 do you not comment in a negative manner
0:03:08 do not condemn
0:03:12 banning or restrictions
0:03:15 to clothe
0:03:16 to clothing especially women women's
0:03:18 clothing but when it comes to the
0:03:20 islamic discourse you do exactly that
0:03:24 this already reveals to me
0:03:26 that you are a hypocrite
0:03:28 you are an absolute hypocrite it's not a
0:03:31 matter
0:03:32 of moral consistency here
0:03:35 it is a matter of
0:03:37 strategic consistency
0:03:39 in fact you have just fell
0:03:42 face-first
0:03:44 into an intellectual ditch you're
0:03:46 embarrassing yourself
0:03:49 this is absolutely shocking
0:03:53 i can't believe it almost to be honest
0:03:55 i'm lost for words but i must say
0:03:58 the problem is the notion in the first
0:04:00 place
0:04:01 that a woman
0:04:02 in the west even
0:04:04 has any
0:04:06 or every right to wear whatever she
0:04:08 wants
0:04:09 this is a false notion
0:04:10 and it can be proven or disproven i
0:04:13 should say with the easiest
0:04:16 of introspection
0:04:17 if i say for example
0:04:20 if a woman wears a bikini in the bank
0:04:23 okay look we've been living i've been
0:04:25 living here all my life i'm a westerner
0:04:27 what's your name i don't know prakash
0:04:29 whatever your name is sorry to say i
0:04:30 don't know your name yeah but i'm a
0:04:32 westerner
0:04:33 i've been educated in the west and i've
0:04:35 been an educator in the west i don't
0:04:37 want you to worship me now please don't
0:04:39 worship me
0:04:40 okay because i know you worship
0:04:42 the creation
0:04:44 not the creator was a lot of your people
0:04:46 they worship the creation aside from the
0:04:48 creator i don't want to go to bombay and
0:04:50 see like a statue of the great hijab
0:04:52 there
0:04:54 muhammad the learned hijab there i don't
0:04:56 want to see this
0:04:58 so please don't worship
0:05:00 but i've been uneducated i've been
0:05:02 educated there in the west
0:05:04 and i've been an educator here in the
0:05:06 west for some time and i can tell you
0:05:08 from my experience and i think people
0:05:10 will share this experience here in the
0:05:12 west
0:05:14 and that in fact
0:05:15 women can't wear what they want
0:05:17 i mean a woman cannot wear a bikini in
0:05:19 the bank now she might be able to get
0:05:21 away with it i mean i don't think
0:05:22 anyone's stopping maybe the police will
0:05:23 come i don't know
0:05:24 but i can tell you for a fact that a
0:05:26 woman cannot wear a bikini
0:05:29 in a school
0:05:31 now if she works in a secondary school
0:05:33 uh she i mean i've been in schools where
0:05:35 women have been told not to have a lot
0:05:36 cleavage hanging out if she's teaching
0:05:38 you a 10-11 why because it will distract
0:05:40 the students this is very fair or you
0:05:43 could say a common
0:05:45 policy
0:05:46 you cannot imagine it's inconceivable
0:05:49 that women will wear bikinis to work in
0:05:51 a school or in a corporate even
0:05:53 corporate environments
0:05:56 and in fact they'll probably be sent
0:05:57 home
0:05:58 i guarantee you they'll be sent home
0:06:01 women that go
0:06:03 to corporate environments or secondary
0:06:05 schools or university places or
0:06:08 hospitals or any of those places which
0:06:10 are
0:06:11 we're talking about tens of millions of
0:06:12 women here just in the uk a population
0:06:14 of i don't know 70 something million
0:06:17 they will be sent home if they wear
0:06:19 those clothes they have uniform they
0:06:20 have to wear
0:06:22 and it will be seen as inappropriate
0:06:24 and public exposure
0:06:27 but why can the same woman
0:06:29 go to a beach and wear the bikini and
0:06:31 there's no issue i mean who gets to set
0:06:33 these guidelines have you ever thought
0:06:34 about it have you ever thought about who
0:06:37 gets to set these societal conventions
0:06:40 why is it acceptable in the beach but
0:06:42 and
0:06:43 it's not and on the roadsides or in a
0:06:45 park but it's not acceptable in a bank
0:06:47 or a hospital or in a school
0:06:50 you could give me a reason you tell me
0:06:52 well because one will cause a
0:06:53 distraction
0:06:54 okay
0:06:55 well maybe if if wearing such clothing
0:06:59 causes a distraction the question is at
0:07:02 what point does it stop causing a
0:07:03 distraction
0:07:05 and where does the line where is the
0:07:07 line drawn what a woman where is the
0:07:09 miniskirt in a corporate environment
0:07:10 doesn't that cause some kind of
0:07:11 distraction are the hormones hormone
0:07:14 levels of men
0:07:15 that much drastically different
0:07:18 or that the behavior of such men will be
0:07:20 completely different
0:07:21 in corporate environments to hospitals
0:07:24 to to this but who gets to who gets to
0:07:26 sorry to say
0:07:28 set those cultural conventions
0:07:30 i tell you gets to do it for the most
0:07:32 part
0:07:33 white men
0:07:34 and once again
0:07:36 well when i'm saying that maybe you've
0:07:38 already jumped into prostration but
0:07:39 before you do get back up
0:07:41 get back up
0:07:44 listen to what i'm saying
0:07:46 white men maybe white women as well yeah
0:07:47 the feminist movement has had a huge
0:07:49 i would say influence as well
0:07:52 but why should we follow those
0:07:53 regulations
0:07:55 they are legally enforceable
0:07:57 organizationally enforceable
0:07:59 structurally enforceable institutionally
0:08:02 enforceable so many times
0:08:04 and so you can't say women can wear what
0:08:06 they want in the west they can't that's
0:08:08 that's that is a misnomer
0:08:10 that is a that is fallacious reasoning
0:08:13 that is wrong legalistically false
0:08:16 john stuart mill himself
0:08:18 he had limits with the father of social
0:08:20 liberalism he said people having sex in
0:08:22 the roadside should be banned
0:08:24 fortunately mexico didn't take his
0:08:26 advice but that's another story for
0:08:27 another day
0:08:29 the point i'm making to you is what is
0:08:32 that much different
0:08:34 the only difference is in the type of
0:08:36 clothing
0:08:38 well you might say well it's actually
0:08:39 more coverage you know the islamic
0:08:41 garment
0:08:42 but when girls go to girls schools or
0:08:44 even mixed schools
0:08:45 or even boys go to such schools they are
0:08:47 told what to wear
0:08:49 ex by color
0:08:51 that you know even the color they have
0:08:52 to if you don't have the tyre you go
0:08:54 back home what do you mean what do you
0:08:56 mean you go back home if you don't have
0:08:57 a tie
0:08:58 isn't that restricting what you wear you
0:09:00 can't wear what you want this is a
0:09:02 misnomer what country do you think this
0:09:04 is do you think
0:09:05 where do you think we are living in the
0:09:06 nudest place the west is a new this
0:09:08 place this is a huge misconception
0:09:11 so that's the first thing i want to say
0:09:13 the second thing is clear your hypocrisy
0:09:15 is very clear
0:09:17 why do you allow
0:09:18 girls to be segregated in girl schools
0:09:20 in olympic events for them to have
0:09:22 designated uh uniform all of these
0:09:25 things legally enforceable in in
0:09:28 organizations and institutes but when
0:09:29 the taliban do it with a different or
0:09:31 these guys do or whoever doesn't you're
0:09:33 thinking this is so much it's so weird
0:09:35 it's not that it's not to be honest with
0:09:36 you it's not that weird it's very
0:09:37 similar to what you guys already impose
0:09:39 but it's just in a different format
0:09:41 it's all it is it's in a different
0:09:42 format
0:09:44 now the question is now a sharia
0:09:46 question
0:09:48 since you you're the expert in sharia of
0:09:50 course yeah
0:09:51 you didn't know what the massage of
0:09:52 sharia were but you're the expert which
0:09:55 means the the sources of sharia the
0:09:57 point is
0:09:58 what happens in a sharia state is there
0:10:00 any had punitive law that stipulates the
0:10:02 quran
0:10:03 for a woman who doesn't wear hijab
0:10:05 there's no such heart actually mentioned
0:10:08 that doesn't mean to say they can wear
0:10:09 what they want
0:10:10 because the quran states
0:10:17 that's not for a muslim man or a muslim
0:10:19 woman if allah and the messenger have
0:10:21 chosen something for them to have any
0:10:22 choice in the matter because if you
0:10:24 really are a muslim muslim someone who
0:10:27 is submitting to allah you believe that
0:10:29 this religion is from god then this is
0:10:31 this this is the godly uniform if you
0:10:33 like
0:10:34 if you don't want to be a muslim if
0:10:35 you're not muslim
0:10:42 there's no compulsion religion but this
0:10:44 verse is for non-muslims as for muslims
0:10:46 is these are our guidelines why why are
0:10:49 our guidelines so foreign and your
0:10:51 guidelines so
0:10:53 the ones that we should all follow you
0:10:54 haven't even given us reasons
0:10:57 do you not see the patheticness of your
0:10:59 you're pathetic
0:11:01 you haven't even argued for your case
0:11:04 so i say
0:11:07 this is a really weak approach the
0:11:08 second thing is i want to
0:11:10 also point
0:11:11 to the fact that when it comes to
0:11:13 religious freedoms
0:11:15 your colleague
0:11:18 look what she says about
0:11:19 encouraging of macron and his policies
0:11:22 which are anti-muslim
0:11:24 and once again one of the policies is to
0:11:27 restrict women's dress code but let's
0:11:28 see what your your colleague says about
0:11:30 this
0:11:33 we start off with the latest coming in
0:11:34 from france where the lawmakers have now
0:11:37 approved president emmanuel macron's new
0:11:39 law that proposes to fight radical
0:11:42 islamism
0:11:43 the law aims to strengthen oversight of
0:11:46 mosques schools and sports clubs to
0:11:49 safeguard france from radical islamists
0:11:51 so once again here look at this
0:11:53 encouraging tone when it comes to whom
0:11:56 when it comes to the secular republican
0:11:59 macron
0:12:01 it's not that you're liberal by the way
0:12:03 you're not liberal
0:12:04 you might call yourself liberal
0:12:07 but you're disguising fascism with
0:12:10 liberalism quite similar to hitler quite
0:12:12 similar to your president actually modi
0:12:14 the bastard
0:12:16 yes the bastard
0:12:17 the one who's allowing all of these
0:12:18 things to happen with minorities in his
0:12:20 uh in his country
0:12:22 this individual here
0:12:24 you are
0:12:26 exposed already as an individual
0:12:28 and the proof is in the pudding because
0:12:30 if had you not been a fascistic person
0:12:32 at least an inclination
0:12:34 then you would have some kind of liberal
0:12:36 consistency which you don't and i have
0:12:38 nothing else to say to you you're
0:12:40 finished good night
0:12:52 you