0:00:00 Music
0:00:03 foreign
0:00:07 Music
0:00:37 YouTube channel every Sunday at 2PM
0:00:40 British summer time we invite you to
0:00:42 subscribe to the channel and activate
0:00:43 the notification Bell for all new
0:00:45 content
0:00:46 today we won't be streaming so uh
0:00:50 initially hopefully next week you'll be
0:00:51 resolved
0:00:52 um so today is session 112 we are on Aya
0:00:56 112 of Surat al-maida
0:01:00 so thank you
0:01:05 foreign
0:01:16 foreign
0:01:45 it is but for your own selves that you
0:01:47 are responsible those who go astray can
0:01:50 do you no harm if you yourselves are on
0:01:52 the right path unto God you must all
0:01:55 return and then he will make you truly
0:01:57 understand all that you were doing in
0:01:59 life next translation Believers you are
0:02:02 responsible for your own Souls those who
0:02:05 go astray cannot harm you if you are on
0:02:07 the right path all of you will return to
0:02:09 God and he will tell you what you used
0:02:11 to do
0:02:12 I wonder did we do that last time
0:02:14 because I added the eye after that
0:02:18 um
0:02:19 I'm not sure I mean I I just tend to do
0:02:21 whatever we last left on uh but I can I
0:02:24 can do the next one as well so oh you
0:02:26 have attained your face
0:02:28 Let There Be witness to what you do when
0:02:30 death approaches you and you are about
0:02:32 to make big quests two persons of
0:02:35 property from among your own set of
0:02:37 people or if the pants of death come
0:02:40 upon you while you are traveling far
0:02:42 from home to other persons from among
0:02:44 people other than your own take hold of
0:02:47 the two after having prayed and if you
0:02:49 have any doubt in your mind let each of
0:02:52 them swear by God
0:02:53 we shall not sell
0:02:55 we shall not sell this our word for any
0:02:58 price even if even though it were for
0:03:00 the sake of a near Kinsmen and neither
0:03:03 shall we conceal
0:03:04 ought of what we have witnessed before
0:03:06 God or else we may
0:03:08 we indeed be counted among the sinful
0:03:11 next translation Believers When Death
0:03:13 approaches you let two men two just men
0:03:16 from among you act as witnesses to the
0:03:19 writings of your will to the writing of
0:03:21 your will if death approaches you while
0:03:24 you are traveling far from home let two
0:03:26 just men from among another people act
0:03:28 as Witnesses
0:03:30 take hold of the two men after having
0:03:32 prayed and if you doubt any if you have
0:03:35 any doubt in your mind let each of them
0:03:37 swear to God we will not sell our word
0:03:40 for any price even if it were for the
0:03:42 sake of a near relative we will not hide
0:03:45 God's testimony or else we'll be counted
0:03:48 among the sinful
0:03:49 okay I'm still doubting if this uh the
0:03:52 previous one is being covered anyone
0:03:54 listening to a son can check
0:03:59 I don't I mean I'll have to go back and
0:04:02 record
0:04:13 focus on yourselves it doesn't harm you
0:04:17 yeah maybe did not do that it doesn't
0:04:18 harm you uh whoever got astray if you
0:04:21 are guided so focus on getting
0:04:23 self-guided getting yourself from the
0:04:25 right path the your return would be to
0:04:27 Allah and he will inform all of you for
0:04:30 about that what you have been doing yeah
0:04:32 that's it read another translation maybe
0:04:35 you did read one I think I'll read
0:04:37 another for this one
0:04:39 vote for the form one two the one before
0:04:41 you
0:04:42 the other one before yeah because I
0:04:44 think
0:04:45 Believers you are responsible for your
0:04:47 own Souls those who go astray cannot
0:04:49 harm you if you're on the right path all
0:04:51 of you will return to God and he will
0:04:52 tell you what you used to do
0:04:54 okay exactly so this is the meaning is
0:04:57 very clear there was some some uh issue
0:05:01 relating to understanding uh focus on
0:05:04 yourself those who go astray would not
0:05:06 harm you and there's a narrative about
0:05:09 some issue happened by the ashari if
0:05:12 they have the the tribe of ashari who
0:05:14 came up with the Giant from abusini was
0:05:18 coming back from Abyssinian and arrived
0:05:20 at Medina when the prophet was in high
0:05:22 bar and then he proceeded to Harbor
0:05:24 together with
0:05:27 one of them and his brothers and so on
0:05:31 and one of these ashari there was some
0:05:33 issue in their tribe not in this in the
0:05:36 battle Campbell of hybrid maybe but
0:05:37 after that and he did not do necessary
0:05:41 intervention or something like that a
0:05:44 messenger why didn't you change
0:05:47 the prophet evil or he obviously has the
0:05:50 capability and the necessary Authority
0:05:53 all of these usual conditions and then
0:05:55 he uh he answered then because I
0:05:59 listened to what Allah said focus on
0:06:01 yourself you'll not be Mr will you will
0:06:05 you will not be accounted for that it
0:06:07 will not harm you for those who got us
0:06:10 three uh because
0:06:14 he said why did you get this
0:06:16 interpretation it is the meaning of that
0:06:19 it is the the those who got astray from
0:06:22 the kofar they will not harm you their
0:06:24 costume not harm you that's it not that
0:06:26 it doesn't apply to any believer and
0:06:28 also if you look at the wedding of the
0:06:30 Ayah you see how how people come
0:06:32 sometimes
0:06:34 misunderstood so this is it doesn't have
0:06:37 you all got to go astray when you are
0:06:39 guided that's not who commits sin and
0:06:41 you are not crazy and you are not doing
0:06:44 it no this is
0:06:46 and usually when going astray or a
0:06:49 guidance is
0:06:50 not about believer doing mistakes which
0:06:54 others should command and enjoying them
0:06:56 to change and Etc so this is the only
0:06:58 collection there's still understanding
0:07:00 so this is it will not harm you with a
0:07:02 disbeliever that I believe I want to
0:07:04 stay if they are guided and you fall to
0:07:06 the right path so don't worry about that
0:07:09 focus on that it does not mean for
0:07:11 example even for this video but that you
0:07:12 don't call them to Islam that doesn't
0:07:14 debate with them in good times to get
0:07:16 them back from some of the misguidance
0:07:18 no it doesn't mean that but that you
0:07:21 should not be concerned about that in
0:07:23 the sense that you grieve or think you
0:07:24 are responsible no they are responsive
0:07:26 of their own acts and so on but you are
0:07:28 still have the enjoyment of calling them
0:07:30 to Islam to God to wear that give them
0:07:33 good admonishment and good advice etc
0:07:36 etc
0:07:37 so that's I think that we did not touch
0:07:39 this last time so so I want to just
0:07:41 assess that point that is does not have
0:07:43 anything to do with the command good and
0:07:45 forbidden evil or or does not have any
0:07:48 uh any restricting meaning to the Surah
0:07:50 that all humans are lost except for
0:07:53 enjoying
0:07:57 and enjoy it to each other or admonish
0:08:00 each other for hack and for Sabbath is
0:08:04 right and to be persistent and
0:08:07 perseverance in sticking to the truth
0:08:10 because usually sticking the truth is
0:08:12 usually painful and Peter
0:08:15 this this is different than this one
0:08:17 here it is those who go astray by their
0:08:20 own will willful doing will not harm you
0:08:23 but if you fail to to do your detail of
0:08:27 calling to Islam and so on when it is
0:08:29 possible or for the entire inside the
0:08:30 believer we have the obligation of
0:08:32 commanding good at video
0:08:34 forbidding evil which is in the
0:08:36 injunction of the Quran Sunnah in many
0:08:38 places then that will harm you because
0:08:40 you've helped your duty so nobody should
0:08:42 misunderstand that like this so as a
0:08:44 companion
0:08:46 in Islam maybe he did not have the depth
0:08:49 of knowledge and education but still
0:08:51 although this is only interesting to see
0:08:53 that so even companion could fall in
0:08:55 such a misinterpretation because they
0:08:59 have not really absorbed the meaning or
0:09:00 did not get enough education over the
0:09:02 prophet because they are late in
0:09:03 companionship but even all this
0:09:05 companion could make mistakes as some
0:09:08 people sometimes have said the
0:09:09 companions say that they think it's a
0:09:10 lecture the moment someone become a
0:09:12 companion somehow you grow wings and
0:09:14 become like an angel this misconception
0:09:16 we almost clean from our head and it
0:09:18 will come down in Shabba and in the next
0:09:20 Ayah so that's the meaning of this area
0:09:21 that's the comet otherwise it's clear so
0:09:25 don't be uh don't think that that you
0:09:28 will be harmed by those going in
0:09:29 Michigan going to miscarriage by the old
0:09:31 design we are not harmful for you as
0:09:33 long as your own Duty and you are
0:09:36 getting back guided part of being guided
0:09:38 is that you carry the dawa when it is
0:09:40 appropriate obvious
0:09:41 is not an obligation
0:09:44 except for those who who have sufficient
0:09:47 knowledge and have in certain position
0:09:49 of dawah but cutting down the other
0:09:51 remote
0:09:53 inside the Muslim Community is an
0:09:56 obligation especially against the rulers
0:09:58 and with the rules that's fundamentalist
0:10:00 part of the description of the Believers
0:10:02 which we I think came to Surah when you
0:10:04 said the main characteristic of the
0:10:06 Believers as a community both male and
0:10:08 female that they come out good and very
0:10:10 evil and believe in Allah has messenger
0:10:12 and performs Allah Etc they say the
0:10:14 commander good they are alive they
0:10:17 support each other they come out good
0:10:19 and forbid even even
0:10:21 a head even believing in Allah we know
0:10:23 we realize the base but this is for such
0:10:25 importance in that context that it's
0:10:27 mentioned even ahead also more important
0:10:30 eyes
0:10:31 so that's the that's what this ISO do
0:10:34 not be I think that these who are one
0:10:37 that's three will harm you as long as
0:10:39 you are guided or part of being guided
0:10:41 is to do your duties whatever it is and
0:10:45 do as much as possible from these
0:10:47 reality things if you're capable and if
0:10:49 you you have a facility for that like
0:10:51 for example if you are a qualified man
0:10:53 who for example has a long arm and long
0:10:56 information about for example the
0:10:59 various we will come to that it is maybe
0:11:01 today or next time what the various
0:11:04 publication and mistakes in the
0:11:05 scripture description to inform that
0:11:07 people have that and call them to
0:11:08 islamans
0:11:09 correction for those mistakes in the
0:11:12 description and so on but that's
0:11:14 obviously what becomes an obligation for
0:11:15 if there is nobody else doing it and
0:11:17 secondly if you are really well
0:11:18 established in that but otherwise you
0:11:20 don't follow up with this believer of
0:11:22 going with the misguidance and uh but
0:11:26 inside the Islamic Camp there you have
0:11:27 no Liberty references of this evidence
0:11:30 especially from the rulers you have to
0:11:32 change it if if necessary if it is the
0:11:35 level of coverage by false if not
0:11:38 capable then by word if not capable then
0:11:40 at least in the heart you have to
0:11:42 condemn it and reject it and train
0:11:44 yourself to
0:11:46 by word or by the sword if necessary
0:11:49 so that nobody should confuse that this
0:11:51 is a liberty or exclusion from
0:11:54 commanding God of everything inside the
0:11:55 Muslim Community
0:11:57 so and concluding all of you will be
0:12:00 sent to Allah and he will inform
0:12:02 everyone what he's doing so get focused
0:12:03 on yourself that you're even guided
0:12:05 because you will be questioned about all
0:12:07 your Deeds so they don't don't divert
0:12:10 your attention well for that which is
0:12:12 not your job do your job and your job is
0:12:14 to be guided
0:12:27 corrupt or they deviate they are capable
0:12:29 usually to be corrupt and male and
0:12:33 destroy the whole society much faster
0:12:35 than any single person but that is
0:12:37 another another issue which we call it
0:12:40 Indulgence and put detail we have a
0:12:42 complete book about that inshallah will
0:12:44 have second edition coming soon and also
0:12:47 translated the first edition is
0:12:48 available in Arabic second edition is
0:12:51 being published now and developed and it
0:12:53 will be inshallah that would be the
0:12:55 initial translated that will take away a
0:12:57 few weeks every few months to finish
0:13:01 so then we continue with the more
0:13:03 complex Ayah which is we just thread and
0:13:05 realization just repeated session again
0:13:07 then the next one uh a look at the pixel
0:13:10 translation see if pectal has some
0:13:11 nuances there different than the others
0:13:16 Music
0:13:24 is
0:13:29 oh ye you believe Let There Be Witnesses
0:13:33 Between You When Death groweth knife
0:13:36 this is ridiculous this is like 15th
0:13:38 century or something to get pixels
0:13:41 they should have there's a Modern
0:13:43 English version of it I don't know why
0:13:45 it is
0:13:50 I said it does not have the English test
0:13:53 he's not an genuine English the best of
0:13:55 English test is that polypical
0:13:57 well this is yeah from 1500s
0:14:01 this is this is a oh ye who believe this
0:14:04 is just the best one is Kafka so they
0:14:08 cut through the unnecessary uh so this
0:14:11 one's good I mean Believers When Death
0:14:13 approaches you let two just men from
0:14:15 among you act as witnesses to the
0:14:17 writing of your will if death approaches
0:14:19 you while you are traveling far from
0:14:20 home let two just men from among other
0:14:23 from among another people act as
0:14:25 Witnesses take hold of the two men after
0:14:28 having prayed and if you have any doubts
0:14:30 in your mind let each of them pray to
0:14:32 God we will not sell our word for any
0:14:35 price even if it were for the sake of a
0:14:37 mere relative we will not hide God's
0:14:39 testimony or else we will be counted
0:14:42 among the sinful okay so the first
0:14:44 collection is that they said two just
0:14:46 men no it is
0:14:49 honesty and truthfulness these two it is
0:14:54 used also for the feminine and general
0:14:56 injunctions so so it could be men and
0:14:59 women so that's that's bad but this one
0:15:00 is stuck in his mentality that woman
0:15:02 cannot be Witnesses or on his restricted
0:15:06 way which is his fallacy and you
0:15:07 remember we discussed at the end of this
0:15:10 fallacy is still stuck in many brains
0:15:12 that's number one so are the two of
0:15:15 Justice
0:15:16 what are these two female female uh male
0:15:19 female uh whatever neutral if they
0:15:21 success doesn't exist obviously despite
0:15:24 all these LGBT Etc nonsense but if it is
0:15:27 done that was that they just and they
0:15:30 are people of justice and honesty and
0:15:32 the Integrity so that their witnesses
0:15:34 can be uh can be relied upon principle
0:15:38 from you what does he say from you some
0:15:42 translate from your own people without
0:15:44 meaning God's Own people they are trying
0:15:46 to run away because there were two point
0:15:47 of view since ancient time what is from
0:15:49 you meaning the correct point of view
0:15:51 establish stressed and brought to so
0:15:53 many narratives from webinar Bus and
0:15:55 many other companions majority not all
0:15:58 but the majority of Companions and is it
0:16:01 from your meaning from the believing was
0:16:02 from the from the belief of the Muslims
0:16:05 and or two others from from the others
0:16:08 too
0:16:10 to just people also which you perceive
0:16:13 to be just again it doesn't say just
0:16:15 want to say two others from that from
0:16:18 from outside not from you and the
0:16:20 correct point of view it is from
0:16:22 non-believers people outside Islam and
0:16:24 you'll find many others saying from the
0:16:26 people of the book but this is
0:16:27 restricting something which Allah did
0:16:29 not restricted Allah could have said
0:16:31 from the word no that's not that's
0:16:33 putting in Allah's mouth what he did not
0:16:35 say that's wrong it's from any outside
0:16:38 the correct point of view from those
0:16:39 from you
0:16:41 do just one could be men could be a man
0:16:44 and woman Etc in in control distinction
0:16:47 and rejection of the misconception which
0:16:50 has been digging itself deep in Islamic
0:16:52 history an Islamic scholarship and from
0:16:55 the others will be outside the Muslim
0:16:57 faith from other faith and other beliefs
0:17:02 and this is specifically the but it is
0:17:05 not a condition
0:17:06 s
0:17:10 are going back and forth on Earth
0:17:12 meaning you are not at home
0:17:14 that's how it usually happens but
0:17:17 there's not been this is necessary
0:17:18 condition for this for this situation
0:17:22 some people say this is a condition that
0:17:24 if you have uh from from the other Faith
0:17:27 only is it it's as conditional on that
0:17:30 but definitely this is not persuasive
0:17:33 that's it it is being being on on travel
0:17:37 and so on the story which is the
0:17:38 revision came to is about travel I will
0:17:41 mention the story soon but that that
0:17:43 should be not regarded as persuasive and
0:17:46 comparing but this is normally where it
0:17:49 happens because you're in your home
0:17:51 unsettled and then and you feel that
0:17:53 approaching then there will be relatives
0:17:55 nearby there'll be there but there'll be
0:17:57 enough Witnesses and relatives and even
0:17:59 lawyers and so on available to do that
0:18:01 there is no need to go into this complex
0:18:03 regulation so this will be mostly and
0:18:06 almost exclusively happening only if you
0:18:08 are not at home you are going to travel
0:18:10 and we mentioned that when we mention
0:18:11 the story become clear what means and
0:18:14 then you are suddenly feeling this
0:18:16 approach getting falling sick getting an
0:18:19 infection getting a deadly injury and
0:18:21 then we have you have to manage that
0:18:25 and these these two
0:18:28 have to be uh forced to stand after
0:18:31 prayer
0:18:32 so that they make an oath by Allah
0:18:35 but only inner septum if you have a
0:18:38 doubt about their witness if there's no
0:18:40 doubt there's no reason for that then
0:18:42 only today that you receive the
0:18:44 testimony
0:18:47 what they have they're delivering I will
0:18:49 mention exactly what that was exactly I
0:18:51 mean we're delivering and then
0:18:52 everything looks correct there's nothing
0:18:55 which missing there whichever any
0:18:56 hinting does it then there is no need to
0:18:58 get them to make an oath after the
0:19:01 prayer whose prayer of also we'll get to
0:19:02 that also that because you have doubt
0:19:06 and they make an oath that we make about
0:19:08 Allah that we are not going uh for for
0:19:11 any motivation even if it's beneficial
0:19:13 for one of our next option and we are
0:19:16 not going to hide anything for the
0:19:17 witness of Allah
0:19:20 otherwise we are definitely sinful and
0:19:23 unjust
0:19:26 so
0:19:29 it seems to be that mentioning
0:19:33 looks like
0:19:35 how to apply that for people who are not
0:19:38 a Believer but that is because because
0:19:40 the the people do not follow the the the
0:19:43 the straight in the Stream of the of the
0:19:46 evidence of the ayas because it says you
0:19:49 could say it is it has two two different
0:19:51 statements that have merged together
0:19:53 with an or in between
0:19:55 if you ask them on traveling away and so
0:19:58 on and then this surprises you
0:20:01 then get to Witnesses of of Justice from
0:20:05 you from the believer
0:20:08 but if when they come to deliver the the
0:20:11 the Wasilla the will or the what they
0:20:13 what the dying person has with him to
0:20:15 commence money Etc the story will
0:20:18 clarify with what we may have and they
0:20:20 deliver it and everything seems to be in
0:20:22 order there's no need to doubt anything
0:20:24 there's no need for them let usually
0:20:25 them to stand get them to the court and
0:20:28 ask him to after Salah that's for the
0:20:30 believer obviously as we're talking
0:20:32 about Muslim and then uh they make an
0:20:35 author a very heavily author like that
0:20:37 without also the heaviness of the author
0:20:39 is also indicated by the should do it
0:20:44 because
0:20:46 the tool do heavy Oaths and very binding
0:20:50 us after starting
0:20:54 thus far in the case two just from us
0:20:57 to to uh two from other from other
0:21:01 people
0:21:03 Manhattan and then we have a reason for
0:21:06 doubt not just because they're from
0:21:08 other people but there is maybe they
0:21:09 deliver things perfectly there's nothing
0:21:10 to be the doubt about just physically
0:21:12 fine no problem but if there's any
0:21:14 reason of Doubt then you can apply to
0:21:16 the court it must be done by the
0:21:17 authority and they have to do something
0:21:19 equivalent to swearing after certain
0:21:21 hustle now the Believers
0:21:23 the disabiliters may not have such also
0:21:25 they may not respect it also what also
0:21:27 means for us doesn't mean anything in
0:21:29 that case they have to integrate it
0:21:31 after such such a ritual of them which
0:21:34 is very heavy and binding
0:21:37 whatever the ritual may be for example
0:21:39 let me give the extreme case of an
0:21:41 atheist says I don't play I don't
0:21:44 believe in does God exist but I can make
0:21:46 an oath under the penalty of bursary
0:21:49 and On My Honor that is the truth
0:21:52 nothing that the truth and the completed
0:21:54 I delivered completely what have been
0:21:56 given to me from the dying person so and
0:21:58 so on and I assigned to the effect in
0:22:01 front of the court and on a pronounce it
0:22:04 publicly or dictate to someone if he's
0:22:06 illiterate and put my seal or my thumb
0:22:07 on it that will be the equivalent of
0:22:10 salt Russell for a Christian it may be
0:22:12 taking the Cross and putting it on the
0:22:14 Bible if it has on top of it for a Jew
0:22:16 there is no cross but he can put his
0:22:17 hand on the on the Old Testament
0:22:19 whatever it is which is equivalent
0:22:22 and uh so it's from foreign
0:22:40 from another Faith just inserted between
0:22:43 under the rest applies to them
0:22:45 appropriately foreign
0:23:08 this is only for the believing one for
0:23:11 them is highly uh highly highly
0:23:14 respectable and they and they have to
0:23:17 attend us Allah with the community and
0:23:18 with the judge and then after Salah they
0:23:21 are
0:23:22 brought to the court of law or the
0:23:23 judges are sitting in the Masjid and
0:23:25 they do the oath the heavy oath con
0:23:27 fortified by being after for the
0:23:29 non-believer clearly doesn't make any
0:23:31 sense to get them in Salah and all have
0:23:33 the fortification of solar generally
0:23:36 so so for so so what what's the meaning
0:23:41 such a ritual of their side which is as
0:23:44 binding according to their faith and
0:23:46 they gave the extreme example over
0:23:47 atheists even
0:23:49 so I think it should be read like that
0:23:51 because that's that's how how Quran
0:23:54 should be that at most generality which
0:23:56 does not but across the borders of
0:23:58 rationality and linguistic limitation
0:24:01 and they might make an oath by Allah in
0:24:04 the case of this believer maybe you
0:24:06 cannot buy their owner or make sure I
0:24:09 make an author without mentioning Allah
0:24:10 otherwise
0:24:15 but under the penalty of perjury that I
0:24:18 have truthful that I'm telling the whole
0:24:19 truth I'm not hiding anything the usual
0:24:21 one was you people put it affidavit in
0:24:23 Britain which is don't necessarily do
0:24:25 actually the the English law does not
0:24:28 specify that you make an oath by Allah
0:24:29 or by God or anyone just by make an oath
0:24:32 other penalty of perjury so on so and so
0:24:34 on
0:24:35 uh under whatever your regardless as a
0:24:38 name for this foreign
0:24:57 Let me Give an example for that
0:25:00 you may have you may be in trouble in a
0:25:02 business every time past business travel
0:25:04 so people under some uh people who are
0:25:07 not believer
0:25:08 with you but they are remotely related
0:25:10 or they from the same tribe and they
0:25:13 have maybe in low relation with the with
0:25:15 the with some of the hairs and then they
0:25:19 hide some of the things or some of the
0:25:22 instructions written instructions of the
0:25:24 dying person because this way their
0:25:26 in-laws will benefit more from that that
0:25:28 will be British of thrusters will be a
0:25:31 higher fabrication let me just mention
0:25:33 so before going through an abstract
0:25:34 things mention what the story which we
0:25:38 have uh was supposedly the reason of
0:25:42 Revelation obviously the national or not
0:25:45 all nicely synchronized with each other
0:25:47 but the corner of story seems to be well
0:25:49 established the story is the following
0:25:50 admitted to you
0:25:52 yeah
0:25:55 yeah so don't make any mistakes
0:25:57 so this story the main story is narrated
0:25:59 from
0:26:01 tabari gives his snad
0:26:03 also have maybe question here and there
0:26:07 um
0:26:09 no this one is good that's from the
0:26:11 outside of his son Abdul America from
0:26:14 his father
0:26:16 a man from balisam
0:26:19 uh that's uh that his name is Mission
0:26:21 another narration uh who is by genealogy
0:26:26 but by Alliance he was a freed slave but
0:26:28 one of the
0:26:29 went out
0:26:31 that time was Christian and he was a
0:26:33 Christian until late he's famous with
0:26:35 the Hadith of Justice
0:26:38 if anyone is interested and his cousin
0:26:42 or next
0:26:43 both of them are Christian
0:26:48 by Alliance uh face death
0:26:52 and then he and then he entrusted them
0:26:56 with what he has with him they were
0:26:58 going for business they they were they
0:27:00 were usually going between Medina and
0:27:02 Sham and yeah and Mecca before even
0:27:04 immigration so then that is
0:27:07 for a long time and he was most likely
0:27:10 doing a lot of business with some before
0:27:12 they immigrated and when they went to
0:27:14 the Medina if immigration because Moses
0:27:18 customer and the business partner where
0:27:20 the one who arrest Islam and went to
0:27:22 Medina his community was between sham
0:27:24 and Madina more frequently than
0:27:27 Mecca but maybe
0:27:29 other business partners too we don't
0:27:32 know but that's what and his cousin or
0:27:34 his brother
0:27:35 was with him back and forth and one day
0:27:38 she said his brother maybe his brother
0:27:40 for a mother only because not the son of
0:27:42 bada but anyway I can shake it that's
0:27:44 his trivial points interesting for us
0:27:46 both our business part and going back
0:27:48 and forth
0:27:50 so he gave them what he has with him
0:27:53 because they were going for business he
0:27:54 has obviously goods and so on and the
0:27:56 the most valuable things he had is a pot
0:27:59 out of silver with with gold
0:28:01 ornamentation highly valuable heavy and
0:28:04 highly valuable obviously going to Sham
0:28:07 where obviously they have the Roman
0:28:09 Empire and we have three that coming
0:28:11 going to the Persian Empire this is
0:28:13 something uh high-class people and Kings
0:28:15 as I usually buy so he was hoping to get
0:28:18 some good money for that
0:28:19 of considerable money because of this
0:28:22 gold ornamentation like like palm tree
0:28:25 leaves and so on
0:28:27 and on clearly you cannot use it Medina
0:28:30 because using gold and silver poses
0:28:32 Haram in Islam so whatever it is and
0:28:34 other things
0:28:36 so he trusted them with that put the
0:28:38 things in in suitcases and luggages one
0:28:41 narration claimed that he wrote
0:28:44 exactly what is there and hit it
0:28:46 somewhere in like a small pocket and so
0:28:48 on in the Box
0:28:49 just because it's a precaution uh
0:28:52 another Nation there's nothing to that
0:28:54 and say about the people back home
0:28:55 before he went have a good record what
0:28:57 he has either way it seemed to me I
0:29:00 don't exclude either I don't exclude
0:29:02 either I I would say such a seasoned
0:29:05 business
0:29:08 whom they trust to travel and so on will
0:29:11 be with the god we take us enough to
0:29:13 keep this exact recording of things so
0:29:15 he will death is approaching he is not
0:29:16 going to survive so he wrote this
0:29:18 documentary obviously he's killed their
0:29:20 writing and so on so it's quite polished
0:29:21 and educated this person I'll get his
0:29:23 name shell from the next narration and
0:29:26 hit it in that and the
0:29:29 um
0:29:32 evidence
0:29:35 or commitment because Christian usually
0:29:38 the committed Christians are honest and
0:29:40 and they don't take Liberties the Jews
0:29:43 they may have some people say even if
0:29:45 they are practicing they say ah we can
0:29:47 we can take home we remember we
0:29:49 discussed that issue and how Allah
0:29:51 condemned that area in the Quran but
0:29:53 Christians are not known for that
0:29:54 generally they are not known for that
0:29:56 but anyway this man seems to be not as
0:29:58 that good practice is more of a
0:30:00 businessman with a bit of lose morality
0:30:03 so I said okay we'll bring that to your
0:30:05 family when we back to Medina
0:30:08 and then
0:30:10 they could not resist the temptation to
0:30:12 open one of the of the bags or would
0:30:14 they know where he have the valuable pot
0:30:17 gold the gold ornament the silver pot
0:30:20 and the doctor
0:30:21 sold it for their own up counts I mean
0:30:24 let's close everything
0:30:27 when they delivered
0:30:31 they go to the family said
0:30:35 well what's happening we remember that
0:30:37 he has these and these things or another
0:30:38 narration said they should they've
0:30:40 checked and they found this hidden like
0:30:41 a hidden Pocket they found this this the
0:30:44 certain documents what is what is all in
0:30:47 these bags or these suitcases uh and his
0:30:50 luggage and something is missing
0:30:53 and the the other nations say then
0:30:55 either either by this or by this or by
0:30:58 both it could be very well that make the
0:31:00 check the records so it's very
0:31:02 reasonable to check records
0:31:19 maybe he was sick for a long time and he
0:31:22 decided something to spend on his result
0:31:24 responsible also no no no
0:31:26 the gifted no so she said but this item
0:31:30 is missing based on that
0:31:33 there was a doubt about this this
0:31:36 handing over of this so they went to the
0:31:38 messenger Allah said without these
0:31:40 people because we have this Reasonable
0:31:42 Doubt at least some doubt
0:31:44 that something is missing and these guys
0:31:47 maybe have taken it it may someone it
0:31:50 may be it was stolen from him
0:31:52 but if he has written a record that
0:31:54 would be but I don't know the story of
0:31:56 the thing before this question about it
0:31:57 anyway
0:31:59 we don't know
0:32:01 so the Messenger will ask him to make an
0:32:03 author and they make an oath
0:32:06 and that's it and the matter was settled
0:32:09 now this narration is very Abridged
0:32:11 another narration is more expanded it
0:32:14 says
0:32:16 and the other thing was was the later on
0:32:18 the the pot was found either in sham or
0:32:23 in in in in Mecca or a third narration
0:32:27 claim that himself after embracing Islam
0:32:29 felt guilty and admitted to them so
0:32:31 you're allowed to them that we we we we
0:32:33 we just we broke the trust and we sold
0:32:36 that and put the money in our pocket I
0:32:38 took 500 Dirham and uh
0:32:41 whatever how it was detected the pot was
0:32:45 mostly I think the most reasonable
0:32:46 stories that was found in Mecca because
0:32:48 maybe they proceed to Mecca and thought
0:32:50 Mac has far away and hostile to become
0:32:52 before the conquest of Makkah to Medina
0:32:55 nobody will will come to but somehow
0:32:58 some people saw it in Mecca and reported
0:33:00 to them and then they is investigated a
0:33:03 little bit and they tell out that the
0:33:04 the those who have it in America saying
0:33:06 we bought it from them
0:33:08 so now now the plot is clear so Next
0:33:12 Step they they went to the messenger of
0:33:15 Allah with this now with these facts
0:33:19 no there's not doubt anymore these are
0:33:21 the factory had been determined
0:33:24 that it's sold by away and that so their
0:33:28 testimony and the oath that have
0:33:29 delivered everything they did not take
0:33:30 anything if they have sold it and
0:33:32 there's good reason that uh what what we
0:33:35 have investigated Mecca is through
0:33:37 because the other guys they have no
0:33:39 interest to accuse to to be to to
0:33:42 telling that we bought it from XYZ which
0:33:44 is not mixed with oh yeah we bought them
0:33:47 from these two guys not from from armor
0:33:49 or Zed or from these two
0:33:51 so they went for the messenger Allah
0:33:54 and they said
0:33:56 despite of these are clearly the author
0:33:58 of that has been shown that this is
0:34:00 false oath these two but they asked the
0:34:02 the
0:34:03 people do you have a further Evidence
0:34:06 than just male that it had been found
0:34:09 there
0:34:13 and they say no say are you winning R2
0:34:16 from you are willing to make an oath by
0:34:18 Allah that our our that investigation is
0:34:21 more reliable more trustworthy than the
0:34:23 initial claim of of these two guys they
0:34:26 said you are winning and in one I said
0:34:28 one of them was so it means the story
0:34:30 must be after before the conquest of
0:34:32 Mecca but after immigrated together
0:34:34 because he immigrated in the in the
0:34:37 library time so in that time of living
0:34:40 so it must be after that or even maybe
0:34:43 after the conquest of Mecca we don't
0:34:44 know what's happened anyway it's
0:34:46 relatively late so let's say eighth year
0:34:48 9th seventh year eight year nine year so
0:34:51 it's quite early sorry
0:34:52 and then the Quran
0:34:54 came down to uh to confirm the survive
0:34:58 whatever you think
0:35:00 I'll keep it on record the wisdom of
0:35:02 that has skipped a record
0:35:04 one of it is that
0:35:06 when you previously link that everything
0:35:09 is fine and the witnesses have been they
0:35:11 made even for the Lost witnesses that
0:35:14 you can open a code because this crazy
0:35:15 became final and everything was as it is
0:35:18 until New Evidence came forward to in on
0:35:22 the balance show that these guys have
0:35:23 lied
0:35:24 any any court case which someone lies or
0:35:28 there's a collusion or something like
0:35:29 that even in the Western in the in the
0:35:31 UK law and most laws or another
0:35:33 fundamental effect in the in the
0:35:35 proceeding can be worth it even if it
0:35:37 has confined it was fine and people
0:35:39 distributed the money and initials were
0:35:41 done everything is gone
0:35:43 it can't be still over 10. so this this
0:35:44 point nobody from characteristics
0:35:46 scholar or tabari has stressed so it can
0:35:49 be over 10 but in that is not enough
0:35:51 that that uh that that's proven that we
0:35:53 Allied because the real the truth may be
0:35:56 something else we don't know uh maybe
0:35:58 they have forgotten maybe we don't know
0:36:01 what's exactly so they have to make to
0:36:04 affirm their right by making an oath
0:36:06 they just found out that our result of
0:36:08 Investigation we are convinced that our
0:36:10 result of Investigation is preferable
0:36:14 and stronger than their oath and and
0:36:17 this way
0:36:19 so they have to do the author in the
0:36:22 name of Allah that same way and then
0:36:24 they will be then then the other ones
0:36:27 will be would be found guilty and they
0:36:28 are forced to retain what they have
0:36:30 resolved and and theft it doesn't need
0:36:33 to be like like a such a gold item or
0:36:36 other merchandise could be for example
0:36:37 give you an example a document for
0:36:40 example
0:36:41 someone is traveling with other people
0:36:44 and then if his death is coming and in
0:36:47 that trouble or maybe he married a woman
0:36:49 in another city and did not tell his
0:36:51 family but whatever he said it's not
0:36:52 good not to do that because you see how
0:36:54 it can happen but now he felt guilty
0:36:56 that she may be neglected from
0:36:58 inheritance or should should be accused
0:37:01 so realize the documentation to let let
0:37:03 me know that I am married to a lady so
0:37:05 and so on that's her address so if I if
0:37:08 if I die my companion will bring this
0:37:10 document with them to you so that you
0:37:13 don't take care you don't allocate her
0:37:15 right in health for example and one of
0:37:18 these guys is the relative tool
0:37:20 to maybe a wife of this one who is dying
0:37:23 or to an in-law and you say ah this will
0:37:26 reduce the share of myself my my uh uh
0:37:30 that wife the other wife which related
0:37:32 to me or reduce the share of other
0:37:34 in-laws now let me hide it don't deliver
0:37:36 it
0:37:37 and later on things come to the daylight
0:37:40 that woman come and bring witnesses
0:37:42 there for the marriage and so on and and
0:37:45 it's a it is the expose that they have
0:37:49 done the obviously the the the the
0:37:51 people have to make an author and make
0:37:53 sure that our our
0:37:55 our submissions are more reliable and
0:37:59 more than these people who have hidden
0:38:00 that documents Well it can't be a
0:38:02 document usually people not hide the
0:38:04 document which has no monetary value
0:38:06 that's what's human nature is
0:38:07 unfortunately human greed what it is
0:38:09 everywhere
0:38:11 so so this is the story clarify what's
0:38:13 going on so it is what really all these
0:38:15 great Witnesses Etc in the Ayah is
0:38:17 actually meaning Oaths because really
0:38:20 they are delivering documents or
0:38:21 delivering Goods
0:38:23 so there's just an oath that we
0:38:25 delivered everything and we do not help
0:38:26 withheld anything that we did not take
0:38:28 anything for us or did not hide anything
0:38:30 for our own interest or anyone who is
0:38:33 maybe next of kin who may benefit from
0:38:35 hiding or absolutely clean neutral not
0:38:38 benefiting or harming anybody by any
0:38:41 intention
0:38:42 so that's that's clarify this and also
0:38:44 that point of that there's such a final
0:38:46 ruling can be uh can be uh can be uh uh
0:38:51 or a case can be opened and then the
0:38:53 previous ruling can be declared null and
0:38:54 void is is clearly that's one of the
0:38:57 reasons I think the Ayah is enshrining
0:39:00 that because it seems to be that I came
0:39:01 at the end after all of that was settled
0:39:04 Allah did not interfere in the whole
0:39:06 process until it has completed and then
0:39:09 that that I was able to record that and
0:39:12 give put the system in place until you
0:39:15 almost came unfortunately most most
0:39:17 Focus actually got stuck with with the
0:39:19 imaginary conception the most problem
0:39:22 they had is that a witness could be
0:39:24 unuslim and they try to beat around the
0:39:27 bush and so on but already answered them
0:39:29 very strongly persuasively and even
0:39:31 hasn't bashed them badly for that so it
0:39:34 is a mockery to claim that's two or two
0:39:37 just Witnesses from you meaning from
0:39:39 your own tribe or immoral City and from
0:39:41 the others Allah
0:39:44 from you meaning from the believing
0:39:46 Community for the believer
0:39:48 and the witnesses from outside you is
0:39:50 the one from not from the believer
0:39:52 because the address is to the believer
0:39:53 or you believe is not the address to the
0:39:55 people of Medina or or people of a
0:39:58 village or a tribe and the address of
0:40:00 colonies usually to the believer Ali
0:40:02 says clearly said this is
0:40:04 addressed to the people in the in the
0:40:06 immigration domain like for example will
0:40:09 come to it that this is that you have no
0:40:12 no Allegiance or or or belonging to
0:40:17 those who breastfeed but did not
0:40:19 immigrate so it's clearly addressing the
0:40:21 immigrants though people certain in
0:40:23 Medina the domain of immigration
0:40:27 Islam those who did not immigrate do not
0:40:29 have the all the rights and and the
0:40:31 aggregation
0:40:32 from a text that is addressing those in
0:40:36 the immigration domain only
0:40:38 they don't have any relation with those
0:40:40 until they immigrate except if they ask
0:40:42 for help because they are present
0:40:44 religion then help them all conditions
0:40:46 so and so on so on will come to that
0:40:48 sort of function it's a very important
0:40:49 issue with Allegiance so the address
0:40:52 holds to the believer
0:40:54 and all the believer even if they
0:40:56 outside the Islamic domain even if they
0:40:58 are living under the ruling of copper
0:41:00 by legitimately or even Symphony this is
0:41:03 totally believable to exclude someone
0:41:05 you have to bring at everything
0:41:06 exclusion so this is a mockery that
0:41:09 people do
0:41:10 sometimes in this
0:41:12 so that's it now I actually I mentioned
0:41:15 the story I mentioned there are
0:41:17 essentially the content of the next Ayah
0:41:18 so let's read the next Ayah and this
0:41:21 translation and then put everything
0:41:23 together already already have been put
0:41:26 together so the next I will read thus in
0:41:29 the case some evidence found later on
0:41:32 after the first case was set up and done
0:41:34 that those fellows have lied
0:41:37 either with certainty or high
0:41:39 probability like the case of Tamil with
0:41:42 Daddy and Adib
0:41:45 the next is
0:41:56 yeah
0:41:57 foreign
0:42:13 but if after they should come to mind
0:42:16 that two witnesses have come become
0:42:18 guilty of this very sin uh then two
0:42:21 others from among those who those who
0:42:24 from the whom the former have deprived
0:42:26 of their right shall take their place
0:42:28 and swear by God
0:42:31 Our Testimony is indeed truer than the
0:42:33 testimony of these two and we have not
0:42:36 transgressed the bounds of what is right
0:42:38 or else we may indeed be counted among
0:42:41 the evildoers next translation if it is
0:42:44 discovered that these two are guilty of
0:42:46 this sin then two of those whose rights
0:42:48 have been usedur have a bite better
0:42:50 right to bear witness let them swear to
0:42:53 God our testimony is truer than the
0:42:56 testimony of these two and we have not
0:42:58 committed perjury because that would
0:43:00 make us unjust
0:43:02 so it's not only that that they found
0:43:06 evidence that the initial two have
0:43:09 committed sin or
0:43:12 broke the trust in certain parts of full
0:43:15 of the system of the or say of the Wind
0:43:18 or the requested request no not all
0:43:20 that's not enough by itself is not
0:43:23 enough but this is
0:43:25 enough to open the code in the court
0:43:26 case and then they have to do these
0:43:28 Oaths in the fraud it has to be in a
0:43:30 court case they said the old case has to
0:43:33 be of attend in a court case it cannot
0:43:35 be just outside the court it has to be
0:43:37 done the same the same quarter of
0:43:39 jurisdiction which in which the first
0:43:40 event has happened let's say in the same
0:43:42 one it has to be
0:43:44 it has to as we perform so they have
0:43:47 they have to bring that evidence the
0:43:49 reason like in the case of this that the
0:43:51 people said we have we have uh
0:43:53 accidentally came to our knowledge that
0:43:55 this the spot this valuable pot was
0:43:58 found in Makkah or whoever this was
0:44:01 and uh people were asked casually where
0:44:04 did you get that from so we bought that
0:44:06 from Tami with Daddy and daddy so
0:44:09 completely
0:44:10 unaware about anything otherwise
0:44:13 completely assuming any sentence that
0:44:15 I've dealed they are the owner and they
0:44:17 bought from them completely instantly
0:44:19 nothing nothing indicating that the
0:44:21 people in Mecca are lying or trying to
0:44:23 accuse us
0:44:24 of something which is not true because
0:44:26 it's completely unrelated so this is a
0:44:28 very strong evidence that something
0:44:30 fishy is happily has happened with the
0:44:33 foreign
0:45:01 according to their proportion Etc so
0:45:04 that's all what happened
0:45:06 I'm not sure if they were punished or
0:45:08 not punished but anyway that's it if the
0:45:11 public law or if the Imam has a major
0:45:13 injunction that for such pleasure is
0:45:15 there a certain penalty or certain
0:45:17 lashes or imprisonment maybe
0:45:20 this will be penalty Penal Code actually
0:45:22 is because penalty for perjury is left
0:45:25 to uh to to be enacted by the Surah and
0:45:27 IMAP the details of it but it's sinful
0:45:30 and and it relates to to the public
0:45:35 order which Imam has to step I'm
0:45:37 relating to our discussion the previous
0:45:38 time yes it is
0:45:41 a public issue and also it entails this
0:45:45 uh
0:45:46 contempt of court and another mining of
0:45:48 the cost proceeding which should be
0:45:50 prevented by all means and by all costs
0:45:51 so this is a public order offense in
0:45:53 which the certain penalty can be
0:45:55 prescribed by the law but this is not
0:45:57 our issue here
0:45:58 so that's what happened the thing with
0:46:00 Daddy later on says telling the truth
0:46:03 yes me and Adib
0:46:06 we took the thing and and one narration
0:46:09 I think it's maybe someone trying to
0:46:11 give out the idea um there is some
0:46:14 better image for that that he after
0:46:16 embracing Islam felt guilty
0:46:18 and admitted that I went to see your
0:46:20 land give the people a 500 told him the
0:46:22 other 500
0:46:24 universe and sued him in front of the
0:46:26 Prophet it could be that but the the
0:46:29 story of that it found in in in in in
0:46:31 Mecca and also the good report for him
0:46:34 saying Allah
0:46:37 we broke the trust we stole that item
0:46:40 sold it bring more stronger that that
0:46:44 both of them were with and shamed and so
0:46:46 on possibly but anyway it doesn't make
0:46:47 any difference this or this it's
0:46:50 ultimately the initial quote ruling then
0:46:52 became final and everything was disputed
0:46:55 after has been overturned by opening the
0:46:59 case because the initial one has a
0:47:01 fundamental defect in this case it is a
0:47:03 perjury perjury is always in in every
0:47:06 law system I think for example in the UK
0:47:08 is is enough reason to even even the
0:47:10 guys ruling has become final
0:47:12 and even if this had become final
0:47:14 hundred years ago UK law you can open
0:47:17 the case
0:47:18 and it can be written there's even no no
0:47:21 statutory status of limitation
0:47:23 in this in a case of British of trust
0:47:27 and so on there's no set of Soul
0:47:28 meditation that's the cannot be at least
0:47:31 they have a status of limitation or
0:47:33 something like that but not in the UK
0:47:35 though for South American law
0:47:37 Islamic law
0:47:39 so that's that's roughly this and there
0:47:42 are very many fine points of issues
0:47:44 there which were discussed by tabari I
0:47:47 think they deserve some maybe a writing
0:47:49 but since we are not through the in
0:47:52 involved very much in fine in fact and
0:47:55 so on but because so many issues have
0:47:58 been related to the issues of witnesses
0:48:01 of non-muslim
0:48:02 understandable conception and people
0:48:05 following their imagination and and
0:48:08 projecting things which clearly
0:48:11 contradicts the scripture I think I
0:48:12 remember you remember maybe when when I
0:48:15 mentioned the story about Witnesses long
0:48:16 ago that when when sahabi was found
0:48:19 killed in the Bible I think I had
0:48:21 reported a story
0:48:23 and then His companion came and found
0:48:25 him dead and then they could not they
0:48:28 didn't find any trace of any action they
0:48:30 don't know who was doing it Etc so they
0:48:32 came to the messenger a lot complete
0:48:35 about that that's after the conquest of
0:48:36 Highborn it became under the control of
0:48:38 Islam and there were Jews were living
0:48:40 there and extending the land and so on
0:48:42 with the share 50 50 or something like
0:48:43 that
0:48:45 and um
0:48:47 and uh and they said this is there's
0:48:50 nobody nobody living there except shoes
0:48:53 but
0:48:55 Music
0:49:07 we have broken the Covenant they
0:49:10 answered him back
0:49:14 we swear by Allah we did not do we did
0:49:17 not we should not know who did that
0:49:22 Adam asked them ask of the family of the
0:49:25 deceased
0:49:27 are you willing if you suspect someone
0:49:29 specifically and you know about
0:49:30 something for good reasons for whatever
0:49:32 you with your your investigation or past
0:49:35 interaction with the people
0:49:37 are are you willing to 50 men of you to
0:49:40 stand and make an oath balance called
0:49:41 kasama
0:49:42 uh that this guy is is the one who did
0:49:46 then he will be delivered to you with
0:49:48 with his rope so you can exclude him and
0:49:50 do whatever whatever he wants with him
0:49:52 he said we do not see anybody
0:49:54 we we
0:49:55 speculate maybe this and this but we
0:49:57 didn't see how can we make 50 or Thrift
0:49:59 five men standing up and even this fifty
0:50:02 Orton jail leader kasama was so so
0:50:04 respected that all reports that anyone
0:50:07 doing kasama and relying in it does not
0:50:10 survive one year he will die before so
0:50:12 that was so widespread after all false I
0:50:14 don't know so I spread that kasama was
0:50:16 like like a Holy Grail nobody could
0:50:19 touch
0:50:20 no no way you can do so then I will ask
0:50:22 you at the Jones to make a Hassam and
0:50:25 decide that they don't know what they're
0:50:26 saying these are kofar who don't accept
0:50:28 everything but what my point is that he
0:50:30 tell them then the Jews will do for some
0:50:33 50 of them so 50 of them like 50 Muslims
0:50:35 don't escape understand Prophet said
0:50:37 that's all that they can give you then
0:50:40 because he did not he disliked that the
0:50:43 blood of this Muslim would be shed for a
0:50:45 Love or and and God vain he paid his
0:50:48 dear his blood money from the treasury
0:50:51 just for it to to just for for the let's
0:50:54 say for the uh to a piece that the
0:50:56 people have for the loss and make them
0:50:58 feel happy that's it but that's that's
0:51:00 clear they cannot get more than than uh
0:51:02 the equal number like the other side but
0:51:04 it's not escape from that so that
0:51:06 evidence that this is the witness of
0:51:07 others is equity equally equivalent in
0:51:10 the case of kasama there's no issue of
0:51:11 just or no just so beautiful it's 50 men
0:51:14 50 men or 50 people even that it doesn't
0:51:17 specify I mean
0:51:23 because woman was usually not involved
0:51:26 in any public life or or prevalence also
0:51:29 like barely and if you ask a woman to
0:51:31 come and do herself and say I was never
0:51:33 on fire but you are the one going back
0:51:34 up for the lab in the business oh how
0:51:36 can I watch this for anything that's
0:51:38 silly but but even that
0:51:40 so that's that's very that's very that's
0:51:43 very clear that this this misconception
0:51:45 is so deep that the people just read
0:51:47 this Hadith and read the eye of the
0:51:48 Quran with closed eyes they are not
0:51:50 opening their eyes
0:51:51 unfortunately but we have to organize
0:51:53 because we have to open this those who
0:51:55 contain the habit and then ultimately
0:51:58 they continue with them quoting this
0:52:00 companion this companion the sahabi this
0:52:02 one said that he said as only accept the
0:52:05 witnesses of non-muslim only in on in
0:52:08 travel only in Russia
0:52:10 and who said that's only in trouble the
0:52:13 Ayah said in that case that's that's the
0:52:14 case but what's about the other cases if
0:52:17 it is there it may be another one also
0:52:18 so for Miss ayak there's no no exclusion
0:52:22 if Allah wanted to exclude they say
0:52:23 otherwise don't accept
0:52:25 witness for many non-muslims no no
0:52:28 that's it that says clearly adding
0:52:30 things from their imagination and
0:52:32 subscribing things by by just by desire
0:52:34 not by really giving the text it's due
0:52:36 respect
0:52:38 so that's that's that's it and and uh in
0:52:41 a nutshell uh and uh and the the
0:52:45 probably discussed very fine linguistic
0:52:47 issues and so on which is an intriguing
0:52:49 and so that is a matter of really more
0:52:51 detergent but this is the general
0:52:52 picture clearly the witnesses of of of
0:52:55 kaffir is is acceptable no problem maybe
0:52:59 you notice um some people may not desire
0:53:01 it because usually the Muslim Community
0:53:03 and the others living in separation
0:53:05 generally so
0:53:07 practically there will be little
0:53:09 interaction except like in this
0:53:10 situation or in businesses and so on but
0:53:13 this is not the case forever for example
0:53:15 with advancing of time
0:53:17 uh the the the
0:53:19 Muslims have been visiting uh people
0:53:22 with a book doctors and and pharmacists
0:53:25 because they are usually they were they
0:53:26 were more skilled in these areas for
0:53:27 centuries and vice versa and there will
0:53:31 be interaction there would be issues
0:53:32 with Witnesses and so on and there's no
0:53:34 reason to think that the witnesses is is
0:53:36 this acceptable than anybody else
0:53:39 and uh in in modern times for example
0:53:42 something like that may happen then you
0:53:44 have local lawyers who are the very
0:53:46 reliable trustworthy what they call
0:53:48 things and communicated but still if
0:53:51 you're doubting the lawyer that he did
0:53:52 something for improval which happens
0:53:54 also by the way lawyers also not
0:53:56 infallible there have been cases of
0:53:59 British of transform lawyers if you have
0:54:01 some doubt they will be forced to make
0:54:03 an oath and if later evidence come
0:54:05 forward they will be forced obviously
0:54:07 and and punished for perjury according
0:54:09 to the the valid Public Law Etc
0:54:12 so that's a that's a that's all these
0:54:15 these uh they're just just whispering in
0:54:18 someone's ear assuming things which are
0:54:21 based on such imaginary concept
0:54:25 uh yeah lack of Alexandria of women
0:54:27 Witnesses because of the is we discussed
0:54:31 which is not true
0:54:32 Decemberists thing told a few that say
0:54:34 oh the criminal issues for example look
0:54:36 at that
0:54:38 condemnation husband and wife were using
0:54:40 his wife adultery and then his his
0:54:42 witness is actually his oath he has to
0:54:45 make thought of that that he's doing the
0:54:47 truth and the second and the fifth one
0:54:48 is that Allah uh care should be upon him
0:54:52 with his lying and she can counteract
0:54:54 with that with eighth also and no with
0:54:56 four authors so one against one so how
0:54:58 come the two the the they claim that
0:55:00 universally witness of a woman is the
0:55:02 half of a manner or something like this
0:55:04 is all it's just uh what they call
0:55:07 psychological projection it has nothing
0:55:09 to do with the text the text is clear
0:55:10 and the textures is not even a shahada
0:55:13 it's not it's the Shad the the comment
0:55:16 of that it's written committed the
0:55:18 writing and in addition
0:55:19 Witnesses are called in Estes
0:55:23 called in
0:55:24 and that is called in
0:55:27 as we said two men or one man and two
0:55:30 women
0:55:31 and the question is reason why the two
0:55:34 women and said because if one of the
0:55:36 does not remember then the other one
0:55:39 will remind here which is establishing
0:55:41 two principles one principle is that
0:55:43 that even Witnesses could remind each
0:55:46 other and support each other that's not
0:55:47 a problem but we do it best on what on a
0:55:50 written document already so just no I
0:55:53 don't remember correctly that was said
0:55:55 secondly the reason was it was only um a
0:56:00 woman for one man is very simple because
0:56:02 either the the the female memory
0:56:07 concerning abstract things like a
0:56:08 debtors something abstract you're not
0:56:10 witnessing someone being overrun by a
0:56:13 car or a wall collapsing on someone
0:56:15 something you see visible that's very
0:56:17 visible Witnesses for women they tend to
0:56:19 be better invisible Witnesses than than
0:56:21 men and they notice things visually
0:56:24 especially dressed and so on better than
0:56:26 men we know that you can you can go in
0:56:28 any in any wedding and so on and you
0:56:30 will notice after after the wedding that
0:56:33 your wife will tell you for example that
0:56:35 have you seen this this man or this
0:56:37 woman dressed like this and this and who
0:56:39 did not notice anything they have they
0:56:41 have an eye for that but abstract things
0:56:43 like a written document and so on
0:56:44 especially but is that is that genuinely
0:56:47 because of the brain structure of Life
0:56:49 brain or it is because of the society
0:56:51 situation that they were barely involved
0:56:52 in businesses to be settled you have to
0:56:55 be analyz but
0:56:56 let's say it is so Wiki but so that's
0:56:59 only for Witnesses in uh for Witnesses
0:57:03 uh invoked and invited to comment that's
0:57:08 it the next of the ISA well but if it is
0:57:12 if you are dealing with the
0:57:13 transactional with goods and services
0:57:15 being exchanged there's no debt or
0:57:17 something like that then and you are
0:57:20 doing buying and selling right away
0:57:21 immediately hand in hand but they call
0:57:26 it
0:57:27 um
0:57:28 immediate cash transaction immediately
0:57:30 immediate transaction then it's enough
0:57:32 to say ah anyone presents witness that
0:57:35 we have exchange of something like that
0:57:37 and nowadays the people have the receipt
0:57:39 of that Hill which is replace that
0:57:41 anyway so it's enough of all the major
0:57:44 transactions would be usually witnessing
0:57:46 but more more thoroughly than that and
0:57:48 they say uh does not say men or women or
0:57:52 two or ten just just help just have some
0:57:55 witnesses
0:57:56 for this in addition to the fact that it
0:57:59 has been exchanged have we done everyone
0:58:00 has here but there may be some defect
0:58:02 later or something so then your such
0:58:05 weakness will be good due to water safer
0:58:07 nowadays the still receipt or other
0:58:09 receipts are but are sufficient instead
0:58:11 of that so you see uh even the next part
0:58:15 of the eye this dimension of two men
0:58:17 order or one man and two women or
0:58:19 another we just actually do General
0:58:22 and there's no reason to to
0:58:24 get this at the one specific for the
0:58:27 specific case
0:58:28 on on a dead instrument which has to be
0:58:30 commented the writing with this specific
0:58:32 injunction to make it Universal in
0:58:34 general
0:58:35 so they go to the specific and make it
0:58:38 by players general which is faulty
0:58:40 although the same I the next one does
0:58:42 not specify anything like that
0:58:48 so so this is just uh give us some
0:58:50 benefit also in hotel which over
0:58:52 non-muslims and Muslims for the
0:58:53 witnesses and also men and women has
0:58:55 been dispatched in other eyes but
0:58:58 as that
0:59:01 and still majority of Scholars choose
0:59:03 just to close their eyes while reading
0:59:04 that all this was some people get this
0:59:07 is
0:59:07 only in this case but imagine and I in
0:59:11 the Quran with such sophistication
0:59:12 because the structure of the island
0:59:14 linguistical is one of the most
0:59:15 sophisticated in the Quran
0:59:17 that needs really
0:59:19 marshaling the the battery of Arabic
0:59:22 grammar and so on to analyze certain
0:59:24 terms like potable he did considerable
0:59:27 but this is only for the first for the
0:59:29 very picky specialist of the Arabic
0:59:31 language
0:59:33 it says and it is sometimes so it is not
0:59:37 as multiple meaning and difficult to
0:59:39 envisage like the Aya and sorted
0:59:44 Witchcraft and things like that
0:59:47 but it is difficult to get it really
0:59:50 expanded in such a way that or in fact
0:59:53 luckily we have here obviously a case a
0:59:56 case which we can analyze and compare
0:59:58 with the eye and then give us a guidance
1:00:00 although it's not necessary but probably
1:00:02 made most of the analysis without even
1:00:04 referring to these narratives about
1:00:05 Tamir daddy and his uh brother or
1:00:09 whatever it is
1:00:10 succeed in doing all of that without it
1:00:13 only at the antibody stores at the far
1:00:16 end he did not need that just from the
1:00:19 language the same with hardwood models
1:00:21 we don't have a actual case to compare
1:00:23 so it remains dark and this is I think
1:00:26 deliberate in the Quran to keep the
1:00:27 issue of wood of of Witchcraft and so on
1:00:30 as dark as possible because it is a
1:00:33 destination of which God and not to get
1:00:35 the people into into a complex research
1:00:39 of of all these things related to what
1:00:42 is really what is this and what which
1:00:44 one it is the one who type cover which
1:00:46 one and how is the effect on on on
1:00:49 husband and wife so that it can be
1:00:51 separated by Sir which is very condemned
1:00:53 obviously in the Quran that's the
1:00:54 maximum cell but this case is given as
1:00:57 the maximum they can achieve so all
1:00:59 these stories that whether someone has
1:01:00 been butched and turned into a donkey is
1:01:02 just nonsense that's nothing that's just
1:01:05 a suggested
1:01:06 Imagination Running white but that that
1:01:09 eye is very dark in that suspect this IO
1:01:12 is very complex in the linguistic
1:01:13 structure in that respect needs some
1:01:16 some hard work relatively hard work and
1:01:19 a few eyes in the Quran like that but
1:01:21 then ultimately when you flesh them out
1:01:23 and analyze
1:01:25 you'll get an enormous amount of
1:01:27 information and injunction which maybe
1:01:29 even the classical scholar did not
1:01:31 notice like the issue of attaining a
1:01:33 court rolling which has become final Etc
1:01:35 it is some people think there's nowhere
1:01:37 we're not here in the Quran in front of
1:01:39 you but you do not see it you have to
1:01:41 dig deeper
1:01:42 you have to do the double of the Quran
1:01:46 lies it more thoroughly than that and
1:01:48 also things like that especially if that
1:01:50 level of complex complexity is also on
1:01:53 the evidence of the of the divine nature
1:01:56 of the column because no way uh a
1:01:58 Shepherd who did a bit for business
1:02:00 transaction in Mecca who is illiterate
1:02:02 no way he will get to all these
1:02:03 sophisticated things and phrase things
1:02:05 such as sophisticated way
1:02:07 how eloquently may be but this all these
1:02:10 legalistic principles in that in that
1:02:12 with this in such a uh how many lines
1:02:16 are those five lines
1:02:18 and the number of words with count them
1:02:20 which are usually expanded in low books
1:02:23 for example written in in tens and
1:02:25 hundreds of pages
1:02:27 all hidden there you just need to dig it
1:02:29 out just can't can't be that that uh
1:02:32 despite where you definitely was a
1:02:35 qualified man an intelligent but it's
1:02:37 not is it not within it was in the reach
1:02:39 not even the issue of the people of
1:02:40 Arabia not even the ratio of the
1:02:42 companies after him they struggle to
1:02:43 understand what's going on and reduce
1:02:45 Rose from that
1:02:47 that's that's one of the evidences so
1:02:48 well the rest of the Quran
1:02:50 straightforward symbolism can't be from
1:02:52 anybody maybe but this one
1:02:55 and so on and these things cannot be and
1:02:58 more will come in a few moments
1:02:59 inshallah
1:03:03 so then the commenting of the whole
1:03:05 story
1:03:20 so translate
1:03:22 thus it would be more likely that people
1:03:25 will offer testimony in accordance with
1:03:27 the truth or else they will have cause
1:03:29 to fear that their Oaths will be refuted
1:03:32 by the elves of others be then conscious
1:03:35 of God and hearken unto him for God does
1:03:38 not bestow his guidance upon iniquities
1:03:40 folk his translation it will be more
1:03:43 likely that people will offer the truth
1:03:45 in their testimony because because they
1:03:47 will be afraid that others might refute
1:03:50 their Oaths remain mindful of God and
1:03:53 listen God does not guide those who are
1:03:55 defiantly disobedient so it's very clear
1:03:57 this this procedure which looks a little
1:04:00 bit complex with all supported and also
1:04:03 the other side Force towards everyone's
1:04:05 supposed to so for us to do the
1:04:07 necessary also and so on and and
1:04:09 Confirmation is that this is more likely
1:04:12 to bring
1:04:13 that the people will bring witnesses as
1:04:15 it should be and or they would be afraid
1:04:18 that their witnesses will be rejected
1:04:19 and they would be scandalized as Earth
1:04:21 breaker or scandalized as perjurious
1:04:24 people and so on with these safeguards
1:04:26 everyone will be alert listen
1:04:28 you will be I don't think that if you
1:04:31 lie today and they get a get away in the
1:04:33 court in the court and get a final
1:04:35 ruling don't think the finality of the
1:04:37 ruling will save you the moment some
1:04:40 evidence come elsewhere that case will
1:04:42 be will be stuck down to zero because it
1:04:44 was null and void of initial as it has
1:04:47 never been so finality don't fool
1:04:50 yourself about penalty that's finality
1:04:51 can be overtained I gave an example and
1:04:54 I came like as the famous so what is the
1:04:56 Birmingham six over the the famous story
1:04:58 it was you which which was one of the
1:05:01 dark spots in British uh criminal
1:05:04 history which will accuse the bombing
1:05:06 and say yeah I think it's the word
1:05:08 yeah Birmingham six and so on uh clearly
1:05:11 the all the evidences now showed that
1:05:14 the the Midland uh West Midland Police
1:05:17 have committed perjury and Light
1:05:20 nobody was punished really as it should
1:05:23 be unfortunately because the regime
1:05:24 itself is colluding behind that an evil
1:05:26 but the individual of that ultimately
1:05:29 it became final even the House of Lords
1:05:32 but later on because of pressure of evil
1:05:34 investigating and so on the the in in in
1:05:37 the UK although unfortunately such
1:05:40 things had to be an opening should be
1:05:42 done by the Home Secretary it cannot be
1:05:44 done by anyone but this is a shortcoming
1:05:46 of the of the UK
1:05:48 a bad shortcoming anyone who have
1:05:51 there's necessary evidence can have an
1:05:54 interest in that either is a party or in
1:05:56 that case because it's a is a criminal
1:05:58 case of the public terrorism
1:06:00 allegitalism act everyone in the public
1:06:03 is is also a party he could anyone could
1:06:06 have applied to the court and asked to
1:06:07 open the case instead of fighting with
1:06:10 the home office for several years while
1:06:12 people were rotting and in jail for that
1:06:14 time but this is also bad access
1:06:16 man-made law is like that that's here no
1:06:19 anyone who is really having interest or
1:06:21 relation here obviously inheritance only
1:06:23 the hairs and the relative I mean
1:06:25 there's anybody else is not involved and
1:06:28 normally he will not uh do uh anything
1:06:31 in that direction maybe someone find
1:06:33 that accident likes their people finding
1:06:34 by accident that the tamim and daddy did
1:06:37 sell that that uh valuable pot
1:06:41 and and they inform the family or
1:06:43 something like that but then the family
1:06:44 has to do the one of the parties were
1:06:46 interested party then the case will open
1:06:49 and it will be over 10 based on the new
1:06:51 evidences and Witnesses
1:06:54 unfortunately even here in the UK
1:06:56 despite of all this grudging back and
1:06:57 forth back and forth back and forth that
1:06:59 was as far as I remember the West uh the
1:07:02 the West Midland the police got away
1:07:05 nobody got really punished or fired or
1:07:07 something because of that which is a
1:07:09 very grave shot coming but anyway that's
1:07:11 it's nothing this is not an Islamic
1:07:13 domain no we can't account him by
1:07:15 Islamic law
1:07:16 so with these safeguards and the
1:07:20 possibility of attending lawyers but in
1:07:22 the forward process with the proper
1:07:23 Witnesses and so on then everyone will
1:07:26 be concerned hopefully
1:07:28 let's tell people providing what they
1:07:31 are they're still violating
1:07:34 but this is more likely to reduce the
1:07:37 number of such incidents in which things
1:07:41 did we attend
1:07:44 the final appeal is to your own
1:07:46 Consciousness to remember and be
1:07:48 conscious
1:07:50 beware of Allah and listen to The
1:07:53 Commandments
1:07:54 Allah does not guide the rebellious
1:07:56 people but don't go because these
1:08:00 Witnesses under oath there isism being
1:08:03 being doing as a perjury knowingly that
1:08:06 you are lying is a major sin well
1:08:08 possibly bordering uncover Allah does
1:08:10 not to guide the the uh the rebellious
1:08:13 people the fasepin the what's the letter
1:08:16 how do you translate
1:08:18 what's the manifestly rebellious or the
1:08:21 how did the last translation translates
1:08:23 the word faster P for a second
1:08:25 Music
1:08:27 definitely disobedient to know that when
1:08:29 they buy their device yeah
1:08:33 so or rebellious sorry or stubbornly
1:08:36 disobedient
1:08:39 you know for example when you uh do just
1:08:42 the
1:08:43 um
1:08:44 Almighty one of the five you know
1:08:46 classical women classical invention you
1:08:48 mentioned previously that it's
1:08:50 invariably linked to disbelief
1:08:53 most of the time but in some places it
1:08:57 may be but if you scan everywhere it's
1:08:59 usually okay because Adam is never the
1:09:04 applying cells ASAP never ever
1:09:08 disobeyed foreign
1:09:25 or something like that and this this
1:09:28 moment of weakness he he thought that
1:09:31 that's it now I will I will overcome
1:09:34 this
1:09:39 is very very thoughtful and very very
1:09:42 very very very determined and very
1:09:44 rebellious
1:09:45 rejecting the command
1:09:49 so if you're taking the Quran
1:09:51 but in other places
1:09:57 it needs to be analyzed but generally
1:10:00 your Main Street Fighter you should have
1:10:03 the alarm built
1:10:04 the buildings then you open your eyes
1:10:07 wide under analyze further let's say
1:10:10 like as a general rule
1:10:12 yeah
1:10:14 and then immediately go through
1:10:16 omokuyama in another issue is related to
1:10:19 the beginning of this world I remember
1:10:20 the beginning not in the beginning it
1:10:22 was no it's a beginning that was
1:10:23 actually a discussion about Teresa but
1:10:26 it's not a disorder we didn't have
1:10:27 anything out
1:10:29 so
1:10:30 Allah does not guide the rebellious
1:10:32 people especially
1:10:34 this whole situation or the that will
1:10:36 come in the day of judgment apparent but
1:10:39 the major issue with blood will be
1:10:41 discussed Allah
1:10:46 so translate this one generally
1:10:50 this is General warning for all
1:10:52 transgression and shortcomings of people
1:10:54 in Dunya and near me all this will be
1:10:57 questioned
1:10:59 on the day when God shall assemble all
1:11:01 the apostles and shall ask what response
1:11:05 did you receive they will answer we have
1:11:08 no knowledge verily it is thou alone who
1:11:11 fully noticed all the things that are
1:11:13 beyond the reach of a creative being's
1:11:15 perception next translation on the day
1:11:18 when God assembles all the messengers
1:11:20 and asks what response did you receive I
1:11:24 will answer we have no knowledge you
1:11:26 alone know the things that cannot be
1:11:28 seen
1:11:29 yeah because even if they have some
1:11:32 believer there's no guarantee that all
1:11:34 these would pretend to believe a True
1:11:36 Believer
1:11:37 we have discussed that and we discussed
1:11:39 the various ayas about more African
1:11:41 especially in Turbo will have massive
1:11:43 discussion of that
1:11:44 which Islam on the face of these guys
1:11:46 there's those so-called salafi and even
1:11:48 the people of Sunnah claim also have all
1:11:50 of the models
1:11:57 but this will come to that issue
1:12:00 inshallah morphology
1:12:02 so even in that they can say no some
1:12:05 some people some people even they're
1:12:07 available
1:12:10 on the Mind fountain
1:12:13 I see people I know them and they know
1:12:15 me and they approach
1:12:16 and when they're about to
1:12:18 get to drink from the fountain obviously
1:12:21 they're done
1:12:22 doing that with them deliberately an
1:12:25 angel comes they must stop them and
1:12:26 pulls them with harshness and get get
1:12:29 out from here go back or be possibly
1:12:31 beating them with with the with the with
1:12:34 the fire whips
1:12:35 on the same my Lord my God this is my my
1:12:38 companion so everyone says my my little
1:12:42 companions also say hey because they're
1:12:44 already used for your kids my son my my
1:12:47 son my son let things like that what's
1:12:49 happening and then she said don't worry
1:12:51 you don't know what they have done after
1:12:53 you let's manage them
1:12:55 they were going backwards leaving that
1:12:58 what you have instructed to them yeah
1:13:00 I said where they are taking lips in for
1:13:01 the head fired then I say it I'm
1:13:03 seriously I will say
1:13:05 destruction down to those who change
1:13:08 after that what I have left them so
1:13:12 they don't know the messenger was really
1:13:14 the realest ones and later they canceled
1:13:16 I know this one I know this one but
1:13:17 that's it but the nation of Southern
1:13:19 Motel no idea
1:13:21 we don't know but you know all things
1:13:23 what's what's usually called hidden
1:13:24 which is not accessible to the creation
1:13:27 and then the conclusion the third what
1:13:30 will be the questioning for Israel
1:13:33 is
1:13:42 foreign
1:14:09 remember the blessing which I bestowed
1:14:12 upon thee and thy mother how I
1:14:14 strengthen thee with holy inspiration so
1:14:16 that thou could speak unto men in my in
1:14:19 thy cradle and as a grown man and how I
1:14:21 imparted upon the Revelation and wisdom
1:14:24 including the Torah and the gospel and
1:14:27 how by my leave thou this create out of
1:14:29 clay as it were the shape of thy
1:14:32 followers Destiny and this breathe unto
1:14:36 into it so that it may become by my
1:14:39 leave their Destiny and how thou didst
1:14:42 heal the Blind and the leper by my leave
1:14:45 and how thou didst raise the dead by my
1:14:49 leave and how I prevented the children
1:14:51 of Israel from harming thee without
1:14:54 chemist unto them with all the evidence
1:14:57 all evidence of the truth
1:14:58 and when those of them who are bent on
1:15:01 denying the truth was saying this is
1:15:03 clearly nothing but deception let's
1:15:05 translation
1:15:06 God will say Jesus Son of Mary remember
1:15:08 the grace which I bestowed upon you and
1:15:11 your mother how I strengthen you with
1:15:13 this holy spirit so you could speak from
1:15:15 your cradle and as a grown man
1:15:18 remember when I taught you the book The
1:15:20 Wisdom the Torah and the gospel remember
1:15:23 when with my permission you fasten
1:15:26 fashioned the shape of a bird out of
1:15:28 clay breathed into it and it became with
1:15:30 my permission a bird
1:15:32 remember when with my permission you
1:15:34 healed a blind person and the leper when
1:15:37 by my permission you bought them dead
1:15:39 back to life remember when I kept the
1:15:42 children of Israel from harming you when
1:15:44 you came to them with all the evidence
1:15:46 of the truth and when those of them who
1:15:48 are bent or denying the truth said this
1:15:50 is clearly nothing but deception okay
1:15:53 yes God with my best here
1:15:56 first of all the association say from in
1:15:58 the cradle and this grown man actually
1:16:03 is an old man like 60 and above
1:16:06 man
1:16:16 they saw they'll say hold on up to 15
1:16:19 years
1:16:21 and then it becomes sharp and then
1:16:24 becomes a man full man Etc and then a
1:16:28 man is a physical fiction of Ages 40 and
1:16:32 then it goes downhill and then God is
1:16:33 50. so that's a hint
1:16:36 that
1:16:38 either
1:16:40 the usual narratives we have that that
1:16:43 he was ascending and so on and born in I
1:16:45 think that's the strongest point of view
1:16:47 that he was ascended to Heaven uh when
1:16:50 him was 33 years or 27 or something
1:16:52 that's most likely but that's refuted by
1:16:55 many evidence even in their scripture
1:16:56 and the associated literature it's
1:16:59 almost certainly the the
1:17:02 birth of Christ is at least at least 10
1:17:06 15 years before the the year zero so
1:17:10 it's not in the year zero
1:17:12 almost set the end of the year zero no
1:17:14 certainly we can say because if he was
1:17:17 ascended in 27 Andrew is 50 how much did
1:17:20 we have to add to that that's three
1:17:21 total 23 so maybe 20 years before 23 or
1:17:25 something like that and also there's a
1:17:26 hint actually thinking look when he said
1:17:29 he was talking about Abraham Ibrahim say
1:17:31 how can this guy talks as if he met
1:17:34 Abraham hmm
1:17:36 and he's he's not even 50 or he's 50.
1:17:39 that's the beginning of his message so
1:17:40 this again that's confirmed in a foot in
1:17:43 a in a side note this one a correction
1:17:46 and secondly
1:17:48 one of the features of of Lisa that he
1:17:52 has a special Grace on him and his
1:17:53 mother mother his mother is very special
1:17:55 and very very elected and he she's dealt
1:17:57 with in another Surah but he was
1:17:59 supported with the Holy Spirit
1:18:01 all prophets received the Holy Spirit as
1:18:03 a medium of of of
1:18:05 uh of communication with Allah this is
1:18:08 another name for jibril
1:18:11 although yeah I don't think if the
1:18:14 people were scriptural equate the Holy
1:18:16 Spirit or not they don't have they have
1:18:18 this concept but it's clear the Quran
1:18:21 clarified that the holy spirit is jibril
1:18:23 he was the Holy Spirit was a joint to
1:18:27 him like like a permanent companion
1:18:30 which is not happening to any prophets
1:18:32 before even Muhammad Assam did not get
1:18:33 your viewers he has visited for him and
1:18:36 one time he asked Gabriel why don't you
1:18:38 visit us more than that and I can say oh
1:18:40 man we don't come down only with the
1:18:42 command of Our Lord we are not coming at
1:18:44 Liberty we come when we order we are all
1:18:47 the not to go we not come
1:18:49 but in the case of Israel he was like a
1:18:52 permanent companion although we have
1:18:53 some people before that a young man
1:18:56 called Toby I think Toby in the book I
1:18:57 don't think it's a book who was supposed
1:19:00 to have Rafael Islam as His companion
1:19:04 for some time on Earth
1:19:06 I didn't read the story of this but the
1:19:08 Intriguing story so this this could
1:19:11 could be even for someone who's like
1:19:12 tobia nobody here with Toby or tobia
1:19:14 Allah what is this man young man not
1:19:18 even a prophet maybe other Prophet I
1:19:19 should read that maybe maybe I
1:19:21 neglectedly that is I think it's in the
1:19:23 Apocrypha it's not in the in the main
1:19:24 Bible
1:19:28 the medium of of Revelation as being
1:19:32 allocated to him like a companion so I
1:19:35 supported to his side supporting
1:19:37 continuously it's not the civilization
1:19:40 comes anything and one about that one
1:19:42 sign of this support is that he was able
1:19:44 to speak and then the Cradle uh this
1:19:47 needs really
1:19:48 militant with a physical Force
1:19:56 the writing scripture wisdom
1:20:00 and the Torah and the gospel Torah is
1:20:02 obviously the teaching which comes
1:20:03 essentially he was taught the the Torah
1:20:06 which was in the tablets not the five
1:20:09 books they call Torah by extension
1:20:11 because there's no guarantee that what
1:20:14 in their hand is really what it
1:20:15 established or what have been given to
1:20:17 Musa a special teaching he was aware
1:20:20 about that until the pure form
1:20:23 but unfortunately that was not recorded
1:20:25 or kept and so on because of the events
1:20:27 which are developed and then in June is
1:20:29 that that's the name that the word in
1:20:30 jail is actually
1:20:32 used for the Christianity as like a
1:20:34 bigger favor but here meant is it that a
1:20:37 very special Revelation to ISA and his
1:20:39 injunction their collection the
1:20:41 collection of their his sayings should
1:20:42 be the injeel should be the good news is
1:20:45 just and it's very well possible that it
1:20:48 even at that time the Jews were using
1:20:50 Evangelion or something like that from
1:20:52 Greek because they were in that Society
1:20:55 was for two centuries and very
1:20:58 influenced by Greek culture and under
1:21:00 foreign
1:21:03 something like that as an adoption from
1:21:06 from the from the Greek language
1:21:09 although maybe he also he was able to
1:21:11 speak Greek we don't know definitely he
1:21:13 was speaking Aramaic
1:21:16 foreign
1:21:20 language of the people in Palestine
1:21:22 especially in North Palestine because
1:21:24 that Hebrew the the classical Hebrew was
1:21:28 really distinctive to The Scholar so
1:21:30 it's like fossa where the common
1:21:31 language or the Arabic
1:21:35 so I taught all of that
1:21:37 we don't need to be taught by anybody
1:21:39 else I taught you directly or maybe
1:21:41 through the Holy Spirit
1:21:42 and then now something civilizing come
1:21:45 which is not in the scripture except in
1:21:47 some popular
1:21:48 mentioned that as next one is
1:22:01 shape of a bed
1:22:04 with my permission I permitted you to do
1:22:06 that and then you blow in it
1:22:08 and then
1:22:10 it turned into a real bet
1:22:12 now there's nowhere in the comment for
1:22:16 scripture
1:22:18 which were the four gospels we have nor
1:22:21 in the writing of Paul but anyway Paul
1:22:24 is not reliable is just living in a
1:22:25 dream world he's talking about the
1:22:27 meeting Christ in the spirit and the
1:22:30 living
1:22:32 if he's lying or telling the truth in
1:22:34 another world not in the real world
1:22:36 completely almost completely the only
1:22:38 thing which and he mentioned barely
1:22:40 anything of the Life of Christ acceptor
1:22:42 so-called crucifixion and more than
1:22:43 Cruces the resurrection that's what they
1:22:46 concerned him nothing else and the
1:22:48 meaning of that and the meaning of the
1:22:50 sacrifice so he's completely in the
1:22:52 metaphysical any other details any other
1:22:55 stories of importance any Reviving of it
1:22:57 I don't think he mentioned even if I
1:22:59 think that that's he didn't but all
1:23:00 about that
1:23:01 but the other
1:23:03 minor
1:23:05 scripture and so on and and Epistles and
1:23:07 things like that they don't mention
1:23:09 except some Apocrypha claimed that he
1:23:11 was doing that with the with the shape
1:23:13 of the bed when he was a child like
1:23:15 something like a child play
1:23:17 so all what remained in the memory of
1:23:19 the people is that that I said but here
1:23:22 it is mentioned ahead of the major
1:23:23 Miracles he was doing in the time of his
1:23:26 message
1:23:27 not as a child play so that that piece
1:23:30 of information was misplaced reported
1:23:33 back into his Youth and making azerbilic
1:23:36 like like and also the the these infancy
1:23:39 gospels various impossible
1:23:41 rejected by the right whistle because it
1:23:44 contains nonsensical things which nobody
1:23:46 can tolerated
1:23:48 uh the they mentioned this issue with
1:23:50 the bed but it's more like a plague not
1:23:52 not as an evidence for money soil so it
1:23:56 has been misplaced into his youth maybe
1:23:59 he done in his youth but in his youth
1:24:01 there's no all evidences that he was not
1:24:04 was living in a private life just
1:24:07 surprised he's a prophet but not a
1:24:08 messenger yet he is profit from his
1:24:10 birth because he said clearly
1:24:14 from the best that's not no doubt about
1:24:17 that but he was
1:24:19 not carrying any message yet I'm not
1:24:21 addressing anybody until the day he
1:24:23 started the message
1:24:25 we always start the message which is by
1:24:27 by him as a mature man in his 40 most
1:24:30 likely not as the the funny story is
1:24:32 over 30 and so on and all these dancers
1:24:34 that's all nonsensical
1:24:36 that I testified with the white God
1:24:39 so what happened to that
1:24:42 obviously the the the
1:24:44 some Christians said oh he hit him he
1:24:47 took a trunk he got it from Apocrypha
1:24:49 that's all first will say this is not
1:24:50 that I'm a gospel so it can't be true uh
1:24:52 it's actually in some apocalypse he got
1:24:54 the trunk that is the usual way he
1:24:56 misplaced it okay fine
1:24:59 leave that aside see that or instead of
1:25:03 saying maybe we got a torso wrong if
1:25:05 that's a revelation then that's what
1:25:07 that book ever had they mentioned there
1:25:08 but they put it in the wrong times three
1:25:10 huh
1:25:12 that this is the moral well-balanced
1:25:14 point of view is that for example the
1:25:15 so-called famous the famous Christmas
1:25:18 Story the best story in Bethlehem and so
1:25:20 on I think all recession I want all the
1:25:22 historic evidences and all
1:25:24 cross-referencing of the events at that
1:25:26 time which make any sense
1:25:29 shows that the whole story is fabricated
1:25:32 that that that they they they because
1:25:36 it's clear that all his life was in
1:25:38 Galilee how come that he went to
1:25:40 Bethlehem ah because uh allegedly his
1:25:43 adoptive father it's not even his
1:25:45 physical father because he's supposed to
1:25:47 be a Son of God or supposed to be
1:25:49 without a human father okay was ordered
1:25:52 like all people with other than the
1:25:54 Caesar and the Roman to everyone to go
1:25:56 to his original City for taxation
1:26:02 about the money you registered in the
1:26:05 place we are living
1:26:07 nobody in his right mind basically the
1:26:09 Roman Empire who is not for very
1:26:12 exacting and streamlined Administration
1:26:15 that's the name of their Mastery their
1:26:16 Master organization the Greek word
1:26:18 master of philosophy and thoughts and
1:26:20 music and things not only the master of
1:26:22 parable and strong Administration they
1:26:24 will not let up or hold by the people
1:26:26 going across Palestine back and forth
1:26:28 clouding the streets so to go through
1:26:30 their own ancestor cities this is
1:26:33 completely nonsensical nobody believes
1:26:35 distances but that's what what the story
1:26:37 you find in the gospel
1:26:40 so that he is descending from David but
1:26:43 this is he said the alleged descending
1:26:46 they will throw his adopting father is
1:26:48 irrelevant because this is only the
1:26:50 adopted father so he's not the center of
1:26:51 Labor and oh there's no clear evidence
1:26:54 that his mother is going to descending
1:26:56 from David most likely she's a she's
1:26:58 from Ireland
1:26:59 so
1:27:01 so if you got it so that's much more for
1:27:04 such a fundamental point a new point of
1:27:05 view that is the Messiah because of the
1:27:07 one coming from the seed of David and
1:27:09 them inside the king Messiah then you
1:27:11 got that completely wrong and this can
1:27:14 be easily refuted that's the one of the
1:27:16 things which has to be refuted nobody of
1:27:18 this series in scholarship accept that
1:27:20 the story of Christmas Story
1:27:24 so you are getting things much more
1:27:26 longer than that so why is not the also
1:27:28 this that you got a drunk and as you had
1:27:31 missed in this scripture why it is
1:27:32 missed we don't know meaning that the
1:27:34 the current there's a for for gospels
1:27:36 you have in hand they have considerable
1:27:39 deficiency and shortcomings
1:27:43 and although this miracle is actually
1:27:45 maybe number one because turning
1:27:48 something out of mud into a bird
1:27:51 is much more miraculous and persuasive
1:27:53 than than uh healing uh the the leper
1:27:58 and the bride
1:28:02 but someone said okay but healing there
1:28:04 but that seems to be uh light is more
1:28:07 mentioned ahead of of uh of Reviving The
1:28:11 Dead
1:28:12 the reason for that is that
1:28:14 the the blind from birth
1:28:17 healing him is actually more miraculous
1:28:21 than the the Reviving the dead because
1:28:27 blind from from childhood will have like
1:28:31 the latest Akama we have in history with
1:28:34 the Disappeared in the in the 30s of the
1:28:37 last century because after that the
1:28:39 surgery was developed and which a child
1:28:41 is recognized to have this problem he
1:28:43 can have the surgery and he can see
1:28:47 that the one who's coming very fast by
1:28:49 surgery there are others which notes
1:28:50 because there's a damage in the eye of
1:28:51 the elephants there was no hope then you
1:28:53 will believe by this life
1:28:54 but the problem with that
1:28:56 now the level is okay leave the level
1:28:58 aside but the problem with with the with
1:29:01 the Akama is that
1:29:04 if you don't have sight from birth
1:29:07 then you have no concept about about the
1:29:10 vision light
1:29:12 the word you know the word they can't
1:29:14 tell you that things look like these
1:29:16 various colors but you have no concept
1:29:17 of them in your mind
1:29:19 and you have no concept how to you know
1:29:21 how to go straight and touch the walls
1:29:24 and so on but if you become seeing you
1:29:27 see things you should make no sense out
1:29:28 of it because you haven't experience
1:29:29 with them before
1:29:31 but those Akbar when they become seeing
1:29:35 they run away directly home so they were
1:29:38 able to find their way without a stick
1:29:41 so as if all these accumulated
1:29:42 accumulated information without seeing
1:29:45 accumulating over their life until until
1:29:46 they reach the age of that one who has
1:29:48 been just now healed as if it is all
1:29:50 that were gone back and loaded in their
1:29:52 brain
1:29:53 and I would say this is more difficult
1:29:55 to imagine and perceive than in
1:29:58 verifying up dead after 10 days
1:30:02 because only just reverse the biological
1:30:04 processes and remove the toxins and so
1:30:06 on or recreate the cells and so on
1:30:09 and the the brain with all the previous
1:30:11 members should should be it seems to be
1:30:14 less less demanding and requiring
1:30:16 entropy and and energy input than the
1:30:20 other one seems to be but also the level
1:30:22 most likely the level of this wavelry
1:30:24 Pelosi had been expelled outside of the
1:30:27 citizens on the time past that the only
1:30:28 way they were dealing with them was very
1:30:30 Advanced usually the Republic is going
1:30:32 deep also in is not only the noses being
1:30:35 fallen and and the face is mutilated no
1:30:37 no it's going deep even the harder and
1:30:39 then and then in the muscles and so on
1:30:41 leading to death
1:30:43 so erasing all of that and the creating
1:30:46 that is as as is maybe like like
1:30:48 Reviving a date or even more because in
1:30:50 certain organs only not the whole body
1:30:53 so this seems to be more miraculous and
1:30:56 the one I'm just marketing to bed is
1:30:58 even more miraculous
1:31:00 yeah but is that relevant anyway it's a
1:31:02 very important miracle and it's not in
1:31:04 the existing so-called non-apocrifa
1:31:07 but the other ones is there
1:31:10 so what is all the premises
1:31:15 so uh and to remove any or it looks
1:31:18 pretty because it is but in this
1:31:19 situation it's important to stress that
1:31:21 that nobody think this is by any any
1:31:23 intrinsic part of a size or by about he
1:31:26 has a power he's given the power and you
1:31:27 can use it at Liberty but with the
1:31:30 Divine permission both legislatively and
1:31:32 creatively with Allah's permission
1:31:36 and then I put access to you from the
1:31:38 plotting of money for the children of
1:31:40 Israel when when uh you got them with
1:31:44 the evidences including these are all
1:31:46 these Bunch tons of evidences under this
1:31:48 video of them who were bent to deny the
1:31:51 truth they said this is evident through
1:31:53 scaff this is this is this is a
1:31:56 we have been we have been imagining
1:31:58 things that's not happening this is a
1:32:00 hologram if we're living in modern I say
1:32:03 oh this is the origami he's making a
1:32:04 projection nothing is happening there
1:32:06 it's just a program that's only a
1:32:08 hologram that's it that's it nothing you
1:32:11 fooled our eye nothing that is real
1:32:13 although it's clearly real in front of
1:32:15 the rights
1:32:16 there's nothing that is real
1:32:19 so remember he said all these famous
1:32:21 that's all Prelude to discuss him and
1:32:23 what has the people claiming that he
1:32:25 said
1:32:26 so
1:32:32 so remember that Teresa
1:32:37 and remember
1:32:40 whether it will come to also a critical
1:32:42 point without hurting
1:32:47 Muslim
1:32:49 yeah
1:32:50 and remember the time when I inspired
1:32:52 the white garbed ones believe in me and
1:32:55 my Apostle they answered we believe and
1:32:57 bear that witness that that we have
1:33:00 surrendered ourselves unto thee the
1:33:03 translation and mentioned when I
1:33:05 inspired the disciple to be the
1:33:07 disciples to believe in me and my
1:33:08 messenger they answered we believe and
1:33:11 we're witnessed that we submit ourselves
1:33:13 to you
1:33:15 yeah I think not nothing tricks I just
1:33:16 remember that because
1:33:19 it's it's Allah inspired them and almost
1:33:23 gifted them the faith because they were
1:33:26 the the disciples if you if you see that
1:33:29 this was mentioned in the uh in the
1:33:31 current books the four on the others
1:33:34 they are actually from the most simple
1:33:37 uh classes of the society fishermen and
1:33:40 some very simple people
1:33:41 not capable of a real communication with
1:33:45 this very sophisticated it's extremely
1:33:47 sophisticated man he has from childhood
1:33:49 been educated about the scripture about
1:33:51 wisdom and possibly he maybe have been
1:33:53 educated about the philosophy and so on
1:33:55 we don't know but definitely all of this
1:33:58 all the knowledge of his time he was
1:33:59 mastering it is the extreme opposite to
1:34:02 Muhammad was completed later barely
1:34:05 having anything completely opposite and
1:34:07 these simple people
1:34:09 were taken over by by like by surprise
1:34:12 Allah Inspire them they are simple they
1:34:14 are willing they are like like a like a
1:34:17 tabular rather like nothing is written
1:34:19 they are very simple not something
1:34:20 because it's sophisticated one are
1:34:22 usually a problem they will come with
1:34:24 counter question with like the Jews this
1:34:26 is witchcraft this is hologram in modern
1:34:28 times say oh this was a hologram the man
1:34:30 was mastering calligraphy at that time
1:34:31 ahead of his time all of his or he
1:34:34 communicating with the Extraterrestrial
1:34:35 they'll come with all these nonsense no
1:34:38 nowadays they may come with something
1:34:39 like that but this is my simple problem
1:34:41 and Allah inspired them believe in me
1:34:44 and see and they believed so they so is
1:34:47 is is is is the
1:34:50 is is like a Divine Divine Light given
1:34:54 to them Exile and other people and this
1:34:56 has the effect and they accepted it
1:34:58 because of their pure heartedness and
1:35:00 simpleness
1:35:01 and then
1:35:02 they became believer and they assemble
1:35:04 of resembleness and a symbol
1:35:06 symbol-mindedness and symbol-heartedness
1:35:08 express them in the next one and also in
1:35:11 all life and how how Paul uh almost uh
1:35:15 let's say draw circles along with them
1:35:16 and play them later but this is
1:35:18 discussing illegal Insanity was not the
1:35:20 job now but let's say the next one which
1:35:23 is a really a very difficult point to to
1:35:26 synchronize with the existing
1:35:28 description they have without
1:35:30 meaning
1:35:40 and lo the white card once said oh Jesus
1:35:43 on a Mary could I sustain a send out
1:35:45 unto us a recast from a heaven Jesus
1:35:49 asked to be conscious of God if you are
1:35:52 truly Believers let's translation
1:35:55 I mentioned when the Believers when the
1:35:58 disciples said Jesus Son of Mary can you
1:36:00 can your lord send us a feast from
1:36:02 Heaven Jesus answered remain mindful of
1:36:05 God if you are truly believers
1:36:07 yeah uh that's the the Texas Kitty let's
1:36:10 show the the honesty assembled minded
1:36:12 this value because if you are a Believer
1:36:15 and you have seen all these Miracles so
1:36:16 what's what's having a feast from heaven
1:36:20 from the window some some table comes at
1:36:22 a table of four legs they have a table
1:36:24 and some like spread come down with the
1:36:26 with the with the with food on it or
1:36:30 with one special meal of it and so on
1:36:33 it's not nothing much more exciting than
1:36:36 the previous ones so it is yeah so but
1:36:41 they wanted most likely they wanted
1:36:42 something private for them private
1:36:44 medical I was stressed I was Private
1:36:46 because something later May hint that it
1:36:48 is of this type
1:36:49 and data was obviously shocking this
1:36:51 kind of a simple-minded that really
1:36:53 relatively shocking request from from
1:36:56 Believers should not be
1:37:00 aware of a life you're a True Believer
1:37:03 and they responded
1:37:14 sad day we decided to partake thereof so
1:37:16 that our site our hearts might be set
1:37:20 fully at rest and that we might know
1:37:21 that thou has spoken the truth to us and
1:37:24 that we might be of those who bear
1:37:25 witness thereto the exploration they
1:37:28 said we wish to eat from it so that our
1:37:30 hearts might be as reassured and that we
1:37:33 might know that you have told us the
1:37:36 truth and be among those who witness it
1:37:37 so basically there when something which
1:37:40 is private and they can't experience it
1:37:42 by not only just by seeing because all
1:37:44 these other Americans you see but you
1:37:46 don't have the Intel in in ingestive
1:37:50 experience that
1:37:54 for example none of these birds flew
1:37:56 away none of them came back and they
1:37:57 could Slaughter and eat for example
1:37:59 something like that that's really a bed
1:38:01 not a hologram but this one and you see
1:38:04 the tablespoed coming down or the food
1:38:06 or the maybe just a big plate and uh
1:38:11 and the issue is that it comes from
1:38:13 Heaven not that the content is heaven
1:38:14 you know this is not about any content
1:38:16 that's not an issue but just that you
1:38:17 can eat from it
1:38:20 digest it gets it in the ability and
1:38:22 feel really that yourself so this feels
1:38:24 more persuasive and more more convincing
1:38:27 that it's real
1:38:28 that is an art house would be completely
1:38:31 at rest because obviously what is the
1:38:32 money Israel claiming this is a
1:38:34 witchcraft is a magician this is done by
1:38:36 this wizard this is done by this one
1:38:38 this is the until a time of Visa there's
1:38:40 some wizard claiming to do Miracles like
1:38:41 him and things like that and and they
1:38:44 were able also to to play certain tricks
1:38:46 with the people and although Mass
1:38:47 hypnosis and things like that so they
1:38:49 were if you read the the scripture under
1:38:52 the epistle at that time and the various
1:38:54 historic reports that you will be amazed
1:38:56 how how many people going around and
1:38:57 doing Mischief with these things so
1:39:00 maybe then excludes for them but they
1:39:02 wanted this private one
1:39:04 then we know that you are telling the
1:39:06 truth just affirm it they know it but as
1:39:09 you want a double affirmation
1:39:11 and it will be witnessed for that
1:39:14 then either based on that circuits
1:39:28 the son of Mary oh Gods our sustainers
1:39:31 sent down upon us a report from Heaven
1:39:33 it shall be an Ever occurring faith for
1:39:36 us for the first time and the for the
1:39:38 first and the last of us and a sign from
1:39:41 thee o provide our us our sustenance for
1:39:45 thou art the best providers yeah
1:39:48 the son of Mary said God our Lord send
1:39:52 us a meal from Heaven that we can have a
1:39:54 recurring celebration for the first and
1:39:57 the last of us and a sign from you
1:39:59 provide for us because you are the best
1:40:01 of providers yeah so you'll notice this
1:40:04 is
1:40:05 repeating that again again to enforce it
1:40:07 it should have been easy just Elizabeth
1:40:10 but also it has to remember how many
1:40:12 many times Mariam appears in the Quran I
1:40:15 will have to check that it has any
1:40:17 significance maybe it has some medical
1:40:19 significance also anyway that's not the
1:40:21 major issue now
1:40:23 is a supplicated
1:40:24 but he has to make this application so
1:40:26 that it is that it looks reasonable and
1:40:29 rational
1:40:30 and that's a uh that he cannot do that
1:40:33 it's not in his authority to bring
1:40:34 something from Heaven down or lift
1:40:36 someone in heaven and in Earth he can't
1:40:38 he can revive this but not this type so
1:40:41 send us down a table thread or a meal
1:40:43 from heaven
1:40:45 so that they say is intending it to be
1:40:48 that's what the intending but is it so
1:40:49 that's a question that it will be a
1:40:52 celebration for us from now and on until
1:40:55 the last of us
1:40:56 and the sign from you both is but so it
1:40:58 will be like a read day so this will
1:41:00 establish a new hit beside the age of
1:41:03 the Old Testament they were similarating
1:41:04 anyway
1:41:05 and give us for music because you are
1:41:08 the best officer what best of us
1:41:15 and the issues of that there's no threes
1:41:18 in the current scripture about that
1:41:20 Allah
1:41:24 foreign
1:41:34 I always do send it down upon to you and
1:41:38 so if any of you should henceforth deny
1:41:41 this truth on him behold will I inflict
1:41:45 The Suffering The Life of which I have
1:41:47 never yet inflicted upon anyone in this
1:41:49 world in the world this is a key point
1:41:52 so
1:41:58 it is such a saturated such a binding uh
1:42:05 miracle for them that whoever
1:42:08 from these disciples were asking which
1:42:10 maybe that's wealth we don't know maybe
1:42:13 more than that they were asking because
1:42:15 he has 12 he had 70 had other people
1:42:17 maybe they were president maybe we don't
1:42:19 know most likely it's only the 12th
1:42:22 foreign
1:42:28 just for the number because they weren't
1:42:30 were not from the 12th shop they formed
1:42:32 by two maybe three traps anyway
1:42:35 but whoever denied the truth after that
1:42:37 I will punish him more severely than
1:42:39 anyone in the universe
1:42:42 Music
1:42:46 then I will punish him more than anyone
1:42:48 in the universe
1:42:50 now
1:42:52 this may be the key for solution for
1:42:54 that that there is no evidence that
1:42:57 there's uh that that it is a spread from
1:43:00 Heaven came what we have is also called
1:43:01 the last meal
1:43:03 which is obviously I eat the last meal
1:43:05 which is at the same time time wise is
1:43:09 synchronous with with the Easter yeah
1:43:12 because that that last meal was uh was
1:43:15 uh a couple day of the Easter day or I
1:43:18 think it was a Wednesday or something
1:43:20 and yesterday was I think Friday and
1:43:22 with the alleged constriction has
1:43:24 happened
1:43:27 now the scholars of Islam
1:43:30 discussed that that there's nothing in
1:43:31 the scripture in the hand of the people
1:43:34 for any mission of this whatsoever
1:43:40 and they tried various Solutions
1:43:43 it's very difficult to assume that it
1:43:45 has happened like that
1:43:48 and
1:43:50 it is not narrated anywhere does not
1:43:52 become a festivity so they assume it may
1:43:54 be that table that that last meal is
1:43:57 that table but in the story of the last
1:43:59 meal there's no mention of anything
1:44:01 coming from heaven
1:44:05 so how to resolve this problem
1:44:09 some of the one one of the better
1:44:11 Solutions said this is
1:44:16 when they hit
1:44:17 that's not about solution because when
1:44:19 they hear that it is it's not Allah it's
1:44:21 not responding that it will be read and
1:44:23 so on no it's free it's not going to be
1:44:24 that so I'll be going obviously going to
1:44:27 be an an enormous punishment for anyone
1:44:29 who didn't have to like that that's not
1:44:31 relevant you can't adopt it that's it if
1:44:33 you want but that's that's it so it's a
1:44:36 private medical for you and anyone
1:44:38 deviating will be
1:44:40 they really punished on anyone in the
1:44:42 whole creation
1:44:43 and then respond understand
1:44:45 we believe without it we don't know and
1:44:48 Allah canceled it didn't come down
1:44:49 that's one Theory
1:44:52 another theory which is I would say is
1:44:55 it's also maybe less persuasive than
1:44:57 this is that
1:45:01 it's a private it definitely Supply with
1:45:02 America because for only the disciples
1:45:04 nobody is present nobody is witnessing
1:45:09 it came down
1:45:11 with the threat and they knew about the
1:45:13 threat and Lisa told them
1:45:18 one that is mentioned in in their
1:45:20 existing gospel after the meal he told
1:45:23 them during the meal after the meal some
1:45:25 of you will betray me and some of you
1:45:27 will even deny me and most of you all of
1:45:31 you will run away from me when the the
1:45:34 extension the detention the ransacking
1:45:37 group comes
1:45:38 investigated by the temple but also with
1:45:41 the cooperation of the Romans because
1:45:42 they came in a cohort almost like a
1:45:44 regiment vegetarianism
1:45:46 and the old enough is clear that all the
1:45:49 displays run away
1:45:50 and even some of the Departed Jerusalem
1:45:53 going back to Galilee and this allegedly
1:45:56 uh Shimon such a moon
1:45:59 Peter was called Peter in in Latin The
1:46:01 Rock
1:46:03 for the story
1:46:04 or not in the in the New Testament uh
1:46:08 sneaked and tried to look at the trial
1:46:10 for the person who appears to be Aisa we
1:46:12 discussed that in another occasion about
1:46:14 the so-called Transfiguration and and a
1:46:19 woman recognizing with ah this is the
1:46:20 one with the Galilean in that time is
1:46:22 terrorist there's a Galilean like today
1:46:25 as a Palestinian is one of the galileans
1:46:29 at the time against the Roman Empire and
1:46:31 he said no no I'm not anymore I don't
1:46:33 know this man whatsoever Angel run away
1:46:36 and against next again and several times
1:46:38 that's the story
1:46:43 and that will happen
1:46:45 so
1:46:47 I know that you understood denial you
1:46:49 will be in a stage showcule you will
1:46:50 fail that but one of you would be above
1:46:52 cover that's that that's you that's
1:46:54 that's the one that would be the story
1:46:55 believe in the punishment but if you
1:46:57 report he may even told him if you
1:47:00 report the story to the people they will
1:47:02 they will accuse you of committing cover
1:47:04 and nobody will listen to you so don't
1:47:06 keep that for yourself that's a very
1:47:08 good possibility I would I would say
1:47:10 this is not not a bad solution for the
1:47:14 for the fact that it is may have come
1:47:16 but they they were instructed don't tell
1:47:19 anybody because the way you behave in
1:47:21 this night when the attack comes if
1:47:24 everyone will hold that against you and
1:47:26 you will be bad-mouthed and nobody will
1:47:28 will even accept anything from you or
1:47:30 trust you but I know this is because
1:47:32 your human weakness at this not because
1:47:34 of cover
1:47:35 except one of you no one hopes betray me
1:47:38 the rest will will just and the shock
1:47:40 and the fear they will run away which
1:47:42 happens weakness but not cover
1:47:45 but don't mention that so don't stretch
1:47:47 anybody you have just final meal that's
1:47:49 it where the meal came from from heaven
1:47:51 from Market
1:47:53 from the shop next Saturday from from
1:47:55 her
1:47:57 eat it at the time there was no eat that
1:47:59 you can order by phone
1:48:01 just a meal don't mention that others
1:48:05 would lead to complete scandalization
1:48:07 I'll be discrediting you completely
1:48:09 is enough that you would not be able to
1:48:11 sustain the shock so no need to mention
1:48:13 that story as I would say this is a
1:48:15 reasonable possibility a third one which
1:48:18 is as I said minor is actually not the
1:48:19 last meal which became a festivity it's
1:48:22 an event which happened earlier
1:48:26 but they did not recognize that it is
1:48:29 that what is that what that's the spirit
1:48:31 but it's very unlikely the way it's
1:48:33 reporting is very a little it may be the
1:48:35 the the this this this the the this
1:48:40 event is when we when he made a win
1:48:43 increased the fish Etc so the the and
1:48:46 then then increase the food for a few
1:48:49 fishes a few few fish one or two fish
1:48:51 which is sufficient for five ten men
1:48:53 were sufficient for three thousand
1:48:54 people
1:48:55 that the the increases can the these
1:48:58 these new fish had come from heaven and
1:49:00 they were they were and the people
1:49:02 failed to record that like that and
1:49:03 failed to record it in detail how it
1:49:05 were whatever there was a request of the
1:49:07 disability and things like that and it's
1:49:09 very well possible because we have that
1:49:10 we have previously just mentioned the
1:49:12 fading to record but probably to record
1:49:14 the the miracle obtaining uh
1:49:18 uh Birds into into a bed repair shapes
1:49:22 and mud shaped as Bears in real beds so
1:49:25 it could be that but I would say this is
1:49:27 not very persuasive I would just one of
1:49:29 the two first ones are the most
1:49:30 persuasive one and the second one is
1:49:32 that it did come
1:49:35 and then he told them
1:49:37 there you will you will know because
1:49:38 that after that in the current year the
1:49:41 documentary on our hand is clearly
1:49:43 mentioned that uh he he said that one of
1:49:46 you will betray me and you do you love
1:49:49 me with Peter uh
1:49:51 let me say yes I love you also but you
1:49:53 will deny me three times that's there so
1:49:56 better for you don't mention that to
1:49:58 anybody
1:50:00 don't inform the people I would tell
1:50:01 about it and otherwise it would be held
1:50:05 against you and they will not be able to
1:50:06 call the people for for almost like you
1:50:09 told them I would be saved I would I
1:50:11 will nothing will happen to me but
1:50:12 anyway Allah will step in and do do
1:50:15 whatever necessary but for you to be
1:50:17 scandalizing that's a possibility
1:50:18 whatever has happened
1:50:23 in many places doesn't give us the
1:50:25 except part of the story which of
1:50:27 relevance obviously the known videos
1:50:32 but this is I would say this is actually
1:50:35 I'm not going to defeat yourself because
1:50:37 if if he the if the story of the last
1:50:41 meal is as in the character description
1:50:43 everywhere even the Apocrypha is the
1:50:45 same message like that I know who it is
1:50:48 Came From Heaven
1:50:50 then why should he invent such a story
1:50:53 get himself in trouble
1:50:56 there's nothing really any persuasive
1:50:59 nothing beneficial in that like we
1:51:01 discussed in the case of of Suleiman the
1:51:05 majority of the Jews are most consensus
1:51:06 to the Jews is that Suleman is a
1:51:08 magician and then died as a cafe and
1:51:10 Idol worshiper so why he goes into
1:51:12 trouble and the user exercise look at
1:51:14 this man he claims to the man is a
1:51:16 prophet actually he was a magician at a
1:51:17 catheter and Idol worshiper
1:51:19 why he should get it what was the
1:51:22 purpose of getting my own
1:51:23 self-interrupted if he has a if you
1:51:25 adopted the story somewhere
1:51:28 so this is it needs an installation this
1:51:31 that's explanation that he got it wrong
1:51:32 the same next station the Mariam there's
1:51:34 Mariam although in their Apocrypha not
1:51:36 in the main books in the mailbox has her
1:51:39 journalism
1:51:41 she's a suppository the daughter of a
1:51:44 man called Joachim
1:51:46 no time run
1:51:48 and they said oh yeah he got to talk he
1:51:50 said foreign
1:51:55 1500 years drunk all these attempts of
1:51:58 of so-called resolution let's just make
1:52:02 the one who claimed them to become a
1:52:03 joker this is not this is not a way to
1:52:06 go you have to bring a better
1:52:07 acceleration I would say this
1:52:10 this Revelation clarified that until if
1:52:13 I historic things which are even
1:52:14 shocking that with what we have
1:52:16 literation our hand is having major
1:52:17 deficiency like the missing of the
1:52:19 missing of the the that missing here is
1:52:22 is understandable is it may be by
1:52:23 instructional visa and or there even
1:52:26 without instruction they decided if we
1:52:28 say that it has come from heaven and
1:52:29 that's what Allah told us it will be
1:52:31 catastrophic just hide it the same for
1:52:33 example by after he reappeared the what
1:52:36 they call this election
1:52:37 is that they knew he was not crucified
1:52:39 but they did not they decided they've
1:52:42 returned the people that he was not
1:52:43 crucified this will not have the effect
1:52:46 for that one as as uh
1:52:49 as as uh rebuking them because the first
1:52:54 sermon of Peter allegedly in the actual
1:52:56 Apostle says clearly to the people you
1:52:58 killed a great prophet of God
1:53:01 and you have invited trouble for the
1:53:03 nation destruction and that people were
1:53:05 very repenting and they were weeping and
1:53:07 thousands embraced belief almost
1:53:09 immediately so using it that you killed
1:53:12 that one you are the guilty one using a
1:53:14 guilt feeling has a considerable effect
1:53:16 on spreading Christianity early
1:53:21 I don't know say I was distracted
1:53:22 administrator that you killed him
1:53:24 which is which is a a good way to access
1:53:27 you intended to kill him you think you
1:53:29 have killed him that's fine but
1:53:31 I wouldn't say I call that Ally Accord
1:53:34 is it like a similar literary expression
1:53:38 you intended to look at him and some
1:53:40 things that's what appeared as a
1:53:42 crucifixion you you think and you are
1:53:43 convinced that some of them are good
1:53:45 you're gloating that you killed him but
1:53:46 with this way you you you got yourself
1:53:49 in a massive sin and then invited
1:53:52 Destruction for your own people as he
1:53:53 announced that your temple will be
1:53:55 destroyed and you will be scattered all
1:53:57 over the world yeah that's what you're
1:53:58 getting so the people were very panicked
1:54:00 so it was very effective so it's very
1:54:02 well possible that they knew that it was
1:54:04 not not a resurrection it was a
1:54:06 reappearance and the crucified was
1:54:08 someone else
1:54:09 very well password I'm not saying this
1:54:11 is a conclusion so many things there
1:54:14 besides obviously in in the existing
1:54:16 even the most reliable ones that's the
1:54:19 four ones now the four ones the the the
1:54:21 four Gospels
1:54:24 have been chosen to be the the cleanest
1:54:26 and the the closest to history as they
1:54:29 could the scholars could in the fourth
1:54:31 Century the in the near the the choice
1:54:33 was done in the in the near Kian and you
1:54:36 see a Nikki and Conference
1:54:38 some people say it is chosen because of
1:54:41 the correlation of the churches but this
1:54:43 is this is not persuasive yes the main
1:54:45 churches have their own main gospels but
1:54:47 these have been chosen over time
1:54:49 based on the best narrative the best
1:54:51 cross-referencing and so on there's some
1:54:53 questions good scholar they were going
1:54:55 on that if you analyze them you see
1:54:57 really converter Apocrypha you see
1:54:59 clearly that these are the greatest and
1:55:02 the best but they have my considerable
1:55:04 deficiencies and they still have
1:55:05 considerable publication here and there
1:55:08 Like A Christmas Story which is almost
1:55:11 100 percent with all compounded evidence
1:55:15 is a fabrication you can't be true it's
1:55:17 just an initial room where someone
1:55:18 invented and then it was even even look
1:55:21 who seems to be the best historian could
1:55:24 not could not uh run away from that
1:55:27 story and were perceived it to be true
1:55:29 and was fooled by this narrative
1:55:32 so that's that maybe but as I said this
1:55:35 is
1:55:36 and then on the other hand it keeps an
1:55:39 open door for for federal recession
1:55:41 history so it keeps things dark so that
1:55:43 people can do some research
1:55:45 the same like for example the story in
1:55:47 the case of talud
1:55:49 who I mentioned that he was crossing the
1:55:51 river Alaska people not to think so this
1:55:53 story in the Old Testament is attributed
1:55:54 to Jerome Gideon the people when whose
1:55:57 name the people put Bibles in the hotels
1:55:59 and so on Gideon so
1:56:02 it seems a bit has taken away from talud
1:56:05 by obviously David and Davidian and
1:56:07 Solomon party
1:56:09 and referred back to they couldn't
1:56:12 attribute such such a virtue of total
1:56:15 route
1:56:17 um
1:56:18 uh salt they couldn't so they attribute
1:56:20 to someone else so they transfer story
1:56:22 from birthstone to another person
1:56:23 because of the political orientation
1:56:25 because of a certain partisanship and
1:56:28 things like that
1:56:29 it's very possible that it could happen
1:56:31 for this things like that so that's why
1:56:34 in the Old Testament but the same could
1:56:37 happen to elsewhere also for various
1:56:40 reasons
1:56:42 but some good research should be can be
1:56:45 done there for the people who are
1:56:46 familiar with the with the New Testament
1:56:48 so on
1:56:52 just let me conclude because uh we'll uh
1:56:57 then the other discussion about that did
1:56:59 you tell them that you are Divine and so
1:57:01 on that's what we will do next time I
1:57:03 just want to mention maybe
1:57:06 um
1:57:07 or just leave it and leave it to the
1:57:09 next time Michelle that's okay because
1:57:11 it belongs more to the issue of divinity
1:57:12 and things like that and divine natural
1:57:15 base at all so we stop here so that
1:57:17 issue of the matter is definitely a
1:57:19 difficult one but it's difficult one
1:57:21 more for the other side than for us
1:57:24 because they have we have manifestly
1:57:27 proven uh claims there which manifest
1:57:30 fabrication uh for example the story
1:57:33 that the conserviction has happened and
1:57:34 then uh the the world of the temple or
1:57:38 had a crack and then the dead were
1:57:41 resurrected from their graves and walked
1:57:44 into Jerusalem hundreds of them
1:57:46 and nobody in where the history anywhere
1:57:48 neither Roman none of Roman non-jews
1:57:50 whatever they put anything like that
1:57:51 it's just here just just smacks for
1:57:54 complete fabrication nonsenseica it
1:57:56 can't be accepted such an event like
1:57:59 that cannot be possibly have happened
1:58:01 without nobody in the world recording
1:58:03 and only just Matthew not even in Luke
1:58:05 not even anywhere else that's just upset
1:58:08 for example but anyway that's
1:58:11 there's still a matter of considerable
1:58:13 research
1:58:14 okay but we stop here in which I always
1:58:17 before the Allah asking uh he said if he
1:58:20 has declared himself to be divine and
1:58:22 his mother yeah
1:58:23 so just a question um so
1:58:25 ending
1:58:29 so that's the last one we did yeah and
1:58:32 the next one will be starting
1:58:35 um
1:58:37 did you tell the people to adopt me or
1:58:39 to appoint me and my mother divine
1:58:45 by this kind of
1:58:51 Music
1:59:25 foreign
1:59:31 Music
1:59:51 Music