Disproving Ahmadiyyah with one Argument. (2019-10-10) #

0:00:00 Salam alaikum warahmatullahi what I care
0:00:02 - how are you guys doing and this is a
0:00:04 short video hopefully which is meant to
0:00:07 elucidate our brothers and humanity from
0:00:11 the at midi community of course we
0:00:14 understand that the ahmadiyya community
0:00:16 is a small community of about ten
0:00:19 million people worldwide according to
0:00:21 statistics and then we also understand
0:00:23 that they because of that because of
0:00:26 that may be susceptible to kind of
0:00:29 violence or oppression all these things
0:00:31 Wow so the first thing we should
0:00:33 actually sell by saying is that whenever
0:00:36 you see people who who are susceptible
0:00:40 to those things we should be careful not
0:00:42 to twist you know ideological points of
0:00:45 contention theological points of
0:00:47 contention which I'm going to raise in
0:00:48 fact in this video to religious violence
0:00:52 or oppression or anything like that so
0:00:55 that's that's a disclaimer that I want
0:00:56 to make and just for those who don't
0:00:58 understand who and what the Atman is aa
0:01:02 the admin is are a group of people who
0:01:04 believe in the Quran the veracity of the
0:01:06 Quran and they actually even believe in
0:01:09 the son now the you know the the
0:01:11 literature of the Muslims of the Sunni
0:01:14 Muslims like Bukhari Muslim etc and what
0:01:18 they also believe which is what
0:01:19 separates them from the main body of
0:01:21 Sunni Islam and Shia Islam the fact that
0:01:25 there was a prophet that came after they
0:01:26 call him what I'm Ahmed now this man was
0:01:28 a man who was born 1835 and died in 1908
0:01:32 and was in British occupied India at
0:01:36 that time now I'm not gonna go to
0:01:38 conspiracy theories about him lazing and
0:01:40 conspiring with the British it of course
0:01:42 this is the main stream kind of
0:01:44 narrative within Sunni circles which is
0:01:47 that you know he was conspiring with a
0:01:49 British or he was enacting the British
0:01:51 will in that you know he kind of unquiet
0:01:57 eyes the the obligation of jihad
0:02:01 physical fighting back because the
0:02:04 British at that time they had an agenda
0:02:07 of course to to
0:02:11 do you militarize if you like the
0:02:14 aggressing military elements of the
0:02:17 indian colonial people's that's that's a
0:02:21 conspiracy i will call it or it could be
0:02:23 true
0:02:23 i'm not going into the details of this
0:02:25 now because it's not my area of interest
0:02:27 at this point in time but it's important
0:02:30 just to know what kind of narratives are
0:02:32 out there now here's what I do want to
0:02:34 say what you think is very important how
0:02:37 do we know a profit is a profit this is
0:02:39 a good question
0:02:40 okay how do we know a profit is a profit
0:02:41 now in the Islamic tradition I've
0:02:43 already made the argument that from a
0:02:45 completely textual basis that they
0:02:48 cannot be seen to be any profit that
0:02:49 comes after Prophet Muhammad why because
0:02:52 of the versions of lab where he's
0:02:54 referred to as hot and hot in the
0:02:56 beginning so that he's the scene of the
0:03:00 profits point is also the final prophet
0:03:02 now linguists and professor hoon
0:03:04 exegetes of the Quran through all of
0:03:06 history have said that this means that
0:03:08 he is the final prophet the Prophet
0:03:09 himself said in Buhari
0:03:11 in many different anyway I have in fact
0:03:13 different narrations that let it be
0:03:15 about me there's no prophet afternoon
0:03:16 now this is the strongest argument and
0:03:18 there are many arguments which are
0:03:19 subsidiary to those arguments we shall
0:03:21 meet to show that there cannot be a
0:03:24 prophet after prophet Muhammad from an
0:03:26 Islamic perspective however there's an
0:03:28 argument I want to make today which is a
0:03:30 different kind of argument you see well
0:03:32 I'm with himself who as we've said was
0:03:35 quite modern man in terms of his
0:03:36 political placement
0:03:38 he says the following he says that to
0:03:41 draw to judge my truthfulness or lies
0:03:43 there is no better test than prophesies
0:03:46 and he also said let it be known to the
0:03:49 unbelieving persons that my truthfulness
0:03:51 or false will be judged on my prophecies
0:03:53 there is no other touchstone for it and
0:03:56 of course I'm going to provide an
0:03:58 article with all of the references for
0:04:02 these things that he said so what he's
0:04:04 saying is and this is mentioned just
0:04:09 mentioned you know
0:04:17 in Boots where I will show you the
0:04:20 evidences for the references for those
0:04:23 particular quotations I just came as I'm
0:04:26 finding those quotations what I'm gonna
0:04:27 say is that I believe that what a madman
0:04:29 is actually right these points in fact
0:04:32 it is a good point to make that
0:04:34 prophecies are wise required for example
0:04:36 those two things to judge my
0:04:38 truthfulness of lives is no business and
0:04:40 prophecies is mentioned in a book called
0:04:42 rahani Mazzini the volume 19 page 288 is
0:04:47 also let it be known to the unbelieving
0:04:49 persons that my truthfulness or false
0:04:51 winters am uneasy there is no better
0:04:53 touchstone for it is in Amenas he mocked
0:04:55 he Islam page 208 of these references I
0:04:59 will provide in an article which I'm
0:05:02 basing it on this research on now having
0:05:05 said that he's saying basically my
0:05:06 prophecies which is my predictions of
0:05:08 the future this is the touchstone to
0:05:11 know if I'm truthful and I think this is
0:05:12 a very fair test because if someone is
0:05:14 being divinely inspired if someone is
0:05:17 being divinely inspired they should be
0:05:19 in fact yeah telling the truth about the
0:05:22 future because if God is all-knowing he
0:05:23 knows the future as well
0:05:24 very fair enough and that is actually
0:05:26 one of the challenges we as Muslims make
0:05:28 to non-muslims that if the Prophet had
0:05:31 made a prediction of the future that is
0:05:33 time-bound
0:05:34 for example place bound that ship have
0:05:38 materialized and if it can be falsified
0:05:39 this effectively falsify his prophethood
0:05:42 it's a very fair enough test because no
0:05:44 one knows the future for sure now I want
0:05:47 to just introduce you to two prophecies
0:05:48 or two or three prophecies that will I'm
0:05:50 adamant made and we want to look at
0:05:51 these prophecies and see was he telling
0:05:53 the truth or not he says what a madman
0:05:57 says in the following he says it was
0:05:59 revealed to me by the Most High God that
0:06:03 I should seek the hand of Ahmed begs
0:06:05 Eldar eldest daughter and to tell them
0:06:08 that a kindly treatment shall be dealt
0:06:11 to them if they accept the proposal and
0:06:13 that this marriage shall bring to them
0:06:15 blessings and blissful beatitude but if
0:06:18 they should refuse to do so the end of
0:06:21 the girl shall be very sad
0:06:23 and the man who shall marry her shall
0:06:26 die
0:06:26 within two and a half years and her
0:06:28 father within three years from the date
0:06:30 of marriage God the most high will
0:06:33 remove every obstacle in the end bring
0:06:36 her into marriage with me Tocqueville
0:06:38 Allah saying this yeah and turn the
0:06:40 irreligious people into Muslims and
0:06:42 bring to guidance those who have lost
0:06:45 the right path it's very clear what a
0:06:49 madman is saying that he will marry this
0:06:51 woman
0:06:52 whose name is Mohammad II Begum yeah
0:06:55 he's saying that will happen in this
0:06:56 time if this doesn't happen and so on
0:06:58 then we problematic now highs will jump
0:07:01 on this and say well hold on he says
0:07:02 that if the people repent there was a
0:07:04 condition of repentance the family if
0:07:06 the family doesn't repent then all these
0:07:08 things will happen however even after a
0:07:11 family was sending because they got a
0:07:13 little bit worried actually maybe this
0:07:14 guy is telling the truth the family side
0:07:16 writing you know letters of apology to
0:07:18 the two and so on even after that he
0:07:22 reiterated so a company because of
0:07:24 repentance he reiterated the same
0:07:26 message she said even after they
0:07:29 supposedly you know apologized and so on
0:07:31 but the death of Ahmed but beg broke
0:07:34 their backs and this was why they sent
0:07:36 letters of apology and regret so he's
0:07:38 acknowledging that they said assembly is
0:07:40 of a program as they were struck by fear
0:07:43 and terror in their hearts it was
0:07:44 essential that God the Most High
0:07:46 according to his ancient way postponed
0:07:48 the day of punishment to some later time
0:07:50 that is to the time when those people
0:07:53 again turned back fully to another time
0:07:56 of fearing and turning to God is
0:07:58 displayed as proved by the whole of the
0:08:00 Quran but the essence of the prophecy
0:08:03 that this woman will enter into this
0:08:05 marriage with me is an absolute fate
0:08:08 isn't a discovery is an absolute fate
0:08:11 which cannot be averted now this is
0:08:14 clear even after the so-called
0:08:16 repentance and apology so absolute faith
0:08:18 which were which one cannot be averted
0:08:20 he says so after these days when God the
0:08:22 most high sees that these people's
0:08:24 hearts have hardened and that they have
0:08:26 not valued the few days of respite and
0:08:29 relaxation given to them then he will
0:08:31 turn to the fulfillment of the prophecy
0:08:33 of his holy word
0:08:35 so you can't say that because of all the
0:08:37 family repented because here saying he's
0:08:38 definitely she's been definitely to be
0:08:39 married with me what did this happen
0:08:45 was he ever married to Mohamed he bigger
0:08:47 this is the question we have to ask
0:08:49 because this was saying it's absolute
0:08:50 the answer is no he never married her
0:08:54 and there's no evidence like he married
0:08:55 her in fact she got married to another
0:08:56 man now then all those bad things happen
0:08:59 to Mohammed he Begum did you know did
0:09:03 Allah break their backs and so on no
0:09:05 more so the question is how can his
0:09:09 prophecy be wrong if he knows the future
0:09:10 it seems someone may be a critical say
0:09:14 this man really wanted to get married to
0:09:15 this woman was using fear tactics to try
0:09:19 to persuade the woman for marriage but
0:09:22 that never materialized but
0:09:24 unfortunately what that did is it put
0:09:26 the cat in with the pigeons it put the
0:09:27 spanner in with the Woodworks because
0:09:29 now we can say that this is a false
0:09:31 prophecy which effectively you could
0:09:34 argue falsifies his whole claim to
0:09:38 profit so by the way he says this and
0:09:42 I'll give you the references in the
0:09:44 article you can check the other comfort
0:09:45 in the description box
0:09:46 by the way of prophecy the exalted God
0:09:49 revealed him to his number one that
0:09:51 ultimately the elder daughter of Mirza
0:09:53 Ahmed Beck son of menahalim Beck would
0:09:57 be married to me these people will
0:09:59 resort to great hostility and would put
0:10:01 many obstacles in the way but in the end
0:10:03 it would surely take place the exalted
0:10:06 God by all possible means bring her to
0:10:08 me
0:10:09 whether a virgin or a widow and would
0:10:11 remove all impediments and would of
0:10:13 necessity to the Sun and no one will be
0:10:17 able to prevent it yeah if this has been
0:10:21 in the hadith literature of the Salim
0:10:24 that he was saying that this is gonna
0:10:26 happen I'm gonna marry this woman and he
0:10:28 never did it imagine what the Orientals
0:10:29 would be doing they'll be having a field
0:10:31 day with this information now look at
0:10:36 this
0:10:36 in addition to this false prophecy yeah
0:10:38 secondary one he says it is God's
0:10:41 intention this is him again God's
0:10:44 intention that he will bring two ladies
0:10:46 in my wedlock
0:10:48 one will be a virgin and the other a
0:10:50 widow
0:10:51 therefore this inspiration now as
0:10:53 related to the version has been
0:10:55 fulfilled and presented by the grace of
0:10:57 God I have four sons from it this wife
0:10:59 I'm still waiting for the fulfillment of
0:11:01 the inspiration regarding Widow now the
0:11:03 thing is what I'm not married twice most
0:11:04 two versions he married twice before and
0:11:07 he married - harmik Bibi and no strategy
0:11:09 em bigger both of them yes both of them
0:11:13 are virgins now the question is he said
0:11:15 I'm gonna marry a virgin and the widow
0:11:16 so wait a minute we should do it the
0:11:19 other way Widow that he married well
0:11:21 someone can argue well when he married
0:11:23 her she was no longer a virgin okay well
0:11:26 this is the when she outlived him so she
0:11:28 became a widow but doesn't work like
0:11:30 that because he said he'll bring him -
0:11:32 no I - my wedlock eonni
0:11:35 that she was in that state of being a
0:11:36 widow already and then she was brought
0:11:39 to my weblog not that I made her the
0:11:41 widow or because of me she became a
0:11:43 widow Yani
0:11:44 so the two things here are interlinked
0:11:46 false prophecies relating to marriage
0:11:48 and so obviously someone will argue if
0:11:51 there was an oriental census
0:11:53 [Music]
0:11:54 self-serving prophesies because you want
0:11:57 to marry the Orient this will sell us
0:11:59 you want to hear the problem on tomorrow
0:12:00 and therefore you say you're gonna marry
0:12:02 this otherwise break your back to sand
0:12:03 that they would have a field day with
0:12:05 this and that he did not marry and so on
0:12:08 so forth by him
0:12:09 so imagine if it was us as the Sunni
0:12:11 Muslims will be here elated in front of
0:12:14 the international community with such
0:12:16 false prophecies
0:12:17 moreover well I'm Ahmed said I shall die
0:12:21 in Mecca or Medina and the man never
0:12:24 stepped foot in Mecca or Medina what
0:12:26 more do you want
0:12:27 ladies and gentlemen let's read the
0:12:29 whole thing are you taking out of
0:12:30 context
0:12:30 I don't think me brother because you
0:12:32 need you so this I shall die in Mecca
0:12:34 Medina means that before my death I
0:12:37 shall be bestowed victory like that of
0:12:39 madcap listen to this that I should say
0:12:41 that the holy prophet had vanquished his
0:12:43 enemies through them
0:12:44 sensation of majestic signs of Allah so
0:12:46 it will happen now the second meaning is
0:12:48 that before my death I shall bestow the
0:12:50 victory like that of Medina which means
0:12:53 that people's heart will be their own
0:12:55 inclined towards me the phrase God has
0:12:59 decreed I and my messengers shall
0:13:01 prevail points of victory like that was
0:13:03 Mecca and the phrase peace is the word
0:13:06 for my merciful look point to a picture
0:13:07 like that of Medina wait a minute
0:13:09 ten million people in the world which is
0:13:10 the side the size of London as a
0:13:12 religious community what Mecca Medina
0:13:14 I'm sorry to say how can you even
0:13:16 compare the victory of Muhammad's Allah
0:13:18 as something was stretched yeah from
0:13:21 Michelle a calamity never of Arabia from
0:13:24 the east part the worst is the worst
0:13:25 part of the West with such Yanni sorry
0:13:29 to say in significant gains
0:13:32 comparatively from a demographic
0:13:33 perspective of Allah but then those
0:13:36 don't forget hold on I told us the truth
0:13:39 so the Kakadu he spoke the truth
0:13:43 even though in many instances he did not
0:13:45 speak the truth - he said in so saying
0:13:48 he said to judge my truthful missile
0:13:51 lies there is no better test than
0:13:52 prophesies like we use the prophecies
0:13:54 and we come to the conclusion that
0:13:56 actually when you came to predicting the
0:13:58 future you did a miserable job you did
0:14:01 not do the right thing and therefore in
0:14:04 addition to all of those evidences that
0:14:07 point to the fact that problem house our
0:14:08 salah is the final messenger you also
0:14:10 have these clear evidences to the
0:14:13 brothers to the sisters in humanity
0:14:15 there are many brothers and sisters
0:14:16 which claim which clearly show
0:14:19 unequivocally ambiguously that Allah
0:14:22 Muhammad made false prophecies with this
0:14:24 legend gentlemen why I think we have to
0:14:26 be humble and I apologize if I came
0:14:29 across the lip of passion but it's very
0:14:30 important matter if we're gonna yeah me
0:14:33 leave a sort of album I'm going to leave
0:14:35 the bulk of the Muslim
0:14:37 body in their reasoning that remark
0:14:39 system is the final perfect the question
0:14:41 is there has to be some incredibly
0:14:43 strong evidences neither this man show
0:14:46 voilá moment that he had a revelation
0:14:49 from his own words or from the
0:14:52 information that is provided up on
0:14:54 Amazon
0:14:55 we invite the brothers and sisters in a
0:14:57 comedy sect to come to a mainstream
0:15:00 Islam and shot a lot to just go back to
0:15:03 what the Sahaba believed him
0:15:04 feminine women you meant to be for buddy
0:15:07 fellow into a loafer in them at home
0:15:08 Fisher Park if I say ik fecal mobilize
0:15:10 the Quran says if they believe in what
0:15:12 you guys believe in them they're on the
0:15:13 right path and if they go away from that
0:15:15 then they are in France question I just
0:15:18 say to the brothers let's go back to
0:15:19 what the Sahaba said on these matters
0:15:20 let's see what the morph SEO Hyun said
0:15:22 let's see what the exegete said for
0:15:24 hundreds of years was the Prophet
0:15:26 Mohammed the final prophet or not did
0:15:28 they understand it linguistically as
0:15:29 that I think you'll find that they did
0:15:32 please consider Sunni Islam Andrew oh
0:15:36 happy happy happy with open arms
0:15:38 well salam alikum warahmatu allahi learn
0:15:40 it