0:00:09 foreign
0:00:12 Music
0:01:03 these episodes are broadcast live on the
0:01:06 study Circles of Professor Dr Muhammad
0:01:07 al-masri YouTube channel every Sunday at
0:01:10 1pm
0:01:11 we invite you to subscribe to the
0:01:13 channel and activate the notification
0:01:14 Bell for all new content
0:01:16 please note also the link to the live
0:01:18 broadcast for widely dissemination
0:01:20 do not forget to interact with us during
0:01:22 the broadcast by participating in the
0:01:23 comments and asking questions through
0:01:25 the chat box you find via the broadcast
0:01:27 link next to the video don't forget to
0:01:29 support our activities by donating and
0:01:31 asking questions in the conversation or
0:01:33 through the thank you button under our
0:01:34 video today is Sunday the 25th of
0:01:37 December 2022 uh Christmas Day the
0:01:40 professor continues the interpretation
0:01:41 of Surah
0:01:43 um we are now on versus
0:01:45 is-70 and 71.
0:01:48 so we finished 70 last time I think we
0:01:51 discuss it extensively
0:01:53 so let's continue with the next one and
0:01:55 there's some comments there of value for
0:01:58 the next one concerning they were having
0:01:59 doc three and about worship and things
0:02:01 like that but let's just read the IFS
0:02:03 foreign
0:02:16 foreign
0:02:32 like one of whom the satans have enticed
0:02:34 into blundering after Earthly lusts the
0:02:36 while his companions trying to guide him
0:02:38 call out unto him from afar Come Thou to
0:02:41 us say verily God's guidance is the only
0:02:44 guidance and so we have been bitten to
0:02:47 surrender ourselves unto the sustainer
0:02:49 of all the worlds in translation
0:02:52 say instead of God will we call on
0:02:54 something that can neither benefit nor
0:02:56 harm us and turn back after God has
0:02:58 guided us this would be like someone
0:03:00 seduced having been tempted by Satan's
0:03:02 Earthly lusts though his companions are
0:03:05 calling him to guidance saying come to
0:03:07 us say God's guidance is the only
0:03:10 guidance and we are commanded to
0:03:11 surrender ourselves to the lord of the
0:03:13 Worlds okay so it's very clear but the
0:03:17 the metaphorical example of someone
0:03:19 being being seduced or or scattered
0:03:22 around by by the satans and he has
0:03:25 combining calling home calling him for
0:03:27 for that will come to us save yourself
0:03:29 could be either the second translation
0:03:32 seems to be going more than metaphorical
0:03:33 way
0:03:34 seduced in life and so on and some of
0:03:37 his companions say you are you are lost
0:03:39 in life come to us and he's confused
0:03:40 someone who like we could have an
0:03:43 example of someone who is indulging in
0:03:46 in debauchery in drugs and alcohol and
0:03:49 things like that
0:03:51 and uh confused agnostic and things like
0:03:54 that and some of his friends and so on
0:03:56 are on the right path and tell them you
0:03:58 are confused you are scattered come to
0:04:00 us let us show you the way and he's
0:04:02 unable to go anywhere because someone
0:04:04 called him from inside and the satanic
0:04:06 force is going on from the other side
0:04:08 and the desire for this one is um like
0:04:10 somebody someone at night lost in the
0:04:12 desert and they usually with the adopt
0:04:15 audition someone is lost at this
0:04:16 especially if he if he Fool by satanic
0:04:19 or demonic entities then
0:04:21 um maybe you you stray away from your
0:04:24 Caravan or Companions and they call you
0:04:26 but you are unable to recognize the
0:04:28 initiation Academy because they may
0:04:31 they may be voices coming from various
0:04:34 Direction by reflection on hair on Sand
0:04:37 Hills or the mountains so you cannot
0:04:39 distinguish between the original coal
0:04:41 and the and the echo so he's confuses
0:04:45 that's that's also the possibility of
0:04:48 acceleration that that example of the
0:04:50 seven one who is that have been
0:04:52 scattered and yet were confused by the
0:04:54 Satan so by the Demonic forces either
0:04:56 way both both metaphors are quite
0:05:00 telling someone is confused does not
0:05:03 find Direction but he has some good
0:05:04 companions like their confused
0:05:06 correction at that time some almost in
0:05:09 every family or in any Vehicles let's
0:05:12 say larger sub tribe a smaller sub-tribe
0:05:15 actually there's some believer and who
0:05:17 are trying to convince their relatives
0:05:19 their friends their their beloved one
0:05:21 you are you are scattered get your act
0:05:24 and come to us will guide you the right
0:05:26 way but Traditions desires business
0:05:30 interest and all of these things power
0:05:32 interest are keeping them away so that's
0:05:34 the metaphor
0:05:36 but I'm going to want to test is that uh
0:05:39 are we going to to uh to to call on
0:05:43 someone who doesn't harm us or benefit
0:05:45 us
0:05:47 interestingly we'll show you that why
0:05:52 why the wahhabi way of thinking which
0:05:55 led them as three is they are they they
0:05:58 think really that this statement is
0:06:01 waiting for whatever he really believe
0:06:03 that they believe that what they're
0:06:04 calling on does not harm or benefit but
0:06:06 this is breath until nonsensical it can
0:06:09 be it's so stupid it can't be but as he
0:06:13 has said is that are we supposed to call
0:06:15 something which we know according to
0:06:17 whether evidence of Russian evidence
0:06:18 truth or evidences according to our
0:06:20 belief at least but also according to
0:06:22 this reality as can be proven by by I
0:06:25 said rational evidences and skillful
0:06:27 evidences doesn't have the power of harm
0:06:29 and benefit and intrinsic power based of
0:06:33 his own being not a power given by
0:06:35 another entity or a power developed by
0:06:37 by natural causes and think of an
0:06:40 example nobody neither the addressee
0:06:44 dispute that your neighbor
0:06:46 can benefit you when you for example
0:06:48 when your car does not start to come say
0:06:50 hey neighbor or John or say do you have
0:06:53 a jumping cable say yes I have come help
0:06:55 me he can benefit you definitely but you
0:06:57 know he can benefit only with using a
0:06:59 jumping cable if he has it if he doesn't
0:07:00 have he cannot benefit and the German
0:07:02 cable is produced by someone else by a
0:07:04 factory and even the factory cannot
0:07:06 produce it without having metals and so
0:07:08 on but will produce and and Earth and
0:07:11 mined by someone else etc etc none of
0:07:13 these is really having power of benefit
0:07:16 intrinsically like Subs like something
0:07:18 which is supposed to be divine which has
0:07:21 benefited from intrinsically by its own
0:07:23 internal Sovereign power that's what
0:07:26 meant in the Ayah
0:07:28 so you want us to call on something
0:07:30 which according to our belief has
0:07:32 intrinsically you know power a benefit
0:07:34 or harm
0:07:35 has no real power has no creative power
0:07:37 has no Divinity genuine Divinity but
0:07:40 some somehow have you got blinded by the
0:07:44 definition of a ship for the
0:07:46 differential worship that they still
0:07:48 think that for example
0:07:50 um that uh that for example let me give
0:07:54 us a story invoke when we're in in
0:07:57 school in younger years that's what he
0:07:59 said they quote um said we were so so
0:08:02 stupid that we we used to to Fashion an
0:08:06 idol out of date and then we get angry
0:08:08 with the idea and then we are out of
0:08:10 debt then we pile a little Versant milk
0:08:13 a little bit more milk on top of it and
0:08:15 then start to assuming it
0:08:17 Omar is reporting what they were doing
0:08:19 the procedure they're using it's not
0:08:20 importing what I believe behind that is
0:08:22 but you have to think a little bit to
0:08:24 use the brain but this will have a
0:08:26 branded the aspastics according to rush
0:08:29 definition because why they milk milk on
0:08:33 it
0:08:33 this is a procedure to invoke the Divine
0:08:36 set and divine being Angels or the sons
0:08:39 of gods or other the ability to connect
0:08:41 with that pile and break the pile become
0:08:44 an idol or become or become an and
0:08:47 weapon either weapon or either an adult
0:08:48 made a distinction between Sodom and and
0:08:50 Idol a general Idol or a general symbol
0:08:54 of shirk and then and the symbol of
0:08:56 Sheikh which has a like a living being
0:08:58 shape or a human shape
0:09:01 is all called Idol
0:09:04 or a symbol of shark
0:09:07 so by this procedure but this procedure
0:09:10 still exists until now for example in
0:09:11 India they go to something like
0:09:13 representing uh Shiva fellows sectoria
0:09:16 fellows and then after putting milk on
0:09:18 it it represents Shiva somehow somehow
0:09:20 Shiva is connected to it and they can
0:09:22 address it as if it is Siva is there as
0:09:24 effective Shiva although they believe
0:09:26 she was in the high mountain of the
0:09:27 Himalaya anyway and it's a one of the
0:09:29 Trinity there in the further development
0:09:32 of the circle of India earlier it was
0:09:34 the the god of wind and then developed
0:09:37 over history into one of the three major
0:09:39 gods of India almost India not out of
0:09:42 India a number of other places India
0:09:43 Shiva is not recognized anyway but
0:09:45 that's it so
0:09:47 ignoring them that it is philosophical
0:09:49 and biological background of these
0:09:51 things and just looking at the surface
0:09:53 of it and thinking that the people
0:09:55 believe really that or Omar was behaving
0:09:57 really in general yeah that this pile of
0:09:59 sand after being being wetted by milk
0:10:03 has suddenly become Divine and Able by
0:10:06 itself as sand to head to benefit the
0:10:09 harm and worthy of worship is just a
0:10:11 blatant
0:10:13 I cannot find any other way to describe
0:10:16 that accepted absolutely nonsensical but
0:10:19 this is when you look at things
0:10:21 in a face value and make a wrong
0:10:25 definition and stick to it until The
0:10:27 Bitter End then it shows you that the
0:10:29 original division must not be wrong
0:10:31 so
0:10:32 I'm going to say we almost said we start
0:10:33 worshiping it meaning we attribute to a
0:10:35 Divinity and start at calling the Divine
0:10:39 being which is behind that that's the
0:10:40 meaning it cannot be otherwise because
0:10:42 neither or anybody always think that a
0:10:45 bit of milk and a bit of sand can buy
0:10:47 suddenly turned into a Divine being
0:10:49 that's impossible neither um
0:10:51 no anybody else
0:10:54 so that's very important to recognize
0:10:57 this that's this I alone is sufficient
0:11:00 if you understand it so they express the
0:11:02 believer we say are we going to call on
0:11:04 something which doesn't harm meaning
0:11:06 someone who has the genuine intrinsic
0:11:08 power of harminger the intrinsic power
0:11:11 device it's sovereign
0:11:15 Force it's not a Divine being you can't
0:11:18 call in it or you can't leave it as
0:11:20 needed and you will call on it only if
0:11:22 you think it's beneficial for example
0:11:25 Let me Give an example that our hobby
0:11:27 which take very big offensive someone
0:11:28 call on someone dead like Ali
0:11:31 yeah this is
0:11:35 but the question is that the one calling
0:11:38 that Ali what does he think what do you
0:11:39 think Ali is about most likely most
0:11:41 likely most Muslims although there are
0:11:43 some small factions here who really
0:11:45 value is divine
0:11:47 like like most Pauline Christian
0:11:50 currently believe that Jesus is divine
0:11:52 or somehow puff Divine or some or a mix
0:11:54 of divine and human or whatever
0:11:56 complicated you they have about them and
0:11:58 they call they call on the Divine Elisa
0:12:00 or the Divine Jesus or the Divine Christ
0:12:02 that's something else the belief in the
0:12:05 ability to proceed that but exclude
0:12:07 these those are not calling if you ask
0:12:10 them why you are calling Ali you say
0:12:12 Bali is close to Allah
0:12:14 and I don't call to Allah directly Ali
0:12:16 will be able to intercede and then and
0:12:18 help by approaching Allah in my behalf
0:12:20 then the issues they say is that right
0:12:23 is really is do you think Ali will hear
0:12:25 you first is that there is any evidence
0:12:28 for that if you check with him and
0:12:30 thoroughly you'll find really there's no
0:12:31 no evidence for that it's just something
0:12:33 told him by some Sufi and some uh some
0:12:37 some misguided people number one most
0:12:41 likely to control the other people
0:12:42 because this is a way to control the
0:12:43 people to keep them in the dark and be
0:12:45 resembled minded secondly uh uh even if
0:12:49 he hear you if there's any evidence that
0:12:51 that he is allowed to approach Allah in
0:12:54 any time in your behalf there's no
0:12:56 evidence for that it's just the opposite
0:12:57 even nobody can intercede except Allah
0:13:00 previous permission Allah has to give
0:13:02 her Mission first
0:13:04 things are more dire than in Dunya
0:13:06 unfortunately
0:13:07 not
0:13:09 but in either of the case this is not
0:13:11 worship this is this is this is a stupid
0:13:14 act based on on let me call it based on
0:13:18 a wrong perception ability on a mythical
0:13:20 or legendary point of view
0:13:27 this this does not entail initial it may
0:13:30 be better because if you declare it to
0:13:31 be the right way of doing things and
0:13:33 being desirable in Sharia that's better
0:13:35 but even that the one doing that maybe
0:13:37 not because he thinks he has an Evidence
0:13:39 he has a quote he is confused and think
0:13:42 he has an Evidence of his Sheikh give
0:13:43 him that fat one do you think the Sheikh
0:13:45 is referring to Quran Sunnah
0:13:47 himself
0:13:50 because he is inventing that but not the
0:13:52 one following so the method in in this
0:13:56 regard needs a little bit more scrutiny
0:13:57 now even tymia did not like that for
0:14:00 whatever reason
0:14:03 foreign
0:14:38 not that the truth come up apparent to
0:14:40 everyone benefit everyone and the
0:14:42 starting point or his starting point is
0:14:44 always what I have is definitely correct
0:14:46 I just to have get the other one to get
0:14:49 confused and get get scattered and get
0:14:51 defeated not come to the truth I want to
0:14:54 repeat him this this this this uh I
0:14:58 always call it the
0:14:59 this egoistic point of view this
0:15:01 self-assetting point of view
0:15:04 this arrogant point of view is not the
0:15:06 point of view of the probability beta
0:15:07 well not always tell us what to do so
0:15:12 hold on tell us to say Through the Bible
0:15:13 speaking on anybody else either we or
0:15:15 you are guided or misguided let us put
0:15:18 both options on the table and balance
0:15:19 the evidences
0:15:24 come come to the table either we are
0:15:27 right or wrong you may be right or wrong
0:15:28 but let's just put the table you will
0:15:30 point to you our point of view on the
0:15:31 new balance
0:15:32 this evidence for this what's your
0:15:34 evidence for this that's the way you get
0:15:35 to the truth not to start in in the
0:15:39 attitude that I am definitely right and
0:15:41 you are wrong and my job is to show that
0:15:44 you are wrong and defeat you not get you
0:15:46 to recognize the truth the moment you
0:15:48 have this attitude that's the arrogance
0:15:50 you are the way over the abyss and you
0:15:52 never succeed and that's what happened
0:15:54 with even Tamia so instead of just
0:15:56 indulging a discussion with so few of
0:15:58 his time
0:16:00 he may have not liked what they are
0:16:02 doing for example like Ali or yeah I
0:16:05 also love something like that for for
0:16:07 good or bad reason
0:16:09 instead of indulging inena he declared
0:16:11 that to be a shark and then he built all
0:16:14 the argument that the sherica taking
0:16:15 after he did not say really he did not
0:16:17 go to extend say taking alternative for
0:16:19 himself say Shirk and did not specify as
0:16:21 above taking out the Islam or there's
0:16:23 just available
0:16:36 so that the people say oh he's
0:16:38 charitable he's generous that's real to
0:16:41 show off showing off his check because
0:16:43 you are you you you are associated to
0:16:45 your intention we should be to Allah
0:16:47 only in the case of charity
0:16:49 you Associated someone else in this
0:16:52 intention but this is
0:16:55 Despicable it will negative the benefit
0:16:58 of your sadakite in my latest but it
0:17:00 doesn't let your Iman or take you out of
0:17:03 Islam definitely not but just by him the
0:17:05 mere act of showing off it's not enough
0:17:08 to take care of the world of Islam but
0:17:09 it is enough to negate that act all the
0:17:13 benefits of the ACT has gone you don't
0:17:15 got any reward for it it's gone it's nil
0:17:18 so he did not say that I mean I think
0:17:21 she took the double sword and then
0:17:23 sharpened it and start cutting the
0:17:24 people's necks because of the starting
0:17:27 with the wrong definition the mayor
0:17:29 calling the Ali is already and making
0:17:31 Ali Divine by calling ali um
0:17:34 you are worshiping Ali when you call Adi
0:17:36 or you're recording while he's dead and
0:17:40 absent maybe they make an exception for
0:17:42 the prophet because there's some ah he's
0:17:43 saying that the Salah reached them and
0:17:45 so on but anybody else there is no
0:17:47 Hadith verse so they say this way you
0:17:49 think the dead can hear you so he must
0:17:51 be by intrinsic power he must be
0:17:53 regarding as Divine in the background
0:17:55 but they never argue this way because if
0:17:57 they argue this in a structured way they
0:17:59 will defeat the argument is defeated
0:18:00 right now we say no no it's not it's not
0:18:02 necessary like that so the mirror code
0:18:05 is very bad and by this definition this
0:18:08 faulty definition of a body of worship
0:18:10 everything has been destroyed completely
0:18:13 finished uncon
0:18:16 and that's that's what that's the
0:18:18 realist has a heel of the habitocrine
0:18:21 which is blatantly contradicting Quran
0:18:24 and in some places contractual such a
0:18:26 way that's really a statement of cover
0:18:28 like the claim that a lot is a man who
0:18:31 has been a good man who was was was was
0:18:34 charitably uh
0:18:36 needing those for the meeting
0:18:40 so he's the one who does the door the
0:18:43 the the don't need any any need neither
0:18:45 that's a lot for the whole judge and
0:18:47 when he died the the Belgium a grave and
0:18:50 then one of them and they started
0:18:51 worshiping him which is obviously
0:18:53 contradiction we come later each other
0:18:55 for Allah give us enough life and time
0:18:57 to get there a certain energy was clear
0:18:59 that Allah is a Divine entity it's
0:19:01 either the the consort of Allah may
0:19:04 Allah started above that or one of his
0:19:06 daughters it's a Divine entity it's a
0:19:08 it's a supernatural being has nothing to
0:19:12 do with a man doing anything that the
0:19:13 world or anything like that and this is
0:19:15 we devoted for that almost a complete
0:19:19 chapter about Circle Arab and some some
0:19:21 sections main section about a lot and
0:19:23 the nature of that ocean and that
0:19:25 statement by itself is obviously
0:19:27 declared the Quran to be false and
0:19:29 statement of government by itself so
0:19:31 that's how it gets there you start with
0:19:33 the wrong definition
0:19:35 by by taking a partisan point of view
0:19:38 and a certain point
0:19:40 and then going through an extreme and
0:19:43 then you go go astray and then you think
0:19:45 this is the read and in reality it end
0:19:47 to being uh instead of being sorry the
0:19:50 tense in real to being sure
0:19:52 unfortunately that's reality of that to
0:19:55 a habit okay that ahead of of graves is
0:20:02 besides even the even the wording itself
0:20:05 is is is is is an attempt to to demean
0:20:09 the other side because those who are
0:20:11 supposed to be worshiping the dead
0:20:12 they're not worshiping the grave itself
0:20:14 they are worshiping the dead if they are
0:20:16 worshiping anything then is the dead and
0:20:19 said but they don't say worshiping the
0:20:20 dead or worshiping they say worshiping
0:20:23 the graves to make it look even even
0:20:25 more disgusting and loading the reality
0:20:28 of the game is just a place let's ask
0:20:30 through in the game but but they made
0:20:33 even the graveyard as an idol
0:20:35 representing the dead and the dead is
0:20:37 the Divine being by the mere Act of
0:20:38 calling on it this is all nonsense well
0:20:41 this area is enough to refute it if you
0:20:43 take it just a symbol straightforward
0:20:45 Lexus I have and the Arabs at that time
0:20:47 but I haven't understood that way that I
0:20:50 believe is saying we're not going to
0:20:51 call something which it has no intrinsic
0:20:53 power or benefited up
0:20:55 while you're calling something you
0:20:57 believe it has that but you are full
0:20:59 your belief is wrong because of these
0:21:02 and these and these evidences after we
0:21:03 have received the guidance of Allah to
0:21:05 us which shows that it is either do not
0:21:08 exist or if they exist in some sense
0:21:11 like Angels they don't have an intrinsic
0:21:13 power of harm and no they have any
0:21:16 Divine genology so
0:21:18 so how we are calling on them giving
0:21:20 them a Divine attributes I'm calling on
0:21:22 them based on the Divine attribution
0:21:24 that's that's like that's really where
0:21:27 the shark comes from not by the mere
0:21:28 calling
0:21:30 is
0:21:32 if you recognize that then you can
0:21:34 destroy the whole happy point of view
0:21:36 completely and the Quran destroyed by
0:21:38 this eye alone and there are many other
0:21:39 eyes will come and they try everywhere
0:21:41 to show every time where you can have uh
0:21:44 argument to destroy their uh their their
0:21:46 falsehood
0:21:48 which has blatantrive also because but
0:21:51 but we we took long-winded approach in
0:21:54 the book of every point every
0:21:56 misconception exposing it giving them a
0:22:00 benefit of doubt maybe they meant that
0:22:02 maybe they meant that you you see it uh
0:22:04 it will come in the translation but
0:22:06 those who can read Arabic will will be
0:22:09 able to advance quickly and get there
0:22:11 both in the chapter five the the reality
0:22:14 of the circle Arab which shows that all
0:22:17 their imagination about the circle Arab
0:22:19 is completely false they they look at
0:22:21 some Arabs who are living maybe on Mars
0:22:24 not on Earth the option as a completely
0:22:26 different and their beliefs and they had
0:22:28 about I about the gods and and the
0:22:31 goddesses and so on is utterly different
0:22:33 than what they were habiting it's
0:22:34 completely different starting from a lot
0:22:37 the one who needs the door all the way
0:22:39 to another Divinity and entities would
0:22:41 they if they mentioned they mentioned
0:22:43 casually and they run away quickly
0:22:46 so that's that's just this area should
0:22:48 be enough if it's red reasonably well
0:22:51 that's all what you need don't indeed
0:22:53 even much of a philosophical
0:22:55 sophistication the only thing is just
0:22:57 when was it are we going to call
0:22:58 something which benefit us or hummus
0:23:00 what's meaning of benefits what what
0:23:03 what's the benefit around method the one
0:23:04 who is by intrinsic power of the one who
0:23:06 does that
0:23:07 not anyone because we and everyone in
0:23:10 the world agrees that your neighbor can
0:23:12 help you with a jumping cable
0:23:19 you're a shepherd and some of your
0:23:21 animals cows or comments run away you
0:23:23 can call someone help me hold that Camel
0:23:25 someone can help you because he has the
0:23:27 accountability of holding the comment
0:23:28 nobody ever neither neither a Hindu nor
0:23:31 an Arab Northern someone in Amazon
0:23:33 believe that by calling this man you
0:23:35 declare them to be divine or this had
0:23:37 the energy to do an act of worship or
0:23:39 any belief that this one is is doing
0:23:41 that by intrinsic divine power it's a
0:23:43 difference in the recording
0:23:46 someone to hold your camel who are
0:23:48 running away hold that camel or restrain
0:23:51 that camel or whatever
0:23:53 is rolling away stop that car push the
0:23:57 brake or something like that and the
0:23:58 defender say oh God do that to me
0:24:00 everyone recognize the difference
0:24:02 intrinsically by by his own nature
0:24:05 everyone recognized that but our hobbies
0:24:07 are blinded from that because they
0:24:09 started on the wrong footing and they
0:24:11 never came back
0:24:13 so just uh just for this this one is
0:24:16 enough really to undermine what what the
0:24:18 what they have just recognize that this
0:24:20 is
0:24:22 saying what they believe about
0:24:25 those entities whether Michelle King
0:24:27 believe that they benefit and harm by
0:24:29 their intrinsic power
0:24:31 because there is no discussion about
0:24:33 other people who can benefit and harm
0:24:36 not by their physical but by the
0:24:37 capabilities which are given them by
0:24:39 Nature by Allah by the law of nature but
0:24:42 about the conditions and so on no this
0:24:44 is the in benefited harm by an entity
0:24:46 which has the power of Friends by its
0:24:49 own intrinsic Sovereign or a Divine
0:24:51 being that's it
0:24:53 don't you recognize that all problems of
0:24:56 the wahhabi doctrine are solved
0:24:58 everything is gone
0:24:59 but unfortunately we need to be
0:25:02 long-winded the book of going to every
0:25:05 small point so that the these guys are
0:25:07 maybe awakened but still they are not
0:25:09 awakened amazingly that's another Wicked
0:25:14 so that's that's the point I want to
0:25:16 test for this the rest is clear and the
0:25:18 conclusive will say the guidance of
0:25:21 Allah is the ritual guidance
0:25:23 and we have been commanded to surrender
0:25:25 to the lord of the universes
0:25:29 alone
0:25:36 that's it one second
0:25:40 and B and to be consistent in prayer and
0:25:42 conscious of him for it is he unto whom
0:25:45 we you shall all you also be gathered as
0:25:48 transition and to keep our prayers and
0:25:50 be mindful of him it is to him you will
0:25:52 all that you will all be gathered yeah
0:25:54 so that's just clear that's a standard
0:26:12 spinal cord of your life
0:26:15 which is uh which is uh essentially like
0:26:19 for example and when we take a talk
0:26:21 about sarula as long as they establish
0:26:24 they say they won't know the website
0:26:26 they would be rulers which have these
0:26:27 and these and these negative aspects and
0:26:29 then they asked if we assume the Hadith
0:26:31 is authentic will seem to be authentic
0:26:33 at least in some good weddings because
0:26:35 there's some some falsification certain
0:26:36 words that's in the in the accounting
0:26:39 with the rulers and also on the
0:26:40 obedience to the to the rulers discuss
0:26:43 these things especially in the second
0:26:44 edition to come soon where we have
0:26:46 scrutinized more channels of narration
0:26:48 and detecting some some uh some
0:26:50 publication and some playing with words
0:26:52 but that's that's notable not the time
0:26:55 to do that so establish salafi in the
0:26:57 case of the ruler what does ministers
0:27:02 like for example
0:27:04 when you say you have listened to obey
0:27:08 even if it is if it is obviously
0:27:10 appealing to the Arab uh tribalism and
0:27:14 racism even if it's a if it's an
0:27:17 Abyssinian slave uh who's who's even
0:27:19 noses cut away
0:27:21 as long as he guides you with the book
0:27:23 of Allah so let's explain what we
0:27:25 established
0:27:26 meaning is guide by the book of Allah
0:27:29 established the Deen in what is a
0:27:32 attribute to the rulers
0:27:34 not like what Taliban thinks that they
0:27:36 can interfere things which Allah do not
0:27:38 make it to the ruler but the distributed
0:27:40 at them because the Lord is not having
0:27:41 an absolute authority over everything
0:27:43 the messenger Allah did not have even
0:27:45 absolutely over everything let alone
0:27:47 these guys claim they have absolutely
0:27:49 preventing someone from going to
0:27:50 University or something like that no no
0:27:52 that's not that's not even the missile
0:27:54 did not have that absolutely this he has
0:27:57 Authority in certain areas calling for
0:27:59 Jihad writing the people calling for
0:28:02 charity collecting zakah controlling
0:28:04 currency only areas which the the
0:28:08 Revelation has clearly sanctioned and
0:28:10 many areas he abstained from an
0:28:12 interfering and doing anything as we
0:28:14 will show in the various evidences and
0:28:15 very values of our writing
0:28:33 just to remember that and keep it like a
0:28:36 medicine remind your life for example be
0:28:39 alive but you cannot stay alive without
0:28:41 having food one meal a day or another
0:28:43 maybe you can fast for three four days
0:28:46 but at least one meal of the day four
0:28:47 days if you don't eat what similar weeks
0:28:50 you'll die or if you don't drink at
0:28:52 least for
0:28:53 seven days you will be dead you have to
0:28:56 you have to replenish this this
0:28:58 Consciousness and that's what has Allah
0:29:00 told Musa in a summary in the Quran
0:29:02 summarization
0:29:04 discussion with Musa of Mount Sinai
0:29:08 it's a very long-winded that's also
0:29:09 discussed in the book of according to
0:29:11 Old Testament and the summary of the
0:29:12 Quran is very simple
0:29:15 welcome I am Allah the only necessary
0:29:19 existing that eternal and and the Old
0:29:22 Testament say when that's what your name
0:29:24 say tell them that I am who is he who is
0:29:27 He Who
0:29:28 here over I am the one who is I am the
0:29:31 Eternal I am the necessarily existing
0:29:34 but the Quran summarized that after that
0:29:36 a personal name of Allah has been
0:29:38 developed to Allah before that Allah in
0:29:41 the Aramaic and then in Arabic Allah
0:29:44 anymore now we have a specific name for
0:29:47 us
0:29:51 surrender to me
0:29:52 and establish prayer to remember me so
0:29:55 you keep remembering this fact so Salah
0:29:58 is to remember last Friday is not to
0:30:00 worship the worship is done before the
0:30:02 life is not a worship all the people
0:30:04 think it's an act of worship because the
0:30:06 focus is
0:30:10 in Consciousness to have to have the
0:30:13 medicine every day five times uh a day
0:30:17 so you keep remembered so you don't get
0:30:19 divorcedure degree
0:30:23 foreign
0:30:27 and human beings are not
0:30:30 omnipresent in their mind so they need
0:30:32 remembrance that those are established
0:30:33 to have their members and the Salah
0:30:35 should be the key for Attack Of
0:30:38 Consciousness it should be if it is done
0:30:41 properly unconsciously
0:30:44 so this this distinction between fat
0:30:46 muttony and uh uh
0:30:51 um is that whether you're making this
0:30:53 distinction that ibada being the
0:30:55 fundamental premise being the worship
0:30:57 and recognition of sovereignty and then
0:30:59 Salah being the remote remembrance yes
0:31:02 remember this fact and keep it always
0:31:06 present in your mind because you cannot
0:31:09 keep these these things continuously in
0:31:11 your mind as a finite being but they are
0:31:14 continuous in our last might
0:31:16 that is the submarine there's no moment
0:31:18 whatever small it is that he is not
0:31:20 conscious of that absolutely and
0:31:22 certainly but human beings cannot be
0:31:24 that if you go out to work you may be
0:31:28 several hours you have only workout for
0:31:30 from two you don't even remember that
0:31:32 that you that you live even you don't
0:31:33 even conscious of your own being
0:31:36 who are you are working
0:31:37 you're just working
0:31:39 for example
0:31:40 so you have to have breaks remember aha
0:31:44 there is a sovereign ultimate sovereign
0:31:48 and they have to be conscious of his
0:31:50 creative presence in the universe and
0:31:53 his creating his legislative sovereignty
0:31:57 and that's Allah will remind you to
0:31:59 remind you of that so the Salah will
0:32:02 will will will will will will
0:32:04 uh invigorate and regenerate your taqwa
0:32:08 your Consciousness that's thicker
0:32:11 that's it
0:32:12 oh that's clear in the in the statement
0:32:14 of Allah to summarizing the long
0:32:16 discussion with Musa if you look at the
0:32:18 Old Testament this guy was very long
0:32:21 why was what was the name in your in the
0:32:24 in your great grandfather as well what's
0:32:25 your name they are using that's also in
0:32:27 the book of translated that it was
0:32:29 called the strong God Elijah died there
0:32:31 was no specific name for Allah for the
0:32:33 Supreme Being and then and then say that
0:32:36 okay which name should I tell him always
0:32:37 send me because they have so many names
0:32:39 whatever they it is the Egyptian now
0:32:42 which one sent me which one is that it's
0:32:44 not clear which one is it
0:33:04 he is he
0:33:06 he is he sent me the one who is who the
0:33:10 one who exists the one who is the
0:33:11 necessarily existed the one who is
0:33:13 eternal
0:33:16 and then another tool to keep permanent
0:33:19 players to remember
0:33:21 summarizing the other Commandments and
0:33:23 others who gave to him
0:33:27 that's a specific things to do specific
0:33:30 action but this is the main the
0:33:32 fundamental one and the rest of Justice
0:33:34 things related to saving by the Israel
0:33:36 so that Allah is fulfilling his promise
0:33:39 to to Ibrahim and yakub and so on in
0:33:41 time past
0:33:42 okay but this is another issue not for
0:33:44 today
0:33:45 it will come sorted out of also if the
0:33:48 debate we discussed about Taliban and
0:33:50 education the
0:33:53 the remit or the or the Restriction to
0:33:55 the rulership is it based on
0:33:58 Ayah Hadith precedent which you
0:34:00 understand
0:34:02 so you gave the example in the Banning
0:34:05 University for women going to University
0:34:07 and things like that okay I I mentioned
0:34:10 that casually because I said I came and
0:34:12 when you say you should not pull the
0:34:14 sword against the world as long as they
0:34:15 they appears
0:34:21 establish a Deen guide by the book of
0:34:25 Allah and I just mentioned casually
0:34:27 meaning
0:34:29 apply those rulings who are relevant to
0:34:32 the rulers and upsetting from that who
0:34:34 is the ruler is bad from doing
0:34:35 interfering in it let me saying himself
0:34:38 did not interfere in many things which
0:34:40 he was barbed and then feeling these
0:34:42 things so these guys attributed himself
0:34:44 that they have the right to intervene
0:34:45 things Allah did not do
0:34:48 and if there's any ruler has more
0:34:50 authorities than him that will be
0:34:52 amazing that's that's so casually yeah
0:34:54 yeah but you know just so in terms of so
0:34:57 again there's a prophet didn't do a
0:34:59 certain actors what's the indication to
0:35:01 say he was barred from actually
0:35:03 legislating Beyond or imposing Beyond
0:35:05 except for example he was bad from
0:35:07 killing them
0:35:08 but that's that's an act of that's like
0:35:10 life and death life and death you need a
0:35:12 yeah that's it no no no you had nothing
0:35:15 he is Bob from for example
0:35:18 a punishing woman who who are not are
0:35:21 not a Muslim women who are noticed
0:35:24 probably except those who are doing
0:35:28 and they were ordered you will not do
0:35:32 that of naked that's a public or the
0:35:34 issue that's the only thing otherwise
0:35:36 when when for example there is a Hadith
0:35:38 that some woman that asthma or another
0:35:40 woman was not addressed probably he
0:35:42 turned away he turned her back to it
0:35:43 that's all and when he mentioned the
0:35:45 women who are naked and and addressed
0:35:49 and naked it says a lot of the famous
0:35:50 Hadith there would be there would be
0:35:52 women who are naked and dressed etc etc
0:35:54 what did he order the people to do
0:35:58 beat them kill them
0:36:02 curse them they are cursed if you say
0:36:05 someone that cares that's it you have no
0:36:08 one Authority than that
0:36:10 you don't think the messenger Allah has
0:36:11 missed that
0:36:15 um
0:36:20 obvious people claim the ruler is have
0:36:22 the right to discipline the people and
0:36:24 be like a father no he's not like a
0:36:25 father
0:36:26 this has to manage the Affairs within
0:36:28 the limitation of sharia
0:36:33 you have no control over them
0:36:36 except what's later on
0:36:38 that's absolute that's in Mecca that has
0:36:42 been restricted
0:36:43 this General you have no control of them
0:36:45 and anything whatsoever but later in
0:36:47 Medina he has certain controls we see
0:36:50 exercised and other he did not exercise
0:36:56 yeah
0:36:58 yep yep
0:37:00 and we know that for for a fact for
0:37:03 please for a fact
0:37:09 but has to all all these incidents have
0:37:12 to be collected and and even the the the
0:37:14 the sahaba and tab you're in Italian for
0:37:17 example Buster said we have to obey the
0:37:19 rulers and he mentioned five things in
0:37:21 in currencies in second route so the the
0:37:26 official currency uh which which is
0:37:28 coined by by the rulers has to be used
0:37:31 doesn't prevent you from using another
0:37:32 currency by the way by the way again
0:37:34 Parliament by preventing people from
0:37:36 using for the Bitcoins is transgressing
0:37:39 their limit
0:37:40 yeah that that official currency my
0:37:43 everyone
0:37:45 can use and should use but does not
0:37:47 prevention of Music another currency
0:37:49 because of the Hadith gold for gold
0:37:51 server for Server wheat for wheat if
0:37:52 someone said no I want to trade with
0:37:54 that for wheat and so on then you cannot
0:37:57 you can't prevent him from that using it
0:37:59 as a currency these people are just
0:38:01 Jokers the the scholars latest Scholars
0:38:04 let's go to the term
0:38:07 they have they have the tools
0:38:10 how do we know that from the Hadith say
0:38:13 or forgive between yourself because
0:38:16 Eddie had to reached me it become
0:38:18 obligatory there is no forgiveness and
0:38:20 no intercession so meaning you should
0:38:23 not
0:38:24 establish or do it by yourself it's only
0:38:26 for the ruler
0:38:28 you should forgive us to do it actually
0:38:30 between yourself not the opposite
0:38:34 not the opposite
0:38:37 see my point
0:38:40 I'm sorry so many we have to put all
0:38:42 these together and to have a clear
0:38:43 picture of really a decentralized
0:38:46 minimal State Islamic stated this
0:38:48 centralized Minima a federal state not
0:38:50 like what has the Tariff thought and the
0:38:52 scholars from the time of of the
0:38:54 oppressive ongoing they try to construct
0:39:00 and this construction started really
0:39:02 seriously in the third generation second
0:39:04 generation like a hasselberry and others
0:39:06 they were they were not agreeing that
0:39:08 ruler has authority over these things
0:39:10 they did not agree they have to
0:39:13 mentioned five things another scholar of
0:39:15 the same generation measures seven
0:39:16 things so dude uh protection protecting
0:39:20 the borders Jihad obviously because
0:39:22 Waging War and so on needs the state
0:39:24 Authority and it needs a writing the
0:39:26 people of organization armies by
0:39:27 necessity is unemployable that people
0:39:30 just go the border and wage war at
0:39:32 desire that's not doesn't work this way
0:39:34 and uh and this is
0:39:38 ETC even even even
0:39:40 Confederates like the Jews were not
0:39:42 allowed to go on war outside Medina with
0:39:44 the permission the prophet so that's it
0:39:46 let's just have to go to the head of the
0:39:47 Confederation even that was the War and
0:39:50 Peace what else a few other things
0:39:53 it's not absolutely that people think
0:40:00 okay
0:40:01 but this is a lengthy issue which needs
0:40:04 more more collection of all the evidence
0:40:06 and so on and deeper analysis and but
0:40:09 looking at the sales generally you will
0:40:10 see what's going on there
0:40:12 completely clear and unobvious but you
0:40:15 have to look at all the Sierra and all
0:40:17 the evidences not taking half an Ayah or
0:40:20 half a Hadith and and build them build
0:40:22 the Palaces and they are like most data
0:40:25 scholar did
0:40:26 mostly is done to justify the oppressive
0:40:28 rules of
0:40:30 bus and give it some legitimacy
0:40:34 and the data then constructed they then
0:40:37 constructed a whole
0:40:39 Mountain outer wall Hill
0:40:45 okay but this is I say this is not an
0:40:47 issue there they are real well in the
0:40:49 more fundamentally philosophical meaning
0:40:52 of worship and meaning of remembrance
0:40:54 and paqwa
0:40:57 and then the Quran assess again as usual
0:40:59 in many occasions
0:41:02 you will be gathered to him so keep that
0:41:06 in mind so that's the whole thing is not
0:41:09 only
0:41:10 it is so basically a rationally sound it
0:41:13 has repercussions also in method
0:41:15 accountability and Punishment and reward
0:41:18 s Divinity is philosophically sound even
0:41:21 if there was no Resurrection it is still
0:41:23 sound that The Sovereign of the universe
0:41:25 deserve to be worshiped
0:41:27 and respected under his commands to be
0:41:29 submitted to even if there is nobody
0:41:31 punishment and they won't
0:41:35 I mean in the afterlife there may be
0:41:37 just a management reward in Dunya
0:41:41 etc etc
0:41:44 you have to be conscious of him
0:41:46 definitely because he is the primary
0:41:49 existence he does also about being and
0:41:51 although that exist all free will so you
0:41:54 should be conscious about that that's no
0:41:56 doubt but actually compelling
0:41:58 but that is not only that it's more even
0:42:01 that it is a religious Duty adhesive
0:42:03 meaning it will be accountable and there
0:42:05 will be it's not only a rational Duty
0:42:07 it's also a religious Duty the
0:42:09 difference between Russia duty is that
0:42:11 something which is the reason dictate to
0:42:13 be good and well balanced in a rational
0:42:16 terms but her religious duty is in
0:42:18 addition to that should be obviously
0:42:20 based on a rational Duty in addition to
0:42:22 that there will be accountability and
0:42:24 reward and Punishment after a master
0:42:26 life
0:42:28 foreign
0:42:58 and he it is who has created the heavens
0:43:01 and the Earth in accordance with an
0:43:03 inner truth and whenever he says be his
0:43:06 word comes true
0:43:07 and his will be the Dominion of the on
0:43:10 the day when the trumpet of Resurrection
0:43:12 is blown he knows all that is beyond the
0:43:14 reach of a created being's perception as
0:43:17 well as all that can be witnessed by a
0:43:19 creature's senses for all mind or he
0:43:21 alone is truly wise all aware next
0:43:24 translation it is he who has created the
0:43:26 heavens and the Earth in truth and
0:43:28 whenever he says be it will be his word
0:43:31 is the truth all control on the day of
0:43:33 the of all contrail are all control on
0:43:36 the day of judgment
0:43:37 oh sorry on the day the trumpet is blown
0:43:39 belongs to him he knows all that is
0:43:41 beyond human's perception as well as all
0:43:44 that can be witnessed by human senses
0:43:46 for he is well he alone is the wise all
0:43:49 aware okay so the two eyes act 28 and
0:43:53 here in duri and simply one Ayah in your
0:43:56 account that's not a problem
0:43:58 so Allah is the one who created
0:44:01 with the truth so it's not it's not it's
0:44:05 not uh it's not a creation for just for
0:44:07 for vain or for for enjoyment or for uh
0:44:11 it has it has a it has a reason it has a
0:44:14 purpose and and is created by by the
0:44:19 true power of Allah all this is all it
0:44:21 is in itself intrinsically irrationally
0:44:23 compelling and rationally well-founded
0:44:26 as according to Allah's comprehensive
0:44:28 and absolute knowledge
0:44:30 so it's not there is not a is not
0:44:32 haphazard that's it and this is again
0:44:35 another form of others so if you see in
0:44:37 the universe something you think it may
0:44:39 be asynchronous or seem to be like
0:44:41 something evil or don't like it it is
0:44:43 more it is synchronous and fits with the
0:44:46 totality of the universe probably your
0:44:48 your vision is limited and you're seeing
0:44:50 only another part of the reality
0:44:53 another part of that even if it is
0:44:55 something is genuinely even like this
0:44:57 obedience to Allah and I guess
0:44:58 definitely genuinely evil because the
0:45:01 ability against the one who is the
0:45:02 ultimate Sovereign by necessity of
0:45:04 Reason must be evil but that could not
0:45:07 have happened his permission to invest
0:45:09 because he decided that creating beings
0:45:11 who caribel against him and have
0:45:13 sufficient free one and sufficient
0:45:15 rationality to do that
0:45:17 is is of highest value because the
0:45:20 absolutely Divine freedom and
0:45:22 sovereignty is the utmost Supreme value
0:45:25 you could imagine for a being which is
0:45:28 which is really uh one of the most
0:45:32 important characteristics of a Divinity
0:45:33 because necessary existing May Be
0:45:36 Imagined in something like a dead matter
0:45:38 like a nature obviously such a dead
0:45:40 nature does not exist it's impossible
0:45:42 most likely by ontological proof and by
0:45:44 cosmological rule but leave that alone
0:45:47 and the giving of that Supreme most
0:45:51 important as the beauty of divinity some
0:45:53 of it which is creatable to a being is
0:45:57 giving
0:45:59 utmost and the highest possible value
0:46:02 for creation
0:46:04 even if the result in some created being
0:46:07 Rebellion against him and a real genuine
0:46:11 evil action that's all
0:46:14 so from another point of view
0:46:16 rebellious which is definitely even in
0:46:19 itself but it doesn't balance out the
0:46:22 extremely high value of freedom of
0:46:25 choice and and Russian rationality even
0:46:28 if it's a limited one and freedom shows
0:46:29 even if the limited one because for
0:46:32 created being it cannot be absolute it's
0:46:34 not creatable for a limited one but this
0:46:36 is because this is an extremely high
0:46:38 value
0:46:40 it balances all of that and this is all
0:46:42 hack has no ton of Valor in his
0:46:44 comprehensive knowledge of the universe
0:46:46 you'll see only a section of the
0:46:48 universe and you may get confused about
0:46:50 that that's the problem that's how the
0:46:51 universe fashion Kaba is something else
0:46:53 we discussed that many times
0:46:56 our decision and action and events are
0:46:58 happening but other structure of the
0:47:01 universe fundamental structure is
0:47:03 definitely created by Rock
0:47:06 and
0:47:07 and the day or when he says it be it
0:47:11 happens his power is so that all what he
0:47:13 needs
0:47:15 is just direct his will he will
0:47:18 something that what he wants happens
0:47:20 that's like this well that's what some
0:47:22 people shows you beyond human perception
0:47:24 on human imagination but for Allah it's
0:47:26 very obvious and clear
0:47:28 we kind of country we can recall to
0:47:30 compiling we cannot imagine that because
0:47:32 the supernatural we are used to that
0:47:34 nothing happened without
0:47:36 ways means and tools Etc really because
0:47:39 that's the way finite and conditions
0:47:42 being worked but a necessary existing
0:47:44 being with absolute sovereignty or what
0:47:46 you need is just to directly
0:47:48 with something yeah under six fifth book
0:47:52 that's a metaphor obviously like because
0:47:56 there there's no need to say see it
0:47:58 happens or something like that it's just
0:48:01 expressing the direction of the will by
0:48:04 by saying
0:48:06 and there's a reason the Sophie say his
0:48:09 his command is doing the calf and the
0:48:11 Lord in Arabic it's a con is
0:48:15 command between the b and e b b e b e
0:48:18 between the b and e but this is all
0:48:20 metabolical expression because we when
0:48:23 we intend to do something then we Face
0:48:25 something in our mind as an action in
0:48:27 form of a linguistic expression that's
0:48:29 the way we work so metaphorically
0:48:32 how it is in the Divine being we don't
0:48:34 know like but it's Christian Michael
0:48:36 it's better to keep it like that I could
0:48:40 and I'll continue over the next hour
0:48:42 which I don't they didn't read another
0:48:44 book what you said when he says his
0:48:47 statement is the truth
0:48:50 every time it's not only for the day of
0:48:53 judgment and so on but every time but
0:48:55 obviously during the day he said that it
0:48:57 may hint that it's for the day of
0:48:59 judgment but it's actually everywhere
0:49:00 from the beginning of Eternity beginning
0:49:02 of time to the all eternities in the
0:49:04 future
0:49:05 whatever he said to me it is what he
0:49:08 says in the truth is never be a
0:49:09 falsehood and never be against the uh
0:49:13 the truthful nature of Allah being he
0:49:16 that he is himself the absolute truth is
0:49:18 Allah Allah is absolutely true in
0:49:20 himself
0:49:24 he has the kingdom in the day when the
0:49:27 trumpet is blown now this is
0:49:31 but he has a kingdom every everywhere
0:49:34 and all the time from the point of the
0:49:37 eternity the starting of absolute
0:49:39 existence at time all the way all in the
0:49:42 future without end so why specifying the
0:49:45 day when the trumpet is blown because
0:49:47 the kingdom becomes apparent
0:49:50 now the kingdom is hidden behind the
0:49:52 veil you don't see it you don't feel it
0:49:54 you may be confused until many people
0:49:57 who thinks there's no no King there it
0:49:59 is just a death a dead blind uh deaf
0:50:03 nature that's all what is there must not
0:50:05 think
0:50:06 no Kingdom
0:50:09 because Allah is behind the veil but the
0:50:12 trumpet is blown
0:50:13 he is present he's praying the veil is
0:50:16 lifted
0:50:17 then the kingdom is apparent
0:50:22 is blown is the apparent Kingdom but the
0:50:25 kingdom the sovereignty under control is
0:50:29 his from eternity to Eternity that's no
0:50:31 doubt about that by necessity of reason
0:50:33 I've been City abbreviation everywhere
0:50:37 and the day of resurrection of the day
0:50:39 of the the day of the trumpet is blown
0:50:41 now the trumpet is blown there are many
0:50:42 I had it about an angel is holding a
0:50:45 trumpet and looking up to uh to Allah
0:50:47 waiting for the command to blow the
0:50:50 trumpet and things like that and that's
0:50:52 all to give you a nice picture of like
0:50:55 like usually announcement of of a
0:50:57 beginning of a battle announcement of of
0:51:00 kings and time pass was usually by
0:51:02 blowing a trumpet so to give keep that
0:51:04 picture in your mind knowing that things
0:51:06 are and there's himself quite
0:51:09 unknown to us what they are but this
0:51:11 metaphor is very nice and you can enjoy
0:51:13 that picture and it's perfectly
0:51:14 legitimate to enjoy that picture so
0:51:16 don't indulge and then and all these uh
0:51:19 these uh uh intellectual acrobatic
0:51:23 versions what is the sword what is that
0:51:25 engine result holding the trumpet what's
0:51:26 it it is is that engine really
0:51:28 unconscious entity all of this may be a
0:51:31 field one of the fields uh no which
0:51:34 which uh and allegedly in some Hadith is
0:51:37 one of the carrier of the throne okay so
0:51:39 I feel okay one of the carriers of the
0:51:42 throne so but the color Throne are
0:51:43 supposed to be eight and who is one of
0:51:45 them so maybe there's one one one maybe
0:51:49 these carriers are symbolizing eight
0:51:52 fields and one of the fields will be
0:51:54 will be changed at that moment and
0:51:56 changing the universe we don't know all
0:51:57 of this speculation try to translate
0:51:59 that into physical world which the way
0:52:01 we see it here it's better to keep it as
0:52:04 it is
0:52:05 in that day when the day of distraction
0:52:07 is happening
0:52:09 which is reserved requests as that the
0:52:13 the blowing in the trumpet
0:52:18 that's where the kingdom become apparent
0:52:21 and this is also each line is foreign
0:52:33 who denied that because he said it's a
0:52:35 so obvious and evident and present to
0:52:37 everyone so is that absolute fact there
0:52:40 and everything for everything for
0:52:42 everyone here it is not evident for you
0:52:45 once enabled not able to feel conscious
0:52:46 being because they are behind the bill
0:52:51 and he's the one who knows the Unseen or
0:52:53 the things which we are doing a
0:52:56 conceptionalization that we think so
0:52:57 share behind human conception
0:53:00 could be things which are present at our
0:53:02 time like for example now we are
0:53:05 25th of December 20 2022.
0:53:09 oh there are things happening everywhere
0:53:12 in there especially in the remote
0:53:14 galaxies
0:53:15 now which will Impossible by any
0:53:18 physical mean to know unless billions of
0:53:21 years have passed in the future when I
0:53:23 will have already gone unexpired
0:53:26 maybe the galaxies will not exist at
0:53:28 that time and what we see now is that
0:53:30 what happened billions of years
0:53:32 past these galaxies there is no
0:53:34 guarantee that they are still there we
0:53:36 assume that they are there and they are
0:53:37 moving in this continue moving in that
0:53:39 direction and so on and we may construct
0:53:40 models but this is only assumption there
0:53:43 is no guarantee that that the universe
0:53:45 is starting to shrink there and we are
0:53:47 not aware about it yet it's not gonna
0:53:49 deal over that
0:53:51 so this is being human perception
0:53:52 although but in principles could have
0:53:55 been accessible but there are things to
0:53:56 shall be understood the future which in
0:53:58 the absolute time which has not happened
0:54:01 yet ever yet that's the only one because
0:54:04 of perception all of that is ripe I mean
0:54:07 the contingency the possibility in the
0:54:09 future all of that is right and there
0:54:10 are many other rights but even on Earth
0:54:12 here
0:54:13 for example this this uh this Malaysian
0:54:16 plane which disappeared suddenly and
0:54:18 nobody knows exactly where it is
0:54:21 is location until now it is ripe but
0:54:24 it's definitely somewhere in the Indian
0:54:26 Ocean
0:54:31 but we don't know what is
0:54:33 we don't have access to it and they're
0:54:35 still digging and working around and
0:54:36 where they were hopeful last year that
0:54:38 they found something but then the things
0:54:40 became cold again and then five six
0:54:43 years ago they were searching for a full
0:54:45 year
0:54:46 and they didn't find anything
0:54:48 and maybe have but it now unders have
0:54:50 some some mud and so on and will never
0:54:53 be founded today but we don't know maybe
0:54:55 you'll be found by accident we don't
0:54:57 know all of this is unknown
0:55:01 so here's the one only the only one who
0:55:03 knows always behind her with my
0:55:05 perception
0:55:06 that's got an conception
0:55:08 and also whatever whatever accessible to
0:55:11 us unfortunately if he knows that then
0:55:13 that's Etc is not him by greater reason
0:55:17 and he's the old wise the perfectionist
0:55:19 and the aware of the express
0:55:24 the one who knows things bye bye by by
0:55:26 experience it that's what habit has the
0:55:28 connotation of something because hebra
0:55:31 experience as you know if I feel apply
0:55:33 for a job that they ask about experience
0:55:35 knowledge which had gained by
0:55:37 experiencing things
0:55:38 Allah's knowledge is that is part of
0:55:41 Allah because he is the one creates
0:55:43 things so he knows how they will be
0:55:44 because he's the one created them so
0:55:46 this is the connotation the test which
0:55:48 you get from Javier he says Javier is
0:55:51 having another test and Alim think which
0:55:54 have been already happened in the past
0:55:55 and present they already done you know
0:55:57 he knows what they are now but things
0:55:59 which will happen in the future will be
0:56:01 created by the fact that he would be the
0:56:03 uncle sexing them and creating them and
0:56:04 allowing him to come into existence he
0:56:07 is expert in that sense if we allowed to
0:56:10 say something like that
0:56:13 foreign
0:56:16 goes to some stories about about the
0:56:18 prophets and so on starting with the
0:56:20 Ibrahim
0:56:21 um
0:56:30 hello Thus Spoke Abraham unto his father
0:56:32 Arthur hated their Idols for Gods verily
0:56:36 I say that thou and thy people have
0:56:38 obviously gone astray next translation
0:56:40 remember when Abraham spoke to his
0:56:42 father other and said how can you take
0:56:45 Idols as good I see that you and your
0:56:47 people are clearly lost okay so that's
0:56:52 that may be a little bit uh
0:56:56 confusing for some people who are not
0:56:58 aware about Abrahim Story another place
0:57:00 in the Quran it's to understand the full
0:57:02 story
0:57:03 you have to read the other place in the
0:57:05 Quran but it's by self-self-explanatory
0:57:07 but nevertheless to have the full
0:57:09 picture the full picture is the
0:57:10 following the way by the chapter six in
0:57:12 the book of the head is the Abrahim
0:57:14 story
0:57:15 a developed by taking all evidences from
0:57:17 the Quran because it's very utmost
0:57:20 importance for various reasons because
0:57:22 Ibrahim seems to be the first really
0:57:24 philosophy in human history
0:57:28 it started first of all that I clarified
0:57:31 the name of ibrahim's Father the eyes is
0:57:33 clearly his father name is Azad the Abi
0:57:36 and the scholars wavered out of that
0:57:38 because in the Old Testament say his
0:57:40 father is
0:57:50 telling you clearly that the genealogy
0:57:53 of the Old Testament is wrong simple we
0:57:55 don't need to to argue about that forget
0:57:57 about the argument on that that's it as
0:58:00 the father some scholar said actually
0:58:02 it's not his father his grandfather Azad
0:58:05 who his father just tried to save the
0:58:06 Old Testament no need for that because
0:58:08 the Old Testament let me just give you a
0:58:11 general rule how to deal with the Old
0:58:13 Testament
0:58:14 first of all it is not available
0:58:29 the first book
0:58:31 Genesis
0:58:32 we can divide in three areas
0:58:35 pray Ibrahim is essentially legendary
0:58:38 forget about it
0:58:40 you can't realize anything about that it
0:58:43 may be some stories but narrated by The
0:58:46 Prophet's interim with a vertical form
0:58:47 and then later people were not satisfied
0:58:49 with that and they added from their
0:58:51 imagination and the other footnotes and
0:58:53 spices and things like that to make it
0:58:55 more because you know how people are
0:58:57 they love to expand this story if you
0:58:59 tell them there was Noah and he has two
0:59:01 sons and so on and it's not very
0:59:03 satisfactory you have to add tails and
0:59:05 things like that you know that or he
0:59:07 built the ship and took the farm animals
0:59:09 with him so when they took all animals
0:59:11 on Earth including elephants there
0:59:17 and the flood flooded the people of news
0:59:20 the whole earth all of these and this is
0:59:23 all legendary that's not true that's all
0:59:24 not true let's pray Ibrahim from Ibrahim
0:59:27 Ibrahim started the philosophical and
0:59:30 the scholarly approach and his children
0:59:33 and so on and the in the in the Old
0:59:35 Testament there are very many indication
0:59:37 that for example even in the time they
0:59:39 were still nomads
0:59:41 like yakub they have another two tents
0:59:44 one tent was used as a school that's
0:59:46 what most scholar conclude because what
0:59:48 you should have two tenths the third
0:59:50 second is the school so even if they
0:59:52 were still nomadic they were concerned
0:59:55 with education and teaching them so they
0:59:57 would they have script they were reading
0:59:58 and they were having tradition so from
1:00:00 Abraham until the Exodus roughly
1:00:04 we can say this is
1:00:07 not bad reasonable history reasonable
1:00:10 history but Intel mixed with some
1:00:12 Legends attacks driver we can't rely
1:00:14 hundred percent maybe some dates
1:00:16 something like that could be gleaned
1:00:18 that genealogy is more or less accurate
1:00:20 things like that
1:00:22 from Exodus on going down then we have
1:00:25 generally
1:00:26 reliable reasonable history
1:00:29 with obviously Fabrications and
1:00:31 interjection until that's very clear the
1:00:33 example for that for example just go to
1:00:35 the book of of the of the Levites
1:00:38 Leviticus and the Book of Deuteronomy
1:00:41 they both describe with certain
1:00:43 differences uh the whole issues about
1:00:46 the uh kohen and their duties and so on
1:00:50 and the rest of things like that you
1:00:52 have if you compare the two there are
1:00:53 certain discrepancies and which shows
1:00:55 that one of them is data most likely
1:00:57 Deuteronomy and their certain adjustment
1:01:00 and possible fabrication and later
1:01:02 invention possibly and the scholar of
1:01:04 the Bible
1:01:05 relying on so-called text critic which
1:01:08 sometimes goes goes overboard but they
1:01:12 they assessing that that is it comes it
1:01:14 is it is constructed from various
1:01:17 documents not one document and cannot be
1:01:18 written by a Musa by necessary that's
1:01:20 that's it that's finished long ago and
1:01:23 is well done already by even has them
1:01:25 already said it's impossible that the
1:01:27 Firebox edited by Musa because the fifth
1:01:30 one describes his death no way he can
1:01:32 write his own death before he died
1:01:33 that's nonsense and also use my money is
1:01:36 used when my moon who is the one of the
1:01:38 biggest maybe the biggest Jewish
1:01:40 philosopher and scholar in the Middle
1:01:42 Ages who I think was generated in
1:01:45 Andalusia and became prime minister in
1:01:47 Egypt this one
1:01:49 this one says the same thing and he was
1:01:51 accused to be a cafe by the by the uh by
1:01:55 the Jewish Scholars and things like that
1:01:57 because of this statement so this is
1:01:59 this is dispatch this issue has done
1:02:01 long ago
1:02:03 but generally the the general genealogy
1:02:06 in the general history the dates and so
1:02:08 on because there is little incentives to
1:02:10 fabricate in these things uh seems to be
1:02:13 reasonable that's that's it
1:02:16 so concerning anything before Ibrahim we
1:02:21 cannot rely on it hundred percent and
1:02:23 there's no way we can certain that the
1:02:25 ibrahim's father name what it was or
1:02:28 whatever it is
1:02:29 not that so the Quran is to be given
1:02:32 prevalence the same way like for example
1:02:34 in the story of The Exodus for example
1:02:36 give me an example that someone across
1:02:39 in accordance within the in the later
1:02:41 part of Genesis
1:02:42 the claim is that Musa when he ran away
1:02:45 to median who's 40 years old
1:02:47 and he stayed in Midian 40 years that
1:02:49 seemed to be the Jews have Obsession of
1:02:51 40 years 40 years and Wilderness Etc
1:02:53 this is correct but not this one
1:02:57 corrects that it says for example we'll
1:02:59 come to the National but says
1:03:01 reached his Peak I shoot the hook
1:03:05 he was in the city and then he killed
1:03:07 that Egyptian and the whole story we
1:03:09 know what's the story how it developed
1:03:10 and then
1:03:12 and then he ran away and the Quran tell
1:03:14 us clearly that he negotiated with his
1:03:16 father-in-law to work for him for as a
1:03:19 dowry at the time the daughter was for
1:03:21 the father-in-law was not for the woman
1:03:22 the woman was like slaves were owned by
1:03:24 their fathers that's the old dog by the
1:03:26 way seems to be awesome though a lot at
1:03:28 the time
1:03:30 so the father negotiated to him you
1:03:32 worked for me eight years and I will
1:03:33 give you my daughter as a wife that's
1:03:35 the devil at that time for the father
1:03:37 not for the woman because yeah it's poor
1:03:39 poor woman has nothing from the aliens
1:03:41 it's not like in Islam Islam has
1:03:43 abrogated that anyway
1:03:45 that we have his fault in this
1:03:49 and if you if you make it then that's
1:03:51 from you an extra hotel and then Musa
1:03:53 completed the 10 Kola does not say which
1:03:55 one but there's a Hadith who says
1:03:56 clearly that the messenger of Allah was
1:03:58 asked Gabriel
1:04:02 which term which are completed this I
1:04:04 don't know let me ask and he asked
1:04:06 another angel
1:04:07 a higher Angel one of the carrier of the
1:04:09 throne allegedly and that's that angel
1:04:12 said I don't know the escalator answered
1:04:15 him he completed the most generous and
1:04:16 the most charitable one that's 10 years
1:04:18 so 10 years
1:04:20 the peak is this by Men by human being
1:04:23 General but by menstrual by 30 years
1:04:25 roughly not by 40. like some people
1:04:27 think no the pick is by 13 after 30 you
1:04:29 go in a plateau and then start declining
1:04:31 and 40 will be full manhood but not the
1:04:33 big the biggest 30 so he was 30.
1:04:37 I don't know how to read the 40s when he
1:04:39 came back appointed prophet he was 40
1:04:40 and that fits with him I have some
1:04:42 research on going on that and someone of
1:04:45 the Shabba in Egypt is doing some work
1:04:46 and that at the moment
1:04:48 he came back and we know now the Pharaoh
1:04:51 which he came and we know also which
1:04:54 which uh which wife of pharaoh which
1:04:57 adopted them as a son is not the same
1:04:58 one who became a Believer and joined him
1:05:01 in the Exodus that's another one that's
1:05:03 the one who abducted my son is most
1:05:05 likely Queen hardships hardship suit
1:05:07 most likely almost all of us settled now
1:05:09 bye bye by synchronizing the dates and
1:05:14 uh and most likely she is the one who
1:05:17 sent one very confident to warn him that
1:05:19 the people are plotting that's in here
1:05:21 she was in high age and then they were
1:05:23 obviously opposition against her being a
1:05:25 queen and things like that and possibly
1:05:27 she was killed somebody some indication
1:05:29 that was that her life ended in being
1:05:31 killed by the one came after her
1:05:33 Etc but anyway that's not our issue
1:05:35 today and he gave him the warning so the
1:05:37 one who adopted him was still motherly
1:05:39 to him until and he ran away anyway
1:05:41 let's let's leave that for that piece of
1:05:43 organization interesting one anyway so
1:05:46 you see the Quran corrects that one so
1:05:47 quran's don't correct because he's the
1:05:50 dominant over the books not the opposite
1:05:51 so ibrahim's father is Azad until we
1:05:54 have a compelling evidence to say
1:05:56 otherwise that's his grandfather that's
1:05:58 one now in another in another place in
1:06:01 the Quran said he said to his father and
1:06:04 people
1:06:06 what are these the materials these
1:06:08 statues you are devoted to
1:06:11 and they answered him say you are
1:06:13 mistaken Ibrahim these are not statues
1:06:15 they look like statues they are not
1:06:19 these are Gods there's Idols there's
1:06:21 difference between a statue and idols
1:06:25 so no no your mistake these are not just
1:06:27 statutes these are statues which have
1:06:29 connection with the gods so they that
1:06:32 they can be identified with the
1:06:33 divinities
1:06:41 they are mistaken they are idols
1:06:47 but I'm mistaken these are Idols which
1:06:50 represent God's in certain things and
1:06:52 certainly I just mentioned earlier the
1:06:54 story of of uh Omar in jahiriya milking
1:06:58 water
1:07:00 melting putting milk on a pile of sand
1:07:03 and then start worshiping it by this
1:07:05 procedure that Palestine became an idol
1:07:07 representing a Divinity the Divinity
1:07:09 comes in it and merge with it somehow
1:07:12 and become a connection to the Divinity
1:07:14 so you can identify it as the Divinity
1:07:16 and you can devote the worship to that
1:07:19 entity as if it is the Divinity that's
1:07:22 not the same like some people like to
1:07:24 direct things
1:07:26 washing the Kaaba that's not the harbor
1:07:30 although in public it's called the house
1:07:32 of Allah means the house which Allah has
1:07:34 worshiped that meaning also wants bless
1:07:36 them
1:07:37 Allah never said about massage he said
1:07:40 what massages
1:07:42 which Allah has allowed them to be
1:07:45 raised and his name will be remembered
1:07:47 there and the same with the Holy
1:07:49 Sanctuary that is sanctuary was enacted
1:07:52 by Allah is not present there no his
1:07:54 marriage there nor it is being the kabba
1:07:57 is being worshiped Kaaba is just a
1:07:58 directional prayer the same with the
1:08:00 Christian when they pray towards East
1:08:03 because they don't want to pay tourism
1:08:06 to distinguish themselves so they
1:08:07 adopted to brain two days I don't know
1:08:09 where they took that mostly from some
1:08:10 Pagan tradition that's right that's they
1:08:13 are not playing toward that toward the
1:08:14 sun because they're like the election no
1:08:17 it's not territory but it is the
1:08:18 direction of the player
1:08:20 symbolized by a certain direction at
1:08:23 least at least in in the tradition
1:08:25 nowadays I think they they are not that
1:08:27 much concerned about the directional
1:08:28 prayer because they don't have really
1:08:30 very fixed clear direction of prayer
1:08:32 doesn't seem to be part of their of
1:08:34 their of the catechism or religious
1:08:37 beliefs in such a way like a Turkish of
1:08:40 Jews and Muslims the direction of Prayer
1:08:43 now here in this essay after that he
1:08:46 said
1:08:48 do you adopt Islam idols
1:08:51 as gods
1:08:53 I think you are on your people are
1:08:56 greatly misguided
1:08:58 do you want to translate and I think we
1:09:01 did not answer
1:09:03 one second I indulging the explanation
1:09:06 got excited and didn't give you the
1:09:09 opportunity read the translation for
1:09:11 sure
1:09:12 um
1:09:13 and thus we gave Abraham his first
1:09:16 insight into God's Mighty domination
1:09:18 before that did you read the translation
1:09:20 the one before I read it all in one yes
1:09:22 oh yeah so that so I did not uh
1:09:23 accelerate and so that's that's it the
1:09:26 important Point here is that uh his
1:09:28 father name is Aza just ignore the Old
1:09:30 Testament that's a mistake until there's
1:09:33 a refutable evidence that there will
1:09:34 never be anyone because there's no no
1:09:36 inscription Ibrahim did not leave any
1:09:38 Trace in Iraq in his original country
1:09:39 and nowhere in inscription they were
1:09:42 showing anything else maybe maybe we'll
1:09:44 find a stone inside the Kaaba or near
1:09:47 Makkah and with some inscription in an
1:09:49 old script of that time which shows
1:09:52 Ibraham the son of azer or something and
1:09:54 maybe miraculously we could have
1:09:55 something like that but I don't think
1:09:57 we'll ever have something like that so
1:09:58 the only thing values the Quran and the
1:10:00 Old Testament and the Quran is more
1:10:01 trustworthy and more reliable than Old
1:10:04 Testament by by far by far by far by
1:10:07 necessity of Reason also so so he's
1:10:10 rebuking his father to adopt these Aslam
1:10:12 these Idols as Gods I regard them as
1:10:15 gods
1:10:17 that you must be misguided and your
1:10:19 people now the next area
1:10:28 and thus we gave Abraham's first insight
1:10:30 into God's Mighty dominion over the
1:10:32 heavens and the Earth and this to the
1:10:34 end that and this to the end that he
1:10:36 might become one of those who are
1:10:37 inwardly sure
1:10:39 next translation this way we made
1:10:41 Abraham to understand God's Mighty
1:10:44 dominion over the heavens and the Earth
1:10:45 so that he might become a firm believer
1:10:49 so this is this is all Ibrahim is doing
1:10:51 his own his own thinking and so on my
1:10:53 God behind the scene behind the veil
1:10:57 but it is ibrahim's too weak he's not a
1:10:59 prophet at that time and there's solved
1:11:01 many problems some of the scholars how
1:11:03 can he is he's thinking and thinking
1:11:05 about the moon and the sun being gods
1:11:07 and so on that's before he became a
1:11:09 prophet that says by by rational
1:11:10 consideration and thus and the way the
1:11:13 story is presented in the Quran here at
1:11:15 other places
1:11:16 another approach how to reach these
1:11:19 important fundamental things how it
1:11:21 should be that the rational approach
1:11:23 should be generally and that's the way
1:11:25 it should be everyone should be really
1:11:26 adopting
1:11:28 it should be like that but not everyone
1:11:30 is like Abrahim in the mental capability
1:11:31 and philosophical ability so you might
1:11:33 take that what you'll get from your
1:11:35 parents on board but you have to verify
1:11:36 it one day you're gonna just take it
1:11:38 photo at face value
1:11:40 so Allah said we show Ibrahim meaning we
1:11:43 we caused condition to be so because of
1:11:45 Ibrahim intelligence capabilities and so
1:11:47 on and the critical mind that he looks
1:11:50 around in heavens and earth
1:11:52 so that he so that he wanted by this
1:11:55 look around to gain certitude what's
1:11:57 going on what are these ideas they're in
1:12:00 a deity because these Idols these Stones
1:12:02 cannot be really representing an idiot
1:12:05 and they claim they are but we know
1:12:07 value from the history of all the Iraq
1:12:09 at the time Ibrahim the Sumerian and all
1:12:11 it was actually familiar with as expired
1:12:14 but it was the old Babylonian and the
1:12:17 Acadian and then all these is all the
1:12:19 Empire but after Sumerian
1:12:21 they oh samirian they were they were
1:12:25 actually mostly worshiper of of stars
1:12:29 and then that's important to know that
1:12:31 and the Quran hence that but also
1:12:33 classical Scholars but because they did
1:12:35 not look at that and maybe they are
1:12:37 exclusive at the time they didn't have
1:12:38 enough information actually the excuse
1:12:41 is little because it was known that the
1:12:43 people of Iraq are a star and and uh and
1:12:47 Planet worshiper that was not that was
1:12:50 not that was well established that was
1:12:52 not so they should not have ignored that
1:12:54 in the analysis of all there is at all
1:12:56 and there's no reason to believe that
1:12:58 the time Ibrahim they were that much
1:13:00 different so all these deities uh
1:13:02 represented by adults on Earth are
1:13:04 actually entities in the heaven and the
1:13:06 gods are actually in heaven as star and
1:13:09 the Moon Sun uh Jupiter Etc all of these
1:13:13 are gods
1:13:15 on Divine beings and represented on
1:13:18 Earth by these idols
1:13:20 so Ibrahim started looking in the in the
1:13:23 in the universe to see if he can gain
1:13:26 any certitude about this entity alleged
1:13:28 Divine entities
1:13:32 so he can gain certitude because of the
1:13:35 claim of his people
1:13:37 just these stones or this is the statues
1:13:40 who become now actually Idols of Gods
1:13:43 that they represent these Divinity it's
1:13:45 just clear they represent that that
1:13:49 man-shaped creature is supposed to be
1:13:52 representing let's say Marduk the god
1:13:55 which is Mars okay and most likely Duke
1:13:58 is is just a mutilation of marut which
1:14:01 we have insulted I didn't find the
1:14:04 commutation of Harold whatever that has
1:14:06 become for so this is
1:14:09 a kind of an ancient angel or an ancient
1:14:12 king or entity which they had been
1:14:15 catapulted to the Divine level much
1:14:17 later at the time Ibrahim it may have
1:14:19 been on
1:14:20 the worshiped so so the origin of
1:14:24 Witchcraft and all these things is much
1:14:26 older than Ibrahim most likely and was
1:14:28 then obviously prevalent and well
1:14:30 established a time of Suleiman but
1:14:32 that's not an issue today all issue is
1:14:34 that Ibrahim now so he's checking see
1:14:36 what's going on
1:14:39 no
1:14:41 he checked by observing
1:14:44 how these things behave
1:14:49 um
1:14:56 one sec also do you think um maybe about
1:14:59 2 30 we can break off into the questions
1:15:02 we've got a few a couple of questions so
1:15:03 we finished this aisle and then yeah
1:15:06 then when he when the Knight
1:15:09 overshadowed him oh I'm sorry then when
1:15:11 the night overshadowed shadowed him with
1:15:13 its Darkness he beheld a star and he
1:15:16 exclaimed this is my sustainer but when
1:15:19 it went down he said I love not the
1:15:21 things that go down next translation
1:15:23 when the Knight overshadowed him he saw
1:15:25 a star and said this is my Lord but when
1:15:27 it went down he said I do not like
1:15:29 things that disappear
1:15:31 yeah okay so I think this is clear the
1:15:34 argument is clear so in the in the
1:15:36 consideration he was then watching the
1:15:38 star in one night most likely uh started
1:15:41 developing obviously a methodology one
1:15:43 night he recognized that there was a
1:15:45 there's a planet or a star a
1:15:48 significantly maybe maybe it is Venus
1:15:50 maybe it is Mars being red and so on
1:15:53 anyway so one which is has significantly
1:15:56 different movements and appearance than
1:15:58 others
1:15:59 uh I said this might be my Lord message
1:16:01 this is the uh the one who supposed to
1:16:05 be all these existence coming from the
1:16:06 Supreme one because necessity is dictate
1:16:09 there must be sassobrine the Supreme
1:16:10 Lord
1:16:11 but this one set down so it's not only
1:16:14 present it is present sometime and
1:16:16 disappearing sometime it is changing
1:16:19 essential in escalation to mind it is
1:16:21 not permanently present or permanently
1:16:23 absent behind the vein
1:16:25 so he said no no this could not be my
1:16:27 Lord cannot be that Necessities it
1:16:29 cannot be that at that time maybe the
1:16:31 concept of necessary existing at the
1:16:33 theater were not yet developed yet
1:16:34 that they were develop the time of Musa
1:16:37 onward but there's something which
1:16:40 appears and disappears goes and cannot
1:16:43 be answers it cannot be the the one who
1:16:45 is established and create everything
1:16:47 that's cannot be the one
1:16:49 and that's the first step and then we go
1:16:51 further after that and then the way
1:16:53 everything is so taking from its
1:16:56 limitation and from its appearing and
1:16:58 disappearing to conclude that it's
1:17:00 essentially essentially a model language
1:17:02 philosophy is it's contingent it is it
1:17:05 is it it is depending upon certain
1:17:07 conditions it appears sometimes
1:17:09 disappears sometime that's a contingency
1:17:11 that's and this contradict the feeling
1:17:15 that the creator of the universities
1:17:17 must be something non-contingent
1:17:19 something Etc itself but do not need any
1:17:23 Excel a condition for its appeals or
1:17:24 disappears and if it's behind the way
1:17:26 like Allah that's because of his doing
1:17:29 to test the Free Will of other creation
1:17:33 not because uh the other thing by his
1:17:35 own doing and by his own design so that
1:17:39 cannot be used okay it cannot be
1:17:41 something which appears to be like a
1:17:43 star and goes up and down and follow a
1:17:45 mechanical way cannot be that that
1:17:47 really the Creator or the initiator
1:17:49 distance it can't be in a level suitable
1:17:53 for that level of discourse and
1:17:55 philosophical sophistication of that
1:17:56 time and I think we'll stop here and
1:17:58 continue next time with I I think 77 or
1:18:00 78.
1:18:02 okay got um one question from today it's
1:18:05 not unrelated
1:18:06 it says uh
1:18:09 does wife infer inherit from her Muslim
1:18:12 husband
1:18:14 there's a wife from al-kitab and helps
1:18:17 from her Muslim husband no yes because
1:18:19 because uh because a a kaffir does not
1:18:23 inherit from a Muslim and the Muslim
1:18:25 the better stronger point of view cannot
1:18:28 inherit from a capital either
1:18:30 although there is a descending point of
1:18:32 view that that modernizable uh one one
1:18:36 uh he was in Yemen made the list he had
1:18:38 this generation they made an Institute
1:18:41 that uh a cafe passed away and he has a
1:18:45 Muslim relative and mahad gave him from
1:18:46 the inheritance of the cafe saying Islam
1:18:49 increases doesn't decrease but this
1:18:50 argument is not correct
1:18:52 because the Hadith is cleared because
1:18:54 Hadith is this very clear the Muslim
1:18:56 does not tell you from the cafe and the
1:18:57 cafe doesn't matter foreign
1:19:02 so the one condition of Milad is Islam
1:19:07 so the wife will not inherit
1:19:11 and they gift they can only gift during
1:19:12 the lifetime app you can and you can
1:19:14 make ours here yeah like uh Sofia the
1:19:16 wife of the Lord
1:19:18 she she made wasiya when she was filthy
1:19:21 that she's dying she made those here up
1:19:23 to the third for her brother was the Jew
1:19:25 after the time
1:19:28 a major enemy of the Prophet her brother
1:19:31 was also a remaining Jews until she died
1:19:35 almost I think she died most likely the
1:19:37 time in the 40s hijri and uh and there
1:19:41 were some people objecting to that and I
1:19:43 I shall fought strongly and enforced
1:19:46 that the double CEO will be fulfilled
1:19:47 saying there was here because you can't
1:19:49 make or say to anybody
1:19:51 definitely so he got that head
1:19:54 and um and the other part I don't know
1:19:56 went to went to the vital map because
1:19:59 there was no next okay of anyone of male
1:20:01 next weekend which will get uh anything
1:20:03 whatever that's what happened to the
1:20:05 part and the letter of this program
1:20:07 blessed Islam some of you said you are
1:20:09 stupid if you haven't blessed Islam
1:20:11 earlier you would have taken all the
1:20:13 money he said I'm not going to miss
1:20:14 Islam for money I'm British Islam on
1:20:16 conviction I'm now convinced I was not
1:20:18 convinced at that time so he became
1:20:19 Muslim
1:20:20 so it was just to clarify so what's here
1:20:23 what's the distinction between wuse will
1:20:27 will okay the one is a mandatory as in
1:20:30 it's it's already set in stone and
1:20:34 um so in where's is that which is
1:20:36 already predefined and and inherent and
1:20:39 uh we'll see is the part that you have
1:20:40 leeway on is that you can make Wasilla
1:20:43 for example unless it is a transgressive
1:20:46 or stupid you don't say in the west you
1:20:48 may go see or maybe for a dog house are
1:20:51 you Muslim judge will evaluate will and
1:20:53 you get that it doesn't make sense but
1:20:55 do you you make was here for example for
1:20:57 uh for let us say uh it should be the
1:21:01 the good rule is that you cannot make
1:21:03 Lucia for anyone who inherits if you
1:21:05 want to sell in Harris you want to give
1:21:07 him something more for whatever good or
1:21:09 bad reason than you do it in your life
1:21:11 you gifted him in your life and transfer
1:21:12 it so he can receive it if he doesn't
1:21:14 leave it in your life and also it will
1:21:16 not be executed that's the strongest
1:21:18 point of view I think it's earlier I
1:21:20 think it's
1:21:22 because of the Hadith Allah gave
1:21:24 everyone his
1:21:26 name for what
1:21:37 okay so you have to be executed from the
1:21:39 money up to the third after you death
1:21:41 and you gifts in your life you can gift
1:21:44 in your life and that is expected
1:21:46 physics it must be excluded in your life
1:21:48 and this can be two years or known as
1:21:49 obviously if you give some hairs I do
1:21:52 not give the others like one son or one
1:21:54 daughter and the other don't give with
1:21:56 no good reason thus will be Injustice
1:21:58 and you might be maybe Haram you'll be
1:21:59 resentful but still you can give
1:22:03 excellent okay next question
1:22:06 Music
1:22:10 I'm not sure what's he trying to say but
1:22:12 what would be the ruling on double first
1:22:14 cousins who are the children of two
1:22:17 pairs of identical twins marrying so
1:22:20 basically two basically two identical
1:22:22 sets of twins identical
1:22:25 Brothers marrying separate identical
1:22:28 sisters yeah I don't know how that'd be
1:22:30 anything barring that but that's the
1:22:32 question is so what what's the what's
1:22:34 the ruling about what's the issue of
1:22:35 that
1:22:36 is there any prohibiting somebody
1:22:38 marrying so for example I suspect this
1:22:41 is what he means if bear in mind this
1:22:43 was asked last week and the person's not
1:22:45 necessarily here what's the problem with
1:22:47 that one two let's say two two identical
1:22:50 brothers let's say Omar and Ali married
1:22:57 identical twins or cousins
1:23:00 they can't marry as long as they are not
1:23:04 so what's the issue with it
1:23:17 for example independently if if Maryam
1:23:21 exists or doesn't exist and the same
1:23:23 would addictive for Maryam that's it
1:23:26 each one is an individual entity being
1:23:28 identical to win with Aisha or not being
1:23:31 and that she deserved that what he's
1:23:33 answered
1:23:35 I'm gonna say that we don't have a whole
1:23:37 deal or something there's no whole deal
1:23:38 there it's individual even if they are
1:23:40 identical twins neither the men's side
1:23:42 nor on the woman's side oh I think I
1:23:44 know what this is talking about saying
1:23:46 so two first cousins
1:23:49 who have ideas I don't know it's just
1:23:51 really difficult to understand in Islam
1:23:54 you are allowed to manifest in first
1:23:57 cycle they are not mahram you can't
1:23:58 marry them so that's a finish
1:24:03 I let him explain give names like for
1:24:05 example a man called a woman called
1:24:08 Alpha and another called beta and then
1:24:10 give us the cross relation and then but
1:24:13 it's it's clearly that's what he means a
1:24:15 first cousin is not maharap you can
1:24:17 marry your face cousin I think in the
1:24:19 west is somehow an issue with the first
1:24:21 cousin they're regarded as like or I
1:24:23 think in India or say regarded as a
1:24:24 brother or sister and people feel a
1:24:26 little bit uh
1:24:28 repelled of marrying them somehow no in
1:24:31 Islam No
1:24:34 Islam
1:24:36 yes I was actually the person who asked
1:24:40 the question and I was using uh this is
1:24:42 actually an alias I use for people whom
1:24:44 on Zoom calls I don't uh I don't
1:24:47 necessarily know but I can I will tell
1:24:49 you my real name but just to clarify my
1:24:51 question I wasn't asking about the
1:24:53 rulings of two sets of identical twins
1:24:55 marry each other I was actually asking
1:24:57 about their their children like that
1:24:59 double for his cousins uh that means
1:25:01 husbands who are cousins of each other
1:25:03 on both the mothers and the father's
1:25:05 side uh or maybe a different combination
1:25:08 of two depending on what's the problem
1:25:10 with that what what what's the
1:25:11 implication of that
1:25:13 well I I guess I guess some
1:25:17 people would say they're genetically
1:25:18 very similar like even closer than half
1:25:20 siblings so I just want I just that's
1:25:23 not today but if it is concerning of an
1:25:26 inheritance
1:25:28 will be applied properly and I don't see
1:25:31 any issue there
1:25:34 okay that's that's what I I expected
1:25:36 because the I had to like specify Newton
1:25:39 Baron cat very don't like have that type
1:25:40 of Allah maybe other people can just uh
1:25:43 can deduce a heck math but uh it's bad
1:25:46 enough to like change the best thing
1:25:48 construct a case like Omar and Ali and
1:25:51 so on and Marie and they have children
1:25:52 and later on after 50 as they die and
1:25:55 inherit and then we discuss the analysis
1:25:57 and we'll show you it makes no
1:25:59 difference there's an identical twin or
1:26:00 not identical twin I think like that I
1:26:03 think since the other question was a
1:26:05 separate question one about inheritance
1:26:06 this is something this is yeah I know
1:26:09 there's not a Hari
1:26:15 my dear
1:26:18 for example Omar is having children from
1:26:20 Asia and Ali having children for Maria
1:26:24 yeah
1:26:25 they are still there are still cousins
1:26:27 in that case
1:26:28 uh definitely Omar cannot marry the
1:26:31 children of Mariam because he's an uncle
1:26:34 or something like that and that's it
1:26:36 it's clear you can you can have the
1:26:37 family tree write it and you will see
1:26:40 who is
1:26:41 and who is a cousin and who is
1:26:44 I think the question was really around
1:26:46 whether something which can result in
1:26:48 major genetic issues
1:26:50 genetic issue something else is that
1:26:52 desirable not desirable definitely the
1:26:55 general tradition of the Arabs at least
1:26:57 is to try equalize specifically we're
1:27:00 trying to marry outside College as far
1:27:02 as possible because they thought this
1:27:04 will make this will make the genealogy
1:27:06 and the kids better and that people said
1:27:09 collage became uh superior to the other
1:27:11 tribes in intelligence and appearance
1:27:13 and Beauty they were their men were more
1:27:15 beautiful than average elements and
1:27:17 women were because they married for full
1:27:19 because they were rich and they were
1:27:21 doing business and so on and they were
1:27:22 dominant in Arabia and this way they
1:27:24 were able to approach most beautiful
1:27:26 women in other tribes an intelligent
1:27:28 woman and marry from them and the
1:27:30 resulted the Qureshi became over several
1:27:32 Generations Superior in intelligence and
1:27:35 capabilities than the others because of
1:27:36 that that's good genetics that's good
1:27:38 marine policy and good Improvement
1:27:40 genetics no problem but this is
1:27:42 desirable there's no prohibition of of
1:27:45 intermarine like that
1:27:48 except brothers and sisters and uncles
1:27:50 and aunties that's it
1:27:51 that's the minimum it's advisable yeah
1:27:54 it may be it may be maybe a future
1:27:56 Islamic State maybe give an advisory
1:27:58 that people should do a genetic test
1:27:59 before especially tribes like for
1:28:02 example in the high mountains of hijab
1:28:03 some tribes are marrying on Villages
1:28:05 over generations and they have developed
1:28:07 a nasty thalassemia and I am aware about
1:28:10 the case I met someone in Germany and I
1:28:12 was studying and they they uh they uh
1:28:17 they have uh they he married to a cousin
1:28:23 maybe a second or third even cousin and
1:28:25 the first baby was still born and the
1:28:28 the doctor told him is because of
1:28:29 genetic Crossing you never have any
1:28:31 living cell and then they tried not to
1:28:34 to have children but the wife became
1:28:36 pregnant by mistake and they ask giving
1:28:37 birth can we abort because of the season
1:28:39 and he gave them fatwa about that things
1:28:41 like that but this is this is this is
1:28:44 fixing an odd situation the best for
1:28:46 that is there to do some genetic test
1:28:47 and give the people advisory
1:28:50 the state cannot even foreign
1:28:56 will have a high probability of genetic
1:28:58 Misfit to advise you to forsake that we
1:29:01 cannot prohibit you from doing that
1:29:03 okay got one more question if that's the
1:29:06 question for the state the state should
1:29:08 be giving advisory in that as a medical
1:29:10 advice
1:29:14 and the people can accept or ignore
1:29:17 but not if it is like for example if it
1:29:20 did so I swear that this is that this is
1:29:22 the next of kin by by genealogy like a
1:29:26 prohibited even if this is for Haram
1:29:28 then obviously although inheritance is
1:29:31 of limit like for example it turns out a
1:29:34 woman was raped okay let's say it takes
1:29:37 the innocent kids she was raped
1:29:39 obviously the child belongs to her and
1:29:42 it takes her genology
1:29:45 found that the father is this guy
1:29:49 okay
1:29:51 and then
1:29:53 his children are maharam to this child
1:29:56 again they cannot marry that girl or
1:29:57 that boy if there's girls yeah because
1:29:59 they will be sisters from you in the
1:30:01 same father
1:30:02 the economically that prohibition is
1:30:04 valid
1:30:05 but he is not a father he does not
1:30:07 inherit these brothers do not inherit
1:30:10 they don't incoming inheritance do not
1:30:12 carry the name all benefits of of
1:30:14 regular marriage and regular genealogy
1:30:18 is off limit because the one who commits
1:30:20 crime is not worthy of having genealogy
1:30:22 but the prohibition is valid
1:30:36 instruction that this son of uh
1:30:39 the brother of Zuma is not is not it's
1:30:42 not a son of uh
1:30:44 Zama yeah yeah he says
1:30:49 it's my son I I committed Jinnah with
1:30:52 his mother in jahiriyah
1:30:56 applied for to take the son for himself
1:30:59 this is the son of my brother
1:31:01 under his brother from the father for
1:31:03 example himself the brother of sauda
1:31:05 said no messenger Allah is born in my
1:31:07 father bid
1:31:08 and he's my brother how can he claim
1:31:11 that my my stepmother committed Zina I'm
1:31:14 rejecting that
1:31:15 he's obviously he's he's protecting the
1:31:17 honor of his stepmother who's very
1:31:19 vulnerable from him most likely or maybe
1:31:21 he's convinced whatever
1:31:23 and then we say I looked at the boy and
1:31:26 he saw clear evidence in his appearance
1:31:28 and that he's similar to Earth
1:31:31 so the story of Zina seems to be true
1:31:34 but he said it is Usama it is for you
1:31:39 because the the child is belonged to the
1:31:42 bed to the marital bed and for the
1:31:45 fornicator and for the sinner only the
1:31:47 stone is worthy he doesn't deserve to
1:31:49 have genealogy he does it to have
1:31:50 children from from Sinner and then he
1:31:53 tells sauda
1:31:55 and sauda do hijab from him because
1:31:57 there's a suspicion that he is that he's
1:31:59 not your brother so prohibition and
1:32:01 hijab goes according to genealogy
1:32:04 but not inheritance not in there but it
1:32:07 is a complicated a bit complicated issue
1:32:09 we'll discuss inshallah in Arabic and
1:32:11 maybe someone will translate it or
1:32:13 something like that but that's it
1:32:15 so in that case
1:32:17 if it's genetically proven that this
1:32:19 that woman was raped by this man maybe
1:32:21 he raped and then he died and after his
1:32:24 death it turned out by by genetic
1:32:26 testing just accidentally you find in in
1:32:29 family tree DNA you find the relation
1:32:31 and the Scandal is apparent and the and
1:32:33 the rapist is dead for example you can't
1:32:35 punish him or if he's still alive we
1:32:37 cannot punish him based on that anything
1:32:38 like that but still in that case this is
1:32:41 enough evidence that his his sons and
1:32:43 daughters are maharam for the one who is
1:32:45 produced by by rape but no inheritance
1:32:49 and no named sharing
1:32:52 because of the Hadith the famous Hadith
1:32:58 um
1:33:01 um
1:33:02 would that be an indication about the
1:33:04 for the prohibition of adultery
1:33:07 um you know sorry no this is
1:33:08 metaphorical for that for the one who
1:33:10 comes he deserves the stone that's it
1:33:15 it doesn't have to be stoned
1:33:19 that doesn't indicate whether it's in
1:33:20 fabricated or not aggregated
1:33:22 no no has nothing to do with the
1:33:23 application it's just a semi
1:33:24 metaphorical okay okay next question um
1:33:27 so I've got one um this is from last
1:33:29 week apologies and it may be at the time
1:33:31 when this was said in the course
1:33:33 was not obligated yet but the individed
1:33:36 of that he doesn't deserve having the
1:33:38 sun attributed to him as a son he
1:33:40 deserves to be stoned and despite his
1:33:42 actual Act is Despicable he deserved to
1:33:45 be condemned that's a meeting with
1:33:47 expression he doesn't deserve to have a
1:33:49 son he cannot say this is my son
1:33:52 I've got a question from last week about
1:33:53 the cup yeah I've seen several different
1:33:56 opinions on when zakat is due for
1:33:58 Investments or assets one owns but does
1:34:01 not have easy access to
1:34:04 firstly what opinion do you favor do you
1:34:06 favor if you favor the opinion that is
1:34:08 due as soon as one has access to it
1:34:10 assume you've owned it what's the
1:34:13 meaning of access this is these are
1:34:14 these are words which are dark do not
1:34:17 make any sense
1:34:19 Is It Anyway is it your ownership or it
1:34:22 is loan to someone else if it's loan to
1:34:24 someone else it is not it is not yours
1:34:26 it is the one who took the loan because
1:34:29 learning meaning you transfer the
1:34:30 ownership of that what you have given as
1:34:32 a loan to the Loney
1:34:35 I think it is it could be in reference
1:34:37 to deduct tax deducting tax and expenses
1:34:41 so he finishes it with would it be
1:34:43 allowed to detect imminent expenses
1:34:44 before calculating how much you paid for
1:34:46 the card so the first question you
1:34:48 basically the question you would have on
1:34:49 this is if it's in the hand for example
1:34:52 it could be in
1:34:54 say it's in a trading account which you
1:34:56 do which you have to in extracting it
1:34:58 you have to remove expenses and taxes
1:35:01 which it's not necessarily in your hand
1:35:03 but you have access to the to the funds
1:35:10 you count your wealth
1:35:12 calculate your wealth now if that if
1:35:15 that account there are there are taxes
1:35:18 due on it take that the taxes out and
1:35:21 pay them out
1:35:26 so with the Mississippi would there be
1:35:28 the CP minus the expense that the tax or
1:35:31 including the tax so say for example
1:35:33 because the tax should have been paid
1:35:35 out if it had not been paid out that's
1:35:37 it that you are the guilty one it is in
1:35:38 your hand
1:35:39 which is is not accessible to it's
1:35:42 accessible too you failed to pay the tax
1:35:44 dollars or uh they say the same if if
1:35:48 you borrow but a borrowed from someone
1:35:49 it is your ownership you have bought it
1:35:51 for a methods you and you you should pay
1:35:53 it back if you don't want to raise a cut
1:35:55 on it returns back to the the one the
1:35:57 one who gave you the Lord
1:35:59 then it's not part of you the same here
1:36:01 if you got the text as if it's a loan or
1:36:03 something I'll send you them but still
1:36:05 in your hand
1:36:07 count all assets and deduct all the
1:36:10 water allows deduct one one animal or
1:36:13 one one riding animal or one car deduct
1:36:16 one house and you are living
1:36:19 is
1:36:25 the common conceptual misconception that
1:36:28 you have to have owned it for a year you
1:36:30 can your point of view is that at a
1:36:31 given time that you designate in your
1:36:34 either designated for you like for
1:36:36 example your text for example the state
1:36:38 would say for all alone in the domain
1:36:40 there's a card and tax are there etc etc
1:36:43 is their birthday
1:36:48 your birthday is the day you you got you
1:36:51 say calculate your assets there all of
1:36:54 them and deductible is permissible by
1:36:56 Sharia and maybe the state give you also
1:36:58 extra deduction as a as a charity
1:37:00 because obviously all that that the tax
1:37:02 collector to leave something for the
1:37:04 people or Plantation so that they can
1:37:06 give their guests and so on they will
1:37:08 leave them like a 20 15 something like
1:37:11 that that's that's left to the Imam
1:37:15 after that the rest Mercy rests two and
1:37:18 a half percent period full stop that's
1:37:20 it
1:37:21 and then all this confusion and they
1:37:23 said they didn't grow not color this is
1:37:25 all this is all mistaken understanding
1:37:28 and the the history refutes that because
1:37:30 the tax collector goes once in a year
1:37:33 and he never asked no tax figure ever
1:37:35 asked I said how much comment you have
1:37:37 today he never asked how many grew from
1:37:40 last year because they said because
1:37:41 every once a year the people thought it
1:37:43 is it is uh that what what what what
1:37:45 what what
1:37:46 persists over there no it's not what
1:37:48 person what is at the end of the year at
1:37:50 the tax day
1:37:51 that's what you have out there from that
1:37:53 the the cut is calculated in the case of
1:37:56 animals obviously there's a calculation
1:37:58 relation set here two and a half percent
1:37:59 but calculated in animals
1:38:02 I like five camels then it says one
1:38:04 sheep if you calculate really five
1:38:06 comments is essentially putting every
1:38:08 common like a cheap eight times sum is
1:38:10 40 so 1 out of forty essentially this
1:38:13 means the surgery five comes as
1:38:15 equivalent a common is equal equivalent
1:38:17 like through a chip roughly
1:38:20 I call one other quick one said it's a
1:38:23 question in Jordan if you revert to
1:38:24 Islam and want a certificate they send
1:38:26 you to Asylum for mental health
1:38:27 assessment it happened to one of our one
1:38:30 of the brothers does this have any
1:38:31 reference in Islam
1:38:37 that's Operation because uh it's a in
1:38:41 that case just just find to to a bright
1:38:43 Muslims who are respected the community
1:38:45 and pronounce have a certificate
1:38:48 obviously that's the death maybe not
1:38:50 official but it should be sufficient for
1:38:52 everything else
1:38:53 and also to clarify Jordan Rules by
1:38:55 gopher yes anyway and the King there
1:38:59 under the Entourage most likely
1:39:07 should be under your feet but sometimes
1:39:10 you are forced to unfortunately what you
1:39:12 can do then you go and get a certificate
1:39:14 what can you do
1:39:18 okay I'm going to open this up to about
1:39:20 Muhammad then after that would like to
1:39:21 make a thing I'm going to pray
1:39:23 over to you yes thank you so much
1:39:27 uh uh I wanna make two points uh one of
1:39:30 them I'm actually positive of and the
1:39:32 second one is I I'm hoping to God that I
1:39:35 got it right you know the first one uh
1:39:37 uh uh actually uh uh other is is in no
1:39:42 way the father of uh Ibrahim
1:39:45 uh and and if you give me just like a
1:39:48 minute I can construct the point for you
1:39:50 so in Arabic
1:39:54 means the biological father and the
1:39:57 predecessors uh like you yeah
1:40:00 yes and and only a whileid is is your
1:40:05 biological father you know there is
1:40:08 plural of Abu which is ABBA Anna and we
1:40:10 use that and even Quran use that but
1:40:12 there's no plural of uh of wallet you
1:40:14 know we don't say well ituna for example
1:40:16 so so in Quran all the eyes
1:40:20 related to other is is expressed in the
1:40:24 word up you know uh as and and and now
1:40:28 for the uh for the evidence that uh that
1:40:31 uh that uh father is not his uh other is
1:40:34 not his father but before that let me
1:40:36 just make a simple Point uh let's keep
1:40:39 the Bible and the Old Testament aside
1:40:41 you know because I agree with you that
1:40:43 the Bible is actually yeah
1:40:45 because you know from the story of the
1:40:48 birth of Jesus as you've uh clarified
1:40:51 many times yeah and you know in Old
1:40:53 Testament they say nasty things about
1:40:55 prophets so we just need to neglect
1:40:58 these two two books from the Quran
1:41:00 actually the Quran itself here in the
1:41:03 story of Ibrahim at the encounter at the
1:41:06 time when he was encountering his father
1:41:08 azer he said uh in Surah Maryam uh 40 uh
1:41:15 Ayah 47
1:41:20 so at that time of Confrontation when he
1:41:23 confronted azer he was uh he told him
1:41:26 that I will ask forgiveness from Allah
1:41:29 and then you know the is came
1:41:33 telling him do not make a stick far for
1:41:36 your father okay here here here in the
1:41:39 here in Surat Surat Ibrahim in Ayah 40
1:41:45 41 which is which is now in Mecca you
1:41:48 know he left he left his father and all
1:41:52 on all of his people and now he is at
1:41:55 the time of Makkah he said
1:42:01 so here in Surah Ibrahim he used the
1:42:05 word
1:42:06 so so my biological parents so so from
1:42:10 so from these two i i as uh what I'm
1:42:13 saying is that there's no way that uh
1:42:15 other could be the prophet the theology
1:42:18 magical father of Ibrahim he could be
1:42:20 you know his father or even a great
1:42:22 grandfather I didn't see the point why
1:42:25 cannot be
1:42:26 you know because
1:42:28 because in because if he was his
1:42:32 biological father then in Makkah uh
1:42:36 he said foreign
1:42:54 like there are different ayas in Quran
1:42:57 between the time of confrontation with
1:43:00 the other and till the time when he came
1:43:02 to Makkah there are uh ayas in Quran you
1:43:05 know uh telling Ibrahim to abstain from
1:43:08 uh making a star to Allah
1:43:12 and and this is
1:43:17 the end of his life and Allah excuse him
1:43:21 saying is
1:43:24 because it has promised him I promise
1:43:27 but then we when he recognized that his
1:43:29 enemy of Allah he has forsaken him did
1:43:32 not report that in another place
1:43:36 when when Ibrahim said that uh you know
1:43:40 or or Quran said that uh
1:43:42 a Ibrahim forsaken to his father
1:43:49 much later maybe before his death we
1:43:51 don't know
1:43:52 or unclarified things which has not
1:43:54 mentioned the Quran anywhere even
1:43:57 was was was given up later much later
1:44:00 which called I did not report before
1:44:03 and because because no no because from
1:44:05 the whole context because from the whole
1:44:06 context I assumed that uh the uh the
1:44:11 abstaining from uh when God told him do
1:44:15 not make esterfar was in between before
1:44:18 coming to Makkah no no no no we don't
1:44:20 know no this is this is that's uh that's
1:44:24 we are told not to do is make excuse for
1:44:27 Ibrahim and say Ibrahim recognized much
1:44:30 later than his father's enemy of Allah
1:44:32 there is no hope in him and he gave on
1:44:34 him up
1:44:37 I don't see any logic and the
1:44:39 construction is not correct
1:44:41 okay okay okay well probably I need to
1:44:44 look further into that no okay now the
1:44:48 second point is is not related and I'll
1:44:51 try to make it uh really quick you know
1:44:53 when we were when we were discussing uh
1:44:56 that or you were making tafsir to the
1:44:59 Iowa um
1:45:01 you know I have contemplate contemplated
1:45:04 what the word Muslim or Islam
1:45:07 like many times in few years and what I
1:45:10 come up with is that
1:45:12 a Muslim or the word Islam is not
1:45:16 actually surrender but
1:45:18 to submit
1:45:20 yes okay okay exactly now perhaps in
1:45:24 English there's no big difference but
1:45:25 but in the in in Arabic there's a huge
1:45:28 difference between Muslim uh and nasty
1:45:32 for example yeah I can give you and I
1:45:34 can give you like a dozen of uh of ayas
1:45:37 in the Quran using the word
1:45:46 Etc there's a
1:46:05 it's actually wrong you know because
1:46:07 because in the word Arabic Islam is
1:46:10 against your will you know but submit is
1:46:13 with your will so you have to come
1:46:14 together
1:46:18 essentially faulty and and deficient
1:46:21 they are not really an authority or any
1:46:23 something like that but it's not a major
1:46:25 point in any case here uh uh yes in that
1:46:30 sense but it's it's true it is submit
1:46:32 submission is better than surrender no
1:46:35 doubt about that much better but also in
1:46:38 English the connotations are there and
1:46:40 but but what I would say is that all all
1:46:44 beliefs and all religions are Islam but
1:46:47 Islam that Islam is the final region of
1:46:49 Muhammad so exactly let's discuss in the
1:46:51 book today this is the more important
1:46:53 Point these are fine points that
1:46:55 surrendered by by by
1:46:58 willingly and so on is that what's
1:47:00 required because you have Free Will and
1:47:01 the whole thing the whole universe is
1:47:03 based on that testing
1:47:05 exactly
1:47:08 the the stars and the universe is is is
1:47:11 is surrendering by force exactly
1:47:14 otherwise profound you know when he when
1:47:17 when he said
1:47:20 he is then Muslim by the definition of
1:47:22 wahhabis because because at the end he
1:47:24 said he surrendered
1:47:26 some people by the way because we'll get
1:47:30 to that inshallah but he may have been
1:47:33 really he may be happy really but it was
1:47:35 too late
1:47:39 it was too late for that for for him to
1:47:42 be accepted because he was dying and
1:47:45 then he he was said and of death and in
1:47:48 that case repentance is not acceptable
1:47:50 but this is a a different point anyway
1:47:52 leave that anyway inshallah when you get
1:47:55 to parallel
1:47:57 um
1:47:59 patiently way
1:48:01 successful okay okay
1:48:05 a final point you know in Arabic we
1:48:09 actually use uh when we say that there's
1:48:13 a criminal and he's uh he's going to
1:48:16 police by his uh own will to to give up
1:48:19 himself we say uh you sell them
1:48:22 but but when it's against his will you
1:48:25 know if if that is foreign
1:48:40 thank you so much thanks a lot brother
1:48:43 so we break for sale inshallah quickly
1:48:49 yeah
1:48:49 brother you mentioned many points and
1:48:52 this nicely brings to my little comment
1:48:55 maybe a suggestion to you said Islam
1:48:59 wherever you call talking about so
1:49:02 Mission and hazrat Ibrahim on that basis
1:49:05 alhamdulillah I am organizing a very
1:49:08 short umrah if any brothers are
1:49:10 interested please get in touch with me
1:49:12 it's very cheap but from Thursday to
1:49:15 Monday the quick weekend umrah and then
1:49:19 visit to the prophet sallallahu alaihi
1:49:21 wasallam's grave in Medina just for 5
1:49:24 49.
1:49:27 just leave the context and so on by by
1:49:29 Rush he will have official and
1:49:31 description of the video and also in
1:49:33 Enterprise in the telegram definitely
1:49:36 definitely
1:49:40 it's only about 50 minutes remaining
1:49:45 so
1:49:59 foreign
1:50:04 Music
1:50:13 Music
1:50:19 Music
1:50:29 foreign
1:50:36 Music
1:50:43 Music