0:00:11 foreign
0:00:15 Music
0:00:39 foreign
0:01:22 these episodes are broadcast live on the
0:01:25 study Circles of Professor Dr Mohammed
0:01:26 and master YouTube channel every Sunday
0:01:28 at 1pm
0:01:30 we invited you to subscribe to the
0:01:31 channel and activate the notification
0:01:33 Bell for all new content please know
0:01:35 also the link to the live broadcast
0:01:36 formided dissemination
0:01:38 don't forget to interact with us during
0:01:40 the broadcast by participating in the
0:01:42 comments section and asking questions
0:01:43 through the chat box you find by the
0:01:45 broadcast connected to the video don't
0:01:47 forget to support our activities by
0:01:49 donating when asking questions in the
0:01:50 conversation or through the thank you
0:01:52 button under our video today is Sunday
0:01:54 the 1st of January 2023 the professor
0:01:57 continues the interpretation of
0:01:59 we are now on verse 76.
0:02:04 so we started the the episode of Ibrahim
0:02:08 and we started becoming believer and
0:02:10 they suggested and they think it's well
0:02:12 established by cross referencing that
0:02:13 with the other place in the Quran that
0:02:15 this is before he became a prophet is
0:02:17 not as many scholars held he is arguing
0:02:19 with his people and discussing looking
0:02:21 at the stars and telling the people
0:02:22 later discuss together no he is himself
0:02:24 the Quran says that he become convinced
0:02:27 that he become persuaded by a rational
0:02:29 argumentation so it's not for his people
0:02:31 most like he's done doing that there's
0:02:34 some narration which he cannot obviously
0:02:35 trust none of them is
0:02:40 may be taken from the people of the book
0:02:43 may be constructed by their imagination
0:02:44 that he was in a cave or something like
0:02:46 that all this is or just dump that in
0:02:49 the bin that's only can be trusted by
0:02:52 people who are who has the people of the
0:02:55 book disease that anything written in
0:02:57 books or narrated with some ancient
0:02:59 people is regarded as a fact until
0:03:01 proven otherwise no it's not true people
0:03:03 imagine and that things from their
0:03:05 imagination all the things connected to
0:03:07 the message of Allah from trustworthy
0:03:09 narrator should be taken on board and
0:03:10 even after thorough scrutiny really to
0:03:13 make sure that it is really from him not
0:03:16 by interference of the mind or the
0:03:17 memory so the strongest point of view is
0:03:20 that he is really searching he is
0:03:22 thinking he's analyzing he's not a
0:03:24 prophet yet and Allah letting him
0:03:26 develop himself so if someone will go to
0:03:29 extreme say even you can achieve profit
0:03:31 in time pass Prophet is now sealed by
0:03:33 rational consideration and devoting
0:03:36 yourself to this purpose until Allah is
0:03:38 pleased with you and adopted you as a
0:03:39 prophet may be possible at least we have
0:03:41 one example which is Ibrahim anyway
0:03:43 that's not our issue now that the
0:03:45 prophet can be achieved by rational
0:03:48 consideration and the developing
0:03:50 yourself until you become such a level
0:03:52 that Allah adopted you it may happen
0:03:54 only only once in history that's Ibrahim
0:03:58 so he was considering the the Stars
0:04:00 especially maybe maybe Venus or another
0:04:03 planet or something which is significant
0:04:05 or very bright
0:04:06 but you notice that this one is go Rises
0:04:09 up and go down and this shows
0:04:11 contingency it is possible that it is
0:04:12 here visible to me and then it
0:04:14 disappears there's a contingency the
0:04:17 people of they say he noticed that it is
0:04:20 events go through events because they
0:04:21 have this idea of events but I think
0:04:23 it's a better approach philosophical
0:04:25 obviously in time of Ibrahim Moses of
0:04:27 events time time events and issue of
0:04:31 contingency were not sorted properly but
0:04:34 future philosophical development showed
0:04:36 that the concept of contingency is more
0:04:38 fundamental and then the concept of time
0:04:41 also comes after that and that solved
0:04:43 many problems which we discussed in
0:04:45 issues of Qatar and so on but that's
0:04:47 very sorry independence of me leave that
0:04:49 other side so we notice these things say
0:04:51 Allah I don't love something I don't
0:04:54 think it is divine something which goes
0:04:56 up and down
0:04:57 appears and disappears
0:04:59 can't be a Divine should be always
0:05:01 omnipresent
0:05:03 because if you could disappear he could
0:05:04 disappear for eternities or could have
0:05:06 not been here forever so
0:05:08 can't be necessary existing you see my
0:05:11 point is more of the issue of
0:05:12 contingency rather than a matter of
0:05:14 change in time finishing time is the
0:05:16 result of being contingent not the
0:05:18 opposite that's what I want to stress
0:05:21 then he said okay let us next next day
0:05:23 see if there's any other candidate for
0:05:25 Divinity he saw the Moon
0:05:27 so
0:05:29 this is
0:05:33 seems to be bigger and more important
0:05:34 maybe not next day maybe uh the first
0:05:38 consideration was there was no moon it
0:05:40 was it was a new moon and the skies at
0:05:43 night is empty only the Spanish now he
0:05:45 waited until mid-month roughly and there
0:05:47 was no more the moon rising up
0:05:50 and then you say oh this this may be a
0:05:52 more worthy of a candidate but this guy
0:05:55 also the moon rose up and the way where
0:05:58 why mention the most respect of the moon
0:06:00 was one of the deities of the ancient uh
0:06:03 Babylonian and Sumerian and so on is one
0:06:05 of the major deities also the ancient
0:06:07 Arabs Etc
0:06:09 so that's the they referred to as a
0:06:11 deity maybe that's the deity represented
0:06:13 by this by these statues which is
0:06:15 because they are representing deities
0:06:18 they are Idols not just male statues two
0:06:22 but then this one I also set down it
0:06:25 wasn't all night or this the guy seems
0:06:27 to be big and interesting now are you
0:06:28 thinking analytically he must have seen
0:06:30 the moon before that many times but
0:06:31 without any analytical thinking about is
0:06:34 it Divine or not just watching and going
0:06:37 up and down now he's analyzing
0:06:39 see
0:06:42 this is also sitting them like the
0:06:44 planet
0:06:45 if my Lord whoever the Lord is I don't
0:06:48 know is the real lord if he doesn't
0:06:50 guide me I would be misguided so this is
0:06:52 also another point which shows the
0:06:54 rationality and the devotion of Ibrahim
0:06:57 to the truth because you say if there is
0:06:59 a Divine Law they seem to be this then
0:07:01 of a perception and reason dictate that
0:07:04 there must be a Divine Lord must be a
0:07:06 Creator ultimately because nobody at
0:07:08 this time just agreed that there must be
0:07:10 some kind of an ultimate Creator or
0:07:12 initiator of existence the issue of
0:07:14 atheism was not on the table maybe we
0:07:17 have 180 is here one eight is there and
0:07:19 they even do not dare say that you're
0:07:20 saying that publicly but nobody
0:07:23 discussed that so if this who is this
0:07:25 Lord I don't know he is him but if he
0:07:27 does not guide me he must be capable of
0:07:30 guiding me and opened my eyes to certain
0:07:32 directions
0:07:33 so guide me and I will be misguided so
0:07:35 he's devoting to and that's what I
0:07:37 advise many atheists nowadays for
0:07:39 example and people say they ask Allah
0:07:41 for guys say I don't believe that exists
0:07:42 see you don't need to believe say God
0:07:45 if you exist then I need your help
0:07:48 give me some guidance over my eyes you
0:07:50 are capable of all things as the people
0:07:52 claim a Divine being should be and you
0:07:55 are kind enough to to give some help in
0:07:57 a roundabout way it doesn't need to be
0:07:59 America but some open my eyes or
0:08:02 something get my attention in right
0:08:03 direction that's the way it should
0:08:05 should someone who is looking for the
0:08:07 truth ask for the one who may exist and
0:08:10 may be according to the usual
0:08:12 description of a Divine being have these
0:08:14 attributes
0:08:15 so Ibrahim is doing that so they said
0:08:17 Allah given us a guidance everyone is
0:08:19 try this way I approach this Lord which
0:08:22 you are doubting is existent by asking
0:08:24 him if you exist please help me
0:08:25 understand this
0:08:27 then
0:08:31 obviously it was all night long because
0:08:34 the Moon Rises after Sunset and then it
0:08:38 sets when the sun is about to rise at
0:08:40 that full moon at the 14th of the month
0:08:42 of the lunar month and then that night
0:08:45 maybe he was suffering not sleeping and
0:08:48 then the sun rose say this one is
0:08:51 amazing it just had more right more
0:08:53 light more warmth
0:08:55 on this larger and more significant
0:08:58 maybe this is my Lord
0:09:00 let me watch it what it does now watch
0:09:03 with critical iview I've seen this hand
0:09:05 Rising many times definitely is doing
0:09:07 this consideration when he is he is at
0:09:09 least
0:09:10 it can't be 70s although maybe an
0:09:12 ingenious ingenious personality could do
0:09:14 that but it must be at least 10 12
0:09:16 something like that so yeah I see that
0:09:18 so many times but so does
0:09:21 nobody's thinking about it now thinking
0:09:23 about in analytical way
0:09:26 then
0:09:27 that one is also after full day of
0:09:30 radiation warmth and so on has set down
0:09:33 and disappeared the same problem like
0:09:35 the moon the same problem like the
0:09:37 planets and the Stars it is here
0:09:39 sometime until not yet another time it
0:09:41 is contingent it seems to be having a
0:09:43 limitation it cannot be the one which
0:09:45 will be initiate everything which cannot
0:09:47 have limitation when this is the reason
0:09:49 at the time maybe he perceives that like
0:09:51 subconsciously without even analytical
0:09:53 thought or maybe he had a little bit
0:09:55 more antique adult whatever it was at
0:09:57 that stage of history for Christ that we
0:10:00 concluded
0:10:02 then he said now I know what's going on
0:10:04 all of these are created being their
0:10:06 contingent there must be someone behind
0:10:08 that which we don't see who is only
0:10:10 present but we are not having no access
0:10:12 to him is not accessible to our
0:10:14 perceptions and so on
0:10:16 and then he addressed his people after
0:10:18 that I direct my face to the one who
0:10:20 created the Heaven and said including
0:10:22 these plans doesn't be the point we say
0:10:24 uh
0:10:26 he that he addresses people I am I am
0:10:30 divorced and innocent from all your
0:10:31 deities that people think that that
0:10:34 previous their consideration is a
0:10:36 discussion of his people but
0:10:38 uh the the typical Quran mission that he
0:10:41 said that immediately after the sunset
0:10:43 doesn't mean it has to be immediate same
0:10:45 day maybe he came to his people and say
0:10:47 I did all this consideration and I came
0:10:49 to this conclusion now hear me all these
0:10:51 deities are false I have nothing to do
0:10:53 with them I'm devoting myself to the
0:10:55 career so when the Quran mentioned
0:10:56 something like as if it looks like an
0:10:58 immediate order even also whether it
0:11:01 will end doesn't mean it's immediate and
0:11:04 this is in many places in the Quran
0:11:06 that's happening and they hinted that
0:11:07 for example when Allah said refer to
0:11:10 raise
0:11:16 after mentioning that Allah saved him
0:11:19 from from being detained and crucified
0:11:20 people think most Scholars and ambassad
0:11:23 that he was lifted up immediately and uh
0:11:26 thus escaping the construction no he may
0:11:29 have not been lifted up and according to
0:11:31 the New Testament he reappeared again
0:11:34 and was lifted up 50 days later
0:11:37 so that doesn't mean that's that's a
0:11:39 trap don't be going in this trap think
0:11:41 that is mentioned immediately meaning
0:11:42 you said immediately it could be uh it
0:11:45 could be separated by by by a long time
0:11:48 another example when the Quran mentioned
0:11:50 the splitting of the Moon
0:11:55 many people thought because
0:11:59 of the moon is related to uh to the day
0:12:02 of judgment no the dev jumped has become
0:12:04 near and become present and mentioned by
0:12:06 the prophets very frequently starting
0:12:08 from Asia before that it was barely
0:12:10 measured it was nobody mentioned it or
0:12:13 barely measured if you go check the Old
0:12:15 Testament there is very dimension of the
0:12:17 idea of judgment or the resurrection
0:12:18 that's one of the traps also if they say
0:12:21 ah all these ideas have developed bit by
0:12:23 bit from paganism and things like that
0:12:25 yeah I said that's a death trap it's not
0:12:27 like that the prophet said that the
0:12:30 object is far away and this was in their
0:12:32 tradition already narrated it's not in
0:12:35 the books but for Melissa on he
0:12:37 announced the kingdom announced the
0:12:39 final Prophet announced many things anus
0:12:41 is coming back and things like that
0:12:42 under Muhammad mentioned
0:12:44 is near it may be next day it could be
0:12:47 any moment and he mentioned the coming
0:12:49 of this as a usual is almost coming now
0:12:51 and he mentioned at the jail the people
0:12:54 think he's almost outside Medina are
0:12:57 about to attack
0:12:58 always separated Maybe by A Thousand
0:13:00 Years
0:13:01 so don't be fooled by that so that what
0:13:03 I said scholar said he was all the
0:13:05 previously I was discussing with his
0:13:07 three people but relying on that he
0:13:09 after that told his people all my people
0:13:11 I have nothing to do with your idols and
0:13:14 your association with with the creative
0:13:15 areas with other partners I I devote
0:13:18 myself only to the one who created the
0:13:21 evidence we don't see him we didn't
0:13:23 perceive him but we see his his action
0:13:25 we see his we see his existence through
0:13:28 the Veil
0:13:29 so that's that's not an evidence that
0:13:31 all the previous discussion is really
0:13:33 just said uh they are logo with his own
0:13:35 people and that's his own research and
0:13:37 this is also uh enforced by the Ayah
0:13:40 before they say
0:13:43 so he becomes thoroughly convinced based
0:13:47 or rational argument not just by by
0:13:49 Revelation given to him and the Divine
0:13:51 forceful uh Making Believe or breaking
0:13:54 Prophet no by his own working hard work
0:13:57 and achieving their truth so then after
0:14:00 the sunset does not came to that
0:14:01 conclusion maybe the same day maybe next
0:14:04 month maybe he came from the cave if the
0:14:06 Cave Story is true until the people
0:14:08 listen
0:14:09 I have nothing to do with your Idols I
0:14:11 came to the conclusion maybe he reported
0:14:13 also this discussion to them or they
0:14:15 said this area and there must be a
0:14:17 Creator behind the scene it's not
0:14:19 visible it's not accessible to us
0:14:21 evidently but his action is visible we
0:14:23 see it and we conclude from that with
0:14:25 necessity that he exists and is the
0:14:27 Creator and he is omnipresent and he is
0:14:29 the one who created evidence that
0:14:30 created heaven are there
0:14:32 and I'm the inclining away for for from
0:14:36 from uh from any other Idols when he
0:14:40 says
0:14:48 so I'm devoting by myself I think I did
0:14:51 not read the eyes and didn't give a
0:14:52 Russian opportunity to translate them
0:14:54 because I got excited about the content
0:14:56 but let us read them again and then you
0:14:58 translate them so much there's three
0:15:02 eyes actually I read them in in sequence
0:15:04 if possible they wanna yeah so no
0:15:06 problem
0:15:07 kick off and I'll press that off to you
0:15:09 no read them read them yes just to
0:15:11 enforce what I said essentially sure
0:15:14 then when the night I was shattered him
0:15:17 with his Darkness he beheld the star and
0:15:19 he exclaimed this is my sustainer but
0:15:22 when it went down he said I love not the
0:15:24 things that go down
0:15:25 no next one yeah okay
0:15:29 um and then it's okay so now we're on 77
0:15:33 then when he beheld the Moon Rising he
0:15:36 said this is my sustainer but when it
0:15:38 went down he said he said indeed if my
0:15:40 sustainer guided guide me not I will
0:15:43 most certainly become one of those one
0:15:45 of the people who go astray I'll skip to
0:15:47 the next slide as well that transition
0:15:49 looks like
0:15:51 then when he beheld the sun rising he
0:15:53 said this is my sustainer this one is
0:15:55 the greatest of all when it two went
0:15:58 down he could explain oh my people
0:16:00 behold far be it from me to ascribe
0:16:02 Divinity as you do to ought beside God
0:16:05 the next one the last is the last one of
0:16:07 the set the three behold unto him who
0:16:10 brought into being the heavens and the
0:16:13 Earth have I turned my face I've been
0:16:15 turned away from all that is false and
0:16:17 I'm not all those who ascribe Divinity
0:16:19 to ought beside him
0:16:21 yeah we stop here at least another
0:16:22 translation so we see some variation of
0:16:24 words but I think there's not very much
0:16:26 of it except this instead of sustain a
0:16:28 better translation is Lord
0:16:31 Etc but at least read the sequence of
0:16:32 other Transitions okay go back to 77
0:16:36 then when he beheld then when he saw the
0:16:38 Moon Rising he said this is my Lord but
0:16:41 when it said when it said he said if my
0:16:43 lord does not guide me I will definitely
0:16:44 become one of those lost people next one
0:16:47 then when he saw the sun rising he said
0:16:50 this is my Lord this is greater but when
0:16:52 it two sets he said my people I disown
0:16:54 all that you worship other than God next
0:16:57 translation I have turned my face to him
0:16:59 who bought into existence the heavens
0:17:01 and the Earth and I have turned away
0:17:02 from all that is false I'm not one of
0:17:04 the idolaters yeah
0:17:23 so the translation is more of
0:17:25 philosophical brought in existence is
0:17:27 obviously a philosophical expression but
0:17:28 father initiated because you could say I
0:17:31 I am the one who did Father this will I
0:17:34 am though initiated the way I dug it I
0:17:37 stabilize the walls Etc because well
0:17:40 this has to be stabilized that they will
0:17:42 collapse inside
0:17:45 people can come and add to it and that
0:17:47 maybe stairs and then drops and things
0:17:49 like that that's not so fatala is the
0:17:52 one who initiated in the case of Heaven
0:17:54 is it because it didn't exist before
0:17:56 they don't initiated their existence
0:17:58 existence so that's the further
0:18:00 philosophical development but it's
0:18:02 initiated anyway
0:18:05 so next I I will try to control myself
0:18:07 not to jump over my head and do the
0:18:09 first translate next I am
0:18:12 then his people obviously argued him and
0:18:15 he said yeah
0:18:16 you don't do the Army first floor
0:18:19 according to our usual uh
0:18:36 and his people argued with him he said
0:18:39 do you argue with me about God well it
0:18:42 is he who has guided me but I do not
0:18:44 fear anything to which you ascribe
0:18:45 Divinity side by side with him for no
0:18:48 evil and before me unless my sister
0:18:50 Wills all things that all things does My
0:18:54 sustainer Embrace within his knowledge
0:18:56 will you not then keep this in mind next
0:18:59 translation
0:19:00 this people argued with him and he said
0:19:03 how can you argue with me about it is he
0:19:06 who has guided me I do not fear anything
0:19:09 you associate with him for no evil can
0:19:11 affect me unless my Lord Wills so Wills
0:19:15 my Lord Embraces everything within his
0:19:17 knowledge how can you not notice
0:19:20 yeah so a few remarks here yeah this is
0:19:23 meaning is clear but it's obviously
0:19:24 Quran as usual it brings only highlights
0:19:28 or certain points without mentioning
0:19:30 certain details which are clear from the
0:19:32 context or your support for you to have
0:19:34 your imagination filling the gaps what
0:19:37 would they argue about him the later
0:19:39 part of the uh uh yeah uh cynical
0:19:43 because his take about fearing that what
0:19:45 you associated with limited so Muslim
0:19:47 said don't you feel that these Gods
0:19:49 which may be the sons of God or the
0:19:52 Divine offsprings or some whatever they
0:19:54 they have constructed a case for them
0:19:55 they may punish you by by you denying
0:19:59 them and rejecting them
0:20:01 so that's that's not clear but it clears
0:20:03 from dead because they're trying to make
0:20:05 terrified be afraid uh we have examples
0:20:08 for example in in uh and when when uh
0:20:11 when I'm real I'm sure but despite of
0:20:13 all his negative characteristics and so
0:20:14 on was sent to demolish a lot in life
0:20:18 and then uh he he he came and and uh
0:20:23 before that another another sahibi came
0:20:25 to them Allah and embraced Islam asked
0:20:28 him about asking about Salah and so on
0:20:30 the one sent from banisad the one said
0:20:32 that the the the the the nursing owners
0:20:35 of the Prophet set up and then when he
0:20:37 came to his people I was the first thing
0:20:39 who he dismounted to come and said that
0:20:41 I settle that down with the latter say
0:20:44 did you lose your mind fear fear Valley
0:20:47 prozi fear the disease feel the strike
0:20:49 of the Lord tell you the last cannot do
0:20:51 anything uh it even doesn't exist I was
0:20:55 the messenger Allah and he told me this
0:20:56 and this and this and they embraced
0:20:58 Islam according to his advice and
0:21:00 discussion the same with the mother I'm
0:21:03 sure Allah being a sneaky guy he is he
0:21:05 went to type and and tell them I am
0:21:07 coming to demolish that say don't you
0:21:09 afraid to have jalam and so on people
0:21:11 have been struck with Calamity they said
0:21:13 oh no don't don't worry about that and
0:21:15 he took the the uh the demolishing
0:21:19 device or something a big hammer and
0:21:21 started demolishing and then he fell
0:21:22 around and
0:21:24 was moving his legs as if his dike so
0:21:27 say oh that stuck him so he stood double
0:21:29 life you say how stupid could you be
0:21:32 it is just a combination of stones
0:21:35 representing and nothing
0:21:43 play playful guy so they they played the
0:21:47 same game don't you afraid that you will
0:21:49 be struck with the Calamity like if you
0:21:52 discuss program with some Christian or
0:21:54 many Christian about the cast is not a
0:21:56 Divine being it's not a god it's just a
0:21:58 messenger of Allah
0:22:01 what do you do what's your mouth if he
0:22:04 is a Divine being you will be stuck with
0:22:05 Calamity you are denying him his most
0:22:07 importantly tribute and most things is
0:22:09 it to be said about him that he is
0:22:11 divine you are advocating a very poor
0:22:13 and low histology things like that it's
0:22:15 the same argument don't you feel that
0:22:17 you'll be struck with a calamity
0:22:20 because they think their Divine beings
0:22:22 will be capable of doing that and he
0:22:25 said Ibrahim tell them
0:22:28 how come that you are to the the
0:22:33 that to terrify me from your idols
0:22:36 and want me to associate with any
0:22:38 importance I will never say about unless
0:22:40 Allah permits that to happen because
0:22:42 they acknowledge that Allah has the
0:22:43 power to permit that to happen then it
0:22:45 will happen otherwise for my own no
0:22:47 there's no way I'm going to do it
0:22:48 because my Lord is impossible everything
0:22:50 and with his knowledge and his power
0:22:52 don't you remember don't you analyze
0:22:55 don't you think that that core meaning
0:22:57 here not only remember but study and
0:23:00 think because the word Dicker and
0:23:03 actually I I I was with with my friend
0:23:05 doing mudakara about preparing for the
0:23:07 exam meaning we remind each other we
0:23:09 study together Mutual studying is modaka
0:23:12 also so thicker is teaching and that's
0:23:15 the reasonatora the teaching is also
0:23:17 called the thicker is also teaching
0:23:19 Mutual teaching discussing discussing
0:23:22 and analyzing not only just remember it
0:23:24 that's part of it but it's not all of it
0:23:28 and then he continues with the second
0:23:30 part of it
0:23:32 is
0:23:39 I'll say this one
0:23:42 and why should I say anything that you
0:23:44 worship side by side with him seeing
0:23:46 that you are not afraid of ascribing
0:23:47 divinity to others to other powers
0:23:51 besides god without without besides what
0:23:54 without his ever having bestowed upon
0:23:57 you from on high any warrant therefore
0:23:59 tell me then which of the two parties
0:24:02 has a better right to feel secure if you
0:24:04 happen to know the answer next
0:24:06 translation why should I fear anything
0:24:08 that you worship besides him why are you
0:24:11 not afraid to associate partners with
0:24:13 him when he never sent you authority to
0:24:15 do so tell me if you'd know the answer
0:24:18 which side is more entitled to feel
0:24:20 secure yeah this is this is going to say
0:24:22 why should they be afraid because we he
0:24:24 and them agree that there's a there's a
0:24:26 Supreme Being for Mom this is the minor
0:24:30 divinities somehow emerged as Sons by
0:24:34 emanation by proceeding whatever well
0:24:36 they use they are not created they
0:24:38 proceed from their father like in the
0:24:40 Trinity that that the son is born but
0:24:45 born not made and the Holy Spirit
0:24:47 proceeded so he was you use Airborne use
0:24:49 proceeding it's the same thing as
0:24:51 foreign
0:24:53 Act of Creation it is either proceeding
0:24:56 or born or emanation whatever reason and
0:24:59 all it is rationally impossible that's
0:25:01 another issue to discuss today not to
0:25:03 discuss today
0:25:04 so you claim that
0:25:07 but we agree that he is the Supreme one
0:25:09 now you claim these minor ones whose
0:25:12 according to your claim proceeded from
0:25:14 there but you have no Authority and no
0:25:16 Revelation or no information
0:25:19 testifying that they are proceeded from
0:25:21 their father which shows that in a
0:25:23 compelling way so relying on just what
0:25:25 you inherited stories and God for others
0:25:29 claim that I should be afraid of those
0:25:31 well you should both of us we should be
0:25:34 afraid of the top one the big one the
0:25:36 initial one the initiator one which whom
0:25:39 you Associated things without any
0:25:40 Authority
0:25:42 so which party should be more afraid
0:25:44 it's a matter of fear it's a matter of
0:25:46 fear and intellectual Terror let us say
0:25:48 what shadow should be more more worth
0:25:50 your fear definitely the one who
0:25:51 attributes the ability to someone
0:25:52 without a compelling evidence and he is
0:25:55 and he's admitting this one is a minor
0:25:58 Divinity or something who preceded from
0:26:00 the fundamental one
0:26:10 do you have any evidence for that
0:26:12 so
0:26:15 so if you know tell me so this is that
0:26:17 this is the this is obviously this is
0:26:19 not Allah went in the sense of of
0:26:21 sexuality but it is a compelling uh
0:26:24 so-called rhetoric argument
0:26:27 there's one point here to be to be
0:26:29 addressed it comes in the Quran various
0:26:30 places
0:26:33 to which Allah did not bring down any
0:26:36 Authority
0:26:37 at that some of us Serene and some
0:26:40 people may think by mistake that and
0:26:44 they discussed that in the book of
0:26:45 actually quite plenty over there I think
0:26:48 several pages
0:26:50 that associate or something that would
0:26:53 Allah does not bring down any Authority
0:26:55 they may think that if Allah sent an
0:26:57 authority was something it may be divine
0:26:59 no what to say you are worshiping
0:27:02 something which by its own natural it's
0:27:03 impossible to have any authority to come
0:27:06 from Allah it is impossible even for
0:27:08 Allah to send any authority of that
0:27:09 because it's largely impossible it
0:27:11 contradict the reality and Allah cannot
0:27:13 lie impossible to arrive so he did not
0:27:15 bring anything down it mentioned the
0:27:17 reality you have nothing in your hand
0:27:18 you claim you have you have nothing in
0:27:20 your heart
0:27:21 if they would have anything in your hand
0:27:23 we may be able to discuss further but
0:27:25 it's impossible that you could have been
0:27:26 anything anywhere and because this is
0:27:28 rationally and logically impossible and
0:27:31 no Authority could have ever come any
0:27:32 way anyway could not have ever come so
0:27:36 my name is meaning that if if something
0:27:39 came down that Associates we have to
0:27:41 accept it no we know that's kind of me
0:27:43 from Allah it must be a fabrication
0:27:44 because necessity of Reason contradict
0:27:47 that
0:27:50 structure of reason is that what we
0:27:52 started with when we received Revelation
0:27:54 and we think about Allah so if if
0:27:57 someone claim we have an elect for
0:27:59 example the
0:28:00 Nicene conference claim that that the
0:28:04 the that the son is born from a father
0:28:06 not made before the beginning of time
0:28:09 etc etc and claiming that they have an
0:28:11 authority of the scripture so say it
0:28:13 can't be from a scripture it is a
0:28:15 mistake of you it is impossible it can't
0:28:18 come from Allah because we came to know
0:28:20 Allah we came to know the scripture we
0:28:22 came to read them because we understand
0:28:24 the language Greek whatever it may be
0:28:26 and the language is based on the basic
0:28:28 business of reason and the whole
0:28:30 perception of the reality is based on
0:28:32 the basic principles of reason so we
0:28:34 cannot have something coming out of
0:28:36 so-called scripture which contradicts
0:28:38 the very basis which we recognize them
0:28:40 as a description in the first place it's
0:28:42 not possible
0:28:43 it doesn't work this way the same here
0:28:46 so my name is
0:28:50 even if it has come down it couldn't be
0:28:53 possibly the case
0:28:54 but they don't have they say bring me
0:28:57 they don't have so it doesn't mean that
0:28:59 if Allah brings down an authority for
0:29:01 something it may be worshiped no Allah
0:29:03 will never bring because impossible
0:29:05 it will be Allah and Allah is above any
0:29:07 lie because he's the absolute truth it's
0:29:09 not worth what it can be so that's
0:29:21 and logically impossible so don't
0:29:24 understand it in the wrong way and send
0:29:26 it the right way
0:29:27 so there's no way a like a kind of
0:29:30 company kind of authority like that
0:29:32 because it's going to addictive
0:29:33 fundamental truth and it will undermine
0:29:35 reason undermine the fact that Allah is
0:29:37 the absolute truth that he's not the
0:29:39 truth can't be from him
0:29:42 so any
0:29:44 Divinity Association
0:29:46 cannot be having any Authority
0:29:50 so
0:29:51 and hence nothing will come down in that
0:29:54 direction if someone claims something
0:29:55 has come down my dear friend you are
0:29:58 mistaken there must some kind of an
0:30:00 error or
0:30:01 or you are being confused or you are
0:30:04 lying directly
0:30:06 so that's that's an important it's a
0:30:08 it's a small point but super important
0:30:10 so there's no way that
0:30:13 there will be any Authority coming from
0:30:15 Allah coming down giving Divinity to any
0:30:18 entity whatsoever if it's impossible
0:30:21 it's largely impossible so there's no
0:30:23 way so any Divinity attributed beside
0:30:25 Allah beside the necessary existing
0:30:27 initiator of the universe
0:30:31 could not buy necessity of Reason having
0:30:34 any Authority
0:30:35 and anyone claiming otherwise something
0:30:37 has come or something in the scripture
0:30:38 or some rational consideration is
0:30:40 suggesting that is difficult
0:30:42 fundamentally unnecessarily mistaken
0:30:46 and then Abrahim continue Quran continue
0:30:48 saying
0:30:51 um
0:30:54 Music
0:31:03 those who have a change of faith and who
0:31:05 have not stood their faith by wrongdoing
0:31:07 it is they who shall they who shall be
0:31:10 secure since it is they who have found
0:31:11 the right path next translation it is
0:31:14 those who have faith and who have not
0:31:16 mixed their faith with adult idolatry it
0:31:19 is they who will be secure since it is
0:31:20 they who have found the right path
0:31:22 what's the last one is makes the affairs
0:31:24 with what
0:31:25 but I've not missed their faith with
0:31:27 idolatry in the second translation yeah
0:31:29 the first one is says we're not obscured
0:31:32 their faith by wrongdoing yeah
0:31:34 okay so that's the other one is taking
0:31:36 out taking uh taking away the question
0:31:39 of Aisha because the original word is
0:31:42 Injustice which is wrong with the wink
0:31:44 but technically Injustice transgression
0:31:48 that's guessing the truth guessing uh
0:31:51 the right action either from thinking
0:31:52 the correct the the correct statement
0:31:55 the haq or transgressive the just the
0:31:57 just actionable
0:32:07 because Aisha said we are we are done we
0:32:11 are finished because even if we attend
0:32:14 Faith none of us did not mix our our
0:32:17 faith and Iman with some injustice there
0:32:21 will be some injustice small or big
0:32:24 then we have no security we are not
0:32:26 guided that is not like what you think
0:32:31 it is those who attain faith and do not
0:32:34 mix their belief with any
0:32:35 ideology
0:32:38 because they're all context is about
0:32:40 here meaning is focusing on and the
0:32:44 majority
0:32:46 those are the guided and those are the
0:32:48 the
0:32:49 because by Mississippi so you know that
0:32:53 all believer even if they are the most
0:32:55 devoted One Voice they will have some
0:32:58 acceptable profits and some and father
0:33:00 even some prophets have even some some
0:33:01 mistakes like for example you
0:33:03 understanding away from the without
0:33:06 Divine permission that's a major sin
0:33:08 it's actually a major sin running away
0:33:11 from his Lord is a major sin
0:33:15 he's not guided and he has no security
0:33:17 he is and he was saved because of that
0:33:19 so no mean again
0:33:23 even even if even the even the smaller
0:33:26 touch object should not uh should stay
0:33:28 do not stay in your email with a proper
0:33:31 definition of shirk like for example
0:33:33 just Totowa is not the touching Graves
0:33:36 like a stupid donkey or harvest cream no
0:33:38 sharing for example thinking that the
0:33:41 King has the right to release date or
0:33:43 the sick mobile without a justification
0:33:46 that's a shirk that you have no Harmony
0:33:49 will not be guided
0:33:51 not by kissing a grape like the Happy
0:33:54 thing that's also silk we have to
0:33:55 understand what silk is
0:33:57 yeah
0:33:59 but if it is stand by by someone who
0:34:02 will be taken away by their sexual
0:34:03 desire and committed fornication that's
0:34:05 not jerk
0:34:06 that's a feeling due to the to the
0:34:09 sexual drive and he recognized that he's
0:34:12 mistaken it is sinful
0:34:13 clearly if he does not recognize that
0:34:16 that's a because he said I am
0:34:17 legitimating for my father for myself
0:34:19 Allah is not commanding me whatever he
0:34:21 wants I commit myself I want let's check
0:34:23 but the one who doing say I did the
0:34:25 commentation for myself the hormones I
0:34:29 was on high steroids I couldn't do
0:34:30 anything that's fine that's fine that's
0:34:32 not check
0:34:33 so that's the one here so the next
0:34:35 demonstration he took already the
0:34:36 objection board and translated not
0:34:40 literally but by the meaning as
0:34:41 explained by the first others which also
0:34:44 the context clear the clarify because
0:34:46 all the discussion is not about
0:34:47 fornication it's not about stealing it's
0:34:50 not about sins this obedience to Allah
0:34:52 is about shark associating Partners
0:34:55 Allah with the proper meaning
0:34:57 not only Partners you are you're both
0:34:59 too and touch and kiss their Idols no
0:35:02 but also partners and Lords recite Allah
0:35:04 who we regard them as they have the
0:35:06 right of legislation and you have the
0:35:08 obligation of obedience yeah
0:35:10 also and this is the peak of shark
0:35:13 not the lower obserk the maximum shirk
0:35:16 and that's the reason when we see this
0:35:18 this one of the reasons
0:35:20 foreign
0:35:28 for this animal
0:35:32 God knows if this guy died I think he
0:35:34 died in an accident if he died as a
0:35:36 Muslim will accept it who knows we are
0:35:38 not going to judge that leave that for
0:35:39 example
0:35:41 because meaning that Hakimi is not
0:35:42 perfect for him
0:35:46 so that's the meaning of that those who
0:35:48 have this faith
0:35:50 when Allah alone
0:35:55 those are associated with any partner
0:35:57 and do not mixed with their Iman any
0:35:59 shirk
0:36:03 Divinity or lordship with a Divine
0:36:06 meaning of lordship
0:36:09 these are having the the security and
0:36:12 the other guided one
0:36:13 whatever other mistake they commit and
0:36:15 so on because even if they commit a
0:36:17 mistake they recognize they committed a
0:36:18 mistake and they they criticize
0:36:21 themselves under acknowledge that they
0:36:22 are mistaken so they are not appointing
0:36:24 themselves
0:36:27 the weak Believers but that's for
0:36:29 forgiveness they will be forgiven or
0:36:31 punished
0:36:33 But ultimately they have the ultimate
0:36:34 security by escaping ultimately the
0:36:37 Hellfire and they are definitely guided
0:36:39 because the moon gravity the fundamental
0:36:40 guidance is to see your place in the
0:36:42 universe there's only one Divine being
0:36:45 with the Supreme Lord and the holy
0:36:47 Commander ultimate command and nobody
0:36:49 can legislative and it accepts by by his
0:36:52 permission and by by within the
0:36:55 limitation of his uh of the laws enacted
0:36:58 by himself
0:36:59 to all water the prophets are doing is
0:37:01 just formulating what he revealed to
0:37:03 them and what Focus are doing is driving
0:37:06 that according
0:37:07 to the best they can find in that Sonic
0:37:09 has Revelation if they are sincere if
0:37:12 they derive the remedy violating the
0:37:14 Revelation they are covered damage they
0:37:16 can cover also
0:37:17 so that's it so those were Embrace faith
0:37:20 I did not mix it with any shirk or any
0:37:22 idolatry of the probably defined
0:37:25 regulatory these are the security and
0:37:27 the other guided ones anyone else is not
0:37:30 guided and have no secretary so his
0:37:31 people can argue as long as they wish
0:37:33 they cannot have security and they
0:37:35 cannot try to make Ibrahim become afraid
0:37:37 and give up on his belief because uh
0:37:39 maybe maybe uh
0:37:42 maybe this this Idol may have some
0:37:44 effect maybe he's a Divine son maybe let
0:37:47 me hedge my bits so amazingly I saw a
0:37:51 couple of days ago maybe two days ago
0:37:54 a story I can't believe that story does
0:37:56 that exist but they claim and even have
0:37:58 a picture of a man who claimed that he
0:38:00 embraced both Islam Christianity and
0:38:02 Buddhism as as just uh as having a
0:38:05 backup just to be safe in case
0:38:09 three it's fundamentally contradictory
0:38:13 motivation between this
0:38:16 divinity
0:38:19 because Muslim believes when when Divine
0:38:23 entity under one person no no not a
0:38:26 multiple person and anybody else is a
0:38:29 created being
0:38:31 and all any things which appears to be
0:38:33 making him Divine is that metaphorical
0:38:35 he's the word of Allah being created by
0:38:37 the word or he is the incorporation of
0:38:39 the word or something like that the same
0:38:42 with the way with the spirit of God
0:38:45 the spirit of Holiness or what they call
0:38:48 it okay now the spirit but the exact
0:38:49 word is the spirit of Holiness is
0:38:52 whatever it may be it is an entity which
0:38:55 is having this title because it's
0:38:57 represented and brings Allah Liberation
0:38:59 it's a created being
0:39:14 Buddhism is different
0:39:16 as far as see the Buddhists Creed it
0:39:18 does not seem to be have a really a
0:39:20 central career divide being something
0:39:22 like like an empty being or something
0:39:24 like a pantheism it's not clear because
0:39:26 the various Buddhist school it's kind of
0:39:28 synchronized with Islamic definition of
0:39:30 the Divine so how can you Embrace three
0:39:32 contradicting things
0:39:34 but they seem to be existing this guy's
0:39:36 here as just a backup
0:39:40 there was a I I once saw a video that
0:39:43 when when there was northern northern
0:39:46 European mostly um what you got what
0:39:49 that what their name the famous Invaders
0:39:51 and famous
0:39:54 Vikings the Vikings when they were
0:39:56 ultimately converted by the Christian
0:39:58 church and so on they they have the
0:40:00 symbol their God Thor or something that
0:40:02 his symbol is the hammer and they found
0:40:04 some Viking King's Graves the corrected
0:40:07 one they found a hammer and the cross
0:40:09 most likely the guy said okay let's have
0:40:12 a hammer in the cage with a store we
0:40:14 always
0:40:16 and here of course in the case it turns
0:40:18 out that the Christ and there's a cross
0:40:20 we can oh listen we believe in him
0:40:25 hedging that's that's that's all these
0:40:29 these guys will never have any security
0:40:30 or India anyway from thinking the first
0:40:34 with the first place but even that
0:40:37 it doesn't work this way you can't have
0:40:39 a hammer on the cross in your grade
0:40:42 that doesn't doesn't mix
0:40:49 you can't have both
0:40:53 and I say according to the final
0:40:55 Revelation neither is is the truth but
0:40:58 in the middle of that whatever they are
0:41:00 together they will not mix not work it
0:41:03 doesn't work
0:41:05 Islam I said it does not mix attributing
0:41:08 Divinity and a lordship to monks scribes
0:41:11 and Kings is contradicts Islam for the
0:41:13 method it doesn't mix
0:41:15 and you will not have security and you
0:41:16 cannot argue renewable care you will be
0:41:18 finished he will be destroyed
0:41:20 and the Quran continue Allah continue
0:41:22 now this obviously the previous argument
0:41:25 seems to be ibrahim's statement even
0:41:27 maybe this one an interjection like an
0:41:29 intervening sentence also this habit
0:41:31 sometimes while mentioning some story
0:41:34 Allah interjects something like that and
0:41:36 between or it's a statement of one and
0:41:38 about this of the discussion we don't
0:41:40 know but here it may be Abrahim Ibrahim
0:41:42 statement maybe but after that Allah
0:41:44 comments Ibrahim
0:41:48 foreign
0:42:01 against his people Paul we do not raise
0:42:04 by degrees who we will verily thy
0:42:06 sustainer is wise all-known this
0:42:09 translation such was the argument we
0:42:11 gave to Abraham against his people we
0:42:13 raise and rank whoever we will your lord
0:42:16 is all wise honoring yeah listen it
0:42:19 seemed to be from that moment maybe
0:42:21 Ibrahim got a revelation now Allah after
0:42:24 he has received all that by himself it
0:42:26 seems to be that moment
0:42:28 this is our argument we gave it to Bryan
0:42:31 it's a rhetoric argument but it is it's
0:42:33 a devastating one we and you agree
0:42:35 there's an ultimate being
0:42:37 and these entities
0:42:39 we should Define a Divinity to them in
0:42:42 some obscure sense and somehow
0:42:44 are supposed to be offspring of this
0:42:46 device because they have to admit that
0:42:47 okay discuss with them that's that's it
0:42:49 that's the situation
0:42:51 then you are saying fear that they will
0:42:54 strike you they may be divine they will
0:42:56 strike you I say it's impossible that
0:42:59 they are divine
0:43:02 but I assume there's an authority have
0:43:04 come down from Allah from the Supreme
0:43:06 one we agree that he is the Supreme and
0:43:08 the only initial the initial one where
0:43:11 is that actually show it to me
0:43:14 they can't it's impossible although they
0:43:16 can say we got that from our fathers
0:43:18 when they got your father's from
0:43:19 they must have authority they cannot be
0:43:21 by themselves Authority and nobody can
0:43:23 deny that
0:43:24 on their grandfathers and the great
0:43:26 grandfathers
0:43:28 Etc
0:43:29 ultimately they end
0:43:33 restore the world
0:43:35 but it's also in the sense that when we
0:43:38 agree on these two premises then the
0:43:40 result will result by necessity
0:43:43 but we have to agree first on these two
0:43:45 premises
0:43:47 so this we gave this this evidence to
0:43:50 Ibrahimovic read the second translation
0:43:52 only one
0:43:54 I refer to them
0:43:56 um not to recap such was the argument we
0:43:59 gave to Abraham against his people we
0:44:00 raise and rank whoever we will your Lord
0:44:03 is always all knowing
0:44:05 yeah so this is this is essentially
0:44:07 clear does this Allah Allah is given to
0:44:09 Ibrahim and this may be the beginning of
0:44:11 Revelation and beginning of a doctor as
0:44:13 a prophet
0:44:15 and then it continues then with his
0:44:17 history
0:44:19 man
0:44:24 Music
0:44:29 uh what are you
0:44:32 also foreign
0:44:44 because I like it out of the way
0:44:46 inshallah
0:44:48 and we bestowed upon Him Isaac and Jacob
0:44:51 and we guided each of them as we had
0:44:53 guided Noah a thought time and out of
0:44:55 his offspring we bestowed prophethood
0:44:58 upon David and Solomon and job and
0:45:00 Joseph and Moses and Arun for thus we do
0:45:03 reward the doers of good
0:45:05 a translation we gave Isaac a Jacob
0:45:09 we gave him Isaac and Jacob we guided
0:45:11 each just as we had guided Noah before
0:45:13 among his defense descendants were David
0:45:16 Solomon job Joseph Moses and Arun in
0:45:20 this way we reward those who do good
0:45:22 yeah so unless Ibrahim become then the
0:45:24 father of the prophets after him then
0:45:26 maybe other prophets from other words
0:45:28 but they are minor and they are not to
0:45:29 mention this kind of major scripture
0:45:31 there may be others in China we can't
0:45:33 exclude that and we cannot exclude that
0:45:35 there may be have been prophets in the
0:45:37 in the North American uh and and to
0:45:39 Americas which we're not aware about
0:45:40 that because this history of that is
0:45:42 essentially gone I don't think I don't
0:45:45 think we have a good a good
0:45:46 understanding or or a decoding of the
0:45:49 language of the Maya and the Inca and so
0:45:51 on so that we can see if there's any but
0:45:53 it is very well possible we we don't
0:45:55 know but the main line of profitable in
0:45:58 the Middle East with the center of the
0:45:59 world Central world is because the
0:46:01 meeting places of the three continents
0:46:04 and the place which has weather-wise I
0:46:06 think that the most perfect weather for
0:46:08 for starting point for the Revelation
0:46:10 and history is Palestine and around all
0:46:14 the way from Mecca all the way to the
0:46:15 beginning of turkey and this area that's
0:46:18 the place where really civilization and
0:46:20 the philosophy I think started which is
0:46:23 a little bit to Egypt and a little bit
0:46:25 to Iraq so that's the calendar of
0:46:27 civilization more than at least recent
0:46:29 civilization ten thousand fifty thousand
0:46:32 before that there may be other
0:46:33 civilization elsewhere but that's the
0:46:35 character of really significant and here
0:46:38 he is the father of the main line of
0:46:40 prophets and some of them are mentioned
0:46:42 here
0:46:51 falling out for these ranks but is
0:46:53 mentioned as an intervening sentence but
0:46:55 all the one after that
0:46:57 has been been guided before but from the
0:47:01 offsprings of Ibrahim we have the awards
0:47:03 that's refutes obviously the Jews who
0:47:06 claimed that wood is only a king not a
0:47:08 Prophet by the way and Suleiman is not
0:47:10 even not about uh not a king but even
0:47:13 died as a kaffirmation according to the
0:47:15 majority of the Jews and we discussed
0:47:17 that in the accused him of Witchcraft
0:47:19 and Saturn is that what are you with the
0:47:24 famous uh story of suffering and so on
0:47:26 uh Yusuf who is known in the messenger
0:47:29 to Egypt and Musa and his brother harun
0:47:32 and this is that's the way Allah because
0:47:35 Ibrahim Ibrahim went Allah
0:47:38 said I appointed you to Adidas
0:47:43 Imam
0:47:45 is
0:47:47 natural he's a human being a human being
0:47:50 said like that they would like to have
0:47:52 the these benefits for the owner of
0:47:54 Springs that's natural that's that's
0:47:56 physiology that's the way you are
0:47:57 created and fashionista with genome is
0:48:00 developed
0:48:01 Allah has just answered with one thing
0:48:03 he did not say they will be except I
0:48:05 responded to the question for for
0:48:08 the son of Ismail when building a Kappa
0:48:11 that was before Daniel is a promise from
0:48:14 Ismail there will be there will be a
0:48:16 messenger who will teach them
0:48:19 that's before but from the other line
0:48:21 and when he finished all these tests
0:48:24 including slaughtering Ismail and then
0:48:26 Etc including building a club and so on
0:48:29 and there's all these abilities have
0:48:31 tests he passed all these things
0:48:38 would certain words and Commandments and
0:48:41 he completed the test one passed with
0:48:43 flying colors Allah said I am appointing
0:48:46 you to a leader of mankind
0:48:49 intellectual and the idea definitely
0:48:51 Imam he is not a head of state because
0:48:53 he clearly is not our head of state and
0:48:55 so on this is to answer properly some of
0:48:58 the shiately I'm okay
0:49:02 Imam his intellectual leadership
0:49:04 ideological leadership could be valuable
0:49:06 and infallible it's not necessary if
0:49:08 he's a prophet he is infallible and
0:49:10 bring you the message but not
0:49:12 necessarily infallible in in in in his
0:49:15 behavior like in the case of units Etc
0:49:17 let's discuss in the book of extensively
0:49:19 we don't go to these fine points
0:49:21 and from these
0:49:23 from that Allah just answered
0:49:26 maybe this is
0:49:29 what I mean he knows that Allah
0:49:31 responded in part to that artist
0:49:33 that definitely from his offspring
0:49:36 a bunch a good number of imams have
0:49:38 imaged
0:49:40 from them some mentioned by name the the
0:49:43 one passed in the previous year the next
0:49:45 Ayah mentioned further Zakaria were here
0:49:47 in
0:49:52 and upon Zechariah and John and Jesus
0:49:55 and Elijah every one of them was
0:49:56 righteous mother of the righteous next
0:49:58 translation Zechariah John Jesus and
0:50:01 Elijah every one of them was righteous
0:50:03 clear question
0:50:05 um
0:50:07 yeah
0:50:19 and you're and you'll have is not Sakari
0:50:21 is only Zakaria no this is the first
0:50:23 translation is and upon Zacharia this
0:50:26 one just says zacharya John Jesus no
0:50:28 maybe he just he just missed it today
0:50:30 sometimes they regard the ant as not
0:50:32 very nice in English maybe yeah I think
0:50:34 almost the only one which is which some
0:50:37 people claim it is a in one of them is
0:50:40 one wow I don't know where it is exactly
0:50:41 and I must have a xiaomi only but
0:50:44 there's no no later which is which is a
0:50:47 matter of dispute is there or not there
0:50:48 except
0:50:50 none whatsoever
0:50:59 the last one which is only the Quran
0:51:02 mentioned as a prophet actually because
0:51:04 there's a book of Zechariah if you go to
0:51:07 the Old Testament this other zakariah is
0:51:09 the one and again some uh missionaries
0:51:13 actually the only is a career you know
0:51:16 is the one after the babylonic Exile
0:51:18 with and the career and so on
0:51:21 which gave it in the final instruction
0:51:23 which is followed by natural that you
0:51:26 should not have a king you should submit
0:51:27 to Pagan Kings as a punishment yes you
0:51:30 are out of the ballionic side but you
0:51:32 are not allowed to establish a kingdom
0:51:54 but the career of the new is not
0:51:57 mentioned as a new testament if I'm not
0:51:59 mistaken even not in the Apocrypha is
0:52:02 not known
0:52:08 next day after Christmas about the
0:52:11 Christmas story and from the according
0:52:12 to the Quran showing the mistakes in the
0:52:14 existing Christmas Story and the blatant
0:52:17 contradiction to history and the story
0:52:19 of the Quran fits history better and
0:52:21 synchronized nicely so listen to that
0:52:23 video so this is the career over here so
0:52:25 their Prophets
0:52:27 why you sell no I don't know what that
0:52:28 says the most controversial issue
0:52:31 between Muslim and Christian about its
0:52:33 nature is a Divine or a prophet and with
0:52:36 the Jews but the Jews is a major
0:52:38 criminal and he's supposed to be having
0:52:41 the West punishment he's in he's not in
0:52:44 a boiling water he's in a boiling semen
0:52:46 and it's the most disgusting for the
0:52:47 Jews
0:52:49 through a bad mood anyway without going
0:52:51 to bring these hostile issues and mess
0:52:54 up our beautiful and peaceful Quran
0:52:58 Gathering but that's what they believe
0:53:00 so it's a very controversial person Isa
0:53:03 and even the issue with it is
0:53:07 there are many evidence for that but his
0:53:10 research by itself I will complete insha
0:53:12 Allah it is
0:53:14 and uh uh what is Ilias they there is a
0:53:20 person which repeatedly mentioned in the
0:53:22 Old Testament of the ocean in cement
0:53:23 Elijah I don't think it's Elijah Elias I
0:53:25 think it's a it's uh because the story
0:53:27 in other places his relation to the bad
0:53:30 worshiper and so on Elias and eliasin
0:53:32 it's Elisha that's the one has the story
0:53:35 with the bad worshiper and the one who
0:53:37 challenged him to a mutual
0:53:40 conversation with the challenge that if
0:53:42 if your supplication is accepted then
0:53:45 you can kill me and if your if my
0:53:48 supplication is accepted and they are
0:53:49 defeated but is not saving you and that
0:53:51 it doesn't existed the academy exists
0:53:54 and then I will kill you and he killed I
0:53:57 think several according to all different
0:53:58 several hundred years slaughtered with
0:54:00 his own hand that's Elisha and his wife
0:54:02 also the prophetess Elisha so this is
0:54:05 Elias
0:54:09 all are from the righteous from the good
0:54:12 men and good people
0:54:15 next I fed them other prophets was
0:54:27 Jonah and lot and every one of them we
0:54:30 did favor among above other people okay
0:54:33 the translation
0:54:36 we favored every one of them above other
0:54:39 people I wonder why the other one said
0:54:41 yes with Elijah
0:54:43 actually yes yes I should be it should
0:54:46 be it should be clear it says Joshua
0:54:50 I wonder how he got at this Elisha
0:54:53 well all three translations have Alicia
0:54:56 Alicia I think is usual
0:55:03 but anyway I I will check that I'll
0:55:06 check what was their grounding for that
0:55:08 I'll check maybe the old the old
0:55:09 Scholars and so on Alias I think I said
0:55:14 yes yes
0:55:16 I mean the large one the the the uh and
0:55:20 this is the one maybe the name of your
0:55:22 sword model after that they and they
0:55:24 think they claim it is Joshua Joshua the
0:55:27 son of noon and then when I came after
0:55:28 Moses in the promised land and just a
0:55:32 small note in history and they claim the
0:55:34 meaning uh for your sword the meaning is
0:55:36 the savior but
0:55:39 Yeshua is not it's not saving meaning
0:55:41 the one who is open winded meaning in
0:55:44 the Arabic relation the one who is who's
0:55:46 generous called White he his hand is
0:55:49 wide open not the one his hand is tight
0:55:51 the one the generous one the
0:55:53 encompassing one the one who is
0:55:55 accommodating the one who can gather the
0:55:57 people and is generous Yes actually the
0:56:00 the Savior the meaning of saving is
0:56:02 exactly in the word Lisa
0:56:08 which is obviously an ancient name most
0:56:10 likely in some kind of Aramaic and maybe
0:56:12 not Arabic lyrics and in Arabic is only
0:56:16 one word which have this any scene it is
0:56:19 is the name of the of the camels in uh
0:56:22 of the of the common social use to
0:56:26 travel the desert and as you find that
0:56:28 in in a famous piece of policy Keller is
0:56:32 like there is in the desert they are
0:56:36 dying of fast and water and big skins
0:56:38 are carried on their back is why they
0:56:41 are called there is because they save
0:56:43 you in the desert they cross the desert
0:56:45 they're capable of Crossing that they
0:56:46 are right they're reliable that is their
0:56:49 Savior and this is indicated another
0:56:51 piece of War 3 of Mali cabinet I said
0:56:54 when he he was he was he was a gangster
0:56:56 and the highway robber in the time then
0:57:00 he repented and joined the the uh the
0:57:03 Muslim armies going to in the conquest
0:57:05 of uh of Afghanistan and uh borders of
0:57:09 Horizon and then he he suffered injury
0:57:12 also a disease and died there while he's
0:57:14 dying he was remembering the The Meadows
0:57:18 of and so on
0:57:22 us
0:57:27 that's the way the Arabs say like like
0:57:30 in a like in humor saying all the
0:57:32 goddesses of poetry inspire me that's
0:57:35 the way the Arab says what about my
0:57:37 poetry will I have ever time to spend
0:57:40 the night near the radar Visa these are
0:57:43 the threes which are common in in
0:57:44 Northern and in in that area
0:57:49 driving the the camels which which save
0:57:53 you and just came through the desert
0:57:57 so this is the only place I found
0:58:01 anything without any Arts so the meaning
0:58:04 they claim to the sword means is that
0:58:06 foreign
0:58:11 so the meaning is correct but
0:58:14 attributing to the wrong word I mean the
0:58:16 the Christian Aramaic Christian
0:58:19 in in English and in European kind of
0:58:22 distinguishes issues it's the end of the
0:58:24 beginning of the end you have to be
0:58:25 decide by the way the discussion is
0:58:27 starting the second is uh Christian
0:58:29 Century it's not recent it's an old
0:58:31 discussion and there's there's various
0:58:33 references and the claim that the Jewish
0:58:36 literature which is very negative to ISA
0:58:38 and the accused him to be of uh boiling
0:58:40 and semen and the son of Harold
0:58:43 Etc this one issue not Joshua
0:58:47 it is again publication to claim it is
0:58:49 in the Jewish as usual no that's not
0:58:51 true this is all have been recessed and
0:58:54 done now it's finished and done and
0:58:55 forgotten so don't be fooled by this for
0:58:57 three people okay
0:58:59 no it is
0:59:02 and there have been a description found
0:59:04 in which someone is calling for ISSA to
0:59:06 focused and Dua which shows which
0:59:10 probably suggests that the man is
0:59:12 Christian because he's calling him as a
0:59:14 redeemer so that can't be on the east
0:59:16 side it's not it's not a big identity
0:59:18 like someone may speculate but this
0:59:21 inscription is like like 300 after
0:59:23 Christ or something like that so that's
0:59:24 the genuine one most likely anyway I
0:59:27 don't want to indulge in that feeling
0:59:28 more than that it's a secondary point
0:59:30 but it's all again shows that the Quran
0:59:32 is correcting things and these guys are
0:59:34 just not willing to open their eyes and
0:59:37 study things meticulously
0:59:42 I think I was always think it's Joshua
0:59:45 yes sir yeah you should have been known
0:59:48 maybe something else I will check why
0:59:50 they got earlier maybe they will try to
0:59:52 advice with Elijah
0:59:54 we'll see I I'm not sure
0:59:58 but whatever it is
1:00:01 the last one is amazing Uranus is
1:00:04 definitely from bunny Israel and this is
1:00:08 before maybe before or at the time I
1:00:11 think before the babylonic excite maybe
1:00:12 because at that at the at the with
1:00:17 animal before the ability and exide
1:00:20 because I shouldn't destroyed North
1:00:21 Israel North the ten tribes and Exile
1:00:25 them and destroy the northern state of
1:00:27 Israel which was his Capital was in
1:00:30 around in in in the current uh Nablus or
1:00:33 around or something like that and excite
1:00:36 them and maybe after that illness was
1:00:38 sent or is exile no it can't be about
1:00:41 because there's no mention of him in the
1:00:43 book of The Book of Daniel it's almost
1:00:45 like it's in the in the assurian Exile
1:00:48 anyway let's show on us and it was sent
1:00:50 to the people of nine hour so most
1:00:51 likely to use an excited lot is
1:00:55 the only exception he's an issue your
1:00:59 brain but he the the the the the the
1:01:02 nephew can be counted as a descendant
1:01:05 because usually your nephew is like your
1:01:07 son and your uncle is like equivalent to
1:01:09 your father and this is mentioned also
1:01:11 called other place so this is the only
1:01:12 exception which also hints that any few
1:01:15 can be regarded as a son in some sense
1:01:17 another
1:01:18 and let's mention another place when we
1:01:20 come to to the I think that we measure
1:01:22 that in the soil in in
1:01:25 when the death came to your group he
1:01:27 asked his children whom do you worship
1:01:30 after me they say Worship You worship
1:01:31 your God and the god of your fathers
1:01:33 yeah
1:01:36 it's right it's not that he's not his
1:01:38 father his uncle was regarded as a
1:01:40 father so the uncle is counted sometimes
1:01:42 as a father
1:01:44 in that sense so the root is not
1:01:47 spelling of Ibrahim directly but his
1:01:49 joints with Rahim with the ibrahim's
1:01:51 father he is his nephew
1:01:53 and celebrate so it's like like a son
1:01:57 look all of these have been elevated
1:01:59 above the people of their time or the
1:02:01 people of all time
1:02:05 um
1:02:14 foreign
1:02:21 ERS and their offspring and their
1:02:24 brethren we we elected them all and
1:02:26 guided them onto a straight path
1:02:28 straightway and also and next
1:02:31 translation and also some of their
1:02:32 forefathers their offspring and their
1:02:34 brothers we chose them and guided them
1:02:36 on a straight path so that's that's
1:02:38 maybe then I just it covers also a lot
1:02:41 because it is either if he's not the
1:02:43 Edict of spring he's from their brothers
1:02:44 from their from their uh
1:02:48 descending from their brothers and from
1:02:50 their fathers who said the forefathers
1:02:51 actually about whom would be fathers and
1:02:53 forefathers yeah
1:02:56 and they're Offspring so it's not only
1:02:58 Ibrahim but also branches around these
1:03:00 and related to this
1:03:03 and they're all guided to the straight
1:03:05 path
1:03:07 Allah
1:03:17 such is God's guidance
1:03:21 he guides there with whomever he will
1:03:23 for his servants and they had they
1:03:26 ascribed Divinity to off beside him in
1:03:28 vain indeed would have
1:03:31 been all the good in indeed
1:03:34 would have been all the good that they
1:03:37 ever did in vain yes it has been lost
1:03:40 yeah next translation this translation
1:03:42 such is God's guidance he guides
1:03:44 whomever he Wills of his worshipers and
1:03:47 they ascribe divinities to others
1:03:48 besides him all their good works would
1:03:51 have been invade yeah that's easier
1:03:53 maybe less complicated such a sentence
1:03:55 but it's really clear so all of this
1:03:57 this guidance all of these bestones all
1:04:00 of this ranking it's conditional that
1:04:02 they didn't describe any Divinity they
1:04:04 have ascribed anything they would have
1:04:05 been destroyed and gone finished over
1:04:07 give over
1:04:09 foreign
1:04:23 and sound judgment and prophethood and
1:04:26 now although the unbelievers may choose
1:04:27 to deny these truths know that we have
1:04:30 entrusted them to people who will never
1:04:32 refuse to acknowledge them next
1:04:34 translation those are the ones to whom
1:04:36 we gave the book wisdom and prophethood
1:04:39 even if these people now choose to deny
1:04:42 chose to deny the truth we will entrust
1:04:44 it to others who will never deny the
1:04:46 truth yeah so this is threatening to
1:04:48 Christ listen that's this this history
1:04:50 is here we'll established about that and
1:04:55 now we will establish a new new branch
1:04:57 of guidance and so on and if you quality
1:04:59 deny that and rejected there will be
1:05:02 other people who will accept that that's
1:05:03 the problem and they will not be
1:05:06 disbelieving in it and they will be
1:05:07 carrying that and that has happened we
1:05:09 know in history that's by the way in
1:05:11 Mecca what Islam was persecuted and
1:05:13 there is no clear
1:05:14 no clear thing in the Horizon showing
1:05:17 that it will ever succeed or even become
1:05:19 become the enormous Empire that became
1:05:22 underneath falls in the world it has
1:05:24 become so that would happen so don't
1:05:27 worry about them let them go down
1:05:29 downhill to the hell it doesn't make any
1:05:31 difference Allah will fulfill his
1:05:33 promise and there will be other people
1:05:34 who would accept that and carry it as it
1:05:36 should be cut it
1:05:38 um
1:05:47 to Those whom God has got it followed
1:05:50 them follow them their guidance and say
1:05:52 no reward do I ask of you for this truth
1:05:55 behold it has got an admonition unto all
1:05:58 mankind next translation these were the
1:06:01 people God guided follow their guidance
1:06:04 and say I ask no reward from for it from
1:06:06 you it is a reminder to all people yeah
1:06:09 there are a few things there that's very
1:06:11 clear the general meaning but only one
1:06:13 point maybe some some people may
1:06:14 misinterpretation
1:06:17 to follow the guidance of the previous
1:06:20 prophets and so on
1:06:22 uh some people may construct from that
1:06:25 that uh
1:06:26 he's obliged to follow the Sharia that's
1:06:28 a mistake because he's talking about
1:06:30 guidance and the whole context from
1:06:31 beginning with the end even the word of
1:06:33 volume up there and all the way that the
1:06:35 threat that they have committed silk
1:06:37 they would have been all loser and all
1:06:39 action would have been in vain Etc shows
1:06:42 the issues of guidance here is only the
1:06:44 issue of fundamental is
1:06:46 the strict model that is describing tool
1:06:50 nobody else any Divinity except Allah
1:06:52 all Divinity exclusively and fully
1:06:55 attributed to Allah and fully and
1:06:59 definitely rejected to be attributed to
1:07:02 anybody else except Allah that's the
1:07:03 guidance and also anything related to
1:07:05 that like struggle with the nation
1:07:07 rejecting their Nation declaring
1:07:09 themselves to be the divorced and then
1:07:10 and this avoiding their nation's Idols
1:07:14 Etc that's the guidance and this is an
1:07:16 obligation to all prophecies are
1:07:17 fundamental it's a it's been dictated by
1:07:20 insistative reason and made the Sharia
1:07:22 to all prophets by Allah it's a
1:07:25 fundamental part so so this guidance is
1:07:27 to be followed and they're endurance of
1:07:29 the suffering etc etc etc Sharia
1:07:32 injunctions
1:07:33 that's financially is quite different
1:07:36 and the evidences we brought in the book
1:07:39 of read that by by appointing them and
1:07:40 saying Allah the final messenger and
1:07:43 other evidences uh all previous Syria
1:07:45 has been abrogated and by the obligation
1:07:48 of osharias and the appointing him final
1:07:50 messenger then the basic ruling of
1:07:52 permissibility applies to everything and
1:07:53 then the Sharia had then made something
1:07:55 permissible something prohibited
1:07:57 something bit by bit until it was
1:08:00 completed by the decibels as of before
1:08:02 the deaths well before the death
1:08:04 so this is not that Sharia before us is
1:08:07 our Sharia no and the people for example
1:08:09 some people take this or they'll play a
1:08:12 game like for example look at Yusuf what
1:08:14 was doing in muscle uh ruling under
1:08:17 under Catholic disregarding the claim
1:08:20 that he was under Cafe King ruling as
1:08:22 ruling with the cover of the king it's
1:08:23 not it's not necessarily true because we
1:08:26 don't know if that King was a cafe
1:08:27 that's number one we don't know if he's
1:08:29 became a Believer we don't know about
1:08:30 that secondly we don't know if that King
1:08:32 has any Sharia differences
1:08:35 and even that that you Yusuf was
1:08:37 applying that shitty interface maybe he
1:08:39 did not apply it maybe he's abrogated
1:08:40 all of this assumption which is not
1:08:42 covered neither but Quran nor by the Old
1:08:44 Testament uh even some Islamic
1:08:47 narrations they say cannot be trusted
1:08:48 because not lifted to the prophet claim
1:08:50 that when he is appointed to the the
1:08:53 controller of all the Treasures of the
1:08:55 earth and the pre-management of the
1:08:57 famine
1:08:58 because he prophesied the famine and the
1:09:00 King accepted that they obviously
1:09:01 believed him that he's an inspired man
1:09:03 the king went to his Palace hand him all
1:09:05 power became a nominal King almost like
1:09:08 a constitutional democracy
1:09:11 and and Joseph was the role exclusive
1:09:14 and supreme Supreme Ruler he's an Act
1:09:16 laws and so on the only thing is the
1:09:18 king became state nominal because the
1:09:20 Sharia did at that time did not enact
1:09:22 the obligation of shura and the people
1:09:25 electing their rulers but especially our
1:09:26 injection has nothing to do with with a
1:09:30 specific injection if there was no
1:09:32 injunction Allah did not give the people
1:09:33 yet the authority to be king of
1:09:35 themselves that came later with with
1:09:37 Musa so that's that's the only thing is
1:09:39 there after anything else is under the
1:09:42 control and the legislation of Yusuf so
1:09:45 there's no
1:09:46 he was allowed to do no that's not true
1:09:49 it can't be so this is all arguments
1:09:51 which is just one waving arguments
1:09:53 trying to to save the day for people who
1:09:55 want to participate and comfort ruling
1:09:57 and find an argument for life no that's
1:09:59 there's no argument for that that's not
1:10:00 an argument
1:10:01 other people get for example when
1:10:05 uh when they when people are exercising
1:10:08 the role say look at Allah all the uh
1:10:10 Musa addressing uh foreign
1:11:05 mental principles later inside in the
1:11:08 Quran and by appointing the messenger
1:11:10 Allah the final messenger is is that the
1:11:14 the the the final Sharia that with the
1:11:17 appointment of him as a messenger to the
1:11:19 mankind uh all previous Syria has been
1:11:21 abrogated
1:11:25 so that's that's that's not contradict
1:11:26 that just to clarify that point because
1:11:28 some people had abused this Ayah for
1:11:30 that sense
1:11:31 the guidance the guidance which is
1:11:33 mentioned all the way for all the page
1:11:35 or maybe Seven Ten eyes before that is
1:11:38 the guidance concerning for example for
1:11:40 Ibrahim in the guidance of looking in
1:11:42 the universe and analyzing the movement
1:11:44 to the stars and concluding that they
1:11:45 are contingent and created and so on
1:11:48 that's a proper guidance yes
1:11:50 and how to analyze the universe
1:11:52 unfortunately Muslim did not follow that
1:11:54 guidance
1:11:56 unfortunately
1:11:57 instead they go try to construct the
1:12:00 case to rule by copper by claiming Yusuf
1:12:03 was grueling Michael that is very
1:12:05 unfortunate but this is what you expect
1:12:06 from from government Scholars and
1:12:09 threators not from real sincere Scholars
1:12:13 so that's the guidance and again
1:12:16 affirming yourself in many places that
1:12:19 many people have accused their profits
1:12:20 like now many islamists are Accused by
1:12:23 governments you are out for God you
1:12:25 wanted to have a rulership you want to
1:12:26 you want your soul you are vying for
1:12:28 power
1:12:31 which maybe or maybe not true but even
1:12:34 if they are lying for more that's
1:12:35 usually also for the islamistic why you
1:12:38 are clinging to power who gave you the
1:12:39 right only for power the other should
1:12:41 not have a shadow power
1:12:42 but anyway let's go to the prophets they
1:12:45 tell the people you must be out for
1:12:47 something you want Kingdom
1:12:49 or maybe your wife is ugly you want nice
1:12:51 wife and our daughter is beautiful we'll
1:12:53 give you our daughters and wives shall
1:12:54 take 100 drives if you want you want
1:12:56 money we collect money so we become the
1:12:58 richest
1:13:00 king with them okay we make you the king
1:13:02 above him but just stop this issue stop
1:13:05 uh negating our divine being and our
1:13:08 attacking our ideology
1:13:20 not from you
1:13:24 this is just a reminder that you think a
1:13:27 knowledge for the whole mankind for the
1:13:30 whole universes for all my kind that's
1:13:32 the obviously foreign
1:13:40 you know in other planets mostly I
1:13:43 cannot addressed by the messenger of
1:13:44 Allah but for definitely any humans to
1:13:47 an earth someone who can accept the
1:13:49 message and understand it in on Earth
1:13:52 is he has he is definitely addressed by
1:13:54 Muhammad
1:13:57 um
1:13:58 well how is the time we still have good
1:14:00 time
1:14:01 yeah we've got verse 233 now
1:14:03 um we can break into question and
1:14:05 answers if you want yeah because you
1:14:07 start a new uh a new issues about uh
1:14:10 did Allah reveal anything that's all it
1:14:12 said around this because they were
1:14:14 arguing that Revelation is not possible
1:14:16 Allah is not possible that's essentially
1:14:18 the argument of the the philosopher the
1:14:21 philosopher the Hindus not the common
1:14:22 symbol Hindus that's usually discussed
1:14:25 in the books of alcoholic about that the
1:14:27 Hindu point of view is the Tribulation
1:14:29 is not possible it's the meaning of
1:14:32 divinity that's that's one one of the
1:14:34 standard arguments of the Hindu I mean
1:14:37 the Hindu philosophers not the common
1:14:38 side
1:14:40 philosophy I'm just discussed in the
1:14:42 books of alcohol so this is a new topic
1:14:44 that's that's indeed Revelation is
1:14:46 possible it does not contradicts Allah
1:14:48 comprehensive power nor free will or
1:14:50 anything like that but I think that's a
1:14:52 topic by itself we'll do it for next
1:14:54 time so we stop here with Allah and
1:14:57 we'll take some some more questions so
1:14:59 so there's one question that came uh
1:15:01 over uh the Youtube channel and that is
1:15:04 since uh you mentioned that Ibrahim
1:15:07 Islam was the first philosopher and
1:15:10 someone use philosophy in dawah because
1:15:12 I heard some some people on YouTube say
1:15:14 that you can't use it I'm assuming what
1:15:17 have you oh that's don't uh you will see
1:15:20 in the two of you between Muslims but
1:15:22 also between Christians Jews and Hindus
1:15:24 you'll find plenty of donkeys just
1:15:26 ignore them no no philosophy meaning the
1:15:30 discourse which go in the depth of
1:15:32 things like what is the nature of being
1:15:34 and so on it goes deep that's not for
1:15:36 the Common People okay the common people
1:15:37 would not go in such a depth
1:15:39 generally but does not mean that but
1:15:42 because the philosophy Islamic
1:15:45 they indulge in issues which in some
1:15:49 places contradicted to the people of
1:15:51 Hadith were involved in and the real
1:15:53 Hadith were hedging by saying this is
1:15:55 not Islamic this is taken from the Jews
1:15:58 the second one because they came from
1:15:59 the Greek Etc they're trying to make
1:16:01 that as if it is a good argument that's
1:16:04 not a good argument because the basic
1:16:06 principles of philosophy are inside the
1:16:08 Quran we just read the story of Ibrahim
1:16:09 and who was he discussing that's a
1:16:12 disability that's a genuine
1:16:13 philosophical discourse in a level of
1:16:15 the 2000 year before Christ
1:16:17 presented by a language which even as a
1:16:20 common Bedouin understand but really to
1:16:23 go into the depths you need to analyze
1:16:25 it further and we did that in chapter
1:16:26 number six in the book of raheed
1:16:30 Ibrahimovic advice if this brother is an
1:16:33 Arabic leader to read it or just have
1:16:35 bite the bullet and wait for the
1:16:37 translation
1:16:38 well this one so that's that's nonsense
1:16:41 I just forget about that no like there's
1:16:43 another there's a group of shabab uh
1:16:46 they they have uh what's what's their
1:16:48 name they are they having like
1:16:50 philosophical discussion and they have
1:16:51 their they were able to discuss with
1:16:53 Christian and others
1:16:55 against there's quite a few sapiens yeah
1:16:58 and the others who are invited various
1:17:00 Christians to Islam and they became
1:17:02 Muslims and they participated in the
1:17:03 discussion anyway they they go into a
1:17:06 deep philosophical issues and so on
1:17:08 but that's good we have also blogging
1:17:10 theology blogging theology goes into
1:17:12 philosophical research but it is more
1:17:14 scriptural and scholarly issues more
1:17:17 than philosophical but he does
1:17:18 considerable amount of philosophical
1:17:20 issues he invited atheists discussed
1:17:22 with them
1:17:23 uh and uh that's all that's all
1:17:26 philosophy searching for that truth and
1:17:28 the deep meaning of words and perception
1:17:31 and things like that behind that the
1:17:34 things at face value
1:17:39 Quran itself but it says that if it was
1:17:41 not from Allah it would be many
1:17:43 contradictions that's a philosophical
1:17:44 also in the school so go there and try
1:17:47 to constructive contradictions
1:17:50 and see if it's really a general
1:17:51 correlation because it will start the
1:17:53 condition you have to show it's a
1:17:54 genuine contradiction this is no way to
1:17:55 have another interpretation because if
1:17:58 you if you and this will be the Quran
1:18:00 Quran the Quran the whole Quran now
1:18:04 that's at any stage in Mecca the Quran
1:18:06 was sufficient to be studied as in front
1:18:09 of them to find contradiction later on
1:18:12 then we have the even up to the 10th
1:18:15 year one with a dialogue with the
1:18:16 Christian from that then the issues of
1:18:18 the ayas
1:18:20 they show you that how to do with them
1:18:22 if something had multiple meanings or
1:18:24 possible interpretation so which
1:18:26 interpretation should we take
1:18:28 there's no there's only only rational
1:18:30 way is that we have to see what is
1:18:32 established with certitude we have to
1:18:34 establish that things will set the tune
1:18:36 fast and then if something has multiple
1:18:38 meaning let us see if any one of these
1:18:40 meaning if all of them contradict them
1:18:42 then there's a contradiction but if one
1:18:44 of the meaning fits with the Markham
1:18:47 that's the one to be shoes otherwise
1:18:49 you're not doing the the rational and
1:18:51 the philosophical discourse probably you
1:18:53 see the point so whatever that's the
1:18:55 reason the qurans deliberately have
1:18:57 things such as
1:18:59 so to force your your mind to work hard
1:19:04 it's not spoon feeding use your brain
1:19:06 work a little bit it could mean this
1:19:09 means this means this which one is the
1:19:11 correct one check the Quran what is the
1:19:13 fundamentally will established with
1:19:15 certitude
1:19:16 and then build on that
1:19:19 if the after that you find the
1:19:20 contradiction then you get then then you
1:19:24 have the evidence you're not right
1:19:25 through history all the people who try
1:19:27 to construct a contradiction they ended
1:19:29 not only defeated they ended actually
1:19:30 detecting things like for example many
1:19:33 have hung on the uh in the Ayah which is
1:19:40 foreign
1:20:05 and if there was and there will be a
1:20:07 biggest campaign in the universe against
1:20:09 that nobody objected to that so what's
1:20:12 that meaning
1:20:19 so so just think a little bit so how to
1:20:23 solve the problem problem is very simple
1:20:24 I found actually I think it was found
1:20:26 nobody found it in this report it is
1:20:28 actually
1:20:36 from them this clarify what is
1:20:42 a branch of Jews and the follower of
1:20:44 John the Baptist is not the star
1:20:47 worshiper of haran or the Babylonian
1:20:49 some people kill him this is no that's
1:20:51 not enough who deviated from their
1:20:54 people and became rebellious and
1:20:55 Mavericks it is the follower of John the
1:20:57 Baptist they are from the Jews and this
1:20:59 I clarify and then discussed actually in
1:21:01 a big section in the circle the meaning
1:21:03 of because of this which they claim to
1:21:06 be
1:21:07 a grammatical mistake but she's
1:21:09 expecting people
1:21:11 Muhammad is not so stupid to make such a
1:21:13 mistake
1:21:14 assume it's from Muhammad
1:21:17 come on people
1:21:19 just have a bit of sense
1:21:21 just have a bit of sense
1:21:25 as I said it looks like lahan but the
1:21:27 Arabs are corrected by their tongues
1:21:31 if if you indulge in such stupidity you
1:21:35 make yourself a mockery but but there's
1:21:37 a problem if someone is drowning he
1:21:39 hangs on on Straw Hat instead of going
1:21:41 to the meaty issues the diva real meat
1:21:43 issues
1:21:45 the same with the recent issues about
1:21:48 erisa and yasua which has been excited
1:21:50 very recently at the time Muhammad used
1:21:52 ASA and they were Christians full of all
1:21:54 the web
1:21:57 I I I I I urge those who specialize in
1:22:00 Reading Greek and so on read John of
1:22:02 Damascus genre who attacks Islam and
1:22:04 attacked the ishmaelite and called him
1:22:06 salazarian the sons of the slave Salas
1:22:08 the son of the slave because this one
1:22:10 the the sun opens my ears the son of a
1:22:12 slave woman okay
1:22:22 that issue
1:22:24 it must have been given for them
1:22:27 as far as you know nobody until that
1:22:29 generation objected only later someone
1:22:31 constructed something much later
1:22:34 try to reinvent the wheel which has been
1:22:36 invented and running long ago before him
1:22:39 the same Mission things like that to to
1:22:43 go about this so This these are all but
1:22:46 it's not really physiology in the school
1:22:47 this is more historical analytical
1:22:49 discourse which you can call
1:22:52 philosophical in the general sense but
1:22:54 not really in the specific set
1:22:55 specifically what Ibrahim is doing
1:22:57 the moon this is a star it looks like
1:23:00 they claim it's a Divine it's just the
1:23:02 Marduk for example if it is if it is uh
1:23:05 if it is Mars and then it sits so it was
1:23:08 here it said it moves it's contingent
1:23:11 and maybe here maybe here not that's a
1:23:13 contingency that's that's not the whole
1:23:15 Mark of a Divine being which somehow at
1:23:18 that time of Ibrahim must be somehow
1:23:21 omnipresent necessarily existing this
1:23:23 does not look like that that's a video
1:23:25 so we can discuss looking deeper in the
1:23:28 existence and being and the meaning of
1:23:30 being at the deeper since and they are
1:23:32 so big that's really the genuine narrow
1:23:34 meaning issues over Issa and yasua and
1:23:37 so on this is historical and as
1:23:38 linguistic analysis it's actually
1:23:40 relatively trivial but trivial people of
1:23:43 trivial mind they will get stuck with
1:23:45 this and they need they need they need
1:23:47 some security
1:23:48 and they have some work on that to be
1:23:50 published in in due course there is no
1:23:51 hurry in there next question yeah just a
1:23:55 double double author there's also
1:23:57 another question that's just limited in
1:23:58 as well uh when I head over to Abu mahab
1:24:00 after that
1:24:01 um so this one is in your earlier
1:24:03 mentioned about with Allah can lie or
1:24:05 does he lie no this is not that's it
1:24:08 that's it so let me ask you the
1:24:09 questions um so is the statement of the
1:24:12 day about this scholar gengari I don't
1:24:14 know who that is that Allah could lie a
1:24:16 statement and next next he says also is
1:24:20 there a difference between Allah
1:24:21 creating lies and lying himself
1:24:23 absolutely difference no no there's a
1:24:25 lot creating life meaning allow his
1:24:27 creation to Ally because they are
1:24:29 contingent and they're capable of lying
1:24:31 and they may allow that in Sharia May
1:24:33 prohibit it that's something else now
1:24:35 Allah himself lying is not possible
1:24:38 because we if we see if we see we see
1:24:40 the Quran says
1:24:42 nobody is because he's not his own
1:24:45 nature or his own attributes that he's
1:24:48 the haq
1:24:49 and now what what if something is the
1:24:53 truth how can a truth
1:24:55 that's not possible
1:24:57 for for contingent being they may be
1:24:59 utterly non-truth because they are
1:25:01 afraid they want to cover up they want
1:25:03 to escape punishment and so on but it's
1:25:04 all these attributes and things related
1:25:07 to contingency to being created to being
1:25:10 needy and that's the reason Sharia
1:25:12 allowed lying in certain situations
1:25:14 because of a greater good foreign
1:25:25 to his wife to keep the peace of the
1:25:28 family in in the specified sense of
1:25:31 sharia because keeping the family peace
1:25:34 is having more important value according
1:25:35 to Syria like that and then what she
1:25:37 said and trying to to bring people
1:25:39 together and solve conflicts like for
1:25:42 example you have you have a conflict
1:25:44 with someone
1:25:45 and you don't talk to each other and
1:25:47 they come to say well you have problem
1:25:48 with this guy I was with him yesterday
1:25:50 and he was full of Praise of you you
1:25:52 must have hit someone told you about it
1:25:54 about that you're talking about you ill
1:25:55 they are like reality I am like he's not
1:25:58 talking well about you but I want to
1:26:00 bring you together to set and then sort
1:26:01 the problem and start starting that's
1:26:03 permissible because bringing people
1:26:05 together and overcoming dispute is more
1:26:07 important than just this white lie but
1:26:10 this is only permitted because we need
1:26:12 it because we have finite and deficient
1:26:14 that's the way you can conceive lying
1:26:16 for created being for Allah being the
1:26:18 haq himself the truth absolute
1:26:20 perfection and truth it's inconceivable
1:26:22 as lie will come from him
1:26:30 I would say it's not possible for him
1:26:33 that's that's that's one one one one uh
1:26:36 but it needs maybe a more more
1:26:38 analytical analysis in the sense that it
1:26:41 is but dictated by by being a
1:26:43 necessarily existing being which is the
1:26:45 truth in itself while Injustice
1:26:47 punishing someone for something he did
1:26:49 not do is contingent it may be possibly
1:26:52 doing that and then he prohibited
1:26:54 himself from doing that like Hadith
1:26:57 it would have been possible to do it but
1:26:59 Allah prohibited himself in eternity and
1:27:02 it will be this way it became impossible
1:27:04 for all eternity it will never happen
1:27:06 alas but it would have been in principle
1:27:08 con not contradicting the the Divine
1:27:11 attributes but Allah foreign
1:27:17 it shows that he prohibited himself from
1:27:20 like he does not lie is an attribute
1:27:23 it's been connected within a nature of
1:27:25 necessary system being which is the hack
1:27:27 could the definition of hackers Allah
1:27:29 Allah
1:27:30 there's no other side
1:27:32 it's impossible
1:27:34 nothing from which is
1:27:41 the same initiating a deception but
1:27:44 deceiving someone as a punishment yes
1:27:48 if you try to deceive Allah Allah will
1:27:50 put you on top
1:27:51 as a punishment yes that's permissible
1:27:55 but not initiating the seat I will never
1:27:57 reset the seat
1:28:00 misguide you start with misguiding you
1:28:02 is impossible
1:28:04 well that's the reason a bliss is trying
1:28:07 to insult Allah says because you may
1:28:10 misguided me Allah did not answer him
1:28:12 out
1:28:19 face Allah gave him a chance was
1:28:21 prevented you from making sujood who I
1:28:23 commanded you look at the way Allah
1:28:25 spoke to him
1:28:27 why I commanded you I gave the comment
1:28:29 that's it the command is
1:28:32 what's the answer of this idiot and said
1:28:35 I made a mistake sorry I thought that's
1:28:37 only optional and something like that
1:28:38 forgive me what does he say
1:28:41 s
1:28:45 it should not be you should not command
1:28:47 someone who's Superior to vote for the
1:28:49 inferior
1:28:49 who said if not to that
1:28:52 is a fundamental principle who said that
1:28:55 the inferior cannot honor the Superior
1:28:57 or the superior country of the inferior
1:29:00 it's all possible
1:29:01 and who said that Allah's command is not
1:29:03 overriding all these considerations
1:29:07 but if someone is is
1:29:11 by his own choice and he got an
1:29:14 opportunity to get out and he refused
1:29:17 and then when he whispered to Adam he
1:29:19 lied about Allah your lord prohibited
1:29:22 you from verse 3 only that if you eat
1:29:24 from it you become Eternal and you
1:29:26 become like angels
1:29:29 he's misleading you he doesn't want you
1:29:32 to prosper
1:29:34 and the stupid guys believe that
1:29:37 nonsense
1:29:38 and he elevated them he honored them and
1:29:40 he told them we were if the devil is
1:29:42 your enemy he doesn't want you to be
1:29:44 honored and they still believe this
1:29:45 nonsense
1:29:47 now anyway go back to the original point
1:29:50 no I I think the best philosophical
1:29:53 point is that Allah by necessity is the
1:29:55 truth and from the truth nothing can be
1:29:57 a minute which is a lie
1:29:59 or initiating a deception but punishing
1:30:02 a deceptor by deceiving him to show him
1:30:04 if you think you are intelligent that
1:30:06 Allah Allah will show you how your own
1:30:09 doing will be your own and do it
1:30:11 but we see that in the reverse of it
1:30:17 that kind of thing so but injustice
1:30:20 Injustice meaning punishing someone with
1:30:22 a sin he did not do or we punishing
1:30:26 someone for he cannot do like some
1:30:28 there's a claim that the ashari claim
1:30:30 that it is possible for Allah to make an
1:30:33 injunction which people cannot possibly
1:30:35 uh execute and still they are obliged to
1:30:38 obey this is a contradiction that's not
1:30:40 correct if it's true that ashadi said
1:30:42 that I don't know how they formulated
1:30:43 what's impossible it's not possible
1:30:45 Allah
1:30:47 that will be Injustice
1:30:49 that's that's rationally with a
1:30:52 contingency because of the power yes but
1:30:55 from eternity
1:30:56 Allah decided I will never do that I
1:30:58 prohibited that to myself
1:31:04 is
1:31:07 the minimum
1:31:10 if we Define other as the opposite of
1:31:12 one then we have a minimal definition of
1:31:13 other that's discussed in the book of uh
1:31:15 come in more details but but that's it
1:31:20 your command
1:31:22 do this I didn't give you the facility
1:31:25 to do it and I am the all-powerful one
1:31:28 but like for example I tell you well I
1:31:30 in the air without you having wings or
1:31:32 giving you airplane obviously asking you
1:31:35 to The Impossible at the moment that
1:31:37 will be Injustice
1:31:40 understand it the same as a reason is
1:31:43 that when the the poet is excusing of
1:31:46 excusing accusing Qatar for his
1:31:49 misguidency claim uh alcoholism
1:31:53 he threw him in the water
1:31:56 with bound hand and told him then to get
1:31:59 wet with the water he means Allah for
1:32:01 all the human being in the testing
1:32:02 Universe without giving the facility and
1:32:04 they'll have no free will this is Jabari
1:32:08 he's accusing a law of Injustice
1:32:10 this disguise if he does what he means
1:32:12 maybe he means something metabolical
1:32:14 really that means he's a Cather
1:32:15 definitely it's impossible can't be
1:32:17 happening from Allah and that's when
1:32:19 available more fundamental things which
1:32:21 might say that the human will is even if
1:32:23 it is limited with conditions on it has
1:32:26 sufficient area of choice
1:32:29 genuine Sovereign free show is in a
1:32:32 limited area
1:32:34 and this is sufficient for completers
1:32:36 for the health sufficient power to
1:32:37 exclude if any one of these missing they
1:32:40 will not be responsible I'll ask about
1:32:41 that
1:32:44 and that's fundamental for the issue
1:32:47 and
1:32:48 reaching the outline punishment
1:32:52 but the jewelry will not recognize that
1:32:54 and the abuse Allah essentially
1:32:56 fundamentally for Injustice
1:32:59 and indirectly for a lie because clearly
1:33:02 the Quran says otherwise so there is
1:33:03 lying also deceiving us also there
1:33:06 initiating life Jeopardy Jabra is one of
1:33:09 the best cover and they still regardless
1:33:11 of
1:33:12 Allah anyway we we we branched a little
1:33:16 bit but that's it so one last one last
1:33:18 question uh that's okay
1:33:20 um
1:33:21 obviously the guy maybe have read that
1:33:24 they can't say that even lying may be
1:33:25 possible for Allah but he decided not to
1:33:27 lie ever made me prohibited himself like
1:33:30 I think this is a mistake it's a logical
1:33:32 and fallacy which they can't fell in in
1:33:35 that point but in Justice yes
1:33:37 so that's that's the Divine necessity
1:33:39 the Divine the Divine attributes
1:33:41 precludes that he lies
1:33:44 but Injustice he precluded himself and
1:33:46 decided and then before the monitor
1:33:48 decided it has decided and it is the
1:33:51 Soulful all eternities as good as if it
1:33:53 is by necessity of of his own nature but
1:33:55 here by his own free decision not to do
1:33:57 that in the case of lying no there is
1:34:00 nothing has nothing to do with any
1:34:01 decision it is just the divine nature as
1:34:03 such
1:34:04 which is a very fine difference
1:34:06 practically doesn't make much of any
1:34:08 difference
1:34:09 a quick last very quick one and then I'm
1:34:12 handing over straight to Abu mahab was
1:34:14 there any was there any mentioning of
1:34:17 prophetess in Quran or other resources
1:34:20 in Islam so basically prophetesses
1:34:22 female profits
1:34:24 there's no indirectly even has a
1:34:27 constructed addressing to Mariam is
1:34:29 making here the prophetess oh the Quran
1:34:31 does not prophetess
1:34:34 but does not even calling here
1:34:38 although uh foreign
1:35:03 and also we have the the Revelation to
1:35:07 uh to the mother of Musa
1:35:10 but what we have in the Old Testament
1:35:13 and uh
1:35:15 there is no reason to believe that it
1:35:17 was so well established as a complete
1:35:19 book we have we have Deborah
1:35:22 and then she was a prophetess and she
1:35:24 was one of the judges when the governing
1:35:26 money Israel and she is the war and led
1:35:30 armies and this scarcely possible to
1:35:33 believe that the whole story is
1:35:34 fabricated it's scarcely possible
1:35:36 especially if you look at the
1:35:38 counterbalance that with even profits
1:35:40 like like actually a man and that would
1:35:43 have been denied profit prophecy because
1:35:45 of things related to Kingdom and
1:35:47 behavior as kings while this one is by
1:35:51 all by all agreement of of of of
1:35:55 Scholars of Judaism is a is a prophetess
1:36:00 so that uh that that's it so that
1:36:02 there's but no mention of any one other
1:36:05 specifically as Maryam is mentioned with
1:36:07 her son insulated Ambia in the sequence
1:36:10 of prophets but uh but that means
1:36:17 related to the story of a so-called
1:36:19 Christmas Story on the bed etc but it's
1:36:22 not clear if it is she can be declared
1:36:24 as a prophetess or not
1:36:27 in essence with certitude
1:36:29 and then as I've said because of the
1:36:31 Revelation to them it's clearly that is
1:36:32 because derivation to Maryam is even
1:36:35 more forceful than the one to zecharia
1:36:37 from Zakaria there's nothing else not is
1:36:39 except that what he what he is asking
1:36:41 for for that he took care it was
1:36:43 Guardian for Maria and took care of of
1:36:46 the of Mariam until she came out of age
1:36:49 and needed to leave the temporary settle
1:36:52 as I discuss it so if that's a prophet
1:36:54 because of this year
1:36:57 anyway
1:37:01 uh the the question is is the whole
1:37:04 thing is good about about uh uh the
1:37:08 issue uh Secretary of feminism and so on
1:37:10 has been excited by these things because
1:37:11 it
1:37:13 hasn't answered let's say a woman could
1:37:15 be a prophet but cannot be a messenger I
1:37:18 think we discussed that once
1:37:21 but I said even that's not persuasive
1:37:24 hundred percent because Regal in Arabic
1:37:26 although mostly meaning men
1:37:29 female a male but it is actually in in
1:37:33 that context is the opposite of an Angel
1:37:35 and in that context result because
1:37:38 believe the angels are female so he used
1:37:41 men as to tell him no the angels are
1:37:43 male or whatever because they actually
1:37:46 without any sex that's the correct point
1:37:48 of view but to review their point of
1:37:51 view we have sent human beings such a
1:37:53 male but there's not many sick exclusive
1:37:55 exclusively because you have the famous
1:37:57 Hadith
1:37:59 inheritance left over
1:38:02 uh which we discuss inheritance then it
1:38:05 should go to the next
1:38:07 to the next male uh make man male sorry
1:38:12 for the man would have been enough then
1:38:15 I would not have used the word
1:38:18 to make it clear this is
1:38:20 your human being an English man is used
1:38:23 for man and woman and German also man
1:38:26 man not only a male man a male human
1:38:30 being
1:38:31 but in Arabic is less but is still there
1:38:33 it's not completely extinct so this is
1:38:36 even has an argument that even a woman
1:38:38 cannot be a messenger is is not is not
1:38:40 katai
1:38:41 that the Quran does not mention does not
1:38:44 mean there are there are definitely many
1:38:46 prophets if you look at it to the Old
1:38:48 Testament for many prophets mentioned in
1:38:50 in uh when nobody dispute their
1:38:52 prophethood and all was recorded about
1:38:54 them is with a stunning with stunning
1:38:57 details which create necessary knowledge
1:39:00 that they were prophets they are not
1:39:01 mentioned the Quran
1:39:04 My Messenger the one went to the state
1:39:07 of North Israel the shepherd and was
1:39:09 prosecuted a ran away for his life
1:39:11 nobody doubt neither Jews nor Christian
1:39:13 or anybody who didn't think that he was
1:39:15 a messenger
1:39:17 and she's not mentioned the Quran
1:39:19 the first Zakaria after the baboon
1:39:21 Daniel is not mentioned the Quran he's
1:39:23 one of the most important with many
1:39:25 Prophecies of importance
1:39:27 barely anyone disagree that Daniel is he
1:39:30 wearing a Quran no
1:39:34 yes
1:39:37 that's that's I think that's it because
1:39:39 the discussion about feminism or
1:39:41 non-feminism I think in that case
1:39:43 because when when the Quran
1:39:46 but in the Quran
1:39:49 we say why did Allah not send an angel
1:39:52 down say no no we have never sent an
1:39:54 angel down because an angel not be able
1:39:56 to communicate to human beings unless he
1:39:58 becomes a human being a played like a
1:40:00 human being then the damage is already
1:40:02 done then you will not recognize him as
1:40:04 an angel this is nonsense it doesn't
1:40:05 work this way it's impossible it's
1:40:07 actually rationally and physically
1:40:09 impossible so we have sent men before
1:40:11 you in that context that means human
1:40:14 beings
1:40:17 and if you don't know that ask the
1:40:19 people of the scripture asks
1:40:23 meaning the people of previous structure
1:40:25 is scripture could could report about
1:40:28 the general issues fundamental issues
1:40:30 about prophethood and natural prophets
1:40:32 and so on in a reliable way
1:40:35 not every small bit and every small
1:40:37 story but the general picture yeah check
1:40:40 about the general picture of what what
1:40:41 we have seen before it's all human
1:40:42 beings and if you check the real
1:40:44 description go all through that all of
1:40:47 the human beings male and female then we
1:40:49 find female under them so we should take
1:40:51 that also in both I don't think it's
1:40:53 there's any reason to reject that
1:40:56 we found also report about the dawood
1:40:58 bad things us clarifying the party
1:41:02 refuse and about Suleiman which the
1:41:04 Quran staunchly refutes that he is a
1:41:06 magician and so on yes we find that the
1:41:09 meaning in that because because these
1:41:10 were Kings and there were kings were
1:41:12 disputed with other kings and that's the
1:41:14 problem of Kings fighting with Kings
1:41:16 there would be a party with this party
1:41:17 with this and the fabricate story you
1:41:19 know propaganda against each other and
1:41:21 December leaks in these books and these
1:41:24 histories is understandable but the
1:41:26 moment you are away from Kings to the
1:41:28 common people and the prophets who are
1:41:29 persecuted or killed and then can that
1:41:32 can't be the case or the princess or
1:41:34 persons who are never controversial you
1:41:36 say like Deborah there can't be any
1:41:38 fabrication that it matter that she is a
1:41:39 prophetess so we can take that on board
1:41:43 you see my point
1:41:46 we ask the people that they can weather
1:41:48 in a female prophets before or or
1:41:49 messenger yes it seem to be happy
1:41:52 other other prophets many other
1:41:55 professors tons of them look at Daniel
1:41:58 look at the hezekiel look at the hakke
1:42:01 look at my Malaki
1:42:04 check but we can't really confirm a
1:42:06 delight based off of previous
1:42:09 from a general context it must be the
1:42:11 core of which must be true because the
1:42:13 whole anchors and that they are not
1:42:16 Angel is referring meaning that they
1:42:19 could contain at least a core of facts
1:42:21 there which we can rely upon
1:42:24 not every Factor not only details but
1:42:27 the core of it we have to distinguish
1:42:29 between a Core Fact the general just
1:42:31 like for example say the Quran is is
1:42:34 acknowledging a Torah energy say you
1:42:37 don't need to offend the Quran probably
1:42:38 educated but say the people who kept it
1:42:41 they some of them fabricated some
1:42:43 they've hidden something and you admit
1:42:44 that you have hidden books
1:42:46 and the Quran says you you're right at
1:42:48 your karates and you hide some of it and
1:42:50 then he warned the people who write the
1:42:52 book and claims from Allah
1:42:55 the core of the Quran is clear these
1:42:57 books are fundamentally reliable but
1:42:59 have been contaminated we have to sort
1:43:01 it out but the contamination cannot be
1:43:04 that the holes that the Deborah is
1:43:06 invented I actually Helio and she's not
1:43:08 a prophetess especially it's not a
1:43:10 controversial issue
1:43:11 the controversial one is like dawood and
1:43:13 Suleiman because they were Kings and
1:43:14 they were fights between them
1:43:17 and the Quran lost over that did not go
1:43:20 into this messy area because the Quran
1:43:22 is not going to that and as it says
1:43:24 clearly
1:43:25 he will tell you many of that what you
1:43:27 have been hidden of the book and he
1:43:28 forgive many because the Quran is not
1:43:30 the opening digging Graves and opening
1:43:33 the the filth of the party let's forget
1:43:35 about the film from the past as much as
1:43:36 we can and proceed forward
1:43:39 foreign
1:44:31 foreign
1:44:50 yes yes yes yes the completion of the
1:44:53 Ayah however however my question is I I
1:44:57 remember like few years ago uh uh you
1:45:00 may you made an argument that uh from
1:45:03 from the scriptures we only have a
1:45:05 direct command or uh uh from Allah to to
1:45:09 take Ibrahim and Muhammad as an example
1:45:12 good examples to follow but we we we do
1:45:15 not have the same scriptures for other
1:45:17 prophets to take as good examples uh to
1:45:19 follow right so uh and and I wasn't I
1:45:23 forget if they say that that way it was
1:45:24 it was it was not a correct statement I
1:45:26 have missed a point or or maybe I I
1:45:29 wasn't following closely anyway I
1:45:31 corrected that now Ibrahim is only in
1:45:33 college
1:45:34 otherwise we did not do the Ayah Justice
1:45:37 cancer Mohammed is is a good example
1:45:43 in everything absolutely absolute
1:45:46 example yes so so my question here how
1:45:49 can we uh like it seems to me maybe that
1:45:52 there's a conflict between these two
1:45:54 ayas and the ayas that we discussed
1:45:56 today uh uh uh what's that
1:46:00 so in this Ayah Allah says all prophets
1:46:04 that he mentioned no no no we discussed
1:46:06 what is it we discusses only
1:46:10 and this is universal that's not
1:46:12 obligated
1:46:14 or you mean in the matter of like uh and
1:46:18 Creed yeah they'll hit only and this is
1:46:20 and so on that's it
1:46:23 the whole context I discussed that also
1:46:25 when it came to the ayat if you just go
1:46:27 back in the recording and check it again
1:46:28 yeah okay okay
1:46:31 I see so so then Allah uh he he only
1:46:35 wanted to stress in the in the Ayah of
1:46:39 Ibrahim uh to take him as a good example
1:46:41 right
1:46:45 Etc so Allah is just repeating uh what
1:46:49 he what he told us specific point what
1:46:51 he is
1:46:53 okay okay okay got it got it I just
1:46:56 wanted to stress that that the
1:46:58 obligation
1:46:59 is an absolute and doesn't contradict
1:47:02 that because this is part of the
1:47:04 fundamental
1:47:07 this is a statement of fact based on
1:47:10 that says Sharia would be built and so
1:47:12 on which can be obligated go back and
1:47:14 forth but fundamentally is not there's
1:47:16 nothing can be obligated there because
1:47:17 I'm being obligated it is true or
1:47:19 neutral at the same time it is
1:47:20 essentially right and some action
1:47:23 related to that which is absolute in the
1:47:25 sense that this
1:47:26 deity do not exist I just above them by
1:47:29 necessity
1:47:30 it must be like that
1:47:38 and cannot be abrogated because it's
1:47:41 related on a fact which is absolute
1:47:43 yes I see I see the the the second
1:47:47 question related to also to this uh uh
1:47:51 now I I I I'm I'm I'm I'm asking uh uh
1:47:55 you know the Ayah was
1:48:02 the Olympics
1:48:05 I was going to ask you if if if this
1:48:08 means that we we should take a good
1:48:10 example for this
1:48:14 and you follow them after them while
1:48:16 they're doing good deeds according
1:48:17 Sharia not following them or not
1:48:19 following them
1:48:59 Music
1:49:08 thank you
1:49:12 Music
1:49:25 Music
1:49:31 Music
1:49:34 foreign
1:49:40 Music
1:49:48 Music